haylie duff _ halo ( new song cover)

[liihportilla4]

this is halo by bethany joy! the voice is distorced but is she!

[avataranime101]

This is Bethany Joy Galeotti.

[NicolasCorpus]

I like it !

[magdabilla]

bleee!!!!!, i love bethany joy 

[MissJonasbrothers4]

this isn't Haylie!!!!

[TheKendallJenner]

This isn't Haylie....

[andreadastoli]

@TheKendallJenner i know!! but i won't remove this!! ahaha!! =)

[LizziesTeamKesha17]

Ok This is not even Haylie u guys no dat so shut up!

[JaredPfan01]

Joy's version so much better!!!

[mememe449]

Ummm Hell No!!! Bethany Joy's is so much better.

[cgw1473]

this isnt even her voice.

[jhapjhip]

eww

[Court12021986]

urg...this is gross...Bethany joy's is like 5000 times better

[TheMileyHilaryFan]

What has she done with her voice?it has changed so much..good tho...

[cacafeia2]

omg i love this!

[MultiSteph14]

ohh dios!!! es asqueroso!!! parece una maldita ardilla!!!

Beth es mucho mejor!

[Monananinha]

Horrivel !!!

Se que imitar alguem como a Bethany imite direito

[ZoeWinter]

uh actually Iove the song sung by bethany..but that one....uh horrible......you have to have a strong, special voice to make it sound well...not the best choice for her

[deydeyyy1804]

horrible ! the voice is just horrible ! bethany is so much better

[lena83211]

Bethany Joy galeotti's song is such better!!!!!!!!

[thePCAshow]

This isnt even her, its just a higher version of the real one

[tamzi101]

i love the song one in this world by haylie duff every one should check it out

[rcgesh01]

URGH fuck her

it sounds like something reallly reallllllly ugly thats been edited to sound fake and sweet

she has BUTCHERED a perfectly good song the hideous fame whore

[XDaveoFalaveoX]

She'll never be her sister

[shaybean54]

I also remember that this song was on Haylie's own website..till they took it down from people saying that bethany joy's version was a lot better. unless that was all a joke....???

[shaybean54]

Joy's version is so better!

[hmichiru20]

m encanta esta cancion pero lo malo es q no la encuentro

[cheetahgalfan07]

Love this song Haylie well rocks

[thedevilwearsJUICY]

so fake...like what's that thing called? auto tune?

[EvilAvril]

Bethany is BETTER...i don't like her voice

[StylinPinkDancer]

She sounds so much like her sister!! I love 'em both!!

[9broncosgirl]

Bring back the original bethany is way better sorry hayley

[GossipGirl1990]

This is just Joy's version, edited.

[Sayaddina]

ew ...what the... why would anyone do this to Bethany's song!?!

[PurpleGlitterLove]

this is so not Haylie Duff!

[xxLaurenxxBabe]

it jst sounds like somebodys messed about with bethanys voice on those u things u can do music effacts with, either that or hilary is holding her nose while singing :/

[WyvernPride16]

it doesn's sound like haylie duff, and bethany is better

[MsPSawyer]

Bethany is better

[cantorwagnermally]

fake?????

[xitsmyobsession16]

hahah yeah dude this is so not haylie duff. this is definitely bethany joy but then like the voice is seriously changed with those technical thingies that I know nothing about :P but ahh i love the song, just not this version! =]

[neeettto]

love her, but i tought that Alvin and the chimpknunks were singing..

[nah07853]

nem se compara a bethany

bethany mil vezes melhor

[thenewlyingmirror]

hey this is so not Haylie Duff (: i've heard her thousands of times so I can tell

[realxgirls]

buena cancion !"!

[xsmellyjellytotx]

erm im sure this is bethany and its just in a higher pitch?

[nathan23091]

song with Bethany is better

[xMiesjee]

weird sound, but good song.

[destineyfaith101]

i like the original better

[BttrflyKisses925]

um yea its not haylie its bethany warped lol

[mizzklm]

this cover is awful compared to the Bethany Joy Galeotti's version i couldnt listen to more than a few seconds of it

[DoCoconutsMigrate]

This song gave me aids.

[humaira5678]

WEIRD SONG

[x3cyrusgoddess]

this is on sony vegas. its like bethany

chipmunked a little. -.-

[sarinharbd]

I prefer the voice of Bethany. The voice is stranger

[charmed9prue]

i think its truth but leave her shi didnt do that think if you were singing it you dont wanna that somebody says that you sings horrible

[prinstongirl08]

this dosents sounds like haylie she sings better the this

[WickedKiwi]

This isn't haylie duff. they changed the pitch of joy's version.

[xoxoxo1983]

I matched this song with Joy's and is the same they just changed the pitch of the voice but is Joy singing

[sarinharbd]

huahauhauhuaa. fala sério. quem foi q deixou essa menina gravar a música da bethany??? parece ateh akelas vozes q o pânico coloca pra zoar com o povo.

será q a Bethany já ouviu isso???

[igot2say]

oh my word!! No no no. Nobody can steal Bethany Joy's songs!

[miynu16]

can anybody tell her that she sounds like alvin and the chipmunks???

god she terrible!!!

[HalloAllemaalxxx]

wahaha i listed to it again and its true! she does sound like alvin and the chipmunks!

( ps sorry for my english i'm from holland and 13 so i'm not that good in english :$)

[miynu16]

haha ze is echt vreselijk!!  Ps je engels is goed hoor:P

[HalloAllemaalxxx]

haha dankjeeee :$

[cameronnx]

this isnt haylie duff, this is bethany singing, but her voice has been altered into a higher pitch :)

[poisongal]

It's horrible, of course. Bethany Joy, one and only, forever.

To me, however, this sounds like this is the original song with Bethany's voice in high pitch, like someone was just messing. Because every single tune sounds exactly the same, every word is sung exactly the same, only chipmunk-style.

I might be wrong, I don't know.

[ary1220]

My god... What has she done to Bethany's song? :S :O :(

[xkara08x]

if it is her singing (which i doubt) shes got nothing on bethany joy so...please dont let haylie duff ever cover this song. leave it to people who actually CAN sing

[xSetahnn]

She sounds like a chipmunk...

[tr33hillrocks]

argh bethany joy lenz is so much better

you fucktard

[GoesTheRain]

My GOD. My ears are BLEEDING.

I don't care if this is really her ugly voice or if its altered which I know it is to some extent, but honestly, I wouldn't alter the song like this to the pitch where DOGS could hear it from a mile away. And if I sounded this bad, God forbid I actually let the world see my act of butchering.

[GoesTheRain]

OMG. WHY is SHE singing this???

I can't believe she recorded this. She SUCKS. Screechy, uhhhggg! Its like listening to a Mozart masterpiece in helium if it had words...

Gross. Haylie Duff, back off and stay with your own disgusting failure shit.

BETHANY JOY GALOTTI::~~<@ <3

[maartjuuh]

Uhm, Hello, this isnt Haylie Duff singing.

[Cornelia189]

it sucks l m sorry...Bethany joy Galeotti for ever

[Jennybunny1991]

This isn´t haylie duff!!! I really love this the song halo but isn´t the really song and that isn´t haylie duff

[ClareSkater12]

if you dont like her songs dont listen

[neverburstintotears]

i agree with you...horrible!!

[nhxforever23]

OHHH MYY GOODNESSS!

bethany joy galeotti is SOOOOOOO much better :) :D

[TheNeNe92]

I love HILARY DUFF,because is a good singer and actres,buty her sisters is an orrible singer and actres!!!! Halo si a beautiful songs By bethany joy lenz galeotti!!,singing by Haley duff si ORRIBLEEE AND DISGUSTING!!!!

Haley PLEASE STOP!!!!STOP TO SINGING!!!!! pleeessaaassse!!!!

[Spewez]

that ISN'T actually Haylie singing you know....they altered the track

[lola2404]

horribleeeeeeeeeeeee

[haleyxnathen123]

wat da FUCK hayley duff doesant evan deserve 2 be in a song by bethany shes a stupid bith bethany is amazing

[hermoosaa]

DIIOOZAA coomoo zuu HEERMANAA !

[King7777777770]

whats with the high voice

[DefyingGravity44]

This isn't Haylie. It's Bethany's pitch changed.

Bethany beats Haylie whether the song is real or not.

[prinstongirl08]

Is this Haylie duff she sound diffrent

[xsomeyougiveawayx]

This is sooo not Bethany higher! This is horrible... Bethaaaany<3<3

[lholly007]

It's Horrible !!!

Bethany ♥

[bethaniiii]

omggggg.

bethany joy galeotti is SO much better

[lilangel3005]

You are all bunch of idiots...no offence but even if it isnt AS good as the original...I bet its better than what the majority of you all could do!

[kars1001]

this isnt haylie.. besides it being a bit higher it sounds exactly like bethany's version.. i really doubt that haylie duff did a cover on this song.

[caseylove19]

thats what i was thinking

[chelslynn08]

what...the...frack...?

[paz6413]

She sounds like a chipmunk.

[crazyovrnaley]

Wow...

...she sucks at knocking off Bethany Joy Galeotti, who is amazing in everyway.

[Leytonluvr107]

It's too screechy, my ears hurt. Bethany Joy Galeotti's version is 1000 times better

[tinkerbellkircubbin]

omw bethany's version is much better even if this is her onli higher as some ppl have been saying lol

this version is horrible dont ruin a good song yal theres no need

o an if any of you come accross any good beth joy songs let me know

luv yaz <3

[RUDEEY1234]

this aint haylie

wat the fuk was the point of this. it is a stupid video and wat r u even trying to do, r u trying to make fun of haylie or wat.

[mischabarton1995]

Nice attempt at faking Haylie Duff.

All you did was take Bethany`s song and raise the pitch a couple notches.

[latinabarbie1707]

No, unfortunately thats really haylie duff, this song was released about a year and a half ago. Its awful, way to butcher a song haylie.

[DefyingGravity44]

IF it was really released, why can't I find one on YouTube?

[latinabarbie1707]

then you arent searching it properly. Search "Halo - Bethany joy lenz" and you'll see the song came out back in 06 or somthing, and haylie had this song on her website about a year or two ago.

[bakagrl56]

ew

ew

ew

bethany joy galoetti is so much better

[cissilicious]

omg, not good!

[SuichiAi]

this is not Haylie`s voice...

[latinabarbie1707]

oh but it is.

[patricia3456]

beurk....

i like bethany's version

[srab55]

THIS IS HORRIBLE!!!

[rosiepep]

yo ppl!

i think its just like a bad copy

[tanjida2008]

u call this a song??? bethany joy lenz definitely rocks at this song...

[Jensenlover23]

Good attempt but I definiately prefere Bethany Joy Lenz version as it has more depth.

xx

[covermewithstarlight]

oh dear god.

[shaybeech]

she sounds like shes 12.

[BamAtticusFreegrove]

Bethany Joy ROCKS. Haylie Duff SUCKS. Simple as that.

[anissima9447]

this sounds like a 7 year old high on sugar. bethanys version is so much better. it suits the song.

[madforbooks]

This isn't Haylie, it sounds exactly like Bethany Joy's version only raised by a couple of tones.

[hanssenmartijn]

omg, this is not haylie duff !

haylie duff sings so mutch nicer

[xAngelPromisex]

Bethany Joy Lenz is way better! Its lower and Bethany's voice has some special quality in it. This is just a high squeak. It sounds so much better when Bethany sings it!!

[njoy93]

bethany joy's version is better

she has one of those annoying chipmunk american accent voices

its really high and disgusting

[skylarfly]

bethany joy lenz sings this song better!

[modernhippie27]

terrible it sounds like a chipmunk version!

[matt7799]

Hahahaha.

[nyxx1]

c'nul.

[WhiteHeartCherry]

This is not Haylie Duff singing. Or is it? It sounds more like Bethany Joy, but someone has make something with her vocie. The orginal is waaay better..

[xlive4totsx]

its not haylie, this has come up before.

it was on some"official" haylie site that didnt even spell her name right. loser. haha.

so yeahhh. it's not her.

[TwilightLover718]

I don't think anybody can do as good of job a as Bethany did with this song. I don't like Haylie singing it.

[0girlwiththecamera0]

this is NOT haylie! Haylie usually sounds better than this. this sounds like a higher version of bethany.

way to ruin a song, asshole!

[HarleyRae9ArtisNow]

people this is NOT haylie!! she doesnt sound like this at all!!

[Tutor23Girl]

WTF is this? This is Bethany's song and NO one can sing it better than her. ppl have got to stop copying her!

[lobster1192]

wow. this is really bad. it sounds totally different from the version that bethany joy sung. haylie just ruined the song. bethany joy's version is so much better.

[MytubeNotyourz]

Not Hay!

[xsuzumiyaharuhix]

boj¬¬

bethanmy jo canta muxo mejor esta tia tiene una voz d pito k no puede con ella!!!

suck her!

[BridgetDancer]

disgusting! Bethany Joy's original version is A MILLION times better!!!

[Maegmel]

wtf? THis is so f-ed up. THis is by Bethany Joy Lenz!! (but her version isn't chipmunky)

[popculturechica23]

Exactly! THIS IS NOT HAYLIE DUFF.

Jeeze people.

[craziichick435]

you people are so thick. its not even her

[Forevertreehill]

Je prefer ma joy damour

[dancingdevil87]

Its bethany joy galeotti sining but it's in a higher pitch he changed her voice or somthing right..

[marissa069]

that's terrible she sounds like a dying cat

[Noticethemusic]

Ik vind het mooier als Bethany het zingt.

Niet omdat ik Haylie niet mag, maar gewoon omdat ik dit niet vind klinken. Alhoewel, het klinkt wel grappig. Maar toch vind ik Bethany beter.

[iknowacatnamedbooty]

Wow, Bethany Joy's version is way better. This girl sounds like she was around helium.

[ALM123]

this is not Haylie Duff lol someone did just have some fun playing around with this recording!

[hansiibojj]

This is not a cover! Someone has just had some fun with it..

[WKLvr]

If that's really her voice it's baaaad. Doesn't suite her. Bethany Joy is hella better at singing it. It's her song for sure she owns it! (Joy) lol

[MrsTylerHiltonxoxo]

Is that really her? It kinda sounds like someone edited her voice to sound like one of those chipmunks voices. Not saying that andreadastoli did that, I'm just saying. I like Bethanys version way better. But I seriously didn't even know Haylie Duff wanted to sing. I thought she was more of the actress type.. interesting

[2onetreehill3]

HORRIBLE!!!!

[emma14watson]

SOUNDS HORRIBLE!!

JOYS SONG!!

[brookeisloved]

It's obvious someone edited the song which by the way sounds horrible.

I <3 this song but obviously not this crappy version.

[jjkvezzi]

That is so Joy singing it and someone took the time to make it sound like crap. It sounds too much like the version that Joy sang for the show but just distorted the cords would be diffrent and there would be diffrent pitches to haylie's voice

[blisteringeyes]

This is just disgusting. She sounds like a chipmunk.

[Jill163]

omg. i love bethany's version soooo much better.

Her voice is so high!

[hilduffsnumber1fan]

I LUV HAYLIE DUFF

[allofdisney]

yeah I agree, I much prefer Bethany's version.

[Amber890]

I sounds like a overdrive frog -.-

Bethany´s is much better

[armony64]

I love this song and lyrics but i hate this voice !!!! i prefer when it's bethany joy lenz sing !!!

[crosslyn]

this is absolutley horrrrrible.

[2onetreehill3]

This is so FAKE!!

[ajleeder19]

i think i'll stick to joy's version of this cover..... shes more attractive, a better singer, and a far more talented actress. i have to give hayley props for having the guts to put something like this out there in the open though....i'd be kinda embarassed.

[superlynksvp]

this doesnt sound like haylie, she has a deeper voice. If you want to see what she really sounds like listen to her in My Lips are Sealed

[2onetreehill3]

Horrible!!

[georgiakate10]

That Bethany Joy person sounds like a man at least haylie's version sounds like a girl is singing it.

[wheneverirun]

this is horrible!!!!! joys version is the best i cannot believe that she would even attempt to out do bethany joy, no one ever will!

[theocgurl121]

hahaa this is terrible how can she even be happy with it...she sounds like shes dying bethany was way better and she was amazing and haylie sucks ass

[potterizeme]

This is Joy's version! This is a disgrace to Joy's beautiful voice! The things that Joy's does with her voice, Haylie could NEVER pull off! Joy is a trained vocalist,Haylie is a chipmunk on Helium! I feel sorry for Joy!

[faithclone]

I don't think this is haylie duff, it sounds exactly like bethany's version but the voice is altered. If it is haylie, i really hope she doesn't put this in her album. bethany is way better

[MMAkat]

she is HORRID

[eveliendorien]

guess we found our new chipmunk...

[Ammie9193]

Exactly! The only musical difference between this and Bethany Joy's version is the fact that Haylie sounds like a chipmunk on helium. If you have to do a cover, at least do something differently. Except change the pitch.

[georgiakate10]

Is this going to be on walk the walk (haylies new album)??

[Ammie9193]

it's such a crime this got remade...

it sounds like some teenage barbie song..

i'm not happy.

bethany joy sings it so much better