I actually did research into this subject. "Witches¨ were more commonly burned in Scotland and mainland europe. In England, most were hung, some were drowned or quartered. For more info on continuation of a limited amount of pre-christian folk belief, see the wikipedia article on "cunning folk". Also look up the etymology (word origins) of the words "bless", "yule" (see especially yule log and ham), and "easter"
@ Enzo012: My objection to ManinCognito's statement indicating an absolute where at best a possibility (though one without any particular support) applied. I certainly have no problem with your statement -- it's actually a good question, though folk songs are notorious for morphing; if it WAS originally made-up in the 6th C., it probably had very different words and melody then....
@ Enzo012: Indeed the song MAY be much older (though there is nothing in the text or music to indicate that, there is nothing to refute it, either ); also, no region/country is ever TRULY monolithic in its belief system -- but it is considered reasonable to consider a country to be of a particular faith if a large majority of the people profess it (e.g. Sunni Islam in Saudi Arabia or Shi'a Islam in Iran).
@ManlnCognito Sorry to disagree, but your timeframe is incorrect. Anglo-Saxon England had pretty much completely converted to Christianity by the end of the 7th C. C.E. This song is attested (and its form clearly shows it to be) from the 13th C. C.E. England had been Christian for something like 600 years by then.
@scalasaig it may have have written then but the song itself may be much older. And the conversion to Christianity was only complete after the witch burning period between 1550-1650.
@Enzo012 The "which Burning Period" is a dubious historical cliche at best. the period 1550-1650 was the period in which a sense of religious paranoia and insecurity resulted from the same social,religious and political movements as were responsible for the protestant reformation. The Practice of burning people alive as a form of punishment was at best rare and obscure during the middle ages and was a punishment for the crime of heresy. (see Joan of arc).
The vast majority of people tried and punished during the which trials (which were more in america than anywhere else) were practicing Christians by faith and were accused by their own people for community based crimes of a supernatural nature.
These people had nothing to do with pagan folk religions native to Europe and Scandinavia. The Closest thing to a mass which hunt in the middle ages were the papal inquisitions which targeted Cathars (Christian heretics) and other political seperatists
See a book called "The sign of the witch" by Dr. David Waldron for a good account of the idea of witchcraft in English history. look it up on amazon.com
one line translates to "the goat is farting"
alatarhasko 3 weeks ago
my choir class is singing this
jzxlovesmjj 2 months ago
O Lord! O Jesus Christ!
gogokt1 2 months ago
This is a pretty song but because of The Wicker Man, I can't helped but feel a bit creeped out when I hewer songs like this one now.
MyKrishkrish 3 months ago
devil music
evenyscrewd 4 months ago
Absolutely wonderful- very bouncy and lively. Thank you for this brilliant recording!
TristanBMusic 4 months ago
And another thing: see on this site "apple wassail"
sacredthornapple 8 months ago
I actually did research into this subject. "Witches¨ were more commonly burned in Scotland and mainland europe. In England, most were hung, some were drowned or quartered. For more info on continuation of a limited amount of pre-christian folk belief, see the wikipedia article on "cunning folk". Also look up the etymology (word origins) of the words "bless", "yule" (see especially yule log and ham), and "easter"
sacredthornapple 8 months ago
Where can this be downloaded?
Cajek2 9 months ago
Very much so. But a nice version of this traditional song, nonetheless.
jwmitch51 11 months ago
What a weird and random conversation
ekras01 11 months ago
@ Enzo012: My objection to ManinCognito's statement indicating an absolute where at best a possibility (though one without any particular support) applied. I certainly have no problem with your statement -- it's actually a good question, though folk songs are notorious for morphing; if it WAS originally made-up in the 6th C., it probably had very different words and melody then....
scalasaig 1 year ago
Comment removed
ManlnCognito 1 year ago
@ Enzo012: Indeed the song MAY be much older (though there is nothing in the text or music to indicate that, there is nothing to refute it, either ); also, no region/country is ever TRULY monolithic in its belief system -- but it is considered reasonable to consider a country to be of a particular faith if a large majority of the people profess it (e.g. Sunni Islam in Saudi Arabia or Shi'a Islam in Iran).
(Please see continuance)
scalasaig 1 year ago
This song (or round) pre-dates Christianity in England.
ManlnCognito 1 year ago
@ManlnCognito Sorry to disagree, but your timeframe is incorrect. Anglo-Saxon England had pretty much completely converted to Christianity by the end of the 7th C. C.E. This song is attested (and its form clearly shows it to be) from the 13th C. C.E. England had been Christian for something like 600 years by then.
scalasaig 1 year ago 2
@scalasaig how do you know
ManlnCognito 1 year ago
Comment removed
scalasaig 1 year ago
@scalasaig you go girl
suznrob 1 year ago
@scalasaig it may have have written then but the song itself may be much older. And the conversion to Christianity was only complete after the witch burning period between 1550-1650.
Enzo012 1 year ago
@Enzo012 The "which Burning Period" is a dubious historical cliche at best. the period 1550-1650 was the period in which a sense of religious paranoia and insecurity resulted from the same social,religious and political movements as were responsible for the protestant reformation. The Practice of burning people alive as a form of punishment was at best rare and obscure during the middle ages and was a punishment for the crime of heresy. (see Joan of arc).
liveyorehistory 1 year ago
The vast majority of people tried and punished during the which trials (which were more in america than anywhere else) were practicing Christians by faith and were accused by their own people for community based crimes of a supernatural nature.
These people had nothing to do with pagan folk religions native to Europe and Scandinavia. The Closest thing to a mass which hunt in the middle ages were the papal inquisitions which targeted Cathars (Christian heretics) and other political seperatists
liveyorehistory 1 year ago
See a book called "The sign of the witch" by Dr. David Waldron for a good account of the idea of witchcraft in English history. look it up on amazon.com
liveyorehistory 1 year ago
hahaha i am never going 2 learn this song....im gonna fail when we sing it :P
EmmaLooseInParadise 2 years ago
haha we're going to sing this in a group in schools music class :S i'm not sure how good it'll sound but :)
evilAramed 2 years ago