Shaykh Muhammad Hassan on Egyptian Riots and Protests - الشيخ محمد حسان

[IMnotSAS]

The dictators need an iron rod in the head.

[abdullahalmahmood]

may Allaah forgive him .ameen

[HwarangMujahideen]

Do Demonstration is haram in Islam?Pls enlighten me...

[IMnotSAS]

What is this imam saying? the corruption and kuf of the dictators in the arab lands is worse than some protests and ransacking. Give the people their rights to live in peace.

[MuslimYTEmirate]

@IMnotSAS

He is saying not to loot buildings and burn down public and private property. There is a major difference between that and simply protesting.

[IMnotSAS]

@MuslimYTEmirate

simple protest doenst get results, you have to hit them where it hurts.

[myyou1]

@IMnotSAS,

You misunderstood his message. Read the English subtitles starting @ 2:38 where is clearly supports the non-violent protests, saying :"I want to bring this from my own money to our pure, resistant youth, who are standing to express their views in a peaceful way, in a communicative way. And I am overjoyed that [scholars] of Al-Azhar have [declared it] obligatory upon the scholars to be with our youth and our sons, and to remind them of Allah, [Blessed] and Exalted. I salute them ...

[IMnotSAS]

@myyou1

Non violence in that lands of the Arabs doesnt work.

[myyou1]

@IMnotSAS,

Give the number of people involved and the violent attempts by the Mubarak secret police, I believe the Egyptian people have shown us an exemplary revolution. You probably haven't seen other revolutions where the people become very violent by looting and murders -- turning the revolution in to a fitna. As for the shaikh's warning against looting was the right reminder and it does not take away from his support for the brave youth of Egypt.

[IMnotSAS]

@myyou1

When an earthquake comes it doesnt ask "who is good? who is bad" it comes to destroy.

[e12sahimali]

@IMnotSAS we must follow what our religion teaches us. Because by allah, if these corrupted leaders cannot create a justic world for their people, then allah will see to it in the day of ressurection, The day of judgment. This also proves that if there was no god, then these corrupted leaders would pass the world unharmed and no justice would ever be found .But justice will be given, if not in this world thean the hearafter. How can two wrongs make a right brother?

[IMnotSAS]

@e12sahimali

Yes, you are right but Allah will not change the situation of a people until they change what is within themselves brother, and it is a good thing to change a thing with ones hand, word, or heart. It is like a ship, if the ones above do not give the ones at the bottom to drink, they will drill a hole to drink some water and then they will all sink.

[ronhaslam38]

@IMnotSAS They will never know peace under islam.

[marconi7711]

I love you in god O SHeikh Hassan

[ah8425]

Asalamualaikum,

Can you also add his other talk on this subject he did recently and also put the translation on aswell. Jazakallah Khairun

[feyza1993]

Excellent speech.

[coldicerose]

sorry to interrupt this conversation... just want to ask... does anybody know the name of person who recite the Quranic verse at the early part of this video?? 

[ALLAHU505AKBAR]

ALLAHU AKBAR!!!!

may Allah grant his blessings&protection to our brothers & sisters demonstrating in the streets of egypt and keep them on the path of goodness.

[TheMujahida90]

May Allah bless our Sheikh Mohammed Hassaan

And protect Egypt and all muslim countries from the evil of Western conspiracy

I have just watched Al Jazeera and they say that is probably the American embassy along with the Egyptian intelligence service that has run over the protesters! Because you cannot steal such a big car from the American embassy that is very well secured in Egypt. 14 people were run over! May Allah accept them as martyrs! la 7awla wala qowatta ila bilah

[juniid]

I dont know if islamicemirate could do a list of all the scholars who said that the one who rules without shari'a is a kâfir.

For most of us unfortunately, Quran and hadith are not enough.

JazakaAllâhu khairan.

[mrssamaha1]

For all those saying that one becomes a kaffir if they revolt against a ruler OR if they fight another Muslim ... Aisha (ra ) and Ali (ra), they fought each other and companions on both sides were killed. Is anyone prepared to say either of these two are kaffir ? Authu billah, may Allah make us stop this quarreling and focus on the main issue. This is what the enemies of Allah swt want us to do, to be so busy fighting one another, that we forget to fight the real enemy !! Wake up oh Ummah !!

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@OwaisbinAmir

Akhee you are being so hypocritical it is unbelievable, you are upset because I used an old saying to you, but you expect me to comment to you with flowers and chocolates when you have just called one of the 'Ulemaa of our times a Shaytaan?

Are you serious?

If you have these jaahil opinions, these destructive words, then keep them to yourself, but there are youth who will be influenced by your comments, like I used to 2/3 years ago, and you will mislead them!

Get real!

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul ok Now its time for me to put some smack down on the saudia leaders

that coward of a king, the hypocrite and scum of the Arab actually had the nerves to go to america and tell them to try and help Mubarak...

hope he has a slow death

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

akhee you talk like a 14 year old, honestly you have no right to call others cowards, especially when you call kings tyrants and support revolutions from the comfort of your house in a different country.

Typical from you people Allaahu Musta'an.

Look at you, is this the talk of a Muslim? a Muwwahid? to say that you wish a Muslim ruler has a slow death.

May Allaah guide you akhee, people like you are tough kids on the internet but are the most jaahil in reality.

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul so are you telling me that your queen fahd or queen abdullah isnt a coward????

you know nothing about me, you dont know nothing about my comforts but good to see that you assume that you know the unseen..looks like your the ignorant Jahil

I feel sorry for people like yourself who are like sheep ,,,you know nothing about Real ISLAM

I guess Imam Ahmed ibn Hanbal should have bowed down to the tyrants like you are doing.

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

I am not saying anything about them, I am choosing to be patient with them, and trying to improve myself and the Muslims so Allaah will change our situation.

You on the other hand insult them like a typical 14 year old on the internet, I bet you do nothing about it in real life?

Why not? Why dont you act upon what you say? Because you are either a coward or a hypocrite.

You call me a sheep yet youre the kid saying youre going to "lay the smackdown" on the rulers.

Just lol

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul Muhammed(p) said the one is is quiet against truth is a silent SHAYTANNNNNNNNNNN

so I suggest you start saying something...

who said I havnt acted upon it??? you see your still assuming your share powers with ALLAH

and by the way I suggest you read the hadith about if one sees a Munkar what they should do

if the least I do is with my heart then who are you to tell me that either I act upon it or shut up?? or are you claiming to have more wisdom then Muhammed(p)?

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

Brother, an honest question, how old are you?

Im not even trying to be rude, but your arguments have more holes than a sponge and you have no idea what you are talking about.

Much like what I was until I was around 18/19 [2 years ago]

I sent you a video by Shaykh al Albaanee raheemullaah, watch it inshaa'Allaah.

This talk between us is going nowhere because when I was young I was just as stubborn.

May Allaah Guide both of us and put us on the straight path.

Salaam 'Alaykum

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul well im 28 , so what now? does that make my comments any more wiser? if not then why even bother with my age?

yes I seen your video but question is have you seen the video? Sheikh al Albani said whats the point of standing aganst the ruler when you cant even stop his injustice or have him fall from his position

Guess what b0th LEADERS in tunis and egpyt have fallen

im not being stubborn im using Quran and SUNNA and your using your head and some fatwas of scholars

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

Its sad that with your age you have not gained much sense.

Yes I have seen the video.

In case you didnt know, hundreds of Muslims died in these protests akhee, if the deceased were from your family, [a'uthubillaah] would you like it? No! So why do you permit it for the Muslims in Egypt?

Bring me Qur'aan and Bring me hadeeth that you interpret yourself, I will bring you the 'Ulemaa of our age who have studied all their lives to respond.

Fear Allaah and be humble.

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul would I like my family member to die while speaking against a taghut?? hmmmmmmmm wow thats a hard one. they die standing for ISLAM or a regular death..well since im not a Jew I guess I would be thrilled if one of them died

and do not think that those who die in the cause of ALLAH are dead but they are alive with ALLAH

your just a young salafi whos been praying for 3 years now after a being a drunk or crackhead....after 2 years you will go back to your girls and drugs

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

loooooooooooooooooooooooool thank you for making this so much easier for me.

By Allaah I have never been as you have described me to be, and may Allaah save me from that!

I can just as easily insult you given what everyone has seen from you akhee, but you are still my brother and I forgive you for slandering me.

Thank you for showing the Muslims of YT the difference between me and you.

Alhamdulilaah now they can see for themselves.

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul OHHhhh SO i WAS WRONG???

I tried being like you and assuming and trying to know the unseen I guess I suck at it..unlike you its the first time I tried assuming I know the unseen...i'll leave that to you since your the expert then

[ah8425]

@TurbanzRus3 "your just a young salafi whos been praying for 3 years now after a being a drunk or crackhead....after 2 years you will go back to your girls and drugs"

No need for that bruva, were not all like that. I agree with Shiek Muhammad Hassan anyway.

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul Also Might I add...Sheikh alalbani said the youth should bascially worry about ISLAM and know there religion so tell me how will you do that when your ruler is oppressing ISLAM and the scholars who teach???

ISLAM isnt your toy that you can play with

just cause you have 2 fatwas doesnt mea I cant bring 2o fatwas from other scholars

btw tell me when the mahdi comes will you elect him or will he be born to a king or will he fight the ruler.....exactlyyyyyyyyyyyyyy­yyyy

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

Are you serious? The [previous] Ruler of Egypt stopped the Muslims from practising Islaam?

Where is the daleel? Where did he forbid them to pray?

You are basing your aqeedah from your emotions, you should seek knowledge instead.

Islaam is ORDERLY and DISCIPLINED not chaotic and revolutionary.

You can face Allaah with your words saying that you wish a Muslim ruler a slow and painful death.

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul so ISLAM is just prayer???

what hole have you been living in? he stopped many MUSLIMS from growing the beards, he was stoping Muslim women from wearing Niqab or are those not ISLAM????

so Imam Albani was wrong the revolution did force them to step down..he didnt mention a verse or hadith he said why do it since they wont even fall...but THEY DID FALL SO GAME OVER

[MuslimYTEmirate]

Ibn Uthaymeen said, "If these two conditions are met, then ruling by something other than that which Allah has revealed constitutes kufr which puts a person beyond the pale of Islam, because Allah says: "And whosoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed, such are the Kafiroon (i.e. disbelievers)" The authority of the ruler becomes INVALID and he has no right to be obeyed by the people; it becomes OBLIGATORY to FIGHT him and REMOVE HIM FROM POWER."

Majmoo' Fataawa Ibn 'Uthaymeen (2/118)

[MuslimYTEmirate]

It appears that some brothers are more concerned about their king (singular), and how long a man's thobe should be, rather than the oppression and slaughter of their brothers in faith.

There is no doubt in Mubarak not ruling and not wanting to rule by the law of Allah. If the words of Allah aren't clear in enough that this is an act of kufr, then read from the long list of scholars who said this is kufr and the Muslims are obligated to remove the ruler from power if certain conditions are met.

[abudujana13]

JAZAKALLAH KHAIRAN

[kabyle1234567]

al kilafa al islamiya !!!

[SonOfHassan]

Assalaamu Alaikum, the problem that almost makes me physically sick is to see Muslims who claim to represent our ummah standing in defence and commending taghout armies who are in the very least the backbone and overwhelming enforcers of the taghout system upon the people. And then with that forbidding the ummah from taking the wealth stored in state-run interest legalising banks and making claims that such wealth is that of the people. Ikhs upon such so-called scholars. I advise MYTE to remove

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@SonOfHassan

Who is defending him?

I am reminding as much as I can the people who declare takfeer on the rulers, by Allaah that is the most sickening disease that afflicts the Ummah!

Go and gain some 'ilm before you start mouthing off over the internet to rulers you jaahil!

Me and you are both jaahil so stop giving fataawa about taghaaweet.

Subhaan'Allaah may Allaah guide us.

[SonOfHassan]

@JihadOfTheSoul it seems that it is indeed you that is the jaahil in these matters as you declare not to know about them then place a judgement against those who have studied for years about these matters. Possibly lacking in knowledge that you are in this subject you will shut your mouth and study rather than speak out against people you don't even know as though your own father has been abused by such statements. Go gain some i'lm about these issues as I only speak of this from i'lm.

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@SonOfHassan

it seems you somehow got offended by me saying that we are both jaahil, in that case, in the next comment I reciever from you, tell me where you studied and who you studied under?

I am not mocking you, I am sincerely wanting to know where a person who claims not to be jaahil has studied.

I am waiting.

[SonOfHassan]

@JihadOfTheSoul second of all the term tawagheet implies the meaning of one who is a leader of kufr as he attributes to himself divine quality(s) of ALLAH (SwT). Hence if you refer to them as tawagheet and then describe them as believers then you're pretty much calling them kafir muslims.

[juniid]

Is ruling by kufr laws a minor kufr?:

opinions of Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen:

islam-qa. com / en/ ref/ 118135

A deep analysis of Ibn 'Abbas (RA)'s statement ''kufr duna kufr''

forums.islamicawakening. com / f18/ kufr-less-than-kufr-2831/ index2. html

Wa Allâhu a'lam, may He forgive any mistakes.

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid what is quite often misunderstood and misapplied is the understanding of the first statements on the forum. what does constitute kuf doona kufr. No.1 The narrations of Ibn Abbaas's statement are generally regarded as not being sound though their isnaad is fine.  One of my teachers who is a prolific muhaddith and student of the late Shaikh Ibn Uthaimeen (rA) mentioned that many of the narrations that are relied upon by Ali Al-Halabi are in fact weak due to Idraaj that can be found.

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid the idraaj points to the fact that many of the repetitions of the narrations attributed to Ibn Abbaas (rAa) do only in fact attribute the statement "It is kufr" to Ibn Abbaas, however the remainder of the matn whether "but not the kufr you are assuming", or "but not kufr in ALLAH and HIS books and HIS Messengers and His angels" are in fact attributed as an after comment made by taawoos (rAa). The suggestion that any of these narrations are authentic is horrific,will explain why next IA.

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid aside from the fact that Ali Halabi totally overlooks the matter of the weakness of these narrations is a mess that some ulemaa believe to be intentional and sinister as the implications for the creation of neo-salafi movement were significant i.e. the likes of spubs. Secondly, many focus on trying to prove this narration authentic in order to fit it with a specific agenda/hizbiyya yet the implications of it if it was authentic are horrendous. For example, Ali (rAa) was one of the...

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid ...was one of the ten mubashireen bil jannah (ten guaranteed paradise), one of those who rasool ALLAH (sAaws) praised highly above many others and one who rasool ALLAH (sAaws) foretole through wahi that he would be upon the truth. He was one of the khulafaa' ar-raashideen al-mahdiyyeen (rightly guided khulafaa') that rasool ALLAH (sAaws) told us to follow their sunnah (example). Last but not least he was the cousin and close companion of the prophet of ALLAH (sAaws) from the earliest.

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid The narration is set when Ibn Abbaas is supposedly sitting with the khawaarij who are accusing Ali (rAa) the Khalifah of Rasool ALLAH (sAaws) of major kufr for not finding the killers of Uthman (rAa) first. They accused him of disbelieving in ALLAH by abandoning ALLAH's judgement. In the eyes of Al-Halabi who claims the sanad is authentic, Ibn Abbaas is purported to have said that it was minor disbelief that Ali (rAa) had committed. Can we accept such slander against noble Ali (rAa)?

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid how can such a horrendous accusation be led against the honourable khaleefah of Rasool ALLAH (sAaws) Ali (rAa)? How could anyone from Ahl-us-Sunnah claim that Ali (rAa) might have committed or been acused to have committed the greatest sin possible - kufr doona kufr. A sin that is so close to the border of disbelief that it is referred to as the lesser disbelief. Anyone suggesting such an accusation is indeed not from Ahl-us-Sunnah to say the least and maybe should review their position

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid Furthermore, if we look into the narration correctly we may also ask the question, 'was Ibn Abbaas in this narration giving tafsir of the ayah that the khawaarij quoted (And whosoever does not judge by what ALLAH Has revealed...) 5:40? The answer is no, instead Ibn Abbaas would have been commenting on the actions of Ali (rAa) and giving tafseer to this ayah. Despite all of this, to my knowledge on this matter there have not been any narrations that can be verified to be authentic.

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid I would like to also point to the fact that anyone with any prior knowledge of aqeedah would know that by virtue of changing the ruling of ALLAH in any even single instant by legalising the forbidden or forbidding that which ALLAH has Legislated, or changing any finite ruling of ALLAH, indeed such an action is an act of kufr akbar (major disbelief) as that person has attributed to themselves a quality of ALLAH (SwT)'s Divinity as HE (SwT) and HE ALONE is the source of ALL Legislation.

[SonOfHassan]

@juniid Another point of interest that needs to be spoken of is a linguistic principle that the ulemaa' of tafsir laid down. Linguistically, when the term 'AL' is used in the Qur'an as a precursor to a description such as kaafiroon (disbelievers), thaalimoon (wrong doers/oppressors), faasiqoon (transgressors) then they are ONLY referring to the major form of that term and in the three above examples only to the disbelievers. This is not a matter of dispute amongst the ulemaa' of ahl-us-sunnah.

[juniid]

@SonOfHassan as salamu 'alaykum, jazakaAllâhu khairan for all these infos. So your saying that Ibn 'Abbas didnt actually say ''kufr duna kufr''? or ''not the kufr you think of...''? Allâhu a'lam, i heard also people who have our opinions but who say it's what he said except neo-salafis didnt understand it in context etc... Allâhu a'lam...

Also, i read in tafsir ibn katheer of my local masjid that the tafsir of 5:44 is very long, and there's not just Ibn 'Abbas's opinion.

[juniid]

i read this:

''Al-Hasan Al-Basri added that this Ayah also applies to us. `Abdur-Razzaq said that Ath-Thawri said that Mansur said that Ibrahim said that these Ayat, "Were revealed about the Children of Israel, and Allah accepted them for this Ummah.'' Ibn Jarir recorded this statement. ''

Wa Allâhu a'lam. 

[juniid]

Ibn Taymiyyah rahimahullah said:

"And the verses regarding the prohibition of taking the disbelievers as allies, explains that the one who does that, from those being addressed in the verse, becomes one of them. Meaning, the one who takes them as allies has apostatized from the Deen of al-Islam, and Islam is not harmed by that at all."

[Majmoo' il Fataawah Vol 18/291-305]

[juniid]

(1) Ibn Taymiyya also explained:

"Undoubtedly, whoever does not believe that it is obligatory to rule according to that which Allah has revealed to His Messenger is a Kafir, and whoever thinks it is permissible to rule among people according to his own opinions, turning away and not following which Allah has revealed is also a Kafir...So in matters which are common to the Ummah as a whole,...

[juniid]

(2) ...So in matters which are common to the Ummah as a whole, it is not permissible to rule or judge according to anything except the Quran and Sunnah. No one has the right to make the people follow the words of a scholar or Ameer or Shaykh or King. Whoever believes that he can judge between people according to any such thing, and does not judge between them according to the Quran and Sunnah is a Kafir."[Minhaj as-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah, 5/130-132]

[Muwahhida20]

@juniid JazaakAllahu khaira yaa akhi. Today so many ppl are claiming to be Muslims, but subhanAllah when u just mention ruling according Sharee'ah, or acting upon it, u see them unsatisfied with that idea, or unsatisfied with Allah's law or part of it... What's even worse are those ppl who have apparent look of Muslims who follows Sunnah, but subhanAllah when u just mention tawagheet of ppl today, or say that there is misguided 'ulama, or that there is 'ulama who sold their Akhirah for dunya...

[Muwahhida20]

@juniid ... they become the worst enemies of those who want to implement Allah's Message, which He sent to all of His messangers, 'alaihimussalaatu wassalaamu ajma'een. La hawla wa la quwwata illa billaah. I expect tht Mahdi is already born, just waiting for his appereance. May Allah protect all muslims all over the world and help them to achieve that level of sincerity so that they can do insha'Allaah as sahabah, radhiAllahu 'anhum, did in Battle of Badr. Allahumma amin!

[juniid]

@Muwahhida20 May Allâh guide us all back to the true islam and help us be the ansarullâh of this era.

Aameen

[Muwahhida20]

@juniid Ameen

[penkallli]

If a man come and says I want to annul the death penalty, allow christians becoming presidents, alow casinos, usury, porn, and he prays 5 daily Salah, fasts, gives zakah,

Will u allow him to rule the muslims ?!?!

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

Read the tafseer by Ibn 'Abbaas [radi Allaahu'an] on surah Maa'idah verse 44, then get back to me inshaa'Allaah.

As for me I dont base my aqeedah of my emotions, I base them from discipline and from order, not from being angry at the injustices we are facing.

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

Subhanallah !!!

Even if that meant kufr asgar, that means MAJOR SIN BORDERING KUFR AKBAR

So r u telling me, u would allow a fasiq to rule BEFORE TAKING THE GOVERNMENT STATING WHAT HES GOING TO DO ?!?!?! Im not talking about a fasiq thats already on power

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

you keep ignoring everything akhee, just leave this talk, this is not beneficial talk.

Spend your time reading books from the 'Ulemaa rather than airing opinions and probability based takfeer on youtube.

I already stated, I am a layman amongst the Muslims, I dont make any decisions, so dont ask me such things.

Perfect your salaah before you start trying to fix governments and start revolts.

Lets finish this conversation inshaa'Allaah.

May Allaah guide us

Salaam 'alaykum

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

Will u let a shia to rule ?!

Or a christian ?!

or a person on pray 5 daily prayers but allows porn ?!

= If u cant answer these questions directly I donw know whats left of ur deen to comprehend !!

[penkallli]

Secularism is in principle kufr, this is a fact and no1 talks about it, incredible !!!

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@OwaisbinAmir

Also

"May your head be rubbed in the dust"

is an old expression, are you not familiar with such old expressions?

By the way, did you want me to send you my love while you insult [or try to] the 'Ulemaa?

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@OwaisbinAmir

loooool apparently I dont have manners yet you are the one calling Shaykh Fawzaan a Shaytaan?

Allaahu Musta'an!

looooool akhee if you knew me in real life youd know im not afraid of anyone, and I have no problems discussing this with you in real.

Also, I never side against my brothers, so dont slander me.

You assume toooo much akhee, you should calm down.

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@OwaisbinAmir

May Allaah GUIDE you, you dare to bite the backs of the 'Ulemaa?

May your head be rubbed in the dust!

Learn your deen!

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

The Ulama can be corrupted and side with the wrong side !

Did Hajaj had his Ulama when he killed muslims !

Did the kalifa had ulama when he tortured IbnTaymiya

Where ther Ulama when the khalifa tortured Abu Hanifa

Where ther Ulama when the khalifa tortured IbnHanbel

Wher ther Ulama when Muhamed bin AbdulWahab was fought etc etc

--Actually many Ulama and muftis were against these people, they were on the side of the sultan and guess what... they got it wrong !

[dinelislam112]

@OwaisbinAmir allahu a3lam i dont know who to listen to but i do not agree with you about you talking about sheikh al fawzan, how could you call a scholar shaytaan?! a3udhubillah dont you know that the flesh of the scholar is poison?! so you have eaten the flesh of your brother who is a scholar, wich means you have eaten poison, ask fogiveness of allah ya akhi. mubarak could be a kafir allahu a3lam, im not gonna call people kufar cause im not a scholar myself. fear allah assalamu alaykoum

[evilheem]

@dinelislam112 May Allah reward you with good akhi for defending the honour of a imam from the imams of ahlus sunnah and may Allah make me and you upon those on the truth and may he rectify the state of our muslim brothers in egypt and elsewhere

[submissive2Allah]

Wow! quilliamfoundation(dot)org did a very good job at putting athaar(dot)org together very fancy website ;)

[ThinkAbout5]

JazzakumAllahkair for the translation!

May Allah swt reward you

[thepeacecat]

All the arab leaders, all governments are traitors and criminals, government is haram, Muhammed{peace be upon} lived his life fighting against authority against conformity.

[submissive2Allah]

Salam Alaykum, I agree with all the Bros. & Sis. in urging the Ulema to call for Khalifa and now is also the time to free the Bro. & Sis. from the secret prisons in Egypt and to find & free the Sis. who were taken and imprisoned by the christians.

[dinelislam112]

and look at what ibn taymiyya said about rulers being kafir or not (vid is on youtube) so im not sure if its allowed allahu a3lam, i heard that the alim of al azhar disliked the revolt, and what have other scholars said about this like saykh salih al fawzaan?

[evilheem]

@dinelislam112 shaykh Abdul-Rahman Al-Ajlaan, shaykh Saalih Al-Luhaydan , shaykh Shaykh Wasiullah ‘Abbaas, Shaykh ‘Uthmaan As-Saalimee, shaykh Muhammad bin ‘Abdul-Wahhaab Al-’Aqeel have all spoken out against the protests in egypt and how this is against the way of the salaf, for more information go on blog.athaar(dot)org

[TurbanzRus3]

@evilheem oh please , MUHAMMED(p) has spoken, you know our messenger who came with ISLAM

they are going against a tyrant, hosni mubarak isnt even a MUSLIM

why dont you study the situation before saying something is haram

[evilheem]

@TurbanzRus3 These are the statements of the scholars of islam and it it is the saying of the learned ones of this ummah, if you want raise this matter with them then do so but their stance on this issue is clear, its not my statement that this is halal or haram rather it is the sayings of the people of knowledge, it is not for me to debate with you on this issue but i will advice you to accept the sayings of the scholars, if you wish to debate, debate with them

[dinelislam112]

Ibn Teen narrates from al-Dawudi:

The scholars have stated that if one is able to remove a transgressing leader/ruler, without causing any Fitnah and oppression, then he should be removed, or else it is necessary to be patient. (Ibn Hajar, Fath al-Bari, Vol.13, P.11/12)

[dinelislam112]

isn't it haram to revolt against the muslim leader, ok there were some early muslims who revolted but maybe that were other stories cause those muslims were very knowledgeable and knew if he was a kafir leader or muslim.

[TurbanzRus3]

@dinelislam112 how is honsi MUSLIM?

it is haram to revolt as long as they dont stop you from practicing ISLAM and dont stop the spread of ISLAM

in egypt they were trying to ban the niqab, they took all pictures of hijabs from school book texts, they cracked down on most scholars torturing, killing and silencing them. they cracked down on Muslim men growing their beards....

and lets not talk about the raping of MUSLIM women in egypt by gov officials to intimated MUSLIMS

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

Fear Allaah!!

Who are you to delcare takfeer??

By Allaah you are a common youth amongst the Muslims and you are declaring leaders to be kuffaar???

Subhaan'Allaah stop this archair Scholarism!

Learn your deen!

Stop acting on your emotions, the Sunnah is not following your emotions!

[TurbanzRus3]

@JihadOfTheSoul dont worry bro I wont call your saudia kings kuffar...maybe thats what scaring you

you salafies call people Like Imam ANWAR ALAWAKI A KAFFIR but hosni Mubarak you want me to dear ALLAH loolz

I dont make takkfir on leaders such as preseident of yemen who is a theif but still Muslim, kings of saudia who are punks but still Muslim but hosni is a kaffir weather you choose to accept it or not

[KautharThalaba]

@TurbanzRus3 Its haram to kall a muslim a kafir full stop.

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@TurbanzRus3

Akhee, stop being a clown, who called him a kaafir? Give me on thing that says he is a kaafir?

You base your enitre life on your emotions, by Allaah you will not get anywhere with this mentality.

Islaam is a religion of ORDER and DISCIPLINE.

We dont destroy the wealth of others not do we participate in fitna, you have just delcared takfeer on Mubaarak, ask yourself.

Who in the world are you?

By Allaah you are a noone! Who will accept the opinion of an ignorant youth?

[spiritlite]

AsalaamuAlaykum, Alhamdulillah thanks for the translation,MashaAllah.

May Allah protect all our brothers & sisters , Ameen. JazakaAllah Khair.

[TheTruth500]

Masha'Allah, jazak Allah khair for the translation

[AbuMusaNiazi]

ameen ya RabalAlameen , we in fact are worried for our brothers and sisters in Egypt..may Allaah the Exalted preserve Honor of Muslims and may He our Rab sustain the youth....ameen

[MrDr77]

JazakAllah Khair Akhi

[WorldCapital1]

mashaAllah great words

anyone who wants to see LOTS of Egypt footage go to my channel inshaAllah

[penkallli]

All the previous butchers of islamic history ruled by sharia, were supported by muftis and scholars,

Now we have even clearer picture, secularists who dont want to rule by sharia, support kuffar against muslims, dont even pray 5 daily salah, oppressing muslims !!

How can God make it clearer than this as to who is on the right, AlQaeda or them !!!

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

Akhee who are you to say that they dont pray? Maybe they do or dont, but how do you know?

And are you seriously saying al Qaa'idah are on the right path?

Akhee you need to listen to the right people, dont follow emotions, the enemy of your enemy is not your friend.

Killing innocent people is not from Islaam.

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

Amazing how shallow ur thinking is !!!

A leader according to sharia has to be pious muslim, faqih, the leader leads the jumah and gives khutbah, so by default the secularists arent fit to rule !! They r nominal muslims ie. dont pray

If a leader whips my back Im gonna complain, if he continues than its another matter

I gave u the issue of Husayn the grandson of the prophet on purpose, he fought against the khalifa and killed other muslims in battle, yet hes guaranteed jannah

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

Akhee, ask yourself this question.

Who are you? Like me, you are noone in this ummah, me and you are nobody when it comes to declaring takfeer and making fataawa!

Akhee, humble yourself, stay away from fitna and just gain knowledge.

I swear by Allaah I used to think like you, it is not the correct way of thinking.

Dont try to fix the whole world with your own opinions, Islaam is orderly and requires the Muslims to be disciplined.

You are doing the opposite of that.

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

Im stating facts on the ground, historical gacts, Im in no way making takfir, or calling to kill some1

1. Ulama can be corrupted and side with the wrong side throughout history

2. Even in islamic system, dictators can arise as Hajaj

3. Secularists have a problem in aqida, in basic islamic beliefs, even if I dont make takfir on them, theyre not fit to rule by islamic standards that I stated

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

Akhee, I am not trying to be rude, but we need to ask ourselves this question, then it will make us humble inshaa'Allaah:

Who are you? Who have you studied under? Where have you studied? I dont get my aqeedah from YouTube comments brother.

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

Have I declared any fatwa ?!?!

WHat r u disagreeing with ?

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

"They r nominal muslims ie. dont pray"

Where is your daleel that they dont pray at all?

Im not asking for speculation, because that is backbiting, I am asking for rock solid proof.

You cannot get that therefore I advise me and you to fear Allaah and gain 'ilm instead of voicing ignorant opinions on the internet where younger ones are easily influenced.

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

As I said, the leader has to lead the prayer !!! If not the mosque, at least the employees in his building and give khutba !!

Since they arent religiously trained, not pious, actively working against establishment of sharia based system, allwoing interest etc etc, its fair to say that the probability of them praying 5 daily salah is veeeery low;

Even if they prayed 5 salah, they wouldnt be allowed to rule since theyre SECULAR, ie, they allow that Islam forbids BY DEFINITION

[penkallli]

"secularism may assert the right to be free from religious rule and teachings, and the right to freedom from governmental imposition of religion upon the people within a state that is neutral on matters of belief."

- This is plain kufr, by definition, Allah didnt make us free from him even in our governments !!!

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

THIS is the problem with the majority of Muslims today.

Thank you for showing the mentality akhee.

I asked you for PROOF, since Islaam is BASED on proof, and all you gave me was a probability?

Subhaan'Allaah, you declare people to be Kuffaar based on PROBABILITY?

Khalas there is no need for this to continue.

May Allaah Guide you and me and keep us away from wrong thinking.

I seek refuge with Allaah!

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

Incredible, so if a person allows usury, prostitution, cancels hudud laws etc, he'll be allowed to rule !?!?!

R u telling me, making lawful what Allah makes forbiden is just a SIN !?!?!?!

Please enlighten me with ur shcolars that teach u this new religion

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

Dont go answer my questions !

How come Husayn ra. killed muslims and rose against the khalifa yet he died shahid ?!?!

Answer the below question also please

[HumanRightsAU]

Mashallah. Allah akbar

[mohamed614]

mashallah

[Nuha383171]

JazakhAllah kheir for sharing!

[bestcookiefan55]

subhanallah! Important message. Thanks for posting. Jazakallah Khair

[JihadOfTheSoul]

A'uthubillaah! Look at all the fitaan that come from revolt! The wealth and blood of the Muslims is not preserved!

[ryukenb2k]

Salaam alaikum akhi. Ya akhi blood will be spilt standing up against munkar. Many sahaba's died fighting against kufr in hayati dunya. And Allah said he will not change a state of people unless they change themselves. And I have seen many muslims thrown into jail simply because th3ey spoke the truth. Ibn taymiyya(r) said that if the emir/leader of the muslimeen is da'eef or corrupt then they should be told to step down by the ulama or removed physically

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@ryukenb2k

wa 'alaykum salaam akhee.

Na'am Allaah will not change us until we change ourselves, when the Muslims are all praying fajr in jamaa'ah, when we return to the Sunnah, do you think Allaah will humiliate us?

Return to your deen and we will have our strength back, not through these protests, how do you expect victory when you dont follow the Sunnah?

[penkallli]

@JihadOfTheSoul

U must me joking, so Husayn ibn Ali the grandson of the prophet, who fought and killed other muslims and rose against the khalifa, is in HELL ?!?!?!

Abdullah ibn Zubayr ibn Awam who rose agaisnt a khalifa, tabeen, is in hell ?!?!?!

Or

Hajaj the butcher who was amir and ruled by "sharia" along with his ulama was protected by sharia to kill ?!?!?! maybe hes in heaven ?!?

The Amir who tortured IbnTaymiya along with his muftis r protected by sharia to do that ?!

[JihadOfTheSoul]

@penkallli

Im joking?

Fear Allaah never did I say he was in hellfire, akhee you need to learn your deen and dont base your actions off your emotions!

Be patient with the ruler even if he WHIPS YOUR BACK!

If your mother died [A'uthubillaah] from these protests then would you be happy with the sacrifice?

Of course not! So why do you accept it for your brothers??!