Love these shows u do man. The models look absolutly amazing. =) Kinda resembles the ones that Thomas & Friends use to use in the old series b4 they changed to CGI. Keep this up dude. =)
Wow. I'm really impressed. I love the old thomas from when I was little and that would've fit in with the classics seamlessly. HIT should hire you and stop the stupid stuff.
Fantastic job! Every aspect was masterfully done; the cinematography, editing, all of it. It was like i was watching the real tv series. Keep up the great work!
Great video. Your sound layering was perfect, and the model coordination flawless. I also liked the editing in of TV series faces to provide expression. Well done.
cool how u replaced donald, bear and douglas with henry, james and edward (since those characters aren't made in these series of models) ur new series is off to a great start!
I love how you edit the entire episode. Gordon's face from an actual Thomas episode is added to your model Bachmann model, how did you do that? It's awesome that how you do it.
@Robtheredengine Nice, but hey sorry for asking I didn't realize alot of users were asking you the same question, they're just amazed about how you use that program which is really amazing.
You are beginning to set a standard here. The quality is fantastic, and I like how you switched from TV series remakes to a RWS remake. it looks like you put some time into this one!
I wish someday I can get the money to make a layout like yours! :P
Got to give some credit to MOAB too! Great narroration!
Awesome remake! You always amaze me with the arrangement of these videoes and the effects of putting engines' real faces over top the bachmann ones. Very enjoyable, and the music scores were good as well; you didn't overdo it like some remakes.
@Coffeeshop246 thank you man^^ I tried to make the remake as if david mitton would have made it and also I also tried to stick to the old thomas not the new thomas. ^^ thank you for you kind comments glad I continue to amaze you^^
I am absolutely speechless about how well this was executed. Gordon in particular when he was on the spot. I mean you made it look so convincing as well as him shaking violently; may I ask how you managed to accomplish that because I didn't see your hands or anything? That is just incredible to say the least :)
@Damocles178 ^/////^ thank you man, glad to know that you like the pe. Anyway to answer your question I had something infront of gordon to keep him running on the spot. I always make sure that my hands are not seen whem I make my videos^^
@oliver11gwr thank you dude^^ I plan to make more from the thomas books and the annuals and getting my mates like yourself to do the narrtion I'm chosing my mates who I want to narrate the storys and your on the list^^
Very cool work dude. ^.^ Keep up the good work. And nice job to missoliverandblossom as well. 8D And yes, I'd like to see more stories like this. They bring back memories of when I used to read the Railway Series.
@Robtheredengine ohh... whoops... I thought this was a new ep. cause of the handmade redubs, but i'll remember to read it the next time... I mean your episodes are soo good i may have mis-read the info.... :/
@NewController01 Thank you man^^, I was wondering man could you help me, I was wondering if you could help me with the Thomas annuals storys, I would like to try and remake any of them if I could get my hand on a few^^
@oricalcross Thank you^^ I will, I plan to do more of these in the future and maybe some from the annuals if I could get a hold of some, I have a few Thomas annuals but I would like to see more to see what range of remakes I could do^^
Thumbs up for Missoliverandblossom and Good Episode Rob. Could I narrate an upcoming episode, perhaps?
thomasedsfan 4 months ago
@thomasedsfan Thanks and sorry but no, I do not know you and I only have friends narrate stories for me
Robtheredengine 4 months ago
MissOliverandBlossom narrating? GOLD.
Woodenfan 4 months ago
wow dude you kick ass for making these!
real213 5 months ago
good work
ThompsOnline3 6 months ago
Love these shows u do man. The models look absolutly amazing. =) Kinda resembles the ones that Thomas & Friends use to use in the old series b4 they changed to CGI. Keep this up dude. =)
Triviumtiger 8 months ago
This is just perfect! Good Robtheredengine.
cameron67761 8 months ago
Very well done 10 out of 10,
Good to see a film well made and put together.
Watermillfilms 9 months ago
Wow this was a good video, how did you get Gordon's wheels to keep spinning constantly at the station.
turbostarbasher27 10 months ago
That's Amazing!
Monislawa220 10 months ago
Seeing this makes me ask all the more...
Why the hell didn't they do a TV adaptation of this story? It was one of Christopher Awdry's best!
Nice one, lads! This is a blessing and a masterpiece!
MrDCWood 10 months ago
OH my God You totally captured Gordon's character in this! Awsome
1986zls 11 months ago
Wow. I'm really impressed. I love the old thomas from when I was little and that would've fit in with the classics seamlessly. HIT should hire you and stop the stupid stuff.
koukinshouyu 11 months ago
Fantastic job! Every aspect was masterfully done; the cinematography, editing, all of it. It was like i was watching the real tv series. Keep up the great work!
KirkianSpocko 1 year ago
did u make the sheds?
ecopeeko 1 year ago
how did you make the faces on the trains
jamesstarkey 1 year ago
really good!
TrainzXtreme 1 year ago
what font did you use for the episode
demarm1 1 year ago
Very good; if you ask me, missoliverandblossom sounded a bit like George Carlin.
ghfdfhfdndxhcg 1 year ago
Loved it! Keep up the great work!
sugaristspice 1 year ago
intro is spot on
Hartsock91 1 year ago
great episode. yet another good job man. true tallent
mulfred100 1 year ago
maybe for a future episode, please could do a similar episode to Fish? Using Henry and Duck, you could do an interesting episode?
RobotsGreatWar2 1 year ago
do you use dcc
modelrailway100 1 year ago
Rob did your james come with the factory errors fixed (Smokebox bit red and grey wheels)
TheSI3DRemakist 1 year ago
@TheSI3DRemakist Yes all james are like that, you have to make some changes to it once you get it, like I did
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine omg missoliverandblossen is so COOL!!!
thomaswoodenrailwayZ 1 year ago
I don't know way that did not make this story in the TV episodes. And you have do a very good job of this story.
penninefilms 1 year ago
Nicely done! 8D
BTW, did the wheels (on the model) spinning create wear on the rails?
CarlosJoseMunez88 1 year ago
Excellent job! You done something that HIT entertainment never could achieve in 6 seasons!
champbaka 1 year ago
Are Hornby Thomas range engines' faces removeable?
CHR652 1 year ago
@CHR652 if they're not glued on, I had to keep the face on my old Hornby Thomas to make the ghost engine on my layout D:
crazyracer12 1 year ago
Nice episode. =3
DantheTrainManUK 1 year ago
@DantheTrainManUK =D thanks dude
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
How about a remake of the episode Thomas, Percy, and Old Slow Coach?
Zorran202 1 year ago
This is excellent! Missoliverandblossom is a really good narrator!
Galisoneh 1 year ago
Great video. Your sound layering was perfect, and the model coordination flawless. I also liked the editing in of TV series faces to provide expression. Well done.
ZeldaTheSwordsman 1 year ago
what brand/name are those orange coaches at @2:10
lukeee1000 1 year ago
Where did you get the Annie and Clarabel stlye coaches a 2:09 from ?
oricalcross 1 year ago
@oricalcross They're the Bachmann Annie and Clarabel with the names rubbed off and possibly the faces removed.
ZeldaTheSwordsman 1 year ago
can you do edward the great
aaron1234567891022 1 year ago
can you do Gordon and the famous visitor
cbolanz 1 year ago
@cbolanz maybe
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
cool how u replaced donald, bear and douglas with henry, james and edward (since those characters aren't made in these series of models) ur new series is off to a great start!
mysterio5productions 1 year ago
@mysterio5productions thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine Would a re-make when the Bachmann Donald and Douglas are released be possible? Bear does have a reasonably serviceable Hornby model.
ZeldaTheSwordsman 1 year ago
mrsoliverandblossom ???
birdy1052 1 year ago
dude, could you teach face effects?!
Deathsquad49 1 year ago
This is really good, nice work =)
TheBejewledtwistfan 1 year ago
@TheBejewledtwistfan thank you, more like this to come as well as my own series
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
This is excellent!!!
Bravo!
You new series has really started off with a big bang!
CHR652 1 year ago
@CHR652 thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Brilliant Work Man :) Good shooting and Superb Face effects :)
Avocet908 1 year ago
@Avocet908 thank you man^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Annie and Clarabel TWINS!!!!
MrMichaelDogson 1 year ago
@MrMichaelDogson lol
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Fantastic job man. The face masking and sound effects are perfect. (:
RobertMProductions 1 year ago
@RobertMProductions thank you man^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
best video made up
MsMoney98 1 year ago
@MsMoney98 thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@pierco5 Thank you and yes I am planning to make more, from the books and the annuals
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
I love how you edit the entire episode. Gordon's face from an actual Thomas episode is added to your model Bachmann model, how did you do that? It's awesome that how you do it.
cruiseshipz 1 year ago
@cruiseshipz thanks and I'm tired of answerin this qestion, I do it in vega pro 9.0 which is a movie editing program
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine Nice, but hey sorry for asking I didn't realize alot of users were asking you the same question, they're just amazed about how you use that program which is really amazing.
cruiseshipz 1 year ago
AWESOME work as always! lol ^^
You are beginning to set a standard here. The quality is fantastic, and I like how you switched from TV series remakes to a RWS remake. it looks like you put some time into this one!
I wish someday I can get the money to make a layout like yours! :P
Got to give some credit to MOAB too! Great narroration!
TidmouthMasterJacob 1 year ago
@TidmouthMasterJacob =D thank you man. Yeah I put 2 whole weeks into making this remake,planning every shot, music to use and so on^^
and yeah have to give credit to MOAB and maybe one day you will^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Fantastic :D
NemesisHero123 1 year ago
@NemesisHero123 =D thanks man
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Really Good!
maxcookie2 1 year ago
@maxcookie2 thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Awesome remake! You always amaze me with the arrangement of these videoes and the effects of putting engines' real faces over top the bachmann ones. Very enjoyable, and the music scores were good as well; you didn't overdo it like some remakes.
Coffeeshop246 1 year ago
@Coffeeshop246 thank you man^^ I tried to make the remake as if david mitton would have made it and also I also tried to stick to the old thomas not the new thomas. ^^ thank you for you kind comments glad I continue to amaze you^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
3:00 the wheel nosie sounds like someones breath
cutekitty300 1 year ago
@cutekitty300 ok
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
I am absolutely speechless about how well this was executed. Gordon in particular when he was on the spot. I mean you made it look so convincing as well as him shaking violently; may I ask how you managed to accomplish that because I didn't see your hands or anything? That is just incredible to say the least :)
Damocles178 1 year ago
@Damocles178 ^/////^ thank you man, glad to know that you like the pe. Anyway to answer your question I had something infront of gordon to keep him running on the spot. I always make sure that my hands are not seen whem I make my videos^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Dude, you did a great job! I loved every single angle, it looked really professional. And you could have not picked a better narrarator! :D
CybertronNews22 1 year ago
@CybertronNews22 thank you man, glad that you think so. I am getting my mates to narrate different thomas stories for me, and MOAB is on the list
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine cool, i can't wait to see your future work of other railway series works :)
CybertronNews22 1 year ago
I Love This Remake,Good Job Man :D
MURPHYPRODUCTIONS828 1 year ago
@MURPHYPRODUCTIONS828 thank you man^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Ace adaption of the RWS story epic work Robert =D
oliver11gwr 1 year ago
@oliver11gwr thank you dude^^ I plan to make more from the thomas books and the annuals and getting my mates like yourself to do the narrtion I'm chosing my mates who I want to narrate the storys and your on the list^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
woah that was fantastic!
LimboProductionsLtd 1 year ago
@LimboProductionsLtd thank you^^ glad you think so
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
awsome. i like the intro.
ThomastheE2engine 1 year ago
@ThomastheE2engine thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Although I've never read Christopher Awdry's books (because I can't access to them), this was nicely handled! I really loved the narration.
GeebMachine 1 year ago
@GeebMachine thank you^^, I plan to more in future. From the thomas books and the annuals
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
W00T! Awesome Work, Rob! :D
VeryOldEngine 1 year ago
@VeryOldEngine thank you man
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
this is awsome! having moab as the narator makes it even greator! good job!
andersinnevada 1 year ago
@andersinnevada thanks but I am also having other good friends of mine doing the nattation
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine thats good. the more the merryer
andersinnevada 1 year ago
@andersinnevada but MOAB is doing my thomas series, he has also agreed to do some other remakes for me
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
This is awesome! Maybe the Missing Coach would be good.
ScottishRails 1 year ago
@ScottishRails That depends, if he can get hold of the new Bachmann models
NewController01 1 year ago
@ScottishRails yes I am planning on doing that remake when I get ahold of donald and douglas
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
amazing!!!!!!!!
JD41796 1 year ago
@JD41796 thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Very Cool.
cybermurph04 1 year ago
@cybermurph04 thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine You're Welcome. I'm planing to make a 2 part episode featuring the stories from book it came from.
cybermurph04 1 year ago
@cybermurph04 ok
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
I like how you used the faces from the TVS in various shots. It makes it look better.
The plot is so good it looks like something from the RWS!
andrexiostudios 1 year ago
@andrexiostudios thanks, glad you liked it
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
DANG! 1000 views in a day! Isn't that a requirement to be a YT partner?
andrexiostudios 1 year ago
great job
SaltyFan12 1 year ago
@SaltyFan12 thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
thsi was a good episode that was never made and was in the books! I applaud you and hope you make more!
contestar5 1 year ago
@contestar5 thank you^^ and don't worry I plan to make more from the books and from the annuals
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
what a great remake. love it all. I really loved the scene with Gordon spining his wheels on the icy rails
SkarloeyFan 1 year ago
@SkarloeyFan =D thank you man, yeah I like that scene myself, all that hard work paided off
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine It shows. =D
SkarloeyFan 1 year ago
@SkarloeyFan I'm plannin on doing more in the future, I really enjoyed making this one
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
This is Brilliant Rob!!!
You are Very Talented!!!
spyfox14 1 year ago
@spyfox14 thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Very cool work dude. ^.^ Keep up the good work. And nice job to missoliverandblossom as well. 8D And yes, I'd like to see more stories like this. They bring back memories of when I used to read the Railway Series.
shadowrivals 1 year ago
@shadowrivals thanks
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine You're very welcome.
shadowrivals 1 year ago
Well done!! This is something great too! :D
but, i thought your first episode for the series is Thomas and the Royal train or something like that.... orrr am i missing something? :/
Zorran202 1 year ago
@Zorran202 this is not the start of my series, it a book remake
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Zorran202 next time can you read the info
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine ohh... whoops... I thought this was a new ep. cause of the handmade redubs, but i'll remember to read it the next time... I mean your episodes are soo good i may have mis-read the info.... :/
Zorran202 1 year ago
@Zorran202 thats ok,
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Stunning. One of your best remakes. Nice job. :)
ThomasandTigger99 1 year ago
@ThomasandTigger99 thank you
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
A really good adaptation of the story there! Loved it! Well done mate
therailwayinspector3 1 year ago
@therailwayinspector3 thank you man^^, thank for you saying that, makes me think ive done a really good job
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
An you certainly have done ;) Look forward to more episodes soon!
therailwayinspector3 1 year ago
Brilliant. just brilliant. I'm actually waiting unitl Donald and Douglas come out to do this story
ShuntingTank043 1 year ago
@ShuntingTank043 thanks, i was going to do that but I did this months ago so went with it, going to do the missing coach when they come out
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Nice Story dude.
badboy417 1 year ago
@badboy417 thank you man
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
alsome
MsMoney98 1 year ago
@MsMoney98 thank you
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Very good work!
billbarman 1 year ago
@billbarman thank you
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Great job, nice masking!
Sodoradventures 1 year ago
@Sodoradventures thank you
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Brilliant remake of the classic story, it really does feel like a TV adaptation, and the face-masking was done really well too. Well done! ;)
TOPPictures 1 year ago
@TOPPictures thank you man, ^^ glad you enjoyed it
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Give my compliments to MissOliverandBlossom!
DarthWill3 1 year ago
Great Job, Those two weeks payed off
DiamondThomas 1 year ago
@DiamondThomas thanks man^^ they did, things always turn out good if you take your time on them
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Hey Rob Great job this is the best episode ever and can i join the cast
thomas9012 1 year ago
@thomas9012 thanks and sorry I'm not looking for any new people at the mo
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
very nice as always, quick question, when donald and douglas are released, are you donig the missing coach?
darthwinsor 1 year ago
@darthwinsor thanks and yes I am
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine cool, but do you have plans to get the tidmouth sheds by bachmann?
darthwinsor 1 year ago
@darthwinsor I don't know
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Very well done~ ^w^
Jussy833 1 year ago
@Jussy833 thank you
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine You're welcome 8D
Jussy833 1 year ago
Awesome work as per usual Rob ^^
Well done =)
*adds to favourites*
Tomthetrainfan 1 year ago
@Tomthetrainfan Thank you man =D
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Nice one, Rob
NewController01 1 year ago
@NewController01 Thank you man^^, I was wondering man could you help me, I was wondering if you could help me with the Thomas annuals storys, I would like to try and remake any of them if I could get my hand on a few^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
@Robtheredengine Well, I've narrated some of them all ready, you're welcome to use them, although 1 or 2 I may have 2 redo
NewController01 1 year ago
@NewController01 thank you man^^ thats most kind of you, say do you use MSN
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
great work man i feel sorry for gorden
x00001 1 year ago
@x00001 Thank you ^^ in a way I sorta feel sorry for him too^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Glad i was able to help.
missoliverandblossom 1 year ago
@missoliverandblossom Thank you for helping^^ it would not have been done if you did not lend a hand, I hope you can contiue to help me^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
this is one of your best peices of work rob keep it up^^
TheTrainFan12 1 year ago
@TheTrainFan12 =D thanks, glad that you think so
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
gr8 work. keep up the good work =)
Graemenumber1 1 year ago
@Graemenumber1 thank you^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
This is amazing rob very impressive keep it up i look forward to more future booke releases (Y)
oricalcross 1 year ago
@oricalcross Thank you^^ I will, I plan to do more of these in the future and maybe some from the annuals if I could get a hold of some, I have a few Thomas annuals but I would like to see more to see what range of remakes I could do^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
WOW thats fantasic rob ^^
rosiethepinkangel 1 year ago
@rosiethepinkangel =D thank you Kirsty
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Nice work, man!
SodorProductions 1 year ago
@SodorProductions thank you^^
Robtheredengine 1 year ago
Very nice adaption, nice seeing another adaption of this story[the first being mine] :)
TheBlueE2 1 year ago