I'm glad I didn't choose this ending T.T Though...the MC lives here(kind of...)....god damn it! Why did you have to die in the "happy" ending!!! Wah! :((
The amount of dramatic irony Atlus put in this scene is a testament to how amazing this game is. The irony is so thick, it's really beautiful, but....it's so thick, it's almost tangible, and is making me slightly sick to my stomach... :-
@PaladinGear15 The End comes unexpectedly, that why it ends like that. While the characters are enjoying their lives, you, the player, know they're all going to die. I think Atlus is trying to make us feel bad for taking the easy way out. :I
kil or not kill ryuji lead to bad ending well the supposedly good ending ends with minato's death while in the bad ending he dide too only that he bring people with him
Obviously. Living only in the moment is wrong, and it's later shown to be Strega's motivation if you chose not to kill Ryoji. Having the main characters accept the villain's life philosophy (and subsequently having that choice get them killed off screen) is a pretty extreme way of showing a bad ending.
@HatoburekaSutajio Well, it's not like for the main character's sake it makes a difference, because massive spoilers,
The main character dies if you get the good ending because in order to kill nyx, he must sacrifice himself, and use an attack that requires all his HP. You have a few more days of school, and die in the hands of Aigis. In short, he dies anyway.
@SuperLlama42 yeah but persona 4 XD and trinity soul <-- watch xD. i mean there will be other poeple who takes care of it by soul extraction. and also i just notice i have penta post -_-
@tommybui You killed her signal beacon, so maybe she got lost for a few months. Either way, she has a pretty one-track mind. After all, she tried to end the world once before.
If you think about it this is kinda the "good" ending, especially if the main character did die or is in a coma because His/her (depends if you played portable) soul is never allowed to escape or pass on, because in this case once the world ends the character's soul is still allowed to pass on, meaning that the main character gets to stick with all of his/her friends!;D -winkwink- I think I might go for this ending...
Then again the "good" ending is all how you yourself depict it. After all, no story is set in stone and there can be many parallel worlds even in real life that can be the same but have very different outcomes, so why can't the ending be all how the player depicts it?
So~ The main character could have died, gone into a coma, have his soul trapped,
or just simply fell asleep from exhaustion and is perfectly okay (which I'm going to take on that idea myself~)
All in all, a game is how you think of it...But I would find it strange to have a soulless body walking around that seems to have a brain, because that is against all laws of anything.O.o...I mean obviously the main character was "alive" and had a soul...gosh...this game is confusing.
well right now im almost at the final shadow and im trying to get thanatos while trying to max out the social links but i had a reverse on the magiacian i havnt fought strega yet ? what happens to them any way?
i find it ironic this is the "bad" ending...the MC doesnt technically die...or at least not shown dieing so its a good thing he didnt die...untill you play "The Answer"
then the "good" ending the MC dies which sucks but then again it all comes dwn to if you understand what "The Answer" shows you about the role of the MC after using the final attack against Nyx
uhm i honestly am sorry if this is a spoiler to some who never played the good ending or "The Answer" before
This ending seriously sucked. You don't put in all those hours of massive character development to have it end like that XP I'm glad I watched this now because I'd have been pissed to sit through the bad ending then go onto the good one xD
Cuz no one remember's anything except Aigis, and all they've done just dissapears. Including the bonds they made, the battles they've fought, and the people they've saved. Well, at least the MC doesn't die in this one...maybe.
The right ending is the one where you let Ryoji live. You climb to the top of Tartarus battle Jin and Takaya, defeat Nyx with the MC alone. He dies in the end but thats the one that "The Answer" is based on
wrong. he DOES die. yes, he goes into a coma, but eventually he dies while still in a coma. apparently only im50yearsold and I were the only 2 paying attention...
NO, he becomes the seal to hold back Nyx. I mean, he could have very well lost his physical form, but he still very much exists. I believe someone said something about Elizabeth looking for him in Persona 4, but I haven't played that one, yet.
if i were in there i would record a video or a diary and it will say everything: the dark hour etc... and explain what happend and why killed that guy was the best but i think with the video will be suficent
i think this was really artfully done, cuz you see how stupid they are while being ignorant, and you realize how much they grew up while they went through all their struggles. and it kinda creeped me out because they didnt show the world ending, but you just knew it was gonna happen reeeeal soon.
In this ending, the heroes run away from death. In the true ending, they confront it and manage to delay the destruction of the world. Playing the extra scenario in FES clarifies many questions from the main game.
The world was destroyed. Ryoji said his death would merely delay the fall a little bit and the heroes could live in peace without their memories of what is coming until it happened.
Whether you kill Ryoji or not, Nyx will destroy the world anyway. The question is in how far is the fall delayed. I mean, what Ryoji meant "little" can be like 100 years.
Well I don't think any game could get any worse in endings than Oden Sphere. Well except some of the alternate endings for Drakengard and Drakengard 2.
I still think that is not as bad as Odin Sphere's endings. I mean come on, at least "Zenon" is satisfied in that bad ending in Disgaea 2. Just watch what happens after Mercedes fights the Beast of Darkova or Gwendolyn fights Onyx. Everyone, including villains, gets to be miserable in Odin Sphere's bad endings.
But, where the hell "The Fall" is?!?!
Mr0901 2 months ago
Comment removed
Mr0901 2 months ago
I played this game and I gotta say it's pretty emo if you ask me. The battle system and everyting is perfect but the story is just... meh.
TheMustik92 3 months ago
I'm glad I didn't choose this ending T.T Though...the MC lives here(kind of...)....god damn it! Why did you have to die in the "happy" ending!!! Wah! :((
pdeleon102004 3 months ago
Junpei : Hey guys.... why the hell are there all these guns lying around? And why does that dog have wings?
ANGRYMAPLE 3 months ago
i really minato always hope alive and live his college life..
i bet a lot of college girls will be clinging in him..
minatoooo T___T
4ir489 5 months ago
The amount of dramatic irony Atlus put in this scene is a testament to how amazing this game is. The irony is so thick, it's really beautiful, but....it's so thick, it's almost tangible, and is making me slightly sick to my stomach... :-
gamefreak8420 6 months ago
@gamefreak8420 You probably need more... IRON in your diet! pffffffffffffff
EAT IT! EAT THE IRONY!!!
(sorry if that comes off as sounding dick-ish, I just couldn't pass that up)
But yeah, great game.
zninja141 2 months ago
And that my friends are why we save before doing anything stupid in the game. Peace bros. Be Wise, Live Well.
DemonWatcher100 6 months ago 3
that's it?.. the bad ending is.. someone buys you a drink and you go to a party with friends?
...ehh, I'm probably looking at it wrong
PaladinGear15 6 months ago
@PaladinGear15 The End comes unexpectedly, that why it ends like that. While the characters are enjoying their lives, you, the player, know they're all going to die. I think Atlus is trying to make us feel bad for taking the easy way out. :I
ZenLearning 5 months ago
@ZenLearning oh yeah, sorry, I guess I wasn't thinking very clearly when I posted that comment, thanks for telling me.
PaladinGear15 5 months ago
*tales of Vesperia game occurs after this* And there was never heard of them again lol.
megamanx1291 6 months ago
Im Guessing Black Screen is Short for Nyx Doomed You All By Ending This Game With The Bad Ending >_<
Ironman8675 7 months ago
They just want to make you feel guilty for picking this ending dont they
XxTurtleTommyxX 8 months ago
A lovely day to go on a stroll with your friends, get drinks, enjoy life. You feel as if nothing can go wrong until suddenly;
Nyx appears with a big ol' troll face, here to fuq everything up and boom the end suddenly everyone is dead.
This could've been stopped if you switched from your old body soap to old spice body wash.
or if you weren't a twit and killed Ryoji.
What.
ScreamerJet 9 months ago 3
the fall hun? i can just imagen.......
MC:I love you yukari
Yukari:I love you to
(thay make out)
Junpei: what the fuck!!!!
Nyx:BOOM!!!!!!
(world ends)
jussssst great
trev9000 9 months ago 3
"It seems you have no choice."
"What will you do?"
Bitch, you just said I had no choice!
VintageBalderdash 10 months ago 8
@VintageBalderdash
That sums up my entire experience with this game.
HatoburekaSutajio 7 months ago
both choices lead to bad endings...the supposedly good ending end with his death and in the bad ending he died too only he bring everyone with him
silentdraconian 10 months ago
kil or not kill ryuji lead to bad ending well the supposedly good ending ends with minato's death while in the bad ending he dide too only that he bring people with him
silentdraconian 10 months ago
Junpei-But for now, let the good times roll....
-end of the world-
W H A T T H E F U C K
KyattKet 10 months ago
Thats a BAD ending¿
santiago540 11 months ago
@santiago540
Obviously. Living only in the moment is wrong, and it's later shown to be Strega's motivation if you chose not to kill Ryoji. Having the main characters accept the villain's life philosophy (and subsequently having that choice get them killed off screen) is a pretty extreme way of showing a bad ending.
HatoburekaSutajio 7 months ago
@HatoburekaSutajio Well, it's not like for the main character's sake it makes a difference, because massive spoilers,
The main character dies if you get the good ending because in order to kill nyx, he must sacrifice himself, and use an attack that requires all his HP. You have a few more days of school, and die in the hands of Aigis. In short, he dies anyway.
VintageBalderdash 7 months ago
So... how the hell was Nyx stopped during the bad ending? Oh yeah, because The Fall gets slightly delayed right? So then... I wonder when it is...
You think they're going to get screwed now?
AkumaUchitoru 1 year ago
dat bad end wasn't dat bad.....til the the you death
JUWON4LIFE 1 year ago
p4 secret last boss O_O sorry got to say that ... ull know wut I'm talking about if u watch it talk about ignorance
danielchen3350 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
three march i thought nyx comes at thirty januari
tommybui 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
three march i thought nyx comes at thirty januari
tommybui 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
three march i thought nyx comes at thirty januari
tommybui 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
three march i thought nyx comes at thirty januari
tommybui 1 year ago
three march i thought nyx comes at thirty januari
tommybui 1 year ago
@tommybui By killing Ryoji you delay the The Fall. But it still happens eventually.
SuperLlama42 1 year ago
@SuperLlama42 yeah but persona 4 XD and trinity soul <-- watch xD. i mean there will be other poeple who takes care of it by soul extraction. and also i just notice i have penta post -_-
tommybui 1 year ago
@tommybui You killed her signal beacon, so maybe she got lost for a few months. Either way, she has a pretty one-track mind. After all, she tried to end the world once before.
rubino83 1 year ago
@rubino83 hmmm its not that xD hmm she comes cose she wants to kill all, its more poeple ask for her right?
tommybui 1 year ago
three march i thought nyx comes at thirty januari
tommybui 1 year ago
3 5 hmmm i tought nyx comes at 1 30 so its next life generation
tommybui 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3/5 hmmm i tought nyx comes at 1/30 so its next life generation
tommybui 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
3/5 hmmm i tought nyx comes at 1/30 :D so its next life generation
tommybui 1 year ago
3/5 hmmm i tought nyx comes at 1/30 :D so its next life generation ;)
tommybui 1 year ago
damn it make me feel to cry if hear such voice acting like this one!!
Songcompiler 1 year ago
If you think about it this is kinda the "good" ending, especially if the main character did die or is in a coma because His/her (depends if you played portable) soul is never allowed to escape or pass on, because in this case once the world ends the character's soul is still allowed to pass on, meaning that the main character gets to stick with all of his/her friends!;D -winkwink- I think I might go for this ending...
StrawberrySerenadeXx 1 year ago
Then again the "good" ending is all how you yourself depict it. After all, no story is set in stone and there can be many parallel worlds even in real life that can be the same but have very different outcomes, so why can't the ending be all how the player depicts it?
So~ The main character could have died, gone into a coma, have his soul trapped,
or just simply fell asleep from exhaustion and is perfectly okay (which I'm going to take on that idea myself~)
StrawberrySerenadeXx 1 year ago
All in all, a game is how you think of it...But I would find it strange to have a soulless body walking around that seems to have a brain, because that is against all laws of anything.O.o...I mean obviously the main character was "alive" and had a soul...gosh...this game is confusing.
StrawberrySerenadeXx 1 year ago
That was the best Bad ending I ever saw...
It really makes you feel bad...by showing that everyone had hope for the future...
Now it made me feel bad too...I can't stop thinking that everything might end after in one minute...
vad1995 2 years ago 2
@vad1995 err....does the MC died???
MrXyron 1 year ago
@MrXyron Nah. Everyone dies!
rubino83 1 year ago
@MrXyron well...yes...everyone died...on this ending, of course.
but that's not the true ending! ^_^
vad1995 1 year ago
And this is the way the world ends.
sodapop513 2 years ago
Fucking sad.
BoscoWins 2 years ago
in 4:28 yukari:in the end it dosent even matter
this remminds me on linkin park in the end
Flippyandgabe 2 years ago
This ending left me feeling...Bitter.
StrikerAver 2 years ago 4
Has anyone noticed that the Fall in the Bad Ending takes place at exactly the same moment Minato falls into the coma, instead of January 31st?
qwertyman006 2 years ago 4
Well, Ryoji told the party that if they killed him, it would delay the fall for some time.
Riseikkiu 2 years ago
such a sadly ironic bad ending x.x
MonkeydluRMXP 2 years ago
That was kinda cheery for a bad ending
clocknighter 3 years ago 4
Until you realize that Nyx decided to bring about the end of the world just a few seconds after this scene...
RobloxMario 2 years ago 42
it does so they die any ways i didnt see any ?? oh after. they dont show you?
project0omega 2 years ago
Well,if they showed the end of the world happening while you could've prevented it,it would've been just plain mean.
Like saying,"Haha,you picked the easy way out and doomed everyone,YOU SUCK!"
RobloxMario 2 years ago 47
well right now im almost at the final shadow and im trying to get thanatos while trying to max out the social links but i had a reverse on the magiacian i havnt fought strega yet ? what happens to them any way?
project0omega 2 years ago
@RobloxMario auhuhsuhsHUUHUHuhsuhsuhaUHSHAhsuauhsUHSUHSAUH
Uroboruss 1 year ago
@RobloxMario uhAHShsaUHHAUSAUHSUHSUHUASHUHuhushushsu
Uroboruss 1 year ago
@RobloxMario i wonder why you got the two top comments O_0
GkArsenal22 2 months ago
THATS the ending?? when does Nyx kill them off?
emoboynumber13 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
A few seconds after the final scene.
Floyd5642 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Does it not show the scene where Nyx kills them?
WTFitsemily 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't think it does.
Floyd5642 2 years ago 3
Wow thats depressing.
DemolitionDebbie 3 years ago
the fall still happens, by killing ryoji you delay the fall and nobody will even know its happening until after they're dead
i thought he explained that was i the only one paying attention?
im50yearsold 3 years ago
Is that it? Do you not even see the Fall with this ending?
darkshineskitty 3 years ago 2
i find it ironic this is the "bad" ending...the MC doesnt technically die...or at least not shown dieing so its a good thing he didnt die...untill you play "The Answer"
then the "good" ending the MC dies which sucks but then again it all comes dwn to if you understand what "The Answer" shows you about the role of the MC after using the final attack against Nyx
uhm i honestly am sorry if this is a spoiler to some who never played the good ending or "The Answer" before
Sorry again if iy was.
xannidel 3 years ago
This ending seriously sucked. You don't put in all those hours of massive character development to have it end like that XP I'm glad I watched this now because I'd have been pissed to sit through the bad ending then go onto the good one xD
Arei 3 years ago
how is this a bad ending...?
OmgCannon 3 years ago
Cuz no one remember's anything except Aigis, and all they've done just dissapears. Including the bonds they made, the battles they've fought, and the people they've saved. Well, at least the MC doesn't die in this one...maybe.
FloatingMist 3 years ago
@OmgCannon Cause you don't save the world :{D
xJisJis 1 year ago
which is the right ending???im so confused...:S
SoraTheBully 3 years ago
The right ending is the one where you let Ryoji live. You climb to the top of Tartarus battle Jin and Takaya, defeat Nyx with the MC alone. He dies in the end but thats the one that "The Answer" is based on
Muncheiy 3 years ago
he don't die he's in a permanent coma but that's exactly the same thing isn't it?
narutouzumakidel1900 3 years ago
Basically yeahh i heard that he may be saved by elizabeth in p4magehhhurrrrururur
Muncheiy 3 years ago
wrong. he DOES die. yes, he goes into a coma, but eventually he dies while still in a coma. apparently only im50yearsold and I were the only 2 paying attention...
CrimsonCrowess 3 years ago
hmmm... sh*t
narutouzumakidel1900 3 years ago
NO, he becomes the seal to hold back Nyx. I mean, he could have very well lost his physical form, but he still very much exists. I believe someone said something about Elizabeth looking for him in Persona 4, but I haven't played that one, yet.
kkeelan 3 years ago
I played it, im sorry to say that she only mentions it once. They didnt give us so much as a hint of if he comes back.
Promisetime 3 years ago
He didn't became a seal to hold back Nyx. He became one to keep human from calling Nyx.
About Liz, no one knows actually.
PoKeMoNFaN953 2 years ago
@SoraTheBully Not this one
xJisJis 1 year ago
if u do a new game plus, can u get a good ending instead of the bad? i mean even it's MAX commu, can u get a good ending in the new game plus?
hoang352 3 years ago
Yeah, you just have to let Ryoji live
Muncheiy 3 years ago
I find this ending really painful, after everything that's happened only for everything to revert back to the beginning...
oblivion136 3 years ago 3
My god, feels like it's telling you to get the good ending. >_>
kaizerx10 3 years ago 5
i agree 1000000%
artemis64739 3 years ago
can we get caugh in p3(i mean going out with 2 girl and one of the 2 girl find out
klomoto 3 years ago
Poor Aegis. She remembers but no one else does. That's just too sad.
123anime321 3 years ago 4
if i were in there i would record a video or a diary and it will say everything: the dark hour etc... and explain what happend and why killed that guy was the best but i think with the video will be suficent
55904753zxx 3 years ago
Yes, same here. However, would YOU belive it if you saw a movie of yourself talking about something that barely anyone heard about?
Kainmaster 3 years ago
thats...true.
xehanort66 3 years ago
PEOPLE
kollerbackx4 3 years ago
i think this was really artfully done, cuz you see how stupid they are while being ignorant, and you realize how much they grew up while they went through all their struggles. and it kinda creeped me out because they didnt show the world ending, but you just knew it was gonna happen reeeeal soon.
RogueDementor 4 years ago 6
what do you mean reeeeeeeeal soon?
xehanort66 3 years ago
thanks for posting this :)
AshantiAvrilBaby 4 years ago
WHAT ABOUT NYX!?
MeRKO20 4 years ago 2
nyx is gonna destroy the world some years later lol
narutouzumakidel1900 3 years ago
THATS ALL!
MeRKO20 4 years ago
Oh crud no, I don't wanna kill Pharos!! He's the cute little kid- -shot-
a745 4 years ago
I don't understand. Either way the world ends. I think the good ending sets up FES. Still... what is the difference if the world ends!?!
AndrewLeeNY 4 years ago
In this ending, the heroes run away from death. In the true ending, they confront it and manage to delay the destruction of the world. Playing the extra scenario in FES clarifies many questions from the main game.
chrisneed 4 years ago
Well this is why it's called the bad ending... but...
ReiKusanagi 4 years ago
we can fight Nyx just look other video here
but master why you choose the worst ending i hope you uploaded the other one
swordied50 4 years ago
i don't get it... so... it just ends like that? no fighting Nyx or anything? Nothing being destroyed?
nocturned85 4 years ago
Well I assume the world probably gets destroyed, but they don't show actually show it.
swillo 4 years ago
The world was destroyed. Ryoji said his death would merely delay the fall a little bit and the heroes could live in peace without their memories of what is coming until it happened.
Velfarre2001 4 years ago
Whether you kill Ryoji or not, Nyx will destroy the world anyway. The question is in how far is the fall delayed. I mean, what Ryoji meant "little" can be like 100 years.
chrisneed 4 years ago
going to a karioky is always a bad endingXD
shippouu 4 years ago
Yeah this is an ending I can't sit with. Well at least its not as bad as some other games.
BradRy2 4 years ago
Everyone lives blissfully ignorant until the world is destroyed? Can't say there is many worse personally.
Velfarre2001 4 years ago 2
Well Odin Sphere. That was truly a bad ending. Not sure you can get worse than that.
BradRy2 4 years ago
Technically they are the same thing. Everyone dies and the world ends. Not much difference really.
Velfarre2001 4 years ago
At least this one's not as bad as the bad endings in Odin Sphere. Not even the good ending is that much better in that game...
chrisneed 4 years ago
Well I don't think any game could get any worse in endings than Oden Sphere. Well except some of the alternate endings for Drakengard and Drakengard 2.
BradRy2 4 years ago
what about disgaea 2 when adell kills rozalin and then he is controlled by the zenon to eat his sibilings?
shippouu 4 years ago
Never played Disgea series. Games so rare.
BradRy2 4 years ago
i meant what do you think about such an ending:)
shippouu 4 years ago
Well it sounds kind of like something that would happen in that kind of game. With Vampires and all. But yeah that sounds bad.
BradRy2 4 years ago
i didn't mean kill and drink their blood....i mean actully eating them while tearing their bones to 12 years boy/girl
shippouu 4 years ago
Well it still sounds bad.
BradRy2 4 years ago
I still think that is not as bad as Odin Sphere's endings. I mean come on, at least "Zenon" is satisfied in that bad ending in Disgaea 2. Just watch what happens after Mercedes fights the Beast of Darkova or Gwendolyn fights Onyx. Everyone, including villains, gets to be miserable in Odin Sphere's bad endings.
chrisneed 4 years ago
Only Drakengard's 2nd and 3rd ending can be just as bad. I mean the whole world comes to an end in those.
BradRy2 4 years ago