Added: 3 years ago
From: photomoviemad21
Views: 33,632
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (189)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Jonas Is a Boy

  • Great job!!!! It was really good!!!

  • i read de book and its so emotionnaaaaaal omg , i criied for it when i seen that they kill little babies and others ! o.o

  • @aiden12201998 actually he ends up seing all colors remember??? Unless you didnt read the book.....just saying:)

  • hahahahahaa thaat wass really gooood!!!! hhahaaha i dont thiink i could do that!! I am reading the giver now and its exactly like that!!....well obiously:)

  • in the book jonas only sees the apple turn red not every color just the apple , just saying :)

  • at the beginning was that titanic music? hahaha

  • gay

  • @CODswag21 aww it made you that happy? I'm glad.

  • jonas has man boobs.

  • WHAT IS THE SECOND SONG, I KNOW THE FIRST ONE (JAMES HORNER) BUT WHATS THE SECOND?

  • For a school project, this is actually pretty decent. It would be nice to see an actual movie based on the book. 

  • Gayest book i have ever fucking read

  • @JacksonSargent if you didnt like the book then dont comment on the project BASED ON THE BOOK!

  • @JacksonSargent trolls gonna troll

  • the "no!" and "jonas no!" was stupid. i dont remember giver saying "jonas no! in the book but yeah it was good still and @whycast its not retarded if you actually read the book, and thats a really disrespectful word.

  • @DannixXxNicola It was filler, maybe internal thoughts...its pretty much artistic freedom on my part.

  • what are the songs you guys used ? im really curios because i've got to do the same project and those were some killer songs!

  • this was actually really good

  • tarded

    

  • @jakethesnake237 Can't have read too many good books then..

  • how did you make the apple change

  • suspenseful, pretty darn good

  • lol i loved it. best one out there

  • Please tell me what the song name is!!!

  • @KeswickCamp08 they are coming out with a movie its just been developing FOREVER!!! Look it up on google er something and ull see.

  • why cant there really be a movie :(

  • Exalent I enjoyed it

  • Cooll but terrible acting

  • I like the book this was almost like the book

  • this was a grate book

  • bad acting but everything else was great:)

  • I'm forced to watch this in LA right now x;D So our class is watching it. Thanks<33

  • @IishEmmy lol I've heard that many times over. This old project of mine has been used countless times as examples or intros to reading the book.

  • My reading group is reading this.

  • Great trailer, but u shud of worn a hat so Jonas looked like a guy

  • @susiF123 thought about it, but since he didn't wear one in the book, I didn't want to have it on her in the video. Plus you wouldn't be able to see her face because its in black and white.

  • @photomoviemad21 he actually did wear something on his head in the book; everyone did. It was to show deference.

  • This is just awesome! Its better than the movie project my group made...

  • @LuvbooksbyErincat Thank you, its all just trial and error =]

  • wtf jonas is a guy in the book! otherwise nice job

  • @iSamxx19 I had an all girl group so I had to use girls pretending to be guys.

  • that sir, made four 12 year olds applaud. js.

  • @horse4568 lol thank you.

  • OMG SO COOL!!!!! but is jonas a dude and wouldnt the baby die cause all that bamging on the head?but anyways IT WAS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I am 10 years old and I am reading this book in class! The book and this trailer are both AMAZING! My friends and I are making a movie for it.

  • I loved tht we watched this video after we read the book in class and this blinking baby freaked everyone out . It was cute and funny. Very nice job

  • @MsLaughingbanana You watched this in a class? wow thats kinda neat. what class was it? what grade for that matter? lol

  • the first and second book were not as good

    

  • @MrJohnathon55 there is not a sequel...theres only the first one. Louis Lowry didn't make a sequel because she wanted everyone to have an idea of what happened at the end.

  • @blasky8 actually she wrote two more books after the giver and they do relate back to the first one.

    the second one is almost a completely different story, but the third one relates back to the baby and what happens later after the escape along with the second book inner twined. Worked out pretty well.

  • This book is amazing i just finished it

  • @rellanwilliams1 It definitely is a good one.

  • I love the book!

  • really amazing trail

    you are so creative person....

    I am 20 years and I really think this book is the most amazing book I have ever read

    it attaches my feelings so much....deep feelings inside of me

    I always think about the life and its meaning.

    I have a quiz on Thursday about this story

  • @StalinKanal Yeah i agree no matter how old you are this is definitely a keeper. Simple, but great impact.

  • For something made with absolutely no budget... it was good. Good job on coloring the part where he/she catches the apple. :D

  • @FCBGin lol it wasn't bad for the time, I could have done a bit more with that now a days, but I still like it for kicks

  • Dude I like your "movie treiller" don't listen to that junk. In my opinion i think its awesome.

  • @Slatecan lol thanks, I made it when i was only 14 so at the time I was really happy with it lol

  • I am 10 years old and reading the book right now! I just got on chaqpter 6. It's one of the best books I've ever read. Another great book is Gathering Blue, which is a companion to The Giver. Another one is The Messenger. I haven't read it, yet, though.

  • @MrSmartdude make sure to read that last one! It relates back to where the giver left off...mentions the sled and everything!

  • @photomoviemad21 We'll be doing an assignment on The Messenger this year. Well, some of us, anyway. I hope it's me! Oh and btw, I am in advanced class. VERY ADVANCED CLASS....

  • @MrSmartdude too bad the wnding sucked

  • @MrSmartdude hey umm the dad is a nurtire he realeses babys (kill)

  • awesome.. by far the best nd wat a great book

  • @13mamafresh yeah it was a good book to read, the next three are pretty good as well

  • Awesomesest <.< ? best yet......da book was so awesome

  • pretty good

    

  • isn't this book illegal in some states? but i LOVE IT! you made it so much clearer THX! =P

  • @commenter1028 No its not illegal...in the U.S. ....maybe another country

  • @photomoviemad21 my english said it was illegal in the southern states o well btw chapter 5 is WRONG!!!

  • is there really a movie? i just had to finish the book for school and i wanna read the sequels 

  • @lol2its7me There is word of one coming out in 2011 I believe

  • The book is awesome but this is the worst/gayest film ever

  • @MMB3M lol and so are you. I made this a hell of a long time ago with no money for a budget. It's not like I'm saying 'oh my god I am the awesome for making this amazing video!"...no don't waste your time with comments like this.

  • t=The book is awesome but this is the worst/gayest film ever

  • holy shit. this is really good!

  • @Shamarafication lol thanks I did it a long time ago, but I was proud of it despite how new I was to editing.

  • @Shamarafication shush! she said not to point out the obvious! :)

  • Love it :) great job !!!

  • wow...really it's by far the BEST i've ever seen !

  • @my0nick0my0love thanks =]

  • I just gone done making a trailer of my own with some friends yesterday, and this is by far better then ours!

  • i loved the book

  • I definitely like the way you did the apple scene. Very nicely done!

  • @chaoticpix93 yeah it wasn't bad for the technology I had at the time, part that sucks now is I could have actually done it the way I wanted too if I had re done it now.

  • This is awesome. 

  • @TheXximee thank you very much =]

  • i've read the book and u made a perfect trailer :) bravo! it was awesome! it made me want to see the actual movie! too bad there isnt one :(

  • @Thejibletz there is a real giver movie in the makes actually 2011 I believe it comes out

  • Awesome trailer u guys. mrs. falzone is reading that with us right now :)

  • this is a good trailer

  • Good job I had to read that book and I actually REALLY liked it:)

  • Good job! My 11 yr old son had to read The Giver as his summer reading and book report this year and somehow I got into the book too. I think you and your friends did an excellent job. I like the idea of a movie trailer as a school project. Job well done girls! i enjoyed the trailer a lot.

  • Pretty good - interesting. Some nice acting too.

  • lol the baby.

  • so good! but in our class we called jonas jona

  • @jsjazzyjams2 thanks glad u liked it.

  • They cant make jonas a girl because its the community rule that each family unit is only to have one girl and one boy, and they already have Lilly.

  • @AngelHorse714 yeah but I had no choice.

    Only girls in my group.

    

  • her name isnt spelled lilly its spelled lily with only one L

  • that was really good! it looked like it was made proffesionally!

  • this is my fav book ever i love it

  • This is effin great ! holy smokes

  • @GIRLSECKS now i want a smokie sausage! LOL but i totally agree great trailer!

  • the book was sooo good.... to me it was a little sad so i cried a bit lol

  • That was reallyy good!! good job!!

  • Awesome:) Go to my channel and see mine:)

  • Very nice:) Go to my channel, I had to create a Giver Trailer for an English project. :)

  • this was amazing

  • make this a movie please!!! :)

  • That was pretty good...I'm impressed....check out my Giver movie...it's ten minutes, but tells the story. =]

  • 2011

  • this is good..but i thought jonas was a boy..well...i like that they made jonas a girl

  • I had only girls in my group to use

  • OMG PERFECT! LOVED IT! :D

  • lol thanks

  • there all white in story..

  • i was assigned a group for a school project. its not gunna be perfect.

  • @heyitsrunescape and you play runescape thats likes white people. because nowadays everyone plays GOOD games like mw2 bfbc2 etc and your stuck with runescape. shame on you

  • @PivotWarKingDX117 uh i play all of those...

  • what is this song called? we had to do this project too.

  • theres actually three well known movie music in there. 1st part was titanic, 2nd was pirates of the carribean 3 and last was harry potter 5

  • well i think it wasrly good :)

  • great! what music did you use?

  • theres actually three well known movie music in there. 1st part was titanic, 2nd was pirates of the carribean 3 and last was harry potter 5

  • two thumbs up

  • woahhhh.

    we just read this is school,

    and this was so good!

    wow!

    i was like omggg!

    dude, nice job. :)

  • I don't care. The book said Jonas, Asher, Giver, and Gabe were, white, boys, an REAL!!!!! SAMENESS!!!!!!!!!

  • Ehhh...The fact that everyone was a girl took away the desired effect. >.>

  • i had to use girls because they were part of my group

  • Jonas was a boy. The Giver was a boy. Gabe was real. Asher wasn't black and he was a boy. WTF?

  • its funny how they didnt know what cars were but i saw a lot of them. lol you should have should jonas riding his bike. good acting skills though. thank god for spark notes. i would have failed the test

  • well thats what happens when you live in the city.

  • That was really good , check out mine on my channel its pretty good as well.

  • thee qiver was ah boy,

  • well i only had girls in my group to work with.

  • whoah that was awesome!

  • awesome job editing! im so excited for the movie!

  • thanks. I'll be interested to see how good the real movie is.

  • I actually enjoyed this trailer. I am 27 years old and am a HUGE fan of the book!! I have read it like 20 or 30 times. I can't wait for the movie to come out next year. It should be awesome!! Great job on this trailer!!

  • Thanks for the feed back. =]

  • They realy are planing to make a Movie of the giver, thes prevus are all fake.

    People are making fun of the idea.

  • yeah david yates is directing it and he'll ruin it.

  • Oh, this is really good. You should get a good mark. Why did you use a girl as jonas>?

  • hey photomovie? wereyou the 1 playin jonas or who?

  • In this one, you never see me lol. I usually stay behind the camera, its better that i do lol. I show up in some of the other ones like "dependant clauses" in the credits, but after that im usually hidden. =]

  • The book was awesome, our teacher read it to us and we had to right an essay on it. Im glad not a trailer lol. If the giver was really going to be a movie. Id do anything to watch it!!!! anything. photomoviemad21, you did excellent on the trailer. Thats good that you got the highest mark in the class.

  • Nice Trailer, Best Student project i've seen.

    You must of got an "A"

    I Really enjoyed the flash of the apple turning red.

  • I love the book, I'm reading it right now as a school project.. hopefully, we won't have to do a trailer. Lol

  • It's an ok i give it 3 stars. But is'nt the giver and Jonas supposed to be boys???

  • yes but when you are put into groups for a school project you have to do what you can.. I didnt get to pick my actors.

  • nicee =) but isnt the giver supposed to be an old man??

  • yeah but for a school project you dont exactly have an old man in a high school class.

  • yeah XD

  • well i think u would get an A-... not turning to be mean but jonas is looks like a girl....

    and the thing in the shot is a clear liquid its not red..... but AWSOME

  • lol well actually mine was the best in the class. top marks. jonas looks like a girl cuz she is one, theres nothing i could really do about it. its not like ive got top quality stuff to work with

  • Well, I bet that got an A. Don't get me wrong, if that was the trailer for the actual movie (no offense), I wouldn't go. But, compared to most of these school projects, this one takes the cake. Great choice in background music, btw, although I think you all swapped roles a little during the movie. Pretty good, though. If you had the money and materials, you could have made a great trailer. Nice job.

  • hey thanks for the feed back. glad to know my editing efforts weren't a total waste. lol yeah some ppl changed parts but that is only because we had four people. plus they were all girls having to fill male roles. I definitly would have been able to pull it off better if I had more than two days to film and create this, plus i dont have the equipment or stock footage i really need to make this one a major success lol.

  • im reading he book at school im going to tell everybody at school and one thing what happens in the book chapter 23 im reading it tomorrow but tell me im excited

  • what school do u go 2

  • En realidad este es el mejor video de todos que he visto sobre el libro: El Dador ( The Giver) Lois Lowry, por que los demas estan hecho un asco no se que sean los anteriores videos que he visto pero parece que es una burla ó trabajos escolares muy mal hechos

  • amzing job!!!

  • lol. but this one might be worth your while? aha. we did a movie like this but... kinda lots better.

  • well it looks like they tried their best, dont be bitter about it. they probably said MIGHT for a reason, they obviously dont think theres is fricken george lucas. no need to be so what bitter about it.

  • wow that was really really good!

  • that was really good. especially for a school project. i could totally tell that thy were girls but it still was amazing. props to you!!!! cant wait till the real movie in 2011 comes out!! im totally gnna see it!!

    (:

  • lol well that could not be helped seeing as our groups were assigned to us.

  • I liked it alot! It was very well done!

  • WOW. What can I say? WOW. That was AMAZING for a school project. WOW. The editing was awesome, and the music made it seem even more like a real movie trailer. GREAT job; I LOVE it! By the way, is the release date on there the one for the real movie? I was just wondering...oh, and I LOVED the ending..."But all pictures develop from a negative" THAT was perfect.

  • nope no real release date for this book. no word yet on it becoming real.

    Thanks for the comment. I enjoy making these sorts of things so its safe to assume its the one sort of school project I actually like. lol. The last saying took me quite a while to come up with but i thought it added a nice touch =]

  • I just discovered your trailer! What a fantastic job you have done! I love the blips of color and the music selections were awesome. Would you mind sharing what software you are using? I teach 6th grade English and teach The Giver every year. I plan on showing the trailer first this time! Thanks for a great piece of work!!

  • wow thank you. I'm honored you would like to use my video project in your class. For that video I used only windows movie maker. A standard program for any windows computer. If theres any other questions you have about the trailer, feel free to drop me a comment.

    by the way the songs used were songs from well known movies

    the 1st half was titanic

    the transition/apple scene was pirates of the carribean 3

    and the ending song was Harry Potter 5.

  • GUYS! when we read the book im class what did the ending mean?!?!?! did him and gabe die? =[ plz comment back plz!

  • well actually i believe jonas comes back in the third book, the messenger.

    i dont know if u knew that the giver's sequal was called gathering blue, it really has nothing to do with the giver's characters but the concept of a strange controled community. the third book follows a character from gathering blue and i believe jonas is the mayor of another community founded for ppl who would normally be sentenced to death.

    if your interested enough i suggest you keep on reading =]

  • gj i wish they made into a real movie

  • they are making it in to a movie its coming out in 2011 look it up

  • where did you find that information?

  • i do too.

  • great job