Added: 3 years ago
From: AmericanIdolBigTv
Views: 36,696
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (112)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I actually TOTALLY agreed with simon when I saw this performance

  • While I KINDA agree with Simon.He's always gonna have something bad to say about someone.If you take a risk it's too big if you don't take a risk it's too boring.It's his nature.Most of the things he says doesn't matter anyway.

  • She was incredible! Why did she get such bad critiqe? She was sick! You woud have never even realized.

  • the end of the perfomance was amazing!

  • Listen youtube.com/watch?v=rpkJD7TjWg­w&feature=related

    MUCH MUCH MUCH better!!!

  • Comment removed

  • ouch

  • so sad she had to be sick for this song! but being sick and sounding this good blows my mind! she is amazing!!

  • i don't like her voice

  • That was funny when Simon said that to Ryan. Lmao. But i think she did a good job under the circumstances and yeah she could have chosen another song but I guess she wanted to see if she could give it her all and have it still work out.

  • i was surprised

    at the first 'all by myself'

    i was like oh shit this is gonna suck

    then she just hit that big note

    i was like wow

  • she slaughtered the song...sounded very tone deph...

  • @nichya11 no she was so sick that week!!! it was sad! she was talking about it!! she isnt off key so i dont what ur talking about!!

  • i love this song

  • @b5fan4lyfeboo23 Then check out the legit version /watch?v=naPgrhX6rIk

  • Why is everyone so mean?! This girl was sick and still she did a very good job with it!!! Probably the nerves made her screw the lyrics at the beginning; but come on she did what she could... she was sick. I'm pretty sure that if she had being healthy she would have nailed it :P Still the record for the best rendition on AI has to go to Latoya London :D

  • she killed!!!!!!!!

  • The song was to big for her.

  • yeah this performance is off

    she shouldn't have sang the song this way

    celine sings is so much better

  • ii think she did gud &&.* she do not suck...she's awesome...

  • Sorry...her voice just wasn't right for this song particularly. Those high notes just didn't sound as they should have and really LASERED through the audience. Instead, they filled the stage like a mellow wave. It wasn't bad, but there was no spark.

  • i agree with simon..

  • I wish she wasn't voted off, I loved her!

  • WOOOOW!! CAN SOMEONE SAY MEAN!! Simon is sooo harsh she wasn't bad she did great in my opinion!

  • I have heard better versions, but I think Simon is wrong. It wasn't perfect, but she did well.

  • yeah, she sucks

  • i really love her voice but i can understand why people would vote her off though STIL LIKE YOU THOUGH:P

  • her voicde is so good

  • she iz great

  • Not right song. She's not a diva.

  • this was the week she was sick and i think she did pretty good considering

  • i love!!! beautiful voice1!!!

  • In 1:43 she was the end of her road, it messed............this song is too big for her, she took the silly risk......simon is right!

  • her vocal doesn't good at all.......how can she go this far?

  • Season 8 isnt even close to season 7

  • ARE YOU KIDDING???

    Season eight's contestants are incredible!!!!!

    Minus Anoop.

  • Agreed!!!

    Lil, Allison, Danny, Kris, and Adam are the best

  • i loved megan

  • the only good one i season 7 was carly

  • "and even though the night's a-young" lol

  • this was still one of the best seasons everyone was super suportive and this year sucks in comparison

  • sloppy

  • diva song? it was written by a rock singing GUY!

  • simon is absolutely right. you have to know your own limitations

  • She shouldve made the Top 12, but she shouldve chosen songs more suited to her range.

  • She totally hit the note at the end and in the middle!!!

  • whoops at 1:43

  • I think that Kady Malloy, performs like Asiah when she was acting robotic...

  • I am sorry to say but all of you are wrong. and I want you asia'h to know that I am in deep love with you and I think that Simon is and absolute asshole on this judgment. If I had a baseball bat I wouldbash his head in. Please find me asia'h I Want you

  • truue but if she wasent sick she would of done qood..buhtt she still did good

  • Well it wasn't really her faught she was sick

  • the thing is that this is a Soprano song, and this girl is a Contralto, so is Clear that if she sings in the natural tone, the song is not gonna come out well, anyway think she did a great job

  • Asia'h is a great singer!

    Her fault was her song choice

    Celine and Whitney's was too big for her vocal ability

    But,I still love her!

  • I think Leona lewis sang it much better then her even I like her voice I never say she has a ugly voice because thats not true but I prefer when LEONA sing this song or of course my dear Celine dion

  • she's good but she fail a note right?

  • for me, Asia'hs's problem was that for Idol diehards, "All By Myself" will always & forever be LaToya's song.

    She did ok with it. She definitely did have better performances... I think what it ultimately came down to was her song choice

  • Her voice is actually very nice and sexy... the only thing shes lacking is the power in her voice... but that can be worked on

  • luv her

  • 0:11 DAMN!!!

  • when hearing this you have to listen to la toya's version and know she was lacking.

  • did anyone notice that instead of saying "and making love was just for fun" she says "and even though the night is young"?! why is that?? that sounds rediciouls! did you see her little smile when she said that? she knew it's wrong! i hate fucking puritans americans! what, even "makin love" is too much 4 tv? you are idiots!

  • its coz she messed up the lyrics!

  • naaa i don't think so at all! i think that's what they told her to sing and she smiles because she knows it sounds rediciouls..

  • she's so amazing and should have made it to at LEAST! THE TOP 12!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! she was so amazing. out of all of the girls she was my favorate i was sad that she left. :(

  • i don't like this performace

  • omg i love her voice and personality

  • Your and asshole.

  • It makes me so frustrated when others seem to not realize that she is sick fo real!

  • the Oher Contestants were also cheering for her, and she did a real good job 2: 10

  • Search for marie picasso all by myself. She can sing the song so you get chills.

  • GOD,THIS IS MY FAV SONG THAT SHE SANG!!

  • It's very obvious she's sick...

  • i wish she would have lasted way longer! top 3 at least!!!

  • did her dad really die? she seems way to happy for someone whos lost theyre father

  • Yes, her dad really died. I think she's a little nervous and she doesn't know how to react in front of the cameras. That's the same way I always react.

  • I disagree, she is a beautiful and stunning girl

  • 5 stars!!!!!

  • She pulled the song off even though shes sick and she looked beautiful

  • i think this was the best song she ever sung on american idol! this rocked!

  • Bad choice for her, but I miss her...she wes one of my favorites.

  • She's really good!Although she did mess it up a bit on the first ''all by myself'' part.

  • who made this song

  • celine dion

  • no. she sang it, too, but it's by eric carmen. actually, it's by rachmaninov, eric carmen just changed some parts and put the lyrics on it.

  • i love her. she has an amazing voice!

  • I love her voice its unique, but this was a Tall Order. To compare her to LaToya London and Gina Glocksen it was stronger than Gina but not go to LaToya. But it had lovely moments. I wonder what it would have sounded like when she wasnt sick.

  • look at little david clapping for her in the back

  • i dont think she should've gone so soon. she deserved to stay more

  • yeah she wasnt that bad i wanted her in the top 12

  • I LOVVEE Asia'h!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • she has a very nice vabrato, and is an extremely talented singer.

  • she should've done i surrender. good for her voice, no?

  • She just doesn't have a big enough voice to be singing whitney or celine.

  • what a brave girl

  • zaqmko26 if ye dnt lik her y do ye watch her ?.... simple as!! >=[

  • Charice Pempengco - All By Myself

  • Jealous?

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more