HoChiMinh won DienBienPhu Battle in 1954, death toll about 5,000 VietMinh soldiers. After that HoChiMinh opened Land Reform killed 750,000 innocent civilians (they were having big house, vast land and gold), HoChiMinh was bastard!!
im not french but are french people outrage about how their soldiers were treated by the vietminh after they surrender at dien bien phu? Making them march for almost 200 miles to prison camps near china border and hardly giving them food like one small rice bag a day. I think around 18,000 french surrender, only less than 4,000 came back to france. It would had been better for them to fight to the death than to surrender and died slowly
Why should French people be outraged? They could have prevented the whole thing but did not. Again, there is no one to blame but the politicians and the French officers in charge. The French have this curious habit of consistently underestimating the abilities of their opponent, especially those from so called 'third world' countries.Only idiots would choose air support to a position which was overlooked by higher ground.It's all history now thank goodness.
fuck it, look at the history they stole canada, america, and declare freedom by saying but in fact they are no freedom, they control that land and out source the natural rich terrain for they own gain. Man when i think of it that make me sick.
i wanna say, fuck all the hater that telling bad thing about VN and French army, We VN want to have freedom, many VNmese soldiers were lost that day and the French soldiers too. For the French, they just follow the order, i feel sad about every lives were lost. So fuck all hater and troller, if you dont understand history so just GTFO.
@whgamer11 thank you for your comment whgamer, its true, the french soldiers didnt want to go to fight in vietnam, it was the wish of the politicians , as usual,im french and i say colonisation was very bad, the vietnamese were right to fight for their freedom, i went to vietnam last summer, its an amazing country , im glad now france and vietnam have a very good relationship
french army pull on a amazing fight against sadistic and vicious ho chi min army, in 2 months 75 percent of he french prisoners died from starvations and brutality from the communist forces, even worse than nazi camps but yeah communism is good
Unlike American prejudiced view of French military, the French defenders at Dien Bien Phu put up a bloody fight. But they found, as Americans found out 15 years later, the Viets were determined to die for their freedom and thus the defeat at Dien Bien Phu. Soldiers on both sides of the conflict did their jobs well. In the end it showed colonialism and servitude had no place in modern world.
@Knguyen281 Thanks. Encouraging to see some enlightenment amongst all the trolling, hatred, chestpounding, stupid nationalist vanity and drivel on Youtube.
The French military is a fine fighting force, but nothing can keep down a people's dream of self-determination. I could have wished the French would have seen that and created a commonwealth instead; with autonomy for all its colonies, but strong ties and cooperation still.
oublier et abandoner a dien bien phu gloire au pilot et aux gars qui on sauté sur dien bien phu a l'attitude inferieure au largage sans brevet de para
Read He'll in a Small Place by Bernard Fall. The French troops showed unimaginable bravery after being placed in a very difficult position. Vive La France!
@glasfurd31 I agree and love the French military, but we have to admit that the Vietnameese showed a lot of courage as well. Just imagine having no field hospitals at all and facing napalm burns...
@glasfurd31 They have no choice but to be brave. They have now where to run. They are in the defensive. It is the vietmin that are braver. they attack knowing that they will be shoot by entrenched french fries when they can wait for them to starve and die of injury. They could have just bombard them with cannons.
the foreign legion and the auxiliary troops who die in mass were brave in the war and in the siege the french only show they suberb as always
the war was lost before dien bien phu this was a pathetic show of arrogance
put a fucking fort in the middle of the jungle with no air support and with only a airlift for the supplies(neutralized by the vietnamese antiaircraft)
@KatiushaVN4 Yup i'm VNmese but hey, is history, the French army do what the goverment order, is not there fault to attacked us. Said those old French's Goverment from the past. And i know french people knew that thier goverment was wrong that time, and we all VNmese know that they feel bad too, not only us.
This has been flagged as spam show
HoChiMinh won DienBienPhu Battle in 1954, death toll about 5,000 VietMinh soldiers. After that HoChiMinh opened Land Reform killed 750,000 innocent civilians (they were having big house, vast land and gold), HoChiMinh was bastard!!
thoyedao 4 days ago
im not french but are french people outrage about how their soldiers were treated by the vietminh after they surrender at dien bien phu? Making them march for almost 200 miles to prison camps near china border and hardly giving them food like one small rice bag a day. I think around 18,000 french surrender, only less than 4,000 came back to france. It would had been better for them to fight to the death than to surrender and died slowly
reddog2007max 3 weeks ago
@reddog2007max
Why should French people be outraged? They could have prevented the whole thing but did not. Again, there is no one to blame but the politicians and the French officers in charge. The French have this curious habit of consistently underestimating the abilities of their opponent, especially those from so called 'third world' countries.Only idiots would choose air support to a position which was overlooked by higher ground.It's all history now thank goodness.
arriviste2020 2 weeks ago
fuck it, look at the history they stole canada, america, and declare freedom by saying but in fact they are no freedom, they control that land and out source the natural rich terrain for they own gain. Man when i think of it that make me sick.
colt35 1 month ago
The worst about this is the french people.
French Army always does outstanding job but there are leftist people at home sabotaging everything.
Democracy at home unfortunately kills any serious military undertaking
SShadow101 1 month ago
We do not want war. We want freedom. I'm Vietnamese.
TheRickyDang 1 month ago 2
i wanna say, fuck all the hater that telling bad thing about VN and French army, We VN want to have freedom, many VNmese soldiers were lost that day and the French soldiers too. For the French, they just follow the order, i feel sad about every lives were lost. So fuck all hater and troller, if you dont understand history so just GTFO.
P/S: sorry for my bad English grammar.
whgamer11 2 months ago
@whgamer11 thank you for your comment whgamer, its true, the french soldiers didnt want to go to fight in vietnam, it was the wish of the politicians , as usual,im french and i say colonisation was very bad, the vietnamese were right to fight for their freedom, i went to vietnam last summer, its an amazing country , im glad now france and vietnam have a very good relationship
streetmusicdefrance 2 months ago 2
@streetmusicdefrance u dont need to thank me for that, i just care about the history true, not some shitty lies just to humiliate a country.
whgamer11 2 months ago
J'admire le courage du soldat au Vietnam
BaByLan1000 2 months ago
gooks are ugly and cowards lol, napalm rules
usa466 2 months ago
@usa466 , i shit in your dirty mouth, dirty rage dog
usa979 2 months ago
FUCK LA FRANCE COLONIAL
yanco72 2 months ago
french army pull on a amazing fight against sadistic and vicious ho chi min army, in 2 months 75 percent of he french prisoners died from starvations and brutality from the communist forces, even worse than nazi camps but yeah communism is good
vladimir2147 3 months ago
@vladimir2147 , ha ha ha loser cries everyday about this battle
PetainPhilippe 2 months ago
@vladimir2147 Merci Vladimir / Thanks Vladomir / Spasibo Vladimir
DeRoquencourt 2 months ago
FUCK VIETNAM
usa466 3 months ago
@usa466 , lolz the VietNamese win....
PetainPhilippe 2 months ago
@usa466 bitch please... your USA army has lost in VN war too, jealous!?
whgamer11 2 months ago
Unlike American prejudiced view of French military, the French defenders at Dien Bien Phu put up a bloody fight. But they found, as Americans found out 15 years later, the Viets were determined to die for their freedom and thus the defeat at Dien Bien Phu. Soldiers on both sides of the conflict did their jobs well. In the end it showed colonialism and servitude had no place in modern world.
Knguyen281 4 months ago 5
@Knguyen281 Thanks. Encouraging to see some enlightenment amongst all the trolling, hatred, chestpounding, stupid nationalist vanity and drivel on Youtube.
The French military is a fine fighting force, but nothing can keep down a people's dream of self-determination. I could have wished the French would have seen that and created a commonwealth instead; with autonomy for all its colonies, but strong ties and cooperation still.
PalleRasmussen 2 months ago
Serious fighting!!!!
Redcoat66 5 months ago
oublier et abandoner a dien bien phu gloire au pilot et aux gars qui on sauté sur dien bien phu a l'attitude inferieure au largage sans brevet de para
flashOverbegin 5 months ago
oublier et abandoner a dien bien phu
flashOverbegin 5 months ago
Read He'll in a Small Place by Bernard Fall. The French troops showed unimaginable bravery after being placed in a very difficult position. Vive La France!
glasfurd31 6 months ago 19
@glasfurd31 fuck you and the french!
tariqziyad 5 months ago
@glasfurd31 I agree and love the French military, but we have to admit that the Vietnameese showed a lot of courage as well. Just imagine having no field hospitals at all and facing napalm burns...
PalleRasmussen 2 months ago
@glasfurd31 They have no choice but to be brave. They have now where to run. They are in the defensive. It is the vietmin that are braver. they attack knowing that they will be shoot by entrenched french fries when they can wait for them to starve and die of injury. They could have just bombard them with cannons.
diosdadoapias 2 months ago
@glasfurd31 the french????
the foreign legion and the auxiliary troops who die in mass were brave in the war and in the siege the french only show they suberb as always
the war was lost before dien bien phu this was a pathetic show of arrogance
put a fucking fort in the middle of the jungle with no air support and with only a airlift for the supplies(neutralized by the vietnamese antiaircraft)
come on be realistic!
horrorvacui121 1 month ago
Look at this Katiusha asshole
39sg1 10 months ago
look at those French pigs
KatiushaVN4 11 months ago
@KatiushaVN4 Not cool to say. The French were not pigs.
MrBasilGanglia 11 months ago 12
@KatiushaVN4 dude, not cool at all to said that.
whgamer11 2 months ago
@whgamer11
Not cool??? Aren't you Vietnamese?
KatiushaVN4 2 months ago
@KatiushaVN4 Yup i'm VNmese but hey, is history, the French army do what the goverment order, is not there fault to attacked us. Said those old French's Goverment from the past. And i know french people knew that thier goverment was wrong that time, and we all VNmese know that they feel bad too, not only us.
whgamer11 2 months ago
@whgamer11
Are you pro-French? Excuse me, how old are you?
KatiushaVN4 2 months ago
@KatiushaVN4 age is not important, but u wanna know, i'm 18.
whgamer11 2 months ago
@whgamer11
ClaudioKyVy 2 months ago
BELLE SOUVENIR JOUBLIE PAS CETTE DEFAITE
colt35 1 year ago
Merci pour la vidéo.
Septimanien 1 year ago
Thank you, its so hard to get good footage of Indochina, these are fantastic
starcrasher 2 years ago