I have looked everywhere on the internet for this live track and still can't find it, would you mind sending me the downloading link for this track please?
The Winter Gardens.... does this mean the Bournemouth winter gardens? If so, I wish I'd been a few years older! I can't even think where the stage would have been?!
I like every song by Joy Division except Isolation *my bad guys * But this is one of the heaviest songs I ever heard. I just wish that they wouldn't have took the live footage of this song. There is another one but with bad quality, oh well, Still a BEAST band. Probably the best thing that came out of the 70's.
@Kento617 It is a shame that there is no video footage, but keep in mind that in the late 70's, video cameras were new & very expensive. Especially in poverty stricken 70's Manchester.
@AgentXPQ oh dang you're right. It was basically hell over there. Factory buildings falling everywhere, smog filled skies, you wouldn't think something that good like Joy Division would come out of there. MTV came out a year or so after their demise so they missed it just barely. I wish I could have saw them live
At least I can say for sure there is no version in existence more drenched in despair than this one. Joy Division's best song? Well, it's sure gaining my personal interest more and more, yes:-D!
is this song about jim jones and his colony? im Just wondering.
Ryanyarb24 1 month ago
@Ryanyarb24
It's based off of Franz Kofka's short story ("Colony"), as well as taking elements from Ian's failing marriage.
NintendoSegaSonyGuy 3 weeks ago
@Rigler01 No, this was Malvern Winter Gardens.
LARECTORY 6 months ago
@LARECTORY
No, it wasn't. It was Bournemouth.
NintendoSegaSonyGuy 2 months ago
@NintendoSegaSonyGuy Yep, you're right. Means I wasn't there after all.
LARECTORY 2 months ago
I have looked everywhere on the internet for this live track and still can't find it, would you mind sending me the downloading link for this track please?
ObeliskL10 8 months ago
@ObeliskL10 youtube - mp3 org
360Freakoutkid 6 months ago
Wow - I was at this gig. A very special night.
LARECTORY 8 months ago
@LARECTORY
The Winter Gardens.... does this mean the Bournemouth winter gardens? If so, I wish I'd been a few years older! I can't even think where the stage would have been?!
Rigler01 7 months ago
otherworldly
TheWheels777 9 months ago
I like every song by Joy Division except Isolation *my bad guys * But this is one of the heaviest songs I ever heard. I just wish that they wouldn't have took the live footage of this song. There is another one but with bad quality, oh well, Still a BEAST band. Probably the best thing that came out of the 70's.
Kento617 1 year ago
@Kento617 It is a shame that there is no video footage, but keep in mind that in the late 70's, video cameras were new & very expensive. Especially in poverty stricken 70's Manchester.
AgentXPQ 10 months ago
@AgentXPQ oh dang you're right. It was basically hell over there. Factory buildings falling everywhere, smog filled skies, you wouldn't think something that good like Joy Division would come out of there. MTV came out a year or so after their demise so they missed it just barely. I wish I could have saw them live
Kento617 10 months ago
It's too easy to see their influence everywhere in rock music 30 years later.
kvic2011 1 year ago 5
@kvic2011 I know right. They influenced me greatly! If Ian wouldn't have died before the american tour, they would have taken over America!
Kento617 1 year ago
@kvic2011 especially interpol.
NineInchNails25 3 weeks ago in playlist Uploaded videos
joy division is la mejor banda de manchester de 1977
igusish 1 year ago
Truly the beest live version of this song. I love the acoustics and the way it echoes like their playing in some deep tunnel.
Jarrodboy 1 year ago
@Jarrodboy Yeah man. Colony and Shadowplay are their best live songs!
Kento617 10 months ago
This is a nightmare where a voice guides us to freedom, la voz de un poeta...
alexandro1011 1 year ago
@alexandro1011 This godly immortal voice!
TheRoseanne58 1 year ago
a eternal WOW for this alternative evergreen
jangenk 2 years ago 3
the best version of the best song from the most powerfully original band in the world
wadetshaw 2 years ago 14
At least I can say for sure there is no version in existence more drenched in despair than this one. Joy Division's best song? Well, it's sure gaining my personal interest more and more, yes:-D!
FSchouten 2 years ago