Added: 2 years ago
From: CenasCorner
Views: 5,213
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (129)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • as far as im concerned.. rock band copied gh. but rockband improved where gh lacked. simple as that.

  • guitar hero 5 is shit. I bought it and I was dissappointed... and I want my money back.

    like who the fuck cares if it's good for parties?

    the format still SUCKS..

    what the pro players want is a new guitar hero game with metal/ rock such as yngwie malmsteen, Children of Bodom, Van Halen, Wintersun, michael angelo batio etcetc...

    GOOD songs, not shit like fucking hiphop? like what the fuck!? it does NOT belong in a guitar hero game,. seriously.

    If you're any good at the game, don't buy it...

  • Absolutley agree AchooZor!!! i was really dissapointed with GH5, been thrashing greatest hits instead

  • GH vs RB??? Have you ever tried Frets on Fire X? Well you should.... with custom themes graphics are identical and you can play with a Pc keyboard or with a gh or rb guitar (or drums)... but while GH has 90 songs Fofix has more than 3k

  • Here's my opinion on the whole conflict: Stfu.

    It doesn't matter who copies who. They are making both games better, so shut up. Would you rather prefer guitar hero but miss some features in rock band that you like or vice versa? No, you wouldn't, so shoosh. >.>

  • Everyone is so Anti-Guitar Hero now. The games are still brilliant in my opinion, but of course 2 things of the same kind cant exist in this world without conflict between the two. This fight is very bias tho, everyones like "Omg they copied the hammer on chord!" but if rockband copied Guitar Hero's sustain thing rockband doesnt have thing then no one would even care

  • no its more than that. its about activision being greedy little idiots. they keep releasing game after game in such a little time span, charging people $60 each. rock band is WAAAY better cause they focuse on DLC and expand their current game instead of releasing 20 games in a year just to compete. face it, the GH franchise from 2005 is dead!! GH IS A SELL OUT!!!

    ROCKBAND FTW!!!!

  • the developers of rockband were the developers of guitar hero 1 2 and rock the 80s. then after 3 when it wasnt harmonix it went down the tubes

  • Guitarhero is better than Rockband

  • You wish my friend. You wish. ;)

    This one could be the comeback Neversoft has been looking for tho.

  • its nuthing but guitar hero world tour 2

  • Wow whyd does it look like Rockband?

  • well actually rock revolution came out like 9 years ago then harmonix was like yah where going to make that u know so they both copied

  • 2:55

    Do my eyes decieve me, or did they just copy the RB2 hammer-on chord?

  • the speaker of all neversoft gh games is lol

  • Neversoft should make more dlc for gh3 instead as its absolute best gh ever.

  • oh true that GH3 FTW

  • LOL expert plus doesn't really seem necessary for that song.

  • now these guys are doing hamered on chords??

  • wtf!? like people have more than one drumset in their house or like 4 guitars laying around? this is gay, is it really that hard to pass a guitar controller to the next person? and stop stealing rock bands ideas just cuz yours suck! this games bullshit, i'm glad the setlist sucks ass, now i don't have to feel bad for not buying it

  • guitar what??? all i see is a bootleg rock band.

  • sooo gh now more like rock band :)

  • Guitar Hero 3 didn't come up with the idea. And why would you even want to play 4 guitars? It'd be pointless, plus the screen is just gonna get crowded just like it was in GH:WT.

  • No it's not. It's no where near the best. So wait, you don't have to worry about points or failing? Oh look, Rock Band has the No Fail option. And why would you even have or buy 4 guitars? It's useless.

  • They didn't make it better with Smash Hits. Guitar Hero will never be a better band game than Rock Band. The only reason Guitar Hero was a better game was because Harmonix was making it. Neversoft should stick to Tony Hawk and forget about Guitar Hero. Plus, Harmonix came up with all those ideas, not Guitar Hero.  Which just proves my point that Harmonix knows what they're doing, and Guitar Hero doesn't.

  • well who is this guitar hero person your talking about lol guitar hero is a game dumb ass not a company

  • It's easier to talk using Guitar Hero because this is a Guitar Hero presentation, and people might not know Neversoft made it, dumbass.

  • well im sure everyone would know neversoft did because how many guitar hero games have they made?? hmm lets see.... theres 3, aerosmith world tour on tour, on tour:decades on tour:modern hits metallica and smash hits soo thats.. 8

  • Yeah, they've made 8. 8 terrible games. Plus, not everyone knows they've made those 8. And by the way, hammer-on chords are just another copy off of Rock Band.

  • exactly the last good guitar hero game was world tour.

  • So you're agreeing with me? Doesn't that contradict your whole argument?

  • I geuss :P

  • Haha. I think I need to stop getting myself into arguments on this video!

  • don't matter who is copying who, more games = more songs = more fun!!

  • in my opionion i think guitar hero metaillca is better than world tour. i do all four instruments on guitar and rock band. and i was upset in the fact that they world tour impossible to get 100% on vocals

  • Try to think of some improvements, they just have to do something to "survive" you dumbass.

  • It does matter. They can't even think of their own ideas. They have to steal them all from Rock Band. How about the whole idea of a band? How about those 20 songs they stole from Rock Band 2? How about showing how many stars you have during the middle of a song? They need to start thinking of their own ideas.

  • yeah guitar hero is losing the match with rock band. once you start blatantly copying ideas just to keep up with your competitor, you ultimately fail and can never go back to what made your product good to begin with.

  • Wow. Big surprise. Copying of Rock Band again by being able to save your band members. Does Activision like stealing ideas?

  • Yes, yes they do.

  • Well, if you think about it RB and GH copied off of each other. GH came out first (before RB) with being able to play songs with a guitar, and then RB copied off of GH with the whole music experience but they added drums and a mic, and then GH copied RB with the full band gameplay. So there, I think I've made a point.

  • No you haven't made any point. Yes, Guitar Hero came out first, but GH was made by Harmonix. Harmonix then made Rock the 80's and 2. They sold the rights to Neversoft, then made Rock Band. Therefore, only Guitar Hero copied off Rock Band.

  • Whatever, it's just a game and you don't have to play it if you don't want to.

  • pfft rock band threw out guitar hero kinda like apple threw out microsoft

  • umm microsoft is leading ahead of apple

    and GH is better...

    you guys all care if GH copies rockband

    but you dont care if rockband copies GH

    like ollie said with the extended sustain notes

  • another ignorant n00b =)

    first of all, those who created rockband, created guitar hero, fucktard.

    when rb3 comes, its all over

    they fuckin released 6 guitar hero games in one year, if u continue to buy these games, u sir are a true sucker because theres nothing new added at all.

    gh4, mettalica, smash hits, vanhalen(the one that came with gh5 free)

    their all the same game with diffrent tracks rofl.

    gh5, band hero, and van halen coming in december are all the same game also,

    dj hero trash

  • wow GHM is the best and you know it...

    GH5 is garbage

  • People need to realize that the makers of the first two Guitar Hero... are the makers of Rock Band. So RB did not copy GH if you go by technicality.

  • did u notice that the left guitarist is a lefty.

  • I'm more impressed with the left guitarist than the actual game play.

  • Multiple of the same instrument is stupid. 4 tracks? It looks cramped and annoying. There's no way I could have fun with this with my 25" TV...

  • get a bigger tv then

  • This game looks just as bad as World Tour.

  • Wow, they copied just about everything from RB. Even using green and yellow/gold colored paths for the vocalist. GG Activision.

  • I think this game looks awesome compare to World Tour, we get even more features and a great setlist. We get Iron Maiden, Megadeth, Rammstein and many more classics!!!

  • the reason is looks awesome compared to world tour (even though it still sucks) is that activision copied EVERYTHING from HMX on RB down to the H/O & P/O chords.... the only thing that is different now is the party play thing which is a kinda good idea but they did a bad job on it.

  • the hmx version of hammerchords suck and were broken...hopefully NS will fix them so they work properly. and how could you possibly say they did a bad job on party play? have you played it? no.

  • they AREN'T broken! they work perfectly fine you just fail. and NS, after 3 games still has broken purple notes, so how can you say anything about hmx? and i can say they did a bad job on party play because I CAN! i don't have to play it to see that it sucks by the way it is being used.

  • lol...okay, fanboy...i can see you aren't going to be rational or provide and useful comments, so run along.

  • lol i'm the fanboy? you are the one here defending NS on all accounts even though they are overproducing items and not paying attention to their games anymore.... like my friend said "They are going all Tony Hawk on Guitar Hero"

  • when exactly did i defend ns? i simply made a rational point that you cannot judge party play yet because you haven't used it and there's only been like 3 gameplay videos about it. and the hmx hammerchords are broken, watch any video of someone playin, and they usually strum them because they don't trust them to register. just because i point out a fault in the game, it doesn't mean i don't like it. how is ns not payin attention to their games, exactly?

  • drummer sucks

  • i agree, both of them sucked lmao

  • Is Expert Plus just for drums?

  • lol the pace that activision is going at, its like stephen kings books

  • 3:05 hammeron chord?

  • Yeah it appears that they are adding HO Chords now in GH 5

  • lmfao the drummer like never got a combo

  • Screw that I want better melodic death metal. Children Of Bodom are good but they still need to add a lot more metal into the game.

  • YEA METAL!!!

  • i just noticed that expert and hards only difference is that it doesnt complete rolls or have all base notes.

  • more than one drummer looks pretty sweet.

  • i think that it was pretty bad that Activision copied rock band completely with the star power and when people fail out.

  • They also have individual SP and HOPO chords. Now all they need is solo sections and fills to activate SP and we have an inferior twin...

  • this is very innovative. this one might be good for Activision, but they really need to slow down, already a bunch since the RB1 release

  • Party mode is actually a welcome addition, and so are a few things they took from Rock Band. Even if it's kinda ripping off, all for the better gameplay experience.

    This and Expert Plus could definitely drag me into GH5, but otherwise I'm happy with Rock Band for now.

  • FUCK they've added chord hopos...

  • Hammeron HO/PO's

    That's original [/sarcasm]

  • This game looks like it could be fun. I'm still not sold on GH but if I were to try one... this would be it!

    In regard to Rock band, it seems as if they have a cigarette business model. Harmonix has addicted the hardcore gamer but wants to do better than that. Rock Band Beatles will attract an older crowd while Rock Band Lego will attract a younger crowd (think Joe Camel Cartoon) If they can successfully get everyone into their game, Rock Band 3 will be a total and complete success.

  • I like how it shows your own percent and your score at the end... That might be the only thing I like. GH has gone just downhill since Rockband 2.

  • hey come on its meant like your friends can bring their drums etc to your place and play multiplayer drums..

  • yeah COB

  • I like the fretboard better than in WT, but it still fails compared to rock band.

  • wut... 4 drums? lol....

  • thats wut i was thinking...who the fuck has room for 4 drum kits??!!?? who the fuck has 4 drum kits??!!??

  • A rich guy ^_^...or someone that has a few RB drums laying around

  • I see a lot of changes...some of them are like Rock Band 2. Such as the revival meter and challenges on songs. I think this game is going to fail.

  • looks awful in my opinion i dont like it at all

  • damn youtube it's taken me over an hour to watch this god damn video..by the time you're reading this I will have finished watching it and be pissed off at youtube for the rest of the night...have a nice day.

  • Sweet, can't wait for it to come out! At this point I'm only going to get the game disc though (For both RB and GH) because I have enough plastic instruments already. LoL

  • I wish they would use a different note system for the drums, the round buttons with the pink line arent that pleasing, plus, those few extra features are pretty cool, you know rock back will prolly introduce that stuff with rock band 3 :) . Im not looking forward to getting this game, I might someday, who knows.

  • shit game. once again as i say over and over that the Beatles rock band just looks much more user friendly and just epic and the music obviously beats it. I just don't see this game succeeding at all. BEATLES FOREVER

  • Actually, this game is going to succeed over The Beatle's game definately, there have been just TERRIBLE outlook and reviews on that game, because only 42 songs are on disc, and there's no DLC. And the instruments look crappy, I lve Harmonix but, the game isn't the greatest.

  • The Beatle's Rock Band is pretty much just Harmonix's reply to Guitar Hero Metallica (which had 40 songs, and no DLC, except for the Death Magnetic Album.) They also just want to buy some time before they release rock band 3, which somewhat makes sense, but I don't know why they're making Rock Band Lego

  • Its so younger kids can get the game because theyre no old eough to buy Rock Band Beatles or any Rock Band game.

  • It's more family songs, there really is nothing different about it except lego characters, notes, and the songs..

  • buy some time?????????? this is the beatles a once in a lifetime opportunity and they took it. seriously this isn't a reply to guitar hero metallica at ALL

  • it does have dlc

    it's just only Beatles songs

  • yes there is only 42 song ON DISC but The Beatles Rock Band does have DLC every Beatles album is going to be put on there.

    Get your facts straight.

  • you are so stupid kid. Beatles rock band has 45 songs PLUS dlc and full albums. and what terrible outlook has been made about the beatles rock band?????????? they got to open for the microsoft press conference and paul and ringo came out. that is success. SERIOUSLY LOOK UP THE FACTS KID YOU ARE SO WRONG! And yes it is the greatest cause it has the biggest and greatest band ever in the world. And the instruments look way better than gh5's so don't say shit anymore you have no idea wat your saying

  • learn some grammar kid my god.

  • If they sucked dick then why do all the fans like them?

  • Yeah, bullshit. The instruments look like SHIT! I love the Beatles. But this game I honestly think looks better. They are not the greatest ever, they didn't revolutionalize music as much as Black Sabbath, Napalm Death, The Who, Rolling Stones. They were all big parts in this great sounding thing we call music. No band really deserves their own game. It's stupid and shows me that they have no where else to go to get more fans. Metallica is good, but do they deserve a game. NOPE!

  • like any of those bands revolutionized music. most of them are good bands but i couldn't say they revolutionized music...

  • what happened to "YOU ROCK!"? And is it me or the drum notes are back to looking like the round guitar notes?

  • They're on Part Play mode, which simply just shows your percentage, and then goes onto the next song in your setlist. In quicklyplay, career, etc. You'll still get the trademark "You Rock!!!"

  • makes sense. but why does the drum notes look like guitar notes? or was i looking at it wrong?

  • The notes have always looked the same... What else are they supposed to look like?

  • I like Bryan Bright. He's such a cool guy. He doesnt deserve having to make 5 guitar heros every damn year. He deserves variety.

  • i bet rock band 3 or 4 will have what GH 5 has sine they both like to improve on each others ideas.

  • Is that hopo chords I see.

  • never really been a fan of GH, more of a RB fan personally, but i gotta admit, party play is EPIC!!!!!

  • Why are the feelings so mixed? It's the same games that we've been playing with more options. That should be good enough.

  • this looks pretty tight but i refused to get excited since wt was a bust.

  • agreed

  • awesome

  • Brian Bright is such a douche

  • well, I see they kept the open strum for bass. Did they at least fix the calibration so you can go into the negative? Think I'll stick with the Beatles, Lego rock bands and uncharted 2... that alone will put the dent in my wallet!! o_0

  • ps2?

    yes no?

  • yes

  • yes i was told

  • th same old stuff

  • Not sweet...

  • Two words: (hopefully) epic

  • kinda gives me a guitar hero 3 feeling with more instruments

  • sick

  • omg nice! did u ask stephen for me?

  • this game looks nive

  • nice Im soo getting this game

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more