Simon telling this wizard of vocal pyrotechnics that she's good enough to be a soloist rather than a backup singer is like telling Elizabeth Taylor in her prime that she has pleasant features.
It isn't that Jodin can't sing; she can. She just is NOT in the same league as Melinda; not very many people are. I am not sure how or why Melinda got voted off the show, but in my opinion, and many others, she was the true winner of AI.
melinda is one of those rare singers in Idol who can belt a whitney song and not get negative criticisms (ex. 'You're not as good as whitney", etc etc.)
did simon say, I really dig you to Melinda? O.o @1:03
overtime2005 9 months ago
Simon telling this wizard of vocal pyrotechnics that she's good enough to be a soloist rather than a backup singer is like telling Elizabeth Taylor in her prime that she has pleasant features.
mmdillon1 1 year ago
Who sing "This is It"?
SteelAVic18 1 year ago
@SteelAVic18 Melba Moore
birdsong40 1 year ago
0:42... um yeah right Simon like there are so many people that are better than Melinda!!! No way!
KristinChenoweth1 2 years ago
what did simon tell her when she kiss her
nikaledesma 2 years ago
I can't believe she got eliminated let alone eliminated before Blake, that crap-hole singer.
KristinChenoweth1 2 years ago 5
When she got eliminated... I just lost interest in the contest...
She is a truly singer.
pamorale 2 years ago 14
I wanted her to win, she should have won.
rosbrownsugar 2 years ago 17
I can't believe she's lost to beat boxing crap boy !! she and jordin should be in the finale...
vermouthnist 2 years ago 10
I was touched by Simon's act..., and it was the first time i saw simon like that.
oliverosmarc 2 years ago 9
Notice the cheer that erupts from the room...even her 'competitors' recognized her talent and knew she deserved to be in the top 24.
thetrebleclef 3 years ago 14
yeah...that was definitely a thunderous cheer from the others.
denzelwvu 3 years ago 5
I totally agree... i love herr!
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago 3
i love how she transformed...so shy to an amazing powerhouse. really loved watching that season because of her. cannot wait for her cd
mzzh 3 years ago 14
Melinda looks sexy in that outfit!
lupi0525 3 years ago 6
simon really believed in her
slimygit8 3 years ago 8
best...best...best...
exceptional melinda
PoNge 3 years ago 15
whats the song she sings?
zkdls 3 years ago
I think it's, "This is It" by Melba Moore, originally that is... I know that its been remade a couple of times.
curlyj76 3 years ago 3
I can not wait to hear what her first single is. I voted for her every week. Jordin is good. But Melinda is fantastic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
anthonystick 3 years ago 22
it is my funny valentine
nomarjramon 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shes ok
cutiepierocks8 3 years ago
Don't ever say that again... She's a million miles beyond "ok", she's phenomenal! If you don't want to be bitch-slapped, don't say that again!
femmefataleminx 3 years ago 7
stupid comment, she's fantastic !!
vermouthnist 2 years ago 3
I love melinda!! Screw Jordan this is the real winner!!!
cutielu8705 4 years ago 24
It isn't that Jodin can't sing; she can. She just is NOT in the same league as Melinda; not very many people are. I am not sure how or why Melinda got voted off the show, but in my opinion, and many others, she was the true winner of AI.
deltahak 3 years ago 8
melinda is one of those rare singers in Idol who can belt a whitney song and not get negative criticisms (ex. 'You're not as good as whitney", etc etc.)
VachConstantin 3 years ago 3
I totally agree... i love herr!
sweetprinces4lyfe 4 years ago 6
Melinda, you are amazing!!! You should have won!!
brontese 4 years ago 9