"Four-fifths of the whole population are Moslems. Some 77,000 of the population are Christians, in large majority belonging to the Orthodox Church, and speaking Arabic. The Jewish element of the population numbers 76,000. Almost ALL have entered Palestine during the last 40 years. Prior to 1850 there were in the country only a handful of Jews."
- League of Nations 1920 Interim Report
-> "Almost ALL (Jews) entered during the last 40 years!"
I don't think you understand... INNOCENT HUMANS ARE BEING KILLED in Palestine- to a mass scale by soldiers with guns and tanks. So people in Palestine are fighting any way they can by ending their own life; not in the name of Religion, but for their people, more than an Israeli could ever do. Essentially you're condoning children being killed for land that doesn't belong to you; justified by the 'fact' jewish history isn't being taught in their schools. Yep, you're messed up.
@LyndaHEYYY What 's all messed up your base assumptions in response to a video, you repeating the propaganda of the Palestinians, even before I checked, I knew you from the UK. The British would be the last to be discovered they had lied to them, now I do not cause discussion, with time you will discover it for yourself, and I will be there to laugh at the stupidity and ignorance, good day(:
@asaf921 So are you denying innocent civilians being killed by Israeli soldiers? If the answer is yes you're the ignorant one. I don't care what propaganda you think is being shown to me, when i see actual photos and footage, that's enough for me.
@LyndaHEYYY I see you only care about the consequences of war, yes, war is shit!, And every war is a shame to mankind,if you really cared about people you would trying to discover the root problem that caused the war to begin with, and try to avoid it.What you're really doing is looking for someone to fight him and charge him under the pretext of humanity,that the worsens the situation is not helpful, now answer me what the source, the word apartheid,and what this is the definition of apartheid
@andrewsummey I'm palestinian and I was never taught those things. You tend to focus on extreme lows of Palestine but you don't even consider what they've been through. Isreal was made because Britain put all the jews in Europe who wanted their own country there. What do you think this country of people would do when they're forced out of their own country. I live in the United States because my family had to leave Palestine. I love it here; but those people their deserve a place for themselves.
Say NO to Zionist ethnic supremacism, terrorism and war-mongering!
Racist losers like Andrew Summey who support the ethnic cleansing of over 5 million indigenous Palestinian Arabs from their homes simply because they are seen as ethnically inferior are no better in the slightest than Nazis kicking gypsies out of their homes to make "living space" for what Hitler considered the "Chosen people"
Why is it that the 117-page Amnesty International report "found no evidence of Palestinian militants using human shields to stop Israeli attacks, but it accuses the Israel Defence Forces of launching attacks from buildings in which Palestinian civilians were sheltering, and charges Israeli forces with killing hundreds of unarmed Palestinian civilians and wanton destruction of thousands of homes."??
Thirdly you say the shouldn't have state because they encourage their children to be murderers well so do many israeli's just look at some of the radical settlers and you don't say they don't deserve a state. Also not all palestinians encourage their children to murderers so don't generalize.
Finally i'd just like to say this is not a black and white conflict where the israelis are good and the palestinians are bad. There is a lot of gray areas.Just do a little research on what happened in '48
@MrPatbradley22 I've done a lot of research into '48. I see it very differently than you. '48 is simply about the move toward sovereignty and freedom for the Jewish people and their defense from the many nations around them looking to kill them all and wipe out the new Jewish state - Israel. Palestinian society does encourage their children to murder in this way. It is tragic. It is sad. It needs to be stopped and shunned.
@andrewsummey aight you can view it like that if you want too. I view it as an act of european colonialism that displaced the indigenous population and raped their way of life. i also don't believe there is a man in the sky that awards land to people or takes sides in wars.
@MrPatbradley22 So you don't believe in a man in the sky and then have a name for him, interesting. First, there is no man in the sky, you are right, second, who is this Joseph Smith, and thirdly, There is a creator to this world, he is God, and if you look in the bible you will see his promise to the Jews to give us the land of Israel which includes, Sinai, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and more by the way.
@potato21012 hahahahahahahahahahahaaahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahahhahhahahahhahahhahahahhahahahahahahahahhhahahahahhhahahaaahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahhahahahhahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahha...there is no god btw. the bible also says to kill people if they don't observe the sabbath. do you also think you should do that?
@MrPatbradley22 You are right, I don't THINK there is a God, I KNOW there is a God and one God only (I do not support Christianity, thus the one, they are idol worshipers). And If you think there is no God, than how was the world created? (If you say there was a big bang then that is irrational, and if there was a big bang than that is what is called in the Bible "Let there be light", but no bang can create anything).
@potato21012 if you say that you are 100% certain in the existence of a supernatural being yes you do need to provide evidence to back up you view. otherwise people can start claiming all kinds of crazy things with no evidence and say that they are facts.
@potato21012 when did you give me proof? you said "I don't need to prove anything." yes i am an atheist and you haven't answered my questions, so don't get all holier than thow on me.
@andrewsummey what does "naw, but God might ;)" mean? and 18 years of going to a catholic church and high school makes me understand the bible and that it is insane book that contradicts itself, preaches hate and is clearly not true.
Your second reason is that they want a jew free state. Well avigdor lieberman the deputy prime minister of israel feels the same way about the arabs in israel. Many other israeli's feel the same way but i don't see you saying that there shouldn't be a jewish state. Saudi arabia which i sure is a country you don't like bans jews but i don't see you saying they have no right to exist.
@MrPatbradley22 What you said about Lieberman is misrepresenting him. And, I'd rather not have Saudi Arabia as it is right now for that very reason. I would not want it to come into existence with their current treatment of non-Muslims and I would not want my country to vote or help it come into existence. Thanks for bringing up that example.
none of these reasons why israel shouldn't exist are air tight. Your first reason why there shouldn't be palestinian state is that they deny jewish history which is partly true but being ignorant isn't a crime and I don't see the connection between that and not deserving a state. Also there are many jews who deny arab history in palestine.
@MrPatbradley22 You are right, not "air tight". But, they are three of my reasons, and I think they are good. How do you feel about Palestinians receiving a state right now?
@andrewsummey 1. Who said that a Palestinian state would support terrorists? Supposedly a state is what they want, so they would not want to support such immature tactics. So this is not a reason.
@andrewsummey why would they go to the UN asking for a state? Look closely at your own hate. You are angry for some reason (maybe you said at some point but I don't follow your channel). You seem to be so angry you can't put yourself into the other people's shoes to see why they are angry. This leads to wasting your life, war and your death. ... "Holding on to anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned." Buddha
@andrewsummey 2. "They promise to ban jews." Again, this is not a reason to avoid a Palestinian state, it's a reason to object to this immature proposed ban on jews. Agree to a Palestinian state in which if people chose they can go there. So this is not a reason.
@andrewsummey 3. "They deny Jewish history" Whether or not this is true, a solution to the disaster In the mideast would be to have a Palestinian state. Look forward to the future, stop acting like hurt little boys punching each other and solve the problem. So this is not a reason.
your interpretation of psalm 137 is off, it is that if I forget Jerusalem may I forget my right hand (No harp connected) and that my tongue will stick to my pallet (No connection to singing) if I don't remember Jerusalem on my happy occasions (Not if I think it is my greatest happiness or not).
@andrewsummey I am an Israeli Jew, so I know Hebrew fluently and that is the simple (and correct) interpretation, what wrote was commentary (I never saw such commentary before so I guess you made it up or someone else told you it.).
@talwino18 אני לא דפוק, זה א', ב', נכון, אני לא רב ולא יודע את כל התנ"ך, אבל אני יודע מה הוא מצטט וזה לא תרגום נכון, אז אני רק מבהיר לו את זה, אז תירגע בבקשה
אלו הפסוקים, אז אם תשווה שנייה אז תראה שמה שהוא אמר זה לא מדוייק, ולא אף אחד אומר שהוא משקר או משהו, אבל שיאמר תירגופ מדוייק ובלי תוספות, זהו, עצה טובה פשוט
yeah, yeah, yeah, of fucking course. bombing the hell out of people who've got FUCK ALL to do with Hamas or Fatah is totally "choosing life". you're a fucking idiot.
and I am not saying that palestine is flawless and great. but for you to sit there and be like "israel is fucking awesome, while the palestinians are a bunch of dickheads" (well, that's at least what you meant) is fucking bullshit. mistakes and crimes have been made on both sides and on both sides there's a lot of hatered.
How many Palestinians have died since 1967? And how many Jews? Look at the land that belongs to the Palestinians and Jews now and who that land belonged to in 1967. The only reason the Jews were able to take control was because we, the Palestinians, being so kind and naive, allowed them to do so. And what about the fact that every Israeli (whether boy or girl) must join the military at 18? What does the military do in Israel other than kill innocent Palestinians for no reason? You are IGNORANT
@TheDazzam Doesn't seem smart to attack folks who are that good at defending themselves. If the Palestinians put down their weapons, then there will be peace. If the Israelis put down their weapons, then there's no more Israel. Sadly, Israel is forced to defend herself and Palestinians are horrible fighters that use innocent civilians as shields. That's the truth that you and others do not wish to face.
@andrewsummey in 1948 if the palestinians put down there weapons all of the arabs would have been ethnically cleansed and when instead of using violence to resist israeli occupation they went the united nations to diplomatically resist, israel withheld their tax funds and accelerated settlement building. In my view diplomatic resistance is better than violent methods. I know many israeli's who while disagreeing with the palestinian decision to go to the UN, do not want them punished for it.
@danny1st your whole statement is stupid just because some were left behind doesn't mean ethic cleansing didn't occur. case in point look up what happened in lydda and ramla.
@MrPatbradley22 I'm saying that you can't prove that if the Arabs would not have fight, they'd be all kicked out, since they fought and still some were left.
@MrPatbradley22 Where do you get the idea that all Arabs would be "ethnically cleansed"? If your take is true, why does Israel give Arabs citizenship, let them serve in Parliament, serve in the military & vote?
@andrewsummey not all but most. look of ramle and lydda. also the deir yassin massacre. look the irgun. read some of things israeli leaders were saying at the time about arabs.
@andrewsummey thats like me stealing your house and then blaming you for the conflict. reality is that I bear some responsibility for the conflict because I stole your home. Thats the truth you and others do not wish to face. This conflict is not black and white. The palestinians have legitimate grievances against the israelis.I admit attacks on civilians are not justified, just that i understand where the hatred comes from. also look up the irgun seems israelis once justified terrorism too
@andrewsummey dude thats like me stealing your house then blaming your for the fact that we have a conflict. and also turning to you and saying well if you would only quit fighting me for your house we would have peace. i also find it disgusting that you are blaming the Palestinians for the fact that more of them are killed than israelis. yes the palestinians shouldn't launch rockets at israel but destroying 50,000 palestinian homes in response seems like overkill to me
we won all the wars cus we do care about this land and we know this is our last chence to have a home that the people in it is like us and not goin to attack us cus we are jewish ..
before 48 ,before 67 and after 67 many jews have been killd ,but we care about any jewish blood that Spilled so we try to protect us ,we buled a A wall separates the West Bank from the rest of the land ,but before we buled it many jews were murderd ..
@TheDazzam That is so wrong! No Palestinian is killed for no reason! And even more so, not enough are killed (I'll explain)! Palestinians who murdered and killed are just put in jail and set free even back to their people! Any murder and especially a country threatening mass murderer should be killed, but Israel is just to nice for their own good! You know how many rockets were shot into Israel by you guys and how many were shot at you by us!? We are too merciful...
@andrewsummey cuz you suck lool and its because of stupid raciste people like you that youtube suck u dumb bitch and for sure i want palestine and palestinian people they are cool not a fagottes like you
@bawsshood It is hard to understand statements with so many stars, maybe you do it because it is stammering because not even you fully agree or know that what you are saying is true deep down inside
@andrewsummey Because he is racist like his name: RacistPizza, and the most hated race on the map right now are the Jews and the palestinians want our land and if they get it it would hurt all the Jews terribly
just wondering since you don't support a palestinian state. what do you suggest israel should do with the arabs in the west bank? since you don't think they should have their own country.
@andrewsummey because if you don't support a palestinian state then you have three other options. #1 Use the israeli military to commit ethnic cleansing and drive the palestinians off the land and into jordan thereby creating a situation where israel can annex the west bank without having to give citizenship to the palestinians. saying this option would be an international incident is an understatement.
@MrPatbradley22 #2 Give the palestinians the vote. this would mean the end of israel however because of the high palestinian birth rate they would eventually be the majority.
@MrPatbradley22 #3 Inflict apartheid on the palestinians with the minority israelis ruling the majority palestinians. an apartheid regime wouldn't last long since they would lose at support from the international community and likely have sanctions placed on them. i could make an argument that apartheid already exists.
@MrPatbradley22 and of course there is a fourth option of giving the palestinians the own country but you don't support that so i was wondering which of my three options would you pick or do you have any other ideas i haven't thought of?
You think Arabs are terrorists!!!????Seriously do you know how many people Israel kill a day!Of course when Israel attacks they are 'soldiers' when the Palestinians fight back they're terrorists.....
@cheerdiver You ignorant person! What economic war!? It is all the same racist reasons! Until only a couple hundred years ago Jews were not allowed to do much jobs and when they could the prospered! The Jews want only peace!
no, justice based on a real promie. the promise that we as humans have given eatch other to respect and accept other humans as equal and not act like fascist bastards....not like the ones who almost eleminated all european jews, made soap of them, burned them alive and so forth...just man made justice and human rights...no need of your fascist self made god...
I didn't quite say that. I do believe in God, and I do believe God speaks. I believe our conversation and what you say is a part of God's beautiful design. It is a creative and engaging way to make points. A little outside the box. And, in a real way, it has brought our conversation together. And, believing in God equals fanaticism to you? And, I appreciate every comment, it helps my YouTube ratings :-) . So, what do you believe in? What is your source of morality? The 99%? That seems irrational
On your other thread, I think you finally spoke most honestly. You basically said you didnt need nor want any other opinion than what you believe your god tells you. No matter what facts, history, rationality or morality is presented to you, it is irrelevant because your God told you to the contrary. Well I wouldn't even try to fight that type of "faith". People should know what you hides behind your cheeky humor. Fanaticism. It is a shame that resource couldn't be used to bring people together.
Yours are neither promising or informed. I cannot tell if you are lying willfully or unwittingly. Palestinians - Jews, Christians and Muslims lived side by side, as friends and neighbors for hundreds of years. There are many great Jews both in Israel and else where who are committed to fighting Zionism. Norman Finklestine, son of Holocaust survivors is an academic who has studied this history in depth. See "Excellent talk on the Israel-Palestine conflict". Look at the record, it becomes clear.
@dariensamuel I'm not lying. I do not think you are either. I do think you are misinformed and misled. I do think Finklestein is profoundly wrong. I've read him, watched him live and spoken with him at an event. I would hardly call him an academic either. I think our positions are clear. And, your comment about the peace prior to Israel's existence is a stretch. Do you know the term Dhimmi? How about the Jizya tax?
The guy who uploaded this video likes to control, and delete comments (typical of those "friends" in the media and the elite.) and he/she never, EVER, say a phrase without insulting people. Everything from him is full of hate words and threatens.
No wonder why most of the planet thinks you are responsible for a Genocide in Palestine...and before you attack, I may be Jewish so....
@IgorLauma First, there is no genocide in Palestine. Second, what comment did I delete? I only delete repetitive comments. I know I may insult, but that is not my aim. My aim is the truth. Who am I threatening? I am pointing out the threats and hatred toward the Jewish people. I don't care if you are Jewish, Muslim or Christian. I will continue to say the truth in a creative, convincing and passionate way. thanks for adding your comment and watching the video.
Yes, I really want a Palestinian state. What do you think would possibly be accomplished by not permitting them to create a country out of a sliver of their original homeland? People like you who abstain them from proper global representation are the reasons why such extremist groups have taken power there, as all other reasonable, peaceful options in regaining a sense of dignity have essentially run out, at least in the eyes of the mostly youth-based terrorists.
@ChuckMcChip Actually, you have this backward. Israel today is a sliver of the Jewish homeland. The Palestinian cause merely wants to create a state in order to destroy Israel. I know what I say isn't popular, but it is the truth. The minute the Palestinian people and culture truly denounce their hatred of Jews, their desire to kill Jews and admit that there can be one Jewish state in the world - Israel, then we are having a different conversation. Until then. Do not allow a Palestinian state.
@andrewsummey Whether it is in fact the Jewish homeland or not is irrelevant to me and I'll tell you why. Even if Israel historically was there first, and of course I acknowledge the existence of Israel going back to hundreds of years B.C, that doesn't mean that there were no Philistines (Palestinians) living in said area as well. If you wish to return to your "homeland" that your people mostly left many years ago, great, but what gives you the right to claim it Strictly for yourself (cotd.)
@andrewsummey ...and make the people who were already there (as many as 2,000,000 Palestinians in the mid-20th century) be converted into second class citizens? If Israel believes it is it's God-given right to have a homogeneous state in an area that as of several hundred years did not belong to them, that reciprocates into giving Palestine such a right of their own to create one as well.
And I'm not denying that there are radicals, but it will only get worse without a State.
@andrewsummey I do understand your point about their anti-Jewish doctrines, but if we give them a nation and by some minute chance things actually get worse...then destroy them, simple as that. The injustices and prejudice they've been subjected to can only be described as that of the Native Americans throughout our own history, and I don't see any sort of improvement until they receive some faint symbol of dignity like the creation of a Palestinian state.
@ChuckMcChip Their land!? Since when have there been Palestinians!? When was and where was the Davidic Dynasty then!? After you answer these questions the facts will hopefully be clearer to you and more easily understood
@potato21012 Wow, my comments were from months ago, were you just itching to get into a youtube fight all of a sudden?
And if your only response is "DO SOME RESEARCH!!1!1!" without providing me with said sources that you are referring to, then this is frankly not worth my time. Some of us have actual lives to attend to until presented with contrary evidence. Links? Sources? Anything?
@ChuckMcChip First of all, I only saw the post today, second of all, look in the Bible brought one, and third of all, why should I bring you links to anything, that is a waste of my time, fourth of all, the Davidic Dynasty ruled over two thousand five hundred years ago and the Palestinians (Who are not Philistines) were created from the post WW1 Jordan and are barely any older than the Jewish State
@potato21012 It's clearly not a waste of your time if you insist on perpetuating this argument...And that's not what I was referring to about you seeing the post today. You literally had to take the time, go through this comments list and find someone you disagree with, then create a comment filed with exclamation marks, as if shouting via message vindicates your message.
I can't say the same for you, but this is not worth my time and I will choose to enter back into the real world, good day.
I think we can all agree that violence is something nobody likes, videos like this foster hate and hate only begets hate... Moreover, the information is extremely biased, perhaps a more balanced view is needed, may be mention WHY that child was dressing up as a suicide bomber or why it is justified to come back to a land after so long...should we support native indians in taking over the US? Also just a little factoid, arabs are also Smites as are certain African people. Truth>bias.. always.
@nothing123456ism How does pointing out hate foster hate? The child is dressing up as a suicide bomber because his/her mother celebrates with the Palestinian culture violence in this way. That is the truth. They didn't "come back" after so long. They never left. The Jewish people have stayed and grown for the majority of the last 2,000 years. And, when one speaks of "anti-Semitism" they mean hatred towards Jews. Don't play silly games.
@andrewsummey I'm assuming the 1st Q is rhetorical,but not entirely sure what is meant. Either way my point stands, this video is very one sided. It does not present the Palestinian view at all. No people on Earth would willingly kill themselves for no reason, for right or wrong. Also, if the Jewish ppl have stayed for 2000 yrs then where did the statement, " A land without a people for a people without a land" come from? I'm not instigating confrontation, but merely eliciting critical thinking
@nothing123456ism My pointing out their hatred does not foster hate as you say. They kill themselves because they believe Allah calls for them to do it. That they will be rewarded in paradise. And, their families will be considered heroes for killing Jews and spreading Jihad by force. Their thinking is very different. The "land w/o a people" saying did reflect the overall empty reality of the land (read Mark Twain's accounts). The Jewish people never lost connection to their Land physically.
@TheSroh You are most welcome! Know that I and many others will be praying for you. Remember, Israel is in the right here. Even though the world comes against you, the G-d of heaven and earth fights for you. And, those who support you are growing strong. We will not back down. We will not give up. "Be strong and courageous. Do not be afraid or terrified because of them, for the LORD your God goes with you; He will never leave you nor forsake you." Devarim 31:6
@andrewsummey Your nothing more than a racist and a lair. You'll go down in history for supporting ethnic cleansing - thanks for posting it on the internet so we've got a record of it. You can never let go of the comments you've made in this video.
@stefancamilleri Do you know the God of Israel? The God of Abraham, Isaac & Jacob? The God of all the earth? He alone was the One who brought His people back as He promised (see my other video - "God Click Like"). And, He also cares very much for the Palestinians and it is sad that they are destroying themselves with their hatred and racism against the Jews. This God also cares for you. Do you know Him?
Jews have contributed endlessly to this world. In physics, medicine, industry, law, commerce, linguistics, economics and they continue contributing, innovating and leading.
What about Arabs?
Israel wants a tiny slither of land that is rightly theirs. Arabs have 21 states.
@andrewsummey I support Israel because as a Kurd I know better than anyone the hypocrite lies of Arabs. The Palestinians shout and scream VICTIM VICTIM when they are attacked by Israel but they found it completely acceptable to come to Iraq and attacks Kurds that were equally fighting for independence. It is from this I say the Kurdish cause is similar to the Jewish cause, and not similar in any way to the hypocrite Arabs who demand another country that they can mismanage like the rest.
First off, any Palestinians that deny a Jewish connection are outliners, just as there are Israeli outliners that deny a Palestinian connection. Second, he did NOT say Jews, he said Israelis, not the same thing, and since they've killed nearly 7,000 of us, seems fair. Lastly, look at the numbers, Israelis are the ones doing the killing, to the tune of 12 of us for every one of them. Heck, more Palis have killed each other than Jews. Nice try in hate mongering though.
@shibbel1 I wouldn't say Israel is going out of their way to "kill" palestinians. I drove through towns in Samaria and saw lit up signs along the road honoring Palestinian terrorists that were killed going out of their way to commit murder. You see no parallel in Israeli society to this. I would encourage you to reset your moral compass. Murder is different than self defense.
@andrewsummey Either you're completely ignorant to Israel's past and present, or you're a hypocrite, probably both. Let's go back to the bombing of the King David Hotel where 91 people were killed. It's celebrated to this day in Jerusalem. Jewish terror groups like Irgun and Lehi have murdered countless innocents. So yes, there is a parallel. 6, that's how many non-combative Palis are killed for every 1 combative. So again, yes, they do go out of their way to impose a collective punishment.
Reasons not to support a Jewish state, partially base on this guy's logic:
1) There are Israeli terrorists, therefore ALL Jews support their children to be terrorists (your logic, not mine) therefore they should not have a state. (your third point)
2) Israelis frequently lie about Palestinian claims, therefore all Israelis are liars and don't deserve to have a state (your logic, not mine).
3) There are Zionists who say all Palestinians should move to Jordania, therefore all Israelis agree.
@GodOfTheInternets You are funny. Israel does not support or endorse children terrorists. Palestinian society celebrates and endorses terrorism.
2. The PA authority makes the claims that Jews make up their history. The truth is, Palestinians invent their history. Classic turnspeak (see my previous video).
Jordania? where are you from? Jordan was created originally by the British to be the Palestinian state. (Or Arab state since everyone was Palestinian then - Jew, Arab, Christian, Muslim).
1. Show me just one Jewish child in a suicide belt or just ONE Jewish mother who says that she wants her child to kill others! JUST ONE!
2. Israelis lie about pali claims? Actually it is the opposite, even though Israel has been accused of many lies, until the investigations were complete Israel took blame. Just look at the case of Al-Dura (the little boy who the palis killed & lied about), Gaza massacre..
3. Don't read news? Some Israelis are stupid lefties, like I WAS!
This has been flagged as spam show
"Four-fifths of the whole population are Moslems. Some 77,000 of the population are Christians, in large majority belonging to the Orthodox Church, and speaking Arabic. The Jewish element of the population numbers 76,000. Almost ALL have entered Palestine during the last 40 years. Prior to 1850 there were in the country only a handful of Jews."
- League of Nations 1920 Interim Report
-> "Almost ALL (Jews) entered during the last 40 years!"
ZIONISTS GO BACK TO EUROPE
OrthodoxDarwinist 2 weeks ago
I don't think you understand... INNOCENT HUMANS ARE BEING KILLED in Palestine- to a mass scale by soldiers with guns and tanks. So people in Palestine are fighting any way they can by ending their own life; not in the name of Religion, but for their people, more than an Israeli could ever do. Essentially you're condoning children being killed for land that doesn't belong to you; justified by the 'fact' jewish history isn't being taught in their schools. Yep, you're messed up.
LyndaHEYYY 2 weeks ago
@LyndaHEYYY What 's all messed up your base assumptions in response to a video, you repeating the propaganda of the Palestinians, even before I checked, I knew you from the UK. The British would be the last to be discovered they had lied to them, now I do not cause discussion, with time you will discover it for yourself, and I will be there to laugh at the stupidity and ignorance, good day(:
asaf921 4 days ago
@asaf921 So are you denying innocent civilians being killed by Israeli soldiers? If the answer is yes you're the ignorant one. I don't care what propaganda you think is being shown to me, when i see actual photos and footage, that's enough for me.
LyndaHEYYY 4 days ago
@LyndaHEYYY I see you only care about the consequences of war, yes, war is shit!, And every war is a shame to mankind,if you really cared about people you would trying to discover the root problem that caused the war to begin with, and try to avoid it.What you're really doing is looking for someone to fight him and charge him under the pretext of humanity,that the worsens the situation is not helpful, now answer me what the source, the word apartheid,and what this is the definition of apartheid
asaf921 4 days ago
fuck you, you doofy clown.
sexyabe 2 weeks ago
one sided, biased asshole
eslamdaoud 2 weeks ago
@eslamdaoud what bias? what side? why the insult?
andrewsummey 2 weeks ago
@andrewsummey I'm palestinian and I was never taught those things. You tend to focus on extreme lows of Palestine but you don't even consider what they've been through. Isreal was made because Britain put all the jews in Europe who wanted their own country there. What do you think this country of people would do when they're forced out of their own country. I live in the United States because my family had to leave Palestine. I love it here; but those people their deserve a place for themselves.
eslamdaoud 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@andrewsummey
Say NO to Zionist ethnic supremacism, terrorism and war-mongering!
Racist losers like Andrew Summey who support the ethnic cleansing of over 5 million indigenous Palestinian Arabs from their homes simply because they are seen as ethnically inferior are no better in the slightest than Nazis kicking gypsies out of their homes to make "living space" for what Hitler considered the "Chosen people"
Racist scum.
OrthodoxDarwinist 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@andrewsummey
Why is it that the 117-page Amnesty International report "found no evidence of Palestinian militants using human shields to stop Israeli attacks, but it accuses the Israel Defence Forces of launching attacks from buildings in which Palestinian civilians were sheltering, and charges Israeli forces with killing hundreds of unarmed Palestinian civilians and wanton destruction of thousands of homes."??
Racist cunt.
GnosticHumanist 2 weeks ago
You're sick.
LyndaHEYYY 2 weeks ago
@LyndaHEYYY thanks! appreciate the compliment...
andrewsummey 2 weeks ago
I cant wait for Iran to destroy Israel after Israel attacks Iran.
sexyabe 2 weeks ago
@sexyabe Why do you want war?
andrewsummey 2 weeks ago
@andrewsummey because its the only way to get rid of israel and people like you
sexyabe 2 weeks ago
@sexyabe why not just say "hey, that's their view..." and move on? Why would you want to kill? What can you gain?
andrewsummey 2 weeks ago
@SerbiaGayPrideCCCC How do you feel this will help any discussion?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey What redeeming qualities can there be with a society that looks to Abbas and Hamas?
andrewsummey 2 weeks ago
@andrewsummey they kinda rhyme?
MrPatbradley22 2 weeks ago
sick sick sick behaviour / like always most jews sick
borsamur 1 month ago
@borsamur What is sick behavior?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@borsamur You mean "sick = awesome" right?
andrewsummey 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
man this is good ,any palestinian or arab wanna talk about the conflict in the middel east send me a massege or write on my wall ..
talwino18 1 month ago
ok i see your point and your right i can't prove that. but it's indisputable that what happened in lydda and ramla was ethnic cleansing. shit happens
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago
@MrPatbradley22 How do you see this as "ethnic cleansing"? What ethnic group was cleansed?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
Thirdly you say the shouldn't have state because they encourage their children to be murderers well so do many israeli's just look at some of the radical settlers and you don't say they don't deserve a state. Also not all palestinians encourage their children to murderers so don't generalize.
Finally i'd just like to say this is not a black and white conflict where the israelis are good and the palestinians are bad. There is a lot of gray areas.Just do a little research on what happened in '48
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago
@MrPatbradley22 I've done a lot of research into '48. I see it very differently than you. '48 is simply about the move toward sovereignty and freedom for the Jewish people and their defense from the many nations around them looking to kill them all and wipe out the new Jewish state - Israel. Palestinian society does encourage their children to murder in this way. It is tragic. It is sad. It needs to be stopped and shunned.
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey aight you can view it like that if you want too. I view it as an act of european colonialism that displaced the indigenous population and raped their way of life. i also don't believe there is a man in the sky that awards land to people or takes sides in wars.
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
@MrPatbradley22 What man is in the sky!?
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 the prophet joseph smith. who else?
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
@MrPatbradley22 So you don't believe in a man in the sky and then have a name for him, interesting. First, there is no man in the sky, you are right, second, who is this Joseph Smith, and thirdly, There is a creator to this world, he is God, and if you look in the bible you will see his promise to the Jews to give us the land of Israel which includes, Sinai, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and more by the way.
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 hahahahahahahahahahahaaahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahahhahhahahahhahahhahahahhahahahahahahahahhhahahahahhhahahaaahahahahahhahahahahahahahahhahahahhahahahhahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahha...there is no god btw. the bible also says to kill people if they don't observe the sabbath. do you also think you should do that?
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
@MrPatbradley22 Lack of knowledge is what I see in your answer, and if you think there is no god then your blind.
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 lack of rational thought is what i see in your answer. if you think there is a god then you are delusional.
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
@MrPatbradley22 You are right, I don't THINK there is a God, I KNOW there is a God and one God only (I do not support Christianity, thus the one, they are idol worshipers). And If you think there is no God, than how was the world created? (If you say there was a big bang then that is irrational, and if there was a big bang than that is what is called in the Bible "Let there be light", but no bang can create anything).
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 prove it. baam!
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
@MrPatbradley22 Baam? Really, I don't need to prove anything. Are you Christian?
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 if you say that you are 100% certain in the existence of a supernatural being yes you do need to provide evidence to back up you view. otherwise people can start claiming all kinds of crazy things with no evidence and say that they are facts.
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
@MrPatbradley22 I told you my proof, and you did not answer my question, are you athiest?
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 when did you give me proof? you said "I don't need to prove anything." yes i am an atheist and you haven't answered my questions, so don't get all holier than thow on me.
MrPatbradley22 2 weeks ago
@MrPatbradley22 naw, but God might ;) What makes you understand what the Bible is talking about if you do not believe in God?
andrewsummey 2 weeks ago
@andrewsummey what does "naw, but God might ;)" mean? and 18 years of going to a catholic church and high school makes me understand the bible and that it is insane book that contradicts itself, preaches hate and is clearly not true.
MrPatbradley22 2 weeks ago
Your second reason is that they want a jew free state. Well avigdor lieberman the deputy prime minister of israel feels the same way about the arabs in israel. Many other israeli's feel the same way but i don't see you saying that there shouldn't be a jewish state. Saudi arabia which i sure is a country you don't like bans jews but i don't see you saying they have no right to exist.
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago
@MrPatbradley22 What you said about Lieberman is misrepresenting him. And, I'd rather not have Saudi Arabia as it is right now for that very reason. I would not want it to come into existence with their current treatment of non-Muslims and I would not want my country to vote or help it come into existence. Thanks for bringing up that example.
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
none of these reasons why israel shouldn't exist are air tight. Your first reason why there shouldn't be palestinian state is that they deny jewish history which is partly true but being ignorant isn't a crime and I don't see the connection between that and not deserving a state. Also there are many jews who deny arab history in palestine.
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago
@MrPatbradley22 You are right, not "air tight". But, they are three of my reasons, and I think they are good. How do you feel about Palestinians receiving a state right now?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey def needs to be a gradual process over the course of say 5-10 years giving them a state overnight could be a disaster.
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
These are not reasons.
farvision 1 month ago
@farvision In what way?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey 1. Who said that a Palestinian state would support terrorists? Supposedly a state is what they want, so they would not want to support such immature tactics. So this is not a reason.
farvision 3 weeks ago
@farvision If you read their stuff, they really just want hate, not a state.
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey why would they go to the UN asking for a state? Look closely at your own hate. You are angry for some reason (maybe you said at some point but I don't follow your channel). You seem to be so angry you can't put yourself into the other people's shoes to see why they are angry. This leads to wasting your life, war and your death. ... "Holding on to anger is like grasping a hot coal with the intent of throwing it at someone else; you are the one who gets burned." Buddha
farvision 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey
ignore potato21012 he dont even know what he talking about ..
god bless u :))
talwino18 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey 2. "They promise to ban jews." Again, this is not a reason to avoid a Palestinian state, it's a reason to object to this immature proposed ban on jews. Agree to a Palestinian state in which if people chose they can go there. So this is not a reason.
farvision 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey 3. "They deny Jewish history" Whether or not this is true, a solution to the disaster In the mideast would be to have a Palestinian state. Look forward to the future, stop acting like hurt little boys punching each other and solve the problem. So this is not a reason.
farvision 3 weeks ago
Dont worry, there will NEVER be a "palestinkian state".
Its jewish land. Those muslim bums can go to Jordan if they wish.
Design770 1 month ago
@Design770 That's not very practical. How would that even happen?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
your interpretation of psalm 137 is off, it is that if I forget Jerusalem may I forget my right hand (No harp connected) and that my tongue will stick to my pallet (No connection to singing) if I don't remember Jerusalem on my happy occasions (Not if I think it is my greatest happiness or not).
potato21012 1 month ago
@potato21012 where do you get this translation?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey I am an Israeli Jew, so I know Hebrew fluently and that is the simple (and correct) interpretation, what wrote was commentary (I never saw such commentary before so I guess you made it up or someone else told you it.).
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012
אל תהיה דפוק ,האיש בעדנו ,ואתה לא איזה רב שיודע את כול התנך , יכול להיות שזה באמת כתוב ..
talwino18 3 weeks ago
@talwino18 אני לא דפוק, זה א', ב', נכון, אני לא רב ולא יודע את כל התנ"ך, אבל אני יודע מה הוא מצטט וזה לא תרגום נכון, אז אני רק מבהיר לו את זה, אז תירגע בבקשה
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 בסדר סליחה אחי אבל עדיין לך תדע אולי זה נכון ,ועדיין מה הבעיה הוא בעדנו ואם הוא אומר זה בטח נכון הוא לא אחד שישקר בשביל האמת ..
talwino18 3 weeks ago
@talwino18 אִם-אֶשְׁכָּחֵךְ יְרוּשָׁלִָם-- תִּשְׁכַּח יְמִינִי.
ו תִּדְבַּק-לְשׁוֹנִי, לְחִכִּי-- אִם-לֹא אֶזְכְּרֵכִי:
אִם-לֹא אַעֲלֶה, אֶת-יְרוּשָׁלִַם-- עַל, רֹאשׁ שִׂמְחָתִי
אלו הפסוקים, אז אם תשווה שנייה אז תראה שמה שהוא אמר זה לא מדוייק, ולא אף אחד אומר שהוא משקר או משהו, אבל שיאמר תירגופ מדוייק ובלי תוספות, זהו, עצה טובה פשוט
potato21012 3 weeks ago
yeah, yeah, yeah, of fucking course. bombing the hell out of people who've got FUCK ALL to do with Hamas or Fatah is totally "choosing life". you're a fucking idiot.
and I am not saying that palestine is flawless and great. but for you to sit there and be like "israel is fucking awesome, while the palestinians are a bunch of dickheads" (well, that's at least what you meant) is fucking bullshit. mistakes and crimes have been made on both sides and on both sides there's a lot of hatered.
BuecherFuerAlle 2 months ago
@BuecherFuerAlle Why do you swear so much? Do you think it helps get your point across? Or, do you see that it makes YOU look bad?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
How many Palestinians have died since 1967? And how many Jews? Look at the land that belongs to the Palestinians and Jews now and who that land belonged to in 1967. The only reason the Jews were able to take control was because we, the Palestinians, being so kind and naive, allowed them to do so. And what about the fact that every Israeli (whether boy or girl) must join the military at 18? What does the military do in Israel other than kill innocent Palestinians for no reason? You are IGNORANT
TheDazzam 2 months ago
@TheDazzam Doesn't seem smart to attack folks who are that good at defending themselves. If the Palestinians put down their weapons, then there will be peace. If the Israelis put down their weapons, then there's no more Israel. Sadly, Israel is forced to defend herself and Palestinians are horrible fighters that use innocent civilians as shields. That's the truth that you and others do not wish to face.
andrewsummey 2 months ago 8
@andrewsummey in 1948 if the palestinians put down there weapons all of the arabs would have been ethnically cleansed and when instead of using violence to resist israeli occupation they went the united nations to diplomatically resist, israel withheld their tax funds and accelerated settlement building. In my view diplomatic resistance is better than violent methods. I know many israeli's who while disagreeing with the palestinian decision to go to the UN, do not want them punished for it.
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
@MrPatbradley22 Your first statement is stupid. 1,500,000+ Arabs live in Israel today...what a sloppy "ethnic cleansing".
danny1st 1 month ago
@danny1st your whole statement is stupid just because some were left behind doesn't mean ethic cleansing didn't occur. case in point look up what happened in lydda and ramla.
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago
@MrPatbradley22 I'm saying that you can't prove that if the Arabs would not have fight, they'd be all kicked out, since they fought and still some were left.
That's all.
danny1st 1 month ago
@MrPatbradley22 Where do you get the idea that all Arabs would be "ethnically cleansed"? If your take is true, why does Israel give Arabs citizenship, let them serve in Parliament, serve in the military & vote?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey not all but most. look of ramle and lydda. also the deir yassin massacre. look the irgun. read some of things israeli leaders were saying at the time about arabs.
MrPatbradley22 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey thats like me stealing your house and then blaming you for the conflict. reality is that I bear some responsibility for the conflict because I stole your home. Thats the truth you and others do not wish to face. This conflict is not black and white. The palestinians have legitimate grievances against the israelis.I admit attacks on civilians are not justified, just that i understand where the hatred comes from. also look up the irgun seems israelis once justified terrorism too
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago
@andrewsummey dude thats like me stealing your house then blaming your for the fact that we have a conflict. and also turning to you and saying well if you would only quit fighting me for your house we would have peace. i also find it disgusting that you are blaming the Palestinians for the fact that more of them are killed than israelis. yes the palestinians shouldn't launch rockets at israel but destroying 50,000 palestinian homes in response seems like overkill to me
my point is don't biased
MrPatbradley22 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
@TheDazzam It isn't very smart to pick on a stronger enemy like that. The Palestinian society's own hatred leads to their own deaths.
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@TheDazzam Also, why am I ignorant?
andrewsummey 3 weeks ago
@TheDazzam
we won all the wars cus we do care about this land and we know this is our last chence to have a home that the people in it is like us and not goin to attack us cus we are jewish ..
before 48 ,before 67 and after 67 many jews have been killd ,but we care about any jewish blood that Spilled so we try to protect us ,we buled a A wall separates the West Bank from the rest of the land ,but before we buled it many jews were murderd ..
talwino18 3 weeks ago
@TheDazzam That is so wrong! No Palestinian is killed for no reason! And even more so, not enough are killed (I'll explain)! Palestinians who murdered and killed are just put in jail and set free even back to their people! Any murder and especially a country threatening mass murderer should be killed, but Israel is just to nice for their own good! You know how many rockets were shot into Israel by you guys and how many were shot at you by us!? We are too merciful...
potato21012 3 weeks ago
yoo i am going to give you a advice leave youtube men you suck balls and im not palestinian but the cool and stick with my advice stupid bitch
bawsshood 2 months ago
@bawsshood Why? Why do you think I should leave?
andrewsummey 2 months ago
@andrewsummey cuz you suck lool and its because of stupid raciste people like you that youtube suck u dumb bitch and for sure i want palestine and palestinian people they are cool not a fagottes like you
bawsshood 2 months ago
@bawsshood It is hard to understand statements with so many stars, maybe you do it because it is stammering because not even you fully agree or know that what you are saying is true deep down inside
potato21012 3 weeks ago
yes i want palestine
RacistPizza 2 months ago
@RacistPizza Why do you want Palestine?
andrewsummey 2 months ago
@andrewsummey Because he is racist like his name: RacistPizza, and the most hated race on the map right now are the Jews and the palestinians want our land and if they get it it would hurt all the Jews terribly
potato21012 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a fucking moron!
Ziyod 3 months ago
just wondering since you don't support a palestinian state. what do you suggest israel should do with the arabs in the west bank? since you don't think they should have their own country.
MrPatbradley22 3 months ago
@MrPatbradley22 I have a couple thoughts. Why do you ask?
andrewsummey 2 months ago
@andrewsummey because if you don't support a palestinian state then you have three other options. #1 Use the israeli military to commit ethnic cleansing and drive the palestinians off the land and into jordan thereby creating a situation where israel can annex the west bank without having to give citizenship to the palestinians. saying this option would be an international incident is an understatement.
MrPatbradley22 2 months ago
@MrPatbradley22 #2 Give the palestinians the vote. this would mean the end of israel however because of the high palestinian birth rate they would eventually be the majority.
MrPatbradley22 2 months ago
@MrPatbradley22 #3 Inflict apartheid on the palestinians with the minority israelis ruling the majority palestinians. an apartheid regime wouldn't last long since they would lose at support from the international community and likely have sanctions placed on them. i could make an argument that apartheid already exists.
MrPatbradley22 2 months ago
@MrPatbradley22 and of course there is a fourth option of giving the palestinians the own country but you don't support that so i was wondering which of my three options would you pick or do you have any other ideas i haven't thought of?
MrPatbradley22 2 months ago
You think Arabs are terrorists!!!????Seriously do you know how many people Israel kill a day!Of course when Israel attacks they are 'soldiers' when the Palestinians fight back they're terrorists.....
thatsanawfulusername 3 months ago
@thatsanawfulusername What difference do you see between active defense and terrorism?
andrewsummey 2 months ago
Interesting...now exactly what are Jews...and where did they come from?
What is their purpose on this planet?
Just a question from someone who wants to be educated.
jjsiegal1 3 months ago
@jjsiegal1 I think the better question is - who are Jews? where did they come from and what is the purpose of there being a "Jewish people".
Before I answer, may I ask what are your thoughts on God?
andrewsummey 2 months ago
No mention of how the Jews declared economic war on Germany long b4 Hitler took power.
So why did most states(countries) have no usery laws on the books, UNTIL THE JEWS MOVED IN?
cheerdiver 3 months ago
@cheerdiver Wow, you really believe that hack conspiracy?
andrewsummey 3 months ago
@cheerdiver Wow, it seems you are believing some real lies. What are your problems with the Jewish people? And, where do you get your sources?
andrewsummey 2 months ago 5
@cheerdiver You ignorant person! What economic war!? It is all the same racist reasons! Until only a couple hundred years ago Jews were not allowed to do much jobs and when they could the prospered! The Jews want only peace!
potato21012 3 weeks ago
I will give you just one single reason why every righteous person should support Palestine: JUSTICE !
Shalom Shabab
ArmenianHolocaust 3 months ago
@ArmenianHolocaust Justice based on a fase premise? Hmmmm...that's not justice.
andrewsummey 3 months ago
@andrewsummey
no, justice based on a real promie. the promise that we as humans have given eatch other to respect and accept other humans as equal and not act like fascist bastards....not like the ones who almost eleminated all european jews, made soap of them, burned them alive and so forth...just man made justice and human rights...no need of your fascist self made god...
ArmenianHolocaust 3 months ago
Comment removed
ArmenianHolocaust 3 months ago
@ArmenianHolocaust What kind of justice are you looking for?
andrewsummey 2 months ago
@ArmenianHolocaust What's shalom shabab? Your ending is what I would call a failure....your justice is just totally screwed up by your comment
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012
You are too smart for me, because you are a chosen one and I am just a little goyim-Armeinan...
ArmenianHolocaust 3 weeks ago
I didn't quite say that. I do believe in God, and I do believe God speaks. I believe our conversation and what you say is a part of God's beautiful design. It is a creative and engaging way to make points. A little outside the box. And, in a real way, it has brought our conversation together. And, believing in God equals fanaticism to you? And, I appreciate every comment, it helps my YouTube ratings :-) . So, what do you believe in? What is your source of morality? The 99%? That seems irrational
andrewsummey 3 months ago
On your other thread, I think you finally spoke most honestly. You basically said you didnt need nor want any other opinion than what you believe your god tells you. No matter what facts, history, rationality or morality is presented to you, it is irrelevant because your God told you to the contrary. Well I wouldn't even try to fight that type of "faith". People should know what you hides behind your cheeky humor. Fanaticism. It is a shame that resource couldn't be used to bring people together.
dariensamuel 3 months ago
Opinions and theories are like assholes, everyone's got one.
IgorLauma 3 months ago
@IgorLauma True, but not all opinions and theories are equal. Some are more informed and more promising.
andrewsummey 3 months ago
Yours are neither promising or informed. I cannot tell if you are lying willfully or unwittingly. Palestinians - Jews, Christians and Muslims lived side by side, as friends and neighbors for hundreds of years. There are many great Jews both in Israel and else where who are committed to fighting Zionism. Norman Finklestine, son of Holocaust survivors is an academic who has studied this history in depth. See "Excellent talk on the Israel-Palestine conflict". Look at the record, it becomes clear.
dariensamuel 3 months ago
@dariensamuel I'm not lying. I do not think you are either. I do think you are misinformed and misled. I do think Finklestein is profoundly wrong. I've read him, watched him live and spoken with him at an event. I would hardly call him an academic either. I think our positions are clear. And, your comment about the peace prior to Israel's existence is a stretch. Do you know the term Dhimmi? How about the Jizya tax?
andrewsummey 3 months ago
The guy who uploaded this video likes to control, and delete comments (typical of those "friends" in the media and the elite.) and he/she never, EVER, say a phrase without insulting people. Everything from him is full of hate words and threatens.
No wonder why most of the planet thinks you are responsible for a Genocide in Palestine...and before you attack, I may be Jewish so....
IgorLauma 3 months ago
@IgorLauma First, there is no genocide in Palestine. Second, what comment did I delete? I only delete repetitive comments. I know I may insult, but that is not my aim. My aim is the truth. Who am I threatening? I am pointing out the threats and hatred toward the Jewish people. I don't care if you are Jewish, Muslim or Christian. I will continue to say the truth in a creative, convincing and passionate way. thanks for adding your comment and watching the video.
andrewsummey 3 months ago
Yes, I really want a Palestinian state. What do you think would possibly be accomplished by not permitting them to create a country out of a sliver of their original homeland? People like you who abstain them from proper global representation are the reasons why such extremist groups have taken power there, as all other reasonable, peaceful options in regaining a sense of dignity have essentially run out, at least in the eyes of the mostly youth-based terrorists.
ChuckMcChip 3 months ago
@ChuckMcChip Actually, you have this backward. Israel today is a sliver of the Jewish homeland. The Palestinian cause merely wants to create a state in order to destroy Israel. I know what I say isn't popular, but it is the truth. The minute the Palestinian people and culture truly denounce their hatred of Jews, their desire to kill Jews and admit that there can be one Jewish state in the world - Israel, then we are having a different conversation. Until then. Do not allow a Palestinian state.
andrewsummey 3 months ago
@andrewsummey Whether it is in fact the Jewish homeland or not is irrelevant to me and I'll tell you why. Even if Israel historically was there first, and of course I acknowledge the existence of Israel going back to hundreds of years B.C, that doesn't mean that there were no Philistines (Palestinians) living in said area as well. If you wish to return to your "homeland" that your people mostly left many years ago, great, but what gives you the right to claim it Strictly for yourself (cotd.)
ChuckMcChip 3 months ago
@ChuckMcChip Who lived there were Philistines, not related to the new 100 year old Palestinians which are actually Jordanians
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012
צודק אבל התרגום בעברית לאנגלית הוא שונה ...
talwino18 3 weeks ago
@andrewsummey ...and make the people who were already there (as many as 2,000,000 Palestinians in the mid-20th century) be converted into second class citizens? If Israel believes it is it's God-given right to have a homogeneous state in an area that as of several hundred years did not belong to them, that reciprocates into giving Palestine such a right of their own to create one as well.
And I'm not denying that there are radicals, but it will only get worse without a State.
ChuckMcChip 3 months ago
@andrewsummey I do understand your point about their anti-Jewish doctrines, but if we give them a nation and by some minute chance things actually get worse...then destroy them, simple as that. The injustices and prejudice they've been subjected to can only be described as that of the Native Americans throughout our own history, and I don't see any sort of improvement until they receive some faint symbol of dignity like the creation of a Palestinian state.
ChuckMcChip 3 months ago
@ChuckMcChip Their land!? Since when have there been Palestinians!? When was and where was the Davidic Dynasty then!? After you answer these questions the facts will hopefully be clearer to you and more easily understood
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 Wow, my comments were from months ago, were you just itching to get into a youtube fight all of a sudden?
And if your only response is "DO SOME RESEARCH!!1!1!" without providing me with said sources that you are referring to, then this is frankly not worth my time. Some of us have actual lives to attend to until presented with contrary evidence. Links? Sources? Anything?
ChuckMcChip 3 weeks ago
@ChuckMcChip First of all, I only saw the post today, second of all, look in the Bible brought one, and third of all, why should I bring you links to anything, that is a waste of my time, fourth of all, the Davidic Dynasty ruled over two thousand five hundred years ago and the Palestinians (Who are not Philistines) were created from the post WW1 Jordan and are barely any older than the Jewish State
potato21012 3 weeks ago
@potato21012 It's clearly not a waste of your time if you insist on perpetuating this argument...And that's not what I was referring to about you seeing the post today. You literally had to take the time, go through this comments list and find someone you disagree with, then create a comment filed with exclamation marks, as if shouting via message vindicates your message.
I can't say the same for you, but this is not worth my time and I will choose to enter back into the real world, good day.
ChuckMcChip 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
nothing123456ism 3 months ago
Comment removed
nothing123456ism 3 months ago
I think we can all agree that violence is something nobody likes, videos like this foster hate and hate only begets hate... Moreover, the information is extremely biased, perhaps a more balanced view is needed, may be mention WHY that child was dressing up as a suicide bomber or why it is justified to come back to a land after so long...should we support native indians in taking over the US? Also just a little factoid, arabs are also Smites as are certain African people. Truth>bias.. always.
nothing123456ism 3 months ago
@nothing123456ism How does pointing out hate foster hate? The child is dressing up as a suicide bomber because his/her mother celebrates with the Palestinian culture violence in this way. That is the truth. They didn't "come back" after so long. They never left. The Jewish people have stayed and grown for the majority of the last 2,000 years. And, when one speaks of "anti-Semitism" they mean hatred towards Jews. Don't play silly games.
andrewsummey 3 months ago
@andrewsummey I'm assuming the 1st Q is rhetorical,but not entirely sure what is meant. Either way my point stands, this video is very one sided. It does not present the Palestinian view at all. No people on Earth would willingly kill themselves for no reason, for right or wrong. Also, if the Jewish ppl have stayed for 2000 yrs then where did the statement, " A land without a people for a people without a land" come from? I'm not instigating confrontation, but merely eliciting critical thinking
nothing123456ism 3 months ago
@nothing123456ism My pointing out their hatred does not foster hate as you say. They kill themselves because they believe Allah calls for them to do it. That they will be rewarded in paradise. And, their families will be considered heroes for killing Jews and spreading Jihad by force. Their thinking is very different. The "land w/o a people" saying did reflect the overall empty reality of the land (read Mark Twain's accounts). The Jewish people never lost connection to their Land physically.
andrewsummey 3 months ago
Comment removed
nothing123456ism 3 months ago
I'm an 18 yo from Israel, And I thank you very much for this.
Soon [on the 27th] I'll be recruited to the IDF for 3 years, And i'll try to defend my country with my life, ofcourse.
I seriously thank you for giving your opinion and supporting Israel, when Israel-Supporters are a minority compared to Palestine-Supporters.
Thank you, from the bottom of my heart.
TheSroh 3 months ago
@TheSroh You are most welcome! Know that I and many others will be praying for you. Remember, Israel is in the right here. Even though the world comes against you, the G-d of heaven and earth fights for you. And, those who support you are growing strong. We will not back down. We will not give up. "Be strong and courageous. Do not be afraid or terrified because of them, for the LORD your God goes with you; He will never leave you nor forsake you." Devarim 31:6
andrewsummey 3 months ago
The hole world stands against you. Up yours
stefancamilleri 3 months ago
@stefancamilleri The God of Israel and I. I'm good :-) Psalm 121:4 But, thanks for the heads up!
andrewsummey 3 months ago
@andrewsummey Your nothing more than a racist and a lair. You'll go down in history for supporting ethnic cleansing - thanks for posting it on the internet so we've got a record of it. You can never let go of the comments you've made in this video.
Viva Palestine, viva freedom
stefancamilleri 3 months ago 2
@stefancamilleri Do you know the God of Israel? The God of Abraham, Isaac & Jacob? The God of all the earth? He alone was the One who brought His people back as He promised (see my other video - "God Click Like"). And, He also cares very much for the Palestinians and it is sad that they are destroying themselves with their hatred and racism against the Jews. This God also cares for you. Do you know Him?
andrewsummey 3 months ago
@andrewsummey I know your nothing more than a religious fundamentalist - thats enough for me.
You've got the same hate and delusion of a suicide bomber
stefancamilleri 3 months ago
@stefancamilleri so, i point out hate, and I am the hater? Seems reasonable.
andrewsummey 3 months ago
@andrewsummey No jews = No Zionists = No corrupt banks who ruin our lifes = No Israel = World Peace
SwedenArise 3 months ago
Palestinian's don't want peace there culture is brainwashed
Booze129 4 months ago
Jews have contributed endlessly to this world. In physics, medicine, industry, law, commerce, linguistics, economics and they continue contributing, innovating and leading.
What about Arabs?
Israel wants a tiny slither of land that is rightly theirs. Arabs have 21 states.
As a Kurd I support Israel.
Runakbin 4 months ago
@Runakbin Thank you for your comments! Often people do not see as clearly as you do!
andrewsummey 4 months ago
@andrewsummey I support Israel because as a Kurd I know better than anyone the hypocrite lies of Arabs. The Palestinians shout and scream VICTIM VICTIM when they are attacked by Israel but they found it completely acceptable to come to Iraq and attacks Kurds that were equally fighting for independence. It is from this I say the Kurdish cause is similar to the Jewish cause, and not similar in any way to the hypocrite Arabs who demand another country that they can mismanage like the rest.
Runakbin 4 months ago
Excellent, this is simple moral clarity!
One small detail, the Psalm of Remembering Jerusalem was a direct result of the Babylonian (Iraqi) Exile which took place closer to 2500 years ago.
raanan111 4 months ago
@raanan111 Excellent note. It is important to be accurate. Thank you!
andrewsummey 4 months ago
First off, any Palestinians that deny a Jewish connection are outliners, just as there are Israeli outliners that deny a Palestinian connection. Second, he did NOT say Jews, he said Israelis, not the same thing, and since they've killed nearly 7,000 of us, seems fair. Lastly, look at the numbers, Israelis are the ones doing the killing, to the tune of 12 of us for every one of them. Heck, more Palis have killed each other than Jews. Nice try in hate mongering though.
shibbel1 4 months ago
@shibbel1 I wouldn't say Israel is going out of their way to "kill" palestinians. I drove through towns in Samaria and saw lit up signs along the road honoring Palestinian terrorists that were killed going out of their way to commit murder. You see no parallel in Israeli society to this. I would encourage you to reset your moral compass. Murder is different than self defense.
andrewsummey 4 months ago
@andrewsummey Either you're completely ignorant to Israel's past and present, or you're a hypocrite, probably both. Let's go back to the bombing of the King David Hotel where 91 people were killed. It's celebrated to this day in Jerusalem. Jewish terror groups like Irgun and Lehi have murdered countless innocents. So yes, there is a parallel. 6, that's how many non-combative Palis are killed for every 1 combative. So again, yes, they do go out of their way to impose a collective punishment.
shibbel1 4 months ago
greetings from israel!
also check out our youtube page and find out that israelis also do comedy (and falafel. lots and lots of falafel :) )
TheIsraelis100 5 months ago
@TheIsraelis100 thanks for sharing!
andrewsummey 5 months ago
and jews wonder why everyone hates them,ha!.
Reptile42o 5 months ago
@brookesarahborden Shalom! Giddy-up!
andrewsummey 5 months ago
Reasons not to support a Jewish state, partially base on this guy's logic:
1) There are Israeli terrorists, therefore ALL Jews support their children to be terrorists (your logic, not mine) therefore they should not have a state. (your third point)
2) Israelis frequently lie about Palestinian claims, therefore all Israelis are liars and don't deserve to have a state (your logic, not mine).
3) There are Zionists who say all Palestinians should move to Jordania, therefore all Israelis agree.
GodOfTheInternets 5 months ago
@GodOfTheInternets You are funny. Israel does not support or endorse children terrorists. Palestinian society celebrates and endorses terrorism.
2. The PA authority makes the claims that Jews make up their history. The truth is, Palestinians invent their history. Classic turnspeak (see my previous video).
Jordania? where are you from? Jordan was created originally by the British to be the Palestinian state. (Or Arab state since everyone was Palestinian then - Jew, Arab, Christian, Muslim).
andrewsummey 5 months ago
@GodOfTheInternets
1. Show me just one Jewish child in a suicide belt or just ONE Jewish mother who says that she wants her child to kill others! JUST ONE!
2. Israelis lie about pali claims? Actually it is the opposite, even though Israel has been accused of many lies, until the investigations were complete Israel took blame. Just look at the case of Al-Dura (the little boy who the palis killed & lied about), Gaza massacre..
3. Don't read news? Some Israelis are stupid lefties, like I WAS!
abbienetvision 5 months ago
@abbienetvision
1) Are you saying there is not one mother who praised the IDF? Or what about the praising of Mister Goldstein by some orthodox Jews.
2) I'm not denying Palestinians don't lie, they both do.
3) You are projecting yourself unto me (psychological projection). I'm not saying all Israelis are Zionists. I'm using reductio ad absurdum.
GodOfTheInternets 5 months ago
You will be blessed, brother; acoording to God's promise to Abraham: 'I will bless those who bless thee'
DsUrgert 5 months ago
@DsUrgert Thank you! I believe it! Genesis 12:3
andrewsummey 5 months ago
Great vid...but you forgot to mention that to them all of Israel is occupied territory to be gotten back eventually. They still