i actually understand what hes saying hes looking passed the things that he did that are negative and is looking at the possitive factors one can do the same with hitler as well
"If the people who lived under Stalin don't think he's a monster then how can we call him one?" Simply if his foreign policy was terrible. Ex:If he wanted to nuke all other nations. I agree though that America has propaganda against some leaders. Castro is a great example who was actually a victim of America until Russia stepped in. About the Nazis, Stalin did agree at first to turn a blind eye to Hiter's tyranny until Hitler betrayed him. But like you said, he made mistakes.
wow just wow..where did u get that information?Do you know anything about how Stalin got the absolute power on Russia.He killed his former comrades one by one and on the year 1938 the actual number of people killed by his men and so called courts were 1.8 millions.And this was only number of killed Marxist-communists on his "counter-revolution". Simply he destroyed communism entirely,Communism became a laughable dream because of his dictatorship...
This is wrong. Stalin was a sick fuck! How can you call someone like that a 'hero'? If he was a hero then why did the Russians turn on him and kill him? He was as bad as Hitler.
you guys are fools to be honest... Stalin might of done some bad things but not as bad as Germany. Stalin did good things the best one was he rejected the western side ( USA,England and all those nations ) he did not team up with them which is good because the Americans are satanics/illuminati's controlling there government. and Russia today is the best nation in the world. so shush u american/hitlerian lovers. Keep up your videos Josef and ignore the dumb people hating on Stalin.
@spaniardytc Americans are satanics? The hell you talking about.... I'm not saying that there are no Anti-Semitic Americans, but a larger population is not satanic. As for Russia being the best country in the world, I hope you are kidding. Russia is poor as hell, and have made no universal contributions.
Just becuase he killed 4 million doesn't mean he wanted to put your self in his boots you have to kill 1 you save ten if 10,10 go to save a 100 now if he has to kill 1 million to save 6 million would you do it you are still going to be hate for killing a million but will you do it if there was noi other way.
P.S. People go over the top with this idea of stalin and commumism in the usa we really don't know anything about history in my nation we make shit up to past the time.
stalin sure is bad for killing his own people but he killed people who would hurt the soviet union theres always a reason to kill and too say hitler wasnt as bad they were just following a belief that he thought is that soo bad if you had a land and nation and got war raped and was told you are not aloud to rebuild or have power you would probally try kill who told you you suck and its gonna be that way even if that means genocide and im not saying genocide is good but theres alwaysa good reason
What so many forget is two simple facts, first, Stalin like all of us is human, and ergo is not perfect, he did some good, he did some bad, he just had the power to do more good and more bad then most. and 2nd is the simple truth of history. History is always written by the winners. Stalin in the end lost. so his history was rewritten. If Washington lost. then he would have been known as a tyrant and a terrorist. nuff said.
Personally, aside from very well documented cases, such as Hitler, anyone NOT FROM A COUNTRY RULED BY A FAMOUS LEADER SHOULD NOT COMMENT ABOUT THEM. Personally I have an opinion, but it is not my place to talk about him, I don't live in an area where he ruled. But I CAN comment of General George S. Patton's sheer awesomeness! ;-)
During WW2, the Germans captured 5 million soldiers, 3 million died in captivity, not counting the Jews. Russia captured 3 million, and 3 hundred thousand died in captivity.
Good you talked to Russians about Stalin. Now talk to the people that are relatives to the people he killed.
Also you said that how can we call Stalin a monster if the people who lived under his rule thought he was good. Same with the Germans, they thought Hitler was a great man but now we see him as a monster.
@arnaldodacomando if your bringing hitler into this then in total hitler killed more people than Stalin, not to mention the holocaust on Jewish population that hitler did
@Edgaras124 Hitler killed roughly about 11 million people Stalin killed roughly 20 million people so yeah he did kill more people than Hitler. and the bolshevik Jews killed around 20-60 million people.
Pretty assuming statemant u made there by saying people back then didnt complain about stalin. I guess u cant ask the dead anymore and also u certainly didnt ask a valid sample of the total population. Anyhow, I dont like how u admire Stalin but I do like your videos.
the thing is most education centers or schools never talk about the things that stalin did that were good teachers only talk about the things that are bad about stalin and other leaders who had a few minor mistakes and thats why the human race is serverly under educated and i swear if any one talks about the 666 in my screen name let me tell you now its just a number nothing more
No. Things would have been better off if Stalin and Russia had just left our country instead of attempting to force communism upon the citizens of Ukraine. As they stole our lands, we went to the forests. As they stole our food, we ate the bark off trees combined with shit as food. As they sent in their militia, we snuck up in the middle of the night and killed them as they slept. Ukraine is free now, but at the cost of 13/15 of the males of my family. Stalin is no hero. Stalin is NO HERO.
actually the americans wouldn't have been pressured to use the nazi scientists if it wasn't for the russians using both russian and some nazi zcientists plus the russians are one of the worlds leaders in space technology since the beginning of the space race
@ICECHICKEN93 i just dont know why dont you HATE hitler the same way you hate Stalin, i mean hitler killed like not only jews but other people in europe and you dont give a shit about theyr Grandparents that suffered? and imagine whitout Stalin, what would of happened? the world would be held by the nazis and then not only would your Grandfather be killed but every standing up for the nazis
@Finalzero u support all the things hitler did then? So Stalin is a monster cuse he killed under 1million people for his country but Hitlers dead on cuse he only started WW2, killed 6million Jews,Gays,gypses and made most of the world start killing eachother! Yea hitler seems like a really nice guy u complete and utter Nazi lover!
@Sharpe1911 wtf, I never said Hitler was "nice" guy. He is a monster like Stalin but this video is pure madness. Seriously how can you name yourself after a man who is responsible for the dead of millions of peoples?
also check out some info about "operation unthinkable"... some facts to think over...
btw. cant quote but as far as i know Stalin said something like that:
"I'm Russian man of Georgian nationallity"
imo that means that Russian is some sort of world-view. i mean if you feel that everything in the world must be fairly, right and honestly, and you may speak Russian language - you may call yourself Russian. if you born in Russia/USSR it doesnt mean much. some betrayers, traitors were born there...
i agree he's no saint but everybody remember that history is written by the victors and NATO pretty much won the cold war so they could have easily exaggerated those numbers made up rumors. plus people forget that man wouldn't be in space if it weren't for the space program Stalin instituted.
@redberra223 Wrong. Much of the Soviet advances in space are owed to contributions made by Germans. The V-2 rocket, the Messerschmitt Me-262 were all taken in by the Allies upon victory.
@JosefVStalin You say that the population of the Soviet Union rose during his murders. However, you must take into consideration the population of the Soviet Union was run through the soviet government. And well, yeah. It kind of does make sense now that it "grew".
Once again, socialism works in the beginning and as it progresses the horrors come out. WWII was not won solely by stalin and his new Russia. Don't forget that even the canadians, YOUR COUNTRYMEN fought and died fighting hitlers germany and undoubtedly died during the coldwar against Stalins russia. I have to say, this disappointed me. You make up figures and numbers and even do what you seek not to do, by putting Words in russians mouths. Russians hated stalin, they didn't revere him.
CONTINUED****Stalin was a paranoid old man even when he was young. He was a horrible man, Murdering nearly 20million(Confirmed) Russians and Slovakian and Ukrainian people. You condone killing Millions for the "Greater good" which is just blasphemous. The russian serfs balked at turning their crops and land over BECAUSE IT WAS THEIRS NOT HIS.
But then again hey, who am i to dissuade the idiot who would live under the yoke of socialist oppression?
Stalin was worse than Hitler, his ineptitude actually almost cost them the victory. The reason why the Panzer corps broke through the Russians like nothing in 1941 is because of the purges in the Red Army leadership. Also, he killed 20 million of his own people (rough estimate) in addition to the horrors committed abroad. He killed 250,000 of my own countrymen (Romania), not soldiers, but civilians. I like your videos, but really, don't condone that paranoid mass-murderer.
@DrStrangebomb1993 ooh and look at the other dictators they are SO much better than Stalin yes? if you think about it atleast Stalin didnt end up like hitler, as in hitler died when Berlin was over run by Soviet soldiers in other words hitler died in shame and left his people to rot when he killed himself on the other hand Stalin died and he was layed to rest and he finished WW2 and died peacefully.
@DrStrangebomb1993 Hitler killed more people than Stalin, Stalin may have killed the Romanians, but they fought against him for a time during WW2. He's not perfect, but Hitler was worse.
@madman5214 OMG, so Vlad the Impaler killed one hundred people? Well that makes the 40 million Stalin killed pale in comparison. Besides, Vlad was well-loved by his people unlike Stalin, hence why even today in Romania and Russia there are tales circulating about his heroism.
you do know the reason why russia was losing in the first years of world war 2 with germany its becuse of stalin. Stalin killed millions of people its not a big mistake hes a russian version HITLER!!!!!
Stalin is a hero? did I hear that right looool. Stalin made mistakes? He committed genocide against 80million people and he knew exactly what he was doing. You retarded fuck after WW2 Ive lived in a communist country governed by soviet union and life was horrible. You dont know what the fuck your talking about you ignorant american dog
Lets liqify army officers, clean (purge) the nation, say we wanted to defeat Nazism but we actually needed an excuse to spread red, kill our own soldiers and command mass rapes! Stalin style!
May Union of Soviet Socialist Republic and Stalin(Iosif Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili), Lennin(Vladimir Illych Ulyanov), Karl Marx, Putin, Mao, all of Communism and JosefVStalin may long live in hell!
This guy badly need to do more research before glorifying an utter paranoid, ruthless and murdereous dictator!
The only man killing more Russians than Hitler, was Stalin himself!
The soldiers and generals of USSR won the war in spite of Stalin, not because of him. He interfered with military strategy, and was responsible for the death of many thousands of his own soldiers, ordering stupid offensives and overruling his own generals.
@BagBody33 so which specific battle that you say was because of him ordering stupid offensive and risking many lives. it was because of his ruthlesses that force people to fight and defend the country
@BagBody33 to be honest it sounds like you know little compared to "this guy" because this guy as you put it has done essays tests and researched more about Stalin then you did in your life im sure plus he's talked to Russians and they backed Stalin up troll me if you feel the need I've been watching this guy since he first joined youtube i do not take his word over my own but I've seen articles on Stalin and most of which that slanders him CONTRADICTS themselves
If the Russians had been defeated by Germany in the Second World War then the Cold War, Vietnam War, Korean and Cambodian War would never had taken place. By 1943/1944 both Germany and Russia were desperate and on there knees. If the Allies had merely let both of them kill each other off then the Allies would have either taken on the decimated Soviet Armies or the ruined German. Neither side could have withstand the Western Allies. The world would have been a better place. Katyn and Poland 1939!
@Trooper725 you are really stupid. one of the reason for stalin loss was because he dont have many friend if they did that they will be seen as the "bad guy" and the world will turn on them like when germany invade poland. the vietnam war was not cause by the soviet union. but because the north want independence from france so it will happen either way. i dont know much about the other . the cold war force both country to make technological advancement like the space program and such
@Trooper725 spelling have no use as long as the person read it understand it. tell me a better ression not to think your a dumb bag of meat cause that my current thought right now
@itzwazme that right there was some mighty good engerish, but really the last line about oil and America made no sense, at first I thought you were saying 100 million people killed America and I was like lulwut, I think you had a good point if you could be a bit more plain in your speech and less emotional, don't take this the wrong way, but I'm going to go make a demotovational poster of that comment
And the statement that equates to "due to his people's contentment in Stalin's leadership, mayhap it is rather null and ill-thought to consider him a murderer or a tyrant" is utterly ridiculous. He simply was an expansionist, violent, narcissistic ruler who crushed all those who'd challenge his rule. A committer of genocide also; contrary to your notion that he attempted to halt such a sordid motivation as ethnic cleansing.
@EmmaandSummer01 Yup, exploited a system Lenin tried so hard to put in place for the country, and did what his interests were, not what the countries were, he as well as a few others brought a bad name to modern day Marxism.
@EmmaandSummer01 Or the Great Purge, the Holodomor and the Gulags. I have no idea why this guy's worshipping one of the worst mass murderers in history.
I totaly agree with you if not stalin the german could possible win. But if not Lenin it would be the old russia so actually it is Lenin who made stalin leader of the soviet union and Lenin build up the country. Im from belarus and i think he was great but i still think Vladimir Ilynich Lenin is the 1 who saved the world.
To all uneducated BRAINWASHED idiots: IN 1920 population of the USA was 106 milion, in 1940 was 132 milion, less than 30%growth. 1920 USSR was 137 milion, 1941 was 196 milion, over 40% growth. BRAINWASHED people should ask them selfs, how under "MORDER" STALIN who "KILL" 100 of milions, population growth is 14-15% higher than "FREE" peace loving USA???? HOW many 100 of MILLION people kill USA???? For what????? For oil and for mony.
while i am watching this i see on the side stalins video "why i'm an atheist" and then i look one vidoe up and it says "...and i'm a mormon" all i could do was laugh :)
Comrade Stalin was a hero of the revolutionary proletariat. Unfortunately, Cold War propaganda still lingers around, better to look into real history books.
This is just a guess, but the negative feelings toward Stalin probably come from the Cold War, where Americans wouldn't have anything to do with communists.
yes but you forget the millions of his own population it got so bad his people starved to death ... if those people didn't die then why was there a coup against him he was mad and he deserved it tbh
Stalin was responsible for approximately 15 million deaths during the purges alone (that's just off the top of my head, not exact, probably more) he signed the death sentences of numerous innocents in a fit of paranoia, made some of the most dumbass decisions in history, e.g. purging the army from 1937-1939, 2 years before Operation Barbarossa; the Nazi invasion of the USSR, he started the FIRST man-made famine in history, and more. The good thing he did? He industrialised Russia.... -.-
Sure he's done some good stuff for Russia. So did Hitler for Germany, or Khadafhi for Libya. Doesn't really cancel out the fact he had millions sent off to camps simply he thought they were against his regime. Families were torn apart on baseless assumptions of 'treachery'. Sure, Stalin didn't sign all the arrests personally, but he knew well enough what was going on. While it is possible to be thankful for some things he did and condemn him for the rest, calling him a hero is way over the top.
Why do you have to explain why you gave yourself that name? Joseph Stalin was indeed ruthless but he lead Soviet Russia into an industrialized nation which then became a superpower.
I live in Britain (Scotland to be exact) and ill be honest,if it wasn't for Stalin's leadership and his assistance in WW2 Britian, Russia and pretty much everywhere would be controlled by Nazis.
I do not hate Stalin, I have a great deal of respect for him he massively helped us all win the war.
@MrCopenhagen113 of he is hitler killed 55.5 million people and try to wipe out a race and stalin killed less than a mill and helped his country fucking think
@minecraftmad11 55.5 million people? lmfao you sir have no clue stalin created a nation built on killing innocent people, he killed his own soldiers and generals for retreating from situations that were useless to send soldiers in anyway, and how did he help his country they were bankrupt and loseing money by the time he died
jens stoltenberg killed cancersick even if they were not at all involved in politics. anders behring breivik killed people that were threats to his regime, regardless of nationality or religion.!!!!!
You should be thankful for the brave Russian soldiers and their commanders who sacrifced their lives on the field for the fate. They are the heroes...Stain is a pussy ass megalomanic who sits in Kremlin and sends milllions of soldiers to their deaths...
@MrBsct You're an idiot, you do know that right? You do know in the Cold War there was no direct fight with America and Soviet Russia. What difference would it have made if Soviet Russia had less soldiers, if America and Soviet Russia NEVER fought each other?
Russia would had kicked germanys ass even without stalin i fucking hate him 1 good thing he done and it was from selfishnes + it doesnt recovers the fact that he killed more than 3 million people
Not to mention communism divided Berlin and opressed the people. You are brainwashed by communist propaganda. You would not like living under communism. You would not have the games you make videos about. You would work for no cash. Wear bland depressing clothes, eat porage or crap like that.
A 'hero' when he starved millions of his own people? You need a history lesson. Stalin didn't beat Germany. The Allies beat Germany. Germany kicked Russia's ass until they got to Stalingrad where gurilla warfare drove the Germans out and all the Red Army had to do was chase and attack retreating German forces into Berlin. Russia basically had a road right ot Berlin. America and Britain had to fight hard to defeat Germany who was NOT retreating. but fighting hard. And America had a pacific front.
@TheEnglishRedcoat typical opinion from uneducated amers. America fighting hard and lose just 400 thousands of soldiers.
Soviet Union lose 2 7 million. Germany 10 million.... but their losses mean nothing just becouse America fighting hard)))))))))) Amerikka win war alone! Okkk Agree with that and stop. Anyway stupid education system soon will destroy that country.
@mphet26 Uneducated aimers? I'm not uneducated. But you're an idiot. ^ ^ Allthough I agree the American educational system is shit. I never said America won the war alone. There was Britain and it's Empire, the Netherlands, Russia, France and Norway just to name a few. But Russia basically had a road to Berlin after Stalingrad. America and it's allies had hard fighting to get to Berlin and America had two fronts. Oh, and communism is shit. ^ ^
@mphet26 Because I know what communism does? Or because I know the details of WW2? You're an idiot my friend. The American educational system fills American minds with lies. The fact that communism is shit is far from a lie. Thus the word 'fact'. You must be one of the many brainwashed by communist propaganda. I guess I've been told a lie and that Russia beat Germany all by itself. Oh no what to do. :( haha. Sure. Wake up.
@TheEnglishRedcoat Haha "the Allies beat Germany", damn i think your the one that was eating (instead of reading) your history books in high school. 90% of Hitlers army was in Russia, the hard weather and the strong resistance in Stalingrad beated the germans, sure the allies contributed to the victory but if it wasent for Russia we would all speak german today. "Gurilla warfare drove the germans out" rofl so civilians with simple guns drove the 6th army (300.000 men) out of Stalingrad? lol
@ThePatricco Also we would not be speaking German because Hitler did not plan to culturally clense Europe. Russia had the largest army in Europe. So of course Hitler sent a large force.
Stalin did some major things in the name of the Soviet Union, but, he did some really bad things. He didn't kill 20 million, not even 10 million. For me he's okay.
glory, benefit, free education... stalin did? he did not only bad things, but you're seariously a psycho. the soviet union defeated the germans despite of stalins bonecrushing regime... because they had nothing to lose out of their country any more. youre laments for him would not have helped you under stalin. he even killed his biggest fans. but you would say "i love you stalin" on your own shooting, yes?
You idiot. 20 million lost their lives to Stalin. He was a brute who murdered his comrades and butchered his own people. And that's not even counting what he did to the Baltics. Go read "Between Shades of Gray", you ignorant prat. If you can even read. Jesus, where did you go to school? Soviet Russia circa 1944?
i actually understand what hes saying hes looking passed the things that he did that are negative and is looking at the possitive factors one can do the same with hitler as well
usmc123100 8 hours ago
"If the people who lived under Stalin don't think he's a monster then how can we call him one?" Simply if his foreign policy was terrible. Ex:If he wanted to nuke all other nations. I agree though that America has propaganda against some leaders. Castro is a great example who was actually a victim of America until Russia stepped in. About the Nazis, Stalin did agree at first to turn a blind eye to Hiter's tyranny until Hitler betrayed him. But like you said, he made mistakes.
congokong87 11 hours ago
I mean i dont hace nothing against communism but i hate Stallin he killed like Millions of people for no reason
fxgsrhy 19 hours ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry, but I find it impossible to defend Stalin. Especially if you're a true communist or socialist.
deekismusic 3 days ago
Comment removed
deekismusic 3 days ago
Ironic fact that we're all thinking; Stalin was Georgian
cleverdogbert 5 days ago
me you and Stalin have a lot in common.
madman5214 1 week ago
dame u did your studys
greenlanternkx 1 week ago
wow just wow..where did u get that information?Do you know anything about how Stalin got the absolute power on Russia.He killed his former comrades one by one and on the year 1938 the actual number of people killed by his men and so called courts were 1.8 millions.And this was only number of killed Marxist-communists on his "counter-revolution". Simply he destroyed communism entirely,Communism became a laughable dream because of his dictatorship...
tarkanardil 1 week ago
This is wrong. Stalin was a sick fuck! How can you call someone like that a 'hero'? If he was a hero then why did the Russians turn on him and kill him? He was as bad as Hitler.
iainp18 1 week ago
you guys are fools to be honest... Stalin might of done some bad things but not as bad as Germany. Stalin did good things the best one was he rejected the western side ( USA,England and all those nations ) he did not team up with them which is good because the Americans are satanics/illuminati's controlling there government. and Russia today is the best nation in the world. so shush u american/hitlerian lovers. Keep up your videos Josef and ignore the dumb people hating on Stalin.
spaniardytc 1 week ago
@spaniardytc Americans are satanics? The hell you talking about.... I'm not saying that there are no Anti-Semitic Americans, but a larger population is not satanic. As for Russia being the best country in the world, I hope you are kidding. Russia is poor as hell, and have made no universal contributions.
mogogrog 1 week ago
@mogogrog not anymore dickhead
madman5214 1 week ago
You're a retard.
CoDWikiTMOI 1 week ago
@CoDWikiTMOI YOURE AN ASSHOLE!!!
madman5214 1 week ago
Just becuase he killed 4 million doesn't mean he wanted to put your self in his boots you have to kill 1 you save ten if 10,10 go to save a 100 now if he has to kill 1 million to save 6 million would you do it you are still going to be hate for killing a million but will you do it if there was noi other way.
P.S. People go over the top with this idea of stalin and commumism in the usa we really don't know anything about history in my nation we make shit up to past the time.
historyfathead 1 week ago
why you named yourself after stalin? Cuz your a fucking bitch thats why
Ryssak18 1 week ago
@Ryssak18 why you named yourself ryssak18 BECAUSE YOUR A FUCKING RETARD!!!
madman5214 1 week ago
@madman5214 do you even know what it mean dickhead? You're the one with shitty name here madman, stupid head!
Ryssak18 6 days ago
This guy is stupid.
yunuss58 1 week ago
soo i agree compleey with you josefVstalin im glad im not the only one who can think past sstuff that people need to get past
falloutguy24 2 weeks ago
stalin sure is bad for killing his own people but he killed people who would hurt the soviet union theres always a reason to kill and too say hitler wasnt as bad they were just following a belief that he thought is that soo bad if you had a land and nation and got war raped and was told you are not aloud to rebuild or have power you would probally try kill who told you you suck and its gonna be that way even if that means genocide and im not saying genocide is good but theres alwaysa good reason
falloutguy24 2 weeks ago
What so many forget is two simple facts, first, Stalin like all of us is human, and ergo is not perfect, he did some good, he did some bad, he just had the power to do more good and more bad then most. and 2nd is the simple truth of history. History is always written by the winners. Stalin in the end lost. so his history was rewritten. If Washington lost. then he would have been known as a tyrant and a terrorist. nuff said.
DGFDDA1076 2 weeks ago
If Russia lost World War 2 wouldn't we not have communism... The Cold War, The Vietnam War probably wouldn't have happened..
tastycookiechip 2 weeks ago
wow this idiot really has his head far up his fucken ass
Gaffer213 2 weeks ago
Personally, aside from very well documented cases, such as Hitler, anyone NOT FROM A COUNTRY RULED BY A FAMOUS LEADER SHOULD NOT COMMENT ABOUT THEM. Personally I have an opinion, but it is not my place to talk about him, I don't live in an area where he ruled. But I CAN comment of General George S. Patton's sheer awesomeness! ;-)
Commissar5 3 weeks ago
@Commissar5 shut up retard
Gaffer213 2 weeks ago
During WW2, the Germans captured 5 million soldiers, 3 million died in captivity, not counting the Jews. Russia captured 3 million, and 3 hundred thousand died in captivity.
CaptainLambcake 3 weeks ago
one problem the NAZIS werent well suppleid
noobtuberukvsusa 3 weeks ago
Zhukov and his troops: Heroes.
Stalin=pussy
MrBsct 3 weeks ago
@swedguy97
I Know I caught it after I posted the comment
redberra223 3 weeks ago
Good you talked to Russians about Stalin. Now talk to the people that are relatives to the people he killed.
Also you said that how can we call Stalin a monster if the people who lived under his rule thought he was good. Same with the Germans, they thought Hitler was a great man but now we see him as a monster.
dragonborn214 3 weeks ago
Stalin killed more Russians than Hitler did.
arnaldodacomando 3 weeks ago
@arnaldodacomando if your bringing hitler into this then in total hitler killed more people than Stalin, not to mention the holocaust on Jewish population that hitler did
Edgaras124 3 weeks ago
@Edgaras124 Hitler killed roughly about 11 million people Stalin killed roughly 20 million people so yeah he did kill more people than Hitler. and the bolshevik Jews killed around 20-60 million people.
arnaldodacomando 4 days ago
your cool but the things you belive are opposite from me not to be mean though love your lets plays and vids dont stop
kristineld 4 weeks ago
i think you should read the first circle by alexander solzhenitsyn
msol0002 4 weeks ago
Pretty assuming statemant u made there by saying people back then didnt complain about stalin. I guess u cant ask the dead anymore and also u certainly didnt ask a valid sample of the total population. Anyhow, I dont like how u admire Stalin but I do like your videos.
ReviewGameX 1 month ago
the thing is most education centers or schools never talk about the things that stalin did that were good teachers only talk about the things that are bad about stalin and other leaders who had a few minor mistakes and thats why the human race is serverly under educated and i swear if any one talks about the 666 in my screen name let me tell you now its just a number nothing more
demondkiller666 1 month ago
@demondkiller666 It's sad they put him as evil because of his government choice.
EmperorXaozx 1 month ago
what do you think of other soviet leaders such as Lenin and Trotsky.
Sizzmaster6985 1 month ago
He was alot better than Gorbachev I mean look what he did!
TheJackGinger 1 month ago
@badcop2009
you spelt reason wrong
redberra223 1 month ago
@redberra223 You spelled "spelled" wrong.
Swedguy97 1 month ago
thats so sad
TheFrencky 1 month ago
whats the song???
PCGamer314 1 month ago
@PCGamer31 its beethoven moonlight sonata
DevLev1997 1 month ago
@DevLev1997 THANK....YOU!!!
PCGamer314 1 month ago
You guy do know that he has changed his views fundamentaly since this uploaded correct?
Just go to his site.
thekingofROFL 1 month ago
Stalin was pretty sick in the head. He would order the KGB to get scores of young women for his sexual pleasure.
mojopojo123 1 month ago
No. Things would have been better off if Stalin and Russia had just left our country instead of attempting to force communism upon the citizens of Ukraine. As they stole our lands, we went to the forests. As they stole our food, we ate the bark off trees combined with shit as food. As they sent in their militia, we snuck up in the middle of the night and killed them as they slept. Ukraine is free now, but at the cost of 13/15 of the males of my family. Stalin is no hero. Stalin is NO HERO.
UkrainianThrowAway 1 month ago
*scientists
redberra223 1 month ago
@DrStrangebomb
actually the americans wouldn't have been pressured to use the nazi scientists if it wasn't for the russians using both russian and some nazi zcientists plus the russians are one of the worlds leaders in space technology since the beginning of the space race
redberra223 1 month ago
I hate Stalin he killed my great great granfather just because he was an officer in Lithuanian army. I dont hate russian people but I hate Stalin.
ICECHICKEN93 1 month ago
@ICECHICKEN93 i just dont know why dont you HATE hitler the same way you hate Stalin, i mean hitler killed like not only jews but other people in europe and you dont give a shit about theyr Grandparents that suffered? and imagine whitout Stalin, what would of happened? the world would be held by the nazis and then not only would your Grandfather be killed but every standing up for the nazis
Edgaras124 3 weeks ago
@Finalzero u support all the things hitler did then? So Stalin is a monster cuse he killed under 1million people for his country but Hitlers dead on cuse he only started WW2, killed 6million Jews,Gays,gypses and made most of the world start killing eachother! Yea hitler seems like a really nice guy u complete and utter Nazi lover!
Sharpe1911 1 month ago
@Sharpe1911 wtf, I never said Hitler was "nice" guy. He is a monster like Stalin but this video is pure madness. Seriously how can you name yourself after a man who is responsible for the dead of millions of peoples?
Finalzero 3 weeks ago 5
also check out some info about "operation unthinkable"... some facts to think over...
btw. cant quote but as far as i know Stalin said something like that:
"I'm Russian man of Georgian nationallity"
imo that means that Russian is some sort of world-view. i mean if you feel that everything in the world must be fairly, right and honestly, and you may speak Russian language - you may call yourself Russian. if you born in Russia/USSR it doesnt mean much. some betrayers, traitors were born there...
jo3ywan 1 month ago
i agree he's no saint but everybody remember that history is written by the victors and NATO pretty much won the cold war so they could have easily exaggerated those numbers made up rumors. plus people forget that man wouldn't be in space if it weren't for the space program Stalin instituted.
redberra223 1 month ago
@redberra223 Wrong. Much of the Soviet advances in space are owed to contributions made by Germans. The V-2 rocket, the Messerschmitt Me-262 were all taken in by the Allies upon victory.
DrStrangebomb1993 1 month ago
@JosefVStalin You say that the population of the Soviet Union rose during his murders. However, you must take into consideration the population of the Soviet Union was run through the soviet government. And well, yeah. It kind of does make sense now that it "grew".
Gamerpark555 1 month ago
Stalin was worse than Hitler cant believe someone is a "fan" of it.
Finalzero 1 month ago 8
@Finalzero
CaptainLambcake 3 weeks ago
@Finalzero fuck you
madman5214 1 week ago
Being Russian I can say he was a total Georgian dickhead
rusty0010 1 month ago
Whether it is 40 million or 100 thousand people he killed, I still believe he was a brutal dictator.
TheFlimsyCrocodile 1 month ago
but who isn't a evil scumbag in goverment
RoaminStarcraft 1 month ago
stalin was an evil scumbag who is burning in hell for his crimes
RoaminStarcraft 1 month ago
Once again, socialism works in the beginning and as it progresses the horrors come out. WWII was not won solely by stalin and his new Russia. Don't forget that even the canadians, YOUR COUNTRYMEN fought and died fighting hitlers germany and undoubtedly died during the coldwar against Stalins russia. I have to say, this disappointed me. You make up figures and numbers and even do what you seek not to do, by putting Words in russians mouths. Russians hated stalin, they didn't revere him.
QuintusMacedonicus 1 month ago
CONTINUED****Stalin was a paranoid old man even when he was young. He was a horrible man, Murdering nearly 20million(Confirmed) Russians and Slovakian and Ukrainian people. You condone killing Millions for the "Greater good" which is just blasphemous. The russian serfs balked at turning their crops and land over BECAUSE IT WAS THEIRS NOT HIS.
But then again hey, who am i to dissuade the idiot who would live under the yoke of socialist oppression?
QuintusMacedonicus 1 month ago
Stalin was worse than Hitler, his ineptitude actually almost cost them the victory. The reason why the Panzer corps broke through the Russians like nothing in 1941 is because of the purges in the Red Army leadership. Also, he killed 20 million of his own people (rough estimate) in addition to the horrors committed abroad. He killed 250,000 of my own countrymen (Romania), not soldiers, but civilians. I like your videos, but really, don't condone that paranoid mass-murderer.
DrStrangebomb1993 1 month ago 17
@DrStrangebomb1993 ooh and look at the other dictators they are SO much better than Stalin yes? if you think about it atleast Stalin didnt end up like hitler, as in hitler died when Berlin was over run by Soviet soldiers in other words hitler died in shame and left his people to rot when he killed himself on the other hand Stalin died and he was layed to rest and he finished WW2 and died peacefully.
No hard feeling, sincerely
Eddie
Edgaras124 3 weeks ago
@DrStrangebomb1993 Hitler killed more people than Stalin, Stalin may have killed the Romanians, but they fought against him for a time during WW2. He's not perfect, but Hitler was worse.
CaptainLambcake 3 weeks ago
@DrStrangebomb1993
Its WAR people die
R.I.P COUSIN
ninjacgy99 2 weeks ago
@DrStrangebomb1993 your county's national hero is VALD THE IMPALER he killed hundreds of his own people so don't talk shit about stalin DICKHEAD.
madman5214 1 week ago
@madman5214 OMG, so Vlad the Impaler killed one hundred people? Well that makes the 40 million Stalin killed pale in comparison. Besides, Vlad was well-loved by his people unlike Stalin, hence why even today in Romania and Russia there are tales circulating about his heroism.
DrStrangebomb1993 5 days ago
you do know the reason why russia was losing in the first years of world war 2 with germany its becuse of stalin. Stalin killed millions of people its not a big mistake hes a russian version HITLER!!!!!
residentevil327 1 month ago
this is true!!! without stalin hitler woode have won!!!
sry for bad english
Crossfire12312 1 month ago
Stalin is a hero? did I hear that right looool. Stalin made mistakes? He committed genocide against 80million people and he knew exactly what he was doing. You retarded fuck after WW2 Ive lived in a communist country governed by soviet union and life was horrible. You dont know what the fuck your talking about you ignorant american dog
K1asH3r 1 month ago
@K1asH3r Hey Hey Hey. Cool story bro.
Aaah605weea 1 month ago
Comment removed
K1asH3r 1 month ago
@K1asH3r I agree w/ your comments, but he's erm, Canadian, not American. XS
NodDisciple1 1 month ago
you dont realy need to explain if it were not for him russia may have lost WWII so keep on going
17crawls1 1 month ago
Why you gotta troll so hard?
Technosauce 1 month ago
stalin and hitler. evil beasts clashing together and putting an end to ww2. in my opinion no one better than the other.
neubtuber 1 month ago
Lets liqify army officers, clean (purge) the nation, say we wanted to defeat Nazism but we actually needed an excuse to spread red, kill our own soldiers and command mass rapes! Stalin style!
EmpireofBritain96 2 months ago
You know I'm not even gonna give take, because if I do, I'm going to get a lot of shit for it. My take is neither good nor bad towards Stalin.
Roguesoldier678 2 months ago
so true
survivor287 2 months ago
May Union of Soviet Socialist Republic and Stalin(Iosif Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili), Lennin(Vladimir Illych Ulyanov), Karl Marx, Putin, Mao, all of Communism and JosefVStalin may long live in hell!
Read a book, moron!
ForIsLifeInPain 2 months ago
I gave up after 4 minutes...
This guy badly need to do more research before glorifying an utter paranoid, ruthless and murdereous dictator!
The only man killing more Russians than Hitler, was Stalin himself!
The soldiers and generals of USSR won the war in spite of Stalin, not because of him. He interfered with military strategy, and was responsible for the death of many thousands of his own soldiers, ordering stupid offensives and overruling his own generals.
Jesus, the ignorance...
BagBody33 2 months ago 7
@BagBody33 you are just as ignorant
and those stupid offensives won the war
so please stop making yourself look stupid
reredrumuoy 2 months ago
@reredrumuoy Read a book, moron.
He forced the Red Army to attack too early when it was not ready, thous throwing Russian lifes away and prolonging the war.
Come back when you actually know something...
BagBody33 2 months ago
@BagBody33 so which specific battle that you say was because of him ordering stupid offensive and risking many lives. it was because of his ruthlesses that force people to fight and defend the country
badcop2009 2 months ago
@BagBody33 hitler killed 28 million russians, stalin killed only 5 million or so russians. it was the ukrainians, polish etc. he killed most.
Adonnus100 1 month ago
@BagBody33 to be honest it sounds like you know little compared to "this guy" because this guy as you put it has done essays tests and researched more about Stalin then you did in your life im sure plus he's talked to Russians and they backed Stalin up troll me if you feel the need I've been watching this guy since he first joined youtube i do not take his word over my own but I've seen articles on Stalin and most of which that slanders him CONTRADICTS themselves
bigjakeyoung 2 weeks ago
If the Russians had been defeated by Germany in the Second World War then the Cold War, Vietnam War, Korean and Cambodian War would never had taken place. By 1943/1944 both Germany and Russia were desperate and on there knees. If the Allies had merely let both of them kill each other off then the Allies would have either taken on the decimated Soviet Armies or the ruined German. Neither side could have withstand the Western Allies. The world would have been a better place. Katyn and Poland 1939!
Trooper725 2 months ago
@Trooper725 you are really stupid. one of the reason for stalin loss was because he dont have many friend if they did that they will be seen as the "bad guy" and the world will turn on them like when germany invade poland. the vietnam war was not cause by the soviet union. but because the north want independence from france so it will happen either way. i dont know much about the other . the cold war force both country to make technological advancement like the space program and such
badcop2009 2 months ago
@badcop2009 if you think i'm stupid then learn to spell.
Trooper725 1 month ago
@Trooper725 spelling have no use as long as the person read it understand it. tell me a better ression not to think your a dumb bag of meat cause that my current thought right now
badcop2009 1 month ago
The music does go with your speech.
ImperialGlory1920 2 months ago
he WAS bad
sigh
rainers10 2 months ago
Heroes don't kill 60 million people, industrialization was a horrible thing, its too bad they didn't lost the war.
ovarNine1000 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Truely, as a Pole, I cant think of anything but negative of Stalin. Though I respect your views sir.
GermanConquistador08 2 months ago
Truely, as a Pole, I cant think of anything but negative of Stalin. Though I respect your views sir.
GermanConquistador08 2 months ago
To all who talk about history of JosefVStalin:Hi
EvilDevilCry1 2 months ago
@itzwazme that right there was some mighty good engerish, but really the last line about oil and America made no sense, at first I thought you were saying 100 million people killed America and I was like lulwut, I think you had a good point if you could be a bit more plain in your speech and less emotional, don't take this the wrong way, but I'm going to go make a demotovational poster of that comment
GenericName137 2 months ago
Stalin was smart but like his best army commander which is zukohv (I think that is how you spell it)he did not care for casualties
lfdnsouza 2 months ago
@JosefVStalin
And the statement that equates to "due to his people's contentment in Stalin's leadership, mayhap it is rather null and ill-thought to consider him a murderer or a tyrant" is utterly ridiculous. He simply was an expansionist, violent, narcissistic ruler who crushed all those who'd challenge his rule. A committer of genocide also; contrary to your notion that he attempted to halt such a sordid motivation as ethnic cleansing.
EmmaandSummer01 2 months ago 17
@EmmaandSummer01 Yup, exploited a system Lenin tried so hard to put in place for the country, and did what his interests were, not what the countries were, he as well as a few others brought a bad name to modern day Marxism.
DarkReaper333 1 month ago
@EmmaandSummer01 Farm to Factory by Robert C. Allen
Scientisticsoviet 1 month ago
The Katyn Massacre.
That is all that is needed to be said.
EmmaandSummer01 2 months ago 2
@EmmaandSummer01 Or the Great Purge, the Holodomor and the Gulags. I have no idea why this guy's worshipping one of the worst mass murderers in history.
timmyvos112 1 month ago
I see you get a hard-on from brutal totalitarianism.
AeolisticFury 2 months ago 14
I totaly agree with you if not stalin the german could possible win. But if not Lenin it would be the old russia so actually it is Lenin who made stalin leader of the soviet union and Lenin build up the country. Im from belarus and i think he was great but i still think Vladimir Ilynich Lenin is the 1 who saved the world.
itzwazme 2 months ago
To all uneducated BRAINWASHED idiots: IN 1920 population of the USA was 106 milion, in 1940 was 132 milion, less than 30%growth. 1920 USSR was 137 milion, 1941 was 196 milion, over 40% growth. BRAINWASHED people should ask them selfs, how under "MORDER" STALIN who "KILL" 100 of milions, population growth is 14-15% higher than "FREE" peace loving USA???? HOW many 100 of MILLION people kill USA???? For what????? For oil and for mony.
mikeplay007 2 months ago
100% RIGHT. GREAT VIDEO, good job my friend, people have rights to know the truth about STALIN, greatest lider in history of this planet.
mikeplay007 2 months ago
Comment removed
mikeplay007 2 months ago
while i am watching this i see on the side stalins video "why i'm an atheist" and then i look one vidoe up and it says "...and i'm a mormon" all i could do was laugh :)
MrBowman101 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You live in Canada and you are a communist? Where did you learn about communism? From a handout brochure?Pathetic....
FreeRoosterGR 2 months ago
Comrade Stalin was a hero of the revolutionary proletariat. Unfortunately, Cold War propaganda still lingers around, better to look into real history books.
DoubleO7even 2 months ago
This is just a guess, but the negative feelings toward Stalin probably come from the Cold War, where Americans wouldn't have anything to do with communists.
Paulgreenify 2 months ago
His people believed he was a good leader because he made it so that they had no reference point at which to compare their quality of life.
TheKodeman85 2 months ago
@menacinghat if i could id slap you and im german
CiceroProductionsIII 2 months ago
yes but you forget the millions of his own population it got so bad his people starved to death ... if those people didn't die then why was there a coup against him he was mad and he deserved it tbh
M0nkeyDropP0d 2 months ago
Stalin was responsible for approximately 15 million deaths during the purges alone (that's just off the top of my head, not exact, probably more) he signed the death sentences of numerous innocents in a fit of paranoia, made some of the most dumbass decisions in history, e.g. purging the army from 1937-1939, 2 years before Operation Barbarossa; the Nazi invasion of the USSR, he started the FIRST man-made famine in history, and more. The good thing he did? He industrialised Russia.... -.-
TheLegendoftheWest 2 months ago
@TheLegendoftheWest Like Josef said, how come the population during the Great Purges rose?
feybart 2 months ago
"Without American war production, the United Nations ( the Allies) would never have won the war." Josef Stalin. 1943
FreeRoosterGR 2 months ago
Comment removed
TheEnglishRedcoat 2 months ago
Sure he's done some good stuff for Russia. So did Hitler for Germany, or Khadafhi for Libya. Doesn't really cancel out the fact he had millions sent off to camps simply he thought they were against his regime. Families were torn apart on baseless assumptions of 'treachery'. Sure, Stalin didn't sign all the arrests personally, but he knew well enough what was going on. While it is possible to be thankful for some things he did and condemn him for the rest, calling him a hero is way over the top.
enjoythestruggle 2 months ago
I might as well change my name in to Chairman mao.
ImperialGlory1920 3 months ago
stalin was probably worse than hitler but Hitler lost.
menacinghat 3 months ago
Why do you have to explain why you gave yourself that name? Joseph Stalin was indeed ruthless but he lead Soviet Russia into an industrialized nation which then became a superpower.
asdfghj38559 3 months ago
I live in Britain (Scotland to be exact) and ill be honest,if it wasn't for Stalin's leadership and his assistance in WW2 Britian, Russia and pretty much everywhere would be controlled by Nazis.
I do not hate Stalin, I have a great deal of respect for him he massively helped us all win the war.
Baron4827 3 months ago
Stalin was a horrible evil man who killed millions of his own people, but he was a good leader--he actually helped Russia's economy A LOT.
YuukiCake 3 months ago
Hey, atleast his name isn't Mao Zedong (Under him 80,000,000 people died because of starvation/neglect alone.)
TheJazzax 3 months ago
@TheJazzax Pol Pot killed 5,000,000. I doubt Chairman mao killed that many...
ImperialGlory1920 3 months ago
@ImperialGlory1920 Nope.
Mao killed 60 million...(cultural revolution)
FreeRoosterGR 2 months ago
if stalin was in power in 1991 the soviet union would still be around
jkraw1 3 months ago
Hitler was nicer than Stalin
MrCopenhagen113 3 months ago
@MrCopenhagen113 of he is hitler killed 55.5 million people and try to wipe out a race and stalin killed less than a mill and helped his country fucking think
minecraftmad11 3 months ago
@minecraftmad11 55.5 million people? lmfao you sir have no clue stalin created a nation built on killing innocent people, he killed his own soldiers and generals for retreating from situations that were useless to send soldiers in anyway, and how did he help his country they were bankrupt and loseing money by the time he died
MrCopenhagen113 3 months ago
@MrCopenhagen113 maybe you should listen to the video before saying bullshit
minecraftmad11 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
jens stoltenberg killed cancersick even if they were not at all involved in politics. anders behring breivik killed people that were threats to his regime, regardless of nationality or religion.!!!!!
perkele181 3 months ago
Comment removed
paradigmentropy 3 months ago
Comment removed
paradigmentropy 3 months ago
Holodomor D:
TheJuxRuler 3 months ago
You should be thankful for the brave Russian soldiers and their commanders who sacrifced their lives on the field for the fate. They are the heroes...Stain is a pussy ass megalomanic who sits in Kremlin and sends milllions of soldiers to their deaths...
MrBsct 3 months ago
Can't wait to name myself AdolfEHitler...he's a hero for killing so many Soviets...without him the Soviets would have won the Cold War.
MrBsct 3 months ago
@MrBsct You're an idiot, you do know that right? You do know in the Cold War there was no direct fight with America and Soviet Russia. What difference would it have made if Soviet Russia had less soldiers, if America and Soviet Russia NEVER fought each other?
TheDemocraticSoviet 3 months ago
josefvstailn
55thecrafter 3 months ago
his new web site
55thecrafter 3 months ago
hey guys umm this is very old news why dont you just like stop whinnig and go to
55thecrafter 3 months ago
to all the biased idiots on here who hate Stalin just because they were taught he was bad need to educate themselves on the FACTS not on opinions
bigbub8912 3 months ago
I like too Stalin... but I prefer more Lenin or Marx...
razvii06 3 months ago
Stalin was the greatest man of the 20th century!
ulaghchi 3 months ago
Russia would had kicked germanys ass even without stalin i fucking hate him 1 good thing he done and it was from selfishnes + it doesnt recovers the fact that he killed more than 3 million people
WarDogTheAwesome 3 months ago
Not to mention communism divided Berlin and opressed the people. You are brainwashed by communist propaganda. You would not like living under communism. You would not have the games you make videos about. You would work for no cash. Wear bland depressing clothes, eat porage or crap like that.
TheEnglishRedcoat 3 months ago
A 'hero' when he starved millions of his own people? You need a history lesson. Stalin didn't beat Germany. The Allies beat Germany. Germany kicked Russia's ass until they got to Stalingrad where gurilla warfare drove the Germans out and all the Red Army had to do was chase and attack retreating German forces into Berlin. Russia basically had a road right ot Berlin. America and Britain had to fight hard to defeat Germany who was NOT retreating. but fighting hard. And America had a pacific front.
TheEnglishRedcoat 3 months ago
@TheEnglishRedcoat typical opinion from uneducated amers. America fighting hard and lose just 400 thousands of soldiers.
Soviet Union lose 2 7 million. Germany 10 million.... but their losses mean nothing just becouse America fighting hard)))))))))) Amerikka win war alone! Okkk Agree with that and stop. Anyway stupid education system soon will destroy that country.
mphet26 3 months ago
@mphet26 Uneducated aimers? I'm not uneducated. But you're an idiot. ^ ^ Allthough I agree the American educational system is shit. I never said America won the war alone. There was Britain and it's Empire, the Netherlands, Russia, France and Norway just to name a few. But Russia basically had a road to Berlin after Stalingrad. America and it's allies had hard fighting to get to Berlin and America had two fronts. Oh, and communism is shit. ^ ^
TheEnglishRedcoat 3 months ago
@TheEnglishRedcoat Good that you agree with me about american education system. You are typical example of that system.
mphet26 3 months ago
@mphet26 Because I know what communism does? Or because I know the details of WW2? You're an idiot my friend. The American educational system fills American minds with lies. The fact that communism is shit is far from a lie. Thus the word 'fact'. You must be one of the many brainwashed by communist propaganda. I guess I've been told a lie and that Russia beat Germany all by itself. Oh no what to do. :( haha. Sure. Wake up.
TheEnglishRedcoat 3 months ago
@TheEnglishRedcoat Haha "the Allies beat Germany", damn i think your the one that was eating (instead of reading) your history books in high school. 90% of Hitlers army was in Russia, the hard weather and the strong resistance in Stalingrad beated the germans, sure the allies contributed to the victory but if it wasent for Russia we would all speak german today. "Gurilla warfare drove the germans out" rofl so civilians with simple guns drove the 6th army (300.000 men) out of Stalingrad? lol
ThePatricco 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ThePatricco Also we would not be speaking German because Hitler did not plan to culturally clense Europe. Russia had the largest army in Europe. So of course Hitler sent a large force.
TheEnglishRedcoat 2 months ago
communism is fucking awesome, i don't care about you damn capitalists faggots, communism is just AWESOME.
LittleKid100 3 months ago
Stalin did some major things in the name of the Soviet Union, but, he did some really bad things. He didn't kill 20 million, not even 10 million. For me he's okay.
MaoLeninTito 4 months ago
glory, benefit, free education... stalin did? he did not only bad things, but you're seariously a psycho. the soviet union defeated the germans despite of stalins bonecrushing regime... because they had nothing to lose out of their country any more. youre laments for him would not have helped you under stalin. he even killed his biggest fans. but you would say "i love you stalin" on your own shooting, yes?
Jauly 4 months ago
You idiot. 20 million lost their lives to Stalin. He was a brute who murdered his comrades and butchered his own people. And that's not even counting what he did to the Baltics. Go read "Between Shades of Gray", you ignorant prat. If you can even read. Jesus, where did you go to school? Soviet Russia circa 1944?
LCWynter 4 months ago
DO not, NEVER let your mind fall to this " this guys is awesome" , its a trap, your declaring a demon a hero. He´s not much better than Hitler.
RomanLegioXx 4 months ago