Personally I believe that both versions are great because both of them have been played according to the music style of the band!The original has a unique sound of classic rock and the other one has a clear metal sound.
What really makes me mad about you guys is that you say that NW are better that PF (although I'm a big fan of NW).Don't you think, you shoud respect a band that has been active for like 30 years and has been recognized as one of the best rock bands ever?
I absolutely loved Nightwish's version of this song. Well, I didn't actually know that this was a cover until I heard the Nightwish version. I think Nightwish sang it much better than Pink Floyd, I find that the thing I like so much about Nightwish is the excitement and drama of the music. I find bands like Pink Floyd tedious and boring.
The video is nuthin´ but a load of bullshit, just can´t understand how professional cameras on TV ain´t able to film the guitar player on his solo, patethic.
yeah i agree with you spike but i also agree with thoes how say that it's 'forbidden' to cover songs from pink floyd cuz i think if someone does so they have no own ideas to make money so they take ideas of other bands.
loool i love to see people arguing wether Classic rock better or Modern Metal, and tbh few of you sounds like they know what they are talking about here...
Comparing these two bands makes you an idiot. That's like Comparing Black Sabbath and Elvis Presley. two completely different styles and both are good in their own right.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
buka you are correct This song was murdered Nightwish should kill themselves but first Appologize to Floyd for what their ignorant followers had said about this shitty immitation! All Hail David Gilmour and Floyd Forever!
that's very surprising considering you have to be into LSD to really appreciate Pink Floyd. you'd think Acid heads would be more open minded lol. Timothy Leary would be upset with ALL of you! LMAO. i'm amazing
Oh...my...god! >.< I love Nightwish as much as I love Pink Floyd but this...this...this is total crap! Where is the bell? Where is the melody? They ruined a good song...
yeah i see what you mean. But it's a classic Floyd song and I couldn't imagine many decent reasons for a cover version, unless it's really different...like scissor sisters...
Also there's more to the song than this before this solo - quite a lot of it in fact. Whoever uploaded this did unfortunately miss some of the best parts of the song.
Well,let's all accept that we can't compare these two bands.You can't compare symphonic metal with psychedelic rock.You just can't!
travel23231 1 year ago
Personally I believe that both versions are great because both of them have been played according to the music style of the band!The original has a unique sound of classic rock and the other one has a clear metal sound.
What really makes me mad about you guys is that you say that NW are better that PF (although I'm a big fan of NW).Don't you think, you shoud respect a band that has been active for like 30 years and has been recognized as one of the best rock bands ever?
travel23231 1 year ago
I absolutely loved Nightwish's version of this song. Well, I didn't actually know that this was a cover until I heard the Nightwish version. I think Nightwish sang it much better than Pink Floyd, I find that the thing I like so much about Nightwish is the excitement and drama of the music. I find bands like Pink Floyd tedious and boring.
thisthatandtother 1 year ago
fucking awesome and greatttttttttt cover
and i like the both version cause they rn't in the same style so i can i enjoy it in metal and in rock
nightwish rocks
risingwarem 2 years ago
A disgrace. Fucking cover.
ssidaoss 2 years ago
i wanna see the full video...
Daudiu 2 years ago
awesome nice cover greatttttttttt
nightwish rocks
123789h 3 years ago
The video is nuthin´ but a load of bullshit, just can´t understand how professional cameras on TV ain´t able to film the guitar player on his solo, patethic.
jbarquilla 3 years ago 3
he likes dimmu borgir! that is so cool, but he seems quite religious...hmmm tuomas is a paradox!
Llokky 3 years ago
lol i went to DB concert! amuzing awesome show!
plutoniangirl 3 years ago
yeah i agree with you spike but i also agree with thoes how say that it's 'forbidden' to cover songs from pink floyd cuz i think if someone does so they have no own ideas to make money so they take ideas of other bands.
liam667 3 years ago
loool i love to see people arguing wether Classic rock better or Modern Metal, and tbh few of you sounds like they know what they are talking about here...
Spike2cool 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
pinkfloyd is the best sucker!!!
mid085 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you are right, this imitation ruin the memories of pink floyd
Honeytimeyeah 4 years ago
NW's outdoes Pink Floyd's all the way, Pink Floyd's is shitty
AeonBloom 4 years ago
I don't think Pink Floyd is shitty, but I agree that Nightwish is better! :-D
Beeshington 4 years ago 11
@Beeshington First, Nightwish is definetly NOT better than PF" you must be high. 2nd, you can not compare apples to oranges.
Nice version of the song but i can not say Nightwish tops PF... I think this is taking it too far.
aelbadri 1 year ago
You got to be kidding me, Pink Floyd was and IS better musicians than NW will ever be.
BiggestE 3 years ago
yes, that's why nightwish does the cover, not Pink Floyd.
Spennis1982 3 years ago 2
Comparing these two bands makes you an idiot. That's like Comparing Black Sabbath and Elvis Presley. two completely different styles and both are good in their own right.
PhantomLord 3 years ago
good god...one of my favourite songs has been killed...no one should cover pink floyd..it should be punished
buka1313 4 years ago
ahhhhh? did you see Dream Theater´s covers of Pink Floyd?
Or Queensryche´s?
Listen to it and speak again.
FallingPT 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
buka you are correct This song was murdered Nightwish should kill themselves but first Appologize to Floyd for what their ignorant followers had said about this shitty immitation! All Hail David Gilmour and Floyd Forever!
LordEli 3 years ago
They made this song even better. Pink Floyd is overrated anyway. Zep has many better songs.
PhantomLord 3 years ago 2
Amen
FutileGrief 3 years ago
@PhantomLord Pink Floyd are overrated?Are you serious?Just try not to be so absolute.
travel23231 1 year ago
@travel23231 lol thanks for responding to something i wrote 2 years ago way to stay current lol.
PhantomLord 1 year ago
@PhantomLord You're welcome!I hope you have thought it over in the last 2 years.
travel23231 1 year ago
Great! They saved this song :)
Idollisimo 4 years ago 4
pink floyd fan's are really close minded ... this is a cool version of this song ... nightwish rocks
Wouli06 4 years ago 11
that's very surprising considering you have to be into LSD to really appreciate Pink Floyd. you'd think Acid heads would be more open minded lol. Timothy Leary would be upset with ALL of you! LMAO. i'm amazing
PhantomLord 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no one should touch pink floyd
nayil100 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hate this version! THEY MURDERED PINK FLOYD!
This is a ridiculous SHIT!
mariafernanda83 4 years ago
Oh...my...god! >.< I love Nightwish as much as I love Pink Floyd but this...this...this is total crap! Where is the bell? Where is the melody? They ruined a good song...
Macio26 4 years ago
Macio you have spoken truth
LordEli 3 years ago
yeah i see what you mean. But it's a classic Floyd song and I couldn't imagine many decent reasons for a cover version, unless it's really different...like scissor sisters...
porly666 4 years ago
hmm they murdered a good song.
porly666 4 years ago
opinionz olo. -_-
I like both versions, anyone who argues without taking opinions and variations in musical styling into account is just being unnecessarily retarded.
idshanks 4 years ago
Also there's more to the song than this before this solo - quite a lot of it in fact. Whoever uploaded this did unfortunately miss some of the best parts of the song.
idshanks 4 years ago
Porly you are correct
LordEli 3 years ago