@chadd990 Yeah man....this song hits the core of you when you're going through issues with your loved one. Good luck on the upcoming journey through it. One thing for sure....Pearl Jams music has always helped me dealing with things. Take a listen to Courdroy, Parting Ways and Rearviewmirror for a little more "help" .
great job on the vid. this is one of my favs, the other being the long road. i wore out two merkenball cd's. crazy mary is one of my faves too. so many great songs, it's really hard to pick. loll
this song is for me i fcked up so bad. i was a singal father for 14 years. now becouse of some poor choices i lost my kids to the state and its like, like the song says.
@1CoLd3 You have a pause button on a Youtube video, just so you know. Indeed, you don't have to search for a button you can just click on the video screen.
When asked about "Nothingman" in an interview, Vedder stated, "The idea is about if you love someone and they love you, don't fuck up...'cause you are left with less than nothing."
One just escapes...ones left inside the well..........and he who forgets...will be destined to remember.....thats wat u call real lyrics not like that shit bieber sings
@iStevie That's his quote. They're asking him if it was written before or after his marriage and he answered. So those are his words. So tell Eddie that Jeff wrote it... see what he tells you .........
@edemvedson no need to, he already told me in london last 25th of june. funny. maybe the guy that interviewed him asked him the same way you are replying to me, but without asking THE question: did you write the song? haha :D
@KLthebig I like that you included AC/DC in as one of the best ever. Most people just stick to Led Zep and Black Sabbath and the like. AC/DC never get the credit they deserve (although they are popular and wealthy as hell).
Didn't expect this to sound so amazing live. Most often these kind of songs by bands sound great on the CD, trash in real life. Eddie, you're the king.
artists evolve CreamyKrau. Its elemental. All bands that are worth a shit are going to grow and change. You can't write about the same stuff when your 35 as you did when you were 25.
said it better than I could've... I can't stand all the stupid "oh you sold out" idiots... like a band'll keep making the same album over and over again JUST to make them happy.. actually THAT is the definition of country. Soem pearl jam albums took gettin used to .. but you can never deny the HEART they put into every single one :)
@CreamyKrau Hi how are ya, this is planet earth we live on. There is a band called Pearl Jam and they rock everyone's socks off when they play. Eddie Vedder can make girl cum just by sayin' ''hey how are ya''. Country ? nah they don't call it country they call it Freakingunbelievablerockingfuckingcryinggrungindrinkinlosingyourvoicebysingingalong!
nothing to do with cobain,cobain was totally jealous in my view of a greater talent,and his views of pearl jam bieng more commercial were unfounded and stupid,seeing as that nirvana quite happily signed to geffen records and there wonderfull pr machine
It wasn't so much a greater talent, but a music and style that was so much different than Kobain's songs of hateful introspection and fixation on wrongs. Vedder knew how to love, not that Kobain didn't, but Vedder wrote about it with joy (at times, and in lamented words like this song displays) while Kobain's words were always so filled with a certain pain derived from a much earlier and deeper root. They really were quite different generes, as I'm sure most listeners agree.
No, Cobain and Eddie hated each other... or at least Cobain hated Eddie. This song is about the idea that if you love someone, cherish it and do whatever you can to keep it alive, cause if you lose it, you're left with nothing.
Actually they didn't hate each other Cobain has said that he liked Eddie as a person and he several conversations with Eddie. Cobain hated there band is what he said.
Cobain believe the band was all about making money and not the music!!
u cant judge the opinions of two people from interveiws on youtube, and everyone knows eddies not in it 4 the money, 2,000,000 dollars to haiti charity!!
Of course most mistook the band as being there for the money, not knowing the history of the band - originally Mother Love Bone, then Wood died and they formed Pearl Jam and released Ten a month or two before Nevermind, so therefore impossible for them to have cashed in on the grunge wave
A person is left with a vacancy in their very essence when the person that completed them, and in some ways defined parts of who they were, is gone. The person is left broken, missing pieces of who they are, and later who they were.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
they were amazing, but when they get political they drown the genious of their music with political ignorance. its sad, i want to hear them but i wish they would shut the fuck up.
I agree. Political songs lack so much emotion, just like politicians themselves. The only person who can ever pull it off is Roger Waters. Leave the political songs to him.
This has been flagged as spam show
My band did a cover of this beutiful song. If you want to check it out: watch?v=OOLXqph3TJ0
grban1989 2 months ago
I made a version of this when I was going through some ish...
Let me know what you guys think .
tower609 3 months ago
@tower609 "Caught a bolt of lightning... cursed the day he let it go..." Love it.
tower609 3 months ago 2
WTF most underrated??? I think many people bought this Album just cause of this song man!
Dortmundfanatiker77 4 months ago
shittiest day of my life first thing i do: listen to this song
Oilers97MessierOrr 4 months ago
Nothingmen unite!!! Not in a gay way, I mean,,, you know what I mean.
Robkinggozer 5 months ago
Song says it all..
Celtix3417 5 months ago
"one, its not the most underrated pj songs"
best lyrics in the entire song my friend.
anyways, this song is stuck in my head today because me and my lady are going through some problems. Its inevitable though.
chadd990 6 months ago 3
@chadd990 Yeah man....this song hits the core of you when you're going through issues with your loved one. Good luck on the upcoming journey through it. One thing for sure....Pearl Jams music has always helped me dealing with things. Take a listen to Courdroy, Parting Ways and Rearviewmirror for a little more "help" .
edemvedson 6 months ago 2
Comment removed
dhgriff33 3 months ago
Comment removed
dhgriff33 3 months ago
@chadd990 stop being such a fag
jonpon69 2 months ago
vagina
brennybizzel 6 months ago
@brennybizzel penis
edemvedson 6 months ago 4
:'(
AmoritoDeJakob 6 months ago
great job on the vid. this is one of my favs, the other being the long road. i wore out two merkenball cd's. crazy mary is one of my faves too. so many great songs, it's really hard to pick. loll
wolfgeist1 6 months ago
Don Nadie,,, excellent!!
NeuMond007 7 months ago
the best Pearl Jam tune ever
finster37 7 months ago 2
This song is about me =(
Immolateswe 7 months ago 2
One of the greatest Pearl Jam songs EVER!
ceejay0207 8 months ago
nothing man vs better man
thundertower 8 months ago 2
Eddie and Chris Cornell teamed up in Temple of the Dog.....how much better can you get???
dixiedad67 9 months ago
one of the best pearl jam songs ever
landon501996 9 months ago
Hit the nail on the head mate. THE most underrated PJ song imo, but of course i'm biased:-)
nothingman2006 9 months ago 2
this song is for me i fcked up so bad. i was a singal father for 14 years. now becouse of some poor choices i lost my kids to the state and its like, like the song says.
2112deadsky 9 months ago
hey guess what?! i acually had time to read the beginning text, those things never last long enough- :)
1CoLd3 9 months ago 18
@1CoLd3 ha... i try pausing long enough for people to read on all my videos........check them out.
edemvedson 9 months ago
@1CoLd3 You have a pause button on a Youtube video, just so you know. Indeed, you don't have to search for a button you can just click on the video screen.
Ylviste 9 months ago
@1CoLd3 u can always press the pause button it will last until u press play button again....
marco136669 9 months ago
Look at the answer of Eddie to the question.
King Vedder!
sergioj17 10 months ago 3
Great Tune, Eddie Vedder is a quality singer!!!
salvitromusic 10 months ago
Fuckin Tune, Eddie Vedder is a quality singer!!!
salvitromusic 10 months ago
@UnchainMyMind which one? the one that has the quote in it ?
edemvedson 10 months ago
if i had one request before i died it would be to listen to this song
MrSwitchFool 10 months ago
Who r the 4 goddamn communist bastards that disliked this & who gives a shit who wrote it, its Pearl Jam & Eddie Vedder loves you!
jasontramel 10 months ago
This song rocks my world!!!!
TheWizzygirl 10 months ago
@mycal64: HAHAHA! HORSE SHIT, THAT'S FUNNY! Now, LISTEN TO THE SONG SHIT BRICK! :-P
rbergsten74 10 months ago
Cool. A song about 'Nottingham'. How about a song about Cardiff?
mycal64 11 months ago
What a song!
HankMoody4 1 year ago
What a song!
HankMoody4 1 year ago 2
4 people need a good slap
wisey6969 1 year ago
,, She once believed...in every story he had to tell..."
yeah...I know it too well....
Mdreamwalker 1 year ago
this song is so beautiful. ...as a girl, i think this realization for a man is so romantic and raw.
reefgurl90 1 year ago
I KNOW THIS GUY 'NOTHING MAN" I HAVE KIDS WITH HIM
jesseka77 1 year ago
@jesseka77 why did you lie to him ?
edemvedson 1 year ago
@jesseka77 Who lied.......your or him?
edemvedson 1 year ago
linda!
edergalodoido 1 year ago
When asked about "Nothingman" in an interview, Vedder stated, "The idea is about if you love someone and they love you, don't fuck up...'cause you are left with less than nothing."
lastnamefirst 1 year ago
simplismente demais ......
TheJanio 1 year ago
One just escapes...ones left inside the well..........and he who forgets...will be destined to remember.....thats wat u call real lyrics not like that shit bieber sings
shortman103 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
shortman103 1 year ago
nothingman was written by jeff, but you put eddie at the beginning. where did you get this from?
iStevie 1 year ago
@iStevie That's his quote. They're asking him if it was written before or after his marriage and he answered. So those are his words. So tell Eddie that Jeff wrote it... see what he tells you .........
edemvedson 1 year ago
@edemvedson no need to, he already told me in london last 25th of june. funny. maybe the guy that interviewed him asked him the same way you are replying to me, but without asking THE question: did you write the song? haha :D
iStevie 1 year ago
@edemvedson ahhh co-written by ament and vedder (in that order) good :)
iStevie 1 year ago
@iStevie i think jeff wrote the music and ed wrote the lyrics.
robdryan 1 year ago
@iStevie
I would like to build upon your knowledge.
music written by bassist Jeff Ament.
lyrics written by vocalist Eddie Vedder
mattspot2 1 year ago 2
@iStevie -- The music was written by Jeff, the lyrics/melody were written by Eddie.
PrayerPeacePurity 10 months ago
One of my favorite songs he does, sounds great too.
5-Stars-Love it.
lois228gmail 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i've been with the same man for 18 years ...and this song hits the nail on the head!!!!!! gotta watch how ya treat the one ya love!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sissandlin 1 year ago
i've been with the same man for 18 years ...and this song hits the nail on the head!!!!!! gotta watch how ya treat the one ya love!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sissandlin 1 year ago 2
Amazing song, man, do you know, which concert is it from?
I wish I could ever find it ... I'd buy all the bootlegs just to find it ...
and believe me that those bootlegs are expensive here in Mexico! hahaha
Greetings!
Nirvanopandroso 1 year ago
I am The Nothingman. I realized this after my ex-girlfriend married my old best friend. Am I wrong to feel offended?
Noz2Much 1 year ago
best rock bands ever:
AC DC; LED ZEPPLIN; PEARL JAM
KLthebig 1 year ago
@KLthebig I like that you included AC/DC in as one of the best ever. Most people just stick to Led Zep and Black Sabbath and the like. AC/DC never get the credit they deserve (although they are popular and wealthy as hell).
kmbllj 1 year ago
I agree!
KLthebig 1 year ago
Amen. Brilliant!
robfield68 1 year ago
Didn't expect this to sound so amazing live. Most often these kind of songs by bands sound great on the CD, trash in real life. Eddie, you're the king.
berzirk 1 year ago
BEST BAND EVER!!!!
roidrich14 1 year ago
edd vedder can touch you with a few words,most bands fail using there full lyricial catalogue,,,,,,
mackeefy 1 year ago
the Best!
vecchiagrandine 1 year ago
Pearl Jam <3 from Brazil !
ZefaNN 1 year ago
Eddie Vedder is the best performer of my generation.
ryonmc53184 1 year ago
one of the best performer
sgrignieri 1 year ago
Kurt Cobain had absolutley nothing on Eddie.This is pure soul and total genius.
JENNIFER3565 1 year ago
Que grandes!!!!
DRP8272 1 year ago
are you guys retarded relating every fucking 90's song to kurt cobain?
zalsaman 1 year ago
@zalsaman most posters on youtube are beyond retarded.
CAPTJACKAUBREY69 1 year ago
pants
moonmatter 1 year ago
a great, GREAT song!!
mrShowaddywaddy 1 year ago
I Hopa Gdl,one day.......
lordsud 1 year ago
there is something special about this man and the band
friendlydictator 2 years ago 35
beautiful song
MrDeemun 2 years ago
artists evolve CreamyKrau. Its elemental. All bands that are worth a shit are going to grow and change. You can't write about the same stuff when your 35 as you did when you were 25.
reverb478 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sucks how PJ is now country basically :,( i loved your first 2 albums Pearl Jam . . .
CreamyKrau 2 years ago
@CreamyKrau dumbest thing I've ever read here on my videos......I've heard some dumb stuff.....but you take the cake. Congrats, retard.
edemvedson 2 years ago 49
said it better than I could've... I can't stand all the stupid "oh you sold out" idiots... like a band'll keep making the same album over and over again JUST to make them happy.. actually THAT is the definition of country. Soem pearl jam albums took gettin used to .. but you can never deny the HEART they put into every single one :)
oehieze 1 year ago
@oehieze dude, they have never takin getting used to wtf are you talking about? I agree they put heart into every single song.
TheSkycarp069 1 year ago
@CreamyKrau Hi how are ya, this is planet earth we live on. There is a band called Pearl Jam and they rock everyone's socks off when they play. Eddie Vedder can make girl cum just by sayin' ''hey how are ya''. Country ? nah they don't call it country they call it Freakingunbelievablerockingfuckingcryinggrungindrinkinlosingyourvoicebysingingalong!
but hey that's just me.
Noisespreads 1 year ago
nothing to do with cobain,cobain was totally jealous in my view of a greater talent,and his views of pearl jam bieng more commercial were unfounded and stupid,seeing as that nirvana quite happily signed to geffen records and there wonderfull pr machine
gazwelsh 2 years ago
It wasn't so much a greater talent, but a music and style that was so much different than Kobain's songs of hateful introspection and fixation on wrongs. Vedder knew how to love, not that Kobain didn't, but Vedder wrote about it with joy (at times, and in lamented words like this song displays) while Kobain's words were always so filled with a certain pain derived from a much earlier and deeper root. They really were quite different generes, as I'm sure most listeners agree.
2turbotitaniumxtreme 1 year ago 6
THANK you people always figh about who is better but they are so different i don't think either is better
Annonymus121 1 year ago
LOVE
staceyswo 2 years ago
more like LACK OF LOVE.........
edemvedson 2 years ago
haha
staceyswo 2 years ago
It's not a song about Cobain.
edemvedson 2 years ago 5
WTF!
sgrignieri 1 year ago
This song is awesome - and Eddie can bring out emotions that nobody else can.
xxhobxx1 2 years ago
Song about Kurt Cobain? Just wondering?
He said No in the past but only not to draw attention to it I believe. As Cobain had just died.
Either way Great song one of my favorites!!
megamo08 2 years ago
No, Cobain and Eddie hated each other... or at least Cobain hated Eddie. This song is about the idea that if you love someone, cherish it and do whatever you can to keep it alive, cause if you lose it, you're left with nothing.
marksworld12 2 years ago
Actually they didn't hate each other Cobain has said that he liked Eddie as a person and he several conversations with Eddie. Cobain hated there band is what he said.
Cobain believe the band was all about making money and not the music!!
megamo08 2 years ago
u cant judge the opinions of two people from interveiws on youtube, and everyone knows eddies not in it 4 the money, 2,000,000 dollars to haiti charity!!
McleanLibertySG 2 years ago
$200,000 not $2,000,000. One zero makes a huge difference.
iLikeNarwhals 1 year ago
chek it out on seattle weekly, tis two mill
McleanLibertySG 1 year ago
Of course most mistook the band as being there for the money, not knowing the history of the band - originally Mother Love Bone, then Wood died and they formed Pearl Jam and released Ten a month or two before Nevermind, so therefore impossible for them to have cashed in on the grunge wave
demravager 1 year ago 3
I hope they play that one on 10 June 2010 in Lisbon. I'll be there. I'll go up trought the skies!!
Pearl Jam!!
punksurfas19 2 years ago
"he who forgets will be destined to remember"
is my favorite line in any song and this my favorite song of all time.
purplefreakshow 2 years ago 2
This song and wishlist are my 2 favorite songs.
nbvca1 2 years ago
love singing to this
jmInDreams 2 years ago
THE BEST PJ SONG EVER!!!
belli1201 2 years ago
Long live Eddie
ElvisStillRules 2 years ago
muito fodaaaa !!!!!
morre1u 2 years ago
i believe the lyrics are "he who forgets will be destin to remember" listen to it
HighVelocitY666 2 years ago
the lyrics are, "And he who forgets...will be destined to remember" (2:36)
edemvedson 2 years ago
he never says the "ed"
HighVelocitY666 2 years ago
@HighVelocitY666
you don't hear it at 2:41 ?? Is "destin" even a word?
edemvedson 2 years ago
destined .. as in destiny
milkman52879 2 years ago
I was responding to his post of ed leaving out the "ed" in the word destined.
edemvedson 2 years ago
If you do that then that's where I live. It's a town in Florida. Ha, ha.
HeyJaw 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
My girlfriend is at the moment at a bar, with some guy friend . and Im at home, alone, drinking and listen this music over and over...
Dont fuck up the relationship you say ?
DaCostaPT 2 years ago
Comment removed
DaCostaPT 2 years ago
Comment removed
DaCostaPT 2 years ago
Simply awesome. I adore this song. xxx
SweetPoisonPenguin 2 years ago 2
One of my favourite songs ever...
Release1987 2 years ago 4
with thoughts I cant help thinking I'm listening, listening, listening...
Okudjawa 2 years ago 2
Great post and great song version.. This one has deep meaning to me and holds me up the days that i just want to fall down.. peace~
AngryCPU 2 years ago 4
well said
jmulhall86 2 years ago 2
This is an Awesome song, one of their best. We all lose at one point or another Radio.
Fromthedarkwaters 2 years ago 3
yeahh one of the best songs.
FarmACDCFreak 2 years ago 2
best song ever!!!
urielgaap 2 years ago 2
cant think of any one with a voice like crazy eddie
rounthwaite1 2 years ago 7
no one even comes close
m21d25 2 years ago 4
brilliant
mihiir 2 years ago 4
The song of my life.... Always has been, always will...
Qlicky 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If this is the song of your life. Thank your a loser. Cause this song is about losing.
So hi Loser
radio19952001 2 years ago
hahaha, if you say so ;)
Qlicky 2 years ago
hahhahahaha hihiihihi wow.
wout112 2 years ago
Unbelievable song...thanks to Eddie Vedder for putting mere emotions into words that I could never express.
rocknroll4ever88 2 years ago 4
Eddie Vedder..amazing vocalist..beautiful lyrics.
ashmariemp 2 years ago 8
what does he mean by nothingman?
shant07 2 years ago
. . . . . . a man becomes nothing once a woman he loves lies to him.
edemvedson 2 years ago
A person is left with a vacancy in their very essence when the person that completed them, and in some ways defined parts of who they were, is gone. The person is left broken, missing pieces of who they are, and later who they were.
rocknroll4ever88 2 years ago 4
nicely said!!!!!!
bern1417 2 years ago
This is a really good live version of this song. Good guitar playing and great vocals! As to be expected from Vedder.
redmesquito 2 years ago 8
happened to me
claymationman36 2 years ago
Great fucking tune. To omarsolimanskaaa.. suck it up bitch, sounds like you left your balls in your girlfriends purse.
dethmag 2 years ago
bono sucks bro
fckwatuthot 2 years ago 4
Bono and Eddie... my two favourite singers. Gods in Earth.
jesubono 2 years ago
Comment removed
omarsolimanskaaa 2 years ago 2
I feel you, I do, but for me words unspoken, can't be taken back
GZR666 2 years ago
crazy talk. the lyrics have always been great and are only getting better
drvrlvr 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love their tunes too,just don't care much for the words.Even reading the lyrics I don't understand!
HighguyinMN 2 years ago
that's cuz ur stupid
xXFooXx 2 years ago
Hell yes, you like this tune?! What the fuck is worng with you?!
One of the best lyrics ever written...
Qlicky 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they were amazing, but when they get political they drown the genious of their music with political ignorance. its sad, i want to hear them but i wish they would shut the fuck up.
cbears00 2 years ago
I agree. Political songs lack so much emotion, just like politicians themselves. The only person who can ever pull it off is Roger Waters. Leave the political songs to him.
musicmine3000 2 years ago 3
Queime... queime
Homem nada
Não é alguma coisa?
Homem nada
Homem nada
Não poderia ter sido algo
Homem nada
Oh...ohh...ohh
digaozeppelin 2 years ago
this was a good find .. thanks
candy14516 2 years ago 2
One of the greatest songs period. Made me cry.
baebameows 2 years ago 9
it's my autobiography
marsjel 3 years ago
You didn't write it so that would make it your biography.
deeebird 2 years ago
He has to be the best frontman of the last 2 decades.
dumby88 3 years ago 7
I totally agree!
But Freddy Mercury was a pretty good frontman
jleb310ce 2 years ago 5
oh man, freddy mercury was the best frontman ever - behind him i'd say are roger daltry and robert plant
demravager 2 years ago
Steve Perry
7elway98 2 years ago
could have been somthing
ALOW524 3 years ago
this is my favorite PJ song since 10 years!
northilien 3 years ago 6
amazing.. where is this recording from?
ryeino 3 years ago 4
thanks to the video poster for putting the lyrics in the details. um, thanks! :)
this stuff really brings me back
bostone737 3 years ago 3
once divided. there's nothin left to subtract.
Break my heart forever.
SCAL2325 3 years ago
Pearl Jam is great. Eddie Vedder stands for so much that is pure and good. Thank you Eddie. Thank you for being genuine. Your music is forever.
jrgtrain 3 years ago 7
I feel the same way!
ilsetencate 2 years ago
Fuck yeah Pearl Jam is sic.Brings back lots of memories.
madsinhysphy 3 years ago 3
Eddie is a pearl of PJ :o]]
arathein 3 years ago
Some words when spoken...cant be taken back...
that is so fucking true :(
drachmonius 3 years ago 2
le grunge aime sa
dratorent 3 years ago
the voice the meaning incomperable
betterthanme44 3 years ago
ME TOO :(
parlachenko 3 years ago
some words when spoken
can't be taken back..
I wish someone I once loved had listened to this song too.
zeldiy 3 years ago 7
Sad. Wish I heard this when I was married. I mean, actually listened.
Stonejohn28 3 years ago 10