very well done , i would of liked to have seen them actually show the earth romulan war as a two hour season endeng and season beginning episode's. because i know they wanted to make their own version of star trek before kirk, but in my opinion they failed in alot of ways. why can't someone come along and still make a good new series but keep the real history correct. whether it is pre-history or future.
@jder06 Unfortunately, all they care about is the next paying gig. They don't really care about Star Trek (or Star Wars, or comic book movies, etc etc).
@jder06 That is sort of the reason that they couldn't make much of the Earth-Romulan war. Kirk was the first human to see a Romulan per the Star Trek timeline.
If enterprise had gone into a fith season, this was possibly going to be one of the topics. I hate that the show got canceled before the critical thing in Starfleet history was shown.
I gotta say...this was kind of confusing...it was a good video, but...the different battles, like the Vulcans vs. Andorians/Enterprise scene kinda confused me...
Aside from the terrible spelling, it also doesn't make much sense to include V'Las, given he was removed from office (and especially given his secret collaboration with the Romulans).
Awesome video! Had the stations not cancelled Star Trek Enterprise after only 4 seasons, who knows how far the show might've gone. It was one of my favourite Star Trek tv series, next to Star Trek Voyager and The Next Generation. I also appreciate the music. Very dramatic.
@bsgenterprise I agree. Why they discontinued Star Trek Enterprise is beyond me. Neilson be damned, I really didn't think the stations should've cancelled the show when it did.
@jeffblitz polarized hull plating gave some minimal protection, but most of the time, the ships simply have armour. :P Enveloping energy barriers are apparently harder to do than phasers. :)
The book series does it's best to give a view of the Earth-Romulan war. In the books the Romulans began to use a tele-control device to control ships, the Kobayushi Maru scenario came from that. The Kobayushi Maru was being taken over and Enterprise tried to save the ship and crew, but the Romulans attempted to take Enterprise and Archer was left with a no-win scenario, he abandoned the Kobayushi Maru to save Enterprise.
Excellent.....nice to hear you picked a great song too. I'm soooooooooooooooooo tired of Requiem for Dream. If I hear it again, I'm going to cut my ears off, LoL
I've always hated how photon torpedoes are supposed to be antimatter warheads, and they make explosions that look like mortar rounds. One of the things should destroy every ship for thousands of miles with an immense radiation pulse, but instead it takes five of them to make a ship break up. And then they use them on ground targets where they really do just look like mortars. They had better torpedoes in 1905.
I don't even remember seeing all those Vulcan ships in a fight befoe good job if you modeled them! Next Star Trek Series should be about Earth Romulan war although I don't think Vulcans and the Andorians would help Earth the war sounded like it was fought Terrans vs. Romulans.
The black level needs to be adjusted, many scenes are way to dark. Also, cut out all the slides with words, and tone the music down. This gets a C- grade.
I remember watching an ep. of enterprise where they highjacked the beetle like romulan ship, because they got pounded on by one, and they had no ship that could maneuver like it, so they resided to highjack one. I think they destroyed it at the end of the show, can't remember been a long time since i saw that ep.
@whitemanstand72 i guess we don't have the guts to digest what we r eating. humans are predators by nature, but so much "democracy" soften our bellies. :))
@ZenithF that makes no sense, yes startrek is written from a human POV, however the Earth romulan war was the only interstellar war to use Atomic weapons! the damage caused is what made the romulans and humans stop the war. and @ benjamin mullin96 the earth romulan war takes place before Kirk (TOS) but after enterprise during archer's time as captain I believe.
What were the beetle ships, looked liked kazon from the delta quad, and why were 2 firing on each other at the end?. Seems like there was lots of friendly fire incidents.
@MrClone501st Hi thanks for the comment glad you liked it most of the clips are form the show, however there are are some clips which are from an animation i saw on youtube can't remember what it's called but if i find it again will let you know. And the clip with the building been blown up 3:16 is from an Voyager episode.
@CBC7118 Actually, the buildings on Earth being blown up is from either DS9 or Enterprise. Voyager only got to Earth once, and it wasn't under attack.
@baalisgod666 Lol how am I a nazi...IF they are fair use great, but there was no mention made of credit or anything else, just that they were taken from someone else's video that he happened to see. Which in most cases would not be allowed. Glad if it is in this case.
how do download this song?
heirofnapoleon 1 day ago
If only this sort of thing happened in Enterprise. It might have saved it.
baalisgod666 1 day ago
very well done , i would of liked to have seen them actually show the earth romulan war as a two hour season endeng and season beginning episode's. because i know they wanted to make their own version of star trek before kirk, but in my opinion they failed in alot of ways. why can't someone come along and still make a good new series but keep the real history correct. whether it is pre-history or future.
jder06 1 week ago 3
@jder06 Unfortunately, all they care about is the next paying gig. They don't really care about Star Trek (or Star Wars, or comic book movies, etc etc).
louisalectube 2 days ago
@jder06 That is sort of the reason that they couldn't make much of the Earth-Romulan war. Kirk was the first human to see a Romulan per the Star Trek timeline.
MrCanadianComedian 6 hours ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Vulcan ships are awesome and unorthodox. Wish to see more modern versions of them.
TemplarX2 1 week ago
Vulcan ships are awesome and unorthodox. Wish to see more modern versions of them.
TemplarX2 1 week ago
I got the NX-01 on Star Trek Online, i know it's not that powerful but it's still nice to have now and then.
ShroudedFury 1 week ago
they should make good film about this war it has so much story and hate <
tadic755 1 week ago
how any times can the enterprise get blown up?!!
collectiveofborg 2 weeks ago
Rather than the Xindi attack they should have had the Romulans attack Earth. That move would have achieved nothing but praise.
Standuble 2 weeks ago
very nice video!
MLangan86 3 weeks ago
If enterprise had gone into a fith season, this was possibly going to be one of the topics. I hate that the show got canceled before the critical thing in Starfleet history was shown.
pardusian141 3 weeks ago
Is this video fan fiction or did this war actually happen in the series Enterprise?
lgr21a5no 3 weeks ago
why am i crying so hard watching this? i guess i have had past life in human- reptilian wars
Gint3r 1 month ago
I hope they kickstart ent the romulan war would have been epic
iDeliverhope 1 month ago
LOL ive seen all these ep's from the enterprise like 40 times over
RagontorProductions 1 month ago
Romulus not Romulas...
luis6079 1 month ago
IS THAT A BREEN PLESH BREK FRIGATE?!?!??!
borgdrone123 1 month ago
where the hell did you get that music?!?!?
borgdrone123 1 month ago
I gotta say...this was kind of confusing...it was a good video, but...the different battles, like the Vulcans vs. Andorians/Enterprise scene kinda confused me...
kickass21ful 1 month ago
what is the song called??
heirofnapoleon 1 month ago
@heirofnapoleon Guardians at the Gate by Audiomachine
CBC7118 1 month ago 6
@CBC7118 This song was in the Avatar trailer, right?
FirstShirtBeastblood 3 weeks ago
@heirofnapoleon Requiem for a Dream
mardlocker500 1 month ago
@mardlocker500 thx man
heirofnapoleon 2 weeks ago
You might want to cut out the scene where Volcan cruisers fire at the Enterprise though...
Qba86 1 month ago
@Qba86 Vulcan... not Volcan... geez... can we get a spell checker for the person who made the video as well.
pmccullo123 1 month ago
Aside from the terrible spelling, it also doesn't make much sense to include V'Las, given he was removed from office (and especially given his secret collaboration with the Romulans).
Other than that, pretty good.
toddsmitts 1 month ago
Just because they have a earth ship does not mean they are earthlings
MrSieish 1 month ago
So, the events montaged here are in the books rather than the series? Well, I just got the books, so I'll have to follow up. Nice video, by the way.
Falchion1984 2 months ago
Awesome video! Had the stations not cancelled Star Trek Enterprise after only 4 seasons, who knows how far the show might've gone. It was one of my favourite Star Trek tv series, next to Star Trek Voyager and The Next Generation. I also appreciate the music. Very dramatic.
Seattlecarnut 2 months ago
@Seattlecarnut i know enterprise was the best shame they stop at season 4 and did not do more
bsgenterprise 1 month ago
@bsgenterprise I agree. Why they discontinued Star Trek Enterprise is beyond me. Neilson be damned, I really didn't think the stations should've cancelled the show when it did.
Seattlecarnut 1 month ago
What episdoe is the scene with the bridge being blown off??
omega856 2 months ago
@omega856 That isn't the bridge. The bridge is on the saucer section.
benjaminmullin96 1 month ago
@benjaminmullin96 Never mind.
benjaminmullin96 1 month ago
@benjaminmullin96 At 1:46 there is a bridge being blown off...what episode is that from?
omega856 1 month ago
@omega856 ENT,Season 3 Episode 8 It's called "Twilight"
CBC7118 1 month ago
where's the shield ???
jeffblitz 2 months ago
@jeffblitz It's from Enterprise, in that series, shields weren't invented yet.
MrAzhrarn 1 month ago
@MrAzhrarn Yes, but they did have hull plating which did provide some protection.
benjaminmullin96 1 month ago
@MrAzhrarn
Whatta ,,,,,???!!! how could when every single shot uses Beam hi-tech arsenal but Shield haven't invented yet its just primitive ^^
jeffblitz 1 month ago
@jeffblitz polarized hull plating gave some minimal protection, but most of the time, the ships simply have armour. :P Enveloping energy barriers are apparently harder to do than phasers. :)
MrAzhrarn 1 month ago
O.o if earth and vulcan and earth are freinds why at 3:05 approx dus a vulcan ship fire on an earth ship O.o
EQINOX187 2 months ago
The book series does it's best to give a view of the Earth-Romulan war. In the books the Romulans began to use a tele-control device to control ships, the Kobayushi Maru scenario came from that. The Kobayushi Maru was being taken over and Enterprise tried to save the ship and crew, but the Romulans attempted to take Enterprise and Archer was left with a no-win scenario, he abandoned the Kobayushi Maru to save Enterprise.
The book series is short, but worth looking up.
ReinaHW 2 months ago
If only they hadn't killed Enterprise. The E-R war would have been epic.
simpsonfan13 2 months ago
nice video
TaCoskun 2 months ago
This footage is from star trek enterprise NX era on the battle with earth and and the andorians versus the vulcans
DUCKDUDE4100 2 months ago
@DUCKDUDE4100 but none the less well done this video is very good
DUCKDUDE4100 2 months ago
Excellent.....nice to hear you picked a great song too. I'm soooooooooooooooooo tired of Requiem for Dream. If I hear it again, I'm going to cut my ears off, LoL
Credithelper75 2 months ago
@Credithelper75 Here here!
Arrakeen77 2 months ago
I've always hated how photon torpedoes are supposed to be antimatter warheads, and they make explosions that look like mortar rounds. One of the things should destroy every ship for thousands of miles with an immense radiation pulse, but instead it takes five of them to make a ship break up. And then they use them on ground targets where they really do just look like mortars. They had better torpedoes in 1905.
aluisious 2 months ago
I don't even remember seeing all those Vulcan ships in a fight befoe good job if you modeled them! Next Star Trek Series should be about Earth Romulan war although I don't think Vulcans and the Andorians would help Earth the war sounded like it was fought Terrans vs. Romulans.
specie8470 3 months ago
The black level needs to be adjusted, many scenes are way to dark. Also, cut out all the slides with words, and tone the music down. This gets a C- grade.
Sunburn2007 3 months ago
such an epic video
OhnoesJG 3 months ago
I remember watching an ep. of enterprise where they highjacked the beetle like romulan ship, because they got pounded on by one, and they had no ship that could maneuver like it, so they resided to highjack one. I think they destroyed it at the end of the show, can't remember been a long time since i saw that ep.
witchphynix 4 months ago
What season of Enterprise is this from?
Battle5tarRJC 4 months ago
@Battle5tarRJC It's not from any season. The Earth-Romulan war took place before Star Trek: Enterprise.
benjaminmullin96 4 months ago
@benjaminmullin96 Ehm...no it didn't.
Battle5tarRJC 2 months ago
@Battle5tarRJC ok...so where do they come form?.....correct me....
ColonelFleet 2 months ago
@ColonelFleet From what I understand Enterprise is the first time they meet the Romulans.
Battle5tarRJC 2 months ago
@ColonelFleet I'm sure there's one episode where they encounter them and Archer asks T'Pol about them.
Battle5tarRJC 2 months ago
yes yes the romulans are the bad guys
while humans are the good guys where we had Hitler, Stalin Bush, Benjamin Yetinhaho, Saddam ...very peaceful place
What the hell is wrong with you trekiees why bes so F****cking racist saying that humans are the good guys. PLease do this again .
whitemanstand72 4 months ago
@whitemanstand72 i guess we don't have the guts to digest what we r eating. humans are predators by nature, but so much "democracy" soften our bellies. :))
ZenithF 3 months ago
@ZenithF that makes no sense, yes startrek is written from a human POV, however the Earth romulan war was the only interstellar war to use Atomic weapons! the damage caused is what made the romulans and humans stop the war. and @ benjamin mullin96 the earth romulan war takes place before Kirk (TOS) but after enterprise during archer's time as captain I believe.
SpookyZalost 3 months ago
Great little movie. Keeps to the canon which considering the limited video material is awesome.
AdmlJoey1701 4 months ago
What were the beetle ships, looked liked kazon from the delta quad, and why were 2 firing on each other at the end?. Seems like there was lots of friendly fire incidents.
EnigmaNZ1 4 months ago
Great job! I wonder what is the music behind?
houndson 4 months ago
They should have used the remans as an explaination for "TOS" and not those stupid drones.
SuperJuliusC 4 months ago
I wish they would make a movie on the Earth-Romulan War. I think it'd make a great story.
hairytoad2008 4 months ago
@CBC7118 AMAZING VIDEO!!! What are the clips from?
MrClone501st 4 months ago 3
@MrClone501st Hi thanks for the comment glad you liked it most of the clips are form the show, however there are are some clips which are from an animation i saw on youtube can't remember what it's called but if i find it again will let you know. And the clip with the building been blown up 3:16 is from an Voyager episode.
CBC7118 4 months ago
@CBC7118 Actually, the buildings on Earth being blown up is from either DS9 or Enterprise. Voyager only got to Earth once, and it wasn't under attack.
KrinkutAlliance 3 months ago
@KrinkutAlliance it's from the Voyager episode Dragons Teeth. It's not earth, it just looks a little like it.
pw8987 2 months ago
@CBC7118 I hope you got permission to use those animation clips.
JWA8402 6 days ago
@JWA8402 doesn't need it. Fair use. Nazi.
baalisgod666 1 day ago
@baalisgod666 Lol how am I a nazi...IF they are fair use great, but there was no mention made of credit or anything else, just that they were taken from someone else's video that he happened to see. Which in most cases would not be allowed. Glad if it is in this case.
JWA8402 1 day ago
@MrClone501st I think the bulk of the clips come from the different seasons of star trek enterprse.....
ColonelFleet 3 months ago
What song is that it's beautiful!
Arqera 6 months ago 3
@Arqera Hi sorry for the long wait in replying the songs Guardians at the Gate by Audiomachine
CBC7118 4 months ago
Hi. That is awesome !!
spacemouse1 9 months ago