Added: 4 years ago
From: incrediblecHiller
Views: 44,473
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (135)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • DJ premier is an asshole for stealing this, he is one of the most shittiest producers anyway.

    Hahahahaha just kidding Premier is a sampling genius

  • nahmean, without premo, this is elevator music... at best..

  • @StrosB4Hos Whats wrong with elevator music?

  • Jazz musicians steal material all of the time whether it is a melodic pattern or phrase, chord progression, chord substitution, rhythmic pattern, etc. This song is Fucking Gay anyway. Feel lucky a contemporary musician of a completely different genre found something of value in your music.

  • Vic gave me a copy of his latest album for free. He's a really nice guy and he deserves credit for his stuff. I saw him at the Rutgers Summer Jazz Camp at Mason Gross; he teaches there.

    He's an amazing guy.

  • I had the chance to meet Vic Juris the other night when he was playing in a small intimate venue. Great guy and great guitar. Even played this track at my request. As both a rap and jazz fan it's obviously a good debate this whole thing. In the end however all of this "art" is still business and Vic is due payment. The idea of sampling for free died a long time ago.

  • 3:35 Primo!

  • how long do u think preem dug for that

  • this the kind of music you hear when someone puts you on hold. old white people like vic juris generally hate hip-hop and will find any way to criticize it. they can't be persuaded because they've made their minds up. quite sad really.

  • @willferris34 First off, you are a racist, probably a no-talent racist. Second, you would be pissed too if someone lifted your track and made money off of it without asking permission or giving out a few dimes of royalties, not that you would ever be capable of doing anything other than dishing it out to "old white people". I don't even know where you get the "hate hip-hop"...he just wants credit. Racist.

  • @FunkEnRegalia I'm white myself, and regardless I'm not a racist. In order for an artist to sample someone else's work, they have to get permission or pay for the rights to use it. If Juris didn't get paid or even approve of the sample use, then he has every right to be mad. Even so, sample clearance is not in the hands of the artists, there are lawyers and A&R's who take care of that stuff. Sampling is the foundation of hip hop, and to call it stealing is such a tired argument at this point..

  • @FunkEnRegalia I'm white myself & I'm not a racist. I never claimed to be musically talented or otherwise, so that insult has no bearing here. DJ Premier took 3 seconds of this song that was otherwise lost in the other 6-plus minutes & made it into something new & ultimately far more important than the work of Vic Juris. Premier has nothing to do with sample clearance issues, that is for lawyers to sort out. If Vic wasn't paid, he should be angry at Gang Starr's management, & not the artists .

  • Primo is a fucking genious

  • Too bad Juris has to be such a dick though. I'm just not going to return and enjoy his wonderful music because his ego and bank account figure into his life more than enjoying his own art does.

  • @vicjury,

    Your guitar playing isn't even that good. Why anybody would even think about transcribing you is beyond me.

  • @stevenjazzguitar Juris has played with Joe Pass, Peter Bernstein, Joe Locke...the list goes on and on and on. Maybe you don't like smooth jazz, but he can play everything else...What have you played, Steven? A coffee shop? Maybe even a yuppie winebar? Man, if you're lucky and keep practicing, they might play your music in a service elevator.

  • @FunkEnRegalia Just because you play with big names doesn't mean you're good. I'm 17 and I've played with Wycliffe Gordon, Roy Hargrove, Joel VanderHayden and Fareed Haque, but I don't consider myself good by any means. I like smooth jazz too, so there's that. As for where I've played, you're right, but like I said, I'm 17 and there isn't much more I can do. His comment was incredibly brash though. You can't deny that.

  • how the fuck did preem even find this

  • @Vicjury if the sample cleared, why are you complaining? If you didn't get paid off the clearance, that has nothing to do with the artist that sampled your work. You should already know to go to the clearinghouse and get your paper. I'd be willing to bet that you made more off Primo's 2 sec. sample than you did with this song, which BTW I love. Maybe that's why you're bitter. Too bad, because if I were you I would find Primo and do a song with him. I know he would be game.

  • There's a whole lot of ignorance going on here... Know who knows more about music than everyone who's commented on this video? Vic Juris does.

  • Takin 2 seconds of a joint, and sampling just one instrument and filtering or panning out the rest and making a whole other thing of it is even harder to do then playing freely on an instrument.

    Premier does it well, creative and probably has the best ear for dope parts.

    2 fucking seconds.

  • @charlyblues excellently stated =)

  • Shut up and collect your royalty check.

  • dude just mad cause more people talking about Premo on a video featuring his music..

  • @StrosB4Hos Very true. I'm sure Vic Juris has a fan base but a lot of the next generation wouldn't even know who he is without Premier

  • @DrMBA28 im going to have to say ditto this....i woulda never heard of this guy....or got this song on my ipod....great guitar playing...cant accept a producer taking 2 seconds of sound from a 7 minute long song is just stingy

  • @Vicjury we wouldn't be listening to it now if it hadn't been sampled. you should probably thank dj premier. 

  • vic is obviously not that cool!

  • how did Premo sample just the guitar riff without any of the background noise from the drums and other instruments in this song?

  • Comment removed

  • @bolts512 filtering

  • ahhhh mass appeal this song is amazing to learn to broaden your horizons hip hop fans no pun intended

  • PRIMO is a GENIUS!!!

  • its at 3:37 the sample that gang starr used for mass appeal

  • I wish You Tube would take this tune of my down....Maybe these thieves could have learned how to play an instrument.....Vic

  • @Vicjury You want me to take your tune down? Just say the word! :-)

  • @incrediblecHiller That's a bit harsh isn't it saying thieves? if it wasn't for youtube i wouldn't of even heard of this tune......

  • Comment removed

  • @incrediblecHiller He did say it.... 

  • @incrediblecHiller Hmm, still up I see :) The fact is Vic doesn't want this taken down because he's probably gotten alot of publicity (and gigs) thanks to DJ Premier's sample. Maybe you should be paying Premo eh vic?

  • @karey26 Vic is just pissed because he didn't get paid for someone else taking his music and making money off of it, you'd be pissed too if you were him. Vic got no publicity out of this, and in the jazz world he was already an acclaimed educator and performer when Guru was shitting his diapers.

    I love Guru and Primo, but Juris has every right to be pissed. It is stupid to posit that Primo actually HELPED a well-established jazz professional by stealing his music without proper dues. Idiot.

  • @Vicjury I assume that this is the real Vic Juris (or a representative). Let me ask you: when your work is sampled, do you appreciate the fact that it sort of propels you into the next generation of music listeners? Or would you rather your work not be sampled at all? Or is it a monetary issue? Namely, you wouldn't mind your work being sampled, but would like to be paid for it. Not meant to be rude or disrespectful, just an honest question.

  • @Vicjury so black people are thieves? white trash...the only good part of this song was at 3:34 when it was sampled by gang star and made it better than you

  • @Vicjury maybe you should have paid more attention in school 

  • @Vicjury fuck off

  • @Vicjury funny how u want you tube to take down,, without it noone would ever get to hear it anymore..and good music would be lost 4 ever..you should be happy that more people can enjoy it now....

    and definetly should be honored your tune was sampled in another amazing song so it can carry on...

    intead of just faintly heard in background in drs office,hotels, the waether channel, on hold...

  • @Vicjury You want your original track taken down because other people have sampled it for completely different tracks? Pffft.

  • @Vicjury You are a part of one of the best tracks in hip hop history. You should be happy with that. I'd be freaking THRILLED. What mark do you think your music would/could leave otherwise? Minimal, even though you are a skilled musician/writer.

    Were I you, I'd be smiling. Forget money, It ruins everything.

  • @LeviMedia

    You'd be freaking thrilled. That's you. Not everyone has to feel that way - and apparently Vic is one. His wishes should be respected.

    What kind of question is that to ask an artist with the creativity, discipline, and soul of a musician on Vic's level? Perhaps he is less concerned with "what mark" he makes than with artistic integrity. If his "mark" is less than someone's who ripped him off, it might say more about marketing than about Vic's artistry. I'll take the original.

  • @RootsinBrooklyn Look at it this way, if only for a moment... I would not know anything about or be listening to your wonderful music right now if it weren't for the track-back research on that sample. One thing leads to another. I'd be likely to catch a show of yours or buy a CD now. Just sayin'. (the original is sweet, by the way!)

  • @Vicjury dj premier took 3 seconds of your song and moulded it into one of the greatest hip hop songs ever made. it's innovative, not theft

  • @Vicjury If it wasn't for these 'thieves' I would have never discovered your music...duh! Sampling gives newer generations a way of discovering the old...

  • fucking nice genious who sampled it

    only with 1 second of this song que made one of the sickests beats in hgip hop history

  • gang starr- mass appeal , damn premo is so genius!

  • I'd be willing to bet that if Juris heard "Mass Appeal" without knowing anything about it he would never have identified that sample as coming from his own track.

  • Premo is before J Dilla, However JAY DEE is allot more creative in his Sampling Syntax construction than premo.

    AERIDU ALULIM SHINAR

    Institute For Sampling Syntax Methods

  • preemo and dilla are tied for #1

  • god, DJ Premier is a god!!!

  • Who the hell else would go all the way to the middle of an almost seven minute song and jack one bar? Who the hell else would have jacked THAT one bar? I said it before and I'll say it again, Preme is the best that ever did it.

  • @oskamadison - That's the art of crate-diggin my man. It takes mad patience and it's one task you have to honesty say that you never know what the person listening to it is thinking or feeling. You never know what or where Preme was at when his ear caught that little moment in time..blink and you would've missed it lol Prolly not like we doing now just sittin here listening for it -- he prolly was doing some other shit while this played and the sound just grabbed him you know?

  • @Seethroo You're exactly right on all counts. I'm washing the dishes listening to Wes Montgomery's "Road Song" album and what do I hear on Wes' cover of "Yesterday"? The guitar sample on the intro to Group Home's album. I always get a little giddy when I come across a sample that Preme used, convincing myself for approximately 2.3 seconds that I'm somehow on Preme's wavelength because I found a joint he sampled over 15 years ago, lmao.

  • @oskamadison LMAO! word up. I've been there on my instances back in the day when I use to raid my father's collection coming across familiar joints, but my pops was on some bashing shit most of the time cause every time we'd go at it from him shittin on hip-hop saying that its not music, he'd always go to his archives and backdoor the original of a classic hip-hop joint that I played for him and just leave me with my face cracked lol

  • @Seethroo What did Will Smith say back in '88? Parents Just Don't Understand, lol.

  • @oskamadison yeah this song pretty much sucks other than the fact that premier sampled it.

  • its only three seconds and your allowed to sample three seconds of anything

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • how the hell did he pick that out at 3:36. thats crazy, ive looked through tons and tons of samples and that was one of the hardest to catch.

  • no inventes 2 segundos de obtener un ritmo y asi hacer crecer una instrumental damn grande

  • Hi!

    I must be a totally without musical talents, but exactly which part of this nice jazz guitar piece was sampled in Mass Appeal?

    Could someone point to a specific section of the track?

    Thanks

  • HI! y dont u try listening thru it bro?

  • 3:36 - 3:37!!!!! Premo Golden Ears!!!

  • Thanks!

     And I can see from previous comments that I was not the only one without musical talent...or rather should we say that Premier is the one with supreme musical gifts!

    Thanks,

  • 3:36

  • Two things you guys should be aware of on Vic Juris's part:

    1.) This is by far from his best work and he admits that. He called it a "not so great recording" and has produced MUCH more exciting work.

    2.) He's actually really upset about this sample, mostly because he's not getting paid ANYTHING from it. Don't know who's fault that is but it's a shame and as a fan of both hip-hop and jazz, I feel really conflicted.

  • No money from the sample? That's crazy! he need a good lawyer!

  • only bait industry people pay for samples! its just about the music bitch ass nigga

  • Like James Brown said: If I put my soul on records I need to be paid.

  • a vic juris sample along with a slightly touched empd drum sample created a classic. preem is a wiz

  • 2 seconds...

  • People need to hear what Vic does now. He was playing well back in '79 but, he's come a looong way in the past almost 30 years.This guy is undoubtably one of the best guitarists on the planet, and I dont say that easily. I listen to them all.

  • this song is a great proof that dj premier is the greatest producer of all time!!!

  • premier knows how to use a 1second sample

    gang starr-royalty the same

  • Comment removed

  • or high

  • Vic is all that's going on. He's the best teacher I've ever had.

  • what part did premo sample?

  • 3:37

  • 3 mins 36 secs

  • True and we all respect that... but its like owning a car then fixind it up to make it nice n fast..... do u think the stock car or the fixed up car gets all the gredit in the end..... 9x out of 10 people like different and what preme did with that sample was different thats y he gets alot of atendion from the sample

  • And yes i do agree this is a very good song

  • nah bro, i think vic juris should pay premo for what he did...mass appeal is a minimalistic masterpiece, you lack the funk it seems...this track is so bland it's unbelievable, why do you think premo is famous and vic juris is unheard of? you should look up the art of sampling, it's not simply ripping off shit. it's being creative and using the old to make new, something ever artist does.

  • vic juris isnt unheard of. maybe to the hip hop community he is, but hes known for what hes done.

  • Damn finding the sample made the hairs on my neck stand up!

  • "Pat Metheny's favorite Guitarist"

    Really? He teaches at my university.

  • The leason is that you have to be diverse in your taste if you want sampling music. There are some bangers out there that sample music from artists that you wouldn't expect.

  • Premier is an absolute champ. I just heard the Gang Starr instrumental on some house buying programme and HAD to find out where the original was from. WOW. Sneeze and you miss it.

  • Pat Metheny's favorite Guitarest.

  • no wayyyyyy

  • damn, premo's got some good ears if he can catch that shit and make an ill beat out of that little bit.

  • this part is in 3:36

  • Word I ma happy i didnt have to sit thru the whole thing and scan the song. I've been diggin for about 2 hours straight.

    Thanks MF Doom7

  • daaamn, big ups primo

  • wow. i was expecting a real big part that premier sampled..it was only like a second..thats genius

  • Damn I would've never tought of this. DJ Premo is purely a genius and the greatest producer of all time

  • how the fuck did he catch that

    i would have missed it if metalface didnt tell me

  • Word

    damn, Premo is just a produce-god that he can make such a dope beat from that tiny half a second sample

  • 3:36 - 3:37

  • @metalfacedoom7 ACTUALLY..JUST MISSED 3:36//3:37-3:38..ALMOST 3:39

    BEAUTIFUL EITHER WAY

  • wow..primo just took that small piece (a few seconds) and made a hip hop classic! wow!

  • so does primo just chill all day and listen to this kind of music until something catches his ear or what?

  • yup

  • damn premo!!!

  • That's why DJ Premier is the best producer on planet Earth.

  • love this song

  • Primo with the patient, good ear.

  • Great SOng Vic Very very Mello... Music back in the day ruled

  • 3:36, mass appeal. Vic Juris is sick.

  • LOL word.

    this song is so great, I wonder how Primo found that one tiny portion of the song..

  • Patience and a good ear.

  • what minute:seconds ?

  • That's it! The thing I liked about Mass Appeal from the first time I heard it was that riff.

  • great as always

  • I also used this in ProtoMan's Stand Tall on Rawkus Records.. Definitely an ill record. All kinds of dope parts...

  • This tune was recorded in 1979

  • ?? Isn't that what i wrote in the info?

    Or what do you mean?

  • Hey Hiller,

    That's the REAL VIC JURIS........He wrote to me as well.

  • Word? Didn't realize...

    Cool stuff!

  • Oh yes.........I'm diggin' this. Fine choice of music you got in here.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more