My dad was a total Archie fan. I was grading each performance of Cook & Archie either giving a thumbs up, down, middle. I thought Cook had done good on first, ok on second, while for my dad, Archie was hitting his zone. But when it came to this song, my dad turned to me and I held a thumbs up. He slowly smiled and nodded yes. I can't imagine him singing any other song that meant so much to him, and he sang it beautifully with feeling. Ha on Simon.
I think he cried beause he is sensitive and emotional... He knew he did an awesome job and I personally think he just felt overwhelmed. Love you David Cook.
wow.i diddnt expect archie (the corporate whore)to win! im surprised.....NOT. thanks media, unimportant people making important decisions. ruining the world & USA. un-american %$#holes!!!
Oh, yes! Randy was wrong. Cook is ten times better than little David. Little David can sing the songs the way they were written but do not have control of the songs. Cook has control of the song and can play with the songs.
He cried because I think the song made him think about his ailing brother, I think in my opinion, his version is the best I have ever heard, better than Collective Soul!
Looking back, i think this was one of his best performances on the show. Beautifully sung from his soul. What could be better than that? Simon was delusional.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
AHAHHAA why he cried, at that moment he knew the results, the fixed the show for him, why did he cry ???...Archuleta is better than him, the real winner was Archuleta, Fox and Producers did not care about people thought that night...
No, it was NOT fixed. Just because you didn't get the result you wanted doesn't mean it was fixed. If you don't like David Cook, don't watch his videos at all. But certainly don't watch and post bullsh*t like this. You won't find me posting negative garbage on Archie's videos. Cook and Archuleta are both good singers, but with different styles. I happen to prefer Cook who is also an excellent entertainer.
he probably cried cuz he was so happy and im sure cuz it was so overwhelming at the same time! i mean, he gave it his all and it totally paid off! david cook totally deserved his win! and as far as u saying archie is better than cook: just cuz u say archie is better, (its only based on ur opinion)doesnt make him better! they are both good singers and i think them getting as far as they got makes them both winners! if u have nothing nice to say, plz dont say it. stop with the hating ok!
David Cook is the best..America did the right thing...He totally rocks...He is so talented and amazing,so where are you Simon?David is a platinum awardee,selling more than million copies,he is so successful already,topping the charts....American Idol can't have this kind of man again....AI should be proud of him...
my personal opinion is that david archuleta was better in this final, david didn't bring this timw the woow in me, but that he sings good is 100% right! better than david archuleta? 50%
haha..I have one question for you? haha do you sing? are u studying music? let me quess nope?! haha I get it that ur his fan. I get that. But be realistic, Hey he's a wonderful singer, sings really good. But I don't think better than Archuleta. And hey it was a personal opinion, so u don't have to think or have the same opinion as I do! I respect urs, so can u respect mine? Thanks
you probably shouldnt guess at stuff , because i do sing , and i am studying music at my school , so dont you feel like an idiot ? David archuleta isnt that good of a singer , he can sing , but isnt that good . the only reason he got as far as he did on american idol is because of that vocal paralisis shit he had going .
i respect your opinion . but i will state my opinion .
wel it doesn't seem like it, but anyway we are arguiing here over someone that doesn't even care,, so yeah! and just for your info, I'm Going to a musical school, and I have a diploma as a singer! so I know what I'm talking about! but anyhow....have a nice day!
THAT, people is how it should be done... beautiful, soulful, emotional. *sigh* Perfect finale. There will never be another moment like this... *nods* Well.... except maybe for his performance in today's finale...
Since he announced he was a homosexual and would strickly be dating males, Kim Caldwell has been very supportive and a good friend to David Cook. She has even been to a baseball game with David Cook and a boyfriend that one of them was dating.
She is so classy and Hott and smart. She will be famous for her whole life because she has SO many talents. Cook? He will struggle to be as famous as Rueben Stoddard though he is more of a Glay Aiken.
aww he cried,i feel like hugging him so bad.cook's so nice that when people started cheering on 'why do something i've already done'he immediately said he understood simon.plus i love the performance
i smiled right at the same time he did on 3:25 YAHOO!
Nicely said Izzy18. I am a major fan of david cook and think he is an amazing talent but i also think that david archuleta is an amazing talent, it all comes down to what music style you prefer, i don't take a liking to ballads and i love rock and pop so i personally like cook, but archuleta has a wonderful voice considering his age. They're both very humble and genuine people and give credit where credit is due, so if they can get along, why can't their fans?
He is sooo dang gifted! Saw Collective Soul last year and am sure they were proud of David's version. Can't wait till his CD comes out. David Cook....definetly an American Idol!
Cook is a good singer... but we can't deny that Archie is cuter and sweeter! hehehe:D both have the energy and sing very very well... Felicitaciones a ambos!
HERE HERE! I don't know why reporters are calling it an American Idol Upset! Look at how selfless David Cook is? It's like the moment was for everyone, he is the true epitome of a winner! I love him!
Im sooo happy David Cook won!he's not arrogant if u pay attention to what he's been showing about himself.He's just has this style which makes ppl sing to his tune. look at what he did with "always be my baby".Its wonderful.i really cant wait for David C's album to come out.I think he'll be one of the best idols ever alongside kelly clarkson.But I dont deny that both were really fantastic, n i really applaud both of them cos its takes alot out of them 2 pull it off for finale.
Archie may have won the night for the judges, but COOK WON THE ENTIRE TOURNAMENT!! COOK OUTPERFORMED Archie many times during the tournament. I can listen to an Archie song halfway. But I can listen to COOK songs again and again! VOTE VOTE VOTE
yeah he was still pretty good without doing that. it was kinda weird to see him go from crying to being arrogant and negative like that. i think i would almost prefer archie's overdone humility to that ugly display..
Archie may have won the night for the judges, but COOK WON THE ENTIRE TOURNAMENT!! I can listen to an Archie song halfway. But I can listen to COOK songs again and again! VOTE VOTE VOTE
My dad was a total Archie fan. I was grading each performance of Cook & Archie either giving a thumbs up, down, middle. I thought Cook had done good on first, ok on second, while for my dad, Archie was hitting his zone. But when it came to this song, my dad turned to me and I held a thumbs up. He slowly smiled and nodded yes. I can't imagine him singing any other song that meant so much to him, and he sang it beautifully with feeling. Ha on Simon.
artisallthat 8 months ago 3
Don't you love the look on Simon's face when Cook put's him in his place with that statement..lol
zz878 8 months ago
I remember this song on late nights...
svnele77 8 months ago
I think he cried beause he is sensitive and emotional... He knew he did an awesome job and I personally think he just felt overwhelmed. Love you David Cook.
janimarie 9 months ago
why waz he crying at the end of the song??
Whee0707 11 months ago
wow.i diddnt expect archie (the corporate whore)to win! im surprised.....NOT. thanks media, unimportant people making important decisions. ruining the world & USA. un-american %$#holes!!!
gnfrf80 11 months ago
I love David Cook but I love David Archuleta more.
eyeshunter99 1 year ago
Oh, yes! Randy was wrong. Cook is ten times better than little David. Little David can sing the songs the way they were written but do not have control of the songs. Cook has control of the song and can play with the songs.
manpokyang 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
allbe413 1 year ago
I still cry and and get full body goosebumps by this performance two years later! My faborite Idol moment
CookieLove1983 1 year ago
david cook was the man of the year<3 and i cant wait for his next album to come out becuase he is what we call a true performer<3love you david.
legoclonefreak1231 1 year ago 3
He cried because I think the song made him think about his ailing brother, I think in my opinion, his version is the best I have ever heard, better than Collective Soul!
36cfalse 1 year ago
Looking back, i think this was one of his best performances on the show. Beautifully sung from his soul. What could be better than that? Simon was delusional.
sweetmama231 2 years ago 4
david Cook is the best!!!
grungy91 2 years ago
oh dont cry u cutie pie
cookhasmyheart 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
AHAHHAA why he cried, at that moment he knew the results, the fixed the show for him, why did he cry ???...Archuleta is better than him, the real winner was Archuleta, Fox and Producers did not care about people thought that night...
wiljavi 2 years ago
No, it was NOT fixed. Just because you didn't get the result you wanted doesn't mean it was fixed. If you don't like David Cook, don't watch his videos at all. But certainly don't watch and post bullsh*t like this. You won't find me posting negative garbage on Archie's videos. Cook and Archuleta are both good singers, but with different styles. I happen to prefer Cook who is also an excellent entertainer.
need4dc 2 years ago
he probably cried cuz he was so happy and im sure cuz it was so overwhelming at the same time! i mean, he gave it his all and it totally paid off! david cook totally deserved his win! and as far as u saying archie is better than cook: just cuz u say archie is better, (its only based on ur opinion)doesnt make him better! they are both good singers and i think them getting as far as they got makes them both winners! if u have nothing nice to say, plz dont say it. stop with the hating ok!
davidcooksweety 2 years ago
People love David Archuleta because no and days all the poeple watching american idol are about 17 and think hes cute.
I'm not really a fan of archuleta. I mena hes ok and cute but I like david cook more
lionsfromnantucket 2 years ago 2
I am sooooooooooo glad he's "permanent"!!!!!!!!
nabel110 2 years ago
nothing's new..whatever
archie25david 2 years ago
David Cook is the best..America did the right thing...He totally rocks...He is so talented and amazing,so where are you Simon?David is a platinum awardee,selling more than million copies,he is so successful already,topping the charts....American Idol can't have this kind of man again....AI should be proud of him...
biancacookhook 2 years ago 2
he's real.
theboldthing 2 years ago 2
I Love This Song :]
And I Slightly Feel Bad, Cause i Laughed When He Cried .
I Have no soul .
GabiGalaxy 2 years ago
thats horrible...
cletiger10 2 years ago
i Realize .
GabiGalaxy 2 years ago
@GabiGalaxy Don't worry. I did the same thing.
lala069 1 year ago
my personal opinion is that david archuleta was better in this final, david didn't bring this timw the woow in me, but that he sings good is 100% right! better than david archuleta? 50%
gianny93 2 years ago
David Archuleta Has no talent Darling . Sorry . His voice Cracks Constantly , And He Just Sounds horrible .
Sorry To Break It To you .
GabiGalaxy 2 years ago
haha..I have one question for you? haha do you sing? are u studying music? let me quess nope?! haha I get it that ur his fan. I get that. But be realistic, Hey he's a wonderful singer, sings really good. But I don't think better than Archuleta. And hey it was a personal opinion, so u don't have to think or have the same opinion as I do! I respect urs, so can u respect mine? Thanks
gianny93 2 years ago
you probably shouldnt guess at stuff , because i do sing , and i am studying music at my school , so dont you feel like an idiot ? David archuleta isnt that good of a singer , he can sing , but isnt that good . the only reason he got as far as he did on american idol is because of that vocal paralisis shit he had going .
i respect your opinion . but i will state my opinion .
GabiGalaxy 2 years ago
lol or the millions of young girls with phones who voted for him
THEY LOVE TO TEXT! lol
o0Dmiz0o 2 years ago
wel it doesn't seem like it, but anyway we are arguiing here over someone that doesn't even care,, so yeah! and just for your info, I'm Going to a musical school, and I have a diploma as a singer! so I know what I'm talking about! but anyhow....have a nice day!
gianny93 2 years ago
so good
CvTakahashi 2 years ago
Simply put... a beautiful man with a beautiful voice. I don't think anyone on
AI, ever again, will compare to DC.
lori7521 2 years ago 2
David will always be the best Idol ever picked.. no one can compare to his voice and his emotion towards songs.. best Idol yet.
sYdThEkYd40 2 years ago
I so love that performance. Watching it a year later... love it just as much... it was gorgeous.
tierbee 2 years ago 2
This performance still gives me chills. There will never be another Idol to equal David Cook.
lesliejay09 2 years ago 3
only because the votes are being fixed now, Adam should have won...then he could have came very very close to Cook, as best Idol ever!
americanidolz2009 2 years ago
THAT, people is how it should be done... beautiful, soulful, emotional. *sigh* Perfect finale. There will never be another moment like this... *nods* Well.... except maybe for his performance in today's finale...
Dementor145 2 years ago 4
This will never be equalled on a final show.
gano8 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He diddnt win, because he wasnt a media, corporate whore..
gnfrf80 2 years ago
Simon really had to eat his words the next night. Talk about pimping Archuleta endlessly. Lordy. Cook was better.
kcmet79 2 years ago 19
love love love it....and it is so sweet that he chokes up at the end...awe man!
underwoodmusic01 3 years ago 3
shut up simon. I agree with david. LOVE LOVE LOVE this song :)
2xcrzkxk 3 years ago 5
Redredbedhed correction, there are actually two of them waiving their hands. You didn't count the one sitting.
kentttj 3 years ago
he's way better than archie
edoralive 3 years ago 27
most of the time i agree with what Simon says but not here. lol "Simon Says"
Ssjtrunks2000 3 years ago 4
haha, "Simom Says"
he wasn't right though. i thought david cook rocked!!!!!!
bathy22 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Since he announced he was a homosexual and would strickly be dating males, Kim Caldwell has been very supportive and a good friend to David Cook. She has even been to a baseball game with David Cook and a boyfriend that one of them was dating.
She is so classy and Hott and smart. She will be famous for her whole life because she has SO many talents. Cook? He will struggle to be as famous as Rueben Stoddard though he is more of a Glay Aiken.
Anus2Mouth 3 years ago
Has he really announced he is the homosexuality?
shebenson 3 years ago
He is THE homosexuality, indeed, and it is okay for men to love manessity.
Anus2Mouth 3 years ago
where did you know that? i still love him
shebenson 3 years ago
Chicago. Good you love him that.
Anus2Mouth 3 years ago
aww he cried,i feel like hugging him so bad.cook's so nice that when people started cheering on 'why do something i've already done'he immediately said he understood simon.plus i love the performance
i smiled right at the same time he did on 3:25 YAHOO!
xrainisfallingx 3 years ago 3
is it fall yet!? gaahhh! cant wait for the album!
ganga316 3 years ago 3
policeofife if its so gay than why are u watching it? okay if u dont like david cook or american idol than why are u watching this?
david cook's amazing. i love him so much
PeytonManningChick02 3 years ago
Nicely said Izzy18. I am a major fan of david cook and think he is an amazing talent but i also think that david archuleta is an amazing talent, it all comes down to what music style you prefer, i don't take a liking to ballads and i love rock and pop so i personally like cook, but archuleta has a wonderful voice considering his age. They're both very humble and genuine people and give credit where credit is due, so if they can get along, why can't their fans?
lisa20tony 3 years ago
He is sooo dang gifted! Saw Collective Soul last year and am sure they were proud of David's version. Can't wait till his CD comes out. David Cook....definetly an American Idol!
packersfan44 3 years ago 2
what girl?
sasuke911fox 3 years ago
the one waving her arms all alone lol
redhedbedhed 3 years ago 4
DC knows his voice. DA is still finding his, but a great singer.
Robert1sLadySaggie 3 years ago 2
0:32 the girl at the bottom
LONER
halfaheart18 3 years ago 4
Cook is a good singer... but we can't deny that Archie is cuter and sweeter! hehehe:D both have the energy and sing very very well... Felicitaciones a ambos!
AnitaMNG1985 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
american idol is so gay...
policeoflife 3 years ago
Its not gay, its amazing. david cook is amazing
if it's gay why do you watch american idol clips on youtube?
garthfaemyspace 3 years ago 5
okay, why don't you all shut up
because if you were real fans to archie or cookie, you wouldn't be bashing each other.
both of them are amazing people
and both of them did amazing. so SHUT UP!
Izzy18 3 years ago 7
HERE HERE! I don't know why reporters are calling it an American Idol Upset! Look at how selfless David Cook is? It's like the moment was for everyone, he is the true epitome of a winner! I love him!
jcanangel 3 years ago 6
Im sooo happy David Cook won!he's not arrogant if u pay attention to what he's been showing about himself.He's just has this style which makes ppl sing to his tune. look at what he did with "always be my baby".Its wonderful.i really cant wait for David C's album to come out.I think he'll be one of the best idols ever alongside kelly clarkson.But I dont deny that both were really fantastic, n i really applaud both of them cos its takes alot out of them 2 pull it off for finale.
ROCK ON!
hushaF 3 years ago 7
Guess you heard wrong. COOK IS THE WINNER !!!
bonk65 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david cook is horrible and never vote for him archuleta is winning i heard
nickrielly 3 years ago
U idiot all the grpahs and dial idol says cook won. wat r u on crack?
mrkayyx 3 years ago 2
cook is winning archy sucks
HannahNeilly08 3 years ago 3
he turn away because he is very shy..
I do that when facing with the compliments.
avatarng 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cooks arrogant. he looked away when simon was commenting on him. unlike Archuleta.. who was "thank you"-ing everything the judges said.
Arrogant vs Humble?
zulaikharozman 3 years ago
that was a cheap shot though. he already knew from rehearsals what songs archie would do.
kguapisimo 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Archie may have won the night for the judges, but COOK WON THE ENTIRE TOURNAMENT!! COOK OUTPERFORMED Archie many times during the tournament. I can listen to an Archie song halfway. But I can listen to COOK songs again and again! VOTE VOTE VOTE
866-436-5701
866-436-5703
866-436-5705
TEXT "VOTE" - AT&T ONLY - to 5701
XsupermanFBI 3 years ago
I will watch david A on Disney channel but I will buy David's Cook album no matter what. He is a winner already!
lsprime 3 years ago 4
Jz like Taylor Hicks against Daughtry..
ronaldtsc 3 years ago
"why do something i've already done", when he said that it seemed like a poke at Archuleta...but I could be wrong. He should have held his tongue
uchoob00 3 years ago 4
yeah he was still pretty good without doing that. it was kinda weird to see him go from crying to being arrogant and negative like that. i think i would almost prefer archie's overdone humility to that ugly display..
kguapisimo 3 years ago
Round 1 goes to Archie, round 2 goes two Archie...David Cook sings "The world I know". And then this happened...
Simon: "You should have sung 'Billie Jean' or 'Hello'"
David Cook: "Why do something i've already done?". 2 min later, David Archuleta sings "Imagine".
And that's when David Cook won American Idol.
dp2882 3 years ago 8
pretty good
uchoob00 3 years ago
Yeah, Archuleta was really good 2nite but Cook outperformed him many times... VOTE FOR COOK
you2b2cme 3 years ago
Archie may have won the night for the judges, but COOK WON THE ENTIRE TOURNAMENT!! I can listen to an Archie song halfway. But I can listen to COOK songs again and again! VOTE VOTE VOTE
XsupermanFBI 3 years ago
ARCHE FOR LIFE!!!!!!!!!
standardwhiz 3 years ago 2
I love this song and want it! Cook is by far more marketable than David A and will have a contract no matter who wins. Love him!
samshepperd 3 years ago 2
Archie may have won the night, but COOK WON THE ENTIRE TOURNAMENT!! VOTE VOTE VOTE
XsupermanFBI 3 years ago 4