Added: 4 years ago
From: homoshame
Views: 432,084
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (512)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The fact she doesn't sing the chorus in the right octave is really dissapointing D:!

  • @aaliyahluva33: u shut ur piehole, don't be a hater she's very popular in the indiepop world here in the u.s.! U don't know good music @ all ur a hater!

  • who is she? like i mean i know shes big in sweden but shes a nobody in the u.s.

  • @Aaliyahluva33 Because you only have crap music.

  • @Aaliyahluva33 Who's Aaliyah?

  • I love Robyn :3

  • Theres nothing like her.

  • Robyn, you rock

  • Robyn is a freakin' genius!!!

  • not very different from the original.

  • Comment removed

  • Love Robyn but this is just dull.

  • Love Robyn

  • To me, I like the instrumental it's great, but her vocals aren't my favourite...

  • Hmm. Don't know if i'm too happy with this. It's the best cover out there tho, but nobody tops kelly.

  • loves it!!!!!

  • Robyn is just as good as back in days as today.... However what happened to the real Robyn?

  • @manny298 this IS the real robyn! she just evolved.....and for the better......she's too talented to do mainstream pop

  • This just shows those of you who did not know exactly how much better Robyn is than every single American Idol winner.

  • She reminds me of a girl in Cyber6.

    I find she's got a bit of an 80's feel to her.

    She's quite adorable.

  • i never really liked robyn, but hearing her acoustic versions, i cant stop listening to them!<3

  • cool she sounds great

  • @ovenstonejoey yea.....i want to be open minded, but kelly does rock this song...correction: she owns it.

  • She sings the demo for kelly!!!

  • her own songs are MUCH better, why do a cover of this? (kelly does it better)

  • Nice synthy version of this song! Robyn's great.

  • sooo viel besser als das original

  • She's awesome and she's SWEDISH! Yeeah take that, we can make it too!^^

  • Great cover if you like Robyn. This song obviously wasn't meant for mass consumption so you'd have to be a fan to appreciate such a stripped down version. In general I wouldn't say it's better than Kelly's version at all, even though I'm a Robyn fan... but I still love the cover and will be adding to to my collection!

  • @christofrr I say different not better, but as a fan of Robyn, this is a great cover. I love that her voice is high and pure and not angrily screaming at me like Kelly mostly does in that song. And the chipmunk comment is rude. You can voice your opinion without dissing her, right?

  • I love her!

  • better than kelly 

  • where can i download this??? i must have it!!!!

  • I love robyn :p great cover

  • As good as the Kelly Clarkson version, but she makes it her own, and makes it sound like a Robyn song. I loved every second of this. This girl has a voice.

  • sounds like cyndi lauper :)

  • great cover, i really like robyn:)!

  • she makes it her own and that is what makes it.she is hot and sings soooo good!!

  • try listening to 'a day to remember' their version is brill <3

  • I like her voice here, but I can't say the same about the music...

  • shes amazing .best singer ever !! .did any1 notice her eyes a bit old though ?

  • @bloodybaron0 it's the makeup -.-

  • i welllll love thissss :)

  • Robyn did a real good job,and if I didn't know Kelly's version,I guess I'd prefer Robyns..But I do know and from my point of view she took the real meaning of the song..But though pretty good cover ;)

  • @KaeseKuchenxD You need to hear Kelly's. Robyn is murdering this with a blunt knife.

  • lol,maybe my english wasn't that good,but I heard Kelly's version and I love it,I meant to say,that if I wouldn't have known her version I had prefered Robyn's...Hope you'll understand now what I mean =)

  • bugh

  • i like this...

  • homoshane, i love robyn too. since 1996!

  • It's aite, but KELLY'S BETTER!! WOOT =]

  • I think Robyn is an extremely talented artist. I adore everything she does because you can feel her heart and soul in it.

    Her voice is captivating.

  • @Kasper8516 It's wonderful how much her voice has improved since she started. Her earlier work her voice is rather... vague. But now it has such character: her voice on "Dream On", Robyn, and "The Girl And The Robot" is just... ahhh!! Amazing :D

  • @12345random67890 I have to completely agree with you on that. Listening to her often times brings me to tears. It's so much more than just noise to her. Oh man, and I love "Girl & The Robot"

  • @Kasper8516 I must be fucked i keep wanting her ,i love her. Her music i can relate to,All i want is a kiss.Give me a kiss.

  • @Kasper8516 she's the best.

  • @GoAwayEmoCunt

    Shame you're probably leagues uglier <3

  • @LCwashere

    Shame you're a twat.

    [:

    x

  • at the start i was like eww she wrecked it but at the first chorus she started being really good! :)

  • It's very good.. but it just doesn't have the power and explosion into the chorus that Kelly gets by going up an octave. Her range makes her song more powerful than this one... but to be fair, this is very nice in its own tranquillity. It's just different from Kelly's version, I suppose.

  • I love both versions, and Kidz Bop it ain't, my friends.  And if you think Robyn was better back in the day, look up "The Girl and the Robot."

  • @goodgrief78 I know right! She is in control of her music. Robyns "Time Machine" is mint!

  • amazing!

  • great cover

  • kelly kills this song. yes, i'm a clarkson fan, but not die-hard. this version is a bit too spritely for me--like Kidz Bop-ish. for what it's worth, i remember robyn from years back, and her being/sounding better than this.

  • She has my name.

  • kellys version is better

    but i like this. saying that i don't like kelly clarkson or robyn, just this one song, is quite amazing.

  • im a bit over kelly but still a half hearted fan but this version is golden robyn rocks.

    where can i get this song?

    thanks for posting

  • i actually lke this

    and i dont like robyn

    so yeah.

  • This is probably subjective, but i think Kelly's version is better, and i'm not really a Kelly Clarkson fan.

  • What a beautiful, beautiful voice!

  • An understated version but I LOVE it!

  • THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU for this upload <3<3<3<3<3<3

  • Much better version

  • Not too fond of it but I do enjoy listening to covers. It nice hearing peoples different ways of singing the songs and interpretions of it. I prefer Kellys original version but I like this one too.

  • robyn du bist meine beste freundin meine stimme meines herzens

  • Comment removed

  • Love it... still. Robyn rocks.

  • i love the a day to remember version!

  • not sure about the music in the background.

    sounds a bit like a demented grandfather clock.. :\

  • PMSL that has really tickled me x lol x

  • it does tho :L

    bit like someone has sped up the grandfather clock messed around with the ticking. x

  • Kelly Clarckson's version is much better than this. Anyway that's a cover in perfect Robyn's style, no surprise this would have sounded like this.

  • FUCK THIS! Kelly kills this with more emotion.

  • its not bad.i do prefer kells version better.the chorus is good in this though

  • Robyn is AWESOME! Everything she sings, I love - this being no exception. Unlike most modern singers, she actually has talent and can bring out beauty in her songs.

  • I like this version. It's like an enitrely different song~

    Ps. She look's like a dragon! ( a cute dragon) ^_^

  • I love this music, I wish she'd do a new song to it for her next album. Xx loving Robyn.

  • Could be a bit dodgy!

  • This is lovely =]

  • Very beautiful. This beauty is totally drown in the over-screaming original.

  • i LOVE this!

  • didn't like it

    her and kellys voices are to different

    no where near as good as the original

  • This is incredibly saccharine. It's kind of weird ro hear this from the woman who;s responsible for 'Konichiwa, Bitches"

  • You should stop sucking yourself first

  • It's aright. I was waiting for some crazy rifts to come in, cause she's good at that, but I guess they never came. :(

  • I agree I think the same with every heartbeat. You keep waiting for it to explode. I think that suffers more than this from it. I think she may have to work on that. However, it does add a different character to the song.

  • The simple background music lets you hear her wonderful voice instead of being drowned out like a lot of mainstream pop.

    Robyn's a very good singer.

  • thanks for sharing! fantastic!

  • AN EXCELLENT showcase of her vocals.... HUGE MARKS!!!

  • better than every version i've ever heard

  • love robyn- finally the song touched me !

  • i love robyn and this is soooo cool!!! i like it^^

  • the beats. u can tell she robyn-fied it.

  • i like her but this is so mad

  • i'm a fan of robyn but.......

  • o0o0o I really like it!

  • Robyn is a genius i love her.....she took a great song and put her corky touch she can do no wrong

  • Meh Its not her who sound chinese... its the "music".. though this doesnt sound very good. Boring

  • so true

  • Shut up about her being shit, Robyn is amazing. People who think she is shit are just jealous, because they could never sing nearly as good.

  • little secret... me too i only like her song eclispe

  • いい歌声ですね。Her voice is very beautiful.(Japan)

  • shes sounds chinese

  • haha she´s swedish :D

  • jag älskar robyn !

    I love robyn!

  • love her songs!!!!

  • oh ok for bubblegum dance the vocals are not that bad.

    but the instrumental is awful. with the right beat, this could have been a good cover.

  • better than the original :D

  • This is a ver good cover by robyn!!!

  • I like this better then the original!

  • shut the fck up!!

  • beautiful

  • i like this she brings her own style to the song. i like kellys version 2. but i actually think i like this version better.

  • This is cool she made the song her own, but i still prefer kelly's version. Anyway still good.

    PLEASE CHECK OUT MY CHANNEL TO SEE ME SING.

    THANK U

  • I would say that this is much better than the original song. Robyn has definitely the better voice and look :D

  • Is this a cover or not ? =)

    my friend and I were confuesed

  • It's a cover, recorded for BBC radio. However, she could quite well sung the demo for it. And I doubt that Max martin gave this song to robyn as tessina5555 wrote.

  • This is not a cover., its a demo.The swedish producers who made this song wanted to give it to robyn first but she didn´t want it in the end, and they change it to a rockier song and gave it to kelly

  • Comment removed

  • Unique voice, I will make a track for you

  • this cover is quite amazing

    her voice is really unique

    (=

  • This is why you they should never allow remixes of rock/pop songs they just don't work!

  • Comment removed

  • it's ok but i prefer the original version!!

  • Gosh, sopme Clarkson fans are very annoyed, aren't they? :D

    It's an electropop take on a pop, rock song. The arrangement could've been a bit better but it's good, IMO.

  • This is to DBomb, obviously you know nothing, this is the "original" version, it's called a demo track that songwriters send to artists. Robyn sang this for Max Martin who wrote the song and they recorded it and sent it to Kelly.

  • really? why didnt she sue? thats so unfair to her most people think its a kelly original. who is max martin? sorry iv been out of the states for a while...

  • Max Martin is only one of the leading songwriters for todays big it things. He wrote alot of Britney Spears's hits, thats what I know him from. Most recently, his latest Britney hit is iF yoU (C)seeK ME.

  • He is a swedish guy that made Kelly Clarkson's hits "Since U Been Gone" and "Behind These Hazel Eyes" and hits for pop artists like the Backstreet Boys, NSYNC, Britney Spears, and Pink among many others..

    From 2008-2009, he's written four #1 hits including "So What" by Pink, "Hot N Cold" and "I Kissed a Girl" by Katy Perry, and Kelly Clarkson's "My Life Would Suck Without You".

  • ew katy perry, if you ask me that must have been a very very dark time for him.

  • then its a good thing that i wont ask you :)

    thb, he must have made loads and loads of money off her.

  • No I really think this is a cover because at least Kelly would have kept some aspects of the demo right???

  • I Like One Hit from Robyn but THIS IS Kelly Brianne Clarkson's song and Kelly sings it Best because she's the Original who sings it.... but Robyn does it interestly. :} Love Kelly's verision though!

  • i live for robyn everything she does is amazing

  • ...I expected more from Robyn.

    >_>

    It could have been a lot better.

  • Kelly does this song much better. Love Robyn, though :)

  • the start sounds like the start of mamma mia by abba.

  • lol!!! it does

  • I really hate Robyn, but she did sing this well.

  • Hate this song, but Robyn sings it pretty well ;)

  • sorry...but i like kelly clarkson's version better :D anyone agree?

  • It isn't really comparable. They are two different styles. Most people are trained to like lots of noise around average vocals. Not saying Kelly Clarkson is average by any means, but I'm not sure her versions would be as loved as they are if she tried to go without the music factory helping her out.

  • Robyn truly is amazing 0_O

    Hope i get to see her in concert again ; )

    Well this song is going straight to my mp3!

  • No harmony =-(

  • Ohhh gott schon mal was von Musik gehört ?? Oder von Töne treffen ??

  • good song. like robyn!