I saw the new video for The Doctor & The Master, and couldn't for the life of me remember where I had seen you before. Oh, yeah. This awesomeness. Thanks for being one of the more entertaining musicians on the youtubes.
Having just done a cover of this myself, I decided I owed to the other musicians out there to listen to some of their covers of this song. Yours is the only one I've felt the urge to comment on. Great job! Somewhere between the original and the Gary Jules version, I would say. One thing that surprises me (not good or bad, just a surprise) is that you didn't have the bridge from the original, or some variation on it. Oddly, nobody seems to have that... anyway, as I said, great job! :)
damn. this is so good. you're an amazing male singer. i never hear people do a cover of this song without reaching the max of their vocal range. nice job honey:)
I finally listened to the original version of this and a different cover of it. The original has a depeche mode feel to it and it sounds funny since I didnt hear that version first
i've grown up listening to this song (my parents music...) and when i heard this it was like wow wee golly gosh bang crash kaboom wizard! and memories of this song came pouring into my brain. i loved this cover.
I really, really love this song, and enjoyed how you interpreted it. This "folksy" sound gives me a warm and contented feeling, (really hard to explain that part). Thanks for sharing. You Rock!
Love this song & your version! I Blip'd the TFF version the other day on Twitter & I think it was BGS , blip'd the Jules cover, saying she preferred 'the original'. I was 'fused. Glad to see I was right!
I'm really glad you think I"m that good, but I don't think I could do a show like that. Don't think I"m good enough for that. Plus I kinda dislike the show, lol.
dude its amazing im not gonna lie plus ive been trying to learn this song for a few weeeks now and uve given me the strumming pattern for it thank you
oh man! it was soo hard not to sing along, because then I would totally screw up the song... so I watched once, and the second time I gave in to my urge to sing.
that has to be one of the best covers, no actualy the best....... loved it, why are you not playing at festivals all round the world? if u were at download i would go and watch. do u know what download is?? if not its a british festival loOol
I'd love to play festivals around the world...but I suppose to do that people would actually have to know who I am...and as it stands...nobody really does! hehe. Very happy you enjoyed it gothic!
isn't it funny how some songs are like that? There's plenty of songs I didn't really like til listening to them over and over, then suddenly they're a favourite!
I think it is really awesome to hear and see how much you have grown as a musician. because this rerecording sounds really amazing. i like your vocals with it.
I like the Gary Jules version better then the Tears for Fears version, unfortunately. I always feel guilty when I don't listen to the original. I think I like your cover the best, though haha :D I'm going to download it ^^
Though I generally prefer originals to covers in almost every case, I'm not a huge fan of the Tears for Fears version, even though the song is theirs.
Still, your cover is awesome, and I shall download it!
thanks! I've actually covered it twice now, I did it once a couple years ago, vid is still up... sound sucked though so I thought it was time to redo it for fun.
Yeah, I did. I'm actually a little freaked out about it. I love the original so much and I'm nervous that they're just going to destroy it. I'm gonna guess that you've probably seen the trailer for it?
On a more or less completely random sidenote: I just saw "Hunger" (dir. Steve McQueen, 2008) at our local film fest and I'm recommending it to EVERYONE (or at least everyone who isn't squeamish) because it was so well done that it blew my mind.
aww, no reason to stop! Learn it and perform it, then let me know where I can watch it. I originally recorded a vid for this in Dec. of 06...still have it on my channel... I said a long time ago to those who liked it I'd redo it cuz the sound sucked...just finally got around to it.
Guess what, i did learn it, about 30 seconds after I finished watching this. I'll edit it once I'm done with all my tests this week and put it up as a video response. :)
I just now decided that you're going to by my "channel of the month" for april. Every month I tell my subscribers a channel they should check out. You definitely got it.
Just downloaded the first version you did of this from your site today (I have Bill on my iTunes now - Yay!). Totally signed up, as well!
Great cover, again. You're consistently amazing! I agree, I prefer covering the TFF version more than I do the Gary Jules version. The original's more upbeat. :]
(Oh, and all five starfish were brilliant, and send their regards..)
thanks a lot. Yeah, both are great version of the song. Naturally one should have the most respect for the original, but it goes without saying that Gary's version is brilliant too.
I saw the new video for The Doctor & The Master, and couldn't for the life of me remember where I had seen you before. Oh, yeah. This awesomeness. Thanks for being one of the more entertaining musicians on the youtubes.
DashCat9 2 months ago
GREAT
unseresache 1 year ago
this is my favorite song.
great job :)
jujubeeluvswrestling 1 year ago
I remember my dad playing me the origninal on his record player i love it but this is a really good cover , i love your voice !!!
rbeccastevenson1 1 year ago
What are the chords??
dtrip09 1 year ago
wow a fight club poster :D:
sinus2alfa 1 year ago
Gary Jules almost had it perfect, but this... this is perfection.
SuperPandas 1 year ago
dont ever change, ur da bomb man. really awesome. how old are you?
sxephlI 1 year ago
watch?v=lVdJSf1A5bI
LetET2010 1 year ago
wow, you're an amazing singer and an amazing guitar player!
VC11122 1 year ago
Having just done a cover of this myself, I decided I owed to the other musicians out there to listen to some of their covers of this song. Yours is the only one I've felt the urge to comment on. Great job! Somewhere between the original and the Gary Jules version, I would say. One thing that surprises me (not good or bad, just a surprise) is that you didn't have the bridge from the original, or some variation on it. Oddly, nobody seems to have that... anyway, as I said, great job! :)
kyletunison 1 year ago
You look like Geddy Lee
Floydthefuckbag 2 years ago
He does! Just because of this I think he should do a Rush cover.
buccaneerpenguin 1 year ago
damn. this is so good. you're an amazing male singer. i never hear people do a cover of this song without reaching the max of their vocal range. nice job honey:)
xxxladyxhavokxxx13 2 years ago
This was so good! Damn good rendition of a damn good song.
Pretty much how I envisioned an acoustic guitar version would sound like.
Nettacki 2 years ago
one word dude .... Awesome!
cayrano 2 years ago
This is one of my favorite songs since i heard it in Donnie Darko and you played it really well.
starrynight1774 2 years ago
hey, you look like Ozzy :D
love your voice, love your music, keep this way. :)
BineyPogo 2 years ago 8
Its great but your hair :O:O
Your older hair was cooler, ;)
Oh and by the way you should do a Nirvana or Pearl Jam cover...Just for the old Grunge days :)
erdr1p 2 years ago 2
WOW YES.
Dr. Noise playing Nirvana... that would be seriously rad.
EmiliaDain 2 years ago 8
great version. you is cool is good.
THIS WAS AMAZING!
misterdjim 2 years ago
I finally listened to the original version of this and a different cover of it. The original has a depeche mode feel to it and it sounds funny since I didnt hear that version first
PaulSaysThings 2 years ago
dman it.. what you've done to your hairs? i just loved your blondie side :D
by the way you got a very good voice.. keep singing!
amiccare 2 years ago 2
You're a good singer
JackWales12345 2 years ago
wow.
THIS WAS AMAZING!
i've grown up listening to this song (my parents music...) and when i heard this it was like wow wee golly gosh bang crash kaboom wizard! and memories of this song came pouring into my brain. i loved this cover.
XD
NerdsAreHumansToo 2 years ago 2
I really, really love this song, and enjoyed how you interpreted it. This "folksy" sound gives me a warm and contented feeling, (really hard to explain that part). Thanks for sharing. You Rock!
erfelgamazig 2 years ago
Love this song & your version! I Blip'd the TFF version the other day on Twitter & I think it was BGS , blip'd the Jules cover, saying she preferred 'the original'. I was 'fused. Glad to see I was right!
I <6 you (so much more than <3!)
bandmum1 2 years ago
hey thre bandmum, saw you signed up for the webpage. :) Glad you enjoyed the cover. Thanks so much!
doctornoise 2 years ago
goog stuff!
llifs123 2 years ago
glad you enjoyed :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
good stuff
sonicsuns 2 years ago
thanks a lot!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I love your version of this song.. :D
your voice suits it very well.. :)
Becky2266 2 years ago
Thanks Becky, I'm glad you enjoyed it :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Saw the live show last night...awesome...had to hear some of the tunes again
bernieb223 2 years ago
glad to hear you had fun BernieB! Hope to see you again in the future.
doctornoise 2 years ago
yea i liked it i think you did a really good job with it
lagunasurfr 2 years ago
thanks laguna!
doctornoise 2 years ago
ok ok hahaha you win but really your good
diesuici 2 years ago
you welcome hehe but i like why you dont go to america idol? seriously you are a great singer
diesuici 2 years ago
I'm really glad you think I"m that good, but I don't think I could do a show like that. Don't think I"m good enough for that. Plus I kinda dislike the show, lol.
doctornoise 2 years ago
thanks so much!
doctornoise 2 years ago
dude its amazing im not gonna lie plus ive been trying to learn this song for a few weeeks now and uve given me the strumming pattern for it thank you
BOBhope4u 2 years ago
Thanks a lot and I'm glad I could help you out! If you have any questions on the chords don't hesitate to write me a youtube message. cheers!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Brilliant! As always :P
Way better than Gary Jules.
*searching for the original song*
Lots of love!
Sara
smickra 2 years ago
oooh, you think it's better? Thanks a lot sara that means a whole lot!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Awesome cover. I love this song. One of the only piano pieces I can play without music :P
helenzebcharles 2 years ago
hehe that's awesome! I wish I could play it on piano!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Well done! =]
Didn't Adam do this song on American Idol?
steelers36867 2 years ago
might have, don't ever watch the show. Thanks so much though, appreciate it!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Aw, that was beautiful :D
The Tears for Fears version is brilliant, but I like the slower Jules version as well. But you're is kinda the best-- 5 starfish! :D
darkemage 2 years ago
that's a great big fat compliment mage, and I much appreciate it. Also thanks for the starfish! haha :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
yay! congrats on 1500 subs :)
FaeryFaith 2 years ago
thanks Heather :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
oh man! it was soo hard not to sing along, because then I would totally screw up the song... so I watched once, and the second time I gave in to my urge to sing.
nenalyzed 2 years ago
thanks Nena! Pffft, you should always feel free to sing along if you ask me!
doctornoise 2 years ago
:D thanx :p I just wish I could sing :D
that would be so much more awesome :p
oh well, I probably have an other talent -or just something I'm good at-, I just need to find it.
nenalyzed 2 years ago
yay awesomeness!! :D
nenalyzed 2 years ago
So awesome!
JayAreEmm 2 years ago
hey there. If I recall you're actual name is Jennifer yes? Thanks so much!
doctornoise 2 years ago
That it is. :)
And you're welcome. I very much enjoy your music.
JayAreEmm 2 years ago
Great cover :)
paisleypower30 2 years ago
Paisley! thanks so much :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Great :D
johnduffboy 2 years ago
hey there John, thank you very much
doctornoise 2 years ago
awsome cover bill
slaveheartband 2 years ago
thanks so much mate!
doctornoise 2 years ago
VERY well done! Loved it!
villeannxD 2 years ago
Thank you villeann!
doctornoise 2 years ago
that has to be one of the best covers, no actualy the best....... loved it, why are you not playing at festivals all round the world? if u were at download i would go and watch. do u know what download is?? if not its a british festival loOol
20/10
gothictitch 2 years ago
I'd love to play festivals around the world...but I suppose to do that people would actually have to know who I am...and as it stands...nobody really does! hehe. Very happy you enjoyed it gothic!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Your cover is so awesome Bill. Brillant.
BarryAldridge 2 years ago
Thanks a lot Barry!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Ahhhh.... I love this song.
I'm always a huge fan of Acoustic covers. Something about a guy or girl with a guitar just doing their thing... is always really amazing to hear.
-Sara
CleverestWitch2188 2 years ago
I know what you mean about acoustic covers, I've always felt that way too. Thanks much Sara :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
You did it again! loved it! Great cover!
Lazydays00 2 years ago
hey Lazydays! thanks I'm glad you liked it
doctornoise 2 years ago
I never really liked this song much but now i have listened to it more i love it!! :D
SarcasticMirkwoodElf 2 years ago
isn't it funny how some songs are like that? There's plenty of songs I didn't really like til listening to them over and over, then suddenly they're a favourite!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I LOVE this song! Great cover. :)
Starlysh 2 years ago
hey Starlysh! Thanks a lot!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Wah~!! One of my favorite songs!
I love this cover! Your voice kinda.. I wanna say it trembles? It adds so much emphasis to the lyrics!! ^^
scrip7ki77y 2 years ago
I know what you're talking about. hehe. I'm glad you like it!
doctornoise 2 years ago
WooooooooooooooooooooooogoBill!
lol Great cover, you should do a 2.0 of 'I feel fantastic' but play it like you do on blogtv.
Just a suggestion.
Peace out, yo! *attempts gangsta exit and nearly trip over himself*
TeddyBearWithSexHair 2 years ago
haha, Joetholomew! Glad you enjoyed the song and thanks for the suggestion!
doctornoise 2 years ago
liked it
diesuici 2 years ago
cheers, thank you
doctornoise 2 years ago
Another great cover done by Dr. Noise!! Great job as usual, Bill =]
KavithaisPadfoot 2 years ago
Hey Padfoot, thanks so much! Means a lot!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Anytime, Bill, I love your videos ;D
KavithaisPadfoot 2 years ago
I think it is really awesome to hear and see how much you have grown as a musician. because this rerecording sounds really amazing. i like your vocals with it.
<3sMK
SciFiGirl1023 2 years ago
Thanks MK, those are some very nice words, I apprecaite it!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Your cover of this never ceases to be awesome :D
valerie2776 2 years ago
hoorrraaaay! Thank you Val! :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Loved it!
I like the Gary Jules version better then the Tears for Fears version, unfortunately. I always feel guilty when I don't listen to the original. I think I like your cover the best, though haha :D I'm going to download it ^^
MusicIsFreedom42 2 years ago
I have to agree.
Though I generally prefer originals to covers in almost every case, I'm not a huge fan of the Tears for Fears version, even though the song is theirs.
Still, your cover is awesome, and I shall download it!
wintersweet 2 years ago
thanks Winter! Glad you liked it
doctornoise 2 years ago
Thanks so much I'm happy you're downloading it. There's nothing wrong with liking Gary's version over the TFF version. Nothing at all!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I <3 Tears for Fears!
Though Gary jules cover is pretty fantastic.
ehmkay 2 years ago
yes yes, both versions of the song are most def. awesome in their own special ways.
doctornoise 2 years ago
I love Tears for Fears. . . and practically every other 80s band. =]
Great Job!
chrissyjeano 2 years ago
80's fan alert! hehe me too... 80's rule!
doctornoise 2 years ago
There's quite the difference between this and the first video you did...that was so long ago.
But this was super. <3
sammicula 2 years ago
yaaa, this time you can hear me being the biggest difference ha
doctornoise 2 years ago
Dr.Noise you are a great singer, but this song isn't really meant for your kind of voice.
HAJS5 2 years ago
I appreciate your comments and opinions, thanks a lot! :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Sweet, that was sick! I love that song and your cover of it as I listen to your cover on my iPod more than that of Gary Jules.
-Julian
ItTakesII 2 years ago
Julian, that's because you have good taste. haha. No but really thanks a lot!
doctornoise 2 years ago
:D I love your cover of this.
kaylaTRON 2 years ago
Thanks Kayla! :) Much appreciated
doctornoise 2 years ago
Good cover Bill!
phampants 2 years ago
Thanks John!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I have that Fight Club poster, but mine's all ripped. :( <3 youuuu
dawlfacex 2 years ago
but you still have it, making you awesome. :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
I LOVE this song! thanks for doing it
bossler13 2 years ago
Thanks Bossler and you're welcome :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
So great.
P.S. Your hair looks really good in this.
amelioooo 2 years ago
AMELIOOOOOO! Thanks so much on both accounts :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
I accidentally rated four starfish instead of five.
I r sadfacepout.
But I love this song, especially your version. It makes me happy. <3
AshleyDough 2 years ago
4 starfish, 5 starfish, as long as there's some starfish everyone's happy! I'm glad you liked the song Ash thanks!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Bill I've heard you sing this song so many times that it's seared into my brain...I sing along too every time you play it.
Please excuse me I have to go download this...I have some singing to do.
Thanks Bill.
dripduke 2 years ago
Hey Duke! Glad you enjoyed it and downloaded it. I very much appreciate it.
doctornoise 2 years ago
this is a great song for you!
well done, deserved five starfish indeed <3
laurelissocoollike 2 years ago
Hey Laruel! Thanks much, I appreciate it very much!`
doctornoise 2 years ago
Great stuff!
DirectorToby 2 years ago
Hey Toby how's it going? Thanks a lot mate!
doctornoise 2 years ago
5 Starfish indeed! Amazingly done! <3 Even my cat liked it :) She was sitting with me while i listened, and be proud, my cat is not easily pleased.
VanillaxSmoke 2 years ago
hoorrrray! I made your kitty happy! Thanks for the starfish also ;)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Freaking awesome! Totally putting this one in my Dr Noise collection on my ipod! :)
-Jenea
xXDiscoLemonadeXx 2 years ago
thanks, and I'm quite okay with any addition to the Dr. Noise Ipod collection. hehe :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Oh, and I love the emotion you put into this.
Gah....now I need to watch Donnie Darko and listen to my 80s music!
SupremeAmanda 2 years ago
Bill you've done it again.
Amazing!
SupremeAmanda 2 years ago
Amanda the SUUPPRREEEEEME! THanks a lot I'm glad you enjoyed it
doctornoise 2 years ago
awesome!
kira902k 2 years ago
hey Kira! Thanks a lot :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
I like both versions of the song, but I like Gary Jules' cover a lot more, I feel it has a lot more depth and feeling in it.
CellPhoneMern 2 years ago
right awn right on. I'm also a big fan of both versions!
doctornoise 2 years ago
This has always been one of my favorite songs, I'm so glad you covered it! :]
musicislife00000 2 years ago
thanks! I've actually covered it twice now, I did it once a couple years ago, vid is still up... sound sucked though so I thought it was time to redo it for fun.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Such a great song. Now I want to go watch Donnie Darko :0P
TwiztedScorpio04 2 years ago
you know, so do I. Did you hear there's going to be a sequel written by an entirely different person?
doctornoise 2 years ago
Yeah, I did. I'm actually a little freaked out about it. I love the original so much and I'm nervous that they're just going to destroy it. I'm gonna guess that you've probably seen the trailer for it?
On a more or less completely random sidenote: I just saw "Hunger" (dir. Steve McQueen, 2008) at our local film fest and I'm recommending it to EVERYONE (or at least everyone who isn't squeamish) because it was so well done that it blew my mind.
TwiztedScorpio04 2 years ago
i love love love this song! ^^
awesomely done!
thenextbigthing12 2 years ago
me too! It's such a good song, and thank you! I appreciate that!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Awesome.
WerewolfActivist 2 years ago
Thanks Werewolf!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I lovelovelove this song!
cindrachilly 2 years ago
me too! hehe.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Ahh Bill! You stole my idea, I was just about to try to learn this on guitar. Lol. :)
caseadillas 2 years ago
aww, no reason to stop! Learn it and perform it, then let me know where I can watch it. I originally recorded a vid for this in Dec. of 06...still have it on my channel... I said a long time ago to those who liked it I'd redo it cuz the sound sucked...just finally got around to it.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Guess what, i did learn it, about 30 seconds after I finished watching this. I'll edit it once I'm done with all my tests this week and put it up as a video response. :)
caseadillas 2 years ago
That was awesome Bill. You always play great music I've never heard before :)
xperpetualmotion 2 years ago
thanks so much and I'm also very happy that I can give to you music you've yet to discover!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Nice. 5 starfish!
also: 28-08-42-12
thhelix 2 years ago
woo hoo Donnie Darko references! Yay thanks for all the kickass starfish!
doctornoise 2 years ago
I just now decided that you're going to by my "channel of the month" for april. Every month I tell my subscribers a channel they should check out. You definitely got it.
PaulSaysThings 2 years ago
thanks Paul, that's very nice of you and I sure do appreciate it mate!
doctornoise 2 years ago
This video is such a success I feel like I wanna put a chain comment on it.
suchducks 2 years ago
hahaha, Nice Blaze nice. That's been reserved for my TROCK video. You wanna give people bad luck? DO IT OVER THERE!!! ;P
doctornoise 2 years ago
Voice works perfect for this song. Love it ^^
hackman460 2 years ago
thanks a lot Hackman, much appreciation.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Kind of ironic how you put this out and it becomes my fave song of the moment again. Awesome job!
lovexxxlost 2 years ago
hehe, glad I could help you find a new favourite song this week :) Thanks so much!!
doctornoise 2 years ago
aaaw, your voice is so perfect for this song... Beautiful Bill, just beautiful... :)
iaMyla 2 years ago
Thanks Myla! Glad you liked it.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Nice cover. I love this song.
Kimmiko 2 years ago
Thanks Kimmiko...it really is a great song. It really sets a good mood in the right atmosphere. Esp. Gary Jules cover of it.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Always enjoy this song, nice job, Dr.
fallofautumndistro 2 years ago 2
thanks Alan. Much appreciated
doctornoise 2 years ago
Lovely!!! I love this song, and your cover was amazing!!! Have a great week.
regamom3 2 years ago
I"m glad ya liked it Rega! Thanks so much and you have a great week too :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Just downloaded the first version you did of this from your site today (I have Bill on my iTunes now - Yay!). Totally signed up, as well!
Great cover, again. You're consistently amazing! I agree, I prefer covering the TFF version more than I do the Gary Jules version. The original's more upbeat. :]
(Oh, and all five starfish were brilliant, and send their regards..)
Flangel66 2 years ago
Thanks a lot Flangel and welcome to my website! I'm happy to have a spot in your ITunes! Makes me feel special :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
Tears for Fears are awesome. I always did like the original Tears for Fears version over Gary Jules'... anyway, good cover.
cushlinkes 2 years ago
yeaaa, 80's music... certainly had it's own sound back then. Thanks a lot!
doctornoise 2 years ago
Nice cover! I know both versions, but I think I like the Tears for Fears version a little more. And now your cover of it.
livin4hymn 2 years ago
thanks a lot. Yeah, both are great version of the song. Naturally one should have the most respect for the original, but it goes without saying that Gary's version is brilliant too.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Awesome. =D
IdiotFest101 2 years ago
thanks Mr. Fest :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
I am so downlaoding this, Bill you're made of awesome. And you mentioned me like 4 times on your live show last week it made me happy!
MissKarma<3
PaperbackWriter9 2 years ago
well you betta download it! hehe. I'm very happy you liked it Miss K. :)
doctornoise 2 years ago
awesome man
CaptainWilhelm 2 years ago
Cheers Wilhelm, thanks a lot.
doctornoise 2 years ago
Awesome as always.
JohnnyXCore 2 years ago