Added: 4 years ago
From: AriePenris
Views: 64,729
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (248)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It's such a hard song to sing anyway surely, given it's so high. But I do think daniel was better, I remember watching this and being blown away.

  • lewis wasnt too bad but his voice is too boyish for this song daniel is much more mature....

  • No one will ever sing this song better than Colm Wilkinson but such an amazing song

  • I LOVE DANIEL BOYS!

  • no doubt daniel was better! daniel's just generally a better singer than lewis, though i think lewis has improved a lot. i've seen lewis in wicked (as fiyero) several times and although i still think he needs to work on his singing, i really enjoy him in the role of fiyero and actually prefer him to lee! daniel's done great too :) with avenue q and everything. wish them both the best!

  • DANIEL YOU KILLED IT :D

  • Daniel is better

  • they both have beautiful voices, if i had to pick i would not be aboul to,they both have great stregnth in their on ways

  • How did Lewis beat Daniel?! Daniel sounded so much more emotional and into the song. I feel like Danile understood what he was singing about. Lewis had too young of a voice and Daniel was much more mature. Daniel should have made it farther than he did.

  • I never understood why Lewis would ever be judged better than Daniel. Lewis had terrible technique and I didn't believe anything he said. Daniel should have made top 2 at least.

  • daniel is so much better than lewis

  • So much emotion in Daniel...

  • Dark haired fella was SO much better.

  • i saw Lewis when he understudied for Lee in Joseph, he was amazing! Like a lot of people I didnt understand why Lloyd Webber kept him in especially compared to Daniel, but seeing him play Joseph I was blown away

  • @StraightEdge01 Totally agree, I saw him in Wicked last week and he was fantastic...I couldn't see it in him in this show - obviously ALW really can see something the rest of us can't see! Daniel is great though, shame either had to go :-)

  • Is this in a lower key? :/ They both have nice voices, but It's a shame two peole had to sing it- doesn't realy have the same effect.

  • I love Daniel- he so should have been Joseph! x

  • they both sucked ! keith is the is the best !!

  • omg dude with dark hair was arse kicking wow lewis (if thats the blonde one) does all songs the same hes good but the other one is better

  • God they're too young to be Valjean anyway >.>

  • they suck

  • daniel is wayy better

    their costumes are butt-ugly, though!!

  • I'd like to know what ALW had drunk or smoked that day.

  • Daniel has an amazing voice. Did Lewis make the final 3?? If so, how?? There were people in that show with much better voices and Daniel is one of the and he just puts so much emotion into every performance.

  • I thinks its cuz he looked the part the most out of everyone... but i totally agree he sucks... and he's such a cry baby

  • Lewis is weak! His voice is weak, his phrasing is poor, he lacks confidence. Get him off the stage!

  • at least he got the words right at the end.

    While not as strong as Daniel, he's also younger and better for the role in question in Andrew's eyes. Also, you have to remember this was based off the previous performance and the viewer vote. Daniel wasn't giving Andrew what he wanted in his performance, so he got the boot. He's mad talented, don't get me wrong, but wrong for Joseph.

  • Daniel is BETTER :D

    also from Holland!

  • Daniel can sing much better!

  • Boo on key change.

  • Daniel so much better.

  • aw. daniel has a much better voice than lewis, and did much better in this sing off. but oh well. he's pretty successful now with avenue Q, so i guess it's all good!

  • Comment removed

  • Daniel is so lovely- fab voice and what a friendly guy! met him last week after Avenue Q and was bowled over by his genuiness and charm. Deserves all the success due to him.

  • Daniel is so mutch better!!

    From Holland.

  • hahah i really agree.

  • Thank you! haha

    (much* sorry)

  • The one in purple is so much better.

    from Holland.

  • Lewis was a pretty face but Daniel had the superior voice. This is such a hard song because your constantly going from falsetto to chest. Very few men can sing it properly and I think Daniel did better by far.

  • Daniel is super. He is special and will get on. He and John Barrowman together have an etremely good sound. JB will look after him. I think Daniel didn't get this job bacause he is gay.

  • Lewis only "won" because he was a "struggling underdog" that brought in viewers from the uncultured and ignorant masses that knew nothing of what musical theatre talent truly is. His technique was absent. YOU DO NOT SING THIS SONG IN YOUR FACE. But Mr. Webber knew what he was doing... He knew that while Dan was immensely talented, he wasn't going to win in the end. So, he cut him loose and kept the little d-bag that brought in viewers. But Dan showed those who knew the truth how wrong that was.

  • OH MY GOSH. I BAWLED when daniel got chucked...wrong decision...*shakes head* :)

  • Dan was good...just couldn't show the vulnerability and expression in his face joseph needs to have...

    still, they are both fantastic, and I doubt any of us could do better :)

  • i screamed at the tv when daniel went. it was completely wrong.

  • its like 2 years on i still think the wrong desision was made!!! lol

  • DANIEL WAS SOOO MUCH BETTER!!!

    But he's done the better out of the two of them anyway :D

  • I have not seen this o tv (im not from uk) but this one is deff better done by Daniel. Shame he didnt go through.

  • i wanted daniel to go through...

    im still angry bout it lol

  • eeuugh i hated Lewis, dunno how he lasted so long. Daniel was great, he's in Avenue Q now though isn't he? So it all worked out for him.

  • Daniel i loved you

  • I'm sorry but I think Andrew Llyod Webber MIGHT know what he's doing...maybe I'm wrong.

  • They BOTH sang VERY well, and all the losers on here who are BASHING them, I'd like to see you nutcases do better !

  • i loved daniel! boooooooooooo!

  • daniel was one of the best, he shouldnt of gone so early.

    His close every door was immense

  • Daniel = sings, acts, looks the best

    xx

  • NO, NO, NO!!! THIS IS TOO TERRIBLE! STOP! STOP! WHY DID THEY SLAUGHTER THE POOR SONG? I want to slap them both for singing so badly!

  • Daniel should have got through!!!!!

  • Daniel in this case is much better. This song needs power and lewis' voice was too whiney and girly to manage it

  • does everyone not see that Daniel rips lewis to shreads on this and yet he gets voted out? ah well daniel doin great now anyway, im glad cos hes fucking talented!

  • yes it was crazy he got voted off against lewis....shouldve been a lee daniel final

  • Daniel is outstanding on this vid i remeber watching this x

  • les miserables is such an amazing musical

    the song bring him home

    is in the dutch breng hem thuis

    and it sound amazing

  • Daniel is awesome, not only is he a better actor, but his voice is so much more mature and beautiful than Lewis'...plus he has better phrasing.

  • i remember watching this and not being able to stop crying

  • they both suck...horribly...good thing they didn't win

  • lewis is rubbish! he can't act! he only concentrates on his singing!

  • Daniel is a brilliant singer!!

  • Lewis couldn't convey half the emotion Daniel could

  • This is my all time favorite musical I love it. I've seen it five times and the last time i saw it i cried at this song, it's such an emotional story line I LOVE IT!!! J xx

  • Does anyone know where this song originally comes from?

  • le miserables

  • les miserables

  • Really can't believe Danile went after that amazing performance. His voice is much more suitable for the west end and the way he swells the notes at the end of words is beautiful. He would make an excellent Jean Valjean in Les Mis!!! :P

  • wow, so beautiful!

  • Who are these guys?

  • Personally I think Daniel was much better. He sounded more rounded...and Lewis sounded girly and naselly compared to the more rounded and bassy tone of Daniel.

  • I think Daniel is so much better than Lewis here!

  • any rim will do

  • i think Daniel was so much better but maybe Andrew thought Lewis would be a better jospeh because he looks more like a traditional joseph. I LOVE DANIEL so glad hes in Avenue Q his voice is amazing

  • arrrgghhh i hate lewis he is shabba!!!!!

  • lewis's vowel placement drives me crazy! Daniel was awesome

  • cant you make up your own mind. do you have to base greatness purely on what an "expert" says it is.

  • did lewis make a mistake near the end or was he meant to sing diff lyrics to daniel?

  • yes he was wrong!!

  • Daniel sang the wrong lyrics.

  • lewis.......what are you doing

  • haha, daniel was sooooooo much bettter, i really dont think lewis can sing very well!!

    x

  • TUT TUT! Where's the falsetto boys?

  • i think daniel did WAY better in this song than lewis did

  • so do i! and i was there so i should know!!

  • my absolute favourite song from les mis :]

    just a brilliant musical really...

  • lewis has a neck like a swan, lolz

  • they really like les miserables

  • Daniel to play JVJ when he is a bit older! I reckon he could pull Javert of too!

  • so does ur face

  • I admit, i cried when i saw this on TV. Esp Daniel singing at the end :'( AMAZING He was also amazing when i saw him in Avenue Q.

  • Everyone knows that Daniel was the best singer in the competition, but I'm glad he did not win, because Avenue Q is much better! +D

  • Lewis sang it like a choirboy, all sweetness and nice. Daniel acted his ass off, he was nearly crying! He shouldn't have gone, he would have been awesome.

  • Daniel more polished and professional though not a Joseph. Though maybe a Phantom? Lewis, as has been said, had the look.

    But more importantly Daniel hashed the lyrics at the end of the song. Lewis didn't. At the very end after it's "If I die, let me die! Let him live, bring him home" Which Lewis nailed, but Daniel didn't. He sang "If I die, let me die! bring him home, bring him home" So he had to repeat it, and it stood out a country mile!

    And for a sing off, that's suicide I'm afraid.

  • the guy in the purple is by far the better- the guy in the blue doesn't understand WHAT her is singing ABOUT

  • Absolute rubbish!

    They stick it down a 4th so they can manage any effort at good singing! The guy in purple is fantastic, the guy in blue not good at all.

    It's still a MASSIVE cop-out not singing it at written pitch.

  • If Lewis is no good at all then why is he filling in for Lee at the Adelphi during Lee's holidays then?!

    Lewis is absolutely amazing. I've seen him in Joseph and he was totally brilliant! He's also a very lovely lad. I've met him twice. :)

    Daniel has gone on to do wonderful things and I agree that he's fantastic. Just that Lewis stood out more for me and I supported him all the way!

  • Based on this performance alone (or if they were looking for a future Valjean) Daniel had to stay. That wasn't what it was about though. The very best to both of them.

  • im still pissed that daniel was kicked out

    he was as good, if not better than lee

    and lewis was gash

  • +Lewis' "Let him live" on his 2nd solo practically perfection. If his "Let me die" just after that isn't emotion and amazing acting, then I don't know what is!

  • Lewis was great, he completely deserved to stay. He'sliving his dream as Joseph on Lee's holidays and he's FANTASTIC!!

  • lewis was amazing, he looked so vunerable (ignore spelling)

    just brilliant.

  • I can see what people see in Lewis, but Daniel shouldn't have gone over Lewis, they are not even comparable as performers!

    Daniel sings this so greatly aswell, he will make a great valjean when he gets older!!

  • Daniel sang this amazingly well- Lewis only got through because he looks like a Joseph with his fucking dyed blonde hair

  • Actually technically Joseph should have dark hair as Joseph is an Israelite, and their most common genetic trait was dark hair. Therefore his blonde hair actually puts him at a disadvantage if you want to take that stand on it!

  • Sorry everyone this was meant to be a direct reply to Mr. Tickster's comment

  • I was sobbing when daniel got voted off, he was way better and i loved him, not as much as lee mead but he was my second fave. still brings a tear to my eye, he was fantastic =]

  • WTF

    Daniel was shittin on lewis

    lewis is a twat who was voted over every 1 good

  • i think Daniel sang and acted it better... but sadly it was ALWs choice

  • the best singoff by a mile. but daniel wiped the floor with lewis; a better actor, and he was more on key. lewis got through cos of his looks.

  • A very good song from Les Mis, and performed very well but I prefer lewis. But if it was for a les mis performance Daniel would suit the part better

  • lewis was much better, daniel was far too over the top

  • You Just Want To Go Give Daniel A Hug!!

  • hahaa!! these jackets are my favourite!

  • love you daniel :)

  • These two are some of my favorites!

  • Lewis && Daniel r So Hot =P

  • I was so upset when Daniel was voted out! He was obviously the better singer - did you hear the crackle in Lewis' voice at the start of the song? He could barely reach that note! It was an unfair plot on ALW's part.

  • i agree and that note isnt that high either

    i couldnt stand lewis when he was on !!

  • i was devistated! i didn't mind lewis but i thought Daniel should have got to the final

  • Daniel sung this with easy. More emotion.

  • Les Mis songs are amazing!

  • Not va most amazin song but its ok I suppose anything to have Lewis kept i!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I get chills when Daniel sings this!

  • Same... Whooa!

  • my baby daniel :(

  • lewis sounded off key at the start

  • My only regret about Lee was all the superb songs were in the sing off and he never got to sing them. love this, Tell meits not true etc.

  • not the best is it

  • 2ND GUY IS WAY BETTER

  • daniel was much better than lewis on here lewis shud of been voted out!

  • Lewis is over-acting in this... he looks like he is getting stabbed!

  • Well, I'm going to be the first to say...I think that Lewis was the best in this performance. I find his voice purer and makes me melt. His overall appearance is more suited for Joseph but Daniel was my second favorite Joseph and I was very upset when he went out, at the same time being glad that Lewis stayed in!

  • I saw Daniel yesterday in 'Sweeney Todd' at the Southbank Center. He was playing Anthony, and though whilst he was in the show I wasn't that big a fan due to his problem with smiling, he really did do well yesterday next to such legends as Bryn Terfel and Maria Friedman.

  • hey does anyone know where i can get these two singing this onto my i pod ???

  • umm..u could try downloading it off limewire on to ur itunes...then put it on ur ipod..

  • Everytime I watch this, I get chills. I am completly in awe of the talent Daniel shows in this clip.

  • Gay <G>

  • ...?

  • Les Mis...LOVE IT!!

  • love daniels voice...*melts*!!!

  • andrew had the best facial expressions ever!

  • Eventhough he's not joseph, the final would be a lot more exciting if we had Daniel in it. Both him and Lee are just superb. Best man for the job, won and ultimately, that's what counts.

    *sigh* always tear up when I hear this song... In this way

  • I don't think throughout ADWD we had so moving a performance by DANIEL BOYS and it was still not good enough for ALW as others have said DANIEL is not just Joe! He is worth much more in THE WEST END!

  • getting carried away ..daniel's tone/voice/diction whatevr on give him peace, give joy....is sublime...

  • sorry but have to add more....his(daniel) voice is just beautiful

  • love les mis, love colm wilkinson...daniel did a fantastic job...cameron macintosh..hope you you were listening...ALW was right he aint joe..he far too good;-)

  • i couldnt believe this!! daniels voice portrayed such emotion and power. and his crescendos were jus beautiful! lewis was pityful! andrew made a LOT of wrong decisions this time in my opinion. lol x

  • I agree Daniel was so much better. Shame, thought he was a winner.

  • YES! His crscendos made my hairs stand on end, and my lip quiver.. he same a very safe tone in his voice like Zoe said, and it does sound boring with the cheesy songs, but in this he shows what he can really do. He leaves the safe tone behind and puts emotion in it, that's what he is best at. But hey, may the best man win tomorrow!

  • Console yourself: give Daniel twenty years to age, and if he can't do a Jean Valjean to be proud of I'll eat my computer.

  • i love this song and daniel sings it with such emotion and hits every note perfect! LEE TO WIN!

  • if there was any justic, the final would be Lee, Daniel and Ben. Tragic they both got knocked out by Lewis.

  • hey all you people saying daniel was better, if he was then andrew would have picked him. he simply picks the better one of the 2

  • the better Joseph, yes. Not necessarily the better allround performer. But, yes Daniel was great but not exactly Joseph...

  • I loved Daniel! I don't think he would have won, but he should definately have been in the final! his voice his sooo much better than lewis'.

  • i love Daniels voice and was gutted wen he was voted off!!

    i agree with the panel though that Lewis wouldnt be able to hack it! hes only 17 and needs more experience to get in it.

    it was unfair that Daniel was voted off, he was abit nice aswell;P lol.

    i really hope that Lee wins this though now. *fingers crossed*

    i still really wana see this performance at the theatre tho.

  • I think this is such a pretty performance by both,

    do prefer Daniel though.

    Lee to win ^^

  • Yes, Daniel was far better that night, and is an amazing singer and actor. But he's not Jospeh. Lewis IS Joseph. And he was AMAZING last time. Completely amazing. Lewis should be Joseph all the way! Though I love Lee too - I'd like to see him as Pharoh.

  • I was thinking that too! Lee as Pharaoh. Then I saw he'd done it before, but still. Lee as Pharaoh :p

    Can I be narrator?!

  • lol, can you sing high? Narrator has to sing VERY high.

    And Ben for Bejamin (I don't like Keith).

    I wanna be in the choir again! (Couldn't be in the horse shoe though, too big now)

  • Well... I'm a mezzo, so I guess not. hehe.. Maybe they could make an exception? Wouldn't mind being in the choir, were it not that I already at uni... Were you in the choir at the west end production?

    I guess I'll just stick with Eponine, and Daniel as Marius ;)

  • Yeah, about three years ago (with the most awesome pharoh EVER).

    I think a mezzo might be able to do it.

    And Les Mis is awesome!

  • The best sing off by far!!! If Daniel doesn't get a part in the west end then well...i haven't thought that far ahead but i'll be very upset!! Absolutely bloody brilliant - but ruined my 18th birthday!!

  • I agree that Daniel is a far better singer (his voice is in a different league to Lewis) and he performs with far more ease (plus I have to mention that he is very sexy) but he's not right for the part of Joseph. Jeseph is young and simply a bragging boy at the beginning of the musical. I just cannot see Daniel in that role. I think that the main reason Andrew keeps going for the younger boys in the sing offs. Personally I think Ben would be best, although he's not my favourite.

  • Beautiful song, beautifully sung and performed by Daniel, and completely ridiculed by Lewis. Daniel's standard is so far ahead of the others that it isn't surprising that the voting public got complacent but for Andrew Lloyd Webber to choose the one not just devoid of a spectacular voice or any sort of acting talent but also of any sort of particular appeal of any sort, belies his years in the industry.

    Having said that, Daniel is far too good for a lightweight musical like 'Joseph'.

  • I reckon the Lord has already chosen his Joseph, and getting rid of Daniel was just being tactical.

  • Now my opinion keeps changing on this but I think ALW knew what he was doing. Half of me believes this was a tactical decision to eliminate Lee's biggest threat, however I do think that as good as Daniel is, he would not be a Joseph. In something else I'm sure he will amaze, but somehow... not Joseph. I also don't think Daniel is necessarily better, I think they both sang very well, they just have strongly contrasting voices. Lewis WOULD make a better Joseph imo. Go Lewis! x

  • Now that Darling Daniel is gone for me it's a choice between Lee and keith.

  • Ah ALW why, why, why!

  • i cant believe that ALW kept in Lewis, Daniel was so much better - not that it matters because Lee had better win because he is AMAZING!! him and Keith for the final xXx