ITS NOT HIM PLAYING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He's missing beats everywhere!!!!! His double bass is way the hell off for one. High hats.....i zoomed and timed your sticking. nice try to try and cover it up though. and like someone said your also missing some symbols....HA....get back to your band hero electric bullshit!!!
@AuCh209 You do realise I am playing along to the CD version of the song? You will hear crash cymbals that I don't have/missed being played by Mike in the original recording. In fact, it's quite obvious that they aren't my cymbals being played based on the sound of them alone.
Yes, the hi-hats are being played correctly. Aside from the double-strokes near the beginning where I play with a looser hi-hat.
Also, Band Hero was released after this video was recorded.
@AuCh209 oi cunt fuck up. how about you do a good job first, and show EVERYONE that you can play this and every other song perfectly, no stuff ups. this is a great cover, so what if he "missed notes" or whatever. fuck off. and how about you go back to your band hero shit, you fuckhead.
@milonkill Haha its all good bro, Ive had the same issues with some videos in the past so I gave up doing covers because it was too hard to sync it lol.
@TomGleesonDrummer I think he means stuff like at 3:05 theres a crash that you didn't hit but there's still a crash sound coming from the song itself.
@marcusfedgus I have. In fact I have a signed copy of Mike's book with the score in it. As you can see, I don't have the sheet music in front of me so I am playing by ear/from memory. Even Mike doesn't play his songs exactly as the score is written live.
i have listened to those and i have a tama anyways but just in my opinion i think yamahas are really lame unless you are filthy rich and have enough money to buy a 5 thousand dollar kit
how long did it take you to learn this. i usually don't have that much trouble learning dream theater songs, but i seem to have a lot of trouble learning this one. oh yeah, great job.
FanTAStic cover, my good man! Really very excellent job, not to mention you have probably the best-sounding drums on YouTube in my honest and humble opinion. Keep up the excellent work!
Kinda hard to play the intro when he doesn't have the right drums set up to do it. I'm sure if he had them, he'd be able to play it. It's not like that intro's hard, especially compared to the rest of the song.
for 16 you;re way ahead of the game...Portnoy is amazing...keep playing his stuff and you'll get better automatically....The only thing Id say is improve your attack on the cymbals; beat the piss out of them..youre half hitting them...keep rockin..youre talented
Thanks a lot for your kind words. I think the cymbals are just not good, I am a pretty hard hitter :P I do think I was going a bit softer in this video however.
did you get lessons? i have never got lessons. but the music stores around my place dont give good lessons. im better than all the people who give them which sucks.
It's real pleasure to watch someone like you. And you also look quite young. It must be too premature to ask your age here, but I guess you must be around 20.
Another thing, I know it's bad to compare, but who do you think is better Portnoy or Carey? I personally like Carey better, but Portnoy is real techincal.
You are excellent! That's exact drumming! How did you get it? By hearing? I've been playing for quite some time, and yet I cant even understand what he does there.
Why do you pretend to have endorsements? I wouldn't advertise for any company unless I was getting something out of it.
xxxlxt 5 months ago
nice job ! get more splashes ;)
dmtharpua 5 months ago
ITS NOT HIM PLAYING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He's missing beats everywhere!!!!! His double bass is way the hell off for one. High hats.....i zoomed and timed your sticking. nice try to try and cover it up though. and like someone said your also missing some symbols....HA....get back to your band hero electric bullshit!!!
AuCh209 9 months ago
@AuCh209 You do realise I am playing along to the CD version of the song? You will hear crash cymbals that I don't have/missed being played by Mike in the original recording. In fact, it's quite obvious that they aren't my cymbals being played based on the sound of them alone.
Yes, the hi-hats are being played correctly. Aside from the double-strokes near the beginning where I play with a looser hi-hat.
Also, Band Hero was released after this video was recorded.
TomGleesonDrummer 9 months ago 4
@AuCh209 oi cunt fuck up. how about you do a good job first, and show EVERYONE that you can play this and every other song perfectly, no stuff ups. this is a great cover, so what if he "missed notes" or whatever. fuck off. and how about you go back to your band hero shit, you fuckhead.
RangaDrummer 7 months ago
@AuCh209 your like retarded you can hear where he plays
AFatGypsyFanny 6 months ago
@AuCh209 shut the fuck up you buffoon
Shleckman2498 1 month ago
it'd be cooler with the first fill in there
llamadan40 11 months ago
Nicely done. Tough beat to hold for that long. Props bro :)
thedoodewhonoodles 1 year ago
yamaha stage custom?
horija 1 year ago
oh my god
TheBhajos 1 year ago
How long have you been playing?
iGatorNation 1 year ago
Hmm.. Drum with more power, it looks somewhat lazy ;) But your're doing a good job, it isn't the easiest song to play (But not the hardest too :P ).
rnarino 1 year ago
Yamaha, huh?
I'd have thought you'd prefer Pearl... but fair enough. :)
gnryeah 1 year ago
played wrong
XxbMcxX23 1 year ago
u missed the intro :S:S
richyn2 1 year ago
aca son las 2:40 am aguante extreme
TheTimyrock 2 years ago
can someone tell me what time signature this song is in i cant quite figure it out
872andy872 2 years ago
@872andy872 time signature is otherwise straight 4/4 but in the "chorus" (2:35) its 6/4
EtYR3Akz 1 year ago
no me gustó... dejen a Portnoy en paz manga de sin talento...
antinazi2007 2 years ago
muah ha ha ha ur good!!!!!! awesome song played by an awesom drummer!!!!
great!
flamecardude 2 years ago
3:43
caruu11 2 years ago
muy mal muchacho
LaMmMusic 2 years ago
No offense, but you're off. Why would you play the cover on drums with drums in the background? JW...
milonkill 2 years ago
@milonkill Ihes not playing out of time it sounds like he had sync issues.
Manic205 2 years ago
Yeah. I listened to it again, and it sounds like your right. I wasn't trying to be an ass. Haha I just noticed it. :-p
No worries.
milonkill 2 years ago
@milonkill Haha its all good bro, Ive had the same issues with some videos in the past so I gave up doing covers because it was too hard to sync it lol.
Manic205 2 years ago
your the luckiest man on earth ,. i would kill to meet mike
apexpein39 2 years ago
my next door neighbor is john petrucci hes ridiculous
motomanic95 2 years ago 2
no way, lucky boy
apexpein39 2 years ago
you know the only you can use is the raid and percusion i el tilintilin xD
no se mucho ingle o_O
oscarskate1 2 years ago
good cover but you missed some stuff
walta12 2 years ago
Is it a coincidence that the video itself is 6:00 long?
stigomaster 2 years ago 20
haha thats awesome
mjriley2994 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thats why its called 6:00 because its that length of time
ManiacMentalMushroom 2 years ago
No no, the studio version is only 5:32
stigomaster 2 years ago 4
@stigomaster i suppose he made that intro on purpose to make it 6:00 long
CrissCoverdrive 1 year ago
@stigomaster 6:01
MrRabbitBlack 1 year ago
@stigomaster its actually 6:01 dumbass
Boobiespudding 11 months ago
yamahas are the best after dw in my opinion i love my set
ludwigdrummer24 2 years ago 2
man this song is the greatest, nice t-shirt btw, train of thought
riceater87 3 years ago
Gosh that is the most awesome beat
Alukart117 3 years ago
its an iconic Portnoy beat :)
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago 4
wow, crash cymbals playing themselves 0.o
CoolEditz 3 years ago
?????
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
0:32 - Sounds like your crash to me, but it's your open hi-hat.
CoolEditz 3 years ago
@TomGleesonDrummer I think he means stuff like at 3:05 theres a crash that you didn't hit but there's still a crash sound coming from the song itself.
29ryan49 1 year ago
dude he brought his left hand up to the other crash :P
872andy872 2 years ago
@CoolEditz Yeah, he obviously hasnt read the actual score for this :|
marcusfedgus 1 year ago
@marcusfedgus I have. In fact I have a signed copy of Mike's book with the score in it. As you can see, I don't have the sheet music in front of me so I am playing by ear/from memory. Even Mike doesn't play his songs exactly as the score is written live.
TomGleesonDrummer 9 months ago
@CoolEditz WTF? lol
SuperXpress2 10 months ago
@CoolEditz WTF?
SuperXpress2 10 months ago
i have listened to those and i have a tama anyways but just in my opinion i think yamahas are really lame unless you are filthy rich and have enough money to buy a 5 thousand dollar kit
InsanePain143 3 years ago
i never mentioned the quality just that yamahas in general suck
InsanePain143 3 years ago
Amazing. If I could I would give it 10stars but 5 is the maximum ;)
PaisteMaster2112 3 years ago
Thank you :)
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
YAMAHA 100% JUNK!!!
InsanePain143 3 years ago
Very nice! Well done.
jgppap 3 years ago
5 stars from me! I'd give more if I could!
numatixtv 3 years ago
Hahaha, thank you!
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
you met my mentoooooooooooooooooor
mrsiix 3 years ago
He is a nice guy who does so much for his fans, a ture musical idol :)
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
That was an amazing cover.
5 stars!
sugarxplum 3 years ago
Thank you!
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
how long did it take you to learn this. i usually don't have that much trouble learning dream theater songs, but i seem to have a lot of trouble learning this one. oh yeah, great job.
robbymadore 3 years ago
Dude that was the best cover i have seen on youtube!!! Awsome drumset... how long have you been playing for?
myturbanisdirty123 3 years ago
Thank you very much, there are better Portnoy covers though.
I have been playing for 9 years now.
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
Beautiful looking drum set.
noon0788 3 years ago
Cheers, looks nice under coloured lights
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
Soon, when I have the time!
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
FanTAStic cover, my good man! Really very excellent job, not to mention you have probably the best-sounding drums on YouTube in my honest and humble opinion. Keep up the excellent work!
PragueMeddler 3 years ago 2
Thanks a lot buddy, that means a lot!
The drums are beautiful!
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
Spot on . I wanna see some death metal covers :-)
TwoEyeCyclops 3 years ago
Anyone noticed that video is exactly 6:00 long haha?
TheDB99 3 years ago 12
Nugget!
Sorabjian 3 years ago
@TheDB99 no it is 6:01 so it is not exatly
timemachinedrummer 1 year ago
@timemachinedrummer it's closer to 6:00 than 6:01 but youtube zeros it to one ahead...
PeikkoKuningas95 1 year ago
you nailed it man, props to you
Raxoplasma 3 years ago
Thanks mate!
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
ps nel ... no mambrun !!!!
morrismx 3 years ago
Nice work, keep it up man!
SabianAxis 3 years ago
Thanks a lot man!
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
ahhahahahah the intro?
floydrebel 3 years ago
haha indeed dude! all that presentation and u cant play the intro?!
persini 3 years ago 4
Kinda hard to play the intro when he doesn't have the right drums set up to do it. I'm sure if he had them, he'd be able to play it. It's not like that intro's hard, especially compared to the rest of the song.
AlexSchickling 3 years ago
for 16 you;re way ahead of the game...Portnoy is amazing...keep playing his stuff and you'll get better automatically....The only thing Id say is improve your attack on the cymbals; beat the piss out of them..youre half hitting them...keep rockin..youre talented
sbw999 3 years ago 2
Hey there,
Thanks a lot for your kind words. I think the cymbals are just not good, I am a pretty hard hitter :P I do think I was going a bit softer in this video however.
Thanks again,
Tom
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
you sound really cool but your cymbals aren't matching the song....they are very dark....but really cool drumming..
probil891 3 years ago
Hey mate, I totally know what you mean about the cymbals. Dont worry, they will be replaced this year :) Thanks for your comments!
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
wat r u gettin??
drumexpert121 3 years ago
Masterwork Resonant Series
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
when you gave a tour of your kit, you didnt have 2 floor toms and your toms were mounted on the bass! now theyre not
JaCkErS59 3 years ago
haha, yes, I didn't have the floor tom then.
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
did you get lessons? i have never got lessons. but the music stores around my place dont give good lessons. im better than all the people who give them which sucks.
drumminboy112233 4 years ago
yes, I have lessons at my school.
TomGleesonDrummer 3 years ago
You are too good. Kudos to you.
ToolPuritan 4 years ago
Thanks again haha!
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
It's real pleasure to watch someone like you. And you also look quite young. It must be too premature to ask your age here, but I guess you must be around 20.
Another thing, I know it's bad to compare, but who do you think is better Portnoy or Carey? I personally like Carey better, but Portnoy is real techincal.
ToolPuritan 4 years ago
I'm 16. I haven't heard enough of Carey's playing to make a learned judgment. Portnoy's technical abilities are impeccable.
I'm really glad you enjoy watching my videos!
Tom
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
Good man. 16, so good at such a young age. You keep playing, and I'll keep watching. And yes, Portnoy really is impeccable. Take care.
ToolPuritan 4 years ago
Thank you! Mike is a great guy and a great drummer. Speak soon,
Tom
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
You are excellent! That's exact drumming! How did you get it? By hearing? I've been playing for quite some time, and yet I cant even understand what he does there.
ToolPuritan 4 years ago
Mixture of ear and reading (my teacher taught me this one last year)
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
why
thedrummer141414 4 years ago
good drumming man!! 5 stars. but i fucking hate dream theater hahaha.
svsh9 4 years ago
Dont hate DT! Thanks for your compliments though haha
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
really awsome job, mike portnoy is sometimes tough to follow, keep it up i like your style
tamaman03 4 years ago
Thank you! He is a tough one to copy, but his drumming sure is fun to play!
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
did they supply you this kit or is it yours.. sounds pretty crisp
tens1son 4 years ago
Man that was insane your awesome, great cover.
VaizardGTACrusader 4 years ago
Why thank you. I'm happy you enjoyed it.
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
HOLY SHIT!
DWdrummer57 4 years ago
Haha thank you? I hope thats a good comment!
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
yes, it's a freakin amazing comment!
DWdrummer57 4 years ago
Wow great sound and accurate cover. Very good
TheKeeby 4 years ago
Thank you very much. Thats what you get for doing it in a studio!
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
Lol true... very few have kits like Mike. Dont sound like you need it though, your fucking insane!!!
LukeThinnes 4 years ago
Why thank you haha! We wish we had kits like Mike :P
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
We all do.. more like bozzio ;P I have a shitty 5 piece electric so im not going anywhere fast :\
LukeThinnes 4 years ago
Bozzio's kit is insanely huge. Save up and get a good acoustic kit! Electrics are great for practicing though.
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
Lol alright. I really like your kit... i wanna pearl ;P
LukeThinnes 4 years ago
I've used some Pearls and they are ok. I would take my Yamaha any day over the Pearl.
Tom
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
Great job man!
silentjav 4 years ago
Thank you!
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
I'm guessing your already sponsered
Bubblesondrums 4 years ago
Nope. Not yet, why do you ask?
Tom
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago
pretty good job, shame you dont have enough toms for the very first fill ;)
M1nstr3l 4 years ago
haha we cant all have kits like Mike!
Glad you liked it!
TomGleesonDrummer 4 years ago