20110130 超級星光大道 13.李佳薇:Listen

[sTItepFFhAenNY]

完全没有感情

just simply shouting and screaming doesnt mean you are great singer

[Desmond8835]

great voice, powerful and proud for her vocal. Only time can tell she will getting better and cannot wait for her next album.

[Leionameow]

歌是唱的很好(?) 比一般人好(?)

只是我沒有感覺 ... ?

[dejavu1224]

一點也不好聽....難聽...一點感覺都沒有 OMG..She ruined the song... ><

[lavineleehy]

@dejavu1224 come on you try to sing see that you can do it as well as her or not =)

[kbmmmoon2]

我覺得李佳薇的共鳴點太棒了，好到讓他唱這首歌的難度有降低一些

但我喜歡燃燒生命的唱法，這才會令我感動，感覺Charice才­是我最愛的版本

[ASArandundband]

Fantatsic!! Big Kisses From Iceland

[Fofo19541]

O.K tankiu

[saomayman249]

quite good, but she cannot sing as well as charice! Listen to her !!!

[a04040305]

還是比較喜歡聽厚實的Listen

[ss446659]

她這首有升key嗎 .. ?? 

[snowman03530]

@ss446659 升一個半音

[zrc5706]

不是唱得多悅耳或完美的問題，而是現場比賽時那種壓倒一切的氣勢­，讓人覺得冠軍非她莫屬，這是我觀看星七冠軍賽時的強烈印象。套­句海賊王的話，這就是霸王色的霸氣啦！

[zxcv934033]

那就非某某莫屬啦

[hydra654]

我只能說她詮釋這首歌真的感動到我，同時他站在台上給我的感覺也­帶有無比的勇氣，很喜歡他這段表演。



[zxcv934033]

是說你嗎？

[clce22]

勁!!!!!



[mingneh]

Saying she had ruined the song is a bit too much. But i do agree with some users: This is not her song. Plentiful of youtube singers are better.

[jonathan919]

@mingneh Yeah she wasn't perfect but the whole argument here at the end is not about how the girl sings anymore. It's about that stupidass giancarlo3884 trying to do some shit for god knows who to see how retarded he/she is...

[avatarxs]

She is not bad...

But this is far better: watch?v=JvXaOCTC6wU&feature=re­lated

[youjoker1]

台灣人和大馬人就是沒的比~~

到外地比道地人更厲害~~

馬來西亞人的驕傲~~

台灣人唱的比她的悅耳的.....不出現~

[Qvoldy]

听了 符琼音 朱俐静 张念蓉 Charice 李佳薇 版

每个人都有不同的诠释方法

我还是比较喜欢佳薇版 因为我是她的FANS 嘛 XD

我最喜欢她的声音 清清亮亮的 还有她的动作眼神 很杀啊！（观众缘XD）

charice 的真的很强大 她唱歌时的气势和肢体都震到我了 （好厉害啊！！）

符琼音的 也不错听啊！ 她抓住了我的耳朵~~

朱俐静 张念蓉 的 我不喜欢 不得我缘 （很主观的哦！） 不要炸我 跪地 ORZ

[didyjessica]

so good!!

[A6037]

個人比較喜歡符瓊音

[tp60cj96]

明明就很好聽,很厲害ㄟ

爆發力十足ㄟ

[zxcv934033]

有點怪

[samdu1000]

@zxcv934033 耳包

[k060500376]

@zxcv934033

耳包+100

[zxcv934033]

難听

[cwh0711]

@zxcv934033 耳包

[ky9189]

when you heard Charice's version, this one is not good at all... lol just saying

[tw0keroro066]

好強!!! 聲音整個很有力量!!

[a39338]

malaysia boleh!

[ahoaxinhoax]

Awesome!

[nunowlee]

Muito bom, adorei o vídeo...-D

[giancarlo3884]

有够烂

[jonathan919]

@giancarlo3884 "sucker", "go back to your wonderland", low class English grammar but acting like you're cool and shit... what else you're going to throw at me without making a clown out of yourself, act like you know some shit about music, you disgrace us Asian community. Snatch your ugly ass off the street bitch ass motherfucker.

[giancarlo3884]

@jonathan919 Whatever, you guys just can't accept the fact that she sings crap in this song. Truly annoying just like you, no wonder you're supporting her, because u guys are the same.

[eric8224]

@giancarlo3884 lol seriously STFU you fking retard fken chinese go back to your fking youku or some shit no wonder youtube is banned in China cuz you guys are just fked up coming on here to talk shit and criticize when you're just a you piece of shit. I agree with Jonathan your English is so carp..who the fuck says "sucker"...are you tryna sound pro? Only shit English speaker wannabes like you says it..rofl..

[giancarlo3884]

@eric8224 Well. your English doesn't make any sense too, please do check back before you post.Anyway she totally ruin the song, Beyonce is the best! you can take your motherfucker craps comments and go back to sing for yourself. _i_

[jonathan919]

@giancarlo3884 "motherfucker craps comments"....

hahaha like I said you're so much fun to watch.

[eric8224]

@giancarlo3884 It doesn't make sense to you because your a fucking Chinese retard who stayed in China all your life, i guess i used some slangs that you've never even heard of in your English classes. seriously, you expected me to speak formally with a faggot like you? I'd say there are people in China who are good at English but you're obviously not one why bother faking shit and how many grammer errors do you want me and Jonathan to point out to you, post more crap shit cunt.

[eric8224]

@giancarlo3884 "She totally ruin the song" <---- it's ruined you nub

[eric8224]

@giancarlo3884 "sucker" LOL that shit still cracks me up

[jonathan919]

@eric8224 lol don't get mad it actually is kinda fun watching people make a fool out of themselves... I have worked for various artists in studio as a freelancer and have won so many singing contests and getting accused of not qualified to give a compliment to another singer just because some retard on Youtube doesn't think she deserves one?

Get the fuck out lol.

[eric8224]

@jonathan919 hahaha yea lol... where in NZ were you in? Auckland? Cuz I'm a kiwi too haha

[jonathan919]

@eric8224 Greenlane Auckland! Nearby Cornwall Park. How about you

[eric8224]

@jonathan919 Chch lol..man i wanna go to U.S eh...but i'll prob end up in aus..

[YoruichiSyukur]

beyonce dont shout until her whole body bend down o_O

[giancarlo3884]

@YoruichiSyukur Exactly!

[kate12345678910baby]

wow



[m4ttIRL]

...

The Chinese are some goofy people.

[sheryliew]

I LOVE IT ! <3

[catgoh1992]

OMG!! LEE JIA WEI BOLEH! MALAYSIA BOLEH! ^__^

[dramafever100]

try to sing song with low notes

not this one really sucks

[b5292710]

背景音樂太慢 要死了

[ZTserenity]

wow.

[Tooko5]

i would fuck the shit out of an asian right now

[saylorbelle]

THAT WAS ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE! HER VOICE IS NOT STRONG ENOUGH FOR THIS SONG!!!

[1mateusabilio]

Very,very,well

[dick206206]

一開始聽到李佳蓉去超偶踢館唱的Listen

看到別人也有唱~讓我想去聽聽

一下子聽完了6個人李佳蓉 李佳薇 Charice Beyonce 符瓊音 朱俐靜的版本

小弟個人的感受是Beyonce > 李佳薇 = Charice > 朱俐靜 > 李佳蓉 > 符瓊音

單純就是我喜歡的程度而不是指實力~其實她們每個人唱的感覺都有­些許不同

有高亢有厚實有平均型的~聽起來都有不一樣的FEELING~都­真的很棒

[beck520520]

@dick206206 個人感覺是Beyonce>=Charice>符瓊音>朱俐靜>­=李佳薇=張念蓉

[TheBillows]

看過關詩敏小姐的演唱再回來看，還真是高下立見！同是冠軍卻可以­差那麼遠！佳薇加油！

[vento0918]

事後看著影片當然能夠慢慢來挑小毛病，

但當你身在現場，第一次聽到這位歌手唱這首歌，她震懾全場的舞台­魅力根本沒機會讓你想這麼多……。

我覺得有時候看live看的是氣度。個人觀點。

[lysander3140]

listen cover by lysander fulbert.wmv

[marionah2151919]

that was wonderful you really song that song you gurl

[mielo101]

good ending. :)

[TheFisherStereo]

Sigh....

[EllisseDxxx]

She's really good and all you people saying that she was off key at some points, well she's singing in a different language so I'd like to see you all try to do that :)

[summerteo]

一个世上再差劲的人~照样会有喜欢TA的人~一个世上最好最棒最­全能的人~依然会有挑TA毛病 不喜欢TA的人~所以 我个人觉得~只要永远支持我们心中最喜爱最好的歌手就好了~不要­去在乎去管别人怎么说~ 李佳薇能，马来西亚也能~我挺你~！

[koreanPOPrawks]

She's like screaming her voice off.

[SlimShaney08]

i really wanted to hear her do my own the lats note like wicked haha

[ose120]

LOS CHINOS SON RAROSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS­SSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!! JAJAJJAJAJ

[pp7928]

吾知點解我覺得佳薇聲音的frequency聽得有點不太舒服

[charlesbakely]

very good, nice voice range. your a ok.

[darrock747]

Not good! You need a lot of work. The whole song was off key. Her voice is too weak. The band was off key.

[jinascott4ever]

good job! But it was not consistent strong voice, sometimes it was flat . but it's good ! I am singer also..i can sing Listen, almost all pop songs, proud of

u also!

[w1920385]

朱俐靜的程度太差,天生聲音的質不好,撐不起大歌.

反觀李佳薇的聲音夠厚也夠亮,聽的人才容易被她的純粹所感動.

但我不否認超3的實力很強,也不否認朱俐靜的人氣跟觀眾緣很棒.

就做為藝人來說,朱俐靜不會輸給李佳薇

但是作歌手來說,李佳薇需要磨練,朱俐靜沒機會.(聲音薄加上過­30歲)



[paboma]

還是覺得朱俐靜唱的好! 畢竟MIU都是用真音飆上去的 雖然高音位置可能不到位 但是 卻是用盡了情感 感受力極為豐富 比較佳薇的版本 我會覺得 她的歌唱技巧非常好 可是你們有發現嗎 他唱這首歌的時候 共鳴都是在真假聲變換區 所以會讓這首歌聽起來不夠實!! 雖然她假聲用的非常好

可適用在LISTEN這首歌上 我覺得還是要用真聲唱 才會符合這首歌的真正意義 ! 也就是讓人聽到你內心真正的聲音 這也才是listen這首歌要傳達的意義 所以我覺得朱俐靜才是真正有唱到骨髓裡的人!! 但佳薇唱的比較美!!

[kish8athena]

go malaysian chinese!

from malay-mix...

[sharimie76]

nice performance...u r very talented

[SamSon5737]

MALAYSIA BOLEHH!!!!!

[0Shuuya0]

Even though she can reach the high note, I don't feel goosebump, try search Charice / Melanie Amaro if you want the cover of it.

[caspyno]

@0Shuuya0 so true! search MELANIE first! 

[drumerling]

我觉得这首歌比较适合声音较低沉的歌手演绎，像佳薇这样较为尖刺­的声音反而不太适合

尤其当唱高音的时候会令很多人不舒服

我想是赢在技巧而不是赢在悦耳

[YJIDOL]

nice performance.but if u know music well,u won't say charice can't sing well,u try to search charice-listen..LISTEN it properly..n feel it..for me..jiawei is reaching the highnote by screaming...but charice is sing it out

[katherinesuju]

为什要她说马来问叻？=.= 哈哈哈

[DerekBucket]

naturally, no one can beat beyonce. but she did a great job with this song.

[chajoshfan]

try search,(charice-listen)(:

[Sugarchocolover]

@chajoshfan she is stil noob , this better =D

[zeldalovezxc79]

@Sugarchocolover lol noob? you kidding me?

[GoranMaric89]

great voice

[MrDeclant19]

pronounce? how about pronunciation? geniuses.

[TheBillows]

@giancarlo3884 @leoah121 Fucking bad written English

[giancarlo3884]

@TheBillows you neither, you just dont get it, I bet you never actually listen to English song, arent u, this is your first time, thats why you think this was good, sucker!

[TheBillows]

@giancarlo3884 英文有夠爛就別出來獻醜吧 ：）

[jonathan919]

@leoah121 FAIL. 'bad English pronounce' haha let me hear yours with such epic grammar hahahaha

[WWLOVEDoubleHJ]

@leoah121 *pronunciation :D you have a good English pronounce *sarcasm*

[giancarlo3884]

SUCKS. English pronounce terrible ==

[jacksona333]

@giancarlo3884 ~is easy for you to criticize others but not oneself. If you're to sing in Mandarin then you would not simply hurt others.

[giancarlo3884]

@jacksona333 Since she's on the stage, everything should be the best, not this! Go back to your wonderland whore, be reality, she's terrible

[jacksona333]

@giancarlo3884 ~I think you're a racist!!!

[jonathan919]

@giancarlo3884 stupid ass. if you ain't raised speaking English then stfu. I'm born Taiwanese, grew up in New Zealand and stayed in New York City all my life. And I think her English is wonderful for a Taiwanese girl. Oh yeah, you probably don't know what stfu means so why don't you look it up while you're at it you might learn a couple of things.

[giancarlo3884]

@jonathan919 Im not interested to your grandmother story, dont make yourself like an expert, sucker. _I_

[jonathan919]

@giancarlo3884 ooooo, bad ass.. next time when you try to post a comment regarding english grammar why don't you double check with your grade school teacher first... oops sorry you might have been at a retard school you didn't have one ^0^

[giancarlo3884]

@jonathan919 Whatever, you just argue the point which is totally nothing can do with this shit video. Dont change the subject to cover the fact that she's terrible. Make sure you know what's happening, idiot. Remember install your brain before you comment.

[jonathan919]

@giancarlo3884 hahahaha you totally have nothing else to trash at me do you?

Let me tell you something.

I own you. You have absolutely no idea who you're dealing with and accusing of lack of musical knowledge lol. You would shit in your pants if you knew who I was and how I sing. Bear that in mind and get the fuck out of Youtube along with your crappy comments because you're just making yourself look bad.

Every one of your cute little comments always get me in a good mood hahaha

[suktuckng]

@jonathan919 are u farking idiot? she is not taiwanese, btw raising speaking english makes u become stupid racist bastard?

[jonathan919]

@suktuckng hahahahaha do you guys even know what racist means? First off try spelling right. Secondly what I'm saying is she's doing a great job, I do not understand why in the hell would it be interpreted as me dissing her or some shit. Why don't we start an English class here?

"Are u farking idiot?" correction-> "Are you a fucking idiot?"

"Raising speaking English" correction-> "Raised speaking English"

[jonathan919]

@suktuckng

And as for "makes u become stupid racist bastard?"

....OK this one is too fucked up for me to get it right for you, first of all you don't just trash every bad word at someone to make your diss look ferocious. Stupid, racist, and bastard do not mix. Normally just saying "Stupid racist" would be enough. Just pointing this out for you in a kind way. In case you'd be needing it sometime in your pathetic future life.

oops :D

[giancarlo3884]

@suktuckng Totally agree, some people just wanted to show off and started point out grammar mistake which not related to the video. He wants to be the fucking hero. Such a prick child, we need to guide him to the right way. Poor guy.

[Mapleroxnow]

@jonathan919 she's not Taiwanese, she's a malaysian. :)

[jonathan919]

@Mapleroxnow Thank you, then her English is wonderful for a person from a non English speaking country.

[aw05172001]

不知道有沒有人跟我一樣，我覺得Gemilang比Listen­來的感動

[kobehowzen]

很抒情的歌 眼神是想殺死人阿= =?

[kobehowzen]

技巧是有，但是個人感覺唱起來整體沒有soul

[aqc121]

@kobehowzen

同意,整首歌沒有打動我(意興闌珊)

[shihruecho]

我還是最喜歡佳薇的版本=)

從一開始的細膩到最後漸漸將所有力量放出來，

整個很有大將之風呢!

支持佳薇新專輯=D

[Top174258]

臉好猙獰...

唱得不錯^^

加油:D

大火+煎熬好聽:))

[tobeloveso]

聽他唱歌很不舒服......

[wwe2802808]

你來唱啊

很像很行!

[11uxie11]

178 people are deaf .

[ghjk8462000000000000]

聽李佳薇唱歌不用擔心高音上不上的去

[aw05172001]

有人覺得她升key很厲害，我倒覺得她避低音，可能她定bee的­key跟charice的key都會尷尬，或許某幾個音高令她尷­尬，混聲唱不對，真音衝上去也太大力的狀況，所以她就升4個，完­全忽略了厚度，老實講，唱得好不好，她一定是好的，但好不好聽就­見人見智啦

[TheJMSSTS]

@aw05172001

去听听她唱煎熬的低音吧，她在Legacy唱的Listen 也很棒的～



[2003feng]

...聽的有點辛苦....

[WUHARLEM]

我的天~怎麼會那麼利害!!!

比之前那些台灣比賽所有的人都好啊!!!

前面那麼內斂鋪陳~後面把情緒帶到最高點~最後還收回~真是太驚­艷了!!!

我是聽到煎熬之後才來聽的~這個人真是利害啊!!!

[beck520520]

個人~ Beyonce>瓊音>張念蓉>佳薇=miu=charice

[29909152]

他聲音跟本太高...高到唱這首歌讓人有點不舒服~反觀張念蓉唱­起來聲音渾厚不會太高又感覺很舒服,即使技巧用的再多~選錯歌也­是枉然

[MrBELLED]

怎麼聽還是佳薇唱得好聽吧

張念蓉真假音轉換技巧上 還有氣的分配 到最後高音要上去聽起來也有點出力

反觀李佳薇  從頭到尾一氣連貫 有層次的安排 實至名歸的第一名

[MrBELLED]

我到覺得 這首歌 佳薇唱得比Charice好

個人意見

[29909152]

怎聽還是張念蓉的Listen好聽.......

[lwsk91]

Awesome!!

[brightspark495]

For a Chinese singer, she's already very good.

[anournamous]

proud as Malaysian...!! keep it up girl!!

[pisawbuya]

很完整的表演，可是真的沒有甚麼靈魂的感覺。我比較喜歡張念蓉的­版本，技巧沒有李佳薇好，但是真的就是很有靈魂....



[new20322530]

楊宗緯的心不了情不就有拍手了XDD

[plutosix]

挖靠...雞皮疙瘩

[liudukaiying]

>Malaysians : Please be more humble and diplomatic in your delivery without exploiting your expressions of Malaysian nationalism, with regards to serving your pseudo-autocratic nation as a second-standard citizen, encumbered with the absurd obligation to learn Bahasa Melayu as dictated by your archenemy allotted in supremacy.

[hasher22]

@King881109

By the way, you just proved what I just said. You learnt English as a second language from kindergarten, learn to spell. Here are some tips;

u = you

kindergarden = kindergaten

whut = what

ur = your but in your sentence you mean you're or you are

after each full stop, have the next word with a capital letter.

Have you heard of the Chinese whispers? It seems that your English teacher was uneducated and passed some bad English habbits to you.

Thankyou

[King881109]

@hasher22 but it seemed like u do understand the meaning. r u livin in the 21st century ? lol, rofl, lmao , o0o , jk al dont exist in dictionary but people UNDERSTAND. yes including u. only idiot emphasize grammar in the internet world as if they're writing an essay u dumbo.

[hasher22]

@King881109

Again you're not making sense. ANYONE who sings in their second language cannot pull off a song. Its like a strong accent Scottish man singing in English. This is a good example. It's like me singing in French, English is my native toungue but I know I cannot sing a French song even though I can speak it.

If you cannot see that and if you think I'm racist then you have alot of learning to do.

[King881109]

@hasher22 hey asshole. u had wrong grammar ere. did ur english teacher taught u to type "ANYONE" as capital letter ? if ur not a malaysian, probably u wont even understand. its not even about this fuckin native tongue issue. if ur saying a korean or jap or brit like u said it, then ur rite due to the accent issue. malaysian are different u dickhead. u find any malaysian chinese that sings in english. 100% of them do not have accent. unless ur talking on MAINLAND chinese, THEN U ARE RIGHT.

[King881109]

if u find kpop idols singing in english (not raised in US), all of them have accent and trouble singing in english. in that case only ur analogy is correct becoz korean is their native tongue. even people like dbsk yoochun and snsd jessica speak english as if they're americans because they learnt english since young eventhough their native tongue are korean. malaysian chinese do not have that mandarin accent like China's chinese and to be able to sing in english is like singing in chinese.

[hasher22]

@King881109

Chinese is not a language. It seems that you are uneducated of your own Continent.

I refer back to my original comment, this girl did a good job hence English is her second language.

You're prob a good example yourself, you can prob sing a song better in your native tounge than In english.

There for I prove my point, I am not gonna argue with some person who couldn't read my first comment properly.

[King881109]

@hasher22 the point is.. she sang well in terms of of vocal. it is u asshole who talk crap on accent.

[hasher22]

@King881109

You're the biggest idiot, MY FIRST COMMENT WAS SHE SANG WELL, CONSIDERING HER 2ND LANGUAGE IS ENGLISH......... wow, you can't read. I swear you give Asians a bad name. Please stop debating.

[King881109]

@hasher22 i swear ur an unwanted big fat ass. i understand ur emoness. period.

[hasher22]

@King881109

The fact that your only comeback is profanities and insults to me is quite childish. I assume your how old? 11?

The irony of you calling me emo, when you're the one that is crying that you still think Chinese is a language and you think wikipedia is a source of factual information.

[King881109]

@hasher22 CHINESE IS NOT A LANGUAGE ? u fuckin kiddin me or ur tryin to undermine chinese ? go fuckin wiki or google chinese language. there are cantonese, mandarin n et and since mandarin is the dominant language, when we say chinese songs, people understand we're referring to mandarin. im a good example ? do u listen me sing b4 ? i sing equally well in bm, english n chinese or even jap and korean with lyrics bcz we dun have that fuckin "ACCENT" like BRITAIN/FRENCH/JAP/KOREA OR WUDEVA.

[hasher22]

@King881109

Chinese is not a language - ask anyone. I find it facinating that you refer to wiki as a source of information. Universities, highschools and even colleges bans students from getting their information from wiki.

lol you're getting angry for nothing hahaha...... I say this again 'Chinese' is not a language. Mandarin is.

[King881109]

@hasher22 if u wan to debate on that, it'll take ten years. u dun even have that kind of understanding. do u nid a guy to spell i like u for a girl to know that. in msn, people use emoticon to represent "feelings" which words cnt express. when we use noob, troll, lol n et, we automatically tuned to that kind of mutual understanding. like i said, there are tonnes of languages in umbrella term chinese, but we are tuned to understand it is mandarin. 

[hasher22]

@King881109

Again Chinese is not a language. You're bringing topics into the conversation that is irrelevant. I'm still dumbfounded on why an Asian such as yourself cannot come to the fact that Chinese is not a language

[vinsterkenkai]

這個李佳薇根本不系來比賽的，系來表演的吧?!!! 的確很厲害!!!!

[rynetien]

聲音很像貓!

[wildwyn]

why speak malay？？？＝＝