I think Unni-sir's comment is valid. Roopa has sung the song very very well. She has however, i feel taken a bit more liberty, and rightly so, with the exploration of the raaga-bhavam and the intricacies which Dasettan may not have had at the time of the recording in the studio, director's cut to fit the picturization. It's in the second stanza she really takes off..you really get carried away with her singing especially from the line "pookum thazavaram.." , the line which Chithra sang.
She sung it very well...the different always be there as you sing with real orchestra... that will be different story and when you record a song for a movie it will be recoded with different format never like this... not in open hall enviornment... so those thinks differ and Yesudas Sir sung it when he had so many years of experiance... so Unni menons Comparison was not at all relevent
one more thing: Did roopa get the trophy? and why is that such wonderful talent is absent in Idea Star Singer Show?
georgtomas2010 1 year ago
I think Unni-sir's comment is valid. Roopa has sung the song very very well. She has however, i feel taken a bit more liberty, and rightly so, with the exploration of the raaga-bhavam and the intricacies which Dasettan may not have had at the time of the recording in the studio, director's cut to fit the picturization. It's in the second stanza she really takes off..you really get carried away with her singing especially from the line "pookum thazavaram.." , the line which Chithra sang.
georgtomas2010 1 year ago
She sung it very well...the different always be there as you sing with real orchestra... that will be different story and when you record a song for a movie it will be recoded with different format never like this... not in open hall enviornment... so those thinks differ and Yesudas Sir sung it when he had so many years of experiance... so Unni menons Comparison was not at all relevent
sachit0421 2 years ago
unnimenonu yesudsinodu virodamundayirikkam pakshe athu kondu ee kutti padiyathu yesudas
padiyathinekal nannavumo ? Orikkalumilla.
Nannayi padiyittund pakshe orikkalum yesudas padiyathinte aduth polum ethiyittilla. Dasettan kodutha bhavam athinte pakuthi polum ithil vannittilla.Ithoro lalitha ganam poleyanu roopitha padiyathu .samshayamundenkil orginal kettu vilayiruthuka
hasankadar 3 years ago 2
absolutely right, nowhere near the original, but still very good. I think the difference is the sound and the effect
knpradeep77 2 years ago
Great song...She sung so well.
gramNY 3 years ago
karthi,thanks alot for posting roopa's songs,If possible please post Teena's songs also
rmnambiar 4 years ago
waiting 4 roopa's new songs.... duet with praveen...
sushamasathyan 4 years ago
Thanks for posting this video...excellent rendition of a beautiful song!
jibhoombaah 4 years ago