This song is fine as music, but, after all, this is an example of pure Chinese propaganda to justify its everlasting control over Tibet. Dalai Lama doesn`t claim that he is a living Buddha. This is manipulation. Tibet could changed on its road to modernisation without Chinese "help". I wouldn`t be surprised if my post will be canceled soon.
Another thing - a Buddhist country tends to justify inhumane treatments as the victims' karma. With this attitude, justice is hard to establish in society and modernization becomes difficult to achieve.
I don't really get your first sentence... where did you hear about that?
Karmas in my opinion cannot be described this way though. If you do anything good, you will certainly get something good -- either in this life or/and in your next lives, whereas you will get punishments in this life and/or next lives if you do anything bad, that's what it is about.
It is a rare cruelty to make a drum using human skin. I don't know much of Buddhism. Seems this type of artifacts only exist in Tibet. Many Tibetans worship their Lamas. Little do they realize that the Lamas are only human, not real Buddhas. Take Dailai as an example. How could a merciful Buddha rule a country for all his 13 reincarnations as they did in Tibet with 90% of its people were slaves? How could anybody tell others that he or she is in a superior class in any modern country?
I'm not Tibetan, but I have heard that they have this kind of funeral called "Sky Burial" -- in which they cut the bodies into pieces and make vultures eat the pieces. Tiibetans think this is generosity -- dedicating themselves to the livings. Also, Tibetans are very very religious, and the lamas can't make the instruments out of living humans. So it wouldn't be surprising if the sister in the song told the lamas that she would dedicate herself after her death and she dies very young.
buddha was a prince before he attained enlightenment. the skins are from corpses, people are not skinned alive. buddhists believe our body is nothing but a vessel, when we die, our soul leaves the body to reincarnate again.
每個民族都有不符合現代價值觀的習慣與文化,沒有誰比較偉大,放話批評快過於有建設性的作為,真的該了解&討論的是背後的意義。
RyanLouR 3 months ago
1970年1月,中国医学科学院年轻的医生叶如陵,响应祖国“支边”号召,带着新婚护士妻子,参加医疗队,来到了西藏。初入海拔5200米的煤矿,因为缺氧,血色素骤高,眼睛充血,嘴唇青紫,心脏扩大……这里,放眼亘古荒原,百里渺无人烟,严酷的自然条件,考验着叶如陵。然而,这里有藏族第一代煤矿工人,400多位藏胞对北京医生的无限信赖与祈盼,深深打动了他,也给了他无穷的动力。三年后,援藏的同伴陆续返京,他却选择了留在西藏,志愿服务边疆:西藏太需要他这样的大学生了! 叶如陵所学专业是整形外科,为了更好地服务西藏人民,他学藏语,开始研究高原医学。30多年间,他由一个普通医师,成长为一位信仰坚定的共产党员,一位深受藏胞信赖的主任医师。他为西藏建立了脑外科医疗小组,开创了西藏脑外科事业;与同事一起在拉萨建起了雪域高原地方上唯一的一所三级甲等医院,并出任业务副院长;西藏几十个县的沟沟坎坎,都留下了他巡回医疗的足迹;他任西藏民族学院医疗系教授,为高原培养不走的医疗队…… 高原服务31年,叶如陵为雪域高原留下了一个共产党人最无私的“名片”。
tanyatang1 9 months ago
大般涅槃經如來性品云:
善男子。有諸外道。或說我常。或說我斷。如來不爾。亦說有我。亦說無我。是名中道。若有說言:佛說中道,一切眾生悉有佛性。煩惱覆故,不知不見。是故應當勤修方便,斷壞煩惱。若有能作如是說者。當知是人不犯四重。若不能作如是說者。是則名為犯波羅夷。
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
[善哉,迷途知返~] @ [網路]似乎越來越多正覺法友脫離正覺同修會了?是啊,就算正覺法友始終堅信真有一個常住不滅的如來藏識體,也沒必要繼續留在一個備受爭議質疑否定且不受傳統大乘承認的蕭平實那裡啊!
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
如你所言~[殺人!殘忍!]~~那器官捐贈千刀萬剮豈不就成了殘忍致極了!~~任誰都知 事實並非如此 因為是出自己或親人認同才做出決定的![正覺邪教的愚夫们] 最擅扭曲事實了!
神經病!照你的推理 : 為了你的臭腳穿的皮鞋 +身上的毛線衣 +養你的大肚皮~~~就可殺生了? (阿姐鼓~是自己發願死後身體還能有所利有情 還是未死去殺生作成鼓? ~笨死了 倒因為果!)
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
如你所言~[殺人!殘忍!]~~那器官捐贈千刀萬剮豈不就成了殘忍致極了!~~任誰都知 事實並非如此 因為是出自己或親人認同才做出決定的![正覺邪教的愚夫们] 最擅扭曲事實了!
神經病!照你的推理 : 為了你的臭腳穿的皮鞋 +身上的毛線衣 +養你的大肚皮~~~就可殺生了? (阿姐鼓~是自己發願死後身體還能有所利有情 還是未死去殺生作成鼓? ~笨死了 倒因為果!)
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
pokeredmund 照你的推理 : 為了你的臭腳穿的皮鞋 +身上的毛線衣 +養你的大肚皮~~~就可殺生了? (阿姐鼓~是"自己"發願死後身體還能有所利有情, 還是未死去殺生作成鼓? ~笨死了 倒因為果!)
如你所言~[殺人!殘忍!]~~那器官捐贈千刀萬剮豈不就成了殘忍致極了!~~任誰都知 事實並非如此 因為是出自己或親人認同才做出決定的![正覺邪教的愚夫们] 最擅扭曲事實了!
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
pokeredmund 照你的推理 : 為了你的臭腳穿的皮鞋 +身上的毛線衣 +養你的大肚皮~~~就可殺生了? (是"自己"發願死後身體還能有所利有情, 還是未死去殺生作成鼓? ~笨死了 倒因為果!)
如你所言~[殺人!殘忍!]~~那器官捐贈千刀萬剮豈不就成了殘忍致極了!~~任誰都知 事實並非如此 因為是出自己或親人認同才做出決定的![正覺邪教的愚夫们] 最擅扭曲事實了!
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
jzzling 如你所言~[殺人!殘忍!]~~那器官捐贈千刀萬剮豈不就成了殘忍致極了!~~任誰都知 事實並非如此 因為是出自己或親人認同才做出決定的![正覺邪教的愚夫们] 最擅扭曲事實了!
神經病!照你的推理 : 為了你的臭腳穿的皮鞋 +身上的毛線衣 +養你的大肚皮~~~就可殺生了? (是自己發願死後身體還能有所利有情 還是未死去殺生作成鼓? ~笨死了 倒因為果!)
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
jzzling 神經病!照你的推理 : 為了你的臭腳穿的皮鞋 +身上的毛線衣 +養你的大肚皮~~~就可殺生了? (是自己發願死後身體還能有所利有情 還是未死去殺生作成鼓? ()~笨死了 倒因為果!)
如你所言~[殺人!殘忍!]~~那器官捐贈千刀萬剮豈不就成了殘忍致極了!~~任誰都知 事實並非如此 因為是出自己或親人認同才做出決定的![正覺邪教的愚夫们] 最擅扭曲事實了!
too728 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
神經病!照你的推理 : 為了你的臭腳穿的皮鞋 +身上的毛線衣 +養你的大肚皮~~~就可殺生了? (是自己發願死後身體還能有所利有情 還是未死去殺生作成鼓? ~笨死了 倒因為果!)
too728 10 months ago
阿姐鼓就是人皮鼓,可以肯定的是,不是用自然死亡的老人的皮做的鼓,不是用达赖喇嘛的皮做的鼓。
是少女的皮做的鼓,是活人剥皮做的鼓。
自己想吧
jzzling 1 year ago
[很多人對於藏傳佛教抱著非常錯誤的看法,多數中國人把藏傳佛教看成是原始野蠻的,甚至懷疑他是否屬於佛陀的教授。一個曾經去過西藏的女孩告訴我,她覺得藏傳佛教非常恐怖,理由是他們居然用人的骨頭做法器。我告訴她,其實沒什麼恐怖的,你每天用眾生的尸體當飯,用眾生的皮作皮鞋,也沒見你覺得恐怖啊。相比之下,那些使用人骨法器的僧人隻是用那些遺落在尸林的人骨做法器,他們並沒有因為自己要做法器就砍掉某人的腦袋。而且人骨法器的好處是,它可以讓你感受無常,我不認為一串水晶念珠可以讓你想到死亡,但是人骨念珠就會。雖然死亡並非無常的全部,但是他是很重要的一部分。]~自網路
too728 1 year ago
这是一首心灵歌曲,纵使世间有许多的天灾人祸,常念om ma mi pa mei hom,希望菩萨及护法神加持,保佑我们平安喜乐,安宁和谐。我们都在追求快乐,而人的快乐,不就只是追求内心的满足,如此而已吗?
ekeong0716 1 year ago
This song is fine as music, but, after all, this is an example of pure Chinese propaganda to justify its everlasting control over Tibet. Dalai Lama doesn`t claim that he is a living Buddha. This is manipulation. Tibet could changed on its road to modernisation without Chinese "help". I wouldn`t be surprised if my post will be canceled soon.
czaromirr 1 year ago
谢谢你的介绍,分析的很精辟到位
coco0871 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fucking shame on such primitive shit
ifpatrick 3 years ago
Comment removed
colind911 3 years ago
每個教派都有獨到之處,也並非每個你所看不慣的風俗就是錯的、殘忍的,否定一個民族長久以來累積的文化,一句話就能做到,但是要提出一個真正正確的論點來否定,則要花費很多人、很多時間、很多爭論才能做到,這是一個世界的頻道,很多人正在看著。
zxz3318 3 years ago 4
Comment removed
colind911 3 years ago
Comment removed
colind911 3 years ago
@zxz3318 是的,我很赞同,我们不能太主观。
pokeredmund 1 year ago
Another thing - a Buddhist country tends to justify inhumane treatments as the victims' karma. With this attitude, justice is hard to establish in society and modernization becomes difficult to achieve.
pwdeng 3 years ago
@pwdeng
I don't really get your first sentence... where did you hear about that?
Karmas in my opinion cannot be described this way though. If you do anything good, you will certainly get something good -- either in this life or/and in your next lives, whereas you will get punishments in this life and/or next lives if you do anything bad, that's what it is about.
HingYok 1 year ago
It is a rare cruelty to make a drum using human skin. I don't know much of Buddhism. Seems this type of artifacts only exist in Tibet. Many Tibetans worship their Lamas. Little do they realize that the Lamas are only human, not real Buddhas. Take Dailai as an example. How could a merciful Buddha rule a country for all his 13 reincarnations as they did in Tibet with 90% of its people were slaves? How could anybody tell others that he or she is in a superior class in any modern country?
pwdeng 3 years ago 6
@pwdeng
I'm not Tibetan, but I have heard that they have this kind of funeral called "Sky Burial" -- in which they cut the bodies into pieces and make vultures eat the pieces. Tiibetans think this is generosity -- dedicating themselves to the livings. Also, Tibetans are very very religious, and the lamas can't make the instruments out of living humans. So it wouldn't be surprising if the sister in the song told the lamas that she would dedicate herself after her death and she dies very young.
HingYok 1 year ago
I mean, "and she happens to die very young".
HingYok 1 year ago
@pwdeng
buddha was a prince before he attained enlightenment. the skins are from corpses, people are not skinned alive. buddhists believe our body is nothing but a vessel, when we die, our soul leaves the body to reincarnate again.
ikhamo 1 year ago