The players on this and the flip side "I Knew I'd Want You" are Hal Blaine on drums, McGuinn, Jerry Cole and Bill Pittman on guitars, Larry Knechtel on bass and Leon Russell on electric piano (removed in the final mix)
Which guy is singing which part on the chorus? I know Roger McGuinn sings the lead during the verse but is Roger singing the high or low part on the chorus? Are there three vocal lines? I can only hear two vocal lines.
David Crosby is singing the high part and Roger's singing the low part I believe. There are two vocal lines, but Crosby's harmonies gives you the impression that there are three voices. Gene used to double Roger's vocal melodies.
oh wow what a find, loved this song for years, but this is great, never thought the Byrds could sound any better than they did, this is proving me wrong..oh just great..
If you take the "split mono" release, flip the phase and work the faders, you can get a vocals-only, or instruments-only version of this song, minus the added effects heard on the version here.
thank you for editing out the music im trying to find three seperate voices for harmonics.... my ear cant find the third voice... all i hear is the high harmony and the interval below.. i think its a diminished fith in the c major scale im not sure.... some one help please
There is a voice out effect on Adobe Audition 2.20 but I'm sure that software costs hundreds if not thousands of dollars. It includes a 120 track studio set up with auto sliders and the whole 9 yards.
this song still holds up so many years since its first release. Still brillant. I don't like a lot of american music but I admit this is still brillant!
What? Crosby told McGuinn that this Dylan song would never make it on the radio. Rog then did the intro with Bach and Beatles influences with his picking style on the 12-string Rick. He took an irritating dylan song and made it a hit. Also that is Rog singing lead. Clark,Clark, Hillman and Rog by themselves had more input than Crosby.
well, firstly, what HFB said, and secondly... none of the other Byrds actually played on this single. Hal Blaine played drums, either Larry Knechtel or Joe Osbourne played bass, Knechtel played electric piano, and the rhythm guitarist was either Jerry Cole or Glen Campbell. Only McGuinn's Rickenbacker marks the contribution of any Byrd to the backing track. Vocals were by Crosby, Clark and McGuinn (McGuinn taking the lead... and that was down to a toss of a coin, it seems).
lol if u listen close u can hear the playback on their headphones. If the mic picked that up, does that mess up the mix? Or does if just blend in when its all pieced together? Sorry I dont know that much about how music is made.
some people are more crazy than others about it. A little leakage is ok. Steve Miller does his vocals with the speakers up/no headphones. It's all one big sound in the end!
WOW!!!I have heard this song over many years but never w/o instruments. Now I know why The Byrds were my favorite in my teen years. Thanks for sharing...
Amazing -my hair is standing up after one hearing! what vocal effects are they using?seems to be a lot of echo or is it reverb?
Did they practise those harmonies a lot for the record and they always keep them the same live or did they improvise and find natural harmonies. I love the video of them live when Dylan Joins them for this song. They certainly seemed to adapt the harmonies to fit in with Bob. Keep posting
How did you separate the vocals from instruments? Do have a device that does it? If so, what is it? Love the vocal harmonies on this
LizzyisMichael 6 months ago
that is a lot of reverb, but it really makes a good vocal track,it gives the vocals a bigger feeling :D
jp0005jp 9 months ago
it would have been a hit this way
abt7217tc 10 months ago
This sounds soooooooooooo good.
brokenseatbelt 1 year ago
Yea, a McGuinn lead vocal and the ever present Crosby high-harmony but no mention of Gene Clarks voice ... humm
onceuponamidnightdry 1 year ago
jim mcguinn aka roger was a great vocalist
sukes58 1 year ago
@sukes58 It sounds like he is singing into the whole in his 12 string
spacepatrolman 1 year ago
soo trippy
scotfreak 1 year ago
This a cool way to listen to this great song. Very nice voices. Thanks for posting !
plastiqueadapte 1 year ago
This was a completely forgettable Bob Dylan song until Roger McGuinn and The Byrds got their hands on it. They turned into a classic for the ages.
TIMOTHYSAARINEN 1 year ago
Recorded January 20, 1965, between 10am-1pm (according to contract listed on Roger McGuinn's website)
steve7138 1 year ago
The players on this and the flip side "I Knew I'd Want You" are Hal Blaine on drums, McGuinn, Jerry Cole and Bill Pittman on guitars, Larry Knechtel on bass and Leon Russell on electric piano (removed in the final mix)
RP50 1 year ago
Comment removed
greenylespaul 1 year ago
Which guy is singing which part on the chorus? I know Roger McGuinn sings the lead during the verse but is Roger singing the high or low part on the chorus? Are there three vocal lines? I can only hear two vocal lines.
TumblingDice66 1 year ago
@TumblingDice66
David Crosby is singing the high part and Roger's singing the low part I believe. There are two vocal lines, but Crosby's harmonies gives you the impression that there are three voices. Gene used to double Roger's vocal melodies.
slayerized86 1 year ago
FANTASTIC!!
THANK YOU VERY MUCH!!
Lucenablues 1 year ago
oh wow what a find, loved this song for years, but this is great, never thought the Byrds could sound any better than they did, this is proving me wrong..oh just great..
ABITTERSWEETGIRL 1 year ago
Holy shit... Absolutely amazing harmony. Better than the Beatles.
RayManzarekGod 1 year ago
If you take the "split mono" release, flip the phase and work the faders, you can get a vocals-only, or instruments-only version of this song, minus the added effects heard on the version here.
mstax 1 year ago
Thank you so much for sharing this; especially in hearing how the vocals build up to create what are the great sounds in this song. Thank you!
~F~
frankfranklyn 2 years ago
thank you for editing out the music im trying to find three seperate voices for harmonics.... my ear cant find the third voice... all i hear is the high harmony and the interval below.. i think its a diminished fith in the c major scale im not sure.... some one help please
schlicktaco 2 years ago
There is a voice out effect on Adobe Audition 2.20 but I'm sure that software costs hundreds if not thousands of dollars. It includes a 120 track studio set up with auto sliders and the whole 9 yards.
djfisher3 2 years ago
Hey could yo u tell a program or effect to do this to any song.??/ please reply. thanks
devondirtbike 2 years ago
Mc Guin created a new jangle guitar sound ,instruments but coordinated with
their voices.
THE MAGIC VOICES OF THE BYRDS made the difference , and with a little help of a Syntheziser
nothing more nothing else
THE BYRDS SHOCKED THE WORLD IN THE MIDDLE OF BEATLEMANIA !!!!!
CANT YOU SEE IT , feel it ??
AWESOME !!!!
alex
Argentina
fangiopiacentini 2 years ago
It's a recording from the studio when they were making the song. The music hasn't been removed, it simply not there. This is so coooool to hear!
McPrfctday 2 years ago
Comment removed
aleecat75 2 years ago
I think it might just be "flanging" from a low bitrate. that sometimes happens with multi-generational versions of an upload.
jeffkahl 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my ears are happy
WWFHEAD 2 years ago
this is when bands had beautiful harmony and the melodies were of "light" and "shade", incredible time for music.
babystinky 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
ROGER MCGUINN IS EVIL
StAndrewtheapostle 2 years ago
no way partner...........the Devil is evil, the Byrds were just the opposite...........
pkappel006 2 years ago
cool man 5 stars,please tell me,how do you do this????
xbox360king94 2 years ago
click the fifth start below the video
dankmon1992 2 years ago
this song still holds up so many years since its first release. Still brillant. I don't like a lot of american music but I admit this is still brillant!
Dbusdriver71 2 years ago
To say the least, that was beautiful, man.
RockMusicLover73 2 years ago 2
omg it's so pretty.
eleana6018 2 years ago 2
so..how did this tape come to surface, i had always heard Byrds Masters were lost??????/
MrBruceBarham 2 years ago
It was a stroke of true originailty to combine folk with Bach on the chorus. And they would have been lost without DC. Sublime.
tfmuch 3 years ago
What? Crosby told McGuinn that this Dylan song would never make it on the radio. Rog then did the intro with Bach and Beatles influences with his picking style on the 12-string Rick. He took an irritating dylan song and made it a hit. Also that is Rog singing lead. Clark,Clark, Hillman and Rog by themselves had more input than Crosby.
Franzko787 2 years ago 2
He said that the song would never make it on the radio with the song's original 2/4 time signature.
And this song would just be...empty without his harmonies.
HIghFlyinByrd 2 years ago
@Franzko787 in irritating dylan song? fuck, its amazing
funkeyjunk 1 year ago
@funkeyjunk
No I meant Dylan's version sounded like Woody Guthrie. The Byrds version is so much better.
Franzko787 1 year ago
@Franzko787
well, firstly, what HFB said, and secondly... none of the other Byrds actually played on this single. Hal Blaine played drums, either Larry Knechtel or Joe Osbourne played bass, Knechtel played electric piano, and the rhythm guitarist was either Jerry Cole or Glen Campbell. Only McGuinn's Rickenbacker marks the contribution of any Byrd to the backing track. Vocals were by Crosby, Clark and McGuinn (McGuinn taking the lead... and that was down to a toss of a coin, it seems).
psychobollox 1 year ago
didn't realize the vocals went through a leslie! this is great!
frankothemountain 3 years ago
where did you get this? I want the files tooo!!! :-)
superherotrekkie 3 years ago
lol if u listen close u can hear the playback on their headphones. If the mic picked that up, does that mess up the mix? Or does if just blend in when its all pieced together? Sorry I dont know that much about how music is made.
Eric13Bravo 3 years ago
some people are more crazy than others about it. A little leakage is ok. Steve Miller does his vocals with the speakers up/no headphones. It's all one big sound in the end!
frankothemountain 3 years ago
type in &fmt=18 and it will come out in stereo
rockerdude59 3 years ago
WOW!!!I have heard this song over many years but never w/o instruments. Now I know why The Byrds were my favorite in my teen years. Thanks for sharing...
searching56 3 years ago 9
Very celestial sounding!
RoyFive 3 years ago
pure magic
windminister 3 years ago
January 20, 1965Mr. Tambourine Man (Takes 1-22)
I Knew I'd Want You (Backing Track)
April 14, 1965
It's No Use (Version 2 Seven Vocal Overdub Takes)
creb1101 3 years ago
I believe this 'bootleg CD' is available somewhere in Europe. I wanna get a copy.
creb1101 3 years ago
Count me in too. When they remixed it in stereo that was a day in rock history. If you play this out of phase, it is pure kariokee
rockerdude59 3 years ago
Amazing -my hair is standing up after one hearing! what vocal effects are they using?seems to be a lot of echo or is it reverb?
Did they practise those harmonies a lot for the record and they always keep them the same live or did they improvise and find natural harmonies. I love the video of them live when Dylan Joins them for this song. They certainly seemed to adapt the harmonies to fit in with Bob. Keep posting
bsteverobinson 3 years ago
Reverb/Stereo mix
METALisLOUDER 3 years ago
This song is pure beauty on at least five different levels... hearing it like this adds to that, strangely. Thank you.
lajillycat 3 years ago 2
I have heard this song many times but not like this. The harmony was fantastic. Thank you for posting it.
timjregan 3 years ago 2
Oh man this is f**king beautiful!!
My life is a bit better because of this... :P
Seriously, thanks, enormous thanks for sharing this!
sukrat69 3 years ago
And Gene's I guess...
gillesbertacco 3 years ago
his voice was recorded on the same track as the electric piano (something like that), so he isn't on this
HIghFlyinByrd 3 years ago