I had the absolute pleasure of attending this concert in January of 97' -- i believe it was held in madison square garden nyc--- it was MAGIC -- as her dew drop inn tour had just ended in 96'..... those were the BEST tori years ......i agree with everyone ... it was intense and raw ---- just timeless xoxo
@jojo324 Jojo is my daughter's name. lol. I am almost reduced to tears as if I am a little child, every time I hear her!!!! She reaches a place in me that no other artist has even brushed the surface of!!!!!
This was my FIRST TORI concert -- EVER ---- I still remember like it was yesterday! I am so excited for the upcoming HUNTERS tour - 11' this fall --- come on TORI ... I am hoping for some of that magic - just YOU and a PIANO and that damn haunting voice ~~ I will be there FRONT ROW - BOSTON MA! xo
Reminds me of Silent All These Years..They're pretty similar to each other expect the rock bridge in Pretty Good Year. Maybe it was a earlier version of Silent All These Years from the Little Earthquakes sessions.
Oh, well. Tori seems to love them. But MAYBE! Maybe she's not running to them to shake their hands, maybe she's going to strangle somebody! Great perfomance though, "what's it gonna take till my baby's alright" gave me goosebumps.
same here Coral, my first soing and I saw her on letterman doing it live.I would love to nibble on that bottom full lip of hers, but I am sure I am one aong millions of men and I am sure a few woman who have that same idea,lol
I love Tori and have seen her live a few times I just wish should wouldn't find it necessary to do the high pitched heeEEEeee thing in almost every song, it gets too repetetive
i miss her concerts. luv, luv, luv this woman with all my heart. she was once asked about her religion and she said something like, basically i'm just into fairies;)
She used to play the metal springs under her bed like a harp at age 2, 3, 4...she won a greand piano at 4 years old! Beautiful child prodigy who grew into a marvelous woman~
this is the song that introduced me to Tori Amos also via the Letterman show a very long time ago. I am still as moved by her passion and voice noiw as I was then
@coralinehue For sure, good call. Takes me WAY back. I taped this song off my VCR so I could have a tape in my car, lol. Beautiful song, still makes me tear up.
she can belt out a tune can't she. Boys for pele is a very good c.d so so is'nt the rest of her stuff, but I have to say putting the damage on from BFP is a awesome fucking tune.Goddamn Tori is awesome, and am I the only guy here that wants so nibbnle on that luscious bottom lip of hers while giving hyer a passionate kiss? I bet now,lol
This version of the song always, always moves me tears. Such an intense version of the song and always very special to me since it was this song that introduced me to Tori.
I didn't know who Tori Amos was until A sorta fairytale, fell in love with the song, purchased Scarlett's Walk, connected to many songs on this, especially Gold Dust, which is quite amazing. Drifted and bought Choir Girl Hotel, it was eye opening. My hubby got Welcome to Sunny Florida and found some great songs to download and now I am picking and choosing songs to download all the time. I am currently addicted to 1000 Oceans.
This is the first song I seen Tori do when I was introduced to her via the David Letterman show a very long time ago.I fell in love with her from that moment on, and I love her dearly to this day. What an incrediblly gifted singer,pianist songwriter this woman is.
1994 was the year my partner died. i carried this song with me to remind me that because of his life, even because of the pain, it was a pretty good year.
oh yeah, I have TOAL and that version also moved me greatly. But this one...can't really tell exactly what it is, maybe it was the occasion of the RAINN concert, but it carries a very unique vibe:)
This is a bit of an off topic-but has anyone seen a Tori video where she's sitting in a lucite box-hair's super matted and there's a police riot in the background? I was in it and have never seen it am an a huge fan of hers. Don't know the song title-obviously. Thanks
I've got so such sentimental attachment to this song. "Greg he writes letters and burns his c.d.'s They say you were something in those formative years. Hold onto nothing as fast as you can..." :Tear: I am such a feminist in training. All I need is a baby grande and a butch...
If we could only have more song writers and or prodigys from "three years old" maybe the music today would have the substance to last at least the next decade. Can you imagine a generation or centuries? think about it.
It's the bit's in her live songs that are improvised that truly make her stand out, like at the end of this one. It's makes your hair stand on end and you just think oh my god, what the hell did she just do, that's incredible! That's the sign of a true musical genius:)
I heard her play this song in 98, she messed up part of the song, and covered it up by singing "Pretty good Smear", which was an absolutely great way to recover from it. Good sense of humor to be sure.
Comment removed
JRussoBuffaloNY 2 days ago
2:17 hit it red
ChrissieBana 2 weeks ago
7 people need a slap.
icklerob 1 month ago
If I could time travel for one day, I would go visit James Dean, but i would spend my final time at this concert!
jan00075 2 months ago
how can someone dislike this video? anyway amazing song that marked my teens
vanessa1118 2 months ago
I had the absolute pleasure of attending this concert in January of 97' -- i believe it was held in madison square garden nyc--- it was MAGIC -- as her dew drop inn tour had just ended in 96'..... those were the BEST tori years ......i agree with everyone ... it was intense and raw ---- just timeless xoxo
glitterdust40 4 months ago
so intense in this part. well you know pretty well where
tihtih996 4 months ago
This is from the RAINN benefit concert... 1997 sounds about right.
sumduffa 5 months ago
I cry still. Like the day that first discovered her.
jojo324 5 months ago
@jojo324 Jojo is my daughter's name. lol. I am almost reduced to tears as if I am a little child, every time I hear her!!!! She reaches a place in me that no other artist has even brushed the surface of!!!!!
deucestrutter1 4 months ago
Beautiful and talented, really wished she had not taken to plastic surgery. What is wrong with being normal. Looks that is.
snazinhouston 5 months ago
@snazinhouston she got plastic surgery??? really? i wouldn't peg her for the type to do so. she's so beautiful naturally. :/
Gigi8877 3 months ago
Who is this disrespectful bastard smoking think he is. That Moron couldn't even wait till he got off stage! I am ashamed of this guys arrogance..
Belikoze 5 months ago
i broke out "under the pink" a few days ago, haven't listenend to it in years, way to good of an album to put it up on the shelf!
thriller79 5 months ago
Didn't this air on TV live? I have a childhood memory of this particular concert... anyone know what year this was?
olives937 6 months ago
@olives937 1997, I think.
spaceasunder 5 months ago
I love Tori :)
heeheehedd 6 months ago
This was my FIRST TORI concert -- EVER ---- I still remember like it was yesterday! I am so excited for the upcoming HUNTERS tour - 11' this fall --- come on TORI ... I am hoping for some of that magic - just YOU and a PIANO and that damn haunting voice ~~ I will be there FRONT ROW - BOSTON MA! xo
glitterdust40 6 months ago in playlist Tori Amos
beautiful song, beautiful tori, beautiful hair, beautiful dress, nothing is not perfect about this
barryframic 6 months ago
truky amazing...one of my absolute favourites, i'm in love with this song (and with the tori of the first 3-4 cds). she's fantastic
lukin68 7 months ago
The song is as old as me it's quite amazing and moving to listen to this.
Hopesfallout 8 months ago
7 people dont have pretty good year!
BadChickLover101 8 months ago 2
GOOD SINGER... PRETTY GOOD YEAR 1992
hasjkdhlsjakDHLASJKD 9 months ago
2:18 gives me goosbumps.. she so beautiful ..she sings with her soul she touchs my heart evrytime <3
BellahMel07 9 months ago 2
Shame no-one's listened to this song in 2 years it seems..... it's really good!
markhammond15 9 months ago
wow.
wow wow wow.
honestly the best performance of this (or any?) song.
EVER, yo.
danicka 9 months ago 2
nice song. You should also listen to a version of this song by Samuli Taskinen - talented guy with great voice
tsiisus7 10 months ago
I've always liked this song, but that's a seriously amazing performance of it. Fabulous stuff.
swanstep 10 months ago 3
Stunning
michaelineangelo 11 months ago
Reminds me of Silent All These Years..They're pretty similar to each other expect the rock bridge in Pretty Good Year. Maybe it was a earlier version of Silent All These Years from the Little Earthquakes sessions.
apnixlover900 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great Performance!!
facku1001 1 year ago
Great Performance!!
facku1001 1 year ago
it's so amazing:X:X:X:
iuliutzaaaa 1 year ago
I was there, an awesome show.....she gives a great performance!!
Antigony07 1 year ago
I'm really speechless... I bow myself in front of this woman!
matteroftime89 1 year ago 4
Who is the FUCKER that dislike this??? Pure Art!!! love you Tori
hellsingx9 1 year ago 4
this is just breathtaking
Karolcia1993 1 year ago
Someone should kill the audience. Am I the only one, that hears these irritating screams?
demonicfiance 1 year ago 6
Oh, well. Tori seems to love them. But MAYBE! Maybe she's not running to them to shake their hands, maybe she's going to strangle somebody! Great perfomance though, "what's it gonna take till my baby's alright" gave me goosebumps.
demonicfiance 1 year ago
wow. i find it hard enough to play the piano without singing. let alone sing it as well as she is. she looks like she is having so much fun.
Bustertexan123 1 year ago
same here Coral, my first soing and I saw her on letterman doing it live.I would love to nibble on that bottom full lip of hers, but I am sure I am one aong millions of men and I am sure a few woman who have that same idea,lol
deathtouch100 1 year ago
I love Tori and have seen her live a few times I just wish should wouldn't find it necessary to do the high pitched heeEEEeee thing in almost every song, it gets too repetetive
nunnipoo 1 year ago
i will take tori amos with me through life. this is such a good preformance, i love how she radiates such raw passion in her music.
CouganSmith 1 year ago 9
i have no words to explain what makes me feel to hear and to see her singing this song in the way she does.
pepebrio 2 years ago 7
I agree Kyle, I see no dad connection in this song either
deathtouch100 2 years ago
Happy 'new year' everyone.
seattletaytay 2 years ago 2
2:18 nothing says "I hate you dad" like this unnecessary outburst.
glennwith2nns 2 years ago
i don't know what that has to do with her dad - but it is one of the few times live that she sung that part in the original octave in full belt
kylegreerrocks 2 years ago 3
what the hell does that even mean?
playboyjudas 2 years ago
it means you're a jackass
glennwith2nns 2 years ago
of course, that certainly clears it up. very intelligent response. Thanks.
playboyjudas 2 years ago 4
i miss her concerts. luv, luv, luv this woman with all my heart. she was once asked about her religion and she said something like, basically i'm just into fairies;)
rainjustice38 2 years ago 3
She used to play the metal springs under her bed like a harp at age 2, 3, 4...she won a greand piano at 4 years old! Beautiful child prodigy who grew into a marvelous woman~
Theannalise9 2 years ago 5
this is the song that introduced me to Tori Amos also via the Letterman show a very long time ago. I am still as moved by her passion and voice noiw as I was then
deathtouch100 2 years ago
This is the song that introduce her to me. There's a naked, hysterical ego hidden in the dark side of us.
Beautiful song.
coralinehue 2 years ago 36
@coralinehue For sure, good call. Takes me WAY back. I taped this song off my VCR so I could have a tape in my car, lol. Beautiful song, still makes me tear up.
MrCj0987 1 year ago
I hit it.
coverdog1 2 years ago
she can belt out a tune can't she. Boys for pele is a very good c.d so so is'nt the rest of her stuff, but I have to say putting the damage on from BFP is a awesome fucking tune.Goddamn Tori is awesome, and am I the only guy here that wants so nibbnle on that luscious bottom lip of hers while giving hyer a passionate kiss? I bet now,lol
deathtouch100 2 years ago 4
My favourite Tori song too. Beautiful.
stevie511 2 years ago
ya know greg was really burning cds tori wrote this before u could do it on a computer shes the lyrical gansta i love her
sirex02 2 years ago 4
@sirex02 - lyrical gangsta.... ha, love it.
CalicoCupcakes 2 years ago
My favorite Tori song.
ScaredPiglet 2 years ago 4
Same here. <3
Joijolepakko 2 years ago
This version of the song always, always moves me tears. Such an intense version of the song and always very special to me since it was this song that introduced me to Tori.
prettygoodyear 2 years ago 3
From the comments I've read here I guess I should get Pele.
ThePatient1986 2 years ago
that would be an outstanding idea.
wanchez33 2 years ago
beautiful!
ScarletsBeautifulLie 2 years ago
I didn't know who Tori Amos was until A sorta fairytale, fell in love with the song, purchased Scarlett's Walk, connected to many songs on this, especially Gold Dust, which is quite amazing. Drifted and bought Choir Girl Hotel, it was eye opening. My hubby got Welcome to Sunny Florida and found some great songs to download and now I am picking and choosing songs to download all the time. I am currently addicted to 1000 Oceans.
MelanieMarlane 2 years ago
if you got the balls
buy "boys for pele"
it is life changing i'm not fucking kidding
damienxxxpele 2 years ago 3
I didnt see your post, I just recommended that someone buy Pele as it will blow her balls off!.
sexysebastian 2 years ago
You've got to get Boys for Pele next! I think it's her finest hour. It will blow your balls off!
sexysebastian 2 years ago
Fel in lov with Tori in 1992
1974Qball 2 years ago
This is the first song I seen Tori do when I was introduced to her via the David Letterman show a very long time ago.I fell in love with her from that moment on, and I love her dearly to this day. What an incrediblly gifted singer,pianist songwriter this woman is.
deathtouch100 2 years ago 3
I had this on vhs tape.. i worn it out by playing it so much! beautiful i love this song! i wish i could play piano as beautiful as she does
Boneaparte386 2 years ago
dis song makes me cry!!
yaywhewclips242 2 years ago
I love her even more.
k8eebear 2 years ago
I love how she does that at 2:18 Soo innocent and soft and then just erupts with anger and furry.
She is a true song writing visionary...
BrianMauk 2 years ago 3
she's one of the few musicians who sound good live as well as recorded.
rileypoo69 2 years ago 3
1994 was the year my partner died. i carried this song with me to remind me that because of his life, even because of the pain, it was a pretty good year.
jackhillty 2 years ago 5
This has to be one of the best versions of this song ever! Especially love the 'what's it gonna take?' bit.
looneyleprechaun 2 years ago 4
Excellent!!
xgirlfiendx 2 years ago
i love ths song so much im doin a solo to it for dance
ETCdancer17 2 years ago 2
Shes a genius...they come so few and far between.
I love you Tori. U R my inspiration.!!
~ s.
deepsoulblu 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
chris martin should play that version with her i think it would be a classic...........brilll tune...
scuttx1 2 years ago
That's indeed the best live version EVER of PGY! SO moving!
CCarmen 2 years ago 2
did you ever see the version on "TAles" collection
the DVD she does it for a sound check
and she said she did it for this boy that had cancer and he asked her to play it for him.....
it ws really sad.
damienxxxpele 2 years ago
oh yeah, I have TOAL and that version also moved me greatly. But this one...can't really tell exactly what it is, maybe it was the occasion of the RAINN concert, but it carries a very unique vibe:)
CCarmen 2 years ago
The most beautyful song coming from the most beautiful female voice all around the world. Unique. Thanks Tori
gianlucaspi 3 years ago 6
Thanks Dan, I will check that out.
lolacc09 3 years ago
what a voice beautiul
danbit5 3 years ago
This is a bit of an off topic-but has anyone seen a Tori video where she's sitting in a lucite box-hair's super matted and there's a police riot in the background? I was in it and have never seen it am an a huge fan of hers. Don't know the song title-obviously. Thanks
lolacc09 3 years ago
oops forgive me i meant to press reply, that could be 1000 oceans lolac,check that video
danbit5 3 years ago
wow that scream was really off key near the end
Iluminator 3 years ago
I think that was the point. Raw emotion doesn't care if it's pretty.
QueenBoudiccea 2 years ago 35
Chills baby, chills.
MizSerpentina 3 years ago 2
I've got so such sentimental attachment to this song. "Greg he writes letters and burns his c.d.'s They say you were something in those formative years. Hold onto nothing as fast as you can..." :Tear: I am such a feminist in training. All I need is a baby grande and a butch...
Whore4Horror 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
*eyeroll* What a dork!
whyumnot32 3 years ago
People buy this video it is brilliant!!'Live in new york'
Tori at her best!!....like always!! hehe
ophelianymph 3 years ago
This is just too beautiful.
I love this concert. : )
One of Tori's best songs I guess..and definately one of my all-time favorites.
By the way,this guys should shut up.
Their screaming is awful.
ENeithneYA 3 years ago
This concert was the best TORI offered for RAINN,I wish it was release on dvd!
FRANKYCG 3 years ago 2
I never get tired of this song. It's one of my favorites.
I love it how she makes it seem effortless, and the "what's it gonna ta-e-ake" part is even better than on the record.
happyfelo 3 years ago
♥ this song!! and Tori!!
NWTFDT 3 years ago 3
why isn't this loading for me?
iieeleelylo 4 years ago
this is my fave song!! i listen to my ipod alot! except my version has no words and its volin
cutie463 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
can you say Terets??
I'm not sure I like the way she flips her tone from more concert choir to country....
kyliemariemattke 4 years ago
can you spell tourettes??
Emericanization 3 years ago
each time i see this call it my manic coming into play she brings tears of joy, love ya girl
sk8erstaind 4 years ago
I am guessing this is from around Pele time because of the Harpsichord
sorcerer101567 4 years ago
Pele came out in '96, right? Yeah. This concert was in 1997.
threedaystime45 4 years ago
i love the stream-of-concious song AND melody, the melody alone tells a story
lostinsimulation 4 years ago 3
Does she still tour?
cramfan 4 years ago
Tori is currently (9/07) on tour in Australia. She is scheduled to return to the US in October. I plan to see her in DC on 10/26.
CommentorX 4 years ago
Arguably the best performance of this song. EVER.
slivertoe 4 years ago 3
If we could only have more song writers and or prodigys from "three years old" maybe the music today would have the substance to last at least the next decade. Can you imagine a generation or centuries? think about it.
dstarj1 4 years ago
It's the bit's in her live songs that are improvised that truly make her stand out, like at the end of this one. It's makes your hair stand on end and you just think oh my god, what the hell did she just do, that's incredible! That's the sign of a true musical genius:)
waaay123 4 years ago 3
I think Tori also deserves a Fashion award- She has such a unique sense of style its weird but cool
brandice10680 4 years ago
I heard her play this song in 98, she messed up part of the song, and covered it up by singing "Pretty good Smear", which was an absolutely great way to recover from it. Good sense of humor to be sure.
robobrow 4 years ago 2
tori is great singer and she has a great personality!!
lulinegracumbiera 4 years ago
tori is amazing! she rocks! ;-)
freehip 4 years ago
WOOOOOW! No need to say more...
LuthienNarmolanya 4 years ago
Amazing, her voice and piano playing, really wonderful.
refresher 4 years ago
Tori is simply...Phenomenal.One of her great songs ever.
Solroberto 4 years ago
Tori is the best singer and piano player. New record coming soon...
olivetiming 4 years ago
Tori is superb-- in person and in concert. She seriously deserves the Nobel Prize (for Superb Musicianship and Personality.)
showtunesman89 5 years ago