Glamorous Sky by Hyde -The Real And Only One-

[MioLuna]

GODVERDOMEN JULLIE ZEGT . . .!!! baai , subete no bodi wa , sutēji jō de kutsujoku wo sōgo sanshō shi te kudasai kanō sei ga aru kimi tachi unmei ni aru . . . FUCK . . .!!!

[Malaquiel09]

WTF... ke mierda... no se escuxa ni una wea bien!!! ¬¬U

[yoshikihammett]

this song was composed by hyde to nana..so what's the problem here? i don't understand

[wbd8568]

what is the title of that album???

[Ninomaru76]

Buy hyde's latest album. The GLAMOROUS SKY english version is the 17th track of the album. I like both Mika's and hyde's versions.

[Rariduz]

yeah the both are great but i like too the girugamesh version!!!!^^

[jameslo93]

WTF IS GOING ON ???????????

[mrbradeliiii]

Just to let you guys know, we do have full version now. Check my channel. I ripped it from the VAMPS LIVE 2008 DVD.

[mithrinwow]

Is that all there is of it? :(

[PedroAsak]

Thank's, I hate the fact the girl who made the other vid can't even recognize the fact it ISN'T hyde and only deceive everybody x_x.

[secretxcode]

Thanks for the real version!

I listened to the fake version and to me it sounds like someone just simply edited the Mika Nakashima single.

I just tried changing the pitch of Mika's voice on this voice morpher program thingy and it sounds like the fake song.

5/5 for you [even if it was short]<3

[japabrasi1]

Mika Nakashima 4ever

[Kallibee]

btw, hyde is not the one who "created" the song per say, Yuzawa Ai wrote it in Nana. Hyde did the musical arrangement and Mika performed so will everyone relax.

+ it's true that the other vid might not be hyde's since his english isn't thaaaat good (for the couple of english phrases spoken like a true anglophone) and the singer's japanese isn't very japanese (his pronounciation) plus he doesn't have that twang that hyde so loves to hit in many of his songs... so yeah...

p.s. I love hyde too

[GlamAholic]

^^aksley Mika did wrote the lyrics

[Kallibee]

Did you not read the manga?

Manga comes out before anime and the creator of Nana, who is Ai Yazawa, is the one who wrote the lyrics IN THE MANGA. HYDE composed the music and Mika interpreted the song, understand?

[LavernaRivers]

yh i was just about to right that exact comment, people should research more b4 bitching.

[barabbass]

wats the big fuzz with this shitty song anyways?

[genesisblack]

I can't wait for VAMPS Live DVD :P ... It seems that the full song G.S. by HYDE will be on the DVD. =D

[Cloud2122]

he composed the song and let them use it lol so whats the big deal? if someone says its not his they are ignorant, but its not fair to burn mika nakashima and company, they were give permission and they even performed a live together. so im not here to start anythng so please be civil and not argue like a bunch of 5 year olds like some people on the H.O.T. and Suju comments lol if you saw it you'd know what i mean.

[springbaby485]

lol the H.O.T. and Suju comments...

[KalB971]

what the hell ? I saw like 5 seconds of "Glamorous Sky"

[Yukihiro21]

lol dumb fangirls and your drama.

>m>

[Cloud2122]

lol ditto

[Kenshinhina]

I don't think he really wanted creds for the song in the first place, that's why he let Mika sing it in the movie. Not to say that I freaking Love Hide~ and I do acknowledge that he composed such a masterpiece.

[GlamAholic]

*correction* He onley wrote the instrumental. Mika did wrote the lyrics :/...not im really fan of them ore something

[secretxcode]

Actually Ai Yazawa the creator of NANA wrote the lyrics ^^

[SpeedPopSnowDrop]

Ai Yazawa wrote the lyrics, Glam. Mika just performed it as NANA. Hyde performed this song when he sang in Mika's hometown during the Faith tour.

As for the fake one, I guess someone got the mp3 and really though it was Hyde. I have listened to more Hyde and L'arc~en~ciel covers by DAi and they're awesome. He has a very nice voice, but he's not Hyde obviously. =)

[Usagichyan]

The other video was hella ghey, so what if he wrote it for mika, the other fid, is shit, and I hate shit attached to hydes name. AND

in all honesty, this video has way more entertainment value.

[Aoikihou]

Lol, no wonder I was like "that isn't by hyde" when my friend showed it to me. :3

Thanks for the video, anyway <3

[Mypinkyrulez]

Chill people. Man. I'm a crazy Hyde fan-girl but I don't feel like blowing up at the guy. Didn't you see the vid where Mika was performing Glamorous sky and Hyde was playing the guitar? Shows that he composed the song, it's no cover, he COMPOSED it. Other than that there should be no fighting. T.T Come on people show the love like it Hyde's song 'Words of Love'.

[gigiekeren]

i love the 'eeh?' he made when a girl asked her 'hyde desu ka?' ^^ i doubt the girls there believed him when he said he just looked like the real hyde.. hehe XD

[billthegeek33]

The other video has the full song, this doesn't.

[qqbbrwo1]

the other video is computer generated i think= = this is the only one

[downwith4kids]

i probably should consider myself fortunate to have the mp3 :)

[tsukiannie1]

Waaaaaa *w*

Hyde the best... a prince... the one...

♥___♥

[eclairwest]

I AGREE WITH XXCOOCONUTT

[JD02]

Thanks alot douche bag, i liked the other version a little better than this shit, that was sarcasm cuz this sucks alot of dick since its not full.

[xBehindDreams]

I believe you saying this is not a real version by Hyde but... I just wanted to point out that this video does not, in any case, prove that it is a fake made by some guy y'know xD. It isn't because Hyde sung it live there that it's a proof... where the hell is the proof ? xD

Whatever x] yea, internet drama; demfae is right ôo.

[BikerBrat]

yeah...why with all the drama? news flash one video isn't going to take away Hyde's "honor and talent" and don't you think a real Hyde fan would know that it wasn't him? So i am formally requesting that you subtract the drama from the video post, and let hyde do his own damn honor saving. :D thanks.

[Emoilijanne]

girugamesh has a cover of the song dumbasses

[wolfgang93]

i could do with the information about the vid not being hyde without the drama thanks. the tittle of the video was 'glamorous sky by hyde'. didn't say anything about being sung by hyde, abet the description. why not try to ask the user to change the description rather than delete the vid. it was be a waste to have such a nice song removed.

[FlyingHat]

Many people tried to send mails. The user never answers back and disabled the comments on the video.

[PockyFueledStudio]

This is total bullshit. We all know it's NOT Hyde. But as far as I know, the guy never CLAIMED he was. Some dumbass found it and thought "Oh, this sounds like Hyde" and started posting it as such and obviously, by putting such a huge name on it, it caught on pretty fucking fast. IT'S NOT HYDE, (I'm pretty sure) HE NEVER CLAIMED TO BE. GET OVER IT, HON.

[xxcooconutt]

who cares...?

his music, he can do aaanyhing that he wants with it

if it is his voice or not in the other one, is a daaamn so good cover

it's good sounds like him

like it, if is him YEAAH! good hyde!...period, why the drama?

[FlyingHat]

why the drama? Because Hyde can do so much more better than this "DAI" guy on internet. He composed this song FOR Mika Nakashima and he's not the type that takes things back. Well, don't say I don't know him etc. I'm just saying he's a good person.

[Songofwyrd]

This is a pretty dramatastic posting. I wouldn't blame anyone for mistaking DAI's version for Hyde.

[visualmicstand]

well all i know is hyde wrote glamerous sky for nana so who knows

[littlemonkey246]

yay..... i like the real one

[ATBG]

well i guess a white dude sang a cover of that song and lied.....he sang it good.

[evilmini86]

OMG, fucking THANK YOU! Anyone who seriously think that fake piece of shit even remotely sounds like him should die. Thank you for going this. Thank you. The Gods will smile down upon you for you speak truth and only those with a sick attention to detail, like you and myself, may understand. For anyone else... listen to him. Just turn on any song. Any live. Any thing at all. What does he sound like? Think about it.

[thechosenonedude]

You are kinda sick in the head aren't ya O_o, what if that "fake" version wasn't him, it was still very impressive, I don't see you singing that good O_o

[FlyingHat]

Well, I don't see the link with us singing or doing better Oo. We never said it is bad. It's just a matter of recognition.

[NamedtheNickel]

Yaanh...you're really immature.

Quite frankly, at times that version does sound like him. There is no proof he didn't do it or proof he did. Maybe he recorded it and didn't put it on a cd. Honestly, it's very obvious it isn't NANA's version edited, different pauses, enunciation, etc. However, no one knows WHO sang the song. At times the voice reminds me of HYDE singing Pretty Girl (L'arc~en~Ciel) or Time Goes By (VAMPS)

[NamedtheNickel]

And just to add further...most artists sing their songs different in lives. So a 5 second clip isn't proof at all darling ;)

[demfae]

You could check out DAi from soundclick(dot)com; he also has covers from other Jrock songs such as Akatsuki from Alice Nine. It's his cover of Glamorous Sky that a few people have been trying to pass off as Hyde's - probably without his knowledge. Hardcore fans of Hyde then reacted violently. Thus, internet drama. :)

[FlyingHat]

about the drama, when we got the idea to make this video we were in some kind of hilarious wave like "lets just do it !". So the drama impression is just to make the video less empty, less boring, and longer, in fact. And because we thought that we could just do as big as we can, because it's funnier.

[hydylover]

Hyde wrote Glamorous Sky for Nakashima Mika... I went to VAMPS concert in Sendaii and Hyde sang it..

[littlemonkey246]

i did not hear glamorous sky -_-

[mrbradeliii]

Listen Harder.

[MyladyC]

1st why you all say hyde COVERED that song...he need not to 'cover' a song he wrote xD

And if somebody is interessed in...the 'fake' version is a in my opinion loveley cover made by DAi ... I think he has a nice voice...IMO

and I definitly won't report the other one...it's just childish sorry...

[telyde]

wow.

this video made me want to have the Faith DVD

nice towards the end when they were playing outdoors..

lucky people who were there to hear them...

and yeah. the other vid... is not HYDE at all. :/

[waf10011]

Ok wow

[ChiruSama]

so he did cover the song, wow. I wish i could see the whole performance..

i like it^^ because it's Hyde XD

and the cover by girugamesh (I like the band too) but it's not as nice as Mika-chans xP

[eudy13]

im not sure its really a cover, since he wrote it.

[Vinkkaz]

You can fake Nakashima Mika's voice and change to "HYDE" version by adding the effect using softwares such as Adobe Audition and so on. I can tell the others are fake because "HYDE" shouts are different than the "REAL HYDE"..

[kyokohimura]

Yeah... I just went to listen to it before I came here and it didn't sound like him at all to me. And I have all the Laruku and HYDE songs... it didn't sound right. I'm glad to know I wasn't crazy! I didn't know he covered it at all, but it was very nice, eventhough it was short! <3

[Bladed0edge0razor]

His real name is Hideto Takarai.

[StarlightLullaby]

Wow, I had heard that the other one was fake, but I didn't know there was a real/true version/that Hyde really did cover it. You can definitely tell this is real though,each note is perfect, as would be expected of the man who composed the music <3

[onyxhikari]

Honestly I didn't think that it really sounded like Hyde in the other one...This sounds just like him, and whether he preformed it or not, him playing the guitar and composing it should be proof enough that his talent is awewome!!

[jefferydu]

最好是hyde啦

到關鍵的時候還不是跳到別的畫面

為什麼不是一氣呵成的，根本就騙人

少在那邊想魚目混珠，無聊

[xsugarxhighx]

i still don't think that HYDE has ever actually "PERFORMED" it. his voice was off and so was his silhouette.

but that may just be me.

[kikusama]

well actually..... Hyde composed the music for the song "Glamorous Sky." the lyrics were written by Ai Yazawa (who also wrote the manga).Mika Nakashima (Nana) just sung it.

[kikusama]

DUH HYDE WROTE IT

[NOLARCNOMUSIC]

XDDDD don't be mad man!!! you know, a lot of stupid fans who are so fool!!!

jajaja I think he thinks that his voice is same as haido sama and he feel like a star jajaja but real fans know that haido sama's voice is unique!!!

[Bladed0edge0razor]

So.....hyde did not create Glamorous sky???

[kestralkitsune]

Hyde wrote Glamorous sky and it was performed by two bands, Mika Nakashima for the NaNa movie, and Girugumesh who covered it. Hyde how ever I believe performed it live once but never actually released a single for it.

if anyone wants the girugumesh cover I have it and can email me.

[hiroki0da0gya]

waiiiit wait, that last part of ur vid confused me. Is the whole video supposed to depict to the real Hyde? Cos the guy at the end denied it, and said "people tell me i'm really similar to hyde". Or was that all a joke

[hydebelle]

haha... it was hyde's lil joke. You know how celebs don't like to admit it's them to prevent being mobbed? Same deal here.

[tubuline]

funny that I only find some similarities between Hyde's voice and the cover version.

the problem is that they labelled this cover version as if it was really hyde's :/

[Songofwyrd]

This was clearly a huge issue that required the overblown text labelling on the video.

I love internet drama.

[hizomihimori]

nw that i hear it...its too weak to be Hyde's voice

[demfae]

Old issue, but please don't blame DAi (from soundclick) for this; I don't even think he knows that his cover was uploaded. If there's anyone to blame, it should be silly_disco from LiveJournal because that person was the one who put up DAi's cover version (probably without his permission) and said it was Hyde's.

[LucyJekyll]

The voice of the referred video is almost identically similar to Hyde's, and the quality is very pro... but the style just does not match. The cover made by Chris (named: Glamorous Sky Cover by Chris) is, I think, closer to the way Hyde would sing it.

I don't think this person should be penalized, but if it is a joke, it should be stated in the description.

[rmanime]

I don't think whoever posted the video is the one who sung it cause he has it on his soundclick. soundclick dott com / dai

It wouldn't make sense. Someone probably just took it and labelled it as HYDE for some reason -___-;

[hydessnowdrop]

I remember seeing comments once on that video and I guess they were removed. This guy is not a bad singer, in fact he's really good...but he's not Hyde in my opinion. I thought his pronunciation sounded off. Hyde feels every song and would've rocked this in his rocker voice, especially at the end. He also says niji with heavy g sound...hyde has never pronounced it that way he always says niji (neehee) with h sound (just watch any l'arc~en~ciel live niji performance).

[kanzakki]

Hmmm... At first I thought that it was hyde singing in that other vid, but when the song progressed, something felt -off- and weird about it. It felt like hyde was downplaying his singing. I mean, if it really was hyde singing I think he'd do a better job. hyde has a wide vocal range and I doubt he'd go falsetto during parts in the chorus (unless it was intentional, of course).

[kiwichibi]

hmm...i had watched the vid just before (it's just a song w/hyde pic)but interestingly enough when i listened to it i immediately thought to myself that this doesn't sound like hyde (honestly). I thought maybe he was trying a new style. The vocals are too...rich/dampered? It makes me feel lazy...yappari i think Mika Nakashima's version is closests to what feeling I want from the song. I wanted to love Gilgamesh's version more than hers but...oh well.

[KitsuneKonno]

I don't wish to be rude but if this is such a big deal, has anyone tried messaging the person who uploaded the other video and told him it wasn't Hyde nicely and politely ask to change the title? just a thought o.O

[Darkdreamer1315]

I agree. I don't think that person's video should be flagged as inappropriate, and that they should be asked to change the title. I mean, yea, it's not the real Hyde or anything, but don't penalize the poor person. I'm sure all they were trying to do was put out a song for all of his fans.

-Maybe they didn't know it was fake. They could have just found it and assumed it was real. :/

[Darkdreamer1315]

sorry- I forgot to mention I was agreeing with KitsuneKonno.

[FlyingHat]

Are you a fool? We can't comment on the guy's video, and sending a mail he won't read is useless ! There's no reason he desactivated the comments if he doesn't know it was a fake, the situation doesn't even make him totally innocent.

[StephanieLacus]

I was about to say that, all they want are views -___-U nothing more than that and that's why they're using Hyde's name..

[shinwu86]

hey, hey, i dont understand at all...what are you talking about, is there anyone can give me some explain, whats the matter is it?....

[haganenorenkinfull]

plz people stop being so stupid type in L'arc~en~Ciel at wikipedia (at leats in spanish) and you will see a paragraph that says "hyde wrote the lyrics and arrange part of the song for mika", and only in one time they were together, buy hyde only played guitar

[FlyingHat]

Exactly.

[hydeist6055]

you need more training to be hyde... maybe u cant... dont judge him by only a sentence of the song.. i think nobody can be hyde..give up !! copy pasting stuff like him into this? crap?

[ReRe12346]

Hmm..im a bit torn on this one..

However the "fake" video is very well done and someone would have to have some expensive equipment/resources to pull it off

I agree the japanese is a bit off on the vid and it probably is a fake however im not sure if it really discredits hyde because whoever sang it did a pretty good job and its a shame he would pose as hyde rather than giving himself the credit

[FlyingHat]

Well, that's part of our point of view. But this is not the case here (about the credits).

[GarbagePlanet]

I mean what is innapropriate about it? Just that it happens to someone immitating hyde. So if I want to upload a video of one of my friends singing Glamorous Sky, I shouldn't be allowed to?

[FlyingHat]

The problem is the credits. If you cover something that's done by someone else and not you, you got to give credits and not pretend it's the guy.

Well this is just a shame people could actually think it's Hyde, cause it's not, and we all know Hyde could do a hundred time better. That's all.

Please read the author's comment and other people's comment before posting your point of view.

[GarbagePlanet]

And it is rediculus to say that it is the one that needs to be flagged as innapropriate, if it isn't even using copyrighted audio like all the other hyde videos on youtube!

[GarbagePlanet]

even ridiculus

[GarbagePlanet]

But it's sang so well.  Why push to have it removed? Fake or not, it's a good tribute to hyde.

[GarbagePlanet]

sung even

[FlyingHat]

A tribute implies credits.

[hanacher]

good job!!

[yukka15]

hehe, at the ending of this vid, the girl ask him " Hyde-san desuka?"(are you hyde?)

then he said,"Yoku niterutteiwaremasu"(people often say 'you looks like hyde')

it was seacret show on that street!

[Aiyoukim]

Lol fangirls amuse me.

[shesadramaqueen]

Didn't he write the song for Mika?

[MyladyC]

Yes he did write it for Mika as Oosaki Nana - up to now it is the first and only song he wrote for somebody else.

[Clearie552]

look just because someone made a mistake and thought it was hyde singing when it wasnt, doesnt mean you have to ban the video... -_- geta life.

[Yannh]

Well, you don't understand the meaning and the logic we're giving here. This is the only video recording we got in wich Hyde is performing Glamorous Sky. And we got no official single or whatever product in wich there is the song Glamorous Sky sung by Hyde, neither on Hyde's Official Website.

[Yannh]

Hyde would not produce anything free and secret especially for Internet circle, and there would be no reason for him to do this. Actually, he only spread some amateur video he recorded with him camera for fun, in wich he only takes the lower part of peoples body and himself being dressed up for example. If you take a better look on Youtube, you got this same fake version with the title "Hyde (by DAi from soundclick)- Glamorous Sky ( Video)", wich proves that this has been made by an amateur.

[Yannh]

Moreover, this video we made is also for personal sound recognition, and Hyde is not the kind of person that changes the tone of a song he sings (see Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds and Careless Wishper) because his voice can reach many many notes. That's why he didn't pitch the song in this live, whereas the other guy who did that fake is not as good as him, so he had to pitch the song to be able to sing it more easily.

[Larcrocks]

Okay I understand that the other vid is supposedly a fake and I understand that that is really Hyde live in the video you made Yannh. But how are you so sure that it's not Hyde in the other vid. It sorta sounded like him to me. You're trying to compare the "fake vid" to a live performance and that doesn't work. Live performances of songs almost always sound different than if they're in a recording area with some sound quality.

[Slackah]

That other video is definitely not hyde. I really doubt hyde would sing that low for any song. Since Glamorous Sky was meant for Mika Nakashima, I doubt hyde would rerelease the song with his own voice. He would just simply play the song for fun at lives, like what he did with "I'm so happy." Even though he wrote the song, it still belongs to L'Arc. And if it sounded good and he likes it, it will come out along with a single, like "Lucy in the Sky..." That's just my interpretation.

[Ainafetse]

Are you really a fan oh HYDE???? Sorry but I'm his fan, I hear him all this years, all his voice's changes trough the ages and YES, this is his voice, the another one is a faker, with similar timbre on his voice but that's all, HYDE have his personal voice, oh my God... I can put my hand on fire that this is the real because I haver the DVD and the oother a faker, no more than that!

[Ainafetse]

for:

Larcrocks

[XXCandyXYZ]

Totally agree with you. I have been listening to L'Arc for more than 10 years now, and no matter how different he sounds live or changes singing style through out the years, he still has this "personal voice", I can always pick out instantly if it's him or not. The other vid is definetely fake. I can bet my head on it. Also that singer is not a native speaker. He has accent, and mis pronaunciatons. What's pissed me off more is the people who claim to be his fans and can't even if it's hyde

[Ainafetse]

Totally agree darling^^

[HYDEcamui]

I agree.

[Larcrocks]

Listen don't start getting pissed off at me or trying to make me feel bad about what I said. I won't take it back and I'm not apologizing. I said what I thought. Besides you guys do know that it was Hyde that created this song for Mika Nakashima right? He even played guitar for her during one performance.

[FlyingHat]

People, don't forget to flag as inappropriate the fake videos =D. And why not give it 1 star >>.

[babyjan83]

ThankSS Yannh... for putting this up!!! I told them umpteenth times the "Glamorous Sky by HYDE" video was a fake.. My mouth ran out of saliva!!... Now prove to all the IDIOTS!!!! *ARGGGHHHH*

*Bangs keyboard*

[eien92]

...okay I have been doubting about Glamorous Sky for a long time, that if it was really hyde, and now I'm sure it's not. Thanks for this.

[kof97]

es el mejor!!!!! kawaiiiiiiii!!

[guitarrocker1]

this was in the house of blues

[KanameHarisen]

evvivaaa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!qual­cuno che ha capito XD questa è la vera GLAMOROUS SKY cantata da HYDE!!!*____* grande!!! (la voglio in un singolo çç)

[Annemone00001]

That guy is WRONG to label it as "hyde-glamourous sky" when he is not sure that it's hyde who sings it. Well if he thinks that it's hyde, then shame on him because he can't even reconize hyde's voice although he is a fan. He should really change its title because it's giving poeple wrong information and impressions.

[FlyingHat]

I'm calm, I didn't say the other guy's singing was awful, the problem is that he do not say he is another guy, the title is "Glamorous Sky BY Hyde". Actually if it was "Glamorous Sky cover by me", I wouldn't blame him, I may even support him.

Now try to think before saying, that may be more apreciable and useful, thank you for your comment.

[FlyingHat]

And Hyde could and can sing as high as Mika Nakashima actually, even if she's got a woman voice. It's Hyde lol ! If you listen to "New World" from L'Arc~En~Ciel's Awake album, he's hitting notes and one note particularly (and it's not a head voice note) even higher that any note from Glamorous Sky (exept the high note in head voice).

Real fans I know instantly recognized it was not Hyde and some people are thanking us for the video we made. Now just chose the right side.

[FlyingHat]

waranghira, it is obviously not Hyde in the fake video... He just took the instrumental version from Mika Nakashima's single and pitched the song one tone higher because he's already singing in a lower octave because he has troubles to sing too low propably, he's not Hyde afterall.

Even if you compare the 2 videos, you can obviously hear that their voice are different! And Hyde didn't make any single of his own version, a real fan should know this.

[Yannh]

With you, now I'm not sur xDD

But I think hyde have the octave of Mika, but you don't think because Mika are a feminine voice and hyde have a low voice. But is the key

[waranghira]

its both in the key of E. but hyde's vocals is one octave lower comnpared to that of Mika's.

if you still insist, im not gonna argue anymore

[Yannh]

Once again, I've listen the music of Mika, and.. I was wrong.. Hyde sang it in a lower octave.. Now I'm agree. excuse me.

But,It's not my really probleme..That guy is pretending to be Hyde !!! And everyone trust him and believe it's Hyde, here I got the proof he's not.

We already said all this in the "author's comment"

[waranghira]

dude, this is not proof @_@

[PiggyGaara]

i agree.

[HYDEcamui]

Me too. I mean, how do we know for sure that the other video is not Hyde? In fact, I have the song that is in question. I downloaded it somewhere and I think it sounds exactly like Hyde. The thing is though, this video didn't really discredit the other video, sorry. One possibility is that Hyde actually did record this single, but never meant for it to be released. Then it somehow got leaked all over the internet. I dunno, just a hypothesis.

[riceboi330]

b/c the in the fake video, some of the lyrics are mispronounced. like "a" which should have been pronounced ah was pronounced like "eh"

hyde would probably not mispronounce lyrics spoken in his native tongue. dont you agree? furthurmore, even if he did, the video in question is a recording. if hyde did sing it, and he accidently mispronounced a word, which everyone does once in a while, wouldnt he have gone back and fixed it?

[HYDEcamui]

I have no idea what line you're referring to, but like I said, the recording could have never meant to be released. I don't know. You could be right and I wrong, which is likely, but I still think that this video really doesn't discredit the other one.

[jielunfan92]

>> "how do we know for sure that the other video is not Hyde"

if you really think so....im sorry

but you need your ear checked

the guy doesnt even have a similar timbre.

he's just opening his throat in a similar way that hyde does to sing

an also, the other vid is not even sung by

a japanese person. I could tell cuz im fully

japanese

[HYDEcamui]

No, my ear is working properly, thank you very much. What I mean is, this video does nothing to disprove the other one. If you really, really think the other video is a fake, then great. Anyway, whatever. I'm done arguing.

[waranghira]

wow, its the same key as to nana's, only that he sang it an octave lower...

whereas the interpretation you're talking about is transposed to another.

well, you still haven't proven that its a FAKE. XD

so I dunno what to believe.

[FlyingHat]

You better believe what your hear and see over what you read.

It's obviously Hyde who's singing (you can see Hyde, it's from an official product, alright), so it's Hyde voice, so if you have a minimum of sound recognition capacity (or whatever), you should understand that the other one is just pretending to be original ! He just pitched the instrumental version in Mika Nakashima's single and sang over it, you can even recognize it from the sound quality !

The most popular is not the better.

[waranghira]

duh..? :O

I know that the live from this vid is genuine and him. The problem Im talking about is that the other interpretation of the supposedly hyde is still in question if its real or not- cause this vid didn't prove anything.

and how are you sure that its just the instrumental version hightened to some semitones?

[Yannh]

Of course, the instrumental version lowted to some semitone, Do you really think that Hyde should do it ? xD Hyde is a good singer, he didnt should pitched her song for her recording.

[waranghira]

in this live version, he didn't change the key of the song. its the same key as to Mika's.

but he sang it in a lower octave.

the supposedly fake version is still higher pitched than to this live version.

[Yannh]

I know, but hyde have the key and the octave of Mika, He can sing like she if he want, he didn't need to pitch anything..

[waranghira]

no, he doesn't have the octave of Mika. that's it

[Yannh]

Oops, Dude xcuse me xD please read the last comment I've forgotten to do "reply"