It was my favourite movement when I discovered this symphony at the age of 12. It was my waking up music before school for a while. I listened to it every morning before school. It brings such peace in the mind. Happily I had a chance to see the whole manuscript of this symphony...At Musée d'Orsay in Paris...
PERHAPS BECAUSE OF THE RECORDING QUALITY THE HARPS AND CELLO PIZZICATO ARE ALMOST INAUDIBLE AS THEY BEAT THE SLOW RYTHM IN THE'BACKGROUND = TAM TAM===TAM TAM TAM==TAM TAM ; IN ABBADO''S VERSION IT IS MUCH BETTER; AND AN OLD RECORDING OF KLEMPERER TOO IN ABBADO
@GraceEleanorWood they probably want to make an attacca after the 3rd mov. and when she walked in then, people would clap and the whole atmosphere would be destroyed...
This music gives me great comfort, and it has always been there for me, when people weren't. When things were gloomy even with so much beauty in life around me, when my heart was broken even when it had so many reasons to sing, this work of beauty sang to my heart. This performance is fabulous, one of history's greatest conductors conducting one of history's greatest orchestras, performing music by one of history's greatest composers.
@MusicInvestigation Yes, I first heard this wonderful adagio in 1972, and it knocked me out then, and still does. Music is a supremely rewarding pleasure, and apart from the damage to one's ears of over-loud playing, is harmless. It also masks my tinnitus, so blesses me yet again.
Greatest solution youtube came out with for bad and negative comments. lets make a general green vote to cast out all the evil that is in you and make your primary goal to reach the higher vote.
Tuve una experiencia muy extraña con este adagio. Lo Iba escuchando en un colectivo, mientras apreciaba el atarder en el campo. La primavera se acercaba, faltaban dos días para septiembre. Dos horas después de eso falleció una persona muy querida para mí; y viendo retrospectivamente la situación del colectivo, la de Mahler y el atardecer, sentí que esa música y esas imágenes me habían anunciado el final
Tuve una experiencia muy extraña con este adagio. Lo Iba escuchando en un colectivo, mientras apreciaba el atarder en el campo. La primavera se acercaba, faltaban dos días para septiembre. Dos horas después de eso falleció una persona muy querida para mí; y viendo retrospectivamente la situación del colectivo, la de Mahler y el atardecer, sentí que esa música y esas imágenes me habían anunciado el final, sin que yo lo entienda, como un anuncio secreto, como una revelación.
@Napelmanak Askenazy said that Mahler is so beloved, because everyone can recognize the own inner world of sentiments in it. And for that reason, he said, his music can be misunderstood.
Mahler was right to remark that this movement 'laughs and cries at one and the selfsame time', since the opening theme, motionless and meditative , is followed by a second theme that is openly anguished in character.
@Epmonito Since the orchestra preforming is the Vienna Philharmonic the insturments that the orchestra uses are somewhat unique amoung professional orchestras.
@kiterunner007 That is a tough one because Mahler constantly revised the scoreing of the 5th symphony up until his death. I would definatly suspect that some of the scoreing of the strings in both symphonies movments are similar but in regards to the actual themes ect both movments are independent.
I find that Bernstein has a visually elegant conducting style, better then in some of his performances later in life, where he had a peculiar way of lifting his shoulders.
@xaviqaz Easiest is a relative term when your talking about mahler lol. While this symphony may have the smallest insturmentation, this symphony also has some of the most trecherous exposed solo passages of any of the mahler symphonies. Because of this I would actually rate this harder than the first through third symphonies.
Imho this is the best rendition of Mahler's 4th. Some conductors seem to want to rush through it, but Bernstein really takes his time and is truly ruhevoll.
Admirable !... Unique !... Merveilleux Poco Adagio... Quelle émotion ! Quel enchantement...
Inoubliable Mahler dans une inspiration exceptionnelle...
BERNARDTRIBAY 3 weeks ago
Too good for this shitty world we all live in...
vonspre 1 month ago
It was my favourite movement when I discovered this symphony at the age of 12. It was my waking up music before school for a while. I listened to it every morning before school. It brings such peace in the mind. Happily I had a chance to see the whole manuscript of this symphony...At Musée d'Orsay in Paris...
elisabeth717 1 month ago
My God, this life has its pleasures, doesn't it?
Josedono 2 months ago
PERHAPS BECAUSE OF THE RECORDING QUALITY THE HARPS AND CELLO PIZZICATO ARE ALMOST INAUDIBLE AS THEY BEAT THE SLOW RYTHM IN THE'BACKGROUND = TAM TAM===TAM TAM TAM==TAM TAM ; IN ABBADO''S VERSION IT IS MUCH BETTER; AND AN OLD RECORDING OF KLEMPERER TOO IN ABBADO
dannymiewdg 4 months ago
Bernstein's old recording with the NY Philharmonic was much better.
yraggnik 5 months ago
Holy shit, The french horn player's beard. Thats a man.
heino320 6 months ago
If anybody could tell me why the soprano walks in on this movement it would make my day!
GraceEleanorWood 8 months ago
@GraceEleanorWood ,,,,do you understand half time in football
gwalgof1st 8 months ago
@GraceEleanorWood they probably want to make an attacca after the 3rd mov. and when she walked in then, people would clap and the whole atmosphere would be destroyed...
kianskiputz92 8 months ago
@kianskiputz92 Thank you :)
GraceEleanorWood 6 months ago
One of the beautiest Mahler's adagio!
jakubkasperski 9 months ago
This music gives me great comfort, and it has always been there for me, when people weren't. When things were gloomy even with so much beauty in life around me, when my heart was broken even when it had so many reasons to sing, this work of beauty sang to my heart. This performance is fabulous, one of history's greatest conductors conducting one of history's greatest orchestras, performing music by one of history's greatest composers.
MusicInvestigation 10 months ago 2
@MusicInvestigation Yes, I first heard this wonderful adagio in 1972, and it knocked me out then, and still does. Music is a supremely rewarding pleasure, and apart from the damage to one's ears of over-loud playing, is harmless. It also masks my tinnitus, so blesses me yet again.
walshamite 10 months ago
Wait.. are the players human or robots? lol
wearetheggmeninit 11 months ago
ΑΡΙΣΤΟΥΡΓΗΜΑ .
MrANTONIOS383 1 year ago
QUERES QUE HABLEMOS DE ORQUESTACIÓN Y COMPOSICIÓN ?? QUE MIERDA SABES DE MUSICA VOS''
gusmarr1 1 year ago
Suena a Beethoven, Muy poco original. Auque pretende "conmover" solo deslumbra.
Lindo pero no bello.
gusmarr1 1 year ago
Greatest solution youtube came out with for bad and negative comments. lets make a general green vote to cast out all the evil that is in you and make your primary goal to reach the higher vote.
javilack 1 year ago
Heavenly orchestrated...
JSweec 1 year ago
Tuve una experiencia muy extraña con este adagio. Lo Iba escuchando en un colectivo, mientras apreciaba el atarder en el campo. La primavera se acercaba, faltaban dos días para septiembre. Dos horas después de eso falleció una persona muy querida para mí; y viendo retrospectivamente la situación del colectivo, la de Mahler y el atardecer, sentí que esa música y esas imágenes me habían anunciado el final
Levinconstantino 1 year ago
@Levinconstantino me come la polla.
memphis148 11 months ago
Tuve una experiencia muy extraña con este adagio. Lo Iba escuchando en un colectivo, mientras apreciaba el atarder en el campo. La primavera se acercaba, faltaban dos días para septiembre. Dos horas después de eso falleció una persona muy querida para mí; y viendo retrospectivamente la situación del colectivo, la de Mahler y el atardecer, sentí que esa música y esas imágenes me habían anunciado el final, sin que yo lo entienda, como un anuncio secreto, como una revelación.
Levinconstantino 1 year ago
A little soothing Mahler for a hot Sunday.....
johnnicolson 1 year ago 2
Esto siempre me hace llorar.
AthlonNapelmanak 1 year ago
Maravilhoso!
Maravilloso!
Wonderful!
Magnifique!
Mahler.
Napelmanak 1 year ago
This always reminds me that I'm still alive
Napelmanak 1 year ago 4
@Napelmanak Askenazy said that Mahler is so beloved, because everyone can recognize the own inner world of sentiments in it. And for that reason, he said, his music can be misunderstood.
jasoncrew 1 year ago 5
Mahler was right to remark that this movement 'laughs and cries at one and the selfsame time', since the opening theme, motionless and meditative , is followed by a second theme that is openly anguished in character.
vonspre 1 year ago 3
Played in Grenoble (FR) 3 days ago, by Symphonic Orchestra of Champs Elysées... In my TOP 3 favorite pieces of Mahler. I love this mvt!
zebrain38 2 years ago
3:06-3:35 Epic moment =]
icedrummer4 2 years ago
what barrels are the oboe using?
Epmonito 2 years ago
@Epmonito Since the orchestra preforming is the Vienna Philharmonic the insturments that the orchestra uses are somewhat unique amoung professional orchestras.
sfrenchhorn07 1 year ago
Lovely, tranquil music indeed. I wonder if Mahler used some of the same ideas for the Adagietto of his 5th?
kiterunner007 2 years ago
@kiterunner007 That is a tough one because Mahler constantly revised the scoreing of the 5th symphony up until his death. I would definatly suspect that some of the scoreing of the strings in both symphonies movments are similar but in regards to the actual themes ect both movments are independent.
sfrenchhorn07 1 year ago
I find that Bernstein has a visually elegant conducting style, better then in some of his performances later in life, where he had a peculiar way of lifting his shoulders.
MarcusHK1 2 years ago
love this music
Vindrag 2 years ago 2
Why?
GoatDaddyVersion2 2 years ago
one of the most inspiring and emotives adagios composed by Mahler, great symphony and even greater 3rd movement,
beethomozart 2 years ago 22
Penderecki is a much better horn player than composer :)
Kurtyoungblood 2 years ago
favourite gustav-mahler-piece of mine.
martinw1906 2 years ago
Comment removed
xaviqaz 3 years ago 17
so beautiful
jotjedl3b 3 years ago 4
@xaviqaz Easiest is a relative term when your talking about mahler lol. While this symphony may have the smallest insturmentation, this symphony also has some of the most trecherous exposed solo passages of any of the mahler symphonies. Because of this I would actually rate this harder than the first through third symphonies.
sfrenchhorn07 1 year ago
this is absolutely breathtaking :)
Fuzzyrush27 3 years ago 6
Freisch weht der Wind,
Der Heimat zu,
Meine Irisch kind,
Wo weilest du?
spinoza1111 3 years ago
Imho this is the best rendition of Mahler's 4th. Some conductors seem to want to rush through it, but Bernstein really takes his time and is truly ruhevoll.
Thanks for posting.
yusefelhalal 3 years ago 3
try Tennstedt conducting London Philharmonic Orchestra...it's closer to heaven...
goldenagepianist 3 years ago
I will! Thanks for the tip.
yusefelhalal 3 years ago
Bernstein had a great respect for Mahler...
danijel370 3 years ago 5
prachtig!! art!! onevenaarbaar! zo sensitive..
ivdycke 3 years ago 4
thank you for posting this!
umnvu09 3 years ago 3