OMG she just fucked it up!... Anette, you are a good POP singer now go and sing along Madona so Marco could save the band as the new solist... (he alone would do a better job) or just sing DPP songs.
If you love Tarja's version do me a favor and rate as 1/5... although it deserves a -10 (negatives rating should be added)
Of course she isn`t Tarja and no one expects her to sing exactly the same or to hit the same notes!The point is,Nightwish used to have a unique sound with a Soprano power house and a Symphonic background now POP! It`s sounds more like a Karaoke track as does a lot of Annettes songs!
man,even if god comes singing in NW it woudln't be enough for you,get over it,it's been 3 and half years since tarja left..gosh buy you self my winterstorm,cuZ OBVIOUSLY TARJA IS ONLY REASON WHY YOU LISTENED NW ,if you like NW you would like it even if adolf hitler comes singing,but you obviously care about the vocal and not about Tuomas's masterpieces so buy oyurself fucking my winterstorm,though you wont hear much,shitty lyrics bad music and comercialed voice
This song is so great that even Anette couldnt fuck it up! She can barely sing those high notes aside that whole song is tuned down whole step for her.Bad singer for this band period!
she is very talented. You guys just want Tarja back and complaining isn't going to make a different. Noone can even try to go in the same vocal range as Tarja. The both are different and great vocalists in their own right.
I agree. The main reason that people hate Annette is simply because she's not Tarja. I think Annette is really good, different singing style, but still good. :)
Not to bad. I often wondered if she would be able to pull off the Tarja's songs (or rather the ones she sang as Tuomas wrote them and are essentially HIS). But when I saw them in concert in May, all doubt was erased from my mind. Absolutely phenomenal!!!
Well, you said that you wanted to kick her ass of a cliff! If my jump makes your NARROW mind oki.. Well, I might just.... Kick YOUR but first! Go home you morron! This band doesnt need this kind of fans!!! PS: I am a big Nightwish Fan since the first CD, so dont start me with that Tarja worshiping stuff!
LOL Midnight...i think you misunderstood my comment =P i said i would kick lostcause5 off a cliff, because i do like Anette too and i found absurd what she said =P
Like you i'm too a fan of nightwish from the first CD...i changed my mind...you don't need to jump =D heheh
excuse me.."Your primitive brain isn't capable of understanding the concept of a music genre. " are you sauing that anette is better than TARJA? this is GARBAGr compared with what was NIGHTWISH! and if you really knew something about music you will say that tarja is a real artist in stead of insulting me!ok?and if you don`t care about my opinion, simply stop reading!
"Now crawl back into the cave you came from, asshole. " you peas of shit! everyone has the right to say his opinion..that is why comments are put here,retard!and if i don`t like her it`s my problem ok?Nightwis is singing pop music now because of that garbage called anette!so piss off!
You aren't saying your opinion, you are spewing insults on multiple videos over and over.
"Nightwis is singing pop music now because of that garbage called anette!"
You know jack shit about pop and music in general. Your primitive brain isn't capable of understanding the concept of a music genre. It's the same musicians playing the same song and it magically turned into pop because of a vocal change? You don't know wtf you're talking about.
As soon as you fuck off Nightwish videos with your bullshit and quietly migrate to the land of My Winter Storm, then i'll stop responding to you. Noone cares about your poor excuse of an opinion that is based on insults. Now go fuck yourself, asshole.
"she is a sorry excuse for a human being!even the croud sings better than her!I HATE YOU BITCH!"
So, spewing garbage, because your primitive brain is incapable of rational thinking, constitutes as a fine addition to society? You're just another cliche fantard, who copies and pastes the same retarded shit on every video. Anette and Nightwish rock, you swim mediocrity. Now crawl back into the cave you came from, asshole.
In all fairness to YulieAna, although Nightwish songs are challenging, they are certainly not impossible. I can sing the vast majority of them even though I've had no vocal training. Although, I still find the higher ones like this one ^ and Stargazers tough.
Anyway, my original reason for commenting - Anette did pretty damn well! I love that girl. She's so fearless for stepping into Tarja's shoes, and no one seems to be giving her any credit for this!!!
I'd be careful there "MyFallWillBeForYou" yes I know its a free world and we both have the right to voice our opinions, but a certain "YulieAna" might come along in a minute and start preaching to you about how he knows everything about classical music and how its so easy to sing a nightwish song.
Shes singing songs written for a classically trained opera singer.Course she isnt going to be at her best singng them. Anyone who is not classically trained singing Nightwish songs would have trouble with these songs not just Anette. Nightwish songs are so complex to sing anyway.
If anything you should respect the fact that she puts everything into these performaces and trys to sound her best at all time. No one is perfect.
She takes on these huge songs & gives it her all she has my respect.
"How you can sit there and say nemo is not hard to sing is beyond me."
Of course it is, because in your universe Tarja exceeds even her own limitations.
I said Nemo is not a complicated opera song, any well trained soprano can sing it, thus it is not as complicated as you make it out to be in order to overrate Tarja some more.
What fucking planet are you on? Where does it say I fucking worship the ground Tarja walks on!!!! I'm sick of you fuckin pompus assholes on youtube who think YOU KNOW EVERYTHING. First of all I was fuckin sticking up for Anette. Second who the fuck are you? You no fuck all about music you cheeky git! Ever sang nemo on stage infront of thousands of people? HAVE YOU SHITE thats why your on YOUTUBE! go get A LIFE!!!
Your the same as the fanatic Tarja lovers who have sent death threats, your the version for Anette.
Now mind your own buisness (I know its hard). People have a god given right to make an opinion and you mate can do nothing about it :) not matter how many times you try pathetically to make yourself sound smart and bilital people, it does not work and you look stupid doing it.
You said the songs were written for a "classical voice" when there is nothing classical in Nemo, Wish I had an Angel and most of the older material. I counterclaimed that, you got angry and started the pissing contest throwing personal attacks at me. When people do that, they usually have nothing better to day.
Your profile says your a student. That would explain the thinking your better than everyone else attitude. You think your better than everyone on youtube dont you?
"Now mind your own buisness (I know its hard). People have a god given right to make an opinion and you mate can do nothing about it :)"
Perhaps you should follow your own advice? You've been attacking me with insults for thd past couple of days because i DARED to say something you didn't agree with.
Putting a smiley face next to the most hypocritical comment possible makes you an asshole. Practice what you preach.
Whats you fuckin musical background then hey? Mister fuckin I know everything about music? BOLLOX. Your a nobody on youtube. If you knew that much about music im sure you wouldnt be spending your life on youtube making your self sound good! YOUR SAD!
I dont bring aything to the conversation because I dont respect you, and your not worth my brillance in conversation, so dont flatter yourself kid.
Your the same as all the other Anette protectors on here you jump down the throats of people who make the slightest reference to Tarja, when actually in the first place my comment was nothing but complementary to Anette, and you accused me of Worshipping Tarja.
Your not making me tick, I find it highly amusing sitting here arguing with some one who is nearly thrity and is a student. Obviously im gettin to you, otherwise being the mature student you are you would of walked away ages ago. What is it? affraid backing down are we?
"Finest lie so far, in another words you ain't got shit."
psychologist as well now are we? By god you really do think you know everything.
And you've been attacking me aswell mate if you can't take it don't dish it out. You've attack many people on here by the hundreds of comments you've posted. You must get a kick out of it or somthing.
Well unfortunately I saw them live a week ago and I can tell that Anette kills the old songs and her voice is not good live. And also she is dancing like a drunk punk girl. Shame for Nightwish. I don't like them anymore.
Agreed.There's no need to slaughter once beautiful songs,with the voice of a 16yold girl screaming as if she gets her nipples pierced...(this coming 2 days after i saw them live).Just stick to the new stuff...
Well Tarja didn't leave... she was kicked out... I guess for being a bitch, lol, but I really don't know the details, they guys wont give it away in their page... at least they are respectful about the situation and manage it in a professional way.
Tranquilos todos. Aquí no se trata de cantar como Tarja ni de llegar a sus tonos, gracias a Dios. Se trata de adaptar las canciones. Porque si lo ponemos así ya directamente no cantaría ninguna canción de Nightwish. Por cierto, Creek Mary's Blood con ella es mas bonita que con Nightwish. Os animo a verla :D y en concreto esta canción tampoco me desagrada como la canta. Muy bonita, me gusta.
Vaya, que elocuente. ¿Por qué debería hacerlo? Yéndose sólo contentaría a gente como tú. Y yo no pienso como tú. Creo que es un gran aporte para Nightwish y un cambio muy significativo para ellos. Yo adoro la voz de esta chica y estoy segura de que muchísimas personas más también. Las canciones suenan preciosas con ella. El grupo está a gusto y a los que nos gusta también lo estamos. No hay ninguna razón para que tenga que irse y sino me gustaría leer tu punto de vista si es que es algo lógico.
jajaja no tengo nada contra ella solo digo que a que estupido se le ocurre poner a cantar she is my sin con anette cuando todo mundo sabe no llega a la voz de tarja, pero bueno cada quien defiende a quien le guste si algunos les gusta la miereda pues que se enbarren en ella, y algunos como nosotros solo preferimos lo mejor
totalmente te apoyo....no tiene un registro vocal para ello..."for the bride to dear for him" esa parte la super-violo...pero ni modo...las canciones del DPP estan decentes, su voz si puede con ellas. ya es "popwish"
que asco de persona la verdad no le llega ni si quiera a los talones a tarja la verdad parece aficionada mas que cantante incluso yo que soy hombre canto mas al estilo de tarja...xD
Shure you do, Tarja's style in these old songs used a very down-pitched voice, I mean, using high notes but with a low tendency... I mean, Tarja can sound like a kitten or like a lion! (Yeahhhhh Tarja FTW!!!) Anyway, Anette is not a bad singer, just some songs she should not touch.
lo mejor de todo es que nadie te pregunto jajaja estamos tratando tarja vs anette ademas no me importan tus amigos y creo que es obio que si su voz es aguda deja de ser tenor para convertirse en contratenor espero estudies mas sobre musica amigo po descracia tu amigo tampoco me alcanza jejeje pero ese no es punto
Bueno, dejémoslo. Hay gente que sino tira contra Anette de una forma tan subjetiva e insistente se aburre. Si todos fuésemos más objetivos seguro que Anette nos daría más de una sorpresa (aunque ya las está dando y muy bonitas ^_^)
Bueno, quisiera estar de su lado chicos, pero la realidad es que encuentro que su voz es una blasfemia contra lo que alguna vez fue Nightwish. Lo siento pero es solo la opinion de una ex-fan, desde Angels Fall First. Pero no me opongo a Anette, simplemente creo que NW debe de empezar de nuevo, desde cero y Anette tambien, no miren sus albumes pasados, eso fue the end of an era, que sigan con su material nuevo, pero no dañen el anterior, por favor, por respeto a los fans!
tu dices k la voz de anette no va con lo k fue nightwish
y es la verdad
y sin embargo en cierta forma "apoyas" a anette diciedo k deberian volver a empezar
y tmb en eso estoy deacuerdo
de hecho cuando la escuche por primera vez lo primero k pense fue k deberian de cambiarse el nombre, pork esto ya no es nada parecido a lo k era antes y almismo tiepo le daba la oportunidad a anette de mostrar lo k podia hacer con esta banda
Sabes que? Creo que eso es lo mas inteligente que alguien por todos estos lares ha dicho, no podria estar mas de acuerdo contigo. Debieran cambiarse el nombre y empezar de nuevo, asi pues no atacarian tanto a Anette, seria mucho mas justo para ella y para Nightwish.
I somehow like Nightwish better with Anette than Tarja. Don't get me wrong, Tarja was amaizing. But still, Anette brings a little more life to to stage than Tarja.
Thats so true. I got the new NW cd Dark Passion Play and it seems like he made Annete a background singer, Tarja wouldn't do that so out she went for him to feel good.
LOL "Dark Passion Play" is 1 million times better than "Once" and Tarja's new album is hilarious - I cannot take that seriously. And oh, Tarja didn't leave the band because she wanted to, she was fired by whole band - anything more humiliating than that? ;)
i do like Anette i think she rocks and i love there new album, but i don't think they should try to do the old songs, Anette and Tarja are totally diffrent styles, they're both good, just totally diffrent, it's like Tarja trying to do Cadence of Her Last Breath, it's would'nt work :-/
I loved Nightwish with Tarja but the band hasn't changed.One person doesn't change anything, because the lyrics and the music is still the same.Just move on and try to understand it.That is Tarja's own fault she's was sacked.Everyone is blaming Anette, I just don't get the point of blaming her.The band wanted and chose her,not you. And if you have only shit to say about them, then y ur listening to them Nah u kno SHUT THE HELL UP.(tarja fans anette haters)
Ademas, para todos los que creen que los de Nightwish fueron unos tarados al botar a Tarja, ponganse ustedes en la posicion de que tengan una perra jodida en su grupo y se harten de ella porque esta cagando a todo la banda...no la botarian?
Excelente!! creo que hay canciones antiguas (como esta) en las que la voz de Annette queda incluso mejor que la de Tarja (hay canciones en las que ya era como que demasiado la voz operatica). Sin embargo, definitivamente muchas canciones perderan su esencia sin la voz de Tarja... es el precio que hay que pagar, digo yo.
xq ofendes a tarja tu no sabes lo q realmente pasó,en dado caso la perra seria anette x querer ser tarja....wash your mouth is like a dirty toilet...and also listen anette's voice,is horrible for the old songs,my ears are bleeding oh GGGGGRRRRRRRRRRRRR
Bueno, asumo que no has leído la carta que le escribió Tuomas a Tarja después del último concierto...Por otro lado, Annette no sería la perra por ningún lado. Ella simplemente aplicó al puesto y los de Nightwish la eligieron.
omg..this is live how can u even expect that she is gonna sing perfect? Its a bad quality too... I think Anette makes the band more fresh than before and I love it:D
o ... NW is just funny with that new chick singing ..., ill keep watching them hoppeing Tarja will return one day, that song bye bye be. sure tells something
Mmmmm......la verdad que Nightwish sin Tarja no es lo mismo,Anette se esfuerza para cantar,pero creo que debería limitarse a cantar como lo hacía Tarja, asi lo queremos los fans!! que no malogre la cancion pretendiendo poner cosas nuevas, así como lo hacía Tarja estaba mejor. He escuchado el nuevo disco de Nightwish y en verdad ya parecen Evanescence,muy comercial para mi gusto, en serio, que regrese Tarja!!!!
llorones, llorones, llorones...supongo que son maestros en sonido ya que pueden distinguir tantos tonos en un video grabado con una videocámara personal en un concierto, en donde con suerte se escucha algo, pero como son tan llorones Juzgan y Juzgan y Juzgan, entiendan algo, tarja no volverá pero nightwish sigue, si quieren a poyar a tarja, compren sus Álbumes de solista pero no la agarren con la nueva cantante, saludos.
nightwish cometio el peor error al haver echado a tara relmente al escuchar esto me deprime se escucha mal y no es la grabacion ella chilla los tonos altos la matan y debe cantar marco para tratar de ayudarla.
realmente pense q se podria salvar la banda pero me equivoque.
suena a nightwish pero ya no se transmite lo mismo.
This has been flagged as spam show
OMG she just fucked it up!... Anette, you are a good POP singer now go and sing along Madona so Marco could save the band as the new solist... (he alone would do a better job) or just sing DPP songs.
If you love Tarja's version do me a favor and rate as 1/5... although it deserves a -10 (negatives rating should be added)
SirThalas 2 years ago
What a stupid comment senseili**********
Of course she isn`t Tarja and no one expects her to sing exactly the same or to hit the same notes!The point is,Nightwish used to have a unique sound with a Soprano power house and a Symphonic background now POP! It`s sounds more like a Karaoke track as does a lot of Annettes songs!
UKPatriotsFan 2 years ago
Mobile phone or high quality video equipment won`t make Annette sound any better!Sorry but although she is good to look at SHE CAN`T SING
UKPatriotsFan 2 years ago
How the fuck can you tell she sucks by listening to this record?!It's fucking made with a mobile phone you professional singers.
Why are you making such a big fuss about it ? Tarja started her solo career so go and praise her ( I like Tarja as much as I like Anette ).
FerralD3mur 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
omg u suck annette u cant sing plz leave nightwish u suck
medieval1377 2 years ago
hey! anette actually reached those high notes! and whoever says this is a key down you are wrong.
Kilicka123 2 years ago 15
i love this new nightwish age. anette yopur are amazing
dmaurixio1 2 years ago 10
man,even if god comes singing in NW it woudln't be enough for you,get over it,it's been 3 and half years since tarja left..gosh buy you self my winterstorm,cuZ OBVIOUSLY TARJA IS ONLY REASON WHY YOU LISTENED NW ,if you like NW you would like it even if adolf hitler comes singing,but you obviously care about the vocal and not about Tuomas's masterpieces so buy oyurself fucking my winterstorm,though you wont hear much,shitty lyrics bad music and comercialed voice
get a life
Lapsellinen 2 years ago 4
Tarja forever
Abu260892 3 years ago
Vesania0kgt, i'm agree with u :)
tkkbyjxrf 3 years ago
LOL she is singing like Tarzan
illidan934 3 years ago
freakin' a, man! Anette is awesome as fuck here!
detroitmadman 3 years ago 2
This song is so great that even Anette couldnt fuck it up! She can barely sing those high notes aside that whole song is tuned down whole step for her.Bad singer for this band period!
Jebemvamkevu 3 years ago
she's not screaming,... this song doesen't fit with her voice and she tries as harder as she can to sing good and she is on the right way
DrzSpectre 3 years ago
she is screaming not singing!Omg my ears!
myrtoulova 3 years ago
"she is screaming not singing!"
That's called belting.
YulieAna 3 years ago
she is very talented. You guys just want Tarja back and complaining isn't going to make a different. Noone can even try to go in the same vocal range as Tarja. The both are different and great vocalists in their own right.
yummiecupcakes123 3 years ago 5
I agree. The main reason that people hate Annette is simply because she's not Tarja. I think Annette is really good, different singing style, but still good. :)
senseilifesonsappren 3 years ago 3
Not to bad. I often wondered if she would be able to pull off the Tarja's songs (or rather the ones she sang as Tuomas wrote them and are essentially HIS). But when I saw them in concert in May, all doubt was erased from my mind. Absolutely phenomenal!!!
sunnieblodn5 3 years ago
BTW even with extremely crappy quality that makes everyone and everything sound and look like they're all underwater...she still sounds great ^^
melnnix 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can't stand Anette... D8
I sing better than her when I'm sick.
I'd kick her off a cliff if I could.
That day would be the happiest day of my life :'D She deserves it.
lostcause5 3 years ago
i'd do the same with you <3 You deserve it ;D
melnnix 3 years ago
Go jump after that lad!!
:P
MidnightMasque 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Only if you go first :3
melnnix 3 years ago
go jump of a cliff..
We won't miss you, I promise!!!
MidnightMasque 3 years ago
i said, only if you go first ;3
it'll be fun c'mon...jump! =D
melnnix 3 years ago
Well, you said that you wanted to kick her ass of a cliff! If my jump makes your NARROW mind oki.. Well, I might just.... Kick YOUR but first! Go home you morron! This band doesnt need this kind of fans!!! PS: I am a big Nightwish Fan since the first CD, so dont start me with that Tarja worshiping stuff!
MidnightMasque 3 years ago
LOL Midnight...i think you misunderstood my comment =P i said i would kick lostcause5 off a cliff, because i do like Anette too and i found absurd what she said =P
Like you i'm too a fan of nightwish from the first CD...i changed my mind...you don't need to jump =D heheh
melnnix 3 years ago
I disagree, I think she is great and very sexy. Tarja was great as well.
vkoo32 3 years ago
excuse me.."Your primitive brain isn't capable of understanding the concept of a music genre. " are you sauing that anette is better than TARJA? this is GARBAGr compared with what was NIGHTWISH! and if you really knew something about music you will say that tarja is a real artist in stead of insulting me!ok?and if you don`t care about my opinion, simply stop reading!
motocica 3 years ago 4
"Now crawl back into the cave you came from, asshole. " you peas of shit! everyone has the right to say his opinion..that is why comments are put here,retard!and if i don`t like her it`s my problem ok?Nightwis is singing pop music now because of that garbage called anette!so piss off!
motocica 3 years ago
You aren't saying your opinion, you are spewing insults on multiple videos over and over.
"Nightwis is singing pop music now because of that garbage called anette!"
You know jack shit about pop and music in general. Your primitive brain isn't capable of understanding the concept of a music genre. It's the same musicians playing the same song and it magically turned into pop because of a vocal change? You don't know wtf you're talking about.
YulieAna 3 years ago
As soon as you fuck off Nightwish videos with your bullshit and quietly migrate to the land of My Winter Storm, then i'll stop responding to you. Noone cares about your poor excuse of an opinion that is based on insults. Now go fuck yourself, asshole.
YulieAna 3 years ago
she is a sorry excuse for a human being!even the croud sings better than her!I HATE YOU BITCH!
motocica 3 years ago
"she is a sorry excuse for a human being!even the croud sings better than her!I HATE YOU BITCH!"
So, spewing garbage, because your primitive brain is incapable of rational thinking, constitutes as a fine addition to society? You're just another cliche fantard, who copies and pastes the same retarded shit on every video. Anette and Nightwish rock, you swim mediocrity. Now crawl back into the cave you came from, asshole.
YulieAna 3 years ago
perseestä
Xxkasumi 3 years ago
Worst Quallity
lordvoltimord 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
worst singing
Timelessdarkness 3 years ago
Lastly, I was sampling the new Nightwish to see what I thought. ~.^
ScarlettEnvelope 3 years ago
i am a big fan of Nightwish but anette cant sing like tarja
tasos654 3 years ago
of course, she is not Tarja...
Tarja can't sing as Floor Jansen, cause she is not Floor
simple as that
Adjanian 3 years ago 2
i simply can't stand listening to her singing.
ProphetCassandra 3 years ago
"i simply can't stand listening to her singing."
Yet you can't stop listening and bitching about how much you hate it.
YulieAna 3 years ago
Shit sound, shit video. why bother?
alfrmo63 3 years ago
YulieAna and jdm14789 I had fun reading your fighting, LOL! =)
Zeliziouz 3 years ago
sucks
EMBUUUR 3 years ago
In all fairness to YulieAna, although Nightwish songs are challenging, they are certainly not impossible. I can sing the vast majority of them even though I've had no vocal training. Although, I still find the higher ones like this one ^ and Stargazers tough.
Anyway, my original reason for commenting - Anette did pretty damn well! I love that girl. She's so fearless for stepping into Tarja's shoes, and no one seems to be giving her any credit for this!!!
eatallpiepods 3 years ago
who the fuck is she kidding.She should go back to her abba cover band, atleast there singing intune aint an issue.
MyFallWillBeForYou 3 years ago
I'd be careful there "MyFallWillBeForYou" yes I know its a free world and we both have the right to voice our opinions, but a certain "YulieAna" might come along in a minute and start preaching to you about how he knows everything about classical music and how its so easy to sing a nightwish song.
jdm14789 3 years ago
OOOO, yuppy! There is someone who advertises for me....for free too!
1)certain "YulieAna" can speak for herself.
2)certain "YulieAna" never said that Nightwish songs are easy. Learn to comprehend before you reply.
YulieAna 3 years ago
No problem!
Anytime :)
And because its you, its always free ;)
jdm14789 3 years ago
"And because its you, its always free ;)"
If that was supposed to be another insult, it came a bit backwords there. Might need some work there, sparky.
YulieAna 3 years ago
It was not meant as an insult.
jdm14789 3 years ago
Shes singing songs written for a classically trained opera singer.Course she isnt going to be at her best singng them. Anyone who is not classically trained singing Nightwish songs would have trouble with these songs not just Anette. Nightwish songs are so complex to sing anyway.
If anything you should respect the fact that she puts everything into these performaces and trys to sound her best at all time. No one is perfect.
She takes on these huge songs & gives it her all she has my respect.
jdm14789 3 years ago
"Shes singing songs written for a classically trained opera singer."
Not really, there is nothing complicated in Nemo or Wish I had an Angel, any well trained soprano can sing them...classical or not.
YulieAna 3 years ago
If its all right with you I'll let a real singer decide that. Not a nobody on youtube who thinks they know everything.
How you can sit there and say nemo is not hard to sing is beyond me. Singer are we?
jdm14789 3 years ago
"If its all right with you I'll let a real singer decide that."
From your previous statements i doubt you know anything about music in the first place.
"Not a nobody on youtube who thinks they know everything.
I know enough to recognize bullshit when i see it.
YulieAna 3 years ago
"How you can sit there and say nemo is not hard to sing is beyond me."
Of course it is, because in your universe Tarja exceeds even her own limitations.
I said Nemo is not a complicated opera song, any well trained soprano can sing it, thus it is not as complicated as you make it out to be in order to overrate Tarja some more.
YulieAna 3 years ago
And that's being said, i don't need the permission of a Tarja hang on to voice my opinion.
YulieAna 3 years ago
What fucking planet are you on? Where does it say I fucking worship the ground Tarja walks on!!!! I'm sick of you fuckin pompus assholes on youtube who think YOU KNOW EVERYTHING. First of all I was fuckin sticking up for Anette. Second who the fuck are you? You no fuck all about music you cheeky git! Ever sang nemo on stage infront of thousands of people? HAVE YOU SHITE thats why your on YOUTUBE! go get A LIFE!!!
jdm14789 3 years ago
"Ever sang nemo on stage infront of thousands of people?"
have you?
"HAVE YOU SHITE thats why your on YOUTUBE! go get A LIFE!!! "
Aha, and i suppose you have a fabulous agenda in front of you everyday, that's why you can't stop replying to my posts.
YulieAna 3 years ago
Your the same as the fanatic Tarja lovers who have sent death threats, your the version for Anette.
Now mind your own buisness (I know its hard). People have a god given right to make an opinion and you mate can do nothing about it :) not matter how many times you try pathetically to make yourself sound smart and bilital people, it does not work and you look stupid doing it.
Peace!
jdm14789 3 years ago
You said the songs were written for a "classical voice" when there is nothing classical in Nemo, Wish I had an Angel and most of the older material. I counterclaimed that, you got angry and started the pissing contest throwing personal attacks at me. When people do that, they usually have nothing better to day.
YulieAna 3 years ago
Your profile says your a student. That would explain the thinking your better than everyone else attitude. You think your better than everyone on youtube dont you?
jdm14789 3 years ago
"You think your better than everyone on youtube dont you?"
No, just better than the stupid people.
YulieAna 3 years ago
"Now mind your own buisness (I know its hard). People have a god given right to make an opinion and you mate can do nothing about it :)"
Perhaps you should follow your own advice? You've been attacking me with insults for thd past couple of days because i DARED to say something you didn't agree with.
Putting a smiley face next to the most hypocritical comment possible makes you an asshole. Practice what you preach.
YulieAna 3 years ago
Whats you fuckin musical background then hey? Mister fuckin I know everything about music? BOLLOX. Your a nobody on youtube. If you knew that much about music im sure you wouldnt be spending your life on youtube making your self sound good! YOUR SAD!
jdm14789 3 years ago
"Your a nobody on youtube."
A "nobody" that makes you pee your pants with angre.
"im sure you wouldnt be spending your life on youtube making your self sound good! YOUR SAD!"
What's sad is that you bring ZERO to this conversation, but make absolutely pointless personal attacks. You bore me.
YulieAna 3 years ago
I dont bring aything to the conversation because I dont respect you, and your not worth my brillance in conversation, so dont flatter yourself kid.
Your the same as all the other Anette protectors on here you jump down the throats of people who make the slightest reference to Tarja, when actually in the first place my comment was nothing but complementary to Anette, and you accused me of Worshipping Tarja.
jdm14789 3 years ago
"I dont bring aything to the conversation because I dont respect you, and your not worth my brillance in conversation"
Finest lie so far, in another words you ain't got shit.
I don't argue opinions, i argue the way they are voiced.
YulieAna 3 years ago
Who are you to define what is classical and what is not.
No you butted in on a comment posted. Which had nothing to do with you, you just think you no everything. But you dont.
jdm14789 3 years ago
"Who are you to define what is classical and what is not. "
Someone who knows far more about classical music and classical education than you do.
"No you butted in on a comment posted."
When people post on youtube, there are usually responses whether you like them or not, that is the point of a discussion thread. Big surprise there.
"Which had nothing to do with you, you just think you no everything."
I don't know everything, but i recognize a fool when i see one.
YulieAna 3 years ago
"I don't know everything, but i recognize a fool when i see one."
Thats funny because you can't see people on youtube. I think its you who's the fool mate. Student HA go back to school mate.
Seriously stop trying to belital its getting boring your a one trick pony all you do is try to sound smart its so see through.
jdm14789 3 years ago
"getting boring your a one trick pony all you do is try to sound smart its so see through."
Bullshit, you are still responding. making you tick ain't I?
YulieAna 3 years ago
"Student HA go back to school mate."
You are REALLY out of ideas now.
YulieAna 3 years ago
Your not making me tick, I find it highly amusing sitting here arguing with some one who is nearly thrity and is a student. Obviously im gettin to you, otherwise being the mature student you are you would of walked away ages ago. What is it? affraid backing down are we?
jdm14789 3 years ago
"I find it highly amusing sitting here arguing with some one who is nearly thrity and is a student."
I find amusing that you turned a Nightwish discussion into a personal attacks contest.
"Obviously im gettin to you"
Sticking "obviously" into a sentese won't make you sound any smarter.
"otherwise being the mature student you are you would of walked away ages ago"
And miss the yappings of a fool? NEVER!
YulieAna 3 years ago
"I find amusing that you turned a Nightwish discussion into a personal attacks contest."
You did that the moment you tried to make yourself sound smart as a defence.
Ok then, I'm getting to you. There said it without the Obviously :)
Not a mature student then are you. This is too easy now, getting bored.
jdm14789 3 years ago
"You did that the moment you tried to make yourself sound smart as a defence."
Offence is the best defence.
"Ok then, I'm getting to you. There said it without the Obviously :)"
I'm sure you've told that to yourself enough to believe it.
"This is too easy now, getting bored."
You've already said that, but yet you're still here.
YulieAna 3 years ago
"You've already said that, but yet you're still here"
so are you ...
jdm14789 3 years ago
Your comments are getting shorter, you're losing your touch.
YulieAna 3 years ago
My comments are getting shorter?
"Your comments are getting shorter, you're losing your touch"
Oh right yes beacuase that ^^^ must be the worlds longest comment.
jdm14789 3 years ago
coukd ytou to stop jabbering about something that is really not important?!
Elesach 3 years ago
"Finest lie so far, in another words you ain't got shit."
psychologist as well now are we? By god you really do think you know everything.
And you've been attacking me aswell mate if you can't take it don't dish it out. You've attack many people on here by the hundreds of comments you've posted. You must get a kick out of it or somthing.
jdm14789 3 years ago
"psychologist as well now are we?"
i never claimed to be one, but if you insist....
"And you've been attacking me aswell mate if you can't take it don't dish it out."
What are you 12? First you insult someone whose comment you didn't like that you play blame games?
"You must get a kick out of it or somthing."
I get a kick out of human stupidity and inability to handle other people's opinions.
YulieAna 3 years ago
in this day...Tokio-Hotel was show in israel too....no?!
cool song....:)
CookiePoli 3 years ago
Well unfortunately I saw them live a week ago and I can tell that Anette kills the old songs and her voice is not good live. And also she is dancing like a drunk punk girl. Shame for Nightwish. I don't like them anymore.
eldameldo1 3 years ago
you can't tell how her voice is with such a shitty video quality. anette is VERY good.
DarkestWorld 3 years ago
frankly speaking, she shouldn't sing Tarja's song. sounds horrible because she misses alot of what Tarja had
Icantfeeeeeelit 3 years ago 3
yeah, i agree with you. she's good but can't sing these songs...when i listen to her singing tarja's songs i miss tarja so much!
imaginary92 3 years ago
Agreed.There's no need to slaughter once beautiful songs,with the voice of a 16yold girl screaming as if she gets her nipples pierced...(this coming 2 days after i saw them live).Just stick to the new stuff...
Webgkil 3 years ago
I will be hopefully seeing this in March
I can't wait
I think it's good :)
Face it, Tarja's gone
She is truely missed
But make the most of Anette
She's ace
AngelsFallFirst666 4 years ago 5
how could they even let annette sing this song?.....oh why did tarja have to be such a bitch and go
SOACV 4 years ago
Well Tarja didn't leave... she was kicked out... I guess for being a bitch, lol, but I really don't know the details, they guys wont give it away in their page... at least they are respectful about the situation and manage it in a professional way.
wil529 3 years ago
Tranquilos todos. Aquí no se trata de cantar como Tarja ni de llegar a sus tonos, gracias a Dios. Se trata de adaptar las canciones. Porque si lo ponemos así ya directamente no cantaría ninguna canción de Nightwish. Por cierto, Creek Mary's Blood con ella es mas bonita que con Nightwish. Os animo a verla :D y en concreto esta canción tampoco me desagrada como la canta. Muy bonita, me gusta.
UnspokenScabbia 4 years ago
Anette deberia irse de Nightwish....Con eso lo digo todo
billykinderboy 4 years ago
Vaya, que elocuente. ¿Por qué debería hacerlo? Yéndose sólo contentaría a gente como tú. Y yo no pienso como tú. Creo que es un gran aporte para Nightwish y un cambio muy significativo para ellos. Yo adoro la voz de esta chica y estoy segura de que muchísimas personas más también. Las canciones suenan preciosas con ella. El grupo está a gusto y a los que nos gusta también lo estamos. No hay ninguna razón para que tenga que irse y sino me gustaría leer tu punto de vista si es que es algo lógico.
UnspokenScabbia 3 years ago
pues yo creo que contentaria a muchas mas personas si se va.
wil529 3 years ago
just a completly different song
IlEtaitUneForet 4 years ago
Por Diosssss, canta muyy maaalllll los temas viejoosss....Nightwish is so dead.Died when tarja was fired......
manuelitasssss 4 years ago
You know whats weird? I absolutley LOVE Tarja, but this version with Annette reminded me of how much I adore this song.
sketchbookessay 4 years ago
Anette isn't that good. I miss tarja..
Jonjondaleprechaun 4 years ago
i cant even focus on the ong b/c the filming sucked that bad
hellstoast 4 years ago
Hard to judge, I think.. Can you hear what she's singing?? I can't. Too bad quality
Natteoenske 4 years ago 2
Wow, she nailed those high notes really well. I was really worried her singing old NW song is gonna suck. Now I wanna see her live more than Tarja.
Still find DPS album mediocre though. I guess Tuomas's still fathoming Anette's vocal range and style.
Here's hoping for the next album.
msantaka 4 years ago
i don't really like anette and i'm going to see her in march xD
CryOfDistress 4 years ago
yea me too :D :P
xatikinxx 4 years ago
Que no les guste es una cosa, pero no tienen derecho a insultarla, ella no les hizo nada, no sean irrespetuosos.
Inferever 4 years ago
jajaja no tengo nada contra ella solo digo que a que estupido se le ocurre poner a cantar she is my sin con anette cuando todo mundo sabe no llega a la voz de tarja, pero bueno cada quien defiende a quien le guste si algunos les gusta la miereda pues que se enbarren en ella, y algunos como nosotros solo preferimos lo mejor
foxxxymania 4 years ago
totalmente te apoyo....no tiene un registro vocal para ello..."for the bride to dear for him" esa parte la super-violo...pero ni modo...las canciones del DPP estan decentes, su voz si puede con ellas. ya es "popwish"
sadrek 4 years ago
es que esta gente es estupida! jejeje! I think it's better with her than with tarja!
Evnightlerd 4 years ago
que asco de persona la verdad no le llega ni si quiera a los talones a tarja la verdad parece aficionada mas que cantante incluso yo que soy hombre canto mas al estilo de tarja...xD
foxxxymania 4 years ago
Shure you do, Tarja's style in these old songs used a very down-pitched voice, I mean, using high notes but with a low tendency... I mean, Tarja can sound like a kitten or like a lion! (Yeahhhhh Tarja FTW!!!) Anyway, Anette is not a bad singer, just some songs she should not touch.
HEDELEX 4 years ago 6
pff yo conosco a varios hombres k tiene un registro mucho mas alto k tarja
y algunos nisikiera son tenores
el registro de tarja es de 3 octavas
y conosco a un hombre k tiene un registro d ms de 4.5 octavas
acrator 4 years ago
lo mejor de todo es que nadie te pregunto jajaja estamos tratando tarja vs anette ademas no me importan tus amigos y creo que es obio que si su voz es aguda deja de ser tenor para convertirse en contratenor espero estudies mas sobre musica amigo po descracia tu amigo tampoco me alcanza jejeje pero ese no es punto
foxxxymania 4 years ago
y cuando dije k mis amigos cantan asi?
con conocer me referia a conocer su trabajo, no conocerlos personalmente
y yo tampoco dije nunca k su voz fuera aguda
si lees bien lo k dice yo staba hablando del registro y con alto me refiero a mas amplio
el decir alto no necesariamente se refiere a k sea mas agudo
y aki no se trata d kien te pide tu opinion
aki simplemente la das y ya
pork si no simplemente a ti tampoco nadie te pregunto si cantas o no como tarja
acrator 4 years ago
Bueno, dejémoslo. Hay gente que sino tira contra Anette de una forma tan subjetiva e insistente se aburre. Si todos fuésemos más objetivos seguro que Anette nos daría más de una sorpresa (aunque ya las está dando y muy bonitas ^_^)
UnspokenScabbia 3 years ago
y es precisamente lo k intento hacer
ser objetivo
y no cerrarse a algo de decir
"no me gusta como canta entonces canta mal"
sino decir
"bueno talvez no me gusta como canta pero sin embargo hace bien su trabajo"
a mi igual me gusta como cant anette
acrator 3 years ago
Bueno, quisiera estar de su lado chicos, pero la realidad es que encuentro que su voz es una blasfemia contra lo que alguna vez fue Nightwish. Lo siento pero es solo la opinion de una ex-fan, desde Angels Fall First. Pero no me opongo a Anette, simplemente creo que NW debe de empezar de nuevo, desde cero y Anette tambien, no miren sus albumes pasados, eso fue the end of an era, que sigan con su material nuevo, pero no dañen el anterior, por favor, por respeto a los fans!
wil529 3 years ago
precisamente eso es a lo k me refiero
tu dices k la voz de anette no va con lo k fue nightwish
y es la verdad
y sin embargo en cierta forma "apoyas" a anette diciedo k deberian volver a empezar
y tmb en eso estoy deacuerdo
de hecho cuando la escuche por primera vez lo primero k pense fue k deberian de cambiarse el nombre, pork esto ya no es nada parecido a lo k era antes y almismo tiepo le daba la oportunidad a anette de mostrar lo k podia hacer con esta banda
acrator 3 years ago 2
Sabes que? Creo que eso es lo mas inteligente que alguien por todos estos lares ha dicho, no podria estar mas de acuerdo contigo. Debieran cambiarse el nombre y empezar de nuevo, asi pues no atacarian tanto a Anette, seria mucho mas justo para ella y para Nightwish.
wil529 3 years ago
This is not bad at all 0.0
ImaginaryVoncroy 4 years ago
I somehow like Nightwish better with Anette than Tarja. Don't get me wrong, Tarja was amaizing. But still, Anette brings a little more life to to stage than Tarja.
Auronsan 4 years ago
she destroys this song with her pop attitude... someone should remind her shes in nightwish not fucking basshunter...
Frozenyak 4 years ago
She knows she is you idiot ;)
ImaginaryVoncroy 4 years ago
puta del orto morite
DarkMetal69 4 years ago
Nightwish is still cool, even with Anette. But i have to say, that the sound of that video is shit -.-
Seralpha15 4 years ago 3
klingt scheußlich!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
koriander2 4 years ago
I hate tuomas. He's such a fucking twat.
nocturneofsilence 4 years ago
Thats so true. I got the new NW cd Dark Passion Play and it seems like he made Annete a background singer, Tarja wouldn't do that so out she went for him to feel good.
bwinterb 4 years ago
LOL "Dark Passion Play" is 1 million times better than "Once" and Tarja's new album is hilarious - I cannot take that seriously. And oh, Tarja didn't leave the band because she wanted to, she was fired by whole band - anything more humiliating than that? ;)
ImaginaryVoncroy 4 years ago
Nope. Screw the Tarja f**kers. They bash NW, I bash Tarja. Oh M.W.S is a mediocre album.
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
Tarja's new album is great........
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago 6
Not. XD
xxxthoughtlessxxx 4 years ago
this makes me sick , really sick
pura puta mierda
fuck annete fuck new nightwish
hellazteka 4 years ago
I think Anette does it good!! I love this one... I'd rather this one than with Tarja! I'm being honest! I think... Nightwish still's good!
Evnightlerd 4 years ago
that's awesome!
I liked it :]
I wish I would go, and be there :\
Nightwish rocks, and the new singer is good!
Tourniquet75 4 years ago
i cant like her...i will not say any more...
tulkastuk 4 years ago
i do like Anette i think she rocks and i love there new album, but i don't think they should try to do the old songs, Anette and Tarja are totally diffrent styles, they're both good, just totally diffrent, it's like Tarja trying to do Cadence of Her Last Breath, it's would'nt work :-/
DemoraX 4 years ago
LOL. You must be deaf. Anette is the worst singer I have ever heard in my entire life!
haha4000hoho 4 years ago
Still, you can't stop listen to her?
MrBushman 4 years ago
I quite agree - how could they pick this singer from so many auditions? I can give them the number of a good singer if they want one!
allenevans1 4 years ago 4
u do that fast please!
cause i can't stand that screaming anymore, she's awful
nathaniell84 4 years ago
Anette is amazing!!
such bad quality thou!
ValerioMean1990 4 years ago
I loved Nightwish with Tarja but the band hasn't changed.One person doesn't change anything, because the lyrics and the music is still the same.Just move on and try to understand it.That is Tarja's own fault she's was sacked.Everyone is blaming Anette, I just don't get the point of blaming her.The band wanted and chose her,not you. And if you have only shit to say about them, then y ur listening to them Nah u kno SHUT THE HELL UP.(tarja fans anette haters)
HaloPcSimpsonsTV 4 years ago
i cant say how bad this is because of the bad quality but i think anette ruins this song ...
13eautiful13itch 4 years ago 2
yeah that's your problem
NocturnalStargazer 4 years ago
Ademas, para todos los que creen que los de Nightwish fueron unos tarados al botar a Tarja, ponganse ustedes en la posicion de que tengan una perra jodida en su grupo y se harten de ella porque esta cagando a todo la banda...no la botarian?
miguelvd90 4 years ago
Excelente!! creo que hay canciones antiguas (como esta) en las que la voz de Annette queda incluso mejor que la de Tarja (hay canciones en las que ya era como que demasiado la voz operatica). Sin embargo, definitivamente muchas canciones perderan su esencia sin la voz de Tarja... es el precio que hay que pagar, digo yo.
miguelvd90 4 years ago
xq ofendes a tarja tu no sabes lo q realmente pasó,en dado caso la perra seria anette x querer ser tarja....wash your mouth is like a dirty toilet...and also listen anette's voice,is horrible for the old songs,my ears are bleeding oh GGGGGRRRRRRRRRRRRR
minskii15 4 years ago
Bueno, asumo que no has leído la carta que le escribió Tuomas a Tarja después del último concierto...Por otro lado, Annette no sería la perra por ningún lado. Ella simplemente aplicó al puesto y los de Nightwish la eligieron.
miguelvd90 4 years ago
omg..this is live how can u even expect that she is gonna sing perfect? Its a bad quality too... I think Anette makes the band more fresh than before and I love it:D
Gundilf 4 years ago 2
me....Do you have any problem????
NFEEFE 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i got no problem with garbage lovers, we need scavengers, just saty away from me ... u smell nasty
nathaniell84 4 years ago
U r pathetic.....
If you don't like something just stay away from it.Don't critisize everything!
NFEEFE 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
just joking about scavengers ...
but her live performance is a crap ...
nathaniell84 4 years ago
Just explain me something...
If you don't like this video why are you around all the time commenting it???????????
You need something called MIND....
Just because we are not like you,it doesn't mean you are better and you can critisize us for what we like.
NFEEFE 4 years ago
o ... NW is just funny with that new chick singing ..., ill keep watching them hoppeing Tarja will return one day, that song bye bye be. sure tells something
ok, ... srry about that scavengers thing again
calm now?
nathaniell84 4 years ago
who like that crap?
nathaniell84 4 years ago
Mmmmm......la verdad que Nightwish sin Tarja no es lo mismo,Anette se esfuerza para cantar,pero creo que debería limitarse a cantar como lo hacía Tarja, asi lo queremos los fans!! que no malogre la cancion pretendiendo poner cosas nuevas, así como lo hacía Tarja estaba mejor. He escuchado el nuevo disco de Nightwish y en verdad ya parecen Evanescence,muy comercial para mi gusto, en serio, que regrese Tarja!!!!
guillermogz1982 4 years ago 2
es pura basura esta tipa no sabe cantar lo unico ke hace es GRITARRRRR ojala ke no dure mucho en Nightwish..........
VIVA TARJAAAA!!!!!!
vivimarilyn 4 years ago
llorones, llorones, llorones...supongo que son maestros en sonido ya que pueden distinguir tantos tonos en un video grabado con una videocámara personal en un concierto, en donde con suerte se escucha algo, pero como son tan llorones Juzgan y Juzgan y Juzgan, entiendan algo, tarja no volverá pero nightwish sigue, si quieren a poyar a tarja, compren sus Álbumes de solista pero no la agarren con la nueva cantante, saludos.
wildforcex 4 years ago
Those who do actually agree are people who do care, dumbass.
lostcause5 4 years ago
no one cares who agree's with you nab...stop listen to nightwish if you dont like Aneete and gtfu
Godlike836 4 years ago
I agree with you!
Tarja is my hero...
Even after her career ended with Nightwish...
Tarja > Anette
Forever and always.
lostcause5 4 years ago
Christ!!!!! no way!!!! I want Tarja back!!! what is this??? Anette can't sing..... bleeee:(( who agrees with me????
bissska 4 years ago
I do...totally. This is utter crap, a disgrace.
Lily033 4 years ago
my ears are hurting me
nathaniell84 4 years ago 3
nightwish cometio el peor error al haver echado a tara relmente al escuchar esto me deprime se escucha mal y no es la grabacion ella chilla los tonos altos la matan y debe cantar marco para tratar de ayudarla.
realmente pense q se podria salvar la banda pero me equivoque.
suena a nightwish pero ya no se transmite lo mismo.
anyelinshadows 4 years ago
anette tiene excelentes agudos..no se q mierda escuchas...de hecho tarja en vivo era muy desafinada...en end of en era masacra ciertos temas
NeoNoks 4 years ago
imbecil, staba nferma y aun asi, lo hizo excelente
knavis15 4 years ago
imbecil vos tarado...no tan excelente.
a mi me gusta la voz d tarja..solo digo q era media desafinada aveces, y q anette es muy clara y golpea bien las notas...bye bye dumbass ;)
NeoNoks 4 years ago
masacre fue escuchar a anette tratando de cantar las canciones de nightwish con tarja
si quieres oir masacre escucha a anette en dark chest... es horroroso.
no digo q cante mal,me gusta su voz pero pero es como escuchar a lacuna coil o sea otra cosa.
anyelinshadows 4 years ago
es hasta q nos acostumbremos..otra no nos keda...
NeoNoks 4 years ago
bad karaoke singer
pertteri 4 years ago
She cant song She is my Sin, The siren, or Te kinslayer cuz she just cant. hear this, she is screaming.. lol but let daywish dream more please
nacos1990 4 years ago
in this crappy quality you say you hear anette?? seriously you cant judge her after a crappy youtube video.= that the fans are singing along.
DarkestWorld 4 years ago