Added: 4 years ago
From: relatora
Views: 238,215
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (180)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This is actually my favorite song. The first time I heard this I was alone, in a dark house, as a teenager..listening to this watching the sun rise. I will never forget that moment. Thanks, dad (I was listening to his cd's)

  • I ended up downloading this in the end. Amazing performance of an amazing song.

  • Brilliant...

  • im dying from microwave murder please pray for me

  • 28 years and 15 albums later still to me, the most beautiful rem song. reminds me of the best of times.

  • @RoddyGacha forgot how cool R.E.M. fans are. We definitely have a long history to reminisce about. Good times for me too my friend.

  • @ProfessorNeuwave Damn Right.

  • @ProfessorNeuwave Peel back the mountains, Peel back the sky - keep loving, keep rocking :-)

  • Will never forget partying, and getting that last beer to watch this that night on MTV in April 1992, then waking up late the next morning, and losing my job the next day..."It was so Effin' Worth it!!" LOL!!!

  • @ProfessorNeuwave LOL fuck 'em for sure ! works not everything and you still remember that night now so it really was worth it !! :-) x

  • R.E.M. were at their absolute peak during this gig, they were on such a roll at this time and carried through to Automatic for the People. Agree with previous posters that this should be released as an cd/dvd combo. Many millions will have already seen this show but it's still worthy of an official release in the near future and give a few folk the chance to see those amazing versions of Low and Fall on Me.

  • Lovely!

  • what a great song i love this band

  • theres a rem mtv unplugged video missing..where is pop song 89?

  • If you dislike this, you have no soul.

  • REM to me will be one one of the greatest bands of all time. RIP 1980-2011

  • best band for me.

  • This is quite possibly my favorite song of all time.

  • I'm nearly 49 now and have heard them all but I never heard a band quite as special as REM.

  • I think the year was 1991 and I was in love with Danice. It was a long circle but we made it. 2011.

  • Greatest band for me...

  • this is the greatest REM collection of songs of all time it should be released as the farewell record

  • imagine, the 4 seattle n' r.e.m :)

  • Une chanson que j'écouterai juqu'à la fin de ma vie!!

    Merci pour tout, vous allez me manquer!!!

  • damn 2

  • damn ...

  • So much better than the album. +1

  • Buck, Mills, Berry, Stipe...maybe not the original fab four but just as talented and just as important. RIP - REM.

  • @dwad112

    Not the Fab Four, but the Fantastic Four :)

  • am really sad..... gonna miss them x

  • Doesn't get much better. Thanks guys for so many memories :)

  • genuis me thinks anyway

  • @spazola789 That was a great show! Be sure to check out the Unplugged version of "Fall On Me," too! Amazing performance!

  • beautifuel...michaels aura too

  • best REM song ever...

    

  • to all- be strong-stand tall no matter what-or what anyone says about you!

  • Am I wrong in thinking Kurt Cobains middle name was Donald? This a dedication and a message to him? Am I just really slow in realising?

  • @stutaggart No,man,no!You're totally wrong!

  • @stutaggart Unless we know 100% sure from somewhere, it's possible. Kurt did die listening to this man sing.

  • I think of U2 and REm as the figure heads of 80s alternative

  • @mediblue9 Definitely

  • @mediblue9 Yeah, lets just forget about The Pixies and XTC.

  • this performance should be a definition of "grace" in the dictionnary

  • Best track on murmur & this sounds as great as the original.

  • Magical..........

  • Thank you for making the videos of this beautiful, beautiful performance available - I've been trying to find these again for years. God bless Youtube. 

  • nothing moves me like they move me

  • god bless Mike Mills

  • who the hell would dislike this?

  • @nilbog44 a jerk. thats who. a jerk

  • Bill wrote the music on a little keyboard on his kitchen table one night when he got out of bed to pee lol

  • Harmonies not hitting too well at first. Great song......

  • Lo diré en español porque me sale de dentro, que temazo, absolutamente genial canción, fantástica melodía, esta canción se sale del mapa, es tan emotiva, pasional, una autentica catarsis. la letra es muy hermosa como ya han dicho.

  • The mans voice is pure magic. There are truly not many artists anymore with as much passion and emotion when they sing. What a perfect performance from a truly amazing group. They are, indeed, the soundtrack to my life. Thanks for uploading.

  • i will miss this world...

  • heaven assumed..........

  • @jimbobhall I was a little older and it was my cousin and you describe my feelings and thoughts about this song exactly.

  • we need more american bands like this

  • I am so appreciative that I was able to live in the same time period as REM...

  • demais, valeu!!!!

    Sandro/ Guaratinguetá SP Brasil

  • I'm only 27 and this music came out when I was a young kid. These guys are one of the most underrated groups of all time. I think anyone who considers themselves a lover of all music must rate REM among the elite. A truly unique style and sound that is breathtaking and inspiring every time I listen. Their music sends your mind on a winged journey, soaring over God's beautiful creation. Stipe's passion is undeniable. There will never be another REM; as special as the likes of the Beatles.

  • @sdalt001 Well said!!!

  • @sdalt001 Lightning struck when they met in 1980, that's pretty much all there is to say. It happened with the Beatles too, just like you said. Those kind of bands really only come around every 10 years or so, and they set the stage for everyone else for a generation. Sure, they were rarely as famous as many of the bands they inspired (Coldplay, Radiohead, Pearl Jam, Nirvana, etc.) but those bands wouldn't exist without them, and that makes them the greatest.

  • @bernlin2000 I agree that R.E.M are an incredibly special band and one of my favourites. But considering that they've sold 30 million + albums, signed the world's most lucrative record contract at one point and spent from 1991-2011 touring huge arenas, I think it's fair to say they are pretty famous. They tailed off a little in the 2000s but they were, without a doubt, one of the biggest bands of the 90s.

  • something inspired going on here.

  • im the guy always referring to the crap music we are subjected to today....you wont hear me saying one bad thing about this band, or this song....our musical parents...REM! √ LOVE!

  • this whole unplugged performance is just awesome

  • Great version of my favorite song!

  • Comment removed

  • Great song!!! Love Mills' backing vocals!

  • Magnifica cançao!

  • I hope Donald didn't give up.

  • THX MR. DONALD!

  • super..................

  • i was a freshman at UGA when this was came on MTV. hard not to be nostalgic when I see this. wish there as a time machine.

  • I love Mike Mills....

  • one of thebesr songs ive ever heard

  • backing vocals of Mike Mills sounds like a calm prayer... perfect sincrony between M. & M.

  • Comment removed

  • @panaboy01 I always held a similar interpretation but the lyric "A perfect circle of acquaintances and friends/Drink another/Coin a phrase" speaks to me of carving out one's own tribe/family of people who love & "get" you & going on to live another day (try to win). Stipe's dedication at the start makes me think we're on the right track. Never heard of a hanging interpretation - have you?

    Either way, this song is simultaneously melancholy and amazingly uplifting. A favorite for MANY years.

  • @tahloolahlee

    no, never heard about an official interpretation by the band.

  • Mike Mills- best sideman EVER

  • Michael, great guy....but REM has gotten too political. They should not be telling people who to vote for, no matter which side they believe in. I don't want to hear about Democrats or Republicans when I go to a concert....his political harping only takes away from the musical experience, and he should be respectful that there are many political opinions among REM's fans.

  • @meccaturbo Stipe's so-called "leftist" social democrat & environmentalist leanings inform many of REM's songs. In the same way that a film director or visual artist's work naturally relects their world view, a rock band's ideals cannot be 'divorced' from their music.

    The same accusation of political bias has been leveled at bands such as Radiohead, Pearl Jam, U2, or Green Day. But these bands are the bands raising awareness about global issues and performing at charity gigs.

  • @LantaGem With REM, it's too much. Stipe was telling people who to vote for in the last presidential election. Radiohead, Pearl Jam, U2, and Green Day have not done that. Telling your fans who to vote for is simply wrong. It's ok to share ideas, not to say "you should vote for this person". The other bands you cited have not done that.

  • @meccaturbo - Haven't they? Check out details of the 2004 "Vote For Change" concert tour.

    Along with REM, performers included such high-profile acts as Pearl Jam, Bruce Springsteen, Dixie Chicks, Death Cab for Cutie, Neil Young, Bright Eyes and countless others, many of whom urged the audience to vote against George W Bush. Green Day were also vocally "anti-Bush" and Radiohead openly spoke out against the policies of the British government while Tony Blair was in power.

  • @LantaGem Yep. All the more reason I don't like those artists....artists have no business telling their fans who to vote for. Sure, free speech is fine, but you automatically alienate some people when you tell the audience who to vote for. Any band with any intelligence knows this, so they don't do it. REM has become more and more this way, and their fan base is rapidly dwindling.  REM has lost so much popularity in recent years.

  • @meccaturbo - Also, if you don't believe it, check out the U2/Green Day cover of "The Saints Are Coming". The video contains a satirical burn of the Bush government for using U.S. resources to keep troops in Iraq at the expense of helping out displaced victims of Hurricane Katrina.

  • @meccaturbo actually, while u2 might have kept quiet on the issue, Green Day clearly made the "American Idiot" album against GWB and in 2004 they were on MTV or some network and one of the band members (Dirnt?) told the crowd "you'd better vote for Kerry" and he was clearly serious. I do wish musicians would just back up and let people decide for themselves. If the artist feels they have to tell people how to vote, then they are overstepping their boundaries.

  • @meccaturbo - Mind you, I'm not saying the political viewpoint of the bands I mentioned is either right or wrong... Just that I believe they have as much right as anybody to express their opinion. After all, isn't freedom of speech one of the main tenets of a democracy?

    OK, rant over.

  • REM's harmony and acoustic work are incomparable...

  • I know this much from a couple of short conversations, Perfect Circle has a lot of allegorical phrases that have to do with hanging, or being hung. 11 gallows on your sleeve is the first mention, ,but standing too soon is a very round the back way of painting the picture of someone hanging by the neck. I dont remember perfectly, but it is also sung from 3 or 4 different views as the song goes. Im probably botching this, but thats the best I can remember

  • @painxtreme i have never known what this song is about, with the lyrics being so abstract...but what you said makes sense. the imagery in the song fits the picture of someone being hung...i used to think this song was uplftiting, but not now. still very good though, but now on a deeper level. thanx. if you remember anymore about the idea behind the song, please post.

  • Put your hair back, we get to leave Eleven gallows on your sleeve Shallow figure, winner's paid Eleven shadows way out of place Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room Pull your dress on and stay real close Who might leave you where I left off? A perfect circle of acquaintances and friends Drink another, coin a phrase Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room
  • Hauntingly beautifull , this song pulled me right in after my first listen . so many years ago.

  • my interpretation is Standing too soon, shoulders high in the room, as referring to a young person who feels awkward and out of place in the world .

    This child or young persons stands too soon in a crowded gathering and compared to everybody else who remains seated, they draw attention unnecessarily, their shoulders the only ones high in the room. They try to speak, to say the right things, to win respect from their perfect circle of aquaintances and friends.

  • @panaboy01 wow ty i thinku are rigth with that analyse.......ty very much

  • this is beatutifuel.......id like to understand englsih 100 persent......"standing to soon shoulders high inthe room"?? omg Rems lyricsa are a mystikal

  • this was my second purchase. so central rain got my attention at first. this one is better.

  • this song is beautiful

  • makes me hurt in a good way

  • Hermosa versión. Mike Mills se luce con ese coro. Michael, excelente como siempre. R.e.m. Los Amo!!!

  • This is what brought me to Murmur.

  • Outstanding performance

  • pretty much as good a performance as you could want

  • Que hermosa canción, Michael Te Amo!

  • Michael is such a beautiful person. His lyrics will always be amazing.

  • @davidbyrne77

    this song was written by Bill Berry, not Stipe.

  • @davidbyrne77

    I agree, though this song was written by R.E.M.'s former drummer - Bill Berry.

  • ...Still beautiful after all these years. I have always loved REM and especially Michael Stipe's wonderful soothing and expressive voice. Their music gave me something to cling to in my adolescent angst in the 1980's, and with the present state of our world, I cling to it today like a frightened child.

  • Always loved this song "perfect circle of acquaintences and friends"...great line. I wore "Murmur" and "Reckoning" out.

  • shit?? ah cmon he got older and they changed a little bit their style. id never say shit to someones voice

  • that is the holy grail voice

  • huh? this was those days

  • STILL BEAUTIFUL,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

  • beautiful song

  • hermoso tema

  • One of many songs that sounds remarkably better live. In the studio version Micheal Stipe's vocie seems to powerful and overtakes the song (in my opinion). Also in the live version Mike Mills backup vocals are incredible! Both versions are awesome but in my opinion live is always better.

  • This is Perfect REM

  • michael is my favourite singer

  • "Heaven assumed, shoulders high in the room..."

    Beautiful line.

  • Stipe is awesome but Mills is very important for REM.. we can see how in this video.. great choir

  • All of them have great chemistry together - they all lend the perfect blend of each other to make that sound - we all noticed that when Bill left.

  • The greatest 'MTV Unplugged' ever performed,fullstop.Their music of the time lent itself to be performed in such a format.Michael Stipe must be the greatest singer alive today.

  • never a truer word spoken.

  • gigantisch gute musik!!!

  • der schaut voll preocuipied

  • Comment removed

  • Thank you for posting this, which is to my mind their perfect concert - every song was gorgeous and each member of the band was on top form, especially Michael.

  • perfetta...assolutamente perfetta

  • huge r.e.m. fan from '82 on...maybe their most heart felt song/performance

  • soory my bad english im from germany, but i always understood "standing to same shoulders high, in the room" lol

  • I MISS BILL TOO!!!...anke a me manka tanto, e mi dispiace sapere ke nn lo vedrò mai più sul palco con loro...:(

  • magnifica! una delle mie preferite. che bello era MS!

  • A classic R.E.M. performance. Been looking for this particular recording ever since I first discovered youtube a few years ago. I'm glad someone uploaded it finally.

  • got to be one of my fav rem songs,i have followed them for years now,great band!!!

  • beautiful song...

  • good voice. good song. good everything. ohmigosh. <33333 heart this song.

  • BILL! BILL! BILL!

    How much I miss Bill Berry.

  • ogni volta che ascolto questa canzone rimango senza forze in corpo per quanto e' bella! come ipnotizzato dal suono....non ho parole e' stupenda

  • vero..semplicemente meravigliosa,una melodia angelica.

  • severos buenos!!

  • This performance by REM inspired me to buy a guitar and learn to play when I was 16 back in 1994. I went to the Twickenham gig in London last saturday and they played Perfect circle live along with Fall on me, Disturbance at the heron house, End of the world as we know it and many other early career songs. An indifferent set but a treat for a die hard fan like myself. This performance on MTV in 1991 is legend. What a band!

  • life is so good listening to R.E.M

  • and try to wiiin...

    i like it when michael lifts his hand

  • what I love about this song is that I can put it on repeat, and just get lost in it. this is one REM song that can bring out so many emotions and it just sucks you in. 4 minutes really isn't long enough, I always want more of this song. it's definitely one of my favorites from the REM catalog.

  • its hard to describe the feeling i got from that ...

  • oh my god....this is such a brilliant version

  • Me encanta esta interpretacion pero la que mas me llega es la que tocan en el video tourfilm de hecho por ahi esta el video es una cancion especial

  • I use to have this recorded on vhs from 1990 but lost it.....thanks for putting it on here.

  • he's got to be one of the best translated from record to live voices out there...smooth and flawless

  • theres something about the tone of the organ that either ruins this version for me or makes it especially special. ill have to give it another listen.

  • is this the song they talk about in the better then ezra song?

  • im trying hard to find the torrent to this session , if you guys have it please email me!

  • Beautiful song, beautifully done. I miss Bill.

  • What's the chances of getting 'Half A World Away' from this show posted?

  • i savor any chance to see this live. I'm glad that at least this one from unplugged got posted.

  • Does anyone have this entire performance? It should be on youtube

  • agreed this is great. the best mtv unplugged performances in my opinion are in no particular order: nirvana, alice inchains, stone temple pilots, rem, pearl jam, clapton, staind, and the new york football Giants. it's too bad that alot of these aren't on DVD they shouldbe.

  • its strange, they used to all be on youtube but they were taken down. Maybe it was due to a copyrights, oh well. If anyone has this whole show please please put it up-

  • sorry but only R.E.M. did it in the spirit really, Nirvana had semi-electric guitars and drum kits etc. R.E.M. looked like they were busking which I always thought was the point

  • @johnnymarrplayguitar "looked like they were busking" excellent! yep, that's the perfect way to describe it!

  • This live version is chillingly good. Thank you!

  • Puta madre! no puedo conseguir el vinilo de Murmur... :(

    ...Standing too soon

    shoulders high in the room...

Loading...