Nice, real nice. I think Feferov did an amazing job too. He knocked it out the ball park, but remember, this song is not easy!!! The worst one in history---- remember her???
DAVID ARCHULETA and Jennifer Hudson are the only ones that sang this so beautifully. Adam Lambert's version is good but not like David Archuleta's or Jennifer and sorry Cook's was not good.
i dunno... i think that even if david cook's was a little bland at least it sounded a lil more professuonal and he was in tune. i kinda think that the anthem should be sung the way it was written if you dont have complete control of your voice... vocalizing kinda kills it :S i still think archie's a great singer.
Hey, what happened to the clearer version of David A. singing the Star Spangled Banner? Did that version of his superior vocals get pulled like so many others? I wonder about that. I seem to remember way back that there was a video that had a gazillion views of David A. singing this song. What happened to it?
Oh, please! How can you tell if Archuletta was better? The crowd won't shut the hell up. And, hello, Cook DID won AI by 47 million more votes. Cook was better! When he sang w/ ZZ Top on the finale...well, God Bless America!
If you would like a free copy of David's new single, "CRUSH" from iTunes, but don't have the cash, please send an email to "team archie @ hotmail . com" (eliminate the spaces) Team Archie has organized a gifting campaign. Please indicate if you are a U.S. or international Archie in your email. Please help get the word out! Thank you!!
Get the word out, and keep his sales up. Your help is greatly appreciated. Lets make sure that EVERY SINGLE Archie gets a copy of CRUSH!!
Archuleta is in a whole different class than David Cook. He has an amazing quality to his voice. David Cook could only hope to be as good as Archuleta. David Archuleta will far exceed the success of David Cook.
I agree, Archie's version of the national anthem is way better than Cook's. David Cook was kinda tensed when he sang it - worried that he might mess up the lyrics (he said that after he performed it). It's really the hardest song to sing, I think - with complicated lyrics and all.
Depends on who you're comparing with.. if compared to crap like green day then yea.. but currently the most moving performance was delivered by Josh Groban..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I am a Cookie fan but I thought Archie and Sy did better in this But that doesn't mean Archie is better is better than Cook.More than 12 million people agree that Cook is better than Archie and I noe u might get mad @ me but lets look again....WHO WON AMERICAN IDOL!!!!
You can't be sure that more then 12 million people agreed that Cook was better then Archie. Voters were able to vote as many times as they pleased so Cook won by 12 million votes, not people. I'm fine with Cook winning though, they both deserved it.
dmgamboa - Please reread my comment. I said I was fine with Cook winning and that both of them deserved it. How is that being bitter? Someone posted a comment earlier saying more then 12 million people thought Cook was better then Archuleta, so I just wanted to tell them that Cook won by 12 million votes, not people.
My apologies! It was not meant for you. It was meant for the people who keep insisting that Archuleta should've won the title! Don't get me wrong, I like both of them Am fine either way who would've won I just am sick of people who still grumbles about how blahblahblah should've had this blahblahblah.
I do agree he sang it better than Cook. There you go: Proof I am not biased.
Young David's rendtion of SSB is really soothing... I felt the sincerity in his voice and he put a lot of soul on this. DA's version is definitely no doubt a MASTER CLASS!!!!
I'm really confused about why Cook fans would comment here, or Archuleta fans on Cook's video. Both guys are talented. I listen to this because I am an Archuleta fan, and I want to comment because I love it.
If DAvidCook had a chance, he will do it in his hot rocking way. but, its national anthem, it should be sang from the heart. and its so cool that David cook as rock star, understood the significance of the anthem. he just sang it the way it should be , giving full respect and love, NOt to sing it in a way that others expected him to do (which i don't find reasonable). David Cook will always be amazing to us. HE will always be loved, for his best and for his worst..for being the only DavidCook!
Grow up people!!!! Archie has weaknesses too. Archie would try to avoid all costs to sing impromptu or on the fly. Arch is a TRAINED singer. He cannot sing on the fly without practicing first and doing vocal warmups. He says that to his friends that he needs to warmup b4 singing. He was asked to sing the phonebook, Cook did but he didn't. He avoided singing on the fly at LK with the AI group. Archuleta CAN'T SING ON THE FLY & will try to avoid it at all costs. He has a team training him to sing.
get your facts straight. they sang the phone book on TRL & archie & cook both sang & both sounded great. archuleta isn't a trained singer. he does perform well under pressure, but what's wrong with that? it's because he LOVES to do it. and he's fantastic at it. so if you don't like it don't watch
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Folks...I really like Archuletta. But it's the NATIONAL F***ING ANTHEM. It's not a pop song. It's our nations anthem. It NEEDS to be sung AS WRITTEN. Archie is a great singer, no doubt. But there shouldn't BE a "version." This song is not about the performer. It's about the US. David Cook's was better because he sang it straight, unadorned and from the heart.
what are you talking about?? archie didnt change the song at all. he sang it just how it was written just with a few runs. cook's version was good too, but not b/c he sang it straight. it was good b/c he's a good singer...and so is archie.
archie was so better than cook but carrie underwood anthem was amazing just amazing and i love them but both finalist werent even close to carrie and daughtry
When I listen to Archie singing the SSB, I feel what he feels and I feel so proud for all American citizens. That shows how powerful his rendition is. Real extraordinary talent at so young an age.
My little bro is a Cook fan but he didn't like Cook's version and although he hated Archie he said it was "the best version he's ever heard." Now granted, he's only 11 but whatev! :)
I just listened to Cook sing the National Anthem. Then I listened to Archie sing the National Anthem. Wow!!!! No comparison!!! Cook did a very amateurish performance and, although Archie had a couple of dicey notes, his performance was far superior to Cook's. I really like David Cook and am not trying to discount his talent, but Archie is a true vocalist who always performs with passion and commitment!
Don't know why people disrespect singing the anthem like this by putting their own spin.
His voice was enhanced using echo w/ distortion. Old trick in the market. Singing the anthem is not a singing contest of who puts more runs. Hooray to those who sing the anthem the way it should be sung.
I agree with KristiB. He's an incredible singer and deserves cheers and such, but when someone is singing the National Anthem you respect America by staying silent until it's done.
boy o boy, somebody really dont admit that this guy really can sing...all the haters shut up. this only proves that archie is superb vocally than the other david...he was a complete messed( COOK)
Archie's voice is masked by the "echo" and it is muffled. I can still hear him go off tune, though, if you listen closely. It's the oldest trick in the book. Cook did not get the benifit of ANY echo. Go to david cook national anthem with echo if you don't believe me.
I'm a huge Cook fan but his version of the national anthem really sucked. There was absolutely no emotion in his performance. David Archuleta wins this battle hands down.
That is no excuse for cook's crappy performance. cook showed no emotion and sang (oh im sorry, screached) the song like he didnt even care. archuleta put all of his heart and soul into the song and the result was an amazing performance.
ARCHIE GOT ROBBED IN THE COMPETITION. HE DID A MUCH BETTER JOB ON THE NATIONAL ANTHEM THAN COOK DID
BUSDRIVER5532 10 months ago
@ 1:31 i thought a young girl was dying.
megancmeganf 2 years ago
@megancmeganf lol
Unknown2894 1 year ago
David Cooks is 10x better.
megancmeganf 2 years ago
Nice, real nice. I think Feferov did an amazing job too. He knocked it out the ball park, but remember, this song is not easy!!! The worst one in history---- remember her???
ClaylovesNC 2 years ago
The version of ARCHIE was great rather than cook and allen. But I like them all.
mackygerman29 2 years ago
i <3 u david cook...=)
jacenruiz 2 years ago
DAVID ARCHULETA and Jennifer Hudson are the only ones that sang this so beautifully. Adam Lambert's version is good but not like David Archuleta's or Jennifer and sorry Cook's was not good.
blueyesand 2 years ago
his version is so much better than david cook !!
you can't say it's not true!!
david Arculeta rocks!!!! and he is really cute=D
lovejacobblack 2 years ago 2
wow he makes David Cook look like TOTAL crappppp!!!!!!!!!!! he is so much betterrrrr
maggiesaysxRAWR 3 years ago
David Cook's was so much more off key, flat and toneless. If that is what you call professional, God help the profession!
linahandbasket 3 years ago 4
i dunno... i think that even if david cook's was a little bland at least it sounded a lil more professuonal and he was in tune. i kinda think that the anthem should be sung the way it was written if you dont have complete control of your voice... vocalizing kinda kills it :S i still think archie's a great singer.
G4B13 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david cook SUCKED
but archuleta was amaaaaaaaazing :)
made2adore 3 years ago
Amen!! :D
leah1597 3 years ago
Man David Cook's version really sucked...
fhenrique07 3 years ago 2
David A is much better!!
theMeganRshow 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david cook is so much better......
teeftaller7 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
teeftaller7 -- i agree!!
BlakeLewisXoX 3 years ago
EEPers!!!!!!!!!!!!
He's amazing!!!!!!!!!!!
bound4broadway94 3 years ago
david you are my role modele shy nice and i beautiful singer. i love you, sexy
!!
limegreen5555 3 years ago
i think he is so cute
AND HE IS BETTER!
destiny800 3 years ago
David Cooks version was good, but Archie's arrangement is beautiful!
danrdrewf 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I LOVE DAVID COOK!!!!!!
Ummm why did they have to add
echo to David Archuleta?? That is gay..
umm.. David Cook sang this accapella using
only his voice with no add in's like echo and
he had a silent crowd that wanted to listen to him.
I LOVE DAVID COOK!!!!! <3
casandramonster 3 years ago
i'm sorry, but doing the national anthem better doesn't prove someone's a better singer.
i dunno, david cook's version KIND OF grew on me..
but i like carrie underwood and jordin sparks' version the best..:)
29052604 3 years ago
he's gifted because he is talented with golden voice, besides he's handsome and the two characteristics is hard to find with a person..
that's why I love David!
djma26 3 years ago 2
Hey, what happened to the clearer version of David A. singing the Star Spangled Banner? Did that version of his superior vocals get pulled like so many others? I wonder about that. I seem to remember way back that there was a video that had a gazillion views of David A. singing this song. What happened to it?
rmanciaz 3 years ago
That was absolutely amazing!
jenbrady12 3 years ago 3
i got chills listening to arch's version..
pcmagazine 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh, please! How can you tell if Archuletta was better? The crowd won't shut the hell up. And, hello, Cook DID won AI by 47 million more votes. Cook was better! When he sang w/ ZZ Top on the finale...well, God Bless America!
r711z 3 years ago
he won by 12 million votes.
pcmagazine 3 years ago
oh, and, i don't think you heard cook's version of the star spangled banner. it was sort of..disappointing.
athousandpieces 3 years ago
Holy shit!! Cook SUCKED!!!! This one is 1,000,000 times better..go archuleta!! You should have won!!!!
UsernameBoobtube 3 years ago
Soo aqree witt thaa ppl whoo thouqhtt he wass better tann cook
Xclusivebabey12 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
If you would like a free copy of David's new single, "CRUSH" from iTunes, but don't have the cash, please send an email to "team archie @ hotmail . com" (eliminate the spaces) Team Archie has organized a gifting campaign. Please indicate if you are a U.S. or international Archie in your email. Please help get the word out! Thank you!!
Get the word out, and keep his sales up. Your help is greatly appreciated. Lets make sure that EVERY SINGLE Archie gets a copy of CRUSH!!
x0mGiLuVDaViDAx 3 years ago
David cook was way off key but this version is great.
mischiefpwns 3 years ago 4
this version puts cook version to shame.
pradafid 3 years ago 11
That was WAY better than cooks version.
CareBear31083 3 years ago 12
SO MUCH BETTER THAN COOKS!
sjhx123 3 years ago 8
that was very good.
raincheck7 3 years ago 5
cook is not better then archuleta, it just puts a better show, that doesnt make him the better singer.
petelebu 3 years ago
Archuleta is in a whole different class than David Cook. He has an amazing quality to his voice. David Cook could only hope to be as good as Archuleta. David Archuleta will far exceed the success of David Cook.
PatriotismRocks 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
no way! david cook has always been bettr than Archuleta...
jessasweetie 3 years ago
ya in your own mine
willtyt 3 years ago
Patriotismrocks: Agree with you 150%!!!!!
USA8869 3 years ago 3
I agree, Archie's version of the national anthem is way better than Cook's. David Cook was kinda tensed when he sang it - worried that he might mess up the lyrics (he said that after he performed it). It's really the hardest song to sing, I think - with complicated lyrics and all.
redjeans66 3 years ago 9
it is a very hard song to sing if youre a poor singer.
petelebu 3 years ago
ARCHULETA SHOULD HAVE WON IDOL......
tastemiDNA92 3 years ago 4
totally agreed.
petelebu 3 years ago
why the hell are people yelling while the national anthem is being played/sung? talk about disrespect
JThomasC08 3 years ago
Whoa, baby! The best singer of AI Season 7 by a mileeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee. Awesome!
rockyljp 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
obviously not. he was the runner up.
JThomasC08 3 years ago
yeah, like the best singer always wins AI, lol...go ahead, drink some more of AI's kool-aid
rockyljp 3 years ago 6
totally agree with you. lol
johnmarity 3 years ago
merci johnmarity, glad you don't like kool-aid either...
rockyljp 3 years ago
will do
JThomasC08 3 years ago
COOKFAN4LIFE BABY!
ErnieCardenasROXS 3 years ago
this guy is so much better than cooks. lol what a rip off
CUBANO76 3 years ago 5
Depends on who you're comparing with.. if compared to crap like green day then yea.. but currently the most moving performance was delivered by Josh Groban..
kaitachi 3 years ago
Archie sings SSB waaaaaaaaaaay better than anybody else...and please , no offense to Cook fans- 12 million votes do not mean 12 million people ..
applsauce03 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am a Cookie fan but I thought Archie and Sy did better in this But that doesn't mean Archie is better is better than Cook.More than 12 million people agree that Cook is better than Archie and I noe u might get mad @ me but lets look again....WHO WON AMERICAN IDOL!!!!
lilrachie05 3 years ago
You can't be sure that more then 12 million people agreed that Cook was better then Archie. Voters were able to vote as many times as they pleased so Cook won by 12 million votes, not people. I'm fine with Cook winning though, they both deserved it.
DavidArchuleta94 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Aw. Are you still bitter?
dmgamboa 3 years ago
dmgamboa - Please reread my comment. I said I was fine with Cook winning and that both of them deserved it. How is that being bitter? Someone posted a comment earlier saying more then 12 million people thought Cook was better then Archuleta, so I just wanted to tell them that Cook won by 12 million votes, not people.
DavidArchuleta94 3 years ago 2
My apologies! It was not meant for you. It was meant for the people who keep insisting that Archuleta should've won the title! Don't get me wrong, I like both of them Am fine either way who would've won I just am sick of people who still grumbles about how blahblahblah should've had this blahblahblah.
I do agree he sang it better than Cook. There you go: Proof I am not biased.
dmgamboa 3 years ago
ARCHIE!!!! WOWW!!!! This just proves more of a reason he should've won!!!
RaquelLuvsEliManning 3 years ago 3
Over 12 million votes do not agree, although David Archuleta is very talented and did a wonderful job on the National Anthem!!!!!!
Patjeanr 3 years ago
Yes!!! Archie sang this better!!!!!!
yelloworange2008 3 years ago 4
yep :)
banditontherun1024 3 years ago
alterspades is so wrong archuleta was much younger 2 but i did like syesha 2
tarah64 3 years ago
archadorable
sefabulus 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Young David's rendtion of SSB is really soothing... I felt the sincerity in his voice and he put a lot of soul on this. DA's version is definitely no doubt a MASTER CLASS!!!!
gems14 3 years ago 5
LOVE HIM! an amazing singer!! not to mention how adorable he is!!!!!!!!!!
OmGiTsMe615 3 years ago 13
i loooove him (:
Katieeex7 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Syesha was so much better than Archie on this anthem.
AlterSpades 3 years ago
sighhhhh i wish i was there
iloveearchuleta 3 years ago 11
I'm a cook fan........But Archie sang this song better than cook did.....
lalamandelala121 3 years ago 15
Same here.
BoxingTheStars16 3 years ago
David is good at EVERTHING!
KEEP SINGING Archie! :)
sarahwebkinzgirl 3 years ago 13
bravo! magnificent!
VANofficialCHANNEL 3 years ago 9
LITERALLY,
his singing gives me chills [:
mondep 3 years ago 9
lakers r gonna lose ;)
pinoycracker 3 years ago
This was pretty much amazing.
BasicallyMagnificent 3 years ago 7
I'm really confused about why Cook fans would comment here, or Archuleta fans on Cook's video. Both guys are talented. I listen to this because I am an Archuleta fan, and I want to comment because I love it.
KaitLMH 3 years ago 2
If DAvidCook had a chance, he will do it in his hot rocking way. but, its national anthem, it should be sang from the heart. and its so cool that David cook as rock star, understood the significance of the anthem. he just sang it the way it should be , giving full respect and love, NOt to sing it in a way that others expected him to do (which i don't find reasonable). David Cook will always be amazing to us. HE will always be loved, for his best and for his worst..for being the only DavidCook!
urep17 3 years ago
that has nothing to do with archie...
alyse411 3 years ago
you sound like youre pissing your pants at the end.
petelebu 3 years ago
Wow i was impressed
ever since i saw his audition on January 22nd i knew that he was going to be great! and he got 2nd!
Area831 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cook is so much BETTER!!!
wicked894 3 years ago
ya watever you fool
ahswarriors 3 years ago
Archuleta is the Bomb! So there.
ttpoling2 3 years ago 6
PSSSSH.... dilusional
alyse411 3 years ago
way way way better than Cook
pisanilover34 3 years ago 9
AMAZING!!!
soccersara122 3 years ago 4
Grow up people!!!! Archie has weaknesses too. Archie would try to avoid all costs to sing impromptu or on the fly. Arch is a TRAINED singer. He cannot sing on the fly without practicing first and doing vocal warmups. He says that to his friends that he needs to warmup b4 singing. He was asked to sing the phonebook, Cook did but he didn't. He avoided singing on the fly at LK with the AI group. Archuleta CAN'T SING ON THE FLY & will try to avoid it at all costs. He has a team training him to sing.
PinkFrostyDonut 3 years ago
But despite the weaknesses, the Cook fans love ARCHIE!!!!
PinkFrostyDonut 3 years ago
you should grow up. Odviously cook did not practice the NA, when he knew he was going to sing for such a big event, shame on him.
willtyt 3 years ago
get your facts straight. they sang the phone book on TRL & archie & cook both sang & both sounded great. archuleta isn't a trained singer. he does perform well under pressure, but what's wrong with that? it's because he LOVES to do it. and he's fantastic at it. so if you don't like it don't watch
alyse411 3 years ago 6
so much better then cook!!
ARCHULETAluvr 3 years ago 3
everyone changes it to fit their voices so shut up ppl!!
vickyvicks0 3 years ago
David Cook led the AI group in an a capella at Larry King
watch?v=LwmGh_C9Bdg
Also feel free to listen to the echo version at
watch?v=oE2HaHywU6s
PinkFrostyDonut 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what is going to happen to enchilada when his sack drops?
wing54 3 years ago
not good? I know, because DA is the best!!!!
gems14 3 years ago 2
Not good.
rainman0006 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Folks...I really like Archuletta. But it's the NATIONAL F***ING ANTHEM. It's not a pop song. It's our nations anthem. It NEEDS to be sung AS WRITTEN. Archie is a great singer, no doubt. But there shouldn't BE a "version." This song is not about the performer. It's about the US. David Cook's was better because he sang it straight, unadorned and from the heart.
Fiondel 3 years ago
what are you talking about?? archie didnt change the song at all. he sang it just how it was written just with a few runs. cook's version was good too, but not b/c he sang it straight. it was good b/c he's a good singer...and so is archie.
superVOLCOMlove 3 years ago
archie was so better than cook but carrie underwood anthem was amazing just amazing and i love them but both finalist werent even close to carrie and daughtry
tuse1991 3 years ago 2
When I listen to Archie singing the SSB, I feel what he feels and I feel so proud for all American citizens. That shows how powerful his rendition is. Real extraordinary talent at so young an age.
nonieang 3 years ago 2
His version is better than Cook maybe....but it is still not that amazing.
Listen to Carrie Underwood and Chris Daughtry's version of the NATIONAL ANthem..
THEY WERE AMAAAAAAAZING!
chatterbox1229 3 years ago
soooo breath taking. I luv Archie's version of NA better!!!!
gems14 3 years ago
My little bro is a Cook fan but he didn't like Cook's version and although he hated Archie he said it was "the best version he's ever heard." Now granted, he's only 11 but whatev! :)
otdtyh 3 years ago
I just listened to Cook sing the National Anthem. Then I listened to Archie sing the National Anthem. Wow!!!! No comparison!!! Cook did a very amateurish performance and, although Archie had a couple of dicey notes, his performance was far superior to Cook's. I really like David Cook and am not trying to discount his talent, but Archie is a true vocalist who always performs with passion and commitment!
okamispiderbrush 3 years ago
much more better performance than david cooks...this proves that david archuleta should have one...
xxXXSniper1XXxx 3 years ago 3
What's the buzz? This sounds sooo muffled. There were a lot of parts that he did not sing right.
-0:58
-1:09
-1:11
-1:23
Don't know why people disrespect singing the anthem like this by putting their own spin.
His voice was enhanced using echo w/ distortion. Old trick in the market. Singing the anthem is not a singing contest of who puts more runs. Hooray to those who sing the anthem the way it should be sung.
randomgen1161a 3 years ago
he's absolutly wonderful. im so dissapointed that he didnt win. but yahh know what? we all know he is better :)
Katieeex7 3 years ago
My ears bled at :59
rachxann12 3 years ago
mine bled from the first second i heard cook sang the NA
willtyt 3 years ago 3
AMAZING!
=]
cookiemonstertaryn 3 years ago
he should've won :-(
buffyrocz 3 years ago
Bravo to both of them....Those of you putting either of them down, YOU try to sing that song....
lgmorris 3 years ago
Oh man, the comment by davidarchie4ever is so RIGHT ON!!
slayter20 3 years ago
done just beautiful David a knockout for me
cb3858 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
There is no battle. Listen at 1:00 and tell me he isn't flat and tries to cover jazzing it up.
u8myapple 3 years ago
Beautiful tone, filled with passion, inspiring... just what you'd expect for a National Anthem rendition!!
fel2345 3 years ago 2
I agree with KristiB. He's an incredible singer and deserves cheers and such, but when someone is singing the National Anthem you respect America by staying silent until it's done.
Smallz04260 3 years ago
David Archuleta defines talent. He doesn't need all the loud music to accompany his voice.
maealo22 3 years ago 2
boy o boy, somebody really dont admit that this guy really can sing...all the haters shut up. this only proves that archie is superb vocally than the other david...he was a complete messed( COOK)
juvecutiepie 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Archie's voice is masked by the "echo" and it is muffled. I can still hear him go off tune, though, if you listen closely. It's the oldest trick in the book. Cook did not get the benifit of ANY echo. Go to david cook national anthem with echo if you don't believe me.
u8myapple 3 years ago
I'm a huge Cook fan but his version of the national anthem really sucked. There was absolutely no emotion in his performance. David Archuleta wins this battle hands down.
ziggy331 3 years ago 4
That is no excuse for cook's crappy performance. cook showed no emotion and sang (oh im sorry, screached) the song like he didnt even care. archuleta put all of his heart and soul into the song and the result was an amazing performance.
davidarchie4ever 3 years ago 4
a knockout!
nessle60 3 years ago 5
DC, this is how you should sing the National Anthem.
Archie, you are the voice!
kuykuy70 3 years ago 2
How stupid for young girls to be yelling for David Archuleta while he's paying tribute to our country. Very childish.
ItsKristiB 3 years ago
Now that's how you belt out the National anthem.
keyper2008 3 years ago 9
Enjoy this version ppl
watch?v=7o9h99RGtFQ
:)
flambere 3 years ago