no this camel was fron button camel to harding camel to yuna camel. because these are the people who can do the best. mao has tried this but wasn't good as this camel is only recognised if the skater's body is at least 170degrees straight
It is just Korean people naming it Yuna carmel. Everyone call that Biellman spin. I bet most of Korean people would believe that Yuna is the one invented this spin. I totally agree with saskiaburgermeister. No one should change the name because one executes better than others. what if there is someone better that Yuna. The name should be changed again ? that's the most stupid idea
No, this is not the Biellmann spin. The Biellmann spin is a one-foot spin while holding the other foot extended over and behind the head, forming a teardrop shape with the body. It would be better for you to enjoy figure skating if you know some basics. Hope this helps.
well, you cant blame them... when shizuka iconized the Ina Bauer move, the Japanese people all called the move the "shizuka way" or something like that, so you see, you cant really blame them....
am3ri3s, i named it the "Arakawa' after Shizuka did her's with incredible difficulties noted and flexibility that no one else can do, even if Mirai is almost to the level of Shizuka's. It made me like the 'original' ina bauer version even less. I like to say that Shizuka's version is very scientifically unique.
an3ri3e I know, you are right, but I think they shouldn't try to blame Yu Na Kim for the same reason, other than I think her camel is much better than that of Chouinard. yet I am starting to see people being riled when they feel that Yu Na Kim is not entitled to the right to have her spin classified as uniquely of her own. People can do whatever they want by naming the camel as "YuNa Camel".
The Biellman Spin got its name because Denise was the first person to perform it regularly. The spin had no name before that. The Harding Camel already has a name, and was performed regularly by Tonya, Josie and others before Yu-Na, even if Yu-Na does it the best. You can't just take the name of a move away from someone and give it to someone else! Should we could rename the triple Axel the triple Mao or the Triple Midori?
hmm out of the others, I like Yu Na Kim's better. These lines of the introverted camel spin looks awkward and not in a straight line form. You may want to disagree with me on that one, but that is tough. Yu Na Kim does her a whole lot better.
As I repeat this like, a thousand times, the name itself has never been officially changed to 'Yuna Camel', although my personal position would be that there wouldn't be any problems if they called it so, same as the Denise Biellmann wasn't the first to execute the Biellmann spin, or Caroline Zhang with the pearl spin
Skaters like Harding and Josee certainly did do a 'bent leg layover camel'. But personally I don't find it insulting to call Yuna's signature spin the 'Yuna Camel' because hers is more perpendicular to the ice, and because she used it all through her career.
The Button Camel is the flying camel lol;; The official name of this spin is the bent leg layover camel, but fans of Harding, Josee, and Yuna wanted their name in it as their signature position;; It is simply absurd to say that Korean fans changed its name to 'Yuna Camel' because it has never been official changed to it;;
Whatever. Biellmann made the move her TRADEMARK. I don't see Yu-Na's broken camel as a trademark at all, and as Justine4FS pointed out, CaroZ and Mao have much more beautiful variants of the spin to begin with. Yu-Na as the jumps, the speed, the confidence and presentation, but you have to be kidding yourselves if you think SPINS are Yu-Na's best selling point (she does maximize the levels, but its nowhere close to what CaroZ/Mirai/Yukari/Alyssa/Mao achieve).
i am interested in figure skating,i always serch different spins on the internet.If there is Yuna camel,would you mind to give me a website that introduce a spin call'Yuna camel'????Thanks
Actually, the best variations of the broken camel were executed by Caroline Zhang and Mao Asada. They were able to bring their arms behind their shoulders in a position similar to the one executed in a classical lauback. Very difficult variation and beautiful to look at. All the other skaters put their arms over the chest, to the side or in a 'Hamilton camel' position - it's easier to keep the balance this way.
no this camel was fron button camel to harding camel to yuna camel. because these are the people who can do the best. mao has tried this but wasn't good as this camel is only recognised if the skater's body is at least 170degrees straight
sumimimi0 1 year ago
@sumimimi0 Mao isn't good at the Yu Na camel as Yu Na Kim sure is. Mao did it all wrong. But I love Mao's spirals!
waddleduckie1 1 year ago
@waddleduckie1 i know... i said that... anyways, i said 170 degrees, mao can't really do it. she tried during her masquerade for her lp. but failed
sumimimi0 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
yuna camel....HAHA XD
you should study about figureskate...
...this spin is easier than other spin....
mikanvlovev25 1 year ago
It's button camel. NOT Yuna camel.
narunoa 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What is Yuna Camel?I want you not to make it without permission.
motta3939 2 years ago
there are no spins named yuna camel
why are koreans always telling lies.....
ezflee 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It is just Korean people naming it Yuna carmel. Everyone call that Biellman spin. I bet most of Korean people would believe that Yuna is the one invented this spin. I totally agree with saskiaburgermeister. No one should change the name because one executes better than others. what if there is someone better that Yuna. The name should be changed again ? that's the most stupid idea
kharma999 2 years ago
No, this is not the Biellmann spin. The Biellmann spin is a one-foot spin while holding the other foot extended over and behind the head, forming a teardrop shape with the body. It would be better for you to enjoy figure skating if you know some basics. Hope this helps.
INA101a 2 years ago
well, you cant blame them... when shizuka iconized the Ina Bauer move, the Japanese people all called the move the "shizuka way" or something like that, so you see, you cant really blame them....
am3ri3s 2 years ago
am3ri3s, i named it the "Arakawa' after Shizuka did her's with incredible difficulties noted and flexibility that no one else can do, even if Mirai is almost to the level of Shizuka's. It made me like the 'original' ina bauer version even less. I like to say that Shizuka's version is very scientifically unique.
waddleduckie1 2 years ago
"scientifically" unique!? Lol! now we apply sciences into figure skating alongside artistry and technicality, haha......... or is it physics????
am3ri3s 2 years ago
more like physics. :-)
waddleduckie1 2 years ago
an3ri3e I know, you are right, but I think they shouldn't try to blame Yu Na Kim for the same reason, other than I think her camel is much better than that of Chouinard. yet I am starting to see people being riled when they feel that Yu Na Kim is not entitled to the right to have her spin classified as uniquely of her own. People can do whatever they want by naming the camel as "YuNa Camel".
waddleduckie1 2 years ago
Comment removed
kharma999 2 years ago
what is Yuna Camel?
I don' know.
mundy0821 2 years ago
nice yuna camel
yunakim1910 2 years ago
Josee chouinard was the first skater to do this spin, and it should be named after Josee.
zoomorph1000 2 years ago
The Biellman Spin got its name because Denise was the first person to perform it regularly. The spin had no name before that. The Harding Camel already has a name, and was performed regularly by Tonya, Josie and others before Yu-Na, even if Yu-Na does it the best. You can't just take the name of a move away from someone and give it to someone else! Should we could rename the triple Axel the triple Mao or the Triple Midori?
saskiaburgermeister 2 years ago
saskiaburgermeister, Hence "The Triple Ito"! ( in honor of Midori Ito)!!!! :-) Yes!!!! LOL
waddleduckie1 2 years ago
I agree that Yuna does this spin quite well, but the real name for this spin is Harding Camel. Chek Wiki's 'camel spin' info.
PochinkoPotanko 2 years ago
it isn't YU-Na camel.
tamagokaketemazemaze 2 years ago
YUNA'S IS THE BEST
delmar7336 2 years ago
???
this is Not "Yuna Camel" lol
Rachmaniyokonov 2 years ago
hmm out of the others, I like Yu Na Kim's better. These lines of the introverted camel spin looks awkward and not in a straight line form. You may want to disagree with me on that one, but that is tough. Yu Na Kim does her a whole lot better.
waddleduckie1 2 years ago
Yuna camel???? Only Korean.
honeybeebee1991 2 years ago
"yuna camel".......lol
Rachmaniyokonov 2 years ago
korean kim's fans are always bashing mao and miki........sooooo crazy ppl...:p
...and this spin isn't "yuna camel"...huh
to korean kim's fans...
please study the history of figure skating.
...and don't insult other skaters!!
I like yuna....her skating is great.
but I hate her fans...:( sick ppl...(not all)
chokennaitei 2 years ago
goyunakimjr>
please delate other skater's name,who is not related to your video.
it is spam! really annoying!
zakkan007 2 years ago
As I repeat this like, a thousand times, the name itself has never been officially changed to 'Yuna Camel', although my personal position would be that there wouldn't be any problems if they called it so, same as the Denise Biellmann wasn't the first to execute the Biellmann spin, or Caroline Zhang with the pearl spin
45in3 2 years ago
Skaters like Harding and Josee certainly did do a 'bent leg layover camel'. But personally I don't find it insulting to call Yuna's signature spin the 'Yuna Camel' because hers is more perpendicular to the ice, and because she used it all through her career.
45in3 2 years ago
Comment removed
45in3 2 years ago
yu-na camel?lol
v0nb0n 2 years ago
臭い物には蓋をする
スパム酷いですね・・・(苦笑)
まるで子供ですね。
でも、やっている人間はいい年した大人たちですからね・・・タチ悪い。
キムがきっかけでフィギュアを見るようになった人たち+捏造大好き韓国人ですからね、やれやれって感じですが・・・。
まぁ、もうちょっと勉強しろ(世界に目を向けろ)って思います(笑)
ojyarumarusama 2 years ago
this is not officially yuna camel,
previously others figures skaters did this.
lifigureskating14 2 years ago
Korean fans are liars !!!
tamachime 2 years ago
well i think it should be called the chouinard camel since josee did it best.. hehe :-)
cookiekart 2 years ago
This spin is called officially the Button Camel. Since Korean fans changed the name to Yuna Camel, ISU has issued a notice to them to stop it.
narunoa 2 years ago
prove it
jolazzzang 2 years ago
The Button Camel is the flying camel lol;; The official name of this spin is the bent leg layover camel, but fans of Harding, Josee, and Yuna wanted their name in it as their signature position;; It is simply absurd to say that Korean fans changed its name to 'Yuna Camel' because it has never been official changed to it;;
45in3 2 years ago
That's right
europa0406 2 years ago
to korean kim's fans
Please study the history of figure skating.
And don't insult figure skating and other skaters......
chokennaitei 2 years ago
Twisted confusion of Love and Hatred toward Yuna..
lyricalassn 2 years ago
Comment removed
fgr8sktrfn 2 years ago
Whatever. Biellmann made the move her TRADEMARK. I don't see Yu-Na's broken camel as a trademark at all, and as Justine4FS pointed out, CaroZ and Mao have much more beautiful variants of the spin to begin with. Yu-Na as the jumps, the speed, the confidence and presentation, but you have to be kidding yourselves if you think SPINS are Yu-Na's best selling point (she does maximize the levels, but its nowhere close to what CaroZ/Mirai/Yukari/Alyssa/Mao achieve).
clovera 2 years ago
??? mao has a more beautiful positions?!?!?!?!?! where did you get that idea from?
starlightdazzles 2 years ago
If you are too blind to see it, I can't help you. :)
clovera 2 years ago
Koreans are believing that Yuna Camel(Yuna Spin) is the movement to characterize Yuna Kim herself.
That's why Koreans can't allow other skaters to do Yuna Camel(Yuna Spin).
Koreans don't insist on the origin of Yuna Camel(Yuna Spin).
They merely wish other skaters don't execute Yuna Camel(Yuna Spin).
We human beings must understand their pure mind.
figure005 2 years ago
Koreans like to call "Yuna Camel" "Yuna Spin".
"Yuna Spin" is more suitable.
figure005 2 years ago
crazy...:p
only korean ppl call this spin "yuna camel".lol
they don't know the history of figure skating at all...
chokennaitei 2 years ago 6
What's the name of this melody?
aquino1mex 2 years ago
the name of this melody is Salut d'amour(Edward Elgar).
goyunakimjr 2 years ago
it is called harding camel, isn't it?
pommexx 2 years ago 7
Famously, Dick Button called this spin (executed by Tonya Harding) "a crossover between a Hamilton camel and a tipsy skater". :D
Josee's broken camel looks quite elegant, though. Nice to see a skater experiment with new positions such a long time ago.
tosca4tosca 2 years ago 3
koreans don't understand figure skating.
"yuna camel".......lololol
are you ok??crazy people...
all koreans are never crazy. ONLY korean Kims fans are crazy.
chokennaitei 2 years ago 14
it's not really called yuna camel... i think it's called bent leg layover camel spin....
anyway you usually name a spin for the first person who ever invented or executed the move...
getmewildO2 2 years ago 17
great clips
rochesterpopulist 2 years ago
By the way, please don't tag the skaters who are not related to this video.
tetris566 2 years ago
those who have interest in figure skating should know about this issue.
goyunakimjr 2 years ago
Denise Biellmann was not the 1st woman who executed Biellmann Spin.
But Biellmann Spin is called Biellmann Spin.
Because Denise Biellmann executed Biellmann Spin most nicely.
goyunakimjr 2 years ago
Who is the first woman ever to execute Biellmann spin?
tetris566 2 years ago
the Internet is there for your question.
goyunakimjr 2 years ago
Comment removed
fgr8sktrfn 2 years ago
Yuna executes Yuna Camel most beautifully.
That's why Yuna Camel should be called Yuna Camel.
goyunakimjr 2 years ago
However,this spin is not invent by Yuna Kim~~
yoyashi 2 years ago 19
you know nothing about figure skating.
goyunakimjr 2 years ago
Only Korean people call the easy spin "yuna camel". :-)
tripleaxel3a 2 years ago 30
those who know about figure skating well call the "easy spin" Yuna Camel.
we Koreans know about figure skating well.
you should become such a person, too.
goyunakimjr 2 years ago
i am interested in figure skating,i always serch different spins on the internet.If there is Yuna camel,would you mind to give me a website that introduce a spin call'Yuna camel'????Thanks
yoyashi 2 years ago 10
Actually, the best variations of the broken camel were executed by Caroline Zhang and Mao Asada. They were able to bring their arms behind their shoulders in a position similar to the one executed in a classical lauback. Very difficult variation and beautiful to look at. All the other skaters put their arms over the chest, to the side or in a 'Hamilton camel' position - it's easier to keep the balance this way.
Justine4FS 2 years ago 17
please search "yuna camel" on youtube.
the answer is there.
yunakim2010 2 years ago
omg....yuna camel?????
koreans are really rude.
do they understand figure skating?
.....poor DICK:(
chokennaitei 2 years ago 21
Comment removed
chokennaitei 2 years ago
good but yuna's is better
yunakim2010 2 years ago