Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (229)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What the hell is victoria doing as a judge

  • @LoveTVDXo What the hell is she doing? Talking about clothes and dress lookking. -_-

  • Oh ok Tyler with that broken arm #Swag lol

  • when he came in people weren't so sure.. but when he started singing and let that chemistry out with his facial expressions, he shined. it's ALL about the way you carry yourself and the energy you give off.

  • she should hv sung the whole song ! <3

  • Is she that good? Dont thing so..

  • she was amazing 

    \

  • I miss old American Idol. I HATED the fact that In Season 8, neither Adam or Alison won. The cute guy did, who wasn't gay. And he sucked! Really..

    And now it's cute GUYS with little talent. Sure, they can sing. But not good. That's why I dropped this show.

    Simon's snarky attitude was a big lose( I loved him. :| ), even Paula was a big lose. Without the original trio and intelligent voters, this show has gone down the drain.

  • Honestly....but what the hell is doing Victoria Beckham there? :D

  • Comment removed

  • lmao all Victoria talked about was how she was dressed. That was kinda funny.

  • lmao all Victoria talked about was how she was dressed. Thats was kinda funny.

  • Posh Spice looks sickly.

  • if you want them through vote! dont complain vote I learned that

  • great singing

  • She's no Mrs. Keys! But shes good

  • i love thatcoca cola glases

  • look at her face in 1:04

  • why is kara always lip syncing with the contestants

  • I wanted her to win, end of story. 

  • She reminds me of Jordin Sparks.

  • @ccgoose93 ikr..i said the samething

  • she's really good, but not the best, idk why they said she was! lol but she's good!

  • you have a look and voice thats very commercial? really? seriously?! so that's what it takes to be on american idol?

  • Mmhm that was hot

  • I think she was completely overrated. She's pretty, but has an average voice.

  • i love ahley voice

  • Randy's tryin to be the blackest... white, black guy.

  • yeh

  • she looks like Ryan Starr

  • Oh gosh o.o" iStarted freakinq out becoz ididnt know where the music was coming from..

  • she's good

  • 2:57 CREEEPPYYY!

  • actually,all these votes depend on popularity.people vote on the popular and good looking people.if these votes were to depend on the natural voice and singing skills,this show would be amazibng

  • i hate how the judges first comment on the contestants looks instead of commenting on their voices. -.-

  • Um does Posh only comment their outfits?? haha

  • Wow she was amazing!!!!!

  • the show has really gone downhill since paula left and now simon is leaving!!!! there goes the show!

  • @DrewDawsonFan ikr ?! :(

  • @DrewDawsonFan no way!!!! really?! the show is gonna be nothing without him,it's bad enough that paula left.

  • i hate victoria she gets on my nerves!!!!!

  • Victoria does nothing but comment on clothing styles lol.

  • this show isnt the same without paula!

  • No offense but i liked it when paula was here 2 judge...but she quitted :(

  • she was my fav from the begining! i couldn't BELIEVE that she didn't get into the top 12..its madness

  • does some one know the music after she sing?

  • @infernux69 show me what i'm looking for by carolina liar

  • i dont get she was eliminated so fast

  • SH3 GUCCI !!!!!!!!!!

  • Does that fat Briton actually understand American English?

  • Show Me What I'm Looking For - Carolina Liar

  • kurva

  • she was one of my favs :( i was rooting for her from her audition

    too bad she got aliminated

  • 617 All Day <3

  • Simonn iS Hittin Thatt ;]

  • subliminal message?

  • posh is there to fucking judge clothes.

  • wtf , da best looking girl on da show , and with a amazing voice gets out in the first night , that is so gay , and dis season sucks

  • I think Victoria should be one of the Judges of AMERICAS NEXT TOP MODEL" not AMERICAN IDOL........... LOL :-))

  • and i think victoria needs a cheeseburger

  • does she remind ne1 else of mariah carey? great voice

  • I am pissed - I was rooting for her - She had the voice, she is beautiful

  • @EternalSounds when was she voted i just started to watch ai9 4 weeks ago

  • @EternalSounds She came from my Home town. M.A Chelsea. :D

  • posh spice is a moron

  • my singing teacher went to school with her :D

    except apparently she's...not nice...

    hahahaha

  • @ericanjess Which school? I went to high school with her. After high school, she went to Berklee College of Music.

  • she went to Berklee with her.

    But she graduated a year or two before Ashley.

    lol

  • i can't believe she went home on the first night. simon said she could have won the show. thats dumb. that ruined the show.

    ;[

  • she's so beatiful...

  • she left too early, she was the best looking in the whole show.

  • she's baaadd

  • whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy??? she was the best i cant shes was eliminated nooooooooooooooh!!

  • she was my fave in the girls :( shes gorjus and has an amazing voice.x

  • cant believe ashley got eliminated sad

  • so madddddddddddddd ! i can't believe tyler left, i loved him ! GRRR !

  • I can't believe Tyler and Ashley went, I could of easily picked 2 people to replace them. maybe I love her cause I think she is hot but still :P

  • i'm so sad that she didnt go through next week, it sucks\

  • Yeah it sure does suck,I thought she was gonna stay for long. Plus, she's very beautiful too.

  • this show is so stupid now...

    it's all a bunch of little preteen girls voting, and ruining the careers of these people.

    i mean, how can you explain why the pretty girls that can sing are voted off, and the most unattractive guys are voted off, regardless of voice?

    AI should've quit after season 3~4.

  • We should all go start watching X factor when it starts as Simon as judge.

  • @hardr0ck Shut up

  • @hardr0ck That is soooo true...

  • @hardr0ck then again... those preteen girls are the rulers of the mainstream crowd nowadays... sadly........

  • @hardr0ck Yeah, but if American stopped at season 4, there would be no...

    Chris Daughtry, Elliott Yamin, Jordin Sparks, Melinda Doolittle, David Cook, David Archuleta, Norman Gentle, Adam Lambert, Allison Iraheta, Danny Gokey, Lee Dewyze, Crystal Bowersox, of course.... Larry Platt, and many others.

  • @oldblubblub who are those people? haahah

  • The first time i saw Tyler and Ashley, I really said "They'll gonna be in the top 12".

    I was wrong though.

  • The "early front runners" are the first to go. Go figure.

  • Tyler is so friggin kool. Ashley hopefully will make it to the next round and do better next time. Im still pullin for ya Ashley!!!

  • Girlfriend you let us Latinas down last night ...What the hell happend?? Yo, that was so flat at times , i was embrassed for her!! She definitely will not last....See Ya Ashley!! lol

  • @navarrosgirl YOU get ur ass up there and try that shit nervs kill shuuuuut the fuck up get off youtube

  • one of my freinds justin rodriguez i go to school with him it his coiusin i was shocked when he told me

  • She lives in Chelsea Massachusetts.

    Shit.

    Really close to East Boston.

    I hope she wins or at least makes it really far.

  • @ranDUMBcomment my lil brother knows her i yelled at him why didnt u introduce her to me shes hooooot hhahahahahaha

  • she has to win or ill kill my self shes way better than katie stevens!!!! shes my FAVORITE person im voting for her every time she sings!!!

  • @soccergirl112299 hahahhahahahahahahahahahahahah­a i with u hahahahaha i voted lastnight did u ??? kill ur self lmao that shit was funny lololol

  • Someone needs to tell Victoria she is not a fashion judge.

  • Simon did tell her... twice

  • @CNSZU OOOOOOH man am i with u hahahaha

  • ashley is good i mean great but i know she not going to the final i wacthed it but she did a great jod.

  • Ashley kinda look like Sandra Bullock.

  • Honestly, she can sing, but so can i...i think their compliments were kinda much, but I can see how she made it thus far....don't see her going to far in the comp though.

  • @r0xygir7 dont be mad cuz she's hot hating has people thats y the worlds so fuuuuuucked people like u  if u could sing y aint u there hahahahahhahahahahaha loooooser

  • Skeletor said: "Yeah, I think you're great, I mean you look fantastic, you're one of my favourites that I've seen." He used to just be really mean and bang on about He-Man.

  • pleaseeeeee vote vote vote for ashlee i know i am

  • ashley is really good, i also like todrick and andrew

  • Victoris Beckham is so freckin ugly

  • need to put him n some movies $ real I love tyler

  • She's too sexy.

    Although I hope she wins, I'm sure Andrew or Todrick are going to.

  • I love her,John Parks,And ANDREW GARCIA!!!

    Tyler Grady is good but not as good as the ones that i named:)

  • luv ashely

  • Yay!

    I loved Ashley & Tyler since I saw their auditions!

    I was so fucking nervous yeaterday and was SOOO happy when they made it to the top 24!!!

  • Don't worry about Ashley and Tyler. They will both go very far this season. Both are "total package" stars (talent, looks, personality). I am excited and will vote for both of them!!!

  • loveherrr! <3

    hope she winss! :)

    imma be by her side

    throughout the wholee

    seasonnn! :)

  • ryan rejected 2:01 hahahhha :P

  • @eyt19

    hahaha LOL

  • she will win

  • andrew and ashley representing for all the latinos out there!!!! Great job......

  • que chica para mas preciosa

  • So proud of you prima!

  • shes sexy. i hope she wins

  • Congratulations Ashley Top 24!!!!!!!!

  • I think she is the next Jordan Sparks.

  • my prediction she wont made it to the top 12. shes my favorite, shes hot, voice not bad.

  • I love how she's got a bit of an attitude/passion when she sings.

    Why is Randy so retarded? Two million thousand five bazilliiionnnnduuuuhhhh retardddd...

  • She is pretty and a great singer!

  • She's in the top 24 :D

  • I cannot wait for American Idol to be broadcasted over here. So far Tyler is among the one I like the most

  • same

  • .janelle wheeler is going to be the winner mark my word!

  • andrew garcia will win

  • I hope so!

  • K she is goinggg to to winnn!!!!! and tyler will come top 24. either ashley, jermain and keia johnson will win in my opinoin, what do you think?

  • She looks a lot like Mariah Carey.

    She sounds great.

  • such a beautiful voice

  • she is smokin!@

  • 1:34 woot!!!!!! :D

  • she is great!

  • She's very good, but she's not my favourite!!! Let's see who makes the top 12

  • i don't know who i want to win. I am going to wait to i see who makes it to the top 12. then decide.

  • I want this girl so bad to win -

    She is humble and talented.

  • Randy needs to stop this one hundred billion 500 and 54 zillion percent yes bull shit

  • V. is always commenting on how well are the contestants are dressed

  • te amoooo mucho

  • she looks like Jordan Spark

  • this girl and jermain sellars i feel are going to come in the top 5

  • holy shit tthe first girl is my friends cousin! thats crazy as shit.

  • hahaha!

    I love Victoria's comment "I love the way youre dressed!"

    Always Fashion conscious! haha!

  • yaa, she always comment on people's dresses more than about their voice..i guess she was there to look on the contestants' appearance..=)

  • shes my favourite so far: )

  • ASHLEYS MY FAVOURITE!

  • Greaaaaaaaaatt!!!

  • She's definitely good enough for Hollywood but she'll crash in 2 -3 more rounds, fo sho'....

  • @dunice1 Deff NOT! take it from someone who knows her Hollywood is gonna be a walk in the park for her

  • Yea, you might be right. I want to hear her sing more songs... She did aight in Hollywood. You gotta get a little farther to get more spotlight so we'll see..!!

  • best attempt of if i aint got you ive ever seen

  • Tons of talented singers this year. I cannot wait to see their performance. The winner will be another one who sets the high bar for the next year.

  • they both are in the top 24.Confirmed!

  • Comment removed

  • eurgh...seriously why choose victoria beckham for a judge? she has no talent!

  • Comment removed

  • she has different personality its better then having the same boring people

  • thanks! this is really a good copy of the clip, audio wise.

  • ashley is very beautiful and one of my favs but i really think ANDREW GARCIA might b the best.

  • I like Andrew Garcia too and he should do VERY well, hopefully top 5 at least. Lots of good competition this year. Ashley Rodriguez and Jermaine Sellers are both seasoned performers on big stages already (search youtube for their vids). Seen Andrew on a big stage too. So it will be a VERY interesting season. Very interesting. Much better than last year.