Her voice is contralto, those voices are much more difficult to find that the typical mezzo as Amy. Cristina has an excellent voice with a lovely contralto vocal range for.
I so love Amy Lee. She's so stunning and she has an absolutely amazing voice. Unlike Scabbia's boring voice and conventional looks with a vocal range so limited...
@funkyfranx ok well no youre wrong. most of these pics were taken when she was younger, now she doesnt dress like that anymore but is still hot as hell. and im ignorant? tht means alot coming from the butt hurt amy lee fan
Ok, learn correct grammar, then I might take you seriously. Do you honestly think the opinion of someone who is too ill-educated to even type means anything at all to me?
there both so Amzing but I have to say Amy lee;s voice just so damn Angelic and Amazing I swear. Don't get me wrong Cristina has an amazing voice too but Its not Amy's.
@allisonrose01 true it's actually really Beautiful. it isn't photoshopped either. amy's just a naturally beautiful woman. even with little to no makeup
Yeah, Amy doesn't need to dress up like one of those sex dungeon mistresses to look beautiful. And Scabbia's voice got annoying after a few seconds. I vote Amy!
Definitely Amy Lee! She has more talent. Plays Piano, Guitar, and Harp. Knows how to do string arrangements, and has a higher range than Cristina. Cristina is not bad, and I do enjoy Lacuna Coil too, but if we're to judge on pure talent, Amy takes the trophy.
It's true. Amy Lee does have more talent. The reason I like evanescence more is because 1st of all, i have two of their album. 2nd of all, I've known evanescence way longer than lacuna coil. And that is why i like evanescence more. I don't mean to be rude to the lacuna coil fans, but that is just my deepest, most personal opinion.
so I love both of these singers for two different reasons.
1. I love Amy Lee for her soaring vocals and her ability to grow as an artist. I mean the woman can sing, play piano, guitar, and the harp.
2. I love Christina Scabbia for her voice. I like because it's kind of raspy but still able to hit those high notes which sound great.
Overall both of these bands are amazing but on different levels. It's hard to compare Evanescence to another band because there really is no other band like them
Amy Lee is good but I like Lacuna Coil slightly more. I love how Lacuna Coil used to have this ethereal sound (In albums like Comalies & In a Reverie). And I think Scabbia has a slightly more angelic voice. I'm not really into their latest work (Shallow Lies) but she is still a good singer in my eyes and well, I just pick her. = )
Amy Lee(great singer/performer/attractive) wins with the fans who have been feed Poop(POP) music as the only sound around.Cristina just WINS with fans who are not cagged in by someone else telling them what to like(corporate music)!!Lacuna Coil will set you Free!
Cristina is in a much better band. And is far more versatile as a singer. As for looks, Amy Lee looks great......as long as she has wears tons of makeup and has a puffy dress to cover up her pudgy figure. Can't blame her though. Eating American food can do that to you!
@studleythename haha great comment but you know as well as I do that the yanks will choose their own everytime no matter how wrong they know they are.
fuck this comparing i like them both, cristina for her talent to make her voice sound so gentle and strong on the other hand.... and amy lee, her style is so emotional..
While I like both, I lean more towards Christina. Her vocals on the albums Closer and In a Riverie were awesome. Amy Lee is awesome too but I like Christina's music more. Evanescence does have better backing theatrics though, I will give them that. = )
I don't even know why people compare these two bands. They sound completely different. Oh, and cristina is way hotter and a much better singer. :) Amy is whiny and way too commercial. Ever hear cristina sing live? Just as good as recorded.
lol...i like amy lee more than christina!amy lee has more originality than Christina!i love amy's VOICE coz its kinda good to listen ttoo, but chritina i dont think her voice is gud!just saying!
Many people usually say that Evanescence and Lacuna Coil are just the same shit. But i think they are wrong. Both bands have a similar sound but female´s voices are diffrent, thanks God. I would like to know what people here think about.
Crisss! Lacuna Coil is better than Evanescence, they make better music, Evanescence is sooo comercial, Lacuna Coil is best! But Evanescence is a good group
Cristina scbbia and Amy Lee in some of those pictures kinda like a little alike in the face.
Anyways as far as music and songs are considered between the 2, i think they both are great artists and attractive as hell. I'm one who grow up liking Amy Lee's music and songs as far as women singers are considered which was in 2002 or 2003.
Cristina Scbbia from i didn't ever hear of tell last year in 2010 by mistake, but both female singers, you can get meaning from their song's and their music rocks
if we what to talk about a female singer who dresses up we need to talk about
Lady Gaga
which im one who could care alot less about her music and dam sure as hell her dressing up, and her music is a joke, or anyways her so called songs and she's weird as hell.
if you want to also talk about a woman who dresses like a whore or anyways a mess up who
People call Cristina a whore because they're too idiotic to appreciate art when they see it. If you look at her pictures, she's artistic, not a slut, and she models. Her music is beautiful and more meaningful with more emotion, and while Amy Lee is busy dressing up like Disney movies, she's in Rezophonic building wells for villages in Kenya. To the lot of you Evanescence fans, please leave her alone. ...
Its all about the vocals. Ever hear either of them live? Cristina sounds awful, nothing like the beautiful music that is on her albums, while Amy's live performances are breathtaking. Amy Lee's voice is one of the best I've ever heard. <3
@TheOnlyTempesT Listen, it is never okay to talk about someone behind their back especially when I didn't do anything and the only reason you said these things was out of hurt because I didn't want to start our toxic relationship again. I probably saved both our lives by doing so, but I know I will never get a thank you because you aren't mature enough to open your eyes and see that the hurtful things you say and have said do mean something to me. They aren't just words spoken out of anger..
@xApokalypseN0w oh and cheats on him too wit some weird looking faggot named "dimitri" lmfao, she cheated on me on the internet with some fabio mother fucker rofl, jesus, at least if your gonna cheat on me do it with someone better than me, fuck lol
Any Lacuna Coil album slaughters everything that Ev ever made and will make in the future. Plus at least Cristina Scabbia doesn't need to shout out her notes and lets them come naturally. As a side note bashing your ex through music is a hell of a lot worse than looking sexy once in a while.
@VelvetSmilex At least Cristina doesn't have to go on tirades to prove the Lacuna doesn't suck. And In A Reverie or Unleashed Memories and some others slaughters everything Ev ever made. Plus if Cristina weren't attractive I still appreciate the atmospheric music the band provides and they take huge risks with their sound.
scabbia, is a whore, just look at her band pictures, half naked. amy doesent have to sell her body.who plays 3 instroments?who won 2 grammys and a nomination?who owns the greatest songwriter award that can be presented to an artist?who has sold well over 20 million albums, but managed to not sell out? who HAS sold out arenas all over the world? who inspired me and millions more to pick up an instoment, and a pen? whos lyrics connect with people so well, it has saved lives? eva-fucking-nescence
omg, i can't choose!!! I've loved them both from the very beginning that I've EVER heard of them, which was YEARS ago, and really, the truth is, I think they'd make an awesome couple, lol. BUT ANYWAY!!! Forget I said that......ahem....they're both so cool.
Even though i think this whole comparison thing between them is goofy, their music while similar, is totally different.. As is their voices, and style of vocals.. as far as looks go, they are both beautiful women.. Any Man would be Hard pressed to choose between them.. lol.. but, Cristina Scabbia is THE, Princess of Metal.. That will Never change.. Amy is softer, a Kitten... Cristina is a full grown Tigress.. With a Powerful voice to back it up ! The Powerful Princess of Metal... Rules !
@KoRnKob11 I know what people's problems are: They're too shallow & only "love" for looks all the time & not for who a person really is or what good talents they possess. That's the problem
The only reason people think Cristina is more attractive is because she dresses like a slut. Amy Lee doesn't do that because she has decent morals (though she is way more attractive). As for singing, composing and pretty much everything else amy lee is way better.
@adamrules2010 Cristina is better for much, she has work with Alter Brdige, Apocaliptyca, MEGADETH, Franco Battiato and Rezophonic (wich help to Africa puting in wells to help with water scarcity) she has record 5 studio albums. with her band she has been in countrys like India, Japon.
@gerematria Amy Lee has been more successful with evanescence than all the other bands you just mentioned. The number of records someone puts out has nothing to do with quality of music and neither does how many countrys they have been in so none of that information shows that she is better than Amy Lee.
@KoRnKob11 Kornkob, I have so much respect for you right now, it's not even funny. I'm glad someone stood up for Amy & other women with the same body structure as her. :3
Christina wins in my opinion, shes been around way longer, her style is so cool and belongs to her cause no one can copy it, shes a lot hotter obviously, and shes a Euro chick, I mean c'mon Euro chicks will always win over any run of the mill typical American girl. Also I enjoy listening to music when my ears don't bleed, Amy lee sings in the same frequency as a friggin smoke detector or when someone opens an emergency exit. Anyways thats just my addition to the question
@ffacfreak I like Amy's tone better, but I'm not so bias about my preference that I'd over look that fact that Amy Lee struggles singing live. It shows. Not saying she can't sing, but she's singing in a way that is not healthy for that beautiful tone she has.
@ffacfreak I like Amy's tone better, but I'm not so bias about my preference that I'd over look that fact that Amy Lee struggles singing live. It shows. Not saying she can't sing, but she's singing in a way that is not healthy for that beautiful tone she has.
On looks: Cristina is just so hot even in her late 30's. Amy Lee has a big following and some talent but Lacuna Coil is the better band overall for all round musicianship.
Cristina is the sort of women that you see their beauty, Amy Lee is the other sort of women, that you feel their beauty. For the voice, Cristina does have an awesome one, but Amy Lee is just way better.
Still both of Evanescence and Lacuna Coil are my favorite bands ( with A7X )
i like both of them but because i've recently found out about lacuna coil, i'm going to have to say amy lee since i've known evanescence for about 7 years.
I give Evanescence credit in me finding Lacuna Coil. I've had both on my MP3 player, several albums of each and shuffled them and listened both for a long time. In the end Lacuna Coil won out as my fave. Yo Cristina!
I'd take Cristina Scabbia for her strong voice and also Lacuna Coil as a band because I looked up the guitar tabs and they are harder to play than any Evanescence song.
Did the person who made this video ask for insults about the singers? I don't see that anywhere in the description. SO STOP BEING RUDE AND JUST SAY WHICH ONE YOU LIKE BETTER AND DON'T SAY MEAN THINGS ABOUT THE OTHER SINGER. GEEZ. They're both equally great, I think. But in my opinion, Amy's my favorite. Christina is great too.
Cristina!!!!!
MustaineIStheMessiah 1 week ago
Amy Lee
Evanescence7654 2 weeks ago
Amy Lee is faaaaar better and always will be.
towelie120592 3 weeks ago
sorry but no disrespect to amy lee but cristina scabbia is at the top of the food chain.
86weldon 1 month ago
CRISTINA RULES!!!
Her voice is contralto, those voices are much more difficult to find that the typical mezzo as Amy. Cristina has an excellent voice with a lovely contralto vocal range for.
Nanamc07 1 month ago 2
I so love Amy Lee. She's so stunning and she has an absolutely amazing voice. Unlike Scabbia's boring voice and conventional looks with a vocal range so limited...
funkyfranx 1 month ago
@funkyfranx umm say what u want about voice, thats opinion. but cristina being hotter than hell itself is pure fact
MustaineIStheMessiah 1 week ago
@MustaineIStheMessiah
No you ignorant fuck head, she's s thirty year old dressing like a fifteen year old, she needs to fucking grow up.
funkyfranx 1 week ago
@funkyfranx ok well no youre wrong. most of these pics were taken when she was younger, now she doesnt dress like that anymore but is still hot as hell. and im ignorant? tht means alot coming from the butt hurt amy lee fan
MustaineIStheMessiah 1 week ago
@MustaineIStheMessiah
Ok, learn correct grammar, then I might take you seriously. Do you honestly think the opinion of someone who is too ill-educated to even type means anything at all to me?
funkyfranx 1 week ago
@funkyfranx Oh I'm sorry oh lord of grammer!!
MustaineIStheMessiah 1 week ago
there both so Amzing but I have to say Amy lee;s voice just so damn Angelic and Amazing I swear. Don't get me wrong Cristina has an amazing voice too but Its not Amy's.
zellytega12 1 month ago
They're just amazing!
AlatreusDyesis 2 months ago
Yum-ness!!!
The68wolf 2 months ago
the picture of amy lee at 0:22 is just all-out beautiful!
allisonrose01 2 months ago
@allisonrose01 It is yes. But photoshopped.
LoveMusicForeverLMF 2 months ago
@allisonrose01 true it's actually really Beautiful. it isn't photoshopped either. amy's just a naturally beautiful woman. even with little to no makeup
zellytega12 1 month ago
Scabbia is alot hotter. And there are way too many Poprockers on youtube.
mupp33n 2 months ago
I would totally marry them both XD
TheLightningSpeed100 2 months ago
Amy is better, but Christina is good also, I like them both XD
TheLightningSpeed100 2 months ago
If you compare them both live..Cristina Scabbia wins by far..Amy Lee can't sing live at all..
xXCharliiXShadowsXxX 3 months ago
Yeah, Amy doesn't need to dress up like one of those sex dungeon mistresses to look beautiful. And Scabbia's voice got annoying after a few seconds. I vote Amy!
cjmsja 3 months ago
I love both and i think Amy lee is better than Cristina Scabbia of lacuna coil. both of them have perfect personalitys. there my favorite musicans.
SkullFadesAway 3 months ago
Amy lee
N1nj4K4m1K4Z31 3 months ago
Definitely Amy Lee! She has more talent. Plays Piano, Guitar, and Harp. Knows how to do string arrangements, and has a higher range than Cristina. Cristina is not bad, and I do enjoy Lacuna Coil too, but if we're to judge on pure talent, Amy takes the trophy.
keytroniclove 3 months ago
@keytroniclove
It's true. Amy Lee does have more talent. The reason I like evanescence more is because 1st of all, i have two of their album. 2nd of all, I've known evanescence way longer than lacuna coil. And that is why i like evanescence more. I don't mean to be rude to the lacuna coil fans, but that is just my deepest, most personal opinion.
allisonrose01 2 months ago
Amy Lee <3
I agree with ravenbalckbutterfly
Amy is so unique xxx
Cristina... alright.
And I'm italian, so no biased opinions here...
funkyfranx 3 months ago
i love Amy but Cristina takes this.....amazing personality too
SheenaAlexis 3 months ago
Lee Is Definitely The Queen.
XxAlexiaStarxX 3 months ago
@XxAlexiaStarxX
Amy Lee is the Queen of rock n roll, hands down!
allisonrose01 2 months ago in playlist Watch Later
i vote for amy she wins
mennatarek2468 3 months ago
i vote for amy she wns
mennatarek2468 3 months ago
My vote for Cristina.
bugsy4173 3 months ago
but u have 2 admit even tho Cristina is older she is still hot
Bioman6262 3 months ago
I like the Original Evanescence better.
1846alexander 3 months ago
Italian do it better...CRISTINA SCABBIA WINS!!! \m/
itarooby 4 months ago 2
AMY LEE <3 SHE IS THE QUEEN
BellaSwan323x 4 months ago
so I love both of these singers for two different reasons.
1. I love Amy Lee for her soaring vocals and her ability to grow as an artist. I mean the woman can sing, play piano, guitar, and the harp.
2. I love Christina Scabbia for her voice. I like because it's kind of raspy but still able to hit those high notes which sound great.
Overall both of these bands are amazing but on different levels. It's hard to compare Evanescence to another band because there really is no other band like them
AlternativeLifeTV 4 months ago
Amy Lee is good but I like Lacuna Coil slightly more. I love how Lacuna Coil used to have this ethereal sound (In albums like Comalies & In a Reverie). And I think Scabbia has a slightly more angelic voice. I'm not really into their latest work (Shallow Lies) but she is still a good singer in my eyes and well, I just pick her. = )
Kaicoyote 4 months ago
Evanescence fucking RIPPED off Lacuna Coil END OF STORY
ladydroon 4 months ago
amy lee hands down
772117 4 months ago
@jaredaz07
NO Amy Lee's songs r NOT the same, no questions, all right?
allisonrose01 4 months ago
@allisonrose01 I'm sure they know. I know I do. = )
Kaicoyote 4 months ago
Amy Lee(great singer/performer/attractive) wins with the fans who have been feed Poop(POP) music as the only sound around.Cristina just WINS with fans who are not cagged in by someone else telling them what to like(corporate music)!!Lacuna Coil will set you Free!
MrMegafubar 5 months ago
Cristina hands down....so yummy and that voice...nom nom nom!
XavierDharke 5 months ago
Cristina Scabbia is better, because she's naturally beautiful, and actually talented.
bemylovepenguin 5 months ago
wait are we talking about their music or their looks??? either way Cristina wins hands down every time!!!!
PaganBorn79 6 months ago
Cristina is in a much better band. And is far more versatile as a singer. As for looks, Amy Lee looks great......as long as she has wears tons of makeup and has a puffy dress to cover up her pudgy figure. Can't blame her though. Eating American food can do that to you!
studleythename 6 months ago 2
@studleythename haha great comment but you know as well as I do that the yanks will choose their own everytime no matter how wrong they know they are.
PaganBorn79 6 months ago
@PaganBorn79 HEY EVERYBODY, LACUNA COIL FANS ARE NATZIS. THEY THINK EVERY NATION IS WRONG. Grow up idiot.
cjmsja 3 months ago
amy lee is the best singer ever
perer676 6 months ago
Cristina is hotter, and have a voice more versatile!
NwColombia 6 months ago
fuck this comparing i like them both, cristina for her talent to make her voice sound so gentle and strong on the other hand.... and amy lee, her style is so emotional..
Sane658 6 months ago
Amy LEE Wins lot lot lot
bdcung 6 months ago
amy lee is the QUEEN
kuku3520 6 months ago 10
@kuku3520 I AGREE wHAT u Said
bdcung 6 months ago
@kuku3520
I agree with u BIG-TIME!
allisonrose01 5 months ago
How Do You Dare Compare Lee With Scabbia ? Lee is Better x3 she is the queen.
XxAlexiaStarxX 6 months ago
Her Royal Highness The Queen Of Metal Amy Lee x3 That's All Folks
XxAlexiaStarxX 6 months ago
BOTH, YOU STUPID FOOLS!!! o.O
djokiful 6 months ago
scabbia wins this so easily!
TheGinashia 6 months ago 5
amy lee rocks and she's unbeatable, that's final
minijohe 7 months ago
JAMAS DE LOS NUNCAS ABRA ALGUIEN TAN IMPONENTE EN ESCENARIO, MUSICA, SENTIMIENTO, COMPOSICION, VOZ QUE MI ADORADA AMY! EVER! I LOVE UUUUUUUUUUU!
mar87gy 7 months ago
Amy. Definitely.
maddiexhatterx 7 months ago
amy forever!!!!
aynamurat 7 months ago
Amy Lee
DanielZ42FT 7 months ago
Amy Lee Forever. I Love You s2
jnesfree 7 months ago
amy lee!
MsStranger57 7 months ago
While I like both, I lean more towards Christina. Her vocals on the albums Closer and In a Riverie were awesome. Amy Lee is awesome too but I like Christina's music more. Evanescence does have better backing theatrics though, I will give them that. = )
Kaicoyote 7 months ago
I don't even know why people compare these two bands. They sound completely different. Oh, and cristina is way hotter and a much better singer. :) Amy is whiny and way too commercial. Ever hear cristina sing live? Just as good as recorded.
MarFish101 7 months ago
@MarFish101 amys never edited her voice while recording a record. but oh well everyone has there opinions and is intitled to them :)
flerfymcflerf098 7 months ago
@MarFish101 Backing tracks
VelvetSmilex 7 months ago
cristina hands down. amy lee is a whiny little girl its just anoying
appelbomber 7 months ago
lol...i like amy lee more than christina!amy lee has more originality than Christina!i love amy's VOICE coz its kinda good to listen ttoo, but chritina i dont think her voice is gud!just saying!
iyah1431 8 months ago
both bands are gothic but have different sounds
amys voice has a larger pitch range but cristinas to me just sounds more powerful
there both great singers leave it at that
supershmap 8 months ago
Many people usually say that Evanescence and Lacuna Coil are just the same shit. But i think they are wrong. Both bands have a similar sound but female´s voices are diffrent, thanks God. I would like to know what people here think about.
vanina781 8 months ago
amy lee . tiene una voz genial la amo!! es la mejor <3
kikheee 8 months ago
Crisss! Lacuna Coil is better than Evanescence, they make better music, Evanescence is sooo comercial, Lacuna Coil is best! But Evanescence is a good group
despedidadelaoreja 8 months ago
AMY LEE IS FUCKING AMAZING'!!
Freeyyaaa 8 months ago
CRISTINA, CAN YOU HEAR ME??
OK AMY LEE IS BETTER...AMY IS THE GODESS OF THE FUCKING ROCK //..//
Thexpumazoxrock 8 months ago
AMY LEE WINS <3
Thexpumazoxrock 8 months ago 16
@Thexpumazoxrock um no she doesnt, not by a long shot!
SouljaSaia17 2 months ago
Amy wins!! =D
TheVendela97 8 months ago
Amy Lee the goddes of the imaginary light
liilyarmstrong 8 months ago
Cristina scbbia and Amy Lee in some of those pictures kinda like a little alike in the face.
Anyways as far as music and songs are considered between the 2, i think they both are great artists and attractive as hell. I'm one who grow up liking Amy Lee's music and songs as far as women singers are considered which was in 2002 or 2003.
Cristina Scbbia from i didn't ever hear of tell last year in 2010 by mistake, but both female singers, you can get meaning from their song's and their music rocks
11000charles 8 months ago
if we what to talk about a female singer who dresses up we need to talk about
Lady Gaga
which im one who could care alot less about her music and dam sure as hell her dressing up, and her music is a joke, or anyways her so called songs and she's weird as hell.
if you want to also talk about a woman who dresses like a whore or anyways a mess up who
Lady Gaga
should be who you talk about
11000charles 8 months ago
People call Cristina a whore because they're too idiotic to appreciate art when they see it. If you look at her pictures, she's artistic, not a slut, and she models. Her music is beautiful and more meaningful with more emotion, and while Amy Lee is busy dressing up like Disney movies, she's in Rezophonic building wells for villages in Kenya. To the lot of you Evanescence fans, please leave her alone. ...
KINGBakurayoufools 9 months ago
@KINGBakurayoufools The world no end in Noth America, Evanescence more exita that MEGADETH ?
gerematria 8 months ago
Its all about the vocals. Ever hear either of them live? Cristina sounds awful, nothing like the beautiful music that is on her albums, while Amy's live performances are breathtaking. Amy Lee's voice is one of the best I've ever heard. <3
xApokalypseN0w 9 months ago
@xApokalypseN0w nobody gives a fuck what a nasty whore says who fucks over her "fiance" who is in Afghanistan... lollll 4realz
TheOnlyTempesT 9 months ago
@TheOnlyTempesT Listen, it is never okay to talk about someone behind their back especially when I didn't do anything and the only reason you said these things was out of hurt because I didn't want to start our toxic relationship again. I probably saved both our lives by doing so, but I know I will never get a thank you because you aren't mature enough to open your eyes and see that the hurtful things you say and have said do mean something to me. They aren't just words spoken out of anger..
xApokalypseN0w 7 months ago
@xApokalypseN0w oh and cheats on him too wit some weird looking faggot named "dimitri" lmfao, she cheated on me on the internet with some fabio mother fucker rofl, jesus, at least if your gonna cheat on me do it with someone better than me, fuck lol
TheOnlyTempesT 9 months ago
Amy Lee has this beautiful big blue eyes!!! I prefer Amy Lee...she is descent, has a beautiful voice and face...
Sevana01 9 months ago
@Sevana01
Amy Lee's eyes are Green
liilyarmstrong 8 months ago
@liilyarmstrong Even better!!!! ;-)
Sevana01 8 months ago 2
LACUNA COIL ALL THE WAY!!!!!
vampygrrl72 9 months ago
i like them both but between the two, i'm gonna have to go with Scabbia.
McCracker90 9 months ago
thumbs up for cristina!
blackjacksim6 9 months ago
Comment removed
SHARON35248 9 months ago
Any Lacuna Coil album slaughters everything that Ev ever made and will make in the future. Plus at least Cristina Scabbia doesn't need to shout out her notes and lets them come naturally. As a side note bashing your ex through music is a hell of a lot worse than looking sexy once in a while.
megaforce811 9 months ago
@megaforce811 Atleast Amy doesn't have to use sex appeal to get fans...
VelvetSmilex 9 months ago
@VelvetSmilex At least Cristina doesn't have to go on tirades to prove the Lacuna doesn't suck. And In A Reverie or Unleashed Memories and some others slaughters everything Ev ever made. Plus if Cristina weren't attractive I still appreciate the atmospheric music the band provides and they take huge risks with their sound.
megaforce811 9 months ago 2
@megaforce811 that*
megaforce811 9 months ago
I'd like to have both
jdog420spaz 10 months ago
amy lee all the way :)
encamile 10 months ago
Amy Lee, fer sure!
Cristina is beautiful, and talented and everything, but I just prefer Amy by a landslide.
LithiumStar28 10 months ago
I love Cristina, but I love Amy more! They are both fantasic.
CatocalaLacrymosa84 10 months ago
I don't see the point in arguing here. It's not illegal to like both you know.
Almostfull777 10 months ago
Cristina 's voice is a lot better then amy lees lol, amy got her boost from who she slept with lol
Xenon676 10 months ago
@Xenon676 and who was that? scabbia is the one who has all the revealing pictures. amy never went past her shoulders
sTapleEVA 10 months ago
AMY AND CRIS ...SO HOT!!
Brantazcoq 10 months ago
AMY LEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
VelesHH 10 months ago
AMY LEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MrsHardy97 10 months ago
AMY LEE
alexandra23drew 11 months ago
scabbia, is a whore, just look at her band pictures, half naked. amy doesent have to sell her body.who plays 3 instroments?who won 2 grammys and a nomination?who owns the greatest songwriter award that can be presented to an artist?who has sold well over 20 million albums, but managed to not sell out? who HAS sold out arenas all over the world? who inspired me and millions more to pick up an instoment, and a pen? whos lyrics connect with people so well, it has saved lives? eva-fucking-nescence
sTapleEVA 11 months ago 2
@sTapleEVA you speak right from my heart!!! I couldn´t have said it better....
MsJune6969 10 months ago
omg, i can't choose!!! I've loved them both from the very beginning that I've EVER heard of them, which was YEARS ago, and really, the truth is, I think they'd make an awesome couple, lol. BUT ANYWAY!!! Forget I said that......ahem....they're both so cool.
rockeramazon 11 months ago
amy lee?? LMAO. I think not. How you even compare Cristina and her :O
IrishRail123 11 months ago
fuggin amy lee duhhhhhhhhhhhh
jennyxcotoure 11 months ago
@jennyxcotoure Yes! thank you.<3
zelly51 11 months ago
AMY LEEE.
cblachsa 11 months ago
Even though i think this whole comparison thing between them is goofy, their music while similar, is totally different.. As is their voices, and style of vocals.. as far as looks go, they are both beautiful women.. Any Man would be Hard pressed to choose between them.. lol.. but, Cristina Scabbia is THE, Princess of Metal.. That will Never change.. Amy is softer, a Kitten... Cristina is a full grown Tigress.. With a Powerful voice to back it up ! The Powerful Princess of Metal... Rules !
Stargzr1000 11 months ago
Comment removed
Stargzr1000 11 months ago
i'd fuck both xD
TheShroom666 11 months ago
O.O WHY NOT BOTH??!!! MAKE LOVE, NOT WAR
arrmex 11 months ago 17
@KoRnKob11 I know what people's problems are: They're too shallow & only "love" for looks all the time & not for who a person really is or what good talents they possess. That's the problem
MissSlipknotJordison 11 months ago
The only reason people think Cristina is more attractive is because she dresses like a slut. Amy Lee doesn't do that because she has decent morals (though she is way more attractive). As for singing, composing and pretty much everything else amy lee is way better.
adamrules2010 11 months ago 3
@adamrules2010 im so.. with you on that.<3
zelly51 11 months ago
@adamrules2010 Cristina is better for much, she has work with Alter Brdige, Apocaliptyca, MEGADETH, Franco Battiato and Rezophonic (wich help to Africa puting in wells to help with water scarcity) she has record 5 studio albums. with her band she has been in countrys like India, Japon.
Tell me now, who is better?
gerematria 9 months ago
@gerematria Amy Lee has been more successful with evanescence than all the other bands you just mentioned. The number of records someone puts out has nothing to do with quality of music and neither does how many countrys they have been in so none of that information shows that she is better than Amy Lee.
adamrules2010 8 months ago
@KoRnKob11 Kornkob, I have so much respect for you right now, it's not even funny. I'm glad someone stood up for Amy & other women with the same body structure as her. :3
MissSlipknotJordison 11 months ago
@KoRnKob11 Cristina is incredibly talented i've loved lacuna coil since before i knew what she looked like, dunno what your talking about.
SnoopPixel 1 year ago
If you're going to decide which one is better then don't base your opinion on the singer's looks...
XdarknessFadesAwayX 1 year ago
Cristina, though amy is a more powerful singer
AkiraFollower 1 year ago
Amy Lee All the Way!!! Evanescence for life!
shyboyllf 1 year ago
Christina wins in my opinion, shes been around way longer, her style is so cool and belongs to her cause no one can copy it, shes a lot hotter obviously, and shes a Euro chick, I mean c'mon Euro chicks will always win over any run of the mill typical American girl. Also I enjoy listening to music when my ears don't bleed, Amy lee sings in the same frequency as a friggin smoke detector or when someone opens an emergency exit. Anyways thats just my addition to the question
Ross175 1 year ago 2
Christina, she's hotter and has better voice (at least my personal opinion)
snowwhitebeautyful 1 year ago
Cristina is way over the top. and I love Amy too!!!!!!
tnoel374 1 year ago
AMY!!!!
thanosls1 1 year ago
Amy is better at head, but christina takes anal like a champ. hmm
dmsanders25 1 year ago
I really can't descide, they are both good ^^
Metalilly1 1 year ago
they are good The same
Y8OMaRyY8O 1 year ago
wat is the amy's songs name?
ffacfreak 1 year ago
i love amy lee with a passion
SuPpAwOoT96 1 year ago
Cristina has much better vocal endurance and technique.
NiymbleFingers 1 year ago
@NiymbleFingers no amy does!!amy can actually sing and not screem!!
ffacfreak 1 year ago
@ffacfreak I like Amy's tone better, but I'm not so bias about my preference that I'd over look that fact that Amy Lee struggles singing live. It shows. Not saying she can't sing, but she's singing in a way that is not healthy for that beautiful tone she has.
NiymbleFingers 1 year ago
@ffacfreak I like Amy's tone better, but I'm not so bias about my preference that I'd over look that fact that Amy Lee struggles singing live. It shows. Not saying she can't sing, but she's singing in a way that is not healthy for that beautiful tone she has.
NiymbleFingers 1 year ago
Cristina Scabbia is way better! I still love Amy Lee though.
TeamEdwardx94 1 year ago
amy better
fghfhg1212121 1 year ago
On looks: Cristina is just so hot even in her late 30's. Amy Lee has a big following and some talent but Lacuna Coil is the better band overall for all round musicianship.
pantherz9103 1 year ago
Cristina is the sort of women that you see their beauty, Amy Lee is the other sort of women, that you feel their beauty. For the voice, Cristina does have an awesome one, but Amy Lee is just way better.
Still both of Evanescence and Lacuna Coil are my favorite bands ( with A7X )
linkiny 1 year ago
i like both of them but because i've recently found out about lacuna coil, i'm going to have to say amy lee since i've known evanescence for about 7 years.
FallofDarkness55 1 year ago
where is Amy Lee nowadays ... no where, she was big but faded away
Cristina Scabbia has the better voice and looks, she has been at the forefront for over 10 years and still going !
disengagejam 1 year ago
Comment removed
SHARON35248 1 year ago
cristina is hotter and she can rock out better than amy, plus amy is so fake!
sqwear 1 year ago
@sqwear fake?dont think so.voice wise amy is better!!
ffacfreak 1 year ago
well the lacuna coil girl is hotter thats for sure
mentalfeed70 1 year ago
Amy Lee is more pretty than Cristina Scabbia and she is the best metal singer....
bobsy301 1 year ago
Both awesome chicks and amazing singers. I think Cristina for looks but Amy has the most amazing and soothing voice i have ever heard!
MsGin13 1 year ago
Amy is DEFINATELY better!
drewsky67 1 year ago
I give Evanescence credit in me finding Lacuna Coil. I've had both on my MP3 player, several albums of each and shuffled them and listened both for a long time. In the end Lacuna Coil won out as my fave. Yo Cristina!
kakamatsu 1 year ago
Evanescence is for retard gothic wannabes virgin boys and teenage whores with no brain or taste on music
Hackmoune 1 year ago
The thing that I also like about Cristina Scabbia is that she and Andrea Ferro actually write deeper lyrics that aren't about teen angst.
megaforce811 1 year ago
I'd take Cristina Scabbia for her strong voice and also Lacuna Coil as a band because I looked up the guitar tabs and they are harder to play than any Evanescence song.
megaforce811 1 year ago
Comment removed
SHARON35248 1 year ago
FUCK Amy lee
Cristina RUUUULZ!!
limpbizkit1990 1 year ago
Amy Lee is thinly disguised christian rock. She's as metal as avril lavigine is punk.
MrFlesh 1 year ago 2
Of course Amy Lee
DarkAteeq 1 year ago
I like Amy Lee, but I looooovve Cristina!
both are very good singers :)
helaina00 1 year ago
Amy Lee - Sagittarius
Cristina Scabia - Gemini
Both - Extremely good. Shush!
c1k4ml3kc3 1 year ago
Did the person who made this video ask for insults about the singers? I don't see that anywhere in the description. SO STOP BEING RUDE AND JUST SAY WHICH ONE YOU LIKE BETTER AND DON'T SAY MEAN THINGS ABOUT THE OTHER SINGER. GEEZ. They're both equally great, I think. But in my opinion, Amy's my favorite. Christina is great too.
imadethis2watchvidz 1 year ago
amy lee amy lee amy lee any day
huneye 1 year ago