Disturbed's version is so much better than Genesis, and better than the In Flames version even more than that. And the reason he doesn't sing so well now is he got a serious throat infection and had to retrain his vocal chords, thus resulting in the raspier voice he has now.
This demonstrates why Phil Collins is so rich and still pulls a crowd if he chooses to ;-). Nonetheless, it´s always fun when a metal band takes on a good classic song, even if it´s beyond their musical ability (especially the singer).
Now I´m waiting for Metallica, Nickelback or Prince to cover this song. Any one of them could pull it off properly.
So the singer doesn't sound like Phil Collins so it's beyond his ability? He sounded great here, and Dan's solo is way more complicated than the original one. I think we can both agree that this one pwns the shitty cover that In Flames did.
Bull shit dude. If a metal band makes it big the it doesn't automatically mean they sold out and are MTV's puppets. They write their own music, nobody condenses it or holds them down with Disturbed's consent. If they were metal condensed then they wouldn't swear, come up with kick ass guitar solos, strong and deep lyrics, solid drum parts etc. they aren't condensed and they're on a hiatus partly because they think the music industry SUCKS!!! They're metal, end of story.
when he loses he breath he sounds like Jack Black, ha!! still, enjoyed this :)
t3hpez 3 days ago
lol
sonnytiger 1 month ago
I like the bridge better in Disturbed's version mainly because it doesn't lose as much of it's built up energy. Other than that i must say Genesis.
kristophize 2 months ago
@kristophize
What about the solo? I prefer Dan's by a longshot.
Fluffypopcicle 1 month ago
@Fluffypopcicle Oh forgot all about it :P Yeah, i like Dan's solo better too.
kristophize 1 month ago
Kinda cool but the original is rad
itchyroid 2 months ago
Disturbed's version is so much better than Genesis, and better than the In Flames version even more than that. And the reason he doesn't sing so well now is he got a serious throat infection and had to retrain his vocal chords, thus resulting in the raspier voice he has now.
improvisedcinema1 2 months ago
everything was okay,except the instrumental part at 2:30
greatpcfan 3 months ago
This demonstrates why Phil Collins is so rich and still pulls a crowd if he chooses to ;-). Nonetheless, it´s always fun when a metal band takes on a good classic song, even if it´s beyond their musical ability (especially the singer).
Now I´m waiting for Metallica, Nickelback or Prince to cover this song. Any one of them could pull it off properly.
OberstHulmbug 3 months ago
@OberstHulmbug
So the singer doesn't sound like Phil Collins so it's beyond his ability? He sounded great here, and Dan's solo is way more complicated than the original one. I think we can both agree that this one pwns the shitty cover that In Flames did.
Fluffypopcicle 1 month ago
I'm not a fan of disturbed - it's metal condensed and popularized through MTV. Still, it's a catchy riff, really powerful, decent song! From 1:33.
slaaaaave 3 months ago
@slaaaaave
Bull shit dude. If a metal band makes it big the it doesn't automatically mean they sold out and are MTV's puppets. They write their own music, nobody condenses it or holds them down with Disturbed's consent. If they were metal condensed then they wouldn't swear, come up with kick ass guitar solos, strong and deep lyrics, solid drum parts etc. they aren't condensed and they're on a hiatus partly because they think the music industry SUCKS!!! They're metal, end of story.
Fluffypopcicle 1 month ago
I like both versions
comedy677 4 months ago 10
Fuckin' hell, he was good then, what ever happened to his voice now ?
PTR01981 4 months ago
GREATEST COVER EVER! This is what is currently going on. Wake UP PEOPLE!!!
ranger5171 4 months ago
EPIC SONG + Epic BAND = EPIC WIN
DoctorWayForward 5 months ago
phil collins is proud of this version
Peloncho666 7 months ago
@Peloncho666 this is an excellent version,no one can't says that they ruined the original,because they do and excellent work on this cover xD
madneess 5 months ago
i like the other version better dont hate on phil collins and other genisis members because if it wasnt for them this song wouldent exist
nh5662 7 months ago
This is better than the other version
apchciabella 7 months ago
Is this a try to fuck up a legendary song?
Sondretungodden 7 months ago
@Sondretungodden i think you're wrong this is a cover,a tribute to the band...for me a excellent cover!
madneess 5 months ago
Phil Collins, Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford disliked this video.
ZachValkyrie 9 months ago 10
@ZachValkyrie dont be hating on phil collins
nh5662 7 months ago
@ZachValkyrie and now justin bieber joined them :/
lovedrums4ever 5 months ago 2
@lovedrums4ever you should not mention her name with legends
greatpcfan 3 months ago
@ZachValkyrie
The 4th man is Steve Hackett?
umakara55 4 months ago 3
@umakara55 no, i think it's the guy from In Flames who has doing a shitty cover of this song....
eurojammer47 4 months ago
@ZachValkyrie and they have earned the right to do anything :)
greatpcfan 3 months ago
@ZachValkyrie well phil collines would have every right to do that if he did...
trecoolmania 3 weeks ago
These guys are unreal, saw them live last year at Darien Lake, which is an outdoor venue and it sounded amazing
XxBlindedGuitaristxX 10 months ago
Driving! So long ago
rocknbluesrock 11 months ago
nothing beats the original, but Disturbed does a great cover
frankieieroisntgay 1 year ago 3
Rapes replay button
VivaLaGaming360 1 year ago 2
2 people are Bieber lovers XD Epic fail on those two, Disturbed is the best band of the 2000's and will be through and through.
gokufan1101 1 year ago
he sounds like a strait jack black
ZaroThorn69 1 year ago
great coveR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
lostinspacex 1 year ago
attach &fmt=18 to the link for better quality and faster loading.
ps.: works for all videos on youtube
Emanuel222222 2 years ago
Blinded by the awesomeness =D
5 stars
Studmuffins1234 2 years ago
Best band in the world History!!!!
Disturbed For EVER!!!!
When i am old enough to have a tattoo, then i want one of DISTURBED!!!
Best band in the worlds history!!
\\m// \\m//
D1sturb3df0r3ver 2 years ago
Amazing video dude! Disturbed 4 life!
deathonwings55 2 years ago
Awsome! Can you see this is the land of confusion?
Metalbass92 2 years ago
Nice dude !
suzandeblanken 2 years ago
AMAZING!!!!!! Disturbed for life xD
Verysadpupet1 2 years ago
awsome 5 stars
brandonkersenbrock2 3 years ago 3