Added: 5 years ago
From: stonedcomedianringo
Views: 70,861
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (57)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • How to butcher a great song. Horrible, horrible, horrible......

  • @jvaish Mark Seymour is married with several kids and is not gay - he is a local on the Mornington Peninsula in Victoria - he wrote this song and his heart-felt performance is streets ahead of any of the other versions of this song.

  • Sounds like shit.

  • Isn't rubbish but suffers in comparison to original, Crowded House or Mark Seymour acoustic versions. He is playing it too fast and the song suits an acoustic better.

  • beautiful song

  • I will kiss you in four places Eddie XX

  • i can sing 180deg as well.

  • fucken shit.. PJ should have stopped singing after better man.

  • That's shit...

  • I will come to you in the DAYTIME ??

  • legend

  • Vedder is a bloody legend . He is paying tribute to a song he says they always play around the campfire. Live it is brilliant ...it's just this recording is not so good.

  • I love Neil Finns version of this , his is not as good and the sound is awful

  • Epic Fail....Too Fast.... Too distorted....

  • Why is this so fast ... wrecks a great song

  • teakwondo, or whatever your name is. You truly are a penis. You........fortunately have never met me (from my point of view). They murder a superb song, i was trying to be objective........however you cant educate pork........so go away you sad cock, hey maybe learn something about music????? WORTH A TRY DICKSPLASH

  • he rushes the song way too much. And he murders the song. Pearl Jam are wank anyway, but this is pitiful

  • your a wanker

  • Firstly,i am a HUGE Eddie Vedder fan and PJ are my favourite band,and I'm sorry to everyone,but Ed kills this classic Aussie song.Hearing Mark Seymour sing it on his own with an acoustic is just magic.

    And as Aussies,we dont throw shrimp's on the barbie! Steaks and chops mate,then shitloads of beer :-)

  • @leesmartin I don't know. I felt the same about the Hunters and Gatherers but then found out Mark Seymour was gay so I couldn't identify with his version as much. I appreciate the sentiment but whenever I hear Mark singing it I get the visual of him being with another man and it changes the tone too much for me. I love vagina too much I suppose. PJ rocks!!

  • THis is my teachers favourite band, after seeing this i respect my teacher alot more.

  • Mark Seymour from Hunters and Collectors wrote this song. H and C are aussies and we are very proud the boys have made a song that is a true classic, evidenced by the great musos who cover it. It is a universal song. I still want to hear Mr. Springsteen perform it.

  • LOL um yeah, the original was Australian, not European, but whatever

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • You Fuckhead The Original Was Australian Not European.

  • Comment removed

  • Ok Dip Shit, 1. I've Never Had Shrimp In My Life. 2. I'm Not The One That Took The Aboriginals Land Away From Them, I AM ABORIGINAL ! 3. I Don't Have A Fucking Stick Up My Arse, Why Don't You Back Up Your Insults.

    Fucking Idiot.

  • hey retared we don't say shimp we say prawns deeeeeeeeerrrrrrrr!!!!

    smack head!

  • @awkando2 "retared" is that slang in Austria there? Was one previously "tared" and the "re-tared"? BTW it's spelled "you're" not "your". Considering you are probably descended from an English criminal we can let it slide. (yeah, yeah I know it's Australia but who cares really? If it ain't American it don't matter... ;) )

  • my neck is sore :(

  • Sound on recorder too high when recorded. It should be down all the way. I don't think it was the reverb of amplifier that the band was using, because they usually record well.

  • Nice to see the song brought to a US audience :)

  • Wow, how did he keep from falling down??

  • LOL

  • this is a nice rendition... it really is! it doesn't have Ben H, it doesn't have D*A*A*S amazing harmonic accompaniment, it doesn't have the gritty realism of the original, but as it stands, and considering it's live, this is a truly heartfelt rendition, listen to his voice, he means every bloody word whether he wrote it or not!

  • Yuck, don't like this version at all, much prefer the originale (obvious!!) and neil finn's rendition of this classic:-)

  • Hunters & Collectors.

  • I like the slight key change he uses on the chorus, but I wish he wouldn't fuck up the second verse. "I touched your head and touched your feet" gives the song the emotional imagery that makes it. I do however prefer to be kissed in 155 places rather than jusr 4, but that can be done in the daytime just as well! Powerful song either way.

  • good comment sadie, thanks! i agree with all you said

  • i was at the pittsburgh show and so pissed i missed this..probably my favorite pj cover

  • Hunters and Collectors song = Mark Seymor ! Neil Finn and Crowded house + many others have covered it (including the BRILLIANT Eddie V) but it's written by Mark Seymor of Hunters and Collectors (Aussie icons)

  • he sings it to fast the doug anthony all stars sing it the best

  • Actually if you manage to find the original version of the Human Fraility album, you'll find it has a faster tempo.

  • Hunters and Collectors= Neil Finn= Split Enz= Crowded House. :) Great song!

  • Not quite, Hunters&Collectors, lead singer Mark Seymour. Nick Seymour was/is in Crowded House. Classic song.

  • cracking song ,

  • this is originally an aussie group song yeah??

  • yep, Hunters and Collectors.

  • no worries.  next time i will try to remember to shoot horizontally.

  • err, sorry didnt see the whole thing before i posted haha

  • hey toss this on windows movie maker and give it a rotate :)

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more