Added: 5 years ago
From: glorious1
Views: 178,690
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (175)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Voice of a LEGEND.

  • what makes me happy is that UNDUBBED version is as good as DUBBED version :)

  • this has very bad quality..but her voice still sounds wonderfull. I think she just wanted everything to be perfect

  • mm iam very sad its regular i prefer the dubbed version

  • so this is undubbed

  • this is lovely...i like the song indeed

  • @CDionLive yes of course!! she is the one who wanted and still wants to dubb her dvd's and tv shows... and i agree with you, only the first vision and mtv unplugged aren't dubbed! check out my vid! ;)

  • @CDionlive i agree with u tht this was dubbed by mariahs choice. shes been a perfectionist since day 1. also i know mtv unplugged was 100% live but wasnt the first vision dubbed? for example the love takes time section, the last chorus where she sings "i just can't escape the pain" her singing doesnt match the footage.

  • MARIAH #1 LIVE singer & artist > celine #1 lipsync horse face

  • @CDionLive again i dont care what your subjective opinion is and your mouth stinks, wash it, you seem like another hardcore fan, just look at your user name loser. just look at yourself asocial noob, kiss my ass xoxo

  • @CDionLive listen i dont care what your subjective opinion is and you excuses the lipsyncer number two after britney, even madonna sings more LIVE! and celine had never hard songs again, NEVER! she has no songs on the level of mariah, whitney, barbara and if even a grandma could lipsynce celine same soundings tracks, alone these performance shows, why mariah is the best and why celine sound shitty, in my opinion next to her and no the concert was 100 % LIVE dubbed.

  • @CDionLive mariah last concert was completley 100 % LIVE, it was just dubbed her voice is rested and if you would be a fan, you would notice that, celine lipsync maybe more then 75/80 % of her shows. mariah sang on the christmas special 100 % LIVE, belts and songs are completely different the peformances are just dubbed and sorry she sang in her prime like a beast and the "christmas special" shows, if she lives healthy, she can belt like a beast in and would kill celine live. go and listen to c

  • @CDionLive yeah if mariah would trick her fans, she could do also more then 20000 hundred concerts in a year, not just 100 but her fans notice when she lips :D and mariah is REAL ARTIST who needs time to write albums to arrange her singles, produce them, sing them and she is not buying like in a market her songs & celines are sooooo fans delusional, excepting that she lips 75 % of her shows with bought amateur songs just because she just about the money and fame celine never be talented like mc

  • @CDionLive sorry, tell me did celine sings in her career hard songs like "make it happen" or "emotions"? over and over using 5 octaves and not just 3 octaves , hard low notes to whistles! for me mariah is and will be forever more vocal gifted and better artist over all. for me celine is to nasal and i prefer singers like mariah, aretha, whit!

  • @CDionLive celine lipped beginning 90´s and mariah beginning 2000 aulthough mariah vocals are more difficult all the hard low notes mixed with high belts, whistles exspecially in the "daydream" tour a lot of g5/g#5

  • @CDionLive ok but you forgot during this period mariah was married to MR MOTTOLA, she was "sing sing" right here...do you think if she refused, it would have been all peaches and cream. she lip syncs on t.v shows not DUBB her voice...she didnt' do it for her emancipation of mimi tour. but she did do it for her "around the world" collection i think tommy forced her.

  • OK, it's not perfect like the dubbed version (She didn't hit the high note at 3:11) but it's still AWESOME and GREAT. I don't know any singer that could sing better than her!!! Mariah's the best!!

  • She makes me cry !!!

  • @drunkdivamariahcarey yup..this is an undubbed version

  • She was so beautiful before she got those huge gazongas

  • I think Mariah still has a lot of the 'old' Mariah essence that many lambs miss dearly. She enchants the audience so much that there's the endearment effect, and I love how she performs everytime in MSG - every moment makes it a worthy concert! The nodules take much effect, but with Angels' Adovacate 2010, most of her is back! We have the powerful belting and the whistling range, and with JD they've probably got the next #1 hit single up and ready. Love Mariah.

  • I love how Mariah twisted it @ 3:34!

  • love

  • it´s beatifull!!!!! i like!! very i like!! i love God!!!

  • her eyes sparkles way back then. . but now she looks very shy and stiff in live performances.. . she really feels her voice changed alot and she doesnt wnt what hapend to it. . still, i like her alot very much. . our bday is near btw. . on 28 of march = )

  • Gostei !

  • she is amazing...i love her voice so much.. :) !

  • what a difference the way she used to sing and the way she sings now... she's lost a lot of her voice. I used to luv her music , but now ..it's just not the same, it's more about being sexy than showing the talent she has.

  • My 'nonsense' was directed at someone below who said something like everyone dubs or this is lipsynched not dubbed lol, I was not saying nonsense to the video rofl, I was the person who placed the audio on it in the first place.

  • well, at least the sound of the audience is not as bloody as this...and seeing and hearing the quality of the audio of this video, the undubbed version...i think they really had to do it...i think, they had problems recording mimi's concerts that resulted in low audio quality...

    but i like the undubbed versions more! her live performances are actually way better

  • @Libogzxh Though this isn't audio that sony taped, this is from a camcorder in the audience, I dubbed it onto the Sony video. Sony's recording of the audio was probably fine that's not the issue, Mariah etc. probably just wanted it studio quality perfect vocals.

  • ah...so this is the REAL audio of the the REAL live perf? this one is actually better than the Sony's audio(of course Sony's is clearer, but mariah sounds better here)

  • @Libogzxh mariah would have sounded just as clear! matter of fact better.....it had mroe heart into it..

  • @LILRuthlessplaya88 Mariah sounded better LIVE than the dubbed version of Sony

  • @LILRuthlessplaya88 And yes, Mariah sounds more soulful when Live

  • @Libogzxh yes she does the undubbed version's mariah puts her heart into and then sony goes and covers it with these...and i love them shes a beautiful singer...but it feels dissconnected from the audience...why sony? mariah's a great singer a emotional singer and they should have left it....no need to dub a queen when she proves herself...

  • @LILRuthlessplaya88 absolutely!

  • @Libogzxh do not be fooled mariah sound better in thedubbed version she no make g#5 here

  • @esteban55200 of course mariah TECHNICALLY sounds better in the dubbed version but when i say "better" it means that she's more connected to the audience and that's how you can say she's feeling the song...got it?

  • @esteban55200 maybe because the g#5 is in  the tokyo dome performance..

  • @sonekkinha Yess! in tokyo version 1996 she does g5 (its no g#5) note also in peace officer's memorial service 1996 she is wonderful :)

  • @CDionLive well they have to bud the DVD releases so they can sell it...audience is so freaking noisy and i think that's the reason why they need to do so...to have a better audio quality...but i like the undubbed versions more

  • her undubbed versions are very tasteful!!... love the rawness of the voice!! cool beans....

  • she is so great!!!!!sad also coz she had her nodules worsen..hmp..anyways..she sang her songs with such feelings..that makes my mariah great!!hehe

  • She must be the most beatiful girl ever

  • I Love You!!!

  • I Love You

  • when I tired I will listen this song.

    It's my strength

    when I heard this song I will feel I'm a big girl!!~

    I don't know why?

    the meaning of this song is remain in my heart... and I know I can survive!!~

    I love this song so much!!

  • this is not undubbed, it's more like someone else recorded it from the crowd and the video was attached to that audio

  • This is undubbed, because the one that you see from the DVD version is very different compared to this "undubbed" version. Some notes are changed.

  • Yes there is camcorder footage (not mine) and I made this video originally by taking the audio from that and pairing it with this... it's far easier to call it undubbed than Hero - MSG (using audio someone else recorded it from the crowd and the sony video to recreate the original etc).... lol ;-)

  • It's not directly undubbed but you can call it "undubbed".

  • What does it actually mean when they 'dub' a concert? Does she sing it again? or what?

  • live performances like these (in front of thousands and on tour) are usually dubbed or edited purely to improve sound quality, no matter who the artist is.

  • :34-:37 is so beautiful how she sings "theres an answeeeeer"

  • and this was the first time she did 'the way' differently.

  • lol she hadn't fully invented the different arrangement by then!

  • u should watch this: /watch?v=jmMBXOyRFWg

  • Mariah Carey is a lagend!

  • "I WISH YOU WELL" is from the E=MC2 CD..NOT!! 4rm TEOM..

  • vos quisiste decir "I wish you knew"

  • this version is so much better than the whiny version they dubbed onto the DVD

  • i think Mariah's nodules are affecting her mid-voice and upper register belting, but her tone is actually richer which is surprising, and her whistles are better than before, she can also hit lower notes its very weird. I bet if she removes those nodules she'll be super powerful but she is an alto with soprano capabilities she might lose a lot of range since they are a result of those nodules....they should have pics of them from the past, they should try to reduce them to make them look similar

  • are u kidding? check out the adventure of mimi tour, vision of love specifically to hear those whistles.

  • @JPhillippeMusic have you noticed what happened to whhiteny's voice after vocal surgery? it ruined her actual SPEAKING voice, as well as singing.

    i disagree that her voice & whistles are better. They're a TAD bit worse...look up angels advocate tour emotions, she sort of struggles with the high notes.. For her age, however, her voice has stayed relatively the same, which is near amazing.

  • @SERTYG well it depends on the person, some are lucky some aren't. Justin Timberlake might not be the mega vocalist but he had he's nodules removed and recovered his old voice back. I do think Mariah's whistles are great and I disagree I was in the angel's advocate tour and the whistles sounded amazing. Judging by the whistles in emotions, those were pre-recorded and sounded relatively low but none the less on pitch and rich sounding.

  • @SERTYG ugh whitney never had surgery she damaged her voice in 94 when her doctors ordered her to take a break from touring to recover...which is what gave whit the deep dark sultry voice...and if you want to argue and say she had surgery i want the article link posted....

  • @JPhillippeMusic i think alot of people read your comment and then lookt up what the word nodule meant..lol i kno i did

  • @JPhillippeMusic If they remove her nodules, there's a serious chance that she could loose her voice forever...

    She can still hit all of these notes...she just needs more rest and more time to prepare

  • @JPhillippeMusic can anybody explain what is ';nodules" ????i dont speak english and i dont understand 6this world

  • @Beautyelenas It is a part of your voice box that helps you speak and sing.

  • she's so beautiful,..

    Why did she need to dub this? This is amzaing!

  • I totally agree!!

  • record label not her.

  • oh yeah

  • about it being alcohol that is lol

  • you are the bullshitter... it is unknowable what caused her voice to change... a major change happened very quickly and then things deteriorated even more... what makes you think you're so sure?????????????????

  • its because of the nodule that she is having.

  • she had her TONSSILS removed , that why, anyone who sings and has their TONSSILS removed have less used of Vibrato and range changes, and she is a woman which means that she has her period, like she and whitney said on Oprah, that their voice lowers an octave or 2, most of the time cuz they have their periods, and mariah used diffnrt styles, with each album and she uses the same style in the album to sing her songs........

  • its live. those people saying she's lip synching pls make a good hearing check.

  • 3:10,

    whoa!

    as in WHOAAAA!.

    she made it so high.

    ariiiiiba!

    yes,Lord knows.

    that's why He sent you here.

  • i wish she still sang like this. she CAN NOT sing like this anymore and it makes me sad =(

    her best vocal years lasted until the Butterfly album.

  • her her new album on youtube, search songs like ' stay in love' , she is stillthe same these days..........

  • Mariah Carey - Tokyo Dome 1996 Concert Compilation

    The Best Singer Period!

  • pre-recording did not happen at any time during this concert, it was live, then dubbed after.

  • wat r u talking about dat she can sing???!!! of course and absolutely she can sing because shes a legend..,,, i have no words to describe mariah but thers only 1 shes a "LEGEND"!!!!

  • This is definitely not dubbed. The last high note is different from the official video. WOW. Mariah Carey can really sing.

  • ONE WORD 2 DESCRIBE MARIAH:LEGENDARY

  • I always wondered if those really high belts toward the end of this performance were too good to be true...I guess so!

  • remember they're not too good to be true in the way that she still sang them, it doesn't matter to me that they were in the studio lol

  • You know what, I thought the same thing after I made my comment so your point is well taken :-D

  • lol cool!

  • best hero live performance!

  • I don't think 96 was her best, but it was really good!

  • i think glitter era was her best vocally.

  • Not reALLY, yes, she was amazing on glitter era but her best was Music Box era I think... on 2000's she was singing really good but lower, in 93 94 she sings sooo strong, so high, so deep... Whatever, she's the one and only, isn't she? =)

  • can anyone please put up the other undubbed performances in this concert?? but in this video quality, not the fan recordings coz this one has better audio.. id really like to see all of the undubbed versions

  • Actually the audio from this IS from the fan recording. I made this video, you see, and dubbed the camcorder audio onto the DVD/VHS video.

  • oh, thank you 4 making this! well it looks a lot better than the fan recording hehe.. it's a great song.. love it much

    have a great day

  • That explains some of the hiss that I hear. I thought it was my headphone connection and I kept pulling it out and back in trying to stop it.

  • i love this!! undubbed and still beautiful.. love it

  • i love how she sings this song live

  • what i am trying to say is that on the DVD, they didnt put up some of the real audio from the performance..!, get it..?, try to compare the actual live performance taken from a fans cam recorder from the dvd and you'll hear the difference..!

  • im prefering to her vocals and the notes she is hitting, ..!

  • i hope they make a version of this dvd with jsut all natural performances

  • it 's a great performance ! it will be even greater if the sound from the audience is supressed !

  • My favorite song from Mariah Carey. Got me through a lot when it came out on the radio back in the early 90's.

  • This is even better than DVD version!!

  • the best song the all times and the best singer the all times

  • THIS IS A BETTER VERSION.

  • wow !! her voice here is much better than in the DVD, I think !!

  • very good

  • Check out my "Hero";D

    You´ll be surprised!

    Much Love, Tuana

  • not better than mine

  • OMG, this is great! Now I hate the dubbed version. It sounded too perfect in the DVD...

  • LOL you managed to keep this recording for 12 years???

  • he did lol

  • My HERO!!! :X

  • It's my favorite hero's performance. her voice is so beautiful.

  • Why is the audio quality suck so much here?

  • the audio of this video is the real recording taken from the concert from the audience..., thats why it sounded differently...!

  • the best thing about mariah is that she can sing her songs in ways u never thought are possible..hehe...she's the greatest! I love her!

  • i wish they had never dubbed the dvd version

  • she looks prettttty

  • its totally different from the dvd... i thought that was live but they just dubb it...

  • can't blame them since all these morons are screaming their heads off

  • loooooooooooooooooooooollll

  • lmao....

  • she is singing live, wth are you talking about?

  • im not saying that all parts of it were dubbed, some of it only..,

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more