the judges should be hitting themselves in the head now because none of those other girl's or their pushy parents got anywhere, whereas she's on broadway and absolutely amazing! sucks for them, go natalie!!!
Natalie you're SOOOOO much better than those persons. And YOU have the sparkle! Your voice is beautiful and you sing perfectly with emotion. You are amazing, never never forget that!
I love how fast she walked out of there as soon as Simon said she didn't make it. She knew right away it was bullshit.
Maybe Simon knew the future and was like "Oh, well, I already know you're going to be super famous and that you're too good for this show, so i'll just give these girls a chance."
Casting Natalie would've been setting the bar way too high. ;)
Screw American Idol. Who are those two girls anyway? haha. They don't have names for themselves and Natalie is uh oh. Doing broadway. Yeah. We're routing for you Natalie!
@Anf26Hollister Actually, Lonnie McFadden is a VERY talented musican, tap dancer and performer. The man has been performing for longer than these contestants have been alive. He knows a thing or two.
Wow I watched your other videos on YouTube like "I Don't Want To Wait / Ya Gotta Be" it takes talen to know it and OBVIOUSLY they have none.
You rock Natalie and let me tell you I have played violin professionally around the world and I KNOW quality when I hear it. You should have won the dam comp.
Expression, sensitivity and roar talent - would not be surprised if you have a #1 US chart buster one day - your fan
and what i LOVE is the fact that after giving natalie so much grief about not knowing her words...out of all of the harmonies she was the ONLY one i understood the words for. and no. no no no. ugh! natalie was the only person on that stage with a dynamic voice who wasnt trying to sound like whitney or mariah. noooo. oh american idol you RAGE me. and im so glad that miss shanae and gina are NOWHERE to be found in this world. Goodluck bein a nobody. Hope your parents can HELP YOU WITH THAT! ughhh
nuh uh. see, no. no. no. no no. ugh. see this is what rages me about american idol. uh uh.
and you know what pisses me off, is the fact that natalie had to deal with those two wannabes parents. uh uh. im gonna need the underage peoples parents to not be present during rehearsals. those two adults should be ashamed of themselves. granted, i realize they were just trying to promote their own children. but no. natalie had to undergo an entire evenings rehearsal being put under a microscope.
Did anyone notice what a seasoned professional she was when they told her the bad news? She may have gotten upset after she left the stage, but that right there is a perfect example of class. Thank you for your time, leave on a positive note. I can't deal with the people who try and fight their way to a "Yes".
Natalie is twelve times better than both of those other chicks.. how is this possible? but clearly she doesnt need american idol to do great things!! =]
No disrespect to anyone affiliated with the show, but I've never been a huge fan of American Idol. It's turned out a handful of great singers, but most of it is all about image and a lot of the contestants aren't properly trained. Natalie is, on the other hand, and she's turning out to be a rising star! I can't wait to see what else she does in the future.
Ha. Natalie Weiss rocks!!! I OWN some of her stuff...I don't even know who the other girls are. The only reason I found this video is because I searched for her. So those girls can take their parents and well....I think you know where this is going.
Let's see......... those other girls...... where are you? Natalie has music on Itunes and she has understudied huge roles like Elphaba and she is currently on Broadway alongside Sheri Rene Scott.
I had no idea Natalie Weiss was ever on American Idol. She's amazing - wonderful performer. You're right, she doesn't need AI. Her talent will take her far.
yeah, for real. screw american idol. Natalie, you are SO above that. they put you in a group with pushy obnoxious self-righteous divas who needs their mommies and daddies holding their hands every step of the way.
my personal opinion- not just because its natalie (haha) but, back when I watched this when it aired and I didnt know of natalie, I felt that she was the best of the group not only vocally but in stage performant all together. The total energy factor was portrayed more in her than in the other two. So of COURSE natalies the star today haha :)
yup they were just jealous that whe could sing better than them. they saw her as a threat, and gave her a cruddy part. but she doesnt even need them. look where she is now! CD, Tours, Concerts, WICKED!i mean really, she was honestly the best singer in that group
I agree with some of the other comments.. Natalie if you read this can you please audition one more time. I would love to see you on that show. Your vocals are incredible and would seriously blow everyone out of the water this time around! Auditions for 2010!!! I'll go with you! haha
Not gonna lie... this was not natalie at her best at all.... the other girls did do better than her but now nat would just blow them right out of the water. I think she should try out now and for her audition use I Believe in You and Me
i just said natalie is the best of the best love her the other girls were not as good as natalie i love her if you read this sub to me if you love natalie weiss she is the best of the best
:-O didnt know you did american idol?! as if you didnt get through!!!!! dw girl ur amazing!! cant stop showing your videos to all my friends here in the UK!!!! i wish you would come over here to do something or have you?! haha love you!! xxx
Shit, if I was Gina I'd be so embarrassed lol. I mean, why is a twenty something year old's parents following her around and accompanying her to auditions?
when the parents can own up to being show business parents I'll give them props. When they beat around the bush because they are in TV, they can go kiss Natalie's ass. NATALIE YOU ARE AMAZING, GO BECOME FAMOUS BECAUSE YOU ARE GREAT, NOT BECAUSE OF SOME REALITY TV SHOW!!!!!
In Season 4, AI still wasn't a "singing competition." Yeah, those parents were a nightmare...pushy as hell. Where are these two "successful" girls now Miss Elphaba?
Natalie, you are more fabulous than anything.
Nerdfighter7814 3 hours ago
DISGUSTING, SHE'S BETTER THAN ALL OF THEM!
breezy501 3 days ago
I like how they said there was no sparkle, and Natalie was trying to add it when they were rehearsing earlier and got shut down by the stage moms
Jazzzkidd 1 week ago
Aww so sad seeing you go =[ It's okay you dont need them! =]
stevmar96 1 month ago
the judges should be hitting themselves in the head now because none of those other girl's or their pushy parents got anywhere, whereas she's on broadway and absolutely amazing! sucks for them, go natalie!!!
theluvbug1988 1 month ago
Natalie you're SOOOOO much better than those persons. And YOU have the sparkle! Your voice is beautiful and you sing perfectly with emotion. You are amazing, never never forget that!
princepeterwolf 2 months ago
And Natalie singing Defying Gravity is a total message to all this bullcrap ;)
So American Idol, go watch that, shit your pants, and roll arouns in all your regrets. muahaha
GenevieveRamirez 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love how fast she walked out of there as soon as Simon said she didn't make it. She knew right away it was bullshit.
Maybe Simon knew the future and was like "Oh, well, I already know you're going to be super famous and that you're too good for this show, so i'll just give these girls a chance."
Casting Natalie would've been setting the bar way too high. ;)
GenevieveRamirez 2 months ago
Comment removed
GenevieveRamirez 2 months ago
Um...simon wants to see "sparkle"? he needs to see natalie's rendition of "i believe in you and me"
navnurse11 3 months ago
HAHHHH at the girls dad "you'll set yourself up for failure." rrrrriiiight
LilLoOpZ 4 months ago
lol Gina wasn't nearly as good as Natalie...stupid judges
LittleShopofMusic 4 months ago
This is the biggest load of crap ever. :)
TMontierth 4 months ago 2
teehee.
i love natalie. and look where she is now! :D
IsThisTourettes 6 months ago 2
She was the best singer of the three.....clean, on pitch, no bullshit riffs.
I hate this show.
LOLOL GO NATALIE!
dotbishop 6 months ago 8
....and that is why i don't watch american idol.
igardrisc95 7 months ago 8
she did amazing! i think it was just the song they were given.
cassierox77 7 months ago
Screw American Idol. Who are those two girls anyway? haha. They don't have names for themselves and Natalie is uh oh. Doing broadway. Yeah. We're routing for you Natalie!
katemcgizzle25 8 months ago 2
My Last Name is Weiss =D
MrLittleman606 9 months ago
I already forgot who else was in the group besides Natalie. Getting rid of her is just.. downright dumb.
EliseWhatever 9 months ago
this just shows how shit american idol is
theellew0rd 10 months ago 3
@theellew0rd Basically.
Epicosity101 7 months ago
Dude. Where is she NOW?! She's doing amazing things.
PunkassxD 10 months ago
Umm...she had the best voice out of the three...it doesn't add up.
SachinStyle 11 months ago
how did natalie not make it to me she was the bestt
acspectacular 11 months ago
Nooo! Don't cry Natalie, they aren't worth it!
1920jenny 1 year ago 2
loool, natalie not making it?
American Idol has made some big mistakes, and this is truley one of them.
Their loss though, Natalie is doing better things than having two hits then slipping into American Idol obscurity as most of them do.
cutiipye 1 year ago 5
BUT YET NATALIE HAS AN ALBUM AND IT IS AMAZING!!!! What happened to those other girls???? I dont even remember their names . . . .
Elphaba88 1 year ago 16
@Elphaba88
LOL Well if you don't remember their names, then you can't say for sure what happened with them, can you?
JoyNicole1974 2 months ago
Who gives a fuck about American Idol. Everyone forgets about who won after like a week. Shes on Broadway and Broadway never dies.
Platinum400 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Natalie, you're too much for that stupid show...
patrirojas 1 year ago
could someone please shoot the meddling dumb as parents who says they are not choreographers but act like one?
Anf26Hollister 1 year ago
@Anf26Hollister Actually, Lonnie McFadden is a VERY talented musican, tap dancer and performer. The man has been performing for longer than these contestants have been alive. He knows a thing or two.
rlbjayhawk11 8 months ago
Wow I watched your other videos on YouTube like "I Don't Want To Wait / Ya Gotta Be" it takes talen to know it and OBVIOUSLY they have none.
You rock Natalie and let me tell you I have played violin professionally around the world and I KNOW quality when I hear it. You should have won the dam comp.
Expression, sensitivity and roar talent - would not be surprised if you have a #1 US chart buster one day - your fan
utubebq 1 year ago
this breaks my heart. that bitch and her parents. UGHHHH ajkfhaisdfbaisugh
ksing210 1 year ago
Shoulda went for the third up @ that end. Natdawgg. You got more talent than them anydayyy.
AmeeReneeM 1 year ago
and what i LOVE is the fact that after giving natalie so much grief about not knowing her words...out of all of the harmonies she was the ONLY one i understood the words for. and no. no no no. ugh! natalie was the only person on that stage with a dynamic voice who wasnt trying to sound like whitney or mariah. noooo. oh american idol you RAGE me. and im so glad that miss shanae and gina are NOWHERE to be found in this world. Goodluck bein a nobody. Hope your parents can HELP YOU WITH THAT! ughhh
xjtiger08x 1 year ago 3
@xjtiger08x haha i love this comment! =] so true!
briannegonzales 1 year ago
nuh uh. see, no. no. no. no no. ugh. see this is what rages me about american idol. uh uh.
and you know what pisses me off, is the fact that natalie had to deal with those two wannabes parents. uh uh. im gonna need the underage peoples parents to not be present during rehearsals. those two adults should be ashamed of themselves. granted, i realize they were just trying to promote their own children. but no. natalie had to undergo an entire evenings rehearsal being put under a microscope.
xjtiger08x 1 year ago
It's okay, Natalie! You're on BROADWAY!
katherinemich 1 year ago 22
american idol suck and natalie rocks lets face it
firepoifairy 1 year ago 5
thats not fair..she hardly got a real solo!!!
patmayonnaise 1 year ago 4
of course natalie wouldnt make it...
she has a completely different style from the other girls...
she is a soprano, not r&b... but boy, do i want to see her up there?!
oh yes i do...
she's amazing.. i love you natalie! youre better than those girls cuz u know what
music is all about. youre a sarah brightman not a beyonce, even though you can be anything you want!
youre greater than greater.
true artist, you are what an artist is all about.
we love you!!
thau450 1 year ago 3
What were they thinking?!?!
.....actually WHAT?!
The others suck in comparison.....
ThomasJWhite93 1 year ago
Did anyone notice what a seasoned professional she was when they told her the bad news? She may have gotten upset after she left the stage, but that right there is a perfect example of class. Thank you for your time, leave on a positive note. I can't deal with the people who try and fight their way to a "Yes".
hellodirtymartini 1 year ago 2
Okay, to me Natalie should have at least gone through...but at least some people saw her potential! She has a sensational voice!
AlexPlowman 1 year ago
well... natalie is like a broadway star. so whatever to american idol. its a shitty show anyways.
pianoprincess38 1 year ago 2
Seriously? Simon didn't think she had any sparkle with Natalie Weiss..bull
theloverofmovies91 1 year ago 2
Natalie Weiss is better for broadway anyway.
BreakTheSkyMyseIf 1 year ago 2
You are way better than that crap. They can eat it, you're Natalie Weiss, dammit!
johnnysnyder4 1 year ago 2
this just shows how much water american idol holds...none
sampleflyer 1 year ago
When shes playing elphaba on broadway and is earning $20,000 a week, those pushy parents and simon cowell are all gonna eb sorry lmao x
asswhole239 1 year ago 2
@asswhole239 she as actually elphaba's understudy, correct? i wish i had seen her!!
crazydivaxox 1 year ago
How is it I absolutely love Natalie and American Idol yet had no idea she was on it??
SONGizMYlife 1 year ago
i think the first girl and natalie were the good. why did the second girl get in like?? what?
angeleyez101 1 year ago 5
gimmie a break they suck compared to her
1215aphrodite 1 year ago
Natalie is twelve times better than both of those other chicks.. how is this possible? but clearly she doesnt need american idol to do great things!! =]
TheLonelyMind115 1 year ago
um....to bad that the two girls who did make it didnt go anywhere and NATALIE IS AMAZING AND IS ACTUALLY DOING STUFF. YAYYYYYYYY
Born4dacity 1 year ago
No disrespect to anyone affiliated with the show, but I've never been a huge fan of American Idol. It's turned out a handful of great singers, but most of it is all about image and a lot of the contestants aren't properly trained. Natalie is, on the other hand, and she's turning out to be a rising star! I can't wait to see what else she does in the future.
JmB8207 1 year ago 3
Wohoo! =)
Sims2Media 1 year ago
Ha. Natalie Weiss rocks!!! I OWN some of her stuff...I don't even know who the other girls are. The only reason I found this video is because I searched for her. So those girls can take their parents and well....I think you know where this is going.
mtgal82 1 year ago
@iBenjafied she still got in.
irishmusicalgurl1216 1 year ago
oh well. Natalie beats them all by a longshot anyway. NATALIE IS BETTER THAN ALL THE AMERICAN IDOL WINNERS PUT TOGETHER!
Oh yeah...which one of those girls is on Broadway? NATALIE!
irishmusicalgurl1216 1 year ago
So... that girl's dad got her on Broadway, right? Oh wait...
Natalie Weiss is amazing.
tlc123 1 year ago
that's so odd because I feel like Natalie was the best idk. Just my opinion. But w.e Natalie is making it right now :)))
angeleyez101 1 year ago 3
Let's see......... those other girls...... where are you? Natalie has music on Itunes and she has understudied huge roles like Elphaba and she is currently on Broadway alongside Sheri Rene Scott.
kicksgirl12 1 year ago 5
well first of all you this is more like a blackwomans song, so it wouldn´t fit to nathalie weiss.
and she is great now!
TimKoopman10 1 year ago
could it be ryan watkinson that shes calling?
flamingo1012 1 year ago
I remember this. Janay Castine was aweful in the top 24 or was it 30. Either or, Janay sounded like a dying sheep.
neosoulfuljojo 1 year ago 3
That's ridiculous! She was amazing. >:/
Whatver, she's so above that pop junk show. I'd choose Wicked over this mindless garbage any day.
shannabanana11 1 year ago 3
Natalie's in Everyday Rapture now. On broadway. I don't think anything else needs to be said.
20251 1 year ago
Thank God she fought back!! That actually makes me laugh. Man, she has improved so much though! Woah!
roytrobe 1 year ago
I had no idea Natalie Weiss was ever on American Idol. She's amazing - wonderful performer. You're right, she doesn't need AI. Her talent will take her far.
mbrooks972 1 year ago
ooh that makes me mad.
but natalie doesn't need american idol. obviously.
i agree- i'd take wicked over this crap any day.
dancerr625 1 year ago 2
Natalie can really sing... granted in this video she wasn't really doing it. That song needed to be in a higher key for her.
princeblondie 1 year ago
They only took those two other two for the diversity. Wasn't this the season Carrie won?
Anyway, Natalie definitley didn't need this dumb show... and Paula looks drunk.
BeautifullyTragicLFB 1 year ago
Oh my God...these people have no idea what talent is. Natalie was so amazing.
anngardner89 1 year ago
I agree! You're amazing...and where are they now?
JuanRocks 1 year ago
natalie, you're sooo much better than this shit. we love you!
sopranopowerr 1 year ago
aww...this is just another example of how simon cowell is a bastard with no taste
SupermarketsRevil 1 year ago
Pretty great how Natalie has a career in singing and performing, what happened to those other two Divas?
ryosuke35 1 year ago
yeah, for real. screw american idol. Natalie, you are SO above that. they put you in a group with pushy obnoxious self-righteous divas who needs their mommies and daddies holding their hands every step of the way.
and who has a world wide fanbase?
uhm, i believe it's you natalie.
MusicGuru1258 2 years ago
aw shit yeh nat specialy luvd wen u sed THANK U and bolted to chat wit ryan luv u gurt call me!!!!
TGdubDUB 2 years ago
my personal opinion- not just because its natalie (haha) but, back when I watched this when it aired and I didnt know of natalie, I felt that she was the best of the group not only vocally but in stage performant all together. The total energy factor was portrayed more in her than in the other two. So of COURSE natalies the star today haha :)
aleerox 2 years ago
Natalie didnt even need AI. Look where she is now. Having solo concerts at Birdland...performing songs on CDs for amazing new composers...Wicked....
Natalie is amazing. End of story.
begreenandMOO 2 years ago 5
the parents were just trying to make they own sparkle and you could tell
CupcakeAndTea 2 years ago
they gave her the worst part of the song and she couldnt show her voice
happsap1 2 years ago 5
@happsap1
yup they were just jealous that whe could sing better than them. they saw her as a threat, and gave her a cruddy part. but she doesnt even need them. look where she is now! CD, Tours, Concerts, WICKED!i mean really, she was honestly the best singer in that group
pandabear1317 1 year ago 2
"is there any way that the parents could just go out for a little bit cause i just feel a lot of pressure" hahaahahah
ashleygiorgi 2 years ago
Natalie - - you are amazin!!
Elphaba88 2 years ago
youre a star. be on b way.
zooger05 2 years ago
@zooger05 she is.
wls250 2 years ago
I agree with some of the other comments.. Natalie if you read this can you please audition one more time. I would love to see you on that show. Your vocals are incredible and would seriously blow everyone out of the water this time around! Auditions for 2010!!! I'll go with you! haha
Ctownkid5 2 years ago 2
the thing is though, natalie made it to broadway and made a name for herself, i've never seen those other girls in my life.
apiewrill01 2 years ago 2
Natalie, you have risen above and are an awesome singer who moves people when you sing. Never give up...you are a star in the making!!!!!
jfieser 2 years ago
OMG!!!1! a new singing contest is here on YOuTube and its called KARAOKE SHOWDOWN!! cant wait!! ^^
1966100x 2 years ago
Not gonna lie... this was not natalie at her best at all.... the other girls did do better than her but now nat would just blow them right out of the water. I think she should try out now and for her audition use I Believe in You and Me
serbalsrock16 2 years ago 5
i just said natalie is the best of the best love her the other girls were not as good as natalie i love her if you read this sub to me if you love natalie weiss she is the best of the best
swimmolly 2 years ago
Natalie, just sayin', you blew that out of the damn box. And you've made it so much farther than those girls. :)
lilelphie22456 2 years ago 4
hahahah where are those other girls now?
Natalie is the understudy for elphaba in New York now and the ensemble of Wicked
angelXD 2 years ago 90
lol she was never in Wicked in NewYork. she covered an ensemble member on tour for 6 weeks and that's it.
thoughtsmeander 2 years ago
@angelXD haha, besides, i'd choose being even in the ensemble of wicked, over winning american idol, any day
monkeygirl610 1 year ago 2
she's not on it here. too bad. she grew into my favourite voice of all time.
dreaming92 2 years ago 2
ugh divas piss me off. Natalie's just having fun, lighten up!
soccergoalygrl43 2 years ago 3
Natalie Weiss doesn't even need American Idol. She is so amazing.
walderbeast614 2 years ago 75
NATALIE ROCKS
kafkaholic 2 years ago 2
Natalie was not at the top of her shit but she blows those other girls away now.
princeblondie 2 years ago 6
oh gawd those parents kill me.
and those other girls sound exactly the same. ugh.
MichaelaBwayGirrl14 2 years ago 2
How did these three girls get eliminated????? They were all sooo amazing!!! Ten times better than some of the other people who made it in!!
OzGal6194 2 years ago
shocking! Cowells biggest mistake! Fool.
NicoHend 2 years ago 6
haha youre too good for american idol anyway.
shealovestom 2 years ago
look who laughing now!
TheBirdElephant 2 years ago
nononono natalie was the best of the group. Thats OBVIOUS now, because who has the success story? Ya did your thing nat.
aleerox 2 years ago
I'm sorry...why didn't she make it OR WIN!!! THE ENTIRE THING!
peerez90 2 years ago
re-audition girl!
in my opinion...you're 10 times better than those two.
and, you're the one that's successful now!
idkjade 2 years ago
No biggy natalies got a plan...oh and a brain haha you go natalie!
allstagdup 2 years ago
i love how you're doing huge things and those other two are probably still living at home doing nothing with their lives.
sasasinggg 2 years ago
So, what are the two girls doing that they kept? Sitting home with their PARENTS? Natalie, you were the one with the talent. Audition again.
rblack04 2 years ago
wait wait wait. they had their PARENTS with them? ARE THEY FUCKING SERIOUS!
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
I am so embarrassed for them.
jesswantstobewicked 2 years ago
you should've made it!!!!!!!!!!!!
themusicaltheaterlif 2 years ago
I'm so proud of you for sticking with this anyway! It looked like the show was just aiming for making drama
Bway2be 2 years ago
those 2 others were fukin shiiit!!! wtf?? i used to love simon cowell! NW we love you!!!! who needs american idol? x
starloz 2 years ago
That's bullshit.
imaligergrr 2 years ago
I THINK YOU SHOULD REAUDITION!
-people do it all the time, and get even further... :)
Ryanriddlers 2 years ago
:-O didnt know you did american idol?! as if you didnt get through!!!!! dw girl ur amazing!! cant stop showing your videos to all my friends here in the UK!!!! i wish you would come over here to do something or have you?! haha love you!! xxx
dancerboi12341 2 years ago
Shit, if I was Gina I'd be so embarrassed lol. I mean, why is a twenty something year old's parents following her around and accompanying her to auditions?
ShesBroadwayBound 2 years ago
lol, girl im so glad you put this video up. Those girls have NOTHING on you, and you know it! xo z
zachariahnyc 2 years ago 2
comeon Natalie!! Musical Theatre is so much better than any of that. Those are fads, what you have now is real!
megustasstuu 2 years ago 5
yeah her voice is so much better now, than it was then...Natalie is AMAZING!!!!!! And where are those other girls now, hmmmmm.....hahaha!
T2theTam 2 years ago 2
i wanna slap that father on the mouth. natalie PWNS those girls now.
cdmsinger 2 years ago 2
and she always did!!!
WeirdFro 2 years ago
when the parents can own up to being show business parents I'll give them props. When they beat around the bush because they are in TV, they can go kiss Natalie's ass. NATALIE YOU ARE AMAZING, GO BECOME FAMOUS BECAUSE YOU ARE GREAT, NOT BECAUSE OF SOME REALITY TV SHOW!!!!!
tonnjai 2 years ago 3
aha natalie has shit on their faces now.. look at her now, being in wicked etc she rocks =)
lewme01 2 years ago
urghh why are parents getting involved!? jog on!
you're so much better than both of them! telling you girl - they were CRAP.
you're awesomee!! :) :)
x
blondejokes92 2 years ago 2
In Season 4, AI still wasn't a "singing competition." Yeah, those parents were a nightmare...pushy as hell. Where are these two "successful" girls now Miss Elphaba?
robertdave 2 years ago 2
Janay and Gina can kiss your ass. We all know that you're doing so much better w/o them.
Keep kickin ass Natalie!!
lilcarmelqt07 2 years ago 2
ugghh the parents were such a nightmare!!!
theVstop 2 years ago 2
Yeah, if she went on Idol now, they probably would refuse to take her because she's too good...
Rmiddl 2 years ago
oh look! the hollywood sign!
dottore06 2 years ago
wow nat you were so good here... but it sounds like your voice has improved!
Misty15big 2 years ago