Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Though I like Dionne Warwick's version better---she's got a better voice---it's still *amazing* to see this original recording.

    Such an incredible song. The combination of musical complexity and lyrical honesty are breathtaking...

  • This is true vocal talent and musicality that you rarely hear these days with what passes for 'singing' now. Beyonce, One Direction, need I go on. :)

  • She's no Dionne Warwick! Dionne brought the "magic" of her truer emotional range purveyed in captivating melodic nuances and in her singular voice and dramatic interpretations. Vocal power alone (as in a roar) is not art. Cilla's voice (like British food) ... authoritative yet bland.

  • @JudgeJulieLit Totally disagree! I like Dionne Warwick and Cilla Black. But Cilla Black sung this song in the only way it should be sung about the character in question, that was Alfie. She sings it with raw emotion and no one in my view sings this song better than Cilla Black. A very underrated vocalist in my oipnion.

  • @MsNerin26 Hmm ... okay, I'll try to see the film Alfie (original c. 1965)--likely you make a good point. And hear other Cilla songs. Thanks for your input ... and (from back then) the Beatles themselves share your enthusiasm for her. Have a fab day.

  • @JudgeJulieLit Yes do watch the original film Alfie that starred Michael Caine. He played this cad character brilliantly and Cilla's version of this lovely song really for me, set the tone of the film and I think she sings the song with the true pathos needed for the movie story.

  • A different era but Whitney, who sadly passed away today, had the same power in her voice. This is Cilla very early in her career given a golden chance to show her wares and she does just that. A brilliant performance that compliments that of Michael Caine in the title role of the movie. Essential 60's stuff - not to be missed.

  • A BEAUTIFUL SONG! By Cilla, In The Studio Burt Bacharach Made Cilla Sing This Song Over & Over Again Coz He Was Not Happy With It Then George Martin Said ''Burt What Is It That Your Looking For?'' Burt Said ''I'm Looking For That Magic Sound'' And George Simply Said ''That Magic You Are Looking For Was On Take 4'' And Take 4 Ladies & Gentlemen Is The Take You Hear Today

  • Cilla startles me everytime she hits the high notes starting with the line "What's it ALL aBOUT when you sort it out Alfie " HAHA<, My vote for the best version of Alfie goes to Dionne Warwick. hands down.

  • It's pretty good

  • Cilla Black will always be for me one of the 60s' great singers."Alfie"was the first ballad she'd ever tackled and she nailed it. Yes, the sessions were an ordeal for everyone because Bacharach is a perfectionist, but look at the results he got! Stunning, moving performance which hits that emotional chord perfectly. And check out what Bacharach brought out in Dusty Springfield when she sang Ä House Is Not A Home"alongside him - magic.

  • clair magire

  • My dogs name is Alfie

  • sh e was so b etter than Barbra streisand.....not evn close. this woman was soooo underrated. she was one of the greatest singers EVER!

  • cher was good too, dont forget her

  • My take on the Cilla/Dionne debate: First and foremost, I'm an American and a huge Dionne Warwick fan. Like most Americans, until recently I didn't even know who Cilla Black was. Both versions are breathtaking. The phrasing and technique belong to Dionne, but the emotion goes to Cilla. I'll put it this way: Warwick's version gives me the chills. But Cilla's version brings me to tears. So I'll have to say that this song belongs to Cilla Black, with Dionne Warwick coming in a VERY close second.

  • OK but most importantly - she does that thing - she suddenly transforms the power in her voice - the power ! - she suddenly blows all and everything into the weeds. I have never heard anyone describe what she does and when she does that. They all talk about her technically but she is / was inique. What was that POWER. She got the power ! POWER

  • why do people leave horrible postings ? oh yea, because they are horrible. Seemples

  • Oh Cilla

  • Oh come on you lot. This was Cillas nemesis. She HAD to give it her all and she did. Was it perfect ? Yes. It has been perfect ever since and so has she. But, personaly I thought her Anyone who had a heart was the most heart rending thing I have ever heard and it still is. I love you Cilla ! xx

  • @unclenora Who was Cilla's nemesis?

  • She is amazing. Wow.

  • @universityofwtmp You sir, GET IT!!!.... +1

  • Good song, She sang it very well.

    A title song sang by Millicent Martin in the film Alfie (1966) starring Michael Caine, Shelley Winters, Millicent Martin, Julia Foster and Jane Asher. Jane was once engaged to Paul McCartney.It was also nominated Best Song for the Academy Awards. 

  • Cher, Warwick, Streisand et al might have made versions that were technically superior, but the sheer emotion that Cilla puts into this is what does it for me. No-one else can switch from angry to wistful and pleading in quite the same way.

    Plus Cilla doesn't just sing - she inhabits the song. You can easily imagine her having been used and discarded by Alfie. Those others, to me, are incapable of being convincing in such a role. Behind their performances, you know they're really hard cases.

  • @Krzyszczynski Agreed. Cilla perhaps wasn't the most technically proficient singer of this track, but her emotional outpouring on this performance pulls on the heartstrings and elevates the song to another level. There's a certain vulnerability in her voice that almost brings me to tears.

  • absolute charm cilla and burt.

  • I never heard of her until today. I think this song is perfect for her.

    I really don't like her singing on most of her other videos. She tends to wail, go off key and under enunciate.

    Maybe Bacharach encouraged her to over enunciate on this one. It feels weird to over enunciate, but it does a lot to keep the voice open and the singer on track. As long as you have a good voice to start with. Otherwise, people will just smile and say, "Oh, how nice." Or throw rocks at you.

  • @PinkLederhosen I believe he made her do 17 takes of this and she hated the entire experience. I think she had a great voice but Burt , perhaps being american, made her emphasise her "englishness" - when at the time most pop singers (including Cilla) adopted Americanised accents.

    I think her voice is great in her other songs, especially the Lennon and McCartney written "Step Inside Love" and this is no exception, really the definitive version. Dionne has never forgiven her though, lol.

  • @PinkLederhosen Sorry, but you're completely full of shit. Musicians, (singers included) DO NOT have to be formally trained technicians bent on perfection. They have to SERVE the song! and Cilla does that here BRILLIANTLY! All of her flaws and technical shortcomings suit the vibe of the tune, and the overall mood of the film for which it was written. This is a POP song written for a FILM made in 1967! Louis Armstrong singing "Hello Dolly" is another example of what I'm describing.

  • Comment removed

  • I would to hear her sing this one more time - maybe 'Loose Women' would be the best place or even better on Paul O'Grady's show with him playing the part of Alfie - now that would be something!!!

  • Her bridge reminds me of an older "Annie." Dionne is the QUEEN.

  • cool 'old' film clip of recording session.

  • Is there anymore British singers who could sing like Cilla Black?

  • @worldpeace32 Like Cilla? Or as good as Cilla? Not many sang like her but IMHO Pet Clark, Sandy Denny and Dusty Springfield were all great in their fields.

  • Cilla was the "Pepsi" girl in the 60s. I remember her doing the commercials.

  • Next! What a horrid rendition. Sorry, honey, you're no Streisand. Never make it in Hollywood. Tired old thing!

  • A powerful song with comforting lyrics I had almost forgotten. I'd never heard the Cilla Black version, but now that I have, I find it's my favorite (with absolutely NO disrespect to the legendary Barbara Streisand or Dionne Warwick). "I believe in LOVE, Alfie. Without true LOVE, we just exist" So True. Thank you for posting.  Peace & Love to ALL.

  • Cilla, with the right song and production made some good singles that eptomise the 1960's just as Maddona did for the 1980's This was brilliant as was that song she did with the lyrics...dirty as a dustbin lid...Now what song was that?

  • @TheBobitt It's called The Mucky Kid or Liverpool Lullaby ("Oh you are a mucky kid, Dirty as a dustbin lid...").

  • It's Cilla's and Burt's (and Hal's) song. Sorry, Dionne. Yes...magic in this one. Check out Cilla doing Lennon/McCartney's, "It's for You".

  • She gave it her all in this performance did she not, so full of emotion...I love it.

    The words are pure Poetry...........and so true............

    "Without true Love we Just exist......." gives me shivers...........

    thankyou so much......

  • I saw a documentary with George Martin, who produced this record, where he said it was Take 3 that was released, although Bacharach pushed on with many further takes with Cilla's singing deteriorating all the time as she didn't see what he wanted from her. It was Martin who pursuaded Bacharach that Take 3 was the one to use. Cilla's greatest achievement - magnificent performance.

  • God, I cant stop listening to this lovely song .. ta Cilla ..

  • this song is beautifully sung by cilla black,the very best version in my opinion,alison moyet does a credible version too,dionne and cher are great singers but this song belongs to cilla.

  • What a great voice and performance! Wow thats good!

  • Cilla Black owns this song .. end of .

  • WOW !!!!!!!

  • beautiful voice ...I love her version

  • While Dionne Warwick soars and glides on this song, Cilla unfortunately stomps and clomps through it gracelessly. It's a pity because she actually has a nice vocal timbre.

  • She can have Alfie, but Dionne Warwick owns the rest!

  • Another thing that helps Cilla own this over Dionne Warwick is the fact that Cilla is English and the film is such an English film (even though the song is written by Americans!)

  • Nice voice.

  • What a smart move for posterity to have cameras at a 60's recording session - a rarity. We're actually witnessing something which has gone forever in popular music: the performance in the recording studio.

  • @Tagg63yes.....'heartless,self­ish'...well said fellow messager....still a few Alfie casanova wannabes floating around in this world...sadly

  • dionne warwick was in mind when this song was writen ,cilla is a great singer but....she is not dionne

  • spot on

  • This is not Dionne's song by any stretch of the imagination. Cilla totally OWNS this song. Bacharach himself said Cilla's was the definitive version of his song.

  • Natural , emotional , . The Lovely Cilla

  • Go on our Cilla, give it some. I like a bit of regional accent coming through, not just generic

  • This song has it alll and Cilla is flawless beautiful

  • Certain artists own certain songs, granted it was initially Cilla's but Bacharach still felt he wasn't satisfied with the initial take. I'll have to go with the composer's gut feeling. I'd say that Burt knows damn well what he wants and has a preeeeety good ear for music.

  • this song was written for Cilla but because of recording contracts she was unable to record the song for the film.

  • All you claiming that she 'copied' Dionne's version are idiots as she recorded it first. Dionne recorded this after 40+ other versions had been recorded!!! Some 4 years later so chomp on that. Cilla destroyed the composition as she interpreted it so get over it. 0_o

  • excuse me, a year later (Dionne's version)

  • Nice but this is Dionne's song. Dionne's version is more in keeping with the mood of the movie. Never did like Cher's version at the end of the movie

  • @csupremes Your kidding me? Neither of those woman have any sort of emotion in their voices. They have nice voices but Cher owns that song. Its about a young girl in love and you cant beat the raw voice and emotion 20 yr old Cher brings to it...

  • @Tagg63 Are you kidding me? Did you ever see the original movie? It's not about a young girl in love ,it's about Alfie and the heartless, selfish person that WAS Alfie. Powerful movie and then it ends with Cher's version of the song which did fit the music of the time but not the picture it's self. And so you know, I loved Cher's voice during the 60's.Raw and full of emotion but then she changed her style and it lost something for me.

  • Comment removed

  • @csupremes I have always adored this song, and I love both versions as they are so different to me..

    It's as if Cilla is singing to Alfie from afar..... narrating his selfishness and losses in the end... Cher, on the other hand, sounds like she is singing to Alfie, like one of his women he kicked to the curb.... desolate and hurt...

  • @TheAlysheba It is such a good song and i like your thoughts on both of those versions. You obviously saw the original movie because you understand what is being said. You make no mention of Dionne's version.

  • @csupremes I like Dionne, but Alfie is Cilla's and Cher's... That's just my opinion...

  • Comment removed

  • @Tagg63 I just checked out your channel and that version of Alfie is not the movie version and my comments were on the movie soundtrack. The version you are showing i like much better then the movie.

  • SHODDA BEEN - WHAT IT ALL ABOUT RALPHIE ! WHAT THE HELL IS A ALFIE?

  • Cilla owns "You're My World". Jackie DeShannon owns "What the World Needs Now"and Dionne owns "Alfie". Cilla can belt with power but there are moments in the song where she resembles Ethel Merman and Kate Smith. I'm sure when the Bacharach-David-Warwick hit machine was in motion it pleased a lot of listeners in the UK, so why not give Cilla the nod to cover thes songs across the pond.Warwick stated "if I sneezed on my recording, Cilla would do the same on hers"

  • the best version.cill doesnt scream,she belts!big difference.the sheer power of that magnificent voice!thrilling to hear and see

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Its true Cilla screams on these songs, I dont know how she got away with it back then.

  • Priscilla Maria Veronica White...FANTASTIC !!!!!!

  • SORRY....but DIONNE WARWICK owns this song. Cilla just basically copies Dionne Warwick. She has no soul, she shouts. No comparison to Warwick's version (which was the million seller worldwide).

  • Brilliant.. I recall Cilla during this film mentioning how painful it was to work with Burt. Not a bad gig, tho.

    Great upload.

  • My favorite version of this song. Dionne's is great but Cilla's interpretation has such passion and texture. The film is charming, too.!

  • @ppaulmorris:

    To say "she is awful" and then blabber something about "sheer faced effrontery" demonstrates that not only do you know nothing, but that you also can't handle poly-syllabic words very well. I can respect opinons that differ from my own. But yours is worthless.

  • Of all the tons of versions of this song recorded by different singers I think this is the best one. She was amazing and apparently Burt Bacharach thought so too.

  • while cleaning my tears(the truth) i´ll send you a happy oldie by the great cilla (1968)

  • I don't think anyone records this way anymore; live with orchestra, piano, back up singers, live in the studio. I read Bacharach did nearly 20 takes until he felt it was just right. George Martin produced this. It's said that he remarked Cila got it on the first few takes but Burt wanted more. Whatever, this is really beautiful. Also, notice that Cila was not a particularly beautiful woman in comparison to today's singers. Back then looks weren't as important as talent. Not today.

  • @Monkey45008 No thank God, Cilla has not the ubiquitous aquiline cookie cutter face purported as beauty but a face of singular beauty as is that singularly beautiful voice. Il est dit que «la beauté est dans l'œil du spectateur." Et je suis entièrement d'accord, car elle est la beauté pour moi.

  • omigod - speechless - tears

  • This brought tears to my eyes.

  • She does a fine version, but dionne warwicks voice really handle this song. this is DONNE WARWICKS song!

  • @masc6feet1man

    This is without question Cillas song. I agree. Dionne sings it beautifully. But she has plenty songs of her own. This one belongs to Cilla.

  • my grandad used to sing this to me when i was little... RIP Grandad xx

  • @forwantofabetterword My mother used to sing it as she pushed me in my stroller. I'm in my 40's now and still love it :)

  • and she sounded so much like Dionne Warwick on this one, too. Maybe that's why she did so many covers of songs that Dionne Warwick did. This one she might have done before Warwick, but the style was definitely the Bacharach and David sound. I prefer that little edge that Warwick had, but this is really quite fine.

  • For me - this IS the best song Cilla ever recorded. This song is perfect for her voice. The Lyrics are absolutely brilliant A Classic!

  • this is the best version of this song thanks Cilla

  • God, how i wish for a return to a world where records were made by musicians! Thank you so much for posting this gem!

  • @mikeymax777

    listen to a girl called rumer. will you find her on youtube.

    maybe her voice is not as strong as cilla or dusty. but it is beautiful.

    and she is english.

  • love the way B.Bacharach is conducting. :)

  • Cilla's greatest ever. Burt B:s greatest? Certainly one of them. Amazing recording to this day. Being a teenager during the 60'ies, I'm prejudiced... but was there ever a better time for pop music?

  • didn't burt do about 31 takes..and then decide that take 2 or 3 was the best ? .. brilliant .. watch him conducting .. unfortunately , cilla will be remembered as a saturday tacky night tv host .. and not this ..

  • What a genius at work, Mr. Bacharach is...One day he'll be acknowledged as one of the worlds best composers ever. He already is, for a lot of critics and fans.

  • wow, what a beautiful song! she has such an amazing voice too, it's perfect for a song like this one! everytime i hear this song it makes me think of my good friend Alfio, but i like to call him Alfie sometimes. i would just love to sing this song some time, it's really sweet.

  • this is one of the rare bacharach songs when lyrics came first....one tends to believe that is the right sequence. and - sorry Dionne, my goddess- Cilla is a perfect choice. i simply am falling for her.

  • Is that backing singer Camilla Parker-Bowles???!!!

  • @Sweetjuniperberry - close, but no turnip greens for you. That's Mister Ed.

  • @iepurasdragalas22 so sweet :*

  • Is the singer on the left in the backing vocal trio Ellie Greenwich?

  • @FabFrank1 : YES ! That's Ellie. Burt brought his favorite female songwriter/singer with him to record this.

  • Good on ya Cilla! Perfect delivery of an awesome song.

  • What a treat!

  • Expecting to hear Dionne, I was surprised to see Cilla in this same documentary. Being here in the states, all I heard was "You're My World", in turn my neighbor never heard that song but loved emphatically, Cilla's version of Alfie. At first impression I felt that this melancholic masterpiece should not be belted out in E. Merman or K. Smith fashion.I now realize that Cilla had done it the only way Cilla can. That day the winds were right ,the planets aligned,forever etched in time.

  • A couple of years ago my English neighbor, a retired sound mixer and Emmy award winner here in So. Cal. invited me over one afternoon to listen to how he put it in his own words, "the best rendition of Alfie".

  • This has everything... great song, composition, arrangement, performance, etc. Epiphany is a word that comes to mind. The musical gods had a hand in this cutting of this track. It is truly a great and rare work of art.

    The look in Cilla's eyes and her mannerisms as she's singing make her look like she's in her own zone outside of reality, like she's caught a wave and she's riding high on it. Absolute perfection.

  • @GoldenTornado wow best comment ever and -thanx for your Epiphany as well.

  • @MrAlbundy87

    It would be impossible to make a bad comment about either the song, the singer or the superb writer.

  • @GoldenTornado : Your comments are as perfect as this recording. Thanks.

  • @GoldenTornado : I agree--a perfect comment to this perfect moment in music history. In addition, I love how this was recorded the old-fashioned way: sung live, with orchestra and backing vocals all at once, not pieced together like a jigsaw puzzle.

  • Thanks for this!

  • Where did all these power house singers go today?

    These were the days.......

  • This is the definitive version of Alfie by which all others should be judged. Cilla does an absolutely fantastic job here and nobody else sings it as well - no not even Dionne.

  • @FlamingFairy great version by Cilla but don't dismiss Dionne's. Hers is better in my opinion.

  • When pushed, Cilla's vocal chops could really surprise....with a uniquely English soulfulness...very under-rated!

  • @jimdivax yes-cilla still has the voice as others have withered away

    she worked hard to perfect this version..

  • I always thought Cilla struggled with most songs she sung, but this is a wonderful performance with a top arrangement from Mr Bacharach. I'm so glad it was captured on film. Love it!

  • Great song, singer and film

  • Great voice!

  • I remember seeing this on TV in a Cilla/Bacharach special a few years ago. It impressed me so much then - and it still has the same impact now, over and over again. A wonderful composition, interpreted to perfection. No-one can sing this as well as our Cilla!

  • @SomersetBob thanks for your comments--yes i remember seeing that--bacharach was trying to get the best from cilla--probably take 3--

  • @MrAlbundy87 She had to do more takes than 3, although I think Burt used her 1st take in the end. Much respect to Hal David who is usually forgotten and shouldn't be.

  • The best vocal version of this song - EVER!

  • She is awful. It is all about sheer faced effrontery.

  • @ppaulmorris :

    You know nothing.

  • Criticising someone just for having an opinion different to yours. You really do sound a reasonable person. Quality.

  • @ppaulmorris  ghb61 observing 'you know nothing' may be harsh, but you do fail on 2 accounts: (1) I 'guess' you mean Cilla had 'sheer bold faced effrontery'? -- or the comment has no real meaning. If so, I hardly think this example of her singing suggests she is 'brazen' or 'impudent': therefore is inappropriate.

    (2) Cilla herself would not claim to have been a 'great' singer, but she sings with character, and most of all with HEART, and that makes her rendition of a difficult lyric, special.

  • @TruthfulBrute - It is all about opinion so save your smarmy illogical comments. You fail by actually calling her a singer. Game, set and match to me.

  • @ghb61 Ooops..having a different opinion from you leads the rattle to be thrown out your pram. Grow up.

  • @ppaulmorris Your just trolling. Ciller songs are the only once ever to make the hair on my neck stand up.

    So go and play some where else.

  • @flyparagliding Weak reply - and you know it. Just because someone does not agree with you.

  • I love this song so much, my little boy who would be 3 in 2 days time if he hadn't been from SIDS was named after this- luv my little angel Alfie ♥. thank you so much for sharing it. x.

  • perfection.

  • Great video thanks for sharing it. I was 12 when that came out and I had the same haircut. Nice trip down memory lane thanks again.

  • cant stop playing this, thank you Cilla, means so much xx

  • best bit - WiTHOUT TRUE LOVE WE JUST EXSIST!!!

    but its all great, best cilla song.

  • this was her finest song.

  • One of the greatest moments in the history of musical recording. Enough said.

  • @Bobbr3

    I totally agree. Amazing.

  • she delivers this o beautifully

  • One of the best songs ever written by one of the best,underrated singers of all time! Cilla's version is #1.

  • Comment removed

  • oh my...i wept while watching this!!!....

  • @crawcoil I'd bet the bank you weren't alone... : )

  • @crawcoil :

    I just discovered this clip about a week ago, have seen it a dozen times or more, and I've wept while watching it each time.

  • @ghb61 thanks for your heart felt sentiments-the song means a lot of things-its damn you do or not &gains and losses in life-and the question of .what is it all about-where we have huge problems in war ,hunger,resources growing over population-and many complex issues-i think-its touching--and the inevitable losses in all lives at the end--burt made her work hard for this song-pushed cilla to the edges of her staying power--what wondeful vocals she has-in all her music-just got to love her ,thx

  • @ghb61 I also weep when ever she's sings, but not for good reasons.

  • Cilla deserves tobe dame

  • a sad but beautiful song.................

  • Bravo.....

  • brillant 5*

  • Well done! You managed to keep it in sync as well as mine (not easy - is it?) But I only had a slightly scratchy record of it, thus yours is better - although the mix sounds slightly different. I did mine years ago, for my own entertainment, but then, when I got online and discovered YouTube... It'll be interesting to see if your version overtakes mine in hits - the race is ON!!!