MARIAH VS LEONA VS KELLY VS ALEXANDRA WITHOUT YOU WMV

[hihello121]

1. Leona

2. Mariah

3. Kelly

4. Alex

Mariah may be a better singer but this song isnt for her, read the lyrics, its about being alone and its meant to be a sad song, i dont get that feeling from her, i get it from leona

[DanScot19]

Leona Lewis. Always :)

[alexburkeisamazin]

mariah is the best ov all them but alexandra burke is the most talented and has a nicer voice than all of them....

[nfscarbonultra]

No one can beat the original. Mariah first, then Leona, then Kelly. Then Alex

[hezronfekitoa]

1. Mariah no one can take it from her

2. Leona lewis she is so close to mariah carey

3. Kelly khos she reaches tha notes sorry

alex buht yuur last dis isn't the song foahh yuuh !!!!

[Darrylyates09]

alexandra, mariah, leona then kelly, alexandra isd amazing and is much better then any of these other girls :D

[tburke644]

Oh and btw, can people stop saying Leona is a "poor duplicate" of Mariah, because I remember the days when crazy Whitney fans would hate on Mariah because they saw her as a threat! Well you dont need to pick on Leona because her and Mariah are 2 different vioces and in different generations!

Can we just appreciate that we have 2 fantasic female vocalists in 2 generations!

One for the older and another for the young!

People with their talent only comes once in a lifetime! And we have 2!!!!!!!!

[tburke644]

In my honest opinion:

1) Leona and Mariah. people need to remember that Leona had been struggling with tonsilitous (or whatever way you spell it just a week before that!!!

2) Kelly. Amazing voice, but I don think it was that was the right song for her.

3) Alex. Great voice, but vocally not as versatile as the others.

Although this song will ALWAYS be remembered as Mariah's.

[merlinsnape]

1.leona lewis the best ever (queen)

2.mariah carey realy good singer love you

3.kelly clarkson nice voice but somtimes of key

4. dont realy like your voice

[forteledemuzica]

Mariah was the best voice of the '90...

[superx57]

1. Mariah (It's just no contest)

2. Alexandra (The chord was extremely deep, and she still delivered)

3. Leona (Nice high notes, but she struggled too much to be like Mariah)

4. Kelly (The tempo was a little too fast for her)

[deonzax]

1. Mariah

2. Kelly

3. Leona

4. Alexandra

[texto2]

1. Mariah (though she couldn't do this with out miming it now)

2. Leona (she sounds the most comfortable and controlled)

3. Alex (low key does no favours for her but she is still an excellent singer)

4. Kelly (just awful, sounded flat na d off key on some parts and her voice even cracked at one point, just dreadful)

[jake27990]

also how come mariahs part was a recording yet leona and alex were live (not really fair)

[jake27990]

honestly

1. leona was best imo

2. mariah (coz its her song)

3. kelly

4. alex (her voice sounds so deep lol)

[Vampireprincess1100]

Wow, this is a tough one i love them all!

Leona's voice is amazing but when kelly came on i was like- who was singing before? seriously her voice is so powerful it blows my mind! i don't really like alexandra's version but i do love most her songs and as for mariah she hits some of the best notes i've ever heard but my favourite version is certainly kelly's.

[raphee13]

factual!

1 MARIAH- obviously perfect low and high register.. with signature 17 seconds of bridging..

2.KELLY-she made her own interpretation of the song.. with 9 seconds of bridging.. thick and strong voice with well defined vibrato in range!

-even simon cowell said that kelly's without you was the performance of the whole competition in season1 outstanding! -priceless

3. ALEX

4.LEONA- POOR MARIAH DUPLICATE

[LazeeLad2k8]

1. Alexandra - Most soulful, most powerful, the best. I love her !! :)

2. Mariah - Really good

3. Leona - Sweet but boring

4. Kelly - doesnt suit her

[jhbace]

1. Leona - Perfect, the better. Makes me fall out of line.

2. Mariah - So good, bt leona sings her song way better than her. Sorry Mariah.

3. Kelly - Bad song choice.

4. Alexandra - What have you done?

[trueslmanz]

1. obvo mariah wins

2. Alexandra lowers the key but seems to be more where leona and kelly starain.

3. leona has the most perfetct control

4 kelly is the most pure

apart from mariah they are all about equal!

[Mastertubeable]

kelly is not struggling, thats her style man! the alexander simply kills it.

[image66698]

1mariah its her song

2leona song suits her

3kelly seemed to struggle

4alex just killed it

[xlulubabeex]

I love em all buh this is wit i wud put em as : 1 mariah - its her song , it suits her voice perfectly . hugh pitched sweet voice . 2. leona . sweeet voice it sounds a bit dull that just because it wasnt a recorded song it was a live song she sang . 3. kelly .. didnt go rite shes into fast music. 4. alex .. shes got a deep voice.

[fazzee360]

You could have chosen a live performance from mariah, such as 1996 daydream tour.

[xxXnickwXxx]

1. Leona Lewis - without a doubt <3

2. Mariah Carey - great voice but leona is better in my opinion

3. Kelly - i didnt like this but its far better than alexandra's hahah

4. Alexandra - OMG. that was shit. i actually hope her career fails. if she becomes anywhere near close as popular as Leona then i will not be impressed. hate her.

[CarrieUnderwoodful]

1.Leona Lewis!Hands down!

2.Mariah Carey

3.Kelly Clarkson

4.Alexandra Burke she is a great singer but not this song.

[henr348]

1. Kelly (for her versatility)

2. Mariah (original version)

3. Leona

4. Alexandra

[Chillumpot]

mariah did it then...but can she now

she out of this competition for now, cuz thas the real song....she cant sing it live now

so i'd say

alexandra burke

leona

kelly

[jimmy642]

this is mariahs song, then leona then kelly and what is this Alex even doing there? heard better than that from several AI runners up

[raphee13]

1. mariah ovbious

2.kelly

coz she made her own interpretation and style with a massive vibrato.. which is well defined and fast

holding 10 seconds of belting with vibrato

3. alex coz her voice is thick and had strength

4. leona

copying mariah so badly!!

[xrebel4evrx]

Phh!!! Okay Mariah is prbbly no1!!! But com'n Alex be4 leona!!!! Doubt it!!! Leona at this moment in time is prbbly the best singer in the world!!!!!!! I dont think she is better than Mariah bcos when Mariah was younger she was untouchable but now Leona is betta!!! Btw Alex ixscompletely average

[raphee13]

leona can hold notes longer than alex.. and thats just it! alex can deliver it with more strenght and she pulled out the massive mariah carey comparisoon! leona is great..but her version is just mariah's poor duplicate!

and im so sorry tro tell you.. that leona is not the best singer in the planet right now! (charice pempengco, kelly clarkson, jennifer hudson,beyonce etc!)

[xrebel4evrx]

Ur a freak!!! Out of all the names u named out Leona is a better singer than all of them!! Believe me i no these things retard

[nwt1234]

oh for god sake they sound so much different she's not copying her she's got her own style i think mariah then leona then alex then kelly wasnt good at that song but but i think she's fantastic other times

[hello07601]

#1 - Obv Mariah

#2 - Leona

Kelly sings this awfully, and alexandra cant sing at all strictly average

[nwt1234]

i agree kelly sings shit here but normally great and alex has an ite voice but can't even compete with the rest.

[worldheiress]

i think alex is the odd one out here

[4h7dzufp]

no female singer can take this song frm mariah she owns it simple fact and come guys maraih has much more range in her voice than the others girls, u all knw it even the haters. MARAIH IS THE BEST FEMALE VOCALIST OUT OF THESE GIRLS

[008babyangel008]

she might be thebest but not in every

song..:) they alll brilliant...

in my opinion mariah,leona,kelly.alexandra burke