@grasshopper7776 Lauren, and Haley are BOTH good, IMO I like Haley's music style better, but that's just me, and she isn't over-confident, she just knows she's good, and she knows where she stands, and that's good, you shouldn't look down on yourself, or think you are better than you really are...
@HaleyReinhartCentral That's what they did; I had it posted on Facebook ,now I can't see it because of copyright BS ... They are trying everything to stop this girl.Haley Reinhart Best Idol Ever !!
SCOTTY KEEPS SAYING HE IS A QUARTER PORTORICAN. LOL AS IF THAT WOULD MATTER..JLO IS PORTORICAN , BUT IS THE AUDIENCE THAT ELECTS AND VOTES..GET OVER IT SCOTTY, YOU ARE MORE PORTORICAN THAT PRESIDENT OBAMA IS CHINESE..LOL..HALEY, AND JAMES, ON THE FINAL..LAUREN IS A CRY BABY AND THE JUDGES WERE AFRAID TO TELL HER HOW BAD SHE SANG UNCHAINED MELODY..DISGUSTING..SHE TAKES ADVANTAGE OF HER TEARS TO GET TO THE AUDIENCE AND THE JUDGES..IS ALL FAKE..TIME TO GO HOME LAUREN..CRY ALL YOU WANT, AND GO HOME
Haley is fighting, she is giving her all! I love Lauren Alaina but I'm disappointed in how she sung Unchained Melody, she didn't give 100% & she was timid. Scotty is one of my favorites too but he isn't giving more of himself. I think if I were to buy his cd or go to a concert it would be the same old thing over & over again...James is ok but he always ruins a song, like he did with MUSE. Everyone who liked that clearly don't even know what MUSE is. Well to me it's all about Haley, true talent!
HAILEY FANS THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT TIME OF THE WHOLE SEASON WE NEED TO VOTE FOR HAILEY NEXT WEEK TO GET HER IN TO THE TOP 3 IF WE DONT SHE WILL GO HOME WE NEED A MAIRACLE AND WE NEED TO VOTE ALL THE WAY AND POWER VOTE WE NEED TO STICK 2GETHER AS TEAM HAILEY AND BE THERE FOR HER SHE DESERVES TO WIN THIS YEAR BUT SHE CANT WITH OUT US FANS WE LOVE YOU HAILEY AND I WILL VOTE MY HEART OUT FOR YOU NEXT WEEK
Hey people if you want HALEY to win all you gotta do is vote. Don't come her and like a video, comment saying how wonderful she is and have the nerve to go to bed and NOT vote. That is just wrong. If you like her don't think for a sec that she is SAFE because NEWSFLASH AMERICA you gotta vote each & every week to see your favorite WIN. So PLEASE vote for Haley for the win, not once, not twice...vote until you die. Lol (joke) Haley is giving her all, she is fighting for the win so VOTE UP!!!!! :D
I can't say anything else about her sultry and sexy voice that hasn't already been said; it is remarkable. Every note is a statement. I am surprised there aren't more comments here on her stage presence. This girl can work it. Even subtle moves...like when she sings "My father was a gambling man" and she does this sexy dice rolling move...are just incredible. I've never watched an Idol video over and over...other than Lambert's Mad World...and I just don't find him sexy to boot!!!!
@mikemarkize YES, SHE IS AMAZING..THE BEST ON AMERICAN IDOL, AND THEY ALWASYS CRITIZISE HER..JIMMY WAS MAD ABOUT JLO'S COMMENTS AND ON THURS I LOVED THE WAY HE CAME ON HALEY'S DEFENSE..WAY TO GO JIMMY..HE SAID IT..HALEY IS LOCKED ON THE FINALS...I SAY IS HALEY AND JAMES..
I have heard that song performed by lots of professional singers.Haley Reinhart that was absolutely the best EVER , cant wait to here more WOW WOW WOW keep it up.
okee 1 hour ago the 21th century mariah... she just AAMMMAAAZZZZIIIINGGGG
haley for idol, i vote 89 times for this week
oh my goodness. 89 TIMES? how many hours do these kids waste on the phone. HA! She's good, and the best left, but she wasn't that amazing, but certainly was about the only reason to even LISTEN to Idol this week. There's just little talent left on this show. The other singers are very flawed, she's not and should win.
she did this nicely. I don't really see any of these remaining 4 being very big at all however. I have yet to be wrong after all these seasons of Idol. The last big hit winner was Underwood. There have been only 2 non-winners the past few years who have done well, of course DAUGHTRY, and to some extent, the amazing Adam. The rest of the winners and top 10 singers have only had minor success, and there's nothing about these singers that's going to change that, this season.
she is absolutely AMAZING! i haven't heard a female sing like this since janis joplin. her voice is so seductive, unique, powerful & beautiful. i love that her voice is so raw & raspy; not all prissy like all the current female singers. my jaw literally dropped after this performance. i can't express how amazing i think she is. =) GO HALEY!
She was totally amazing in both of her songs and she has improved the most among the remaining four... Haley's future victory must also be assured. How? Remind Casey and Adam fans to vote for her. Casey and Adam love her!!!
The most amazing performance I have seen on this show!! The sheer artistry in every note of this is amazing! Thank you so much to all that voted and voted to keep Haley in this competition and allowed us to experience this moment of beauty!
Hey, I’m a young artist, and I would really appreciate it if everyone would check out my original compositions “My Bluest Sky” and “Será.” “My Bluest Sky” sounds a bit like a cross between “Irreplaceable” by Beyoncé, “Water Runs Dry” by Boyz II Men, and “Tell Him” by Lauryn Hill. And “Será” is, of course, a Latin number that is very high energy, hot-blooded, and extremely unforgettable. Thanks!
Last night this girl won american idol. After being told her 1st song basically sucked, Hayley came out and slammed this song and brought everyone to their feet. Way to go .. !
While this is the best version of this soung I have ever heard and I will buy it if she records it this is the only solo of her I like. I also liked one of the duets she did with Casey. She has no humility and I don't think she has a humble bone in her body. Guess I could be wrong. She has a fantastic range and could be a great vocalist but she needs to right songs!!! This is one of them!!!!!!!
Let's put it this way folks: Who would you pay money to see live in concert? For me its this girl. Great unique voice, nice looking, and very entertaining.
im glad she got to sing a 2nd song cuz she needed to redeem herself BAD.. and her doin this is FANTASTIC... but she still has that chance to go home like rest do.. cuz of her first song was just horrible i agreed with the judges on the gaga song.. but i loved how she did this song awesome... good choice girl
I agree with the comment that she's too good for this competition, the four best performances of the series and still she struggles to stay in from week to week. The only thing missing from this was Alan Price on the organ, the two of them together, out of this world
@pizzacurse You a dumbass!!! I am by nooooo means comparing Haley with Fantasia....I said they both had memorable moments on idol. Read it well before you open your dumbass MOUTH!!!!
when i first saw her in the auditions she became my favorite. and some how for a while either by song choice or delivery she did not express herself well,,but now for the past few weeks she has displayed what a talent she is. i think casey rubbed off a little of his jazz style to hers but either way. i think she is crazy great...
Haley is probably one of the best young singers in America. Great and unique voice, great creativity : in performances and outfits, great confidence and motivation. Each of her songs is memorable and could be recorded and made into music-videos.
In my opinion she is the best singer and artist in this competition. In one word: WOW!!!
the first "forever moment" i have seen on Idol.....(not that the talent isn't incredible by the top 12) BUT>>> clean up the recording and put it on the radio>>> N O W.
@PaulMcdonaldFan You've left several negative comments here. Going on other idols performance videos and bashing to make James better isn't working here...sorry kid
@PaulMcdonaldFan ok ok, then go to james videos and say that, and by the way just a suggestion to let u know that commenting things to drag ppl down doesn't make paul mcdonald come back but make u look pathetic here, so sorry darling!!! Go grab some tissues cuz u may wanna cry
@smokyMcnasty I agree, stage presence and personality all are contributing factors. Sadly, Jacob kicked ass at the beginning and then started spiraling downward. Hailey started downward and is spiraling upward. Props to her improvement - (I just wish she would stop stomping her legs like that - so "80's dance"). Go Team James :)
@sordidfate My bad, that goes to show I didn't care much about her pre-performance story. She was ok, but frankly there's 3 others she should watch out for (I'm not counting Jacob...sorry my brotha from anotha motha). :p
Haley owns that damn stage. Like no other in this competition. Everyone else except for James are nothing more than cover singers. They have no stage presence at all. Haley is a star in the making.. The different variations of her voice and how effortlessly she switches between them.... amazing. Sweet and gritty at the same time.. And the way she struts around that stage.. with that signature growl.. maaaan.. it is just... soooo... damn... sexy....
Judges got it right on her 1st performance. Stupid idea to perform a song that hasn't been released. Total disrespect to Gaga. And this performance reminded me of Siobhan Magnus sending this song to the heavens. Oh well. James, Lauren, and Scotty top 3...IMHO.
i actually liked her first performance better, but i thought she nailed both of them, i dont know why the judges didint like her first performance but this one was extremely good.
at one point I was kinda sorta ready to accept it if she just made it into the Top 6, then I thought at least Top 4, but as of now now I'm thinking Top 3 and I'll only be truly satisfied if she wins
Having said that, I could only accept James beating her and even then reluctantly so !
@agata804 hahah, I'd be satisfied with your choices just so long as Haley gets second place so we can get more of her. I really do think Haley should win, but maybe cannot based on votes unless she keeps up her "strategy" It's always been apparent to me that she has more up her sleeve so more shock and awe is possible =)
I like James and I liked Scotty in the beginning, but I just don't see that they have as much potential and room for growth as Haley . Lauren has more potential. Just saying.
I love Haley, and I Think Haley and Scotty will fight for winner. They are both fighters, but. Scotty has a better voice, range and he is more talented.
Scotty has an OKAY country voice, that's it. More talented and range than Haley?? you must be out of your mind.. she blows him away in every single aspect of singing.
@doct3rj Scotty has an OKAY country voice, that's it. More talented and range than Haley?? you must be out of your mind.. she blows him away in every single aspect of singing.
Ha! none of the remaining singers is as impressive as this lady. she is fortunate to have gotten rid of Jacob. When on, as he often was (not this week!), he was amazing, but this is hers to lose/win! The rest are average karaoke singers. No shame in that at all, but for Top 4 on Idol? OUCH.
@PaulMcdonaldFan Nooo Haley should win x) Since when's the last time a girl won American Idol? But even if James won, I would still be happy because he has extraordinary talent too.
@PaulMcdonaldFan When it comes down to it, in my opinion, they both deserve to win. Scotty, Lauren, and Jacob are all good but Haley and James are winners to me. In this point of the competition it's really hard to see any of them go home because not everyone is ever satisfied with the results. I respect all opinions, but I'm still rooting for Haley to win, and if it's not Haley, then James, MAYBE James... anything is possible, nevertheless.
@TheFluffinator22 agree with 2 of the 3, scotty is a good country singer but he's not for this show, he needs to be able to not make every song he sings country related.
James #1 Haley #2 Love them both and whoever ends up winning doesn't matter as they are both going far in the music business. They are leaps and bounds above Scotty who will have a good career in country (just not my thing) but the other two will be all but forgotten in a year or two.
MERCY! My WORD! Get it, girl! THAT is called SANGIN' where I came from. This is so killer over-the-top she puts MANY of the most famous music elite to SHAME here! I am enthralled! More! More! More!
Wow im not surprised this got so many view so fast when i heard this live this gave me the chills all the way down my spine.. her Acapella part was AMAZING in the begging this sound quality doesnt really do it justice but people who saw it live know...i been all about James Casey and Scotty especially James but when she song this i realized her pure vocals outshine ANYBODY on here and many celebrity singers BY FAR her voice is Majestic.. its was so amazing to hear her sing... L1oVe....
don't get too comfortable and not vote for her because you think a lot of people will. Trust me, Scotty has girls voting for him like CRAZY.... keep up the votes guys!
@ mma665.. I have agreed all the way before but after tonight's performances... OMG.. this girl hasa great unique voice...Janis Jopliny, Joss Stonish and those blues in her soul. Go get them Haley!!
what a contrast to lady gaga and katy perry stuff going on in pop music right now. she can really bring back rock n' roll. she can have no make up on, bare feet , no false eyelashes and bring out emotion - just like rock n' roll is suppose do. Haley if you read this, don't do the whole pop thing, dont do what adam lambert did, b bare and raw, you can be bigger than the grunge movement of the 90s. ppl are hungry for this stuff, mumford & sons are proving it.
originally I thought that maybe this was a bad song choice for her....but omg when she started it acapella it was freakin amazing from the get go..!! loved it!!!
She has been my girl from the beginning. She is the best! She has the potential to be the biggest star AI has ever produced. She is on the level of Whitney, Mariah and Celine. Thank God for Haley!
I have watched every season of idol, and this ranks up there with one of the very best performances on the show
CuppaVaccine 9 months ago
Haley vs James.
Asianzilla 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2011 AMERICAN IDOL
natuza 9 months ago
i LOVE laUREN.... HOPE SHE GOES FAR!! HALEY IS WAY WAY TO CONFIDENT
grasshopper7776 9 months ago
@grasshopper7776 Lauren, and Haley are BOTH good, IMO I like Haley's music style better, but that's just me, and she isn't over-confident, she just knows she's good, and she knows where she stands, and that's good, you shouldn't look down on yourself, or think you are better than you really are...
pokemongurl93 9 months ago
Fantastic. My goal is 200 votes by phone next week. She is my American Idol.
MrChicoLos 9 months ago
What happened to that other video over 200,000 views? I guess Lauren fans got jealous and flagged the video for copyright.
HaleyReinhartCentral 9 months ago 4
@HaleyReinhartCentral That's what they did; I had it posted on Facebook ,now I can't see it because of copyright BS ... They are trying everything to stop this girl.Haley Reinhart Best Idol Ever !!
perryhodgins 9 months ago
SCOTTY KEEPS SAYING HE IS A QUARTER PORTORICAN. LOL AS IF THAT WOULD MATTER..JLO IS PORTORICAN , BUT IS THE AUDIENCE THAT ELECTS AND VOTES..GET OVER IT SCOTTY, YOU ARE MORE PORTORICAN THAT PRESIDENT OBAMA IS CHINESE..LOL..HALEY, AND JAMES, ON THE FINAL..LAUREN IS A CRY BABY AND THE JUDGES WERE AFRAID TO TELL HER HOW BAD SHE SANG UNCHAINED MELODY..DISGUSTING..SHE TAKES ADVANTAGE OF HER TEARS TO GET TO THE AUDIENCE AND THE JUDGES..IS ALL FAKE..TIME TO GO HOME LAUREN..CRY ALL YOU WANT, AND GO HOME
HerecomesLori 9 months ago
Haley all the way!
lisa3754 9 months ago 2
It's amazing what Chicago has given us here..................
The talented bluesy soulful jazz singer known as HALEY REINHART!
Vote Haley
sfaster 9 months ago 6
Haley is fighting, she is giving her all! I love Lauren Alaina but I'm disappointed in how she sung Unchained Melody, she didn't give 100% & she was timid. Scotty is one of my favorites too but he isn't giving more of himself. I think if I were to buy his cd or go to a concert it would be the same old thing over & over again...James is ok but he always ruins a song, like he did with MUSE. Everyone who liked that clearly don't even know what MUSE is. Well to me it's all about Haley, true talent!
nomie321 9 months ago 4
SHE WAS AWESOME BUT SCOTTY IS BETTER HE IS FROM RALEIGH NORTH CAROLINA JUST LIKE ME =D
MHlovesorigami1 9 months ago
Haley rocks!! Woohoo!! She needs to win it America!!
MsKts10 9 months ago
HAILEY FANS THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT TIME OF THE WHOLE SEASON WE NEED TO VOTE FOR HAILEY NEXT WEEK TO GET HER IN TO THE TOP 3 IF WE DONT SHE WILL GO HOME WE NEED A MAIRACLE AND WE NEED TO VOTE ALL THE WAY AND POWER VOTE WE NEED TO STICK 2GETHER AS TEAM HAILEY AND BE THERE FOR HER SHE DESERVES TO WIN THIS YEAR BUT SHE CANT WITH OUT US FANS WE LOVE YOU HAILEY AND I WILL VOTE MY HEART OUT FOR YOU NEXT WEEK
3711JESUS 9 months ago 4
Go Haley!! AWESOME
buckystate 9 months ago
Hey people if you want HALEY to win all you gotta do is vote. Don't come her and like a video, comment saying how wonderful she is and have the nerve to go to bed and NOT vote. That is just wrong. If you like her don't think for a sec that she is SAFE because NEWSFLASH AMERICA you gotta vote each & every week to see your favorite WIN. So PLEASE vote for Haley for the win, not once, not twice...vote until you die. Lol (joke) Haley is giving her all, she is fighting for the win so VOTE UP!!!!! :D
nomie321 9 months ago 3
James/Haley toss up. Love them both.
Scotty has a great country voice but that's it, he belongs on a country show, he never changes his genre'.
Mgarguemare 9 months ago
I can't say anything else about her sultry and sexy voice that hasn't already been said; it is remarkable. Every note is a statement. I am surprised there aren't more comments here on her stage presence. This girl can work it. Even subtle moves...like when she sings "My father was a gambling man" and she does this sexy dice rolling move...are just incredible. I've never watched an Idol video over and over...other than Lambert's Mad World...and I just don't find him sexy to boot!!!!
mikemarkize 9 months ago 5
@mikemarkize YES, SHE IS AMAZING..THE BEST ON AMERICAN IDOL, AND THEY ALWASYS CRITIZISE HER..JIMMY WAS MAD ABOUT JLO'S COMMENTS AND ON THURS I LOVED THE WAY HE CAME ON HALEY'S DEFENSE..WAY TO GO JIMMY..HE SAID IT..HALEY IS LOCKED ON THE FINALS...I SAY IS HALEY AND JAMES..
HerecomesLori 9 months ago
Yeah, GO GO GO HALEY FIERCE!
DizzyPuke 9 months ago
I have heard that song performed by lots of professional singers.Haley Reinhart that was absolutely the best EVER , cant wait to here more WOW WOW WOW keep it up.
jwa43 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
okee 1 hour ago the 21th century mariah... she just AAMMMAAAZZZZIIIINGGGG
haley for idol, i vote 89 times for this week
oh my goodness. 89 TIMES? how many hours do these kids waste on the phone. HA! She's good, and the best left, but she wasn't that amazing, but certainly was about the only reason to even LISTEN to Idol this week. There's just little talent left on this show. The other singers are very flawed, she's not and should win.
papabear777 9 months ago
she did this nicely. I don't really see any of these remaining 4 being very big at all however. I have yet to be wrong after all these seasons of Idol. The last big hit winner was Underwood. There have been only 2 non-winners the past few years who have done well, of course DAUGHTRY, and to some extent, the amazing Adam. The rest of the winners and top 10 singers have only had minor success, and there's nothing about these singers that's going to change that, this season.
JusticeForTheDead 9 months ago 5
i wanna marry her already!!!!
ray1234532 9 months ago
she is absolutely AMAZING! i haven't heard a female sing like this since janis joplin. her voice is so seductive, unique, powerful & beautiful. i love that her voice is so raw & raspy; not all prissy like all the current female singers. my jaw literally dropped after this performance. i can't express how amazing i think she is. =) GO HALEY!
steelers0514 9 months ago 4
She was totally amazing in both of her songs and she has improved the most among the remaining four... Haley's future victory must also be assured. How? Remind Casey and Adam fans to vote for her. Casey and Adam love her!!!
36KH 9 months ago
the 21th century mariah...
she just AAMMMAAAZZZZIIIINGGGG
haley for idol, i vote 89 times for this week,,,
haley for idol
oke00306 9 months ago
The most amazing performance I have seen on this show!! The sheer artistry in every note of this is amazing! Thank you so much to all that voted and voted to keep Haley in this competition and allowed us to experience this moment of beauty!
drushum 9 months ago
she's so bad-ass and has an amazing and unique voice
my favorite girl contestant that was ever on American Idol!
TheLocalcat 9 months ago
This was a HUGE song for Hayley. To come back like a lioness after all the criticisms and being sent to the corner several times should be admirable.
cjcheri 9 months ago
All Haley Fans Join My Channel..Subscribe/Friend..thx
Haley needs more followers on Twitter, so please follow her there.
HaleyReinhartCentral 9 months ago
i meant go haley:)
nkotbluvr 9 months ago
love her voice soooo much....gi haley
nkotbluvr 9 months ago
Has the view number been hacked? It cant be true
sharingheart 9 months ago
shes really pretty! and shes deff gunna get a deal from producers even if she gets voted off!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)
fireskater2 9 months ago
I'm gonna be honest I didn't really like her until like the top 10. But now that Casey's gone I want her to be the American Idol now.
XxRusty96xX 9 months ago
Best performance she's had
DevinJStar 9 months ago
ANY DOUBT SHE'S THE BEST ONE THERE?
Jujuhzinhanfg 9 months ago
adam thinks shes the best
supermanfan62 9 months ago
OMG SOOO GOOOOD! I THINK THE FIRST ONE WAS GOOD ALSO EVEN THOUGH IT DIDNT SOUND LIKE LADY GAGA!!!!!! IT WAS RLLLY GOOD SES MY FAVORITE!!!!!
stephluvspenguins38 9 months ago
14 people smoked a little too much crack this morning and clicked th wrong button!!
SupernovaPrincess 9 months ago in playlist Haley Reinhart
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey, I’m a young artist, and I would really appreciate it if everyone would check out my original compositions “My Bluest Sky” and “Será.” “My Bluest Sky” sounds a bit like a cross between “Irreplaceable” by Beyoncé, “Water Runs Dry” by Boyz II Men, and “Tell Him” by Lauryn Hill. And “Será” is, of course, a Latin number that is very high energy, hot-blooded, and extremely unforgettable. Thanks!
Cerandubois 9 months ago
she should try with a christina aguilera song...her voice would fit in perfectly
elbugambilio 9 months ago 2
What a gutsy performance.
Last night this girl won american idol. After being told her 1st song basically sucked, Hayley came out and slammed this song and brought everyone to their feet. Way to go .. !
tosarge 9 months ago
i want her to win!!!!!
cuutieree8 9 months ago
voted for her 20 times :)
SupernovaPrincess 9 months ago
@SupernovaPrincess thats not enough dont be proud of your self!!!! lol
stolen4eighty 9 months ago
While this is the best version of this soung I have ever heard and I will buy it if she records it this is the only solo of her I like. I also liked one of the duets she did with Casey. She has no humility and I don't think she has a humble bone in her body. Guess I could be wrong. She has a fantastic range and could be a great vocalist but she needs to right songs!!! This is one of them!!!!!!!
Engineer245 9 months ago
She BLEW EVERY OTHER COMPETITION AWAY WITH THIS SONG.... SHE WAS FKNNNN AWESOME WITH THIS SONG!!!!!!!!!!!
ChristyLove816 9 months ago
this was the best performance by her!
bowiehs 9 months ago
F%$# me! no, seriously, Haley... F&$# me with that voice! Loves!!
OfficialMercy 9 months ago
Just look at the number of views.....There's no better proof that this girl is so damn good....even THE BEST!!!!!
MultiBigboy90 9 months ago 2
14 people are upset cause there tone def
TheRadicalraven 9 months ago 3
NOW!!! this is what we looking for. Best performance of the season for anyone.
bigsmoke634 9 months ago
Let's put it this way folks: Who would you pay money to see live in concert? For me its this girl. Great unique voice, nice looking, and very entertaining.
sonofmabarker 9 months ago
Best proformance of the night!!!!!
TwilightWarriorcats 9 months ago
This gal has more jazz & soul in her little finger than any other Idol performer in Idol history put together! She's so young, but she's got it!
oldcollegecoed 9 months ago
I loved it!!!! It was the best performance of the night!
TheGitana71 9 months ago
She's been in the bottom 3 a lot but I sure wish my bottom three was in her, if you know what I'm sayin'!
AtomicHercules 9 months ago
im glad she got to sing a 2nd song cuz she needed to redeem herself BAD.. and her doin this is FANTASTIC... but she still has that chance to go home like rest do.. cuz of her first song was just horrible i agreed with the judges on the gaga song.. but i loved how she did this song awesome... good choice girl
nicolejstarr2011 9 months ago
THAT'S MY GIRL !!!!!!!!!
Israel944 9 months ago
I agree with the comment that she's too good for this competition, the four best performances of the series and still she struggles to stay in from week to week. The only thing missing from this was Alan Price on the organ, the two of them together, out of this world
mawsley9 9 months ago
Fantastic!!!!!!!!!!
LRmayMX 9 months ago
I love how this song builds up with intensity and emotion....JUST POWERFUL!!!!! Nothing like it since Fantasia with Summertime ; )
nana071786 9 months ago
@nana071786 Fantasia sucked and should never have won,
pizzacurse 9 months ago
@nana071786 Fantasia sucked and should never have won,
she can in no way be compared to Haley
pizzacurse 9 months ago
@pizzacurse You a dumbass!!! I am by nooooo means comparing Haley with Fantasia....I said they both had memorable moments on idol. Read it well before you open your dumbass MOUTH!!!!
nana071786 9 months ago
Your lookin at the winner
jizzum4000 9 months ago
All I can say is. A SUPPER STAR IS BORN:) I love it. Hailey. U r the best:)
gotti12341 9 months ago
when i first saw her in the auditions she became my favorite. and some how for a while either by song choice or delivery she did not express herself well,,but now for the past few weeks she has displayed what a talent she is. i think casey rubbed off a little of his jazz style to hers but either way. i think she is crazy great...
TheNutopian 9 months ago
She is not one of my favorites singers, but boy she was crazy good last night! I'm really impress, good for you girl!
ruthw143 9 months ago
When she says "it's been the ruin of many a poor boy" I JIZZ my pants each time. My balls hurt from watching this too much.
AtomicHercules 9 months ago
I just got the song on ITunes, and there is over 1000 reviews. Of she goes home tonight, American Idol just lost almost all of there ratings.
dumbbandgeeks101 9 months ago
you got to be kinding me this was TOTALLY ALSOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tigerslear 9 months ago
This was better than Siobhan's!
KatieStevensRocks 9 months ago
She was AWESOME. I would buy her album in a heartbeat. Very jazzy!!!!
tlcmdc1 9 months ago
Okay - I've been a James fan previously...but Hailey KILLED this!!!! You Go Girl!!!!
walkshe 9 months ago
Unbelievable!!!!!!
kswans3 9 months ago
Haley is probably one of the best young singers in America. Great and unique voice, great creativity : in performances and outfits, great confidence and motivation. Each of her songs is memorable and could be recorded and made into music-videos.
In my opinion she is the best singer and artist in this competition. In one word: WOW!!!
solanjoe 9 months ago 30
She was amazing and anyone that says otherwise has no vocal experience at all.
100CHEKA001 9 months ago 2
i really like this
buddhidev 9 months ago
I was speechless for this performance. It was amazing. She got down and dirty on this one. she killed it!
It's like she just chopped it in to pieces and just threw at the judges and said "have it"
ImJustNobodySpecial 9 months ago
the first "forever moment" i have seen on Idol.....(not that the talent isn't incredible by the top 12) BUT>>> clean up the recording and put it on the radio>>> N O W.
KITOhuskies 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SHE IS HOT! HOT! HOT! ....I LOVE HER YOUNG VERGIN OF JANIS JOPLIN... TEAM HALEY ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!
dlove13699 9 months ago
SHE IS HOT! HOT! HOT! ....I LOVE HER YOUNG VERGIN OF JANIS JOPLIN... TEAM HALEY ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!
dlove13699 9 months ago
only james
gooshvaretala 9 months ago
@gooshvaretala james will win!!
PaulMcdonaldFan 9 months ago
@PaulMcdonaldFan You've left several negative comments here. Going on other idols performance videos and bashing to make James better isn't working here...sorry kid
vgirl200078 9 months ago 2
@PaulMcdonaldFan ok ok, then go to james videos and say that, and by the way just a suggestion to let u know that commenting things to drag ppl down doesn't make paul mcdonald come back but make u look pathetic here, so sorry darling!!! Go grab some tissues cuz u may wanna cry
truongphan90 9 months ago
get rid of jacob!!!!!!
ray1234532 9 months ago
yes..keep her, get rid of jacob
sleebingpimp 9 months ago
MAN THIS GIRL SNAPPED ON THIS SHIT SHORTY HOT ASS HELL
(THIS SNOOP Y)
shortii3B88 9 months ago
she sucks i think
PaulMcdonaldFan 9 months ago
@PaulMcdonaldFan Your a singer right? Why dont you post something of yourself, so we can see what you got.
vgirl200078 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Man this girl killed this shit
SNOOP Y
shortii3B88 9 months ago
Man this girl killed this shit
shortii3B88 9 months ago
@smokyMcnasty I agree, stage presence and personality all are contributing factors. Sadly, Jacob kicked ass at the beginning and then started spiraling downward. Hailey started downward and is spiraling upward. Props to her improvement - (I just wish she would stop stomping her legs like that - so "80's dance"). Go Team James :)
101mek 9 months ago
@sordidfate My bad, that goes to show I didn't care much about her pre-performance story. She was ok, but frankly there's 3 others she should watch out for (I'm not counting Jacob...sorry my brotha from anotha motha). :p
101mek 9 months ago
you suck ass
ForeverxMemoriesxxx 9 months ago
@ForeverxMemoriesxxx i agree
PaulMcdonaldFan 9 months ago
Haley owns that damn stage. Like no other in this competition. Everyone else except for James are nothing more than cover singers. They have no stage presence at all. Haley is a star in the making.. The different variations of her voice and how effortlessly she switches between them.... amazing. Sweet and gritty at the same time.. And the way she struts around that stage.. with that signature growl.. maaaan.. it is just... soooo... damn... sexy....
SmokyMcnasty 9 months ago
Judges got it right on her 1st performance. Stupid idea to perform a song that hasn't been released. Total disrespect to Gaga. And this performance reminded me of Siobhan Magnus sending this song to the heavens. Oh well. James, Lauren, and Scotty top 3...IMHO.
101mek 9 months ago
@101mek She actually got the blessing of Gaga before she decided to perform it.
sordidfate 9 months ago
TOP 2
Haley, James
mommasguy 9 months ago 3
She took Casey's cool and added plenty of SEXY!!! She could bear my children any day :)
Morenitosuave 9 months ago 2
i actually liked her first performance better, but i thought she nailed both of them, i dont know why the judges didint like her first performance but this one was extremely good.
xramborinox 9 months ago
She has such a beautiful and unique voice.
gooTubeSux 9 months ago
I hope her votes counts are rising so she won't be gone
From the House of the Rising Sun :)
Win it Haley!
flippinablazing 9 months ago
VOTE VOTE VOTE! she's not safe yet. Last week they did it in random order so she could've been in the bottom 3.
she is so amazing!!!!!!!! best performance of the night.
012dmp12 9 months ago
Top 3 =p
1 Haley
2 James
3 Lauren
at one point I was kinda sorta ready to accept it if she just made it into the Top 6, then I thought at least Top 4, but as of now now I'm thinking Top 3 and I'll only be truly satisfied if she wins
Having said that, I could only accept James beating her and even then reluctantly so !
pooliette 9 months ago
Comment removed
agata804 9 months ago
@pooliette Top 3 =p
1 Scotty
2 Haley
3 James
agata804 9 months ago
@agata804 hahah, I'd be satisfied with your choices just so long as Haley gets second place so we can get more of her. I really do think Haley should win, but maybe cannot based on votes unless she keeps up her "strategy" It's always been apparent to me that she has more up her sleeve so more shock and awe is possible =)
I like James and I liked Scotty in the beginning, but I just don't see that they have as much potential and room for growth as Haley . Lauren has more potential. Just saying.
pooliette 9 months ago
@pooliette
I love Haley, and I Think Haley and Scotty will fight for winner. They are both fighters, but. Scotty has a better voice, range and he is more talented.
agata804 9 months ago
@agata804
Scotty has an OKAY country voice, that's it. More talented and range than Haley?? you must be out of your mind.. she blows him away in every single aspect of singing.
doct3rj 9 months ago
@doct3rj Scotty has an OKAY country voice, that's it. More talented and range than Haley?? you must be out of your mind.. she blows him away in every single aspect of singing.
Ha! none of the remaining singers is as impressive as this lady. she is fortunate to have gotten rid of Jacob. When on, as he often was (not this week!), he was amazing, but this is hers to lose/win! The rest are average karaoke singers. No shame in that at all, but for Top 4 on Idol? OUCH.
JusticeForTheDead 9 months ago 12
3 week from tomorrow haley and scotty we be stand on the stage and ryan is going to say and your next american is HALEY REINHART.
i can the future so you know no biggie
candycanegirl111 9 months ago
VOTE for her..
IF you want her to STAY!!!
1-866-436-5705 & 5710
retach08 9 months ago 17
Top 3.
1. Haley
2. James
3. Scotty
:D
TheFluffinator22 9 months ago
@TheFluffinator22 james will win thoo
PaulMcdonaldFan 9 months ago
@PaulMcdonaldFan Nooo Haley should win x) Since when's the last time a girl won American Idol? But even if James won, I would still be happy because he has extraordinary talent too.
TheFluffinator22 9 months ago
@TheFluffinator22 i want james to win he has more too him then haily
PaulMcdonaldFan 9 months ago
@PaulMcdonaldFan When it comes down to it, in my opinion, they both deserve to win. Scotty, Lauren, and Jacob are all good but Haley and James are winners to me. In this point of the competition it's really hard to see any of them go home because not everyone is ever satisfied with the results. I respect all opinions, but I'm still rooting for Haley to win, and if it's not Haley, then James, MAYBE James... anything is possible, nevertheless.
TheFluffinator22 9 months ago
@TheFluffinator22 james will winn
PaulMcdonaldFan 9 months ago
@TheFluffinator22 agree with 2 of the 3, scotty is a good country singer but he's not for this show, he needs to be able to not make every song he sings country related.
xramborinox 9 months ago
Haley must WIN! <3
TheFluffinator22 9 months ago
James #1 Haley #2 Love them both and whoever ends up winning doesn't matter as they are both going far in the music business. They are leaps and bounds above Scotty who will have a good career in country (just not my thing) but the other two will be all but forgotten in a year or two.
BluesGirlBabe 9 months ago
omg... chills!!!! She HAS to win this season. If Scotty or Lauren or Jacob win this season there is something wrong with America!
doda 9 months ago 3
OMG, OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MAJOR GOOSEBUMPS!!!!! VOTE FOR THIS BAD ASS GIRL EVERYONE!!!!! WOOOOOOHOOOOOOOO!!
truongphan90 9 months ago
Comment removed
mommasguy 9 months ago
i'm f**king obsessed with this girl.
blondebabee110 9 months ago 2
Haley is a goddess. Word.
teenyweenygenie 9 months ago
She can do anything! She has such an awesome versatile voice! She has to be in the Top 2
ArcDrako 9 months ago 3
2 dislikes? Wow ok Scotty not so Hotty fans please why are you on here watching it, you know you like it!!!
doct3rj 9 months ago 3
omgee this girl is a freakin god. loveeeee herrrrrrr<3
x0xalliieex0x 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Is she intentionally trying to throw this competition?? When she isn't growling, her voice makes me want to puke violently.
ALittleLoveAtCaesars 9 months ago
this video has more likes than any of the others tonight.
sovintagerock 9 months ago 4
@sovintagerock with good reason! Hell's BELLS!
teenyweenygenie 9 months ago
@teenyweenygenie I know! It's awesome. We just have to vote like crazy hahaha.
sovintagerock 9 months ago
MERCY! My WORD! Get it, girl! THAT is called SANGIN' where I came from. This is so killer over-the-top she puts MANY of the most famous music elite to SHAME here! I am enthralled! More! More! More!
teenyweenygenie 9 months ago 4
She rocked this out! Way to go Haley!
rakuhn27 9 months ago 2
i find it funny how haley is the underdog but shes gotten 2 of the 4 only standing ovations given since the top 24 by the judges. VOTE!
llecomedies52 9 months ago 2
I like this alot ! ! ! But I think I more Like siobhan magnus version. , siobhan magnus's version is simple but Great :) That was my opinion :)
mommasguy 9 months ago
Casey was my fav but now haily is! I love her
heathermuffins1 9 months ago
Wow im not surprised this got so many view so fast when i heard this live this gave me the chills all the way down my spine.. her Acapella part was AMAZING in the begging this sound quality doesnt really do it justice but people who saw it live know...i been all about James Casey and Scotty especially James but when she song this i realized her pure vocals outshine ANYBODY on here and many celebrity singers BY FAR her voice is Majestic.. its was so amazing to hear her sing... L1oVe....
LoVeInADiUniVerSe 9 months ago
sexiest American Idol performer EVER. if she doesnt win I'll kill myself.
angeljmoreno 9 months ago 2
don't get too comfortable and not vote for her because you think a lot of people will. Trust me, Scotty has girls voting for him like CRAZY.... keep up the votes guys!
mma665 9 months ago 12
@mma665 Like it probably did for Casey -_-!!
thonycinq 9 months ago
Go Haley. You rule!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tngoddess 9 months ago 3
AMERICA! Pls vote hard for Haley! This is just an awesome performance! PLS pLS PLS
sordidfate 9 months ago 3
If she doesn't win American Idol after performances like this one, America has no taste whatsoever!
DonnaRowe 9 months ago
shes going 2 win it all
gnfdgfrg1 9 months ago
looooooooooooooove! <3
laurie7s 9 months ago
Best song of the entire season. Blew it away! I was concerned after the LGaga one, but this was amazing!
nothinbutrouble99 9 months ago
I just came.
DUSKiX0O 9 months ago
I got goosebumps.
This performance was fantastic, absolutely fantastic.
maplecake 9 months ago 3
so far dialidol has haley in last place :( vote vote vote :P
Rainb0wBryte1 9 months ago 3
GOOSEBUMPS! :D
banana719 9 months ago
@ mma665.. I have agreed all the way before but after tonight's performances... OMG.. this girl hasa great unique voice...Janis Jopliny, Joss Stonish and those blues in her soul. Go get them Haley!!
jd6226 9 months ago 2
Awesome..... I am totally a fan now for sure... She took it home on this one. Go Haley! <3
cpoling1912 9 months ago
Winner good performance!
claus49 9 months ago
what a contrast to lady gaga and katy perry stuff going on in pop music right now. she can really bring back rock n' roll. she can have no make up on, bare feet , no false eyelashes and bring out emotion - just like rock n' roll is suppose do. Haley if you read this, don't do the whole pop thing, dont do what adam lambert did, b bare and raw, you can be bigger than the grunge movement of the 90s. ppl are hungry for this stuff, mumford & sons are proving it.
taliehead 9 months ago 3
originally I thought that maybe this was a bad song choice for her....but omg when she started it acapella it was freakin amazing from the get go..!! loved it!!!
PandaPhantom 9 months ago 2
wow!!!
VOTE her please....
retach08 9 months ago
HOLY SHIT!
rodriguez4433 9 months ago
love it. love it. love it. Truly amazing.
VictorYuYu 9 months ago
that person who dislikes this video has some serious jelousy issues
ShawnMyersMusic 9 months ago
who would ever dislike such great singing.
samg12316 9 months ago
She has been my girl from the beginning. She is the best! She has the potential to be the biggest star AI has ever produced. She is on the level of Whitney, Mariah and Celine. Thank God for Haley!
epi8 9 months ago