Scott is unequivocally the best singer in ALL, but IMO Chad is the best singer in ALL, also it goes without saying that Dave was the best singer ALL ever had. But I have to admit Milo is still the best.
Yeah Milo is better, but Scott is def. the best ALL singer (though a little off here). Saw them in 1991 or 2?? at City Gardens in Trenton N.J. and they were brillant. This one was on the Dot single........great song. Check out the band "Goodbye Harry" for more prime Scott Reynolds stuff.
@pippurinkives ye man, thats what i thought. i read somewher he was pretty unhealthy and had to sort out his health, new 2010 descendents vids at fun fun fest hes lookin wey more skinny. still what a rad guy!!!!
I don't wanna start an argument here, but I really think that Chad's a better vocal man than Scott. Scott's great, but I mean, compare "Live + 1" (Chad) with "Trailblazer" (Scott). Scott even goes outta key sometimes in that recording. To me it's Milo > Chad > Scott > Dave. Just my opinion, though. But undoubtedly Bill's the best drummer ever... I mean, even with all those pounds between his spine and the drumset, he can still play as tight as he ever played... fuck*n' amazing!
You also have to keep in mind the years they were recorded and the technology used to record them. Not trying to start an argument, but I don't think it is quite fair to compare those albums. I do like Chad and Scott, but as an old school fan prefer Scott.
Bill told me they were offered money to do a tour with scott instead of chad. and they didnt really think about. "Milo, Chad, Scott... Whatever" is what i think he said. anyway scott said he only wanted to play stuff that was written when he was in All. this was on the dot single
`Can't Say' was one of the two bonus tracks on the `Dot' (off `Percolater') cd single...the other song was `Boy Named Sue' (Johnny Cash cover)...Scott was on vox at the time...
ahh thanks for that!, i dont have dot single, i looked for it on ebay, pretty expencive, its a good tune, and ye ive been reading that scotts been playing a few gigs with all recently, and riot festervil, i think he said thers a chance of him doing another ALL album, would be rad!
My fave record with Scott was `Allroy's Revenge,' and is arguably their best...they were a totally unique band at that time, before the whole pop-punk explosion in the 90's...if they do come out with a new album, I hope it's better than their last studio effort (the aptly titled, `Problematic')...
yeh man, i would say Allroys revenge is my fave out of all the albums, ye man blink were well influenced by them, and descendents, they coverd christmas vacation and hope, i was reading, i think it was on wiki, that they were planing on releasing 2 albums at once, one of them was gonna be kinda "heavy", duno what that means, maby mathy like check one and educated Idiot would be cool, are u a descendents fan?!!
Perhaps heavy as in darker and less poppy, like `Pummel'...I've always liked All, and the various singers, but Descendents have always been my favourite...I'd imagine most pop-punk bands of the 90's were influenced by them...I haven't heard Blink's covers...I remember a band called Face to Face did a cover of `Bikeage'...
Great ALL song...not quite sure why it didn't appear on Percolater, one of their weakest records...also liked liked the Johnny Cash cover from the `Dot' cd single...
I think Dave Smalley did a much better job vocally with ALL than with Dag Nasty. But I think Scott is the probably the best. I personally think Chad sucks compared to Scott, and even Dave.
Hey, listen to Scott with All and the Pavers the body of work is awsome, so don't knock it ! ... don't forget Goodbye Harry as well ! Scotts one of my favs fur-shr aight....
I'm surprised to see how many people are supportive of Scott over Chad...Chad's voice is so much better...a lot more similar to Milo's. I don't know, maybe you guys aren't Descendents fans or something.
true i like chad better but i think all should hav more of its oun sound cuz like u hav 2 sick fucking bands ALL and Descendents but do u rlly want 2 of the same band
I'm a huge Descendents fan but Scott is my fave singer out of all of them, including Milo. Scott was in ALL when I got into them, so that might be why. He's just awesome, and was on my fave stuff by them. Chad is awesome too though, don't get me wrong.
I love every singer the band had from Milo through Chad, but I've always said I would like to see a reunion with Scott. I really hope they tour and possibly record another album!
Bill had gained so much weight there for a while. I'm glad he's doing alright now.
kylewagoner 4 months ago
I want that Slorder T-shirt.
Matle666 5 months ago
I CAN say actually. I can say a word. It's "winded".
os101king 7 months ago
Scott is unequivocally the best singer in ALL, but IMO Chad is the best singer in ALL, also it goes without saying that Dave was the best singer ALL ever had. But I have to admit Milo is still the best.
FissureFilms 7 months ago
Scott's voice has really changed over the years. I'm kinda disappointed. I like the albums with Scott, especially Percolater.
Storly 8 months ago
Its on the Dot EP,find it used on Amazon and Ebay. I couldn't find it on itunes or amazon mp3.
ns2joel 8 months ago
all are great
nuff said
we need them
wombsquid 10 months ago
@CoyoteSteveJohnson I think Scott is the worst, he's good, but Chad more fits my style. I of course like Dave, but not many people can mess with him.
mickeyboneszc13 1 year ago
Yeah Milo is better, but Scott is def. the best ALL singer (though a little off here). Saw them in 1991 or 2?? at City Gardens in Trenton N.J. and they were brillant. This one was on the Dot single........great song. Check out the band "Goodbye Harry" for more prime Scott Reynolds stuff.
CoyoteSteveJohnson 1 year ago
what album is this from?
robolitious 1 year ago
@robolitious B side of "Dot" single.
SuperBrandone 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anyone interested in ALL/Descendents audio/video bootleg trade? PM me.
MassNerder85 1 year ago
i dont think this song was on an album
PKMLshow 1 year ago
Milo is better.
jcfuentes 1 year ago
Comment removed
slutpuppy69 1 year ago
Comment removed
slutpuppy69 1 year ago
world fattest drummer
StevenAteYourDogs 1 year ago
@StevenAteYourDogs Haha, Bills gotten a little chubby but hes the best godamn punk rock drummer out there
pippurinkives 1 year ago 2
@pippurinkives ye man, thats what i thought. i read somewher he was pretty unhealthy and had to sort out his health, new 2010 descendents vids at fun fun fest hes lookin wey more skinny. still what a rad guy!!!!
parkerman23 11 months ago
one of my top ten song!
dadaroromeme 1 year ago
Chad is better in drag the river ;)
DreamAwayDreamless 1 year ago
It's good to see them playing with Scott, but I miss Chad.
Ricardo72 1 year ago
Yo dudes, anyone knows where I can download the DOT- EP (which contains this song studio version)? i searched like hell...can't find it...
Thx!
posnike 1 year ago
I don't wanna start an argument here, but I really think that Chad's a better vocal man than Scott. Scott's great, but I mean, compare "Live + 1" (Chad) with "Trailblazer" (Scott). Scott even goes outta key sometimes in that recording. To me it's Milo > Chad > Scott > Dave. Just my opinion, though. But undoubtedly Bill's the best drummer ever... I mean, even with all those pounds between his spine and the drumset, he can still play as tight as he ever played... fuck*n' amazing!
rhdcrossover 1 year ago
You also have to keep in mind the years they were recorded and the technology used to record them. Not trying to start an argument, but I don't think it is quite fair to compare those albums. I do like Chad and Scott, but as an old school fan prefer Scott.
blevan1 1 year ago
@rhdcrossover I love both singer Chad and Scott bu Scott was sick during the recording of TrailBazer
Stephanage 1 year ago
No one can beat Milo.
and Bill has gotten huuuuge!
hupy44 1 year ago 2
Tour America again, motherfuckers!!! Forget that one-off shit in Portland.
machinesbreathe 1 year ago
Sucks very hard live!!!
sagalirte 2 years ago
Bill told me they were offered money to do a tour with scott instead of chad. and they didnt really think about. "Milo, Chad, Scott... Whatever" is what i think he said. anyway scott said he only wanted to play stuff that was written when he was in All. this was on the dot single
patrickdolin 2 years ago
each ALL singer brought their own skillz ....I prefer Dave smalley and scott reynolds (although chad did a good job on the breaking things album)
khandajatt 2 years ago
No singer in ALL can compare to Scott.
blevan1 2 years ago 22
@blevan1 yeah he can fit a lot of words into one line my uncles freinds with him
PKMLshow 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i prefer chad's version
simpson24 2 years ago
nice tune, this is pretty new right?!, then whats scott doing there??!,
best all vocalist anyway!!
parkerman23 2 years ago
`Can't Say' was one of the two bonus tracks on the `Dot' (off `Percolater') cd single...the other song was `Boy Named Sue' (Johnny Cash cover)...Scott was on vox at the time...
cscian1 2 years ago
ahh thanks for that!, i dont have dot single, i looked for it on ebay, pretty expencive, its a good tune, and ye ive been reading that scotts been playing a few gigs with all recently, and riot festervil, i think he said thers a chance of him doing another ALL album, would be rad!
cheers
jimbo
parkerman23 2 years ago
My fave record with Scott was `Allroy's Revenge,' and is arguably their best...they were a totally unique band at that time, before the whole pop-punk explosion in the 90's...if they do come out with a new album, I hope it's better than their last studio effort (the aptly titled, `Problematic')...
cscian1 2 years ago
yeh man, i would say Allroys revenge is my fave out of all the albums, ye man blink were well influenced by them, and descendents, they coverd christmas vacation and hope, i was reading, i think it was on wiki, that they were planing on releasing 2 albums at once, one of them was gonna be kinda "heavy", duno what that means, maby mathy like check one and educated Idiot would be cool, are u a descendents fan?!!
parkerman23 2 years ago
Perhaps heavy as in darker and less poppy, like `Pummel'...I've always liked All, and the various singers, but Descendents have always been my favourite...I'd imagine most pop-punk bands of the 90's were influenced by them...I haven't heard Blink's covers...I remember a band called Face to Face did a cover of `Bikeage'...
cscian1 2 years ago
hahaha Story of my life.
Burialprism 2 years ago
SHIT! They killed it! :D
CaseyJ2009 2 years ago 2
the singers in all are good, but milo is 100 times better then all of them combined!
Pogokid150 2 years ago
what's bill been up to put on some wieght hope he is a.o.k great band cheers,
matttildesley 2 years ago
scott was pretty awesome. no longer. this is horrible.
these2boots 2 years ago
Great ALL song...not quite sure why it didn't appear on Percolater, one of their weakest records...also liked liked the Johnny Cash cover from the `Dot' cd single...
cscian1 2 years ago
good tune, i dont remember this from any of the records, could u tell me what it was from?
hm, i loved most of percolater, there were a few songs i dident like as much, but there was some rad tunes on that album i though,
cheers
parkerman23 2 years ago
ALL the ALL singers were good, but Milo was the best...
cscian1 2 years ago
i think milo is the best and dave is the wrost
rockandrollnigger 2 years ago
I think Dave Smalley did a much better job vocally with ALL than with Dag Nasty. But I think Scott is the probably the best. I personally think Chad sucks compared to Scott, and even Dave.
ShinobiKunai 2 years ago 4
hey does anyone have the album version of the song????
Lostinspace138 2 years ago
chad rulez ¡¡¡¡¡¡
simpson24 2 years ago
Hey, listen to Scott with All and the Pavers the body of work is awsome, so don't knock it ! ... don't forget Goodbye Harry as well ! Scotts one of my favs fur-shr aight....
AllroyPA 2 years ago
scott sounds country!
X-D
sitdownmarty 3 years ago
lmao true say
descendents4life 3 years ago
I'm surprised to see how many people are supportive of Scott over Chad...Chad's voice is so much better...a lot more similar to Milo's. I don't know, maybe you guys aren't Descendents fans or something.
TrubadourMusic 3 years ago
true i like chad better but i think all should hav more of its oun sound cuz like u hav 2 sick fucking bands ALL and Descendents but do u rlly want 2 of the same band
descendents4life 3 years ago
Chad always liked Scott over Dave, so Shut The Fuck UP!
lightbringerrr 3 years ago
I'm a huge Descendents fan but Scott is my fave singer out of all of them, including Milo. Scott was in ALL when I got into them, so that might be why. He's just awesome, and was on my fave stuff by them. Chad is awesome too though, don't get me wrong.
MechGorilla 2 years ago
Milo>Chad>Dave>Scott
Milo was best by a wide margin.
tml4873 2 years ago
'Milo was best ' Milo IS best :-)
Failtoreason 2 years ago
descendents and ALL kicks ass!
fujiwarataku 3 years ago
Scott's voice has got a lot better!
tabethguster 3 years ago
I love every singer the band had from Milo through Chad, but I've always said I would like to see a reunion with Scott. I really hope they tour and possibly record another album!
Mozzer232 3 years ago
Where's Chad? Looks like Bill ate him.
bradbsd 3 years ago
Pretty gooooood
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
jonaslaves 3 years ago
Chad's been doing a lot of alt-country solo stuff since Drag The River split up.
originalkingofska 3 years ago
Why not Chad and Scott at the same time?
jonaslaves 3 years ago
ALLs creative peak was with Scott, i hope they do another album with him.
EFK76 3 years ago 2
the best ALL singer was, without ANY doubt, Chad Price!
antimacrista 3 years ago
chad price rules ¡¡¡¡
simpson24 3 years ago
Comment removed
Peltolater 3 years ago
i prefer chad price
simpson24 3 years ago
man, i am so glad scott reynolds is singing with them again. chad price was good, but all the best ALL albums are Scott Reynolds albums.
dragonforks 3 years ago 12
ALL?
NO ALL!!!!
DarekHB 3 years ago
this is the best thing my ears have heard in years. more please!
fruitbooter360 3 years ago
i'm so happy right now!
i just love this band playing live...
more footages like this one would be outstanding!
tecoall 3 years ago
Quebec to Chicago... oh yeah Baby i'll be at the Riot Fest even if it costs me a thousand bucks
macpascal 3 years ago
one of my favorite ALL songs!!! I can't wait for Riot Fest!!!
kurtatrc 3 years ago
Awesome! More videos please :)
freddaeriksson 3 years ago
They're all beaming! And so am I!
Peltolater 3 years ago
最高のバンド!!
yasuuuuu 3 years ago
whoa! reynolds IS buff in that tank top!
brentcordero 3 years ago
whoa! reynolds looks buff in that tank top!
TACOVAN 3 years ago
This has made my day. Wish there was more footage
krisg6 3 years ago
Squirt!
millergregg 3 years ago
What a great way to make a comeback after 5 years..that crowd went nuts! The japanese truly get this awesome band!
boonatron 3 years ago
awesome!!!
lewpal 3 years ago
Wicked good.....
pallular 3 years ago
THANK YOU! More, please...
Peltolater 3 years ago