you know if he really had just did this to keep him, wouldn't it look more like SEX instead it looks like they made LOVE they look like they where taking the time out to enjoy one another : ) to soak each other in : O
Oh come on you fucking director, if Shane does not love Jonathan like that and only slept with him to keep him as his best friend (which really doesn't make sense), why is their so much passion in that kiss?
That girl is just a trouble maker and annoying. The director really messed up on the ending.
This movie has been out for years, but I only got the chance to watch it yesterday. Of course the ending was sad but the movie was great. Excellent performance for the 3 leads.
the movie ending was very very disappointed, as usual,the director put a b....h with Shane, how can Jon be friend with Shane after the sex,he just used him,even gay have moral,Jon wasn't that type of guy, Shane messed up really bad with Jon,i felt so sad, also Jon started to loose all he made for his studies as failed on last test,really sad.
i dont understand how you could become friends again after that. like. im straight but i wanted to keep you as a friend so i decided to screw you. that would make me really mad.
This movie will alwayz be my No.1... the story,the performances,the music everything was just PERFECT but the ending OMG i wanted to slap the director hard...it was so confusing... everyone's commenting dat dey stayed friends but how can SHANE just go back to CARRIE after having sex with Jonathan?? Dey'l just pretend dat noting happened?? its so stupid...
Every1 in the end when shane sed to jonathan on the beach im really 2 lonely and ur my best friend he basically declared that he has feelings for him 2 thats y carrie was crying in the car and jonathan2 i watchedf this movie 5 times n not until yesterday did i really cry n finally understand it i neva cried the other times
I loved this scene, it was really beautiful (the whole movie was beautiful). But the ending wasn't that great.. I mean yay, good that they become friends but it would be better if they got together as a couple.
i watched this movie and it was really beautiful, but i couldnt help but feel like even though Jonathan liked Shane. Shane was obsessed with keeping Jonathan by his side.
This movie was based on a book and according to book, both guys had feelings towards each other... they cut it pretty sharply at the end, I was pretty sad actually. I thought at least they would know their true feelings but an open ending was okay, too, I guess
I've seen this movie more times than I would like to admit, and I don't believe that Shane slept with Johnathon to keep him from leaving. Shane had no idea that Johnathon was in love with him, he doesn't find out until the last 5 mins of the movie. Shane slept with him because that's what HE wanted to do. Johnathon assumed that Shane would not share his feelings, when the reality was that he felt the same way. Carrie figured out Shane's feeling which was why she was crying in her dark room.
he did this to keep his best friend..... ok yeah id never sleep with mine to keep her around (no offence hayley)
i mean you have to have some feelings for your friend to want to keep them THIS badly. this is a huge step to take especially if you dont know if you like someone in this way.
still a gorgeous scene though. i just wish it ended better :(
you know if he really had just did this to keep him, wouldn't it look more like SEX instead it looks like they made LOVE they look like they where taking the time out to enjoy one another : ) to soak each other in : O
catchtime20 4 weeks ago
@1:13 LOL, I saw that screen cap SOOOOOOOO many times because some people said it's YunJae, Lolololol. Aigoo, if it had a happy ending, I'd watch it.
Nomuna1V 4 weeks ago
omg :l sick
CrazyRedxxAly 1 month ago
1:15
Oh come on you fucking director, if Shane does not love Jonathan like that and only slept with him to keep him as his best friend (which really doesn't make sense), why is their so much passion in that kiss?
That girl is just a trouble maker and annoying. The director really messed up on the ending.
nickjonasbigfan 1 month ago 4
No way u can do that to your best friend and not have some sort of feelings for them Lol
silversaphiremoon 1 month ago 6
This movie has been out for years, but I only got the chance to watch it yesterday. Of course the ending was sad but the movie was great. Excellent performance for the 3 leads.
jaypeewarning 1 month ago
I'm sorry but Shane is an asshole and Jon should tell him to go fuck himself.
wickedb01 1 month ago
i love this scene. it's fantastic, a lot because of the soundtrack.
tallrik 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
THIS IS DISGUSTING HE IS BETTER WITH RAINIE YANG
kungbefu 1 month ago
i love this so much but i so wish that the ending was a happy one...:(
shawtyvwj 2 months ago
the movie ending was very very disappointed, as usual,the director put a b....h with Shane, how can Jon be friend with Shane after the sex,he just used him,even gay have moral,Jon wasn't that type of guy, Shane messed up really bad with Jon,i felt so sad, also Jon started to loose all he made for his studies as failed on last test,really sad.
lucaipiranga 2 months ago
what happen in the end they become couple or not?
Samanthacassie94 2 months ago
why???
erdfcv456123 2 months ago
i dont understand how you could become friends again after that. like. im straight but i wanted to keep you as a friend so i decided to screw you. that would make me really mad.
alexevensfan 2 months ago 2
that was disturbing.
azaraa999 2 months ago
can anyone tell me what the ending mean?
is they become a couple or what?
and i hate that girl, he know that Jonathan loves Shane, why she still date Shane?
accu26 2 months ago 3
AWWW :( so sweet
xxForgottenx 2 months ago
This movie will alwayz be my No.1... the story,the performances,the music everything was just PERFECT but the ending OMG i wanted to slap the director hard...it was so confusing... everyone's commenting dat dey stayed friends but how can SHANE just go back to CARRIE after having sex with Jonathan?? Dey'l just pretend dat noting happened?? its so stupid...
OinlovesJoon 2 months ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
(4)电影里呢? 除了混乱还是混乱。 床都上了,三个人居然还是维持着虚假的平衡,没办法,导演要求的。 于是我们看到慧嘉仍然厚着脸皮夹在两个男人中间,康正行仍然逃避余守恒,而强上了康正行的余守恒硬逼对方说出秘密,理直气壮到仿佛那一夜只是观众YY出来的同人。 我简直目瞪口呆,是导演的思维异于常人,还是他末了末了想学一把蔡明亮? 他也不嫌台词太多。 呆呆的看到最后,康正行泪流满面的表白,余守恒抛回来一句轻飘飘的“你是我最好的朋友”,画面切换字幕,完。
我当下决定,踢飞导演! 这个不知所谓的开放式结局让无数人重伤吐血,不是因为不确定,而是……他妈的你简直是在耍我! 整部电影里,导演竭力想告诉我们,这是三个人的爱情,可是我看到的,明明是两个相爱的男人互相折腾,用一个女人当道具的故事。 一篇好的小说,一个好的剧本,自然有他的灵魂。 我们的眼睛,总有一天能发现真相。 无论异性恋沙文主义如何扭曲,否认,抹杀……爱情,就是爱情。
顺序是 1-2-3-4,希望大家能明白.... 也希望有人能翻译成英文 !!~
Christayzhifan 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(3)他说完,头也不回的走了,丢下仓皇失措的余守恒,无助的像个迷失了方向的孩子。 原著里,余守恒知道自己做错了,在康正行和慧嘉之间,他必须做出选择。于是他立刻和慧嘉分手,去找康正行,吻他,和他做爱。 我们又说回了这场床戏。 原著里,这场床戏是没有攻受之分的(同人女的尾巴露出来了),但写明了,余守恒先吻康正行,却是康正行脱去了两人的衣服,两人在平等的,心甘情愿的情况下做爱。 而电影里,与其说是做爱,不如说余守恒硬上了康正行!最令我愤怒的是,导演凭什么认为,康正行会温顺的承受一个可能并不爱他的男人的侵犯? 是的,我说是侵犯,因为导演毫无常识,这场所谓性爱里康正行得不到任何快感,只会感觉痛苦和屈辱。 就因为他爱他?难道同性恋的爱情就一定卑屈低下如此?
更有甚者,事后打电话给上他的人的女友:“不管发生什么事,你们都要好好的在一起”,我冷笑,好一个圣母受啊。 原著里,故事到此为止,余守恒选择了康正行,慧嘉勇敢的重新上路寻找自己的幸福。
Christayzhifan 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(2)之前我说过,整部电影中充满着异性恋对同性恋的狭隘的一厢情愿的想象,一种貌似同情的鄙视。 为什么这么说? 首先,原著里的康正行并不像电影里那么“楚楚可怜”,不错他是完全的同性恋,可是同性恋并不表示他就肯定是弱势的一方,他先爱上,并不代表他就一定会隐忍到底牺牲到底自卑到底。 在他和余守恒的关系中,虽然余守恒是恒星,他是围绕恒星的行星,但余守恒对他的依恋明显更强,康正行没有余守恒能活下去,余守恒没有康正行,会疯了吧? 原著里,康正行试过将他和余守恒的关系转变为情人,没有成功,所以主动疏远了余守恒——既然你只要朋友,那我们就只是朋友。 是余守恒无视他的疏远,非要把他一次次的拉回自己身边。 而电影里的康正行从意识到自己对余守恒的感情就开始逃避他,导演未免太看不起他,《蓝色大门》里的女孩子都敢向好朋友告白,堂堂男人连尝试的勇气都没有?
原著里,康正行和余守恒的互动一直是平等的,很多时候甚至是强势的,尤其是得知余守恒和慧嘉在一起,他不是像电影里那样哀怨(老天)的快快离去,而是向余守恒问个清楚明白,然后才冷静的说,我们以后不要再混在一起了。
Christayzhifan 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我是转载别人的评语,因为本人实在接受不了结局了.看不懂结局的人可以参考一下哦^^由于评语过于长,所以我分成几段.
(1)看《盛夏光年》之前,我先看了原著《光年》,庆幸这个决定,让我在导演的叙述方式之外看清了整个故事,发现了影片中无处不在的,来自异性恋对同性恋的歧视。 首先,不谈原著,在电影中,我怎么看余守恒都是爱康正行的。 他打篮球是为了给他看,康正行不在他就打得差,康正行在场边和女生说笑,他就憋屈得跟人打架,他对引起康正行注意的所有女生都怀有敌意,首当其冲的慧嘉,他先下手为强,让她爱上自己。
OK,到这里我们还可以说是小孩子的独占欲,所以电影的前半段还能看,可是从那场莫名其妙的床戏开始,一切都乱了套。 原著里,这场床戏为什么会发生是有铺垫的,水到渠成的,而电影里,这似乎就是余守恒一时的心血来潮。甚至前面,余守恒为了康正行和慧嘉分手的一段也被剪掉了,显得更加突兀。 实在的说,这场床戏的画面很漂亮,就像整部电影的光影一样美好,音乐带来淡淡的伤感,余守恒吻康正行时珍惜而小心翼翼的神情令人感动。 可是,我愤怒了。
Christayzhifan 2 months ago
the last time i saw joseph kissing rainie yang,,, and then,,, this,,, oh my!!! i hope it'll be me instead of that guy,,,
melibyne 3 months ago
WAIT this scene was cut. Show the entire scene....
UFOSPACE1999 3 months ago 3
where can i watched the full movie subbed in eng?
tubercdz 3 months ago
whats the name of the song played in this scene or the piano music
thebabyjjm1 3 months ago
Every1 in the end when shane sed to jonathan on the beach im really 2 lonely and ur my best friend he basically declared that he has feelings for him 2 thats y carrie was crying in the car and jonathan2 i watchedf this movie 5 times n not until yesterday did i really cry n finally understand it i neva cried the other times
thebabyjjm1 3 months ago 2
I loved this scene, it was really beautiful (the whole movie was beautiful). But the ending wasn't that great.. I mean yay, good that they become friends but it would be better if they got together as a couple.
xeliberg33x 3 months ago
I'd be like well were halfway there and let him in the back door.
23raynsc 4 months ago
My face: *U*
lederping 4 months ago
i watched this movie and it was really beautiful, but i couldnt help but feel like even though Jonathan liked Shane. Shane was obsessed with keeping Jonathan by his side.
youcrazyism 5 months ago
This movie was based on a book and according to book, both guys had feelings towards each other... they cut it pretty sharply at the end, I was pretty sad actually. I thought at least they would know their true feelings but an open ending was okay, too, I guess
nesli 5 months ago 3
@nesli:
Really? What's The Books Name And Who's The Author?
XxProhibitedLovexX 4 months ago
@XxProhibitedLovexX I remember finding it but it's been years, so you have to go and search chinese websites "盛夏光年"
nesli 4 months ago
@nesli: O_O Is there a translation for that and thank you lol
XxProhibitedLovexX 4 months ago
@XxProhibitedLovexX I don't think it's published in english :(
nesli 4 months ago
@nesli:
Awww D: TY Any ways
XxProhibitedLovexX 4 months ago
1:12 kaboom jaejoong XD
MoonrockSea 5 months ago 2
@Cagallirocks the scene is not ended like this.i've watched the full movie and the scene is ended in a beautiful but HOTTTTTT way
hirumayoichi21 6 months ago 7
I've seen this movie more times than I would like to admit, and I don't believe that Shane slept with Johnathon to keep him from leaving. Shane had no idea that Johnathon was in love with him, he doesn't find out until the last 5 mins of the movie. Shane slept with him because that's what HE wanted to do. Johnathon assumed that Shane would not share his feelings, when the reality was that he felt the same way. Carrie figured out Shane's feeling which was why she was crying in her dark room.
kiaransali 6 months ago 18
this is sooooooooooooooooo hot
277124 6 months ago 4
OMG Yaoi is really HOT.... This video made me horny
margc1988 8 months ago 13
where can i watch this?
bluesky8002sbcglobal 8 months ago 2
he did this to keep his best friend..... ok yeah id never sleep with mine to keep her around (no offence hayley)
i mean you have to have some feelings for your friend to want to keep them THIS badly. this is a huge step to take especially if you dont know if you like someone in this way.
still a gorgeous scene though. i just wish it ended better :(
Cagallirocks 8 months ago 77
@Cagallirocks excellent comment, I just wanted to say. Not just because I agree but, because it covers all the bases and well spoken.
Tebigong101 6 months ago
@Tebigong101 thank you :D a non rude/abusive comment. i knew there were decent people still on the internet <3
Cagallirocks 6 months ago
:) It's such a beautiful scene. I was happy that they became friends again in the end, but I was disappointed that they didn't end up being a couple.
xxLittlexPrettyxx 9 months ago 47