Zakir Naik's misleading explanation of controversial Quranic Verse

[babyturtlefilms]

why did allah give his speaker a stupid face and silly girly lisp ?

hes right you know... its out of context with the modern world... so stop reading the stupid outdated non-sense 5 times a day like an obsessive compulsive monkey

[eao6qas5ipt]

"Wherever you find a Kafir Kill him"

Wherever you find that statement on Koran, I have a good laugh. Allah & Momad looks like two clowns.

[ByChoiceMuslim]

Verse 9:6 said "If one amongst the Pagans ask thee for asylum, grant it to him, so that he may hear the word of Allah; and then escort him to where he can be secure. That is because they are men without knowledge." What a stupid explanation you gave for this verse! The verse is basically saying this men are without knowledge so give them the opportunity so that they may have the chance to hear the word of Allah. It does not mean let them go if they only want to hear the word of Allah.

[Alexplus20]

Islam is the religeon of piss!! For every moderate verse that they can come up with I have a hundred more from the Qu'ran and Hadiths. Theire faith is pathetic and rather disgusting.

[VanGoghsEar1890]

Atheist just love reading the cherry-picking views of all believers. All of it is painting God's eyebrows. He works in mysterious ways, he is beyond the the understanding of the human mind, and everybody can still read his mind. I love it....

[ThinkingGuy100]

zakir NALAIK is a faggot

[chanu07888]

Was Allah fought war with mushriks of mecca as he is telling or muhaamad fought with mushriks, He is refering Allah as general and saying that allah gave 4 months time to mushriks. Now my question is did allah fought with mushriks or Muhammad lead army fought with mushriks. Allah or we can say in english god or in hindi bhagwaan, if he decides to eliminate human, it would be just with in flash of seconds.Zakir Naik is misleader.

[shaim143music]

y cant u read the quran ..n not tke te verses taken out of context are u blind brother!

[shaim143music]

And if they break their pledges after their treaty (hath been made with you) and assail your religion, then fight the heads of disbelief - Lo! they have no binding oaths - in order that they may desist. :verse number 12 :chapter 9

[shaim143music]

(8) They have purchased with the revelations of Allah a little gain, so they debar (men) from His way. Lo! evil is that which they are wont to do. (9) And they observe toward a believer neither pact nor honour. These are they who are transgressors. (10) But if they repent and establish worship and pay the poor-due, then are they your brethren in religion. We detail Our revelations for a people who have knowledge. (11)

[shaim143music]

verse no 7 again says: How can there be a treaty with Allah and with His messenger for the idolaters save those with whom ye made a treaty at the Inviolable Place of Worship? So long as they are true to you, be true to them. Lo! Allah loveth those who keep their duty

[shaim143music]

And if anyone of the idolaters seeketh thy protection (O Muhammad), then protect him so that he may hear the Word of Allah, and afterward convey him to his place of safety. That is because they are a folk who know not.

[shaim143music]

surah thawba chapter number 9 vere number six just after that verse says : And if anyone of the idolaters seeketh thy protection (O Muhammad), then protect him so that he may hear the Word of Allah, and afterward convey him to his place of safety. That is because they are a folk who know not.

[ayunus7]

whoever made the title of this video is a twat and misguided

[zindabhaag]

There is no controversial verse in Quran. Dr. Zakir have explained what is the truth. Simple is that.

[20033716]

Ya context Dr.Naik

explain the context in Sura 9 verse 29

If it is war why should he ask for Jizya?Who the hell is Allah to decide in what I believe?Why should I not believe in whatever I wish to?

[20033716]

Dr.Naik can you compare Allah with army general???

[karthige79]

It is so sad that because of a few misinterpreters an entire religion and those following it are tagged as extreme elements.

God is for the righteous. He doesn't differentiate if you are a Muslim, Christian, Hindu, Buddhist etc.

I don't know why people claim that God is only for a particular religion and you have to get converted to be blessed by him.. Nonsense !!

[786mansoor786]

true, god does not differentiate but people's concept of God differentiates. for exampel Hindus believe in numerous God but Budhist dont believe in the almighty at all.

[metoowahchef]

786mansoor:

Hindus believe in different ASPECTS of ONE God, and not in different Gods.

Get your facts right before posting comments.

[786mansoor786]

@metoowahchef

you may believe in one god, but there are Hindus who believe in many god, i totally agree with you that hinduism also states that there is only one god it is mentioned in the vedas many times. but you may also know that many hindus do not know this and some even worship cattle and the sun and stars.

[asharpervez1000]

@metoowahchef, so a monkey, an elephant and a cow are aspects of the ONE GOD as well? If so, how? Also why stop at these animals? What is wrong with the bull, the horse or the hippo?

[raja1731]

@asharpervez1000

You are right rasool allah who killed 600-900 jews, had sex with a 9yr old and owned slaves is the prophet of god. Thinking monkeys and cows are holy is stupid but praying five times a day to a black meteorite in a desert is the path to 72 virgins. Also why live in a kaffur country like uk go back to the islamic republic of pakistan and live with ummah.

[asharpervez1000]

@raja1731 well it is only idiots who call christians kaffirs. In case you are slightly ignorant, the trinity concept was in full force by the time the Prophet SAW came along yet still the followers of Jesus have been referred to as chrsitians and people of the book instead of kaffirs.

Besides you seem like an atheist so go live your life the way you want to. Why interfere in a somewhat religious conversation?

[metoowahchef]

karthige79:

you said "God is for the righteous. He doesn't differentiate if you are a Muslim, Christian, Hindu, Buddhist etc".

That is EXACTLY the point that HINDUISM makes. Most of the OTHER faiths claim EXCLUSIVE rights over God.

I hope you see the self-contradiction in your comment.

Peace!

[786mansoor786]

@metoowahchef

i would like to state that for you to say that all other religions are wrong and yours is right would be a ridiculous claim. if hinduism shows the true god then why do have numerious names for God and create states of the almighty. how would you know what he looks like. In your own Vedas, Yujurveda 32:3 it say 'of god there are no images' so why do all hinduism have pictures and idols of god , because you are not even following your won religion properly.

[lollylopdraws]

@metoowahchef christianity says we are all part of the one body e.g there is one god the enitre human population is a part of the body of god no matter what u call him e.g allah buddah there is one god and to me religion are just branches which he gives us all to get closer to him

[evolution100001]

@karthige79 you are absolutely right...A common tenet of Hinduism is "Sarva Dharma Sambhava, which literally means that all religion are equal to or harmonious with each other.all religions are the same" - that all religions are merely different paths to God or the same spiritual goal.

[amrita0286]

@karthige79 100% agree with you! I wish more people thought like this. I'm Sikh and in Sikhism that is the belief as well :)

[arvindan1983]

Reply to 1:33 whereever you find Zakir Naik kill him.

[rahmat82]

so brother do not make things which are easy and simple complicated, and also plz try to understand that you need to have enough knowledge in order to discuss or quarral, for this reason you need to listen to what he says carefully and think about it, than you will understand what he is saying and what does he means.

[rahmat82]

Dear urdadable, Dr. Zaker is correctly translating it, you do not understand. He does not mean that, it was only for that time, of course Quran is for all time. But what he is saying that on that time the situation was like that and also he is saying in any battle field this kind of things making sense so it means it was not for that time specific its for all time but it is not out of battle or in a situation where there is no war. So brother Allah give you mind plz use it in a correct way.....

[tarun1982]

this man Zakir Naik is such a clown ..... but the fact that he is trying to convert people and that he is a fraud is not very amusing ... but yes the way he behaves/talks is funny.

[richie7rich7]

this is a correct translation. I dont know what the heck are you trying to prove metoowahchef

[urdadable]

who has given right to anyone to tell them how to follow or obey the Almighty.................... quran is the word of God just believe and read it by heart not by ur missguided obscured by doubt mind and The ALmighty shall guide you who needs clowns like these .............why to encourage them and make controversies out of such an easy book just follow it with heart ...and let these vultures eat each other in the name of God remembr these bastrads are in every religion ....

[untamedheart4u]

"We know indeed that they say there is a man that teaches him The tongue of him they wickedly point to is notably foreign while this is arabic pure and clear".. Quran 16:103

Do they not consider the Quran with care?

Has it been from other then Allah they would surely found therein much discrepancy" Quran 4:82 ...

[untamedheart4u]

Brother, the true implication of the verse is according to you dont say its according to islam...

U said:"the ONLY SECURE place for a non-muslim is the place where he (the non-muslim) has no choice but to hear the word of allah..."

Quran doesnt say ,Enemy has no choice but to accept Islam. Read and Understand correctly...

Brother Zakir just gave the reply to arun shoories Allegations.

Remember: "Let there be No compulsion in religion". Qur'anCh:2 V:256..

[metoowahchef]

UNTAMEDHEART4U:

No. That's the TRUE IMPLICATION of the verse: a prisoner of war(PoW) would be in fear; utilizing this fear in such a situation, to get a non-Muslim PoW to listen to the word of Allah "in a place of security", is NOT true magnanimity. Rather, it is a way of intimidating the prisoner into listening to the word of Allah.

Therefore, by portraying the Surah Al Tawbah Chapter 9, Verse 6 as a message of generosity, Zakir Naik is trying to FOOL people....

[cont...]

[fucknuaf]

The true implication is that there is force and pressure to be used in matters of religion, is this what I am reading here?

[metoowahchef]

UNTAMEDHEART4U:

My friend, we ought to accept that scriptures of ALL faiths have contradictions within them.

THEREFORE, the only way to mutually respectful, and peaceful coexistence, is to refrain from trying to establish that any one faith is the only path that leads to God (that, by the way, is one of the central tenets on Hinduism).

[famigo451]

Brother, Islam has been made perfect by Allah. People are the ones that are imperfect. If you truly believe and truly adhere in the teachings of Islam then you would believe in the words of the Koran and of the prophets. You would not become extremists and would not interpret ISlam erroneously. Believe in Allah, brother and you will certainly walk on the path to heaven. Islam is the only one true Religion. a perfect Religion. ISLAM!

[bambrinar]

Brother, don't provide illogical answers! This fellow says that Koran was written for all times for all people. He also says that it is out of context like American president calling to kill Vietnamese during the Vietnam war! This means that Koran was written for that period and cant be taken for all times. Otherwise agree that the Koran is not for all the times. Bull shit brother!

[hawkmoon6]

i could not get the true message in ur video.. wat was it about this speach that would misguide anyone... And wat point do u want to make? plz explain!

[metoowahchef]

HAWKMOON6:

Please read the explanation in the panel on the right, below the SUBSCRIBE button.

If the text of my explanation appears 'collapsed' there, click on 'more info' in the parentheses.

[hawkmoon6]

okk.... my friend! this verse interprets exactly the way Dr .Zakir explained... in Quran it says ' if any of the non believers seek ur protection u should protect them so that they can hear the word of Allah, and afterwards convey them to their place of safety' this is the exact translation of Quran... Islam does focus on spreading the word of God but never forces anyone to convert.. And its upto the listener whether he accepts it or not coz Allah will loose nothing but that non believer will.

[metoowahchef]

HAWKMOON6:

No, my friend---a prisoner of war(PoW) would be in fear; utilizing this fear in such a situation, to get a non-Muslim PoW to listen to the word of Allah "in a place of security", is NOT true magnanimity. Rather, it is a way of intimidating the prisoner into listening to the word of Allah.

Therefore, by portraying the Surah Al Tawbah Chapter 9, Verse 6 as a message of generosity, Zakir Naik is trying to FOOL people.

[sohaibmansoor]

well probablly that is one of the interpretation. Well try to see another perspective of that verse. First of all i agree POW woud be in fear, but by providing him secuirity and comfort during that harsh period, he will attracted towards good behavior of muslim thus he will be interested in to listening word of Allah.

Well stereotyping any concept out context is not justice to any of the religious scripts. Thanks.. God Bless you!

[sohaibmansoor]

"escorted to a place of security so that he (the non-muslim) may hear the word of allah" That is the translation , it doesnt say much. U can make anything out of it. one way to see is ur exactly Your interpretation, Or other way around is mine explaination.

Reality is, A person whos holding feeling against islam, will see YOUR EXPLANATION, and on other side any one who's trying to represent that in good way , will see MY EXPLANATION.

anyway this is true for any thing, like media does that..

[bagh98]

cleva cleva! both mr. naik and the videoposter, salam bro!