Bee Gees - Live by request - I started a joke

[stevewantsit1]

You can combat that nasty bastard cancer Robin.

[mauricewhite2]

Fantàstic show de televisió!!

Una de les meves preferides!!

Pell de gallina!!

[vk026481]

love it love the beegees

[littlemissmusictunes]

The melodies and Lyrics pull at the heart! 

[Liz25able]

A beautiful song to this day, we forget how good these band of brothers were.Not too many songs that Robin performed especially latterly. But when Robin did sing it was special. Fight the fight Robin and beat this bastard disease..

[princessoffire1107]

I cry every time I hear this beautiful voice and sad song. I am praying hard for Robin's health to improve , but if God decides to take him home... all I can say is , He needed Robins angelic voice to harmonize with Andy and Maurice's until Barry is taken Home. The day they are gone from this world, it will be a much less beautiful place but I am so grateful we will have their amazing songs to keep us going !

[Alicia5525]

@princessoffire1107 Beautiful words for Robin. He can´t leave us. Too much talent..!!! As the song says.."fight....", please!!!! / Hermosas palabras para Robin. No nos puede dejar.... demasiado talento!!!!! Como dice la canción " lucha...", por favor....!!!! Many blessings for him ( and for his brother, the georgeus Barry...!!!)......

[mcampeau11]

@princessoffire1107 What a beautiful thing to say...thank you for speaking for us all! <3 ♫

[blitzcraig7]

The best song ever written.

[mollysangelique]

ok,ik,weet,het,niet,helemaal,v­ol,er,is,iets,gebeurd,is,dat,z­o,het,bracht,ons,samen,ik,hou,­,van,jou,we,zyn,gelykwaardig,

[AnonymoussourceL0L]

good singing voice, even live. We need more of that now a days.

[ikinmath]

What a beautiful song! Great !

[KarHeiSanjo]

May GOD heal Robin for the best by HIS grace !

[mickeyadams527]

@KarHeiSanjo like i told porcelaincougar, Robin's health is in GOD's hands, he is in control of the situation, the LORD may let him stay or take him home

[porcelaincougar]

Worried about Robin, say a prayer, it doesn't look good. :(

[mickeyadams527]

@porcelaincougar it sure doesnt look good, but only GOD himself will control whether Robin stays or goes, it's always in his hands.

[rbford]

What a great song, thanks for posting it

[DorothyShelley]

love his his voice his pitch perfect1 of the best groups ever sad maurice is no longer withus r i p thankyou so much mythras90x

[dwipbhakti]

May the Almighty God gives you hidayah, Bee gees lovely

[Unkidi]

Fantastic! But Cant Believe Barry Isn't Facing The Audience

[TekkerzOOT]

Truly one of those songs that you just have to sit back and listen to atleast 10 times in a row, like I just did. :o)

[MrLucas150295]

she was not unnecessarily broke here in Brazil in 1969

incredible vibrato robin

[1MindAstray]

No one can sing this song but Robin Gibb! What a great voice ... beauty beyond compare ... beauty beyond words!

[CaroleBoudreau58]

IT IS TO BEAUTIFUL FOR WORDS....

[redrosas]

The emotions he gives, just takes my breath away, he got a fantastic voice, the best.

[mollysangelique]

ik,heb,gelyk

[MegaStizzo]

I'm from Italy. Bee Gees is one of those bands that make great music and their music is just like poetry.

[jjaypatton]

The disrespect that Barry Gibb shows in this video is disgusting. As soon as Robin started singing he turned his back to him and the crowd. I love the BeeGees with a passion but this rankles me sooooooooooooooo much. Robin you sang this amazingly

[hebab1]

@jjaypatton

it's not "in this video". Barry always does so. each time they perform this song.

[mollysangelique]

a,joke,beter,nooit,meer,doen,h­e,jy,kan,zoveel,vertellen,stil­l,waters,wil,jy,myn,man,worden­,nee,geen,huwelyk,perse,joke,d­aar,ook,by,my,he

[mollysangelique]

a,joke,beter,nooit,meer,doen,h­e,jy,kan,zoveel,vertellen,stil­l,waters,wil,jy,myn,man,worden­,nee,geen,huwelyk,perse,

[rsut16]

These guys are the best group in history, there will never be a better group.

[Efrem2011]

but the wig?

[mollysangelique]

still,????no,chris,lykt,op,jou­,slim,foto,jy,in,jong,je,chang­ed,met,older,wordenxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxzit,je,nog,vast,in,je,jo­ke

[mollysangelique]

still,????no,chris,lykt,op,jou­,slim,foto,jy,in,jong,je,chang­ed,met,older,wordenxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxx

[mollysangelique]

ik,las,je,doet,overdag,veel,sa­vonds,wil,je,ontspannen,is,ok,­dan,type,ik,niet,voor,my,minde­r,druk,maakt,my,ook,actief,hyp­er,opgefockt,dacht,hy,is,alone­,vind,hy,gezellig,nou,ok

[GeorgeCarlinEatPussy]

Great song to slit your wrists to.

[001silky]

robin gibb - one of the most beutifull and talented male vocalists of all time.

his voice is god given and heaven sent ,and i get the shivers down my spine every

time i listen to him sing.

this is a truly magical performance.

[DannyBoy7584]

This is for my brother ,who love this song ..R.I.P with love to you alway`s ..

[erickvanlobster2010]

y ahora

[topperharley822]

this is the first time I hear this song...very much unlike any other song I heard, very particular and detailed in feelings that lets u feel..

[chinds1985]

I too, while a teenager in the 1970's loved the Bee Gee's and their music helped me through all of the growing pains of being a teen. To this day, I still turn to my albums when I need a Bee Gees fix, and it never fails, I leave happy.

[Lyricz33]

I live and breath the Bee Gees's I have been a devoted fan since I was 14 and received my first album Bee Gees Love Songs. Robin's voice is intoxicating.

[mike7378]

what a voice

[sdakotag]

This song moves my heart every time i hear it

[robowen11]

I like the Bee Gees, but Barry's a bit full of his own self importance at times. I think its ignorant to turn his back to the audience because he's not in the spotlight. But in doing so he's attracting attention to himself and taking from Robin. They all should face the audience for every song. Great song though, beautifully sung.

[YawnGod]

@robowen11 What? I took it the other way. I took it as him turning his back on the audience as him giving the stage to his brother, so he's the only face to look at in this solo song.

Interesting.

[chiqistar]

Not sure if this was ever released as a single in the U.K. If not, then what went wrong? It must be one of their best songs.

[comtransbg]

@chiqistar

It's a song from 1968. Indeed, one of their best and most popular.

[911muskrat]

a good song  and i still love it

[youbestbequiet]

His voice is just Hauntingly awesome.

[Catcherintherye11111]

this song makes me think of the last person on earth all alone with no one around. very sad image.

[leilalovesrobin]

thanks for the beauty of your songs.... i love you robin....

[DannyBoy7584]

such a good song ,lovey "Bee Gees Rock!!!!!!!

[vofela23]

song that can make you sleep, song that can make you feel the beauty of life and song. a legendary song

[cyndym2001]

I love all the brother's voices, but I swear Robin Gibb has the most beautiful voice that I have ever heard! Btw, miss you Maurice (RIP)

[Eriksen13]

I've been planning to have my Will updated for a while now, and one of the changes I'm going to make is that "I Started a Joke" be played at my funeral/gathering/whatever the living decide to do with me after I'm gone.

[golfern58]

How long do you think this will be on You Tube before A and E will have it removed for copyright infringment?

[vipyaofu]

时光倒转 回到儿时记忆

[immanicmania]

Does anyone know why Barry has his back to the audience when they perform this song,. this song and Robin very beautiful

[draakmanz]

@immanicmania cuz this song isnt about barry being in the spotlight

[yeoGlover]

@immanicmania Maybe a bit of interaction with the band,he does seem to have done it alot on this song live over the years.

[huntingun1]

@immanicmania Cause he is a fucking spoiled brat!

[Bo618]

Fantastic

[Jack55seu]

that serious of the love without the romantic music?.. excellent.. video

[Jack55seu]

that serious of the love without the romantic music?....

[orempillo]

Excellent!~~~~~~

[orempillo]

Hello there.. watching you again,, oh really i will not tired of always looking at you and listening your songs. I love you Mr Robin!~

[NyeTunes]

Oh Robin, lose that wig already...

[hdiylove]

I just had to stop and listen again all the way through of course!

[truckstar42]

than you must all listen to the song weddingday also from dis dvd

[Cem0305]

I think the technical term is "tear in his voice" - Just like Patsy Cline, STUNNING!

[scuterzola]

splendidi con la loro musica hanno segnato l esistenza di 4 generazioni e continueranno a farlo w brothers gibb andy e maurice we miss you

[TheHunter528]

I love all their music? Is anybody knows where I can get this DVD? I'm dying to get this one! Thank you very much!

[larrek]

Try on amazon. Search for Bee Gees - Live by request

[TheHunter528]

thank you very much larrek I found it..

[bio999777]

Robin Gibb eres el mejor... Desde Venezuela te envio un gran saludo y mi admiracion por ti!!!

[milomilesaway]

best vocals and song writers ever.

Love their lyrics!

[katiya64]

I just happened upon this song and WOW it's a beautiful song. His voice is wonderful. I did look up an older version and I like this one the best. It does bring tears to your eyes.

[sclubsamm]

they rock!!!! awesome i love bee gees

[roseuk1]

Wonderful.........makes me cry, the emotion and singing are amazing.

[Emmalala123]

Robin's voice is just mindblowing - it's so special and he is fantastic live. He has so much emotion in his voice...

[ninjabluewings]

The Way Robin Sings This Song Is PURE EMOTION! It Could Bring A Tear To The Eyes Of The Devil For Sure, NO OTHER PERSON! On Earth Could EVER! Convey This Song As WONDERFUL!

[MrPassfield]

@ninjabluewings

Have you heard the version by Angela Zhang... Check it out now.

I am a huge Bee Gees fan but she does and AMAZING cover.

[ninjabluewings]

@MrPassfield No I Hadn't So On Your Suggestion I Checked It Out And I Have To Agree It's One SUPER VERSION!

[chimmalo]

the great beegees you'll last forever in our hearts!! when you arrive to perlygates surely god will say "you've done more than i've expected well done my boys"!!!!

[mythebau]

P.s. -Robin, just in case u EVER watch utube..im so, so sorry for your twin brother (and andy) but twins run so rapid in my family, probably more then any family i have ever known and i just cant imagine how it feels to lose ur twin brother..luv and hugs, Jenni

[ilovemaroon5]

you should write him his youtube is robingibb i wrote him

[GeorgeCarlinEatPussy]

@mythebau Hi,I am Robin.Your mother should have aborted ALL of her children,as they are even uglyer than me.

[mythebau]

One of my FIRST favorited ballets as a teen, GOD i love this song sofa king much!! ty , jenni  p.s. - if there is ANYONE who has more from this event/concert of the beegee's, pls copy and paste links to my email here??? thx in advance if you take that time :)

[winciepoo]

You can never go wrong with these talented

guys. Wonderful singers, entertainers. I've

always loved them and their music.

[BeeGeesFan]

I was there live in the fifth row on April 27, 2001!

From Kirsten

[mythebau]

Hey BeeGeesFan - u lucky dog!! (sorry for being so gabby here today but i just love this song) so, just two more things, One - Man, he sings this song just as good as the day he/they released it and Finally, notice how Barry has his back to the fans during this song as not to take any distraction from Robin :) GOD i wish i was old enough to have been at their concerts...and damnit MY GENERATION - PLEASE, pls find some talent and use it like this!! NO MORE RAP CRAP!!