Thanks again for sharing this video with us. My son just asked to listen to you play this piece to get the big picture of the final product. I let him, but with the warning that he was no allowed to try to play it fast yet. :-) You are an amazing pianist!
Muito bem executado, sem erros. No entanto, só não entendi por qual motivo os movimentos têm velocidades tão diferentes a ponto de comprometerem a unidade da obra. O primeiro e o terceiro deles foram tocados tão rapidamente que o segundo aparece isolado e de tal forma lento que não parecemos estar ouvindo uma única peça
A very fine performance. In the slow second movement I would avoid playing some of the ornaments and grace notes too loud, so they do not interrupt the overall mood.
Accent the note on the beat, but play the off-beat leadups softer. Try it.
Excellent playing! The 1st and 2nd movement's tempo was accurate in my opinion..I think the 3rd movement was too fast (my version of the score says presto ma non tropo). I actually try to learn it this period, and I play it at m.m.=126! Anyway, keep playing and enjoying music! Bravo!
Two excellent Austrians prefer even quicker tempo: Brendl, Buchbinder. The Expert of the hammer piano Steier plays exactly in the same tempo, as this Girl. As u know „con brio signifies so to say shine and fire. But stragarz and peteski probably know better...
REAL GOOD BUT REAL FAST. It's good but it's too fast SLOW DOWN so it sounds more musical. I'm playing this song too and I have been playing for years so far. How long have you been playing?
great technique and it's not too fast but that is the way this particular piece should be played. I play this piece by the way. Very good interpretation also.
your playing is really excellent. it is clear you and your sister are on the right way to become professional pianists. slavs and especially russians were everytime the best pianists. good luck to the future!
Thanks again for sharing this video with us. My son just asked to listen to you play this piece to get the big picture of the final product. I let him, but with the warning that he was no allowed to try to play it fast yet. :-) You are an amazing pianist!
Melkhi 1 year ago
too fast but great~
Sakura88Kyuuketsuki 1 year ago
Y do use paddle????
not enough difference of loud and soft... prefer not use paddle at the beginning....but i love the speed...overall, well done
leeyantim 1 year ago
Muito bem executado, sem erros. No entanto, só não entendi por qual motivo os movimentos têm velocidades tão diferentes a ponto de comprometerem a unidade da obra. O primeiro e o terceiro deles foram tocados tão rapidamente que o segundo aparece isolado e de tal forma lento que não parecemos estar ouvindo uma única peça
osni1961 1 year ago
A very fine performance. In the slow second movement I would avoid playing some of the ornaments and grace notes too loud, so they do not interrupt the overall mood.
Accent the note on the beat, but play the off-beat leadups softer. Try it.
Lactoris1 1 year ago
how long did it take you to learn this?
JoshGoldenFan352 1 year ago
Excellent playing! The 1st and 2nd movement's tempo was accurate in my opinion..I think the 3rd movement was too fast (my version of the score says presto ma non tropo). I actually try to learn it this period, and I play it at m.m.=126! Anyway, keep playing and enjoying music! Bravo!
IgnotusPerIgnotium 1 year ago
Very, very good! Thanks for sharing :]
hpbryan 1 year ago
its very good.. just..take care of your speed and movings .. its a little bit to tense for haydn..
danielakehler 2 years ago
Comment removed
JoshGoldenFan352 2 years ago
i love how my comment is removed
Peteski09 2 years ago
Two excellent Austrians prefer even quicker tempo: Brendl, Buchbinder. The Expert of the hammer piano Steier plays exactly in the same tempo, as this Girl. As u know „con brio signifies so to say shine and fire. But stragarz and peteski probably know better...
domisoldo12 2 years ago 12
Comment removed
domisoldo12 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it sounds really bad, no offense
too fast, which makes it sound messy and uncontrolled.
Peteski09 2 years ago
PREDIVNO
kulisicd 2 years ago
Just a personal opinion here. I think the piece is played way to fast and almost played very robotic...again, just an opinion.
stargazr1977 2 years ago
Played like an etude.
TemperedWell 2 years ago 8
me re gustó
roquense25 2 years ago
The sound is terrible
domisoldo12 2 years ago 8
That is not too fast.
Listen - Brendl's world-class recording of this sonata.
domisoldo12 2 years ago 9
i think a little bit fast..but very nice
MUNNOT 2 years ago
wow I just started yesterday (not as in 4 months ago)
hydrocannon123 2 years ago 2
The second movement for this Sonata is probably one of the most beautiful in the world!Although short it is truely a feast for the ears!!
irishrocker182183 2 years ago 3
Sound of perfection. Simply Russian School, don't wonder why !
katowsky 2 years ago
REAL GOOD BUT REAL FAST. It's good but it's too fast SLOW DOWN so it sounds more musical. I'm playing this song too and I have been playing for years so far. How long have you been playing?
CHICKENFAT101 2 years ago
I don't think it sounds too bad at this tempo
TheSoundDepo 2 years ago
oh my god..i´m learning it too, but i think i will never play it so amazing and so fast....
soo good..
abc123mysterious 2 years ago
great job i am learning this piece too, im just learning ( and i suck so far)
cherrybooster 2 years ago
nice speed.
excellent playing
MOSTWANTED417 2 years ago
Great! I can play the first movement as well! Difficult stuff!
aaabbbccc5 2 years ago
On the last movement she is playing to much "Forte". She is being agressive.
templedread 2 years ago
justo estoy estudiando esta obra y puedo decir que te salió perfectamente bien!
elDiooo 2 years ago
great technique and it's not too fast but that is the way this particular piece should be played. I play this piece by the way. Very good interpretation also.
GREAT JOB!!!!!
love2beitalian 2 years ago
really too fast.
wi4ka13 2 years ago
Great, amazing>! :D
MyLordLoke 2 years ago
too fast
henrymbida 2 years ago
demasiado rapidoo !!!!!
yodaniii 2 years ago
EXCELLENTE!
tharhodyhomieKdollaz 2 years ago
Hi there =) Loved it :) 5*
Thomas
thomandy 2 years ago
haha wow it takes me like 12 minutes to play it through :D
this girl is fast!
SurrendaYoPie 2 years ago
Great, very fast though subtle played!
wastedlittleharpist 3 years ago
Perfect tempo and execution! very nice!
SirArmengol 3 years ago
great
ufukmetesahin 3 years ago
Отлично играешь, просто супер!
bananamama383 3 years ago
Too rushed for my liking.
34Bbridgeboy 3 years ago 3
O_O
GREAT.
94Eros 3 years ago
Wow!!! ur really good! how long did it take u to learn that? im nowhere near as good as that!
luelly92 3 years ago
It's very good but I think that the tempo is too fast... Some times it's difficult to understand the theme... But it's great. Excellent work.
templedread 3 years ago
Thanks, templedread! :)
gromoglas77 3 years ago
Thank You, Justin!
gromoglas77 3 years ago
your playing is really excellent. it is clear you and your sister are on the right way to become professional pianists. slavs and especially russians were everytime the best pianists. good luck to the future!
pejkr 3 years ago
Grande talento, grandi possibilità!!
PianoPerformances 3 years ago
bravo! you convey the happiness and joy of this piece beautifully!hope to get more from you soon! bravo bravo bravo!!!
gyseegy 3 years ago
Nice work. Great.Where are you now?
youngprodigy2008 3 years ago
Thanks! :) Nastia studies on 5 course of the Moscow Conservatory now.
gromoglas77 3 years ago
It's a combination of the performer and the music itself, but this video absolutely makes my day. Thank you!
lilly763 3 years ago
This is incredible
mollyleah92 3 years ago
Thanks, FFL!
gromoglas77 3 years ago
Excellent performance! Keep up the good work.
macerini 3 years ago 3
Thank You!
gromoglas77 3 years ago
we call this "the Chicken sonata" in the UK. very nice . i love haydn but oh so much practice . Spasiba :)
chad410 3 years ago