Added: 4 years ago
From: MrMcClane
Views: 19,407
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (163)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • lol xbox is left with crap

  • haha xbox destroyed me!

  • who cares about the noise lol xbox is awesome and so is ps3

  • Whe winner is ........ PC!

  • @Player768913 not really :/............

  • The Xbox360 has a more graphically intensive GPU that needs more cooling due to its superior processor.

  • @BudzMcgr33n

    it still fails. I would rather have no noise and a stable processor than a unstable and noisy one.

  • @BudzMcgr33n You keep telling yourself that. It was really just microsofts tendancy to send out a half ass product charge their consumers with extra fees and then fix it a few years later. Face it they did not put the right size fan in and their gamers had to pay for it. While sony usually sends out products that are ready and when they have a free product like home they have issues but that is only their free stuff that they have launch issues with.

  • @houkou1 You've never heard of Ylod?

  • @BudzMcgr33n Ya but that is extreamly rare and only occures when a PS3 is in a heated area with the vent blocked off.

  • @houkou1 It happened to my roomates PS3 and he has adequate ventilation. He was playing FFXIII and it froze. When he tried to turn his PS3 back on, the yellow led flashed then turned to red followed by a beeping sound. Sony was gonna charge him $150.00 to fix it, so he found PC repair shop to fix it for less than $100..

  • @BudzMcgr33n I am sure there were other factors involved because I have had my PS3 running for a few days straight and it had no problem. However I left a xbox on for a few hours and I got rrod. Same with the original xbox that when I left 1 disc in the tray it broke and I got a PS2 and had it up to the point that 360 came out then I got one of those it burned out and I got a PS3 for monster hunter tri and then it changed to wii only so I got a wii.

  • PS is way quiter

  • XBOX 360 is shit. PS3 rules!!!

  • Xbox360=v12 pagani zonda f engine

  • Wouldn't a fanboy only own the console they're a fan of and not both? More importantly, what does it say about you when the title clearly states the subject matter...yet you still watch? My guess is you're just jealous because you don't have either, can't read, and actually do live with your mom. My guess is....30 years old or so.

  • The PS3 and 360 both get louder when a game is in either. The 360 however, goes louder.

  • Last I heard, they make games where there are silent parts. You know, where the game's sound is really low and quiet? In which case, you hear the fan. Of course, a genius with your technical skills would obviously have been well aware of this fact. Yet...you obviously fail at basic reasoning skills.

  • Take a look at Xbox 360's failrate and compare it to the PS3's. After that you can make your comments based on facts and not stupidity.

  • ok now all the fanboy's of 360 what i dont get is why the ps3 sucks i know you have your reasons but just cause the ps3's fan system is quieter than the xbox360's doesnt mean it sucks or fail's i have both a 360 and a ps3 and guess what im not really bothered they both have around the same graphics and memory etc, etc. but what makes them different. THEY ARE EXACTLY THE SAME THEY BOTH PLAY GAMES AND WATCH MOVIES AND PLAYS MUSIC AND THEY BOTH BREAK AS EASILY! XBOX360- RROD PS3- YBLOD

  • @gamemaster79

    xbox has better anti aliasing though and all games that are released for both ps3 and xbox 360 looks better on the 360 (at least like 98%). Ps3s games like havy rain and games like that looks awesome though. The ps3 has it's good parts and bad parts and xbox has it to

  • liuke2fast suck my balls asshole 360 sucks

  • Nice and mature comment for a 28-year-old. Fanboyism it's called...

  • ps3 is # 1

    Microsoft uses a desktop hardrive from a computer for the xbox that's why its so loud

    XBOX 3 SHITTY

    PS3 IS DA BOMB AND IS ALSO IS THE QUITEST

  • xbox is lyk u shouting

  • ps3 is awesome

  • Dude, I just got a ps3 for Christmas, and I don't even hear it... Not a BIT! SO ALL YOU FUCKING 360 FANBOYS CAN GO TO HELL!

  • u are crazy my ps3 has an intercooler and it sounds silent but wheels on an xbox and it will drive

  • ps3 rocks

  • xbox start up doesnt sound healthy lol like my 360 plus on start up of a game the sound goes over the roof o.o

    the ps3 is silent and deadly ;) i cant wait to get mine at christmas i wont have a console shouting at me lol im selling my 360

  • I hate how the X box 360 looks. It has buttons and buttons are gross.PS3 is touch sensitive which is sexy

  • The PS3 is so silent the only way u know if it's on is by checking the green light lol =p

  • hah yeah its ture,its funny how its still works

  • i'm surprised your 360 even works

  • Omg. The 360 is even louder than my 7 years old ps2. Well... im not really surprised. Sony is awesome. Im so glad I got a Playstation 3.

  • xbox sounds like a mix of a chainsaw and a plane taking off i used to have one but needless to say it broke and with a 30 % failure rate i thort it wud break agen so i gt a ps3 which im writing this message on now for free neva regretted it since

  • Mine got the 3 red lights yesturday and like you I cant take another chance of this happening. Im getting me a PS3

  • and well as 4 whoever sed the ps3 fan makes no noise i would like 2 mention that well at least u can tell when the 360 fans stop working lol

  • true dat xD

  • yo y r u fighting bout who made em they were both friggen made in china for cryin out loud calm down people (gets off soap box) lol

  • the 1 thing i dont get is in reality if u realese a console early ur rivals are gonna get a look at it and maby make some improvments to their console based on what they have seen frm urs lol thankyou (takes bow)

  • o my god do not get the 360! I have gone through 2 already and the 3rd one they sent me scratches my discs to shit and only plays discs half the time like every half hour it pops up disc unreadable i fucking i hate it. I was so pissed of at my 360 that i bought a

  • thank you. People don't tell this enough, they put up with it because of fanboyism. Thank you. (fair minded ps3 supporter)

  • ps3 I love Im a huge Metal Gear Solid fan and mgs4 is amazing. Also one time i decided to watch Prison Break on my 360 almost immediately started to skip I took the disc out (brand new dvd by the way) nice big ass circualr scratches holy shit i was pissed so i went to the front room put the disc in my ps3 and even with the freshly made scratches thanks to my 360, the ps3 played it perfectly I was very happy I love the ps3 and i will never put a dvd in my 360 again.

  • Eh laron the 360 isn't all that dude.The reason why i hate microsoft is because, they knew they had hardware issues and yet let it out because they wanted a year start ahead sony and nintendo.They didnt care about what would come outta it alot of 360 owners got fked because microsoft's greed.I am not a fan boy,Like when sony let the ps2 out it had disk errors.Just microsoft really messed up,i had a xbox loved it was great stuff.Even it had a harddrive why not the 360? cost yea sure hdd are cheap

  • after playing the xbox a few hours it feels weird when u shut it off, its like im wondering how i have been able to put up with that noise for so long.. imagine being in an engine room on a ship or something then being instantly transported to your quiet cabin. its a sense of relief i guess..

  • what ps3 model did u use ? 40? 60 ? 80 ?

    very impressive :o

  • 60. Launch unit. Bought it in the first month it came out. Still just as quiet as the day I bought it.

  • all xbox owners buy a ps3 xbox sounds like a planes taking off

  • yeah my 360 is shit i have te get a ps3

  • lol @ xbox 360s old clangy cd drive.

  • my xobox 360 sound like a old jumbo motor

  • YEAH PS3 RULES AND QUIET

  • Yeah go PS3!!!! it almost makes no noise at all and the XBOX is like a jet engine that is so aoud.. if you go back and forth on the video you can see that 360 makes 3-4 times the noise of the PS3!!!

    PS3 RULES!

  • OMG the XBO sounds like a JUMBO JET OMFG :S

  • Yeah my 360 sounds like that honestly

  • The PS3's a quality bit of kit. The same can't be said of the Xbox 360.

  • What do you expect from an American made electronic product?

    Americans should stick to making rockets, it cant be much louder than that!

  • Oh aren't you original. Did you think of that all by yourself or did you have help. Who cares how loud a console is. I have a 60 HD tv and the 360 is up under it on a shelf. You guys better be wondering how you're going to improve on your system even the Wii was beating ps3 in sales. Your online sucks an is no where near the 360 live version but you probably don't care you guys still have 56K modems in europe right. Plus at least we did go to the moon and actually go to space unlike u tards

  • Can you name me one American made product that isnt defective?

    Also why are pointing to the achievements of other people and taking pride in it? Or did you personally work on the appolo missions? If not then youre pathetic.

    LOL! The 360 is only a success in America. In Europe its selling reasonably well but in Asia its a fucking joke! My system? I dont produce ps3s you moron - ill let sony worry about improving it.

    Sales = better? By your logic Backstreet boys are better than Nirvana!

  • An can you name a Japanese product or an electronic product in your house thats not made in Asia or China? You spelled Apollo wrong must have hit a soft spot because i'm not trying to say i worked on the apollo missions i'm just saying americans went to the moon first while you guys over there had your head up the queens ass. Nobody cares if the ps3 is successful in europe. We all know you guys over there will follow a sheep off a cliff You probably got an iphone and ipod don't you

  • Dude what are you talking about? You're confusing yourself. I'm saying i don't give a shit how loud a console is. I'm there to play games on it. You retards brag about ps3 like you have stock in the company or something or like it was made by god himself. You guys are the ones sucking on jap cock talking like this product has no flaws or like it doesn't break when it does so who's taking credit for what?

  • holy crap i dident realise it was THIS loud i thought it was only slightly louder than the ps3

  • wat do i get pple 360 or ps3 aprt from noise what r da advantges and disvantages

  • ps3 trust me msg me if u want to konw y

  • ok people jump to 6:33 then back to 1:17 it will be clear to you.....

  • ps3 has no noise

  • when u put the game in was that noise from the game or the fan goin faster becuz on ps3 when u put in a game it dosnt make a noise

  • Mostly the drive. However, you can clearly hear the fan on the 360 before I put the disc in. Where as you can't hear the PS3 fan or drive.

  • u can hear the ps3 fan and drive but the drive could be heard when the game is starting too spin and the fan can be heard but there must be no other noise and its very wuite too

  • @MrMcClane

    But when the ps3 fan kicks in, it sounds like a damn hair dryer, i need to put my 40gb ps3 in a seperate room for it to not annoy me

  • well the sound does matter for me because my parents room is right above the room where i play and the 360 is so fucking loud that i can't hear the game without it being farely load but i can't have it very loud because it will wake my parents so i have to just really

  • strain to hear and its a bitch. O and also i compared the ps3 noise to the ps2 slim noise (the slim has no fan) and the ps3 is quieter i was amazed that that litle ps2 slim was louder than the ps3, o and the loudness does matter, because the louder the 360 gets the more it is strugling to stay alive trust me mine broke, when it starts getting loud your fucked.

  • i just dont get why u people fukin argue over this shit so fukin wat if one is louder then the other they are both basically the same cmon just let it go

  • haha 360 sucks ass! while they are having to open a disk drawer, ps3 disk's slide right on in, make the 360 sound like a cheap P.O.S.

  • Umm ... no. The PS3 has a better processor, and it has to process more data (BluRay discs have bigger capacity than dual layered DVDs), and the only reason that Xbox is loud is because it has a very cheap DVD drive, it has nothing to do with the electrical use. Next time do some research before posting a dumb comment

  • Xbox 360 had problems. But for my part my 360 never had a freeze and its not noisy and I am proud of it.

  • xbox 3shitty is like a fucking moterbike trying to start ps3 is the best u cant even hear it that much ps3 rule 3shitty sucks

  • 360=crappy ive got a ps3 they r best evr

  • how old is ur elite?

  • dammmm xbox 360 is hella noise man turn that shit off LOL

  • wow my xbox 360 is making my ears bleed. like im gonna care how little noise my system makes when im playing a fps or madden game. to all you tards who say, "the ps3 is better cause its quiet" who cares how much noise it makes?

  • OMFG the 360 just fkn barked!!!

  • wtf everybodies arguing ova thz 4 both systems r tight

  • Get over it they r both good consoles

  • MY moms friend works at microsoft and she told my mom that she once heard in 2002 that microsoft was planning to create a new console which is daily the 360 because they were in a hurry to save someone with aids.

  • hey on the PS3 part i think your camera was in mute.

  • Sure wasn't, you can hear me click open the case and shit. If you have it, use your brain.

  • who gives a fuck about how they sound ps3 is gay and 360 kick ass

  • fuck xbox

  • lol ps3 is soo quiet

  • Apparently there is speculation on this rumour, the 360 fans will blow so loud in 08 when they realise PS3 has quality games... they will take off, leave Earth, and then we can all benefit.

  • I've spend too much money on this crap console xbox 360 okay it has more games than the ps3 but who cares 2008 will be the year for the ps3. I'm sellin my xbox360 in a motherf*cking hurry. The console failure rate is near 100%. I do too have a ps3 that is near silent and not loud as hell like the 360!!! BOOOH M$!!

  • iunno why the noise is so important becuz wen i play i have my surround blasting?

  • Cant hear a friggin' thing with the ps3

  • the ps3 is so silent

  • im looking to buy a ps3 80gb model; im curious though cause ive heard it runs hot and loud sometimes how does yours run?

  • mine runs silent most of the time...but one time I had it in a poorly ventilated shelf system and it got hotter that way so the higher fan speed kicked in while playing, which was about as loud as cpu fan at 100%. Keep it in a cool, open area and it should be quiet.

  • i have a 60gb ps3 and the noise is SHIT QUIET its only if you play it for AGES that its a little louder.

  • 40GB and I can't complain, blows some REALLY warm air out though (normal), not hot just warm. Quite noisy if im playing for a while, but not really noticeable.

    Compared to the 360 mine is good.

  • good thing they fixed the 360(sept 28 2007)it has the chip what runs better to cool it down

  • what does sound matter anyway?? you cant hear the fan of any console if your sat back relaxing playing a good game with surround sound...

  • i would have to say it's the XBOX 360 cuz i have one too but mines is the loudest

  • WTF? the ps3 its very silent! silent!

  • true but who cares if its loud or silent?

  • Me...

    thats who

  • wow

    thats dumb

  • Silence = healthy...for me and the PS3

  • wow

  • PS3!!!

  • the ps3 looks all fat and wide and looks like a dome and the controller is the same exactly from ps1 and ps2 its just more black

  • So?

  • exactly- so? it's much better so who goddamn cares about the same controller when it fits like a glove in your hand

  • also the controller of ps3 feels cheap and tacky and dead in your hand. tthe 360 controller is soo fucking comfortable

  • "the controller is the same exactly from ps1 and ps2 its just more black"-SomeKid00

    If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

  • it looks like a grill!!

  • plz fanboys just stop gettin these stupid ass ideas because of the negatives of one system. nothing is perfect like each and every one of ur moms' ass. thank u for listneing to my spheal.

  • if the ps3 didnt cool enough y arent there ne issues with the ps3 overheating. its not really whether the fans cool enough or not. the main reason y the 360 overheats so much is because its design was rushed. the fan in the 360 is a mile away on the other side from chips, leaving all tha heat there and it only comes out 1 way. the fan in the ps3 is right under the chips. and the fan pushes the heat away from it in almost every direction so plz think before u say some bs lik that.

  • david wtf

    dosent break that much, ... for all i know that peice of shit called tha 360 is a fire hazard all 360 degrees... man ur stupid. lol.

    and andrizza ur an fing fnboy wat u said was as shitty as ur moms ass.

    "the ps3 is quieter because it dosen't cool enough" wat kind of bs was that

  • The PS3 is definitely more quiet, but there's no point in having that console if there's barely any good games on it. And when you play games you can barely hear the console's noise if you have your volume maxed out.

  • dude...listin there are plenty of games out for it i have 10 game that are all worth playing and are holding me off for 2008 the breakthrough for th ps3 so many excluseves in 1 month never mind in the comming months better high quality games take longer to produce so while ur playing ur 1 day experience of halo 3 ill b playing killzone 2 and mgs4 for about 1 month is a pull a no lifer and id rather keep my eardrums then blast the tv so i can muffle that junkbox

  • is that a halo 3 special edition console?

  • No, that special edition console was a rip-off.

  • ...if you're weren't a fan of Halo, yes it was.

  • why wuz it a rip off? i didnt get one.. just asking

  • PS3 Better

  • get a 360 it doesent break or get loud "that" much. but microsoft is putting out a new system whith a smaller cooler so it wont break or make noise as much. and it cost the same its coming out in maybe a month or 2 months

  • The worst thing about the 360 noise is the barking. I always wondered why it does that.

  • The PS3's only quieter b'cos the fans dont cool it enough. If I were to have a coin for every time i've seen the PS3 in my store crash or overheat, id be ~£20 better off a year. It's stupid, what's the point of being quiet if that's bad for the console? Ye I admit, the 360 has it's issues with the red-rings. However not only are most of them due to bad connections at the back, but they're also ALL repaired for free now, so no worries. However, the same is definitely NOT so with the PS3!

  • Umm, you're wrong. The consoles in stores, are NOT part of the production line. The production line is ALWAYS better. Only an idiot judges a console by the display models. Not to mention, those things are locked up in tight environments. My PS3 has been on 24/7 since March with zero problems. Did ya hear that one? ZERO problems.

  • No our PS3 is taken from a retail model box. So you cant use that excuse. Also we keep it out in the open, yet it still messes up often.

    So what your PS3 hasn't failed (yet)? When you work in retail, even just a weekend job, you see the Macro events; in other words, I see how many PS3s are brought back.

    In the end, noise isnt what determines a good console, it's games. Something the PS3 massively lacks, and will still lack until after Xmas. The poor sales of the PS3 reflect this.

  • Andrizza, I'd be willing to bet a large sum of cash that you're lying.

    If you work at any large retail store (Best Buy, Circuit City, Walmart, K-Mart, Gamestop, etc.) you won't be using a retail PS3. So don't even try and pull that BS over on me.

    Another thing, customers don't return PS3s or 360s to the retail store. That's what the company is for. Are you starting to see why I'd be willing to bet you're lying?

    Let's just end it on a simple note, you're an idiot.

  • ok ps3 is good like system wise, but the only reason it lacks games u can say iz cuz xbox has been out with a 1 year lead plus BLU RAY discs cost more so most gaming companies dont wanna spend that much money on it.

  • You forget the fact that the software development tools Sony's given out for the PS3, are dreadful, which also puts Developers off.

  • what u mean "software development tools"?

  • lmao doesnt cool enough you ever felt the heat that comes off a 360 its like a furnace. If u ever had or played a ps3 you,d know what u said is bullshit :D

  • the ps3 does send out a large sum of heat out.. but that console doesnt overheat...

  • PS3 owns for noise, my xbox is pissin me off atm much louder than my PC. which at one point it thought was loud lol

  • i bought a ps3 instead of a 360 cus it has a lot more features :O. the ps3 is quiter except for the beeps when u turn it on, off, and when u press eject when theres no disc inside.

    if that guy isnt from som game/console reviewing group or somthing, hes just showin off both his consoles =P

  • lol i never go on 360 at night cuz it wakes people up i always go on my ps3 any time of the day

    and the elite makes about the same noise

  • Wow that 360 is loud, I have the Elite and it makes a lot less sound.

  • That IS an Elite, so yours makes just as much noise. Before I put the disc in, you can hear the fan running. That's not the case with the PS3. The 360s are loud, plain and simple.

  • u guys can shut the hell up halo 3 is ganna blow every game out of water killzone is fun yeah but its story sucks and halos story is wat makes it better than everything else i garuntee u that killzone will fall short compared to the halo series

  • the story i never actaully played solo mode its the online that will make the win not story

  • kill zone 2 will make halo 3 its bitch this time around

  • kill zone 1 sucked, kill zone two will be worse.

  • no not this time. they have learned from there shamefull mistake from last time

  • I hear no shit from The PS3. its obviously better and higher performance than the xbox.

  • look the PS3 is Quiter than the dammnn XBox360 elite

  • the ps3 does over heat put i guess ur not a serious gamer but the xbox does have the better games

  • i think the whole point is that listen to how load the fan is, it sounds like its working pretty hard to keep the 360 cold but it yet it still over heats, but then you got the ps3 its so quiet and wont over heat so which do you think is better quality?

  • (kevin) lmafao who the fuck cares about halo 3 halo is the gayest piece of shit WE'RE GETTING METAL GEAR SOLID 4 YOU STUPID FUCK SO WHO THE FUCK CARES

  • 6 million people care, they got the 360 over the PS3.

  • i have a ps3 and i agree that its really quiet but does it really matter when your playing a game. i put the volume up really high when i play games.

  • 1.who cares which ones louder

    2.u need to be a little less spoiled to have an xbox 360 elite and a PS3

    3.halo 3 is going to make all other games its bitch

  • GTA IV is going to make Halo 3 AND the all the other games IT's bitch.

  • Why does it matter? Grand Theft Auto IV is coming to the 360 and PS3.

  • Since the so called rumors going around say the delay is due to the PS3 i have a feeling the PS3 version will be good but not as good as the full experience. with exclusive content and all.

  • 1. I really don't care, this video was made because a lying individual.

    2. Perhaps you should get a better job if you can't afford them, I sure can.

    3. Waste your money on Halo.

  • The number one problem with all 360s is, the drive noise. It's horrendous.