TalkBack w/ Wajahat Khan & LK Advani Ep29 Pt3

[anant14]

The SPG identity is secret........only the top positions are known........it is also drawn from both the police forces (CRPF/BSF/some state polices/ITBP) and the army.......the leadership is from IPS and Army both...... so no one can say that there are are no Muslims and Sikhs.......or even Hindus......therefore such propaganda is not correct........

[ahmeds027]

advani : yes i stand by that he was secular n i have mentioned this in my book

after listening to the party statement

advani : oh yes thats a fact, that the party said

I think, this one was statement of advani was a huge blunder, on his stance n haunts him for long

[hongkongkaka]

What an idiot host!

[sushil2002]

pakistan aaj bhi apne creation ko justify karta rahta hai ..aur india aaj bhi use 1 galti bolna chahta hai...yaar root cause britain tha ..uski bhi koi baat karo !!!

[kanthasingh54]

i dnt understand y dnt these bloody indians talk straight.....if there is no muslim/sikh in the SPG....please admit there is a mistrust.....!!! thts the thing bout these hindus....they never talk straight

[vinaydey2006]

So are you saying we Indians don't trust Sikhs and Muslims in a relatively minor position like SPG but trust them in vital positions like President,Vice president,Prime minister,chief of armed staff,Prime ministers economic advisory committee,chairman & vice chairman of planning commission etc.,Captain of Indian cricket team etc. Go and find out how many times these posts have been held by non hindus. The answer will be MANY TIMES.

[kanthasingh54]

well i hope u knw tht when it comes to power, probably the SPG has more power than an indian President.....the prime minister of india leads a jig-saw hindu coalition and thus has no power of his own

when there are only 5% muslims in the indian parliament (compared to their population of 15%)....they have little power...when an MP can say in parliament that 2 crore sikhs should be slaughtered, without little opposition, they have no power

these posts are given to minorities deliberately

[errolmiranda]

@kanthasingh54 yeah right ! so are you trying to state that in Pakistan even ONE HINDU OR CHRIsTIAN has been given a major position???/ NEVER ! Please ask Pakistan to be accountable for their actions first then speak of India needing to be accountable to Pakistan.

[ramsob]

@vinaydey2006 That doesn't rid your society of all the ills and shabby treatment of the minorities in India especially Muslims who remain mostly marginalized and economically,socially and politically deprived !!

[samester123]

@ramsob wow.. Pakistani talking about minority?.. Well you have no minority left in your country.. from 10% hindu population after creation of Pakistan to less than 1% hindu population in today's Pakistan (as compared to India where Muslims have grown in percentage and absolute numbers), you have no locus standi on this issue

[samester123]

@ramsob wow.. Pakistani talking about minority?.. Well you have no minority left in your country.. from 10% hindu population after creation of Pakistan to less than 1% hindu population in today's Pakistan (as compared to India where Muslims have grown in percentage and absolute numbers), you have no locus standi on this issue

[hashpuppy101]

thaz like saying all singhs are daft after reading you comments.stop generalizing.politicians are politicians.its called ducking and waving in their dictionary.supposed to be an invaluable asset in their arsenal.im hindu, and i talk straight.if you want questions answered, ask me.ill talk straight as much as possible. provided you insist as much as I do in keeping it hygienic and healthy.

[errolmiranda]

@kanthasingh54 - kantha sngh i have no idea why you are so angry mate... firstly please understand ....the assasination of indira gandhi evoked a reaction . true.. was it right ? NO//

But after partition what Indira Gandhi ws trying to do was to keep the peace.. and the reason military entered your gurdwara was because there was a plan being made to kill the muslims .... see out of religion was it not logical ?

im christian , should i speak about how hindus are suppressing me ? NO

[anant14]

@kanthasingh54 ,

You see SPG identity is secret. It is drawn from both police forces (all states including Punjab, plus central police organizations like CRPF, BSF etc) and Army....... the directors are from IPS ranks and the actual officers on ground are from Army.......Each state has a local SPG unit (consisting of local police) for outer level security.......

Therefore such rumors should not be believed..... but I can guarantee my friend from Nagaland is there (there are Naga rebel group )

[anant14]

@kanthasingh54 ,

An Indian PM faces threats from all religions and regions and even genders potentially..... lolz!..... If you think like that noone can be in SPG....... ha ha

As far as NSG (National Security Gaurds) is considered it has people from all religions, languages, castes and genders !.....