Added: 3 months ago
From: l1lxbunny
Views: 87,753
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (283)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Sweet troll jegus, that was quite possibly the most beautiful thing in the omniverse.

  • My. Poor. Heart. ;____;

  • i am sad now. but it's a good sad.

    

  • i love how you made daveified it

  • I'ts a good song. But techno solo is pretty anoying. :3

  • ALL MY TEARS

  • Did no one else notice... this song ends at 3:41.

  • Beautiful job! *sniffle*

  • Sadstuck is sad ;__;

  • So much Love... Bro and Dave are the best....

  • Bro :'(

  • omg i almost cry ( * A *) i love it

  • EPIC BR0 :3

  • My heart is literally aching....

  • sad but amazing

  • This is just so beautiful ;-;

  • wait..did bro die?

  • @capeofdarkness Quick! Go read some more! It's URGENT.

  • I want to make one of these but I know I could never make anything this great.

  • My sister drew this. Awesome :)

  • @CampyMcCamperPants ....Randy?

  • @cgeezman Yes, hello there. :) Although I'm afraid you have me at a disadvantage.

  • Yeah, I lost it "trying to fall behind."

    That's when I noticed Lil Cal's reflection pop up on Bro's sword.

    Okay, but seriously, the ending really got to me; how they're both each other's "Bro," and it's just a punch to my feelings to see them standing side by side like that. While my absolute favorite character is whoever the narration is following at the moment, the Striders will always hold a special place in my heart. Good characters, best video.

  • Definitely needs a "sadstuck" tag :(

  • Sometimes...I think some songs were made just for homestuck... :')

  • ;___;

  • This video is honestly amazing. It broke my heart - in a good way, but nevertheless.

    To be honest, in order to 'catch up', I read the early(ish) pages of Homestuck very quickly, and never paid attention. Dave never rubbed me the right way, and other than being epic with Rose, I didn't get why he was there.

    Rereading his arc, I now realize - rather, fully remember - that he has one of the worst character arcs in the game.

  • It was the headphones part that really got me

  • @gaaraissoawesome Me, as well. I think we all noticed him always wanting to go back to doing nothing more than messing around with music and rapping - as someone else said, he wanted to stay "dave of guy"; he didn't want the responsibility of a player in the game because he knew he'd dissapoint.

  • at least he will be able to meet dirk(bro) again when dirk enters his session. :DD

  • A friend has told me I should read it, but somehow I could not get used to the style, so I guit... while clicking around on youtube I accidentally stumbled on this video ... this video is the reason I´m now reading Homestuck, ... it´s awesome, Thanks...

  • What song is thiis??

  • @RunningEcho Eet by Regina Spektor

  • @Gumbosplat Well now i feel stupid..

  • @Gumbosplat Is this a remix or something?

  • @RunningEcho It's her Cityboy Remix

  • Do you always get that feeling where you suddenly remember why you like a certain character?

    I think I may have been reminded why I love Dave, and for that matter, Bro, so much.

  • Songs like these make me loves characters. ;__;

  • Homestuck so far is the greateast thing I have ever read in my life.The deep in the story is just incredible.

    I would like to say thank you to the creator of this video.Because of you,I have discovered Homestuck.Thanks owo/

  • OW! Right in the feels... ;__;

  • ow...

  • Cried like a bitch, not gonna lie. And I don't cry easily....

  • So fantastic! Truly a masterpiece. ^u^ Thank you for making this. I'll always love homestuck for this. So many artists and dreams swinging in and out into the blue.

  • My tears... All of them..

  • One of my favorite songs...

    This is so beautiful but so sad ;-;

  • OMG The "Using your headphones to drown out your mind" is so deep. This vid is awesome

  • FUCK IM IN THE SADSTUCK PART OF YOUTUBE AGAIN.

  • 1:03 I see little cal on his sword. :3

  • Thank lord I'm not the only one that cried.

  • a lot of people ask, "Why is Dave so popular?" and if you don't know the reason, obviously you haven't payed enough attention. Just, his character, doomed timelines, all of it, SO MANY FEELINGS.

  • Did anyone else literally "feel the chill"? 

  • dontcrydontcrydontcrydontcry "its his turn but his brother wont let him try" OH GOG WHY!!!!! WAAAAAAAHHHH!!! DX

  • Comment removed

  • DON'T FUCKING CRY 

  • It's like forgetting the words to your favorite song.

    Oh irony; i tried singing this song to my friends but i forgot the words to my favorite song.

  • New head canon theme. Just... Holy shit, I literally almost cried.

  • This is quite possibly my new favourite.

  • I couldn't finish the video.. my heart hurts :[

  • Only tears now

  • i c8nt even........no words. None of them.

  • Enjoyable unexpected dubstep.

  • Ellie. If your reading this, then I want you to know I love you.

  • The only time I have ever enjoyed any bit of dubstep. Probably only because I was oogling at God Tier Dave at the same time.

  • YOu are freaking Awsome

    YOu get all the awsome things!

    I love this

  • This video gets me every time. Love it all. <3

  • 3 minutes 41 seconds

    Creepy.

  • Also. ALL OF MY CREYS.

  • ... Am I really the only one who notices the "lolz" in the URL?

  • ON AN SOMEWHAT UNRELATED TOPIC: Every game has a sort of Scratch or Glitch, I believe. The trolls in John's universe were supposed to be in Jane's session, from what I remember Doc Scratch saying. The trolls' ancestors/predecessors couldn't possibly win their game, so they CHOSE to release the scratch, thus dooming every game after.

    Idk I have dumb head-canons.

  • I have a love/hate relationship with this video. You see, I love Regina Spektor. I love the art. I love how well the lyrics go with the images. I enjoy some of the melodies that this remix added to the original song.

    But I hate the drop. I hate most drops in dubstep songs, but I hate this one especially. Drops do not belong in a Regina Spektor song. They don''t belong in a video that's supposed to evoke emotions.

    I want to love this video unconditionally, but that drop infuriates me.

  • I'm sorry. But like, at 1:27. With my heart sore with sorrow because this song is touching and the drawings are purrfect, I couldn't help but think. 'DAT. ASS.'

  • ....okay back to my crying my eyes out. again.

  • Why do I always respond to this emotionally.... its sends a very strong message and I keep coming back to this...

  • Tears are every where, I can't handle this--

  • I'm glad people make things like this. Most people only make videos about the trolls, which, in my opinion isn't very fair because the story revolves around the kids, not the trolls, and most of the trolls are dead now anyways. Don't get me wrong, they play an important part in the story, but people overlook the kids because of them :(

  • i just sobbed all over my dog someone help this is too sad and perfect

  • As much as the "his brother won't let him try" bit is perfect for Dave, my favorite part is "You've spent half of your life / trying to fall behind." It reminds me of Dave just wanting to be "the dave of guy" - not because he doesn't WANT to be a hero, but because he doesn't feel like he deserves it. He doesn't want the responsibility because he knows he'll only fail no matter how hard he tries, he'll never be as good as Bro or John. ;__; Favorite kid.

  • I think this is the best Homestuck video that I've seen to date

  • oh my... this is perfect.

  • Not gonna lie. I teared up a little.

  • Wow, this is just gorgeous. And fucking brilliant song choice. AMAZING ALL AROUND.

  • Holy mother of Hussie, this is brilliant.

  • WOW.

  • fucking shit, creying

  • Who else lost it at "its his turn but his brother wont let him try"?

  • First, I gotta say I have all these FEELINGS now. Damn you. Damn you for being so awesome.

    Secondly, thanks for giving me a headcanon that Godtier Dave is like the realization of each instance in every timeline. Doomed or no, as a sort of successor that carries on their will.

    Third, as a nitpick to get SOME negativity out of this happy-fest, I think it might have been a bit to better dissolve to and from black in the first -eet section rather than the clean cut. But that's all.

  • Comment removed

  • @Farsinian Part Two

    On a fourth note, on the line "Now it's his turn, but his brother won't let him try." While I agree with another person down below that it could be talking about Bro taking Dave's place in the new session, I think that given both the event that opened the video and the pool of blood with the sword that transitioned right after, I believe it better describes a sense of fatalism on Dave's part.

  • @Farsinian

    Now that his bro is dead, and after seeing all his other selves dead, he feels that it's his duty to die, as a sacrifice to protect the other kids. In his mind, they're simply worth more than he is. The brother in the line could mean either Bro, in the vague way of always trying to protect and train Dave, or Rose, who very specifically tried to save Dave by putting him to sleep as Derse's moon drifted towards the Green Sun.

  • This is beautiful. Just. Just woah.

  • sobs

  • ouch my heart

  • Oh my god this is amazing. Dave is my favorite <3

  • Oh my god Regina Spektor and dubstep. <3

  • 8 people dislike this......8 people have no heart or soul. 

  • This. Is. So. Beautiful. ;_; Almost made me cry... I love it. <3

  • Oh god.

    I can't describe the awesomeness of this song and video itself.

    I really want to do singing-sign language with God-Tier Dave cosplay or Dave cosplay for the Deaf Idol. And yup I am deaf. Well. It hard to explain how i could hear.

  • @MochiMochiXD Through the vibrations? Just guessing, sorry if i'm wrong. D;

  • It's honestly like this song was made for the character....

  • o m f g.

  • Because that's the thing about memories, Amy Pond. If they can be remembered, they can always come back.

  • BEST BROTHERS EVER ;A;;

  • @Izon22 The poster of this video has already pointed out it's not Caledfwlch, but the Royal Deringer.

  • 3:41

  • This. Is. The. Definition. Of. Perfect. <3

  • First, I watched this. Then I realized I have no playlists that this fits under (since this is way more then a favorite) so I made a new one. It's called "Exceptionally Perfect Videos" and this is the only one in there so far.

  • I WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO EXPRESS THE INFINITE AMOUNT OF LOVE I HAVE FOR THIS VIDEO

  • 8 peo

  • Eet city boy remix

  • They say the Scratch resets everything in the game, right down to the circumstances leading to them playing the game in the first place

    ...

    What if that wasn't their first time playing?

  • @TheUncannyValley0 i think there's only one Scratch per universe, and the second session is a guaranteed win.

    or something.

  • @Izon22 There's a scratch in every game, I think.

    Just sometimes you won't need it. ^^

    I'm guessing that when the new kids win, their game will create the new troll universe. And possibly the same thing will happen to the trolls that happened to the first kids. It said that the troll's first time didn't win, so it'll lead up to the circumstances that made it win the second time around, thus creating John and Dave's universe. Infinite loop much?

  • So close to 43,100 views

  • 3:10 - 3:15 damn you Lord English

  • bRoMaNcE iS a MoThErFuCkInG mIrAcLe, It'S bEaUtIfUl, BrOs :,o(

  • oh my god...

    this was one of the most amazing things i have ever seen in my entire life

  • 8 people aren't ironic and cool enough to love this video.

  • I don't even like Homestuck and this is fucking beautiful. That takes alot.

  • I have successfully watched it with only a lump in my throat and misty eyes!

    That took about ten views...

  • Pause at the perfect part of 1:04, right after the word "behind."

    HAA HAA HEE HEE HOO HOO

  • Wearing makeup. Must not cry. Must not--oh crap. ):

  • Man, Blue Lips did nothing to me, but this one is INCREDIBLE.

  • i am drowning in my tears ;-;

  • I accidentally at Dave's Godtier

  • Now do Sail On in the same scrolly fashion? ; ^; <3?

  • The part where the beat drops right as it shows Dave in God Tier was genius.

  • Dave is a very unique character, however 'mainstream' he may seem. He has always had to prove himself, coming 2nd to his brother. Also claiming John is a hero, Bro is a hero, he's no hero. However hard he tried, he failed. But when Bro died, it was the first time he had actually shown how we has feeling, he had to be unbelievably strong throughout all of Homestuck. I love Dave.

  • the build up before god tier dave is GODLY. no pun intended.

  • this is so perfect and tear

    jerking okAY i am going to cry for forever

  • I like how at 1:43 the tumor has 1:43 on it.

    Also, 413.

  • I LOVE the part at the very end with Dave and Bro. The words are so perfect right then.

    'Because it's his turn, and his brother won't let him try.'

    And then Bro gets to try.

  • can I cry now

    this is alright

    right

    yes

  • I'm bleeding rainbows from my eyes... Ironically.

  • It was like 'EET' and I was like 'AAH' and then I sobbed a little.

    So amazing. No words.

    But ALL of the thumbs up.

  • I tell myself I won't cry every time I watch this.

    ... I still yet to reach that goal.

  • Sometimes i just don't understand how someone could dislike something.

    I'm gonna give a benifit of the doubt and say that it's cause this video is sad and they're mad that they haven't yet learned to cry :'(

  • AHHH the end gave me chills ;__;

  • At first I was watching but then I VRRR WIRR BUBUBUUWUUWBWBUWBUWBUWBUWBUWBU­WBUBWUWBU WR VWUWUWUWUBWUBWUWBUBWUW'd

  • This gave me shivers. <3

  • this is perfect and i am crying. the end. ;n;

    <3

  • Can I just say that I love the way one of Dave's themes was edited into this?

  • 3:01 ALL OF MY TEARS, ALL OF THEM.

  • Wow, this is really amazing.

  • the drop though

  • I KEEP WATCHING THIS. AND I KEEP. CRRRYYIIIINNNGGG~!!!

  • I could never get into homestuck, but gosh darn it, I love the character designs!

  • @MissSenna96 Not to force, but you should give it another try! Many people end up liking it when they were sure they weren't. It's a bit of an acquired taste to get into.

  • @JeanKP14 Very true. I'm the poster child of this. Took me three tries, I had to skip several acts.

    Reread it after, of course.

  • ...oh

    D-Dave ; n ;

  • Everything about this and homestuck in general...it just all gives me so many feelings ;_;

  • @RandomKPluver Also, when it scrolled down to his God Tier..oh god, I got chills.

  • SO AMAZING

  • As seen on: Homestuck

    Wat.

  • Dear God. That was the best Dave video I've ever seen. I actually feel SHAKEN.

  • already commented but i cannot stop watching this vid. it is just so incredibly well-made. props to you for doing something so stellar with only two months of sv under your belt! may i ask what version of sv you're using?

    frankly i don't see the major imperfections you mention in the description! literally the only thing i would've done differently is adding some vid distortion when the song starts going wubwub. :>

    so so so tragic and captures dave perfectly. your efforts definitely paid off!

  • Just want to make this song even sadder by pointing out that none of Dave's panels are seen through the fourth wall during cascade.

    Guess what that means.

  • @Feresten Wait, he's alive though.

  • I love how when the clock at 1:43 hits 1:43 the same time as the video

  • I can't even finish the video! my heart can't take it.. :(

  • help i can't hold...all my feelings.......

  • Could I know what program you used to make this video?? It's truly amazing *-*

  • there's a rumor going around that, because there was no dave panels present as the kids rewound the comic in the scratch ([S] Cascade), dave won't show up in the new session... that idea just makes this video sadder....

  • I watched this and cried :''''''''(

    This is awesome on the rick tor scale of sadness :''''}

  • And I just noticed Lil Cal in Bro's sword....

  • I just...wow I cannot express how much I love this. So many emotions! It is easily one of my favourite Homestuck related thing. The fandom helped me get into Homestuck and it helps me stay with it, and I can say this may be the only series where I can say such. Thank you all!

  • D --> Oh my. I am in need of a towel for my sweaty eyes.

  • This is one of my favorite Homestuck related videos on YouTube. The remix of the music is amazing, the artwork is fabulous, it's just overall... epic! I really love the transitions between each image, it really ties it together. :3 Dave is definitely near the top of my favorite list out of the four kids, and I'm glad this featured him. <3 And thank you so very much.

  • There were many "thank you so much." comments, but how am I supposed to resist to leave one?...

    A huge, well deserved thank you.

  • This fandom is terrifying but this video and this remix are awesome.